r/darksouls3 • • May 13 '16

DS3 Poise Researched and Explained

0 Upvotes

Yeah, this is pretty much the reaction I expected. Called a liar (by people who have done no work and have no data) and an entire "debunking" post (also by someone who has done no work and has no data) instead of just reserving judgment and waiting for the data. There's just too much emotion around this subject right now. Peace out. See you in a few months when everybody remaining has accepted this is how the game works and chilled out.


Long time lurker in the Souls subreddits, but have never posted. I have been doing a ton of poise research and thought I would give back to this community by posting it here first. Thank you for all your help over the years!


tl;dr - Poise definitely has a game effect. In community terms, we would probably describe as non-deterministic hyper armor. Having more poise means you are more likely to complete your attacks without interruption, but it is never predictable or even probable (>50%).

Intro

After spending the $50 for a second copy of DS3 and about 50 hours testing over the past two weeks, I have come to the conclusion that poise definitely works in DkS3, but it works very differently from DkS1 and DkS2. You may remain unconvinced or you may dislike the new poise system, but I have looked at thousands of vidcaps frame-by-frame in a wide variety of test scenarios and I am quite sure of my analysis. Let's put it this way, if I knew that FromSoft was going to release the DS3 source code tomorrow, I would confidently bet $1000 of my own money that the code would reveal a poise/hyper armor mechanic that works approximately as I describe it here.

Background: DeS Hyper Armor (feel free to skip if you know this)

For those of you not aware, hyper armor was a term coined by the Demon's Souls community to describe a mechanic where, when using large weapons (like a greatsword for example), you would get a small window of immunity to interruption if you were hit in the middle of your attack animation. Demon's Souls had no poise mechanic at all, so this was the only way that Ultra-class weapons could be usable against faster weapons.

/u/TheChaosBug made a good point. Hyper armor in DeS could also make you immune to taking damage. It does NOT do this is DkS3. The only hyper armor effect we are talking about is immunity to interruption.

Background: DkS1/DkS2 Poise (feel free to skip if you know this)

In Dark Souls 1 and 2, hyper armor was replaced by the poise system. Poise acted as an invisible status effect bar, like bleed or poison, that filled up every time you were hit. The size of your poise bar was determined by your poise stat, and being hit by different attacks filled it up more or less quickly (a Zweihander could "break" poise quickly in fewer hits than a longsword). If you didn't get hit for even a very short amount of time (seconds), it would reset. This system was entirely deterministic. If you had 43+ poise, you knew you could take exactly 3 straight-sword R1 hits before your poise would be broken and you would be stunned.

How DkS3 Poise Works:

If you're using a large weapon (UltraGS, Greataxe, Greathammer), hyper armor works very similarly to how it worked in DeS. You have a small window during your attack animation where you cannot be interrupted. The big change this time around is that every weapon is eligible for hyper armor some of the time. The simplest expression of this mechanic I could come up with is:

"If you are struck in the middle of an attack animation with any weapon, you have a chance to finish your attack and not be interrupted. This chance is positively influenced by your poise, and negatively influenced by the size of the attack that hit you".

In this way, it acts like a kind of non-deterministic hyper armor. You will sometimes get to swing through incoming attacks, but you cannot predict when that will be unless you are using certain very large weapons.

Some notes from my research:

  • With zero poise, the chance to get hyper armor is 0. Even if you're using an Ultra-class weapon.

  • If you have any poise at all, you always get hyper armor with Ultra-class weapons.

  • Otherwise, the probability of getting hyper armor seems to scale fairly linearly with your poise stat.

  • Getting hit with heavier weapons or more powerful attacks reduces the chance, sometimes dramatically (you are not gonna poise through a greataxe hit, I think it actually goes to zero).

  • This doesn't seem to have anything to do with damage, since upgrades did not seem to affect it either way. My intuition tells me it either depends on how much stamina was spent on the incoming attack, or perhaps it is a hidden stat of every moveset.

  • Even in very high poise situations, it never becomes probable (>50%) that you will receive hyper armor. Like damage reduction, the effect of poise is fairly subtle. It's clear they wanted armor to be less important (more like DeS).

Keep in mind, I am far from being able to get the level of granularity where I can predict exact percentages or give you something as specific as our old poise breakpoints (53 poise, yo!). Without FromSoft revealing the specifics, it will take hundreds more hours of testing, and sadly, I have a job and kids and no time to do it. However, in broad strokes, the effect is so obvious when you watch hundreds of vidcaps, that it is undeniable from my perspective.

Bonus: Rampant Speculation

I believe Miyazaki wanted to bring back some of the Demon's Souls feel, where you could not tank hits reliably and needed to focus more on dodging and position. I think they wanted to be able to back out easily, so they left the old code in place and stubbed it out with a variable, which is why you can still enable it with CE.

Bonus 2: Unbridled Opinion

I think this is great! No more Havel-monsters! Much more focus on movement and positioning!. I never cared for the way poise worked in DkS1/2, and am glad to see it become much less prominent.


r/darksouls3 • • Feb 13 '25

Video How many times did that guy buff?? 😂

0 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Dec 06 '24

Video Low level invasions, because I like to attack hosts. (PvP)

27 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Dec 29 '24

Discussion Anyone think that DS3 looks better than Elden ring

11 Upvotes

I'm not trying to say Elden ring graphic sucks but I was playing DS3 on my tv on my computer linked to an HDMI cable. My father came in the living and told me DS3 graphics were crazy. I told him that the game was 8years old. Then, I told him that a more recent game was released. I show to my dad Elden ring gameplay on max graphics on YouTube and he told me the game colour and graphics look not as great. He didn't like the yellowish tone of the game. I personally agree. What are you thought ?


r/darksouls3 • • Feb 11 '26

Question I just hit central Irithyll. Is it normal for standard enemies to be able to 2-3shot me with 1000HP/24 vigor?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Holy shit, never in my life have I seen so many fee-fees getting hurt about a comment in passing surrounding not wanting to turn on easy mode by mindlessly blocking with a greatshield.

Not being able to upgrade my armor is really punishing me for making any mistakes. A single missed parry is basically death. And I refuse to have to lug around a greatshield like some bitch lol


r/darksouls3 • • Mar 09 '25

Discussion Finished Dark Souls 3 today Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

So today i finished Dark Souls 3 and I wanted to share my game statistics. Build:
-Mercenary curved swords -rings: stamina regen, HP on successive hits, damage boost on successive hits, and max HP, stamina and equip load increase. -stats: 35 vitality, 15 vigor, 40 endurance, 40 dex, 36 strenght.

Overall I found the game to not be as hard as many people said, has anyone similar boss attempt counts as mine? Also I didn't use any summon and have never played online (crying in no ps+).


r/darksouls3 • • Mar 22 '16

Third Game in a row to have horrible last-minute Matchmaking details dumped on us... what the hell Miyazaki?!

0 Upvotes

Prerelease for Dark Souls 2, we knew that the odds would be stacked against invaders thanks to the lack of an infinite invasion item and the inclusion of Blue Sentinels. It wasn't until a few days before release that we learned Soul Memory would cripple any chances of invasions in the first playthrough.

In Bloodborne, it looked as if From was learning from the backlash to Soul Memory by reinstating level-based matchmaking and giving early access to an infinite invasion item. Again, upon release we learned that the integral chime maiden system was essentially broken in 90% of the game's zones and that PvP before reaching level 30 was impossible.

Now, here we are in Dark Souls 3, a game where Miyazaki explicitly stated that matchmaking would be based on Soul Level and that there would be no Soul Memory equivalents... and upon release we uncover a buttload of stipulations that will once again neuter invasions and allow for consequence-free co-op.

I love Miyazaki, but this is actually getting kind of shitty at this point. He knows that multiplayer in the past two games was a pale shadow of the unrestricted systems found in Demon's Souls and Dark Souls 1, and he refuses to warn PvP enthusiasts in advance of the BS that will obfuscate the system in his latest game.

If you're going to continue ruining a significant portion of the game, at least be honest about it.


r/darksouls3 • • Nov 10 '24

Fluff Just got the game. Why does this keep happening?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Oct 03 '23

Discussion Do you think that DS3 needs a remastered edition?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Oct 23 '24

Discussion My boss tier list from DS3 after playing through it in 34 hours.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Couple pointers here:

I’ve beat the game before - only once before as strength. Unga bunga.

I did the lord of hollows ending sort of on accident because I wanted 5 free levels. We beat EVERY boss, with the ones at lothric castle actually being very underleveled for.

My build was pure dex, ending at 110. +10 sharp uchi or sharp Onikiri and Ubadachi. Frayed blade felt bad since I never leveled for mana. Never found the washing pole (RIP). This is the first time I ever beat DS3 as dex. No guides, no pre planned build.

These bosses are graded on “was the boss fun to fight and die to? is it fair relative to your expected progression level? does it LOOK cool?” stuff like that

Stat spread was starting as deprived, 50 vig, 32 end, 13 str, 50 dex, who cares about the other stats. All we really used was pine resins for buffs that I can remember.


r/darksouls3 • • Oct 09 '25

Discussion I don't get the hype around the Ringed City

4 Upvotes

Lately I've been laying through the souls games for the first time and I've just finished most of the ringed city dlc (only need to kill Midir). Online I see a ton of hype and love for the Ringed City, but I just can't seem to get into it.

The visuals are stunning and Slave Knight Gael is one of, if not my favourite Souls boss. I just feel like the rest of the DLC is overly punishing with a ton of gimmicky enemies (like the guys that basically die when hit with a plunge attack but are insanely tough to take down otherwise).

I was curious if maybe someone could make me change my mind about the dlc. For those of you that like it so much, I was wondering why


r/darksouls3 • • Feb 09 '23

Is there a way to skip cutscenes? Do I have to watch this everytime I fight him? cause it's pissing me more then dying múltiple times

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Sep 22 '16

[DLC] I realize I'm alone in this, but I feel ripped off.

72 Upvotes

According to the interviews with Miyazaki, the latest DLC will have two bosses, and the length of both DLCs combined will be similar to Artorias of the Abyss.

I feel as though From thinks we are stupid. We were promised two DLCs, and that's what we paid for in the season pass. Not one DLC split into two parts.

Now you could make the argument there was precedent for this in that Bloodborne's DLCs were combined into one, but otherwise were supposed to have a similar amount of content to this current DLC. If you feel this way, that's fine. But I personally feel like From have set a certain standard with their previous DLCs, regardless of what circumstances led to those standards. And this latest entry ignores these standards, in order to make more money from less content.

The Bloodborne DLC costs 20$ and has more content than Artorias of the Abyss. Meanwhile these two DLCs will cost 30$ combined, or 25$ for the season pass. We pay 75% of the price of Old Hunters for 2 bosses and 1 new area, a pathetic amount of content compared to other DLCs in the series.

Considering that From is now a significantly more successful and wealthy company than it was prior to the explosion of the Souls' series, and even Dark Souls 1 gave us significantly more bang for our buck, there is IMO no excuse for this.

It is true that many other companies release more expensive DLC of far lower quality than From Soft typically does. But with this latest move it feels as though From is prioritizing monetary gain over its fanbase's loyalty and expectations.

Admittedly none of us have played the DLC yet, so the state of things might be better than what was described in the interviews. But personally - unless From seriously surprises me, I don't think I will be blindly purchasing a Season Pass from them anymore. I believe that a lot of people made an exception and purchased the Season Pass due to the good will From has built in its fan base, and those people are going to be similarly disappointed.


r/darksouls3 • • Mar 03 '24

Hot take: I hate the ringed city dlc

0 Upvotes

But I love the bosses. So much so in fact I force myself to go through the horrendous areas that give Dark Souls 2 scholar edition a run for its money. It’s the only part of the game I run through. I absolutely hate it, the butterflies in the dreg heap, the archers when you enter the ringed city, the ringed city streets. The swamp is more just annoying than anything else and the rest is okay. I just absolutely hate it. Rant over


r/darksouls3 • • Oct 22 '16

Quit talking about the leaked stuff

6 Upvotes

Please, have some respect for the people who have to wait until the actual release of the DLC to experience it. If you are gunna post something before the 25th, keep names and spoilers out of the titles of the posts and tag your spoilers.


r/darksouls3 • • 3d ago

Discussion Not a huge fan of the Ringed City so far

2 Upvotes

I believe I’m around halfway through the area? Am currently exploring the big swamp place with a judicator giant walking around and despite the fact that this place has maybe some of the coolest lore out of any dark souls location so far, the area design itself is kinda getting on my nerves.

I know, I know, git gud and all that but I just don’t know, half a dozen harald knights that can fuck you up brutally if you lower your guard for a second (was definitely made easier when I understood that you can plunge them but it can often not make a difference if you get swarmed), the ringed knights (especially the pair of them on the bridge on top of the stairs), the fucking silver knight which pretty much one shots me with many of his attacks since the first one stuns me for the second to finish me off.

It’s come to a point where, for the first time since early into DS1, I’ve had to look up where the next bonfire it because of how royally this place is fucking me up lmao.


r/darksouls3 • • Apr 28 '24

Discussion What is the worst boss in this game?

1 Upvotes

I fully believe it's Aldrich. The fight just isn't made well and it's super buggy. I get it has lore significance, but it really sucks as a boss.


r/darksouls3 • • Dec 03 '16

MOD /r/DarkSouls3 is hiring new mods. All interested parties are encouraged to apply!

0 Upvotes

We are looking to add 1-2 members to the mod team for /r/darksouls3. Please fill out the linked application if you are interested.

APPLICATION

Some basic requirements:

  • Your Reddit account must be at least 6 months old

  • You must have positive comment karma on the sub

Helpful, but not required:

  • Prior experience moderating a subreddit

  • Experience with CSS and Automoderator

Our apologies, but only those applicants who have been selected for further screening will be contacted.


r/darksouls3 • • May 01 '25

Discussion Why do so many people still hate Midir so much?

0 Upvotes

I can't understand, his hp is actually not that high, I recently defeated him using Crow Talons at ng+6 and had no problems with damage. His attack pattern is absolutely fair, with clear openings, and all of his attacks can be avoided, In my opinion,A Boss as excellent as Gael, well done, fair and epic. People should just admit that they were hitting Midir's legs all this time and not his head.


r/darksouls3 • • May 07 '26

Discussion The cpu has no idea how to handle casters lol

0 Upvotes

I decided to see if i could kill the Pontiff casting only, thinking his aggression and range would make it more challenging than melee.

I was wrong, phase 1 i barely had to dodge, just back peddled and soul speared him.

Same with phase 2. It seemed like once i got to a certain range he just stanced and aura farmed for a good 10 seconds and wouldnt react no matter how many spears hit him.

Do all bosses react this way?

*Just to clarify for the 60 vigor summon crowd thats a little slow, the point isnt to show off skill, the point is that I barley made any effort, with 9 vigor, and still won comfortably. therefore, magic is easy mode. Anyone who disagrees is in denial of their crutch. 🤏


r/darksouls3 • • Aug 23 '25

Video all hit no estus fight for the twin princes, pontiff left eye moment

0 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Feb 07 '22

Question I feel like I does something wrong does invading is something bad now? I fighted him where no enemy would kill him and we were in the dlc to give him chance

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/darksouls3 • • Oct 30 '23

Fluff This singular structure looks better than anything i saw playing lies of p

Post image
0 Upvotes

Circle jerk commence


r/darksouls3 • • May 27 '16

I'll be Way of Blue from now on

21 Upvotes

I was saved last night by a mighty hero. SPOILERS. And wall of text. Sorry...

Just before the dragon at Lothric Castle bonfire I was invaded. I never laid eyes on him and it was making me very nervous. I luckily had switched to Way of Blue from my usual Sunbro swag at the bonfire once I used an ember.

(EDIT: Jerks saying this story didn't happen. It did. Don't have to hate since I got a few up votes)

Within about a minute I was informed that a dapper blue robo-cop had joined. Strangely, I didn't see him at first. This felt odd because USUALLY everyone sticks together in Jolly Co-op. Then I remembered, the Blues are not like us. He was scouting, hunting; he cleared my path while he was at it.

I was having trouble passing the huge morphed monster after you leap down from the dragons fire. I ended up using Hidden Body and walking slow. After I went up around the stairs and into the castle, I saw my BlueBro clapping as he had watched the whole thing from up above.

We proceeded up, around, down, left, right, and so forth until I saw a tempting chest. Lo and behold it was a mimic! My friend didn't have time to stop me as he was clearing the room, and I was immediately swallowed and chewed by this bastardly box.

With a millimeter of health, things got worse. The sneaky invader lunged at me from God knows where they hide...missing me only by what seems like 1 roll frame.

What happened next was tremendous.

A flash of blue as the Sentinel tore the invaders health to shreds with a few well timed R1s. Not spam, mind you... The invader was spamming his parry. No, BlueBro staggered his attacks perfectly. Red belly fled, only to be hunted down.

I did not see how it ended, but I will never remove this Way of Blue as long as I am kindled.