r/darksouls3 • u/H-H-H-Hyperamor • May 13 '16
DS3 Poise Researched and Explained
Yeah, this is pretty much the reaction I expected. Called a liar (by people who have done no work and have no data) and an entire "debunking" post (also by someone who has done no work and has no data) instead of just reserving judgment and waiting for the data. There's just too much emotion around this subject right now. Peace out. See you in a few months when everybody remaining has accepted this is how the game works and chilled out.
Long time lurker in the Souls subreddits, but have never posted. I have been doing a ton of poise research and thought I would give back to this community by posting it here first. Thank you for all your help over the years!
tl;dr - Poise definitely has a game effect. In community terms, we would probably describe as non-deterministic hyper armor. Having more poise means you are more likely to complete your attacks without interruption, but it is never predictable or even probable (>50%).
Intro
After spending the $50 for a second copy of DS3 and about 50 hours testing over the past two weeks, I have come to the conclusion that poise definitely works in DkS3, but it works very differently from DkS1 and DkS2. You may remain unconvinced or you may dislike the new poise system, but I have looked at thousands of vidcaps frame-by-frame in a wide variety of test scenarios and I am quite sure of my analysis. Let's put it this way, if I knew that FromSoft was going to release the DS3 source code tomorrow, I would confidently bet $1000 of my own money that the code would reveal a poise/hyper armor mechanic that works approximately as I describe it here.
Background: DeS Hyper Armor (feel free to skip if you know this)
For those of you not aware, hyper armor was a term coined by the Demon's Souls community to describe a mechanic where, when using large weapons (like a greatsword for example), you would get a small window of immunity to interruption if you were hit in the middle of your attack animation. Demon's Souls had no poise mechanic at all, so this was the only way that Ultra-class weapons could be usable against faster weapons.
/u/TheChaosBug made a good point. Hyper armor in DeS could also make you immune to taking damage. It does NOT do this is DkS3. The only hyper armor effect we are talking about is immunity to interruption.
Background: DkS1/DkS2 Poise (feel free to skip if you know this)
In Dark Souls 1 and 2, hyper armor was replaced by the poise system. Poise acted as an invisible status effect bar, like bleed or poison, that filled up every time you were hit. The size of your poise bar was determined by your poise stat, and being hit by different attacks filled it up more or less quickly (a Zweihander could "break" poise quickly in fewer hits than a longsword). If you didn't get hit for even a very short amount of time (seconds), it would reset. This system was entirely deterministic. If you had 43+ poise, you knew you could take exactly 3 straight-sword R1 hits before your poise would be broken and you would be stunned.
How DkS3 Poise Works:
If you're using a large weapon (UltraGS, Greataxe, Greathammer), hyper armor works very similarly to how it worked in DeS. You have a small window during your attack animation where you cannot be interrupted. The big change this time around is that every weapon is eligible for hyper armor some of the time. The simplest expression of this mechanic I could come up with is:
"If you are struck in the middle of an attack animation with any weapon, you have a chance to finish your attack and not be interrupted. This chance is positively influenced by your poise, and negatively influenced by the size of the attack that hit you".
In this way, it acts like a kind of non-deterministic hyper armor. You will sometimes get to swing through incoming attacks, but you cannot predict when that will be unless you are using certain very large weapons.
Some notes from my research:
With zero poise, the chance to get hyper armor is 0. Even if you're using an Ultra-class weapon.
If you have any poise at all, you always get hyper armor with Ultra-class weapons.
Otherwise, the probability of getting hyper armor seems to scale fairly linearly with your poise stat.
Getting hit with heavier weapons or more powerful attacks reduces the chance, sometimes dramatically (you are not gonna poise through a greataxe hit, I think it actually goes to zero).
This doesn't seem to have anything to do with damage, since upgrades did not seem to affect it either way. My intuition tells me it either depends on how much stamina was spent on the incoming attack, or perhaps it is a hidden stat of every moveset.
Even in very high poise situations, it never becomes probable (>50%) that you will receive hyper armor. Like damage reduction, the effect of poise is fairly subtle. It's clear they wanted armor to be less important (more like DeS).
Keep in mind, I am far from being able to get the level of granularity where I can predict exact percentages or give you something as specific as our old poise breakpoints (53 poise, yo!). Without FromSoft revealing the specifics, it will take hundreds more hours of testing, and sadly, I have a job and kids and no time to do it. However, in broad strokes, the effect is so obvious when you watch hundreds of vidcaps, that it is undeniable from my perspective.
Bonus: Rampant Speculation
I believe Miyazaki wanted to bring back some of the Demon's Souls feel, where you could not tank hits reliably and needed to focus more on dodging and position. I think they wanted to be able to back out easily, so they left the old code in place and stubbed it out with a variable, which is why you can still enable it with CE.
Bonus 2: Unbridled Opinion
I think this is great! No more Havel-monsters! Much more focus on movement and positioning!. I never cared for the way poise worked in DkS1/2, and am glad to see it become much less prominent.