r/darkestdungeon • u/Solid_son • Dec 23 '23
r/darkestdungeon • u/Always_Missing_ • Mar 07 '25
[DD 1] Question Is this a good team to fight the Crew?
r/darkestdungeon • u/-B-r-0-c-k- • May 10 '24
Wayne June has been sharing transphobic posts on socials
The voice actor for the Ancestor and Academic has recently liked a post calling non-binary people mentally ill on twitter.
He's also shared a transphobic video on facebook.
It's so disappointing as I've been looking up to him and his amazing work ever since I played Darkest Dungeon for the first time.
Edit: other relevant posts in his twitter likes:
Make of these what you will
r/darkestdungeon • u/IWannaHaveCash • Feb 23 '25
[DD 1] Meme Objectively correct drip tier list
This is confirmed by the devs
r/darkestdungeon • u/AMP3412 • Oct 12 '22
[DD 1] Meme Leper is trash, not his trinkets. Move on
r/darkestdungeon • u/MentionKey5826 • May 10 '25
[DD 1] Discussion Is it just me or is DD 2… far less enjoyable than 1?
I've completed both games, and I gotta say, even tho I've done everything in DD 1, I love the vibe of the game. I could honestly just chill at the Hamlet. Perfect game
DD 2 is a solid game, better in some aspects, but overall FAR worse than DD 1 imho. No DD vibe, aesthetics are overall worse, idk I can't vibe with the second game. Anyone else feel that way?
r/darkestdungeon • u/letaluss • Mar 15 '25
[DD 2] Discussion My Tier List for Heroes in Darkest Dungeon 2: Confessions
r/darkestdungeon • u/No-Perspective-9612 • Dec 25 '23
[DD 2] Discussion Any idea why DD2 lacked the longevity of dd1? Why did the player count tank?
r/darkestdungeon • u/Strict-Fudge4051 • Jun 29 '25
OC Fan Art Tried drawing my bf fursona in dd2 style
Seems like you guys liked my previous thing so why not :з
r/darkestdungeon • u/boshudio • Apr 22 '23
Modders for this game need to go outside and touch grass. NSFW
I've been playing games in my steam library I haven't touched yet, and recently Just finished a Stardew Valley run. That game has a good selection of mods that add to the QoL of the game. I've heard of some QoL problems for DD so I decided to check out the nexus mods before playing to see if any were worth it and ..... jesus christ. I mean, it makes sense that a game such as this would have a degenerate modding community, but wow.
r/darkestdungeon • u/DanielYKW • Sep 25 '24
People here really need to chill about the recent news
It's crazy seeing how people are acting as if Red Hook wasn't aware of the negative possibilities of entering this deal. Being an indie dev is hard as shit and knowing that DD2 didn't perform as well as the original probably put them in a really tough situation.
Of course I would have preferred for Red Hook to still be an independent studio (and I'm sure they do too), but if I gotta pick between RH going under or having them be acquired by someone with the pockets to keep the franchise alive, it's a no brainer.
r/darkestdungeon • u/Ordinary-Problem3838 • May 25 '23
DD2 is a good game. But it's not a good DD game.
Just finished the game. Music, art and animation top tier. The rest? Bland.
This is a long one. Like, essay structured shit, because I'm on holidays and I have the time and I love DD so fucking much and I was so very disapointed. So if you don't like rants, here's the tl;dr.
Highs:
-Combat. Unsurprising, since it's the thing that's changed the least.
-Relationship/stress system.
-Story/Narration.
Lows:
-A lot less customization.
-Roguelike elements poorly implemented.
-Runs are too long/too samey.
-Player agency has been hugely reduced.
-Runs have no impact on characters/world -> less player investment.
A bit of background.
The shifted corridors and sloped vaults of our ancestry are beginning to feel familiar.
I've bought DD three times, that's how much I like the game. Bought it when it came out on gog, bought it in Steam after gog updates were dropped and bought it on Switch. I played stigian without lighting a single torch, I played mods, I played in every which way. The original DD is a banger. DD2 is a good game, but now that I've finished I don't think I'll play it again or even buy any DLC unless there is some big rework of everything that's not the tactical combat part of the game.
I played DD2 on standard difficulty, took me 8 runs to finish the thing. I played around 25 runs overall. I think I'm a hardcore player, so I will not address balance/difficulty issues. The game felt easy and I'll likely play it a bit more using the badass blue flame. But my critique will not touch on that. I will stick only to things I believe have an impact on every player's experience.
Party customization:
A simple choice. At least, it should be.
The game has plenty of variety when it comes to building a party. However, it is very limited in the ways in which you can play it. By this I mean that if you want to build a sucessful party, there are only so many ways in which you can go at it. This is mainly because the strategy layer of the game has been removed in favour of a roguelike system (which I'd be okay with, if implementation wasn't a bit of a mess).
Other roguelikes like slay the spire, risk of rain etc make me invested in the game through run progression. I have a cool combo of cards/relics, or I'm building towards something, or... DD2 does not have that. I have a certain degree of agency on how to achieve this, and it is usually based on the first drops that I get. I can adapt my run to these drops and the game provides enough choice points through events and rewards in a manner that makes that achievable.
DD2 does not. Paths and party composition and ability choices provide a lot of customization initially, but the best customization bits are absolutely RNG. Events do not provide 'themed' rewards. I'm going to get a combat item? Ok, but I have no idea of knowing what kind. Same goes for trinkets/quirks. The best thing you can hope for is that somewhere along the run you will have hoarded enough random stuff to build something you are satisfied with, but everytime it feels like a crapshoot. I don't feel like I have control over my party build and it sucks.
The skill leveling system only makes this worse. By forcing you to commit to a particular route. So you got a really cool drop for a blight doctor? Tough shit, I already chose surgeon; leveled healing and incision and I cannot respec skills, not even paying. Compare that to picking your cards after each encounter and your relics after a boss. Give us a pick pool! It's not that hard.
Not only that, but there's no external motivation to build a party that is anything but as good as possible, there are no objectives other than defeating the boss. I'll come back to this if anyone has the patience for it. But it is a huge point as to why the game fails to deliver on customization.
The game has a lot of variety, but not enough control on how to shape things. Compared to DD, where you start scrappy but can build towards something by doing quests to get specific trinkets, locking particular traits and build up a character over a number of runs... DD2 feels more limited.
Trinkets:
Glittering gold, trinkets and baubles - paid for in blood.
Trinkets are absolutely underwhelming. Even if they have strong effects, they may be absolutely irrelevant to team composition. The problem to me its randomness. In other games when you get a reward you can choose between a small pool, or you can save your resources for later on hoping to find what you want. In DD2 this happens at the inn/hoarder. This together with the fact that you only have 8 slots for trinkets, AND the trinkets have to be the right ones for A) your party comp B) your hero C) your hero's path makes building a run a total crapshoot.
In the original DD, finding a powerful trinket, even if you couldn't make use of it, was always a treat. You immediately start thinking about who can take advantage of it and it had a huge impact on your playthrough, particularly early on. It could unlock different party compositions or give you the extra boost required to go for a particular boss or farm a particular area more confidently. In DD2 I shift click on most of the trinkets I find.
Hope:
There can be no hope in this hell, no hope at all.
I love roguelikes, I love unlock systems. I think in DD2 it's poorly implemented. Having rewards linked eclusively to hope leads to always playing the same way. You just want to build a strong run, tackle one of the lair bosses and the final boss. Most roguelikes fence particular upgrades behind particular milestones, not just through regular playing.
DD2 has such wasted potential when it comes to this... Why not use milestones to fence certain trinkets or items? It makes absolutely no sense. Some examples:
-Visit oblivion Ingress ->Unlock new stained trinket.
-Win oblivion Ingress encounter -> Unlock new cultist.
-Defeat x Fanatics -> Unlock a sprawl trinket.
-Get bleed x times on your character -> Unlock bandages.
Doing this will have the added benefit of providing strategic depth to the game. My decisions will be impacted by something other than which route am I better equiped to deal with. It would give me some objectives other than mindlessly farming hope for my unlocks.
Hope is such a bland, lazy way of implementing progression in the game. There's so much wasted potential here it's absurd. What a way to make progression boring.
Runs are too long/samey.
A long road... and an abrupt end.
I have 5 choices, which boil down to the same thing, because really where I choose is at the inn. My five choices involve run length, but they also determine which boss I'm facing. So I want a party for that boss, and that kind of party does well in certain areas and against certain lair bosses so in the end most of the runs end up structured the same. So I have no extrinsic motivation to choose anything other than the 'optimal' party/route for that boss because the progression system does not reward anything that getting as far as possible while doing the secondary objectives.
There's no run objective. There's no money runs, there's no "I'm going to run scout trinkets on my whole party to get the goddamn grain and get out doing as little combat as possible". There's just the goddamn road and that mountain at the end of it. Which from a storytelling perspective is amazing, but from a gameplay perspective is just boring. In a nutshell, you are always running the same run, only a bit shorter or longer and with a different boss at the end.
One of reasons the original DD worked for me was because I could take a look at my resources in the hamlet, take a look at the quests available and decide what I could tackle, how to progress, and how to create a comp that would be able to take on the challenge. Do I have a strong team and want to make extra money? Kick that lazy antiquarian out of bed, pack no torches, and lets make some big bucks!
There's also the fact that other than the death encounter (which showed up twice for me in about 30 runs) there are no unexpected things coming down along the road. And the death encounter always happens during combat. You are not going down the road to the healer when suddendly death shows up in the middle of the road to ruin your day.
When I was talking about party customization, I complained about not having enough agency. This is the reason why. You are giving me all these things, and so little control as to what to do with them. And the fact that all the runs aim at exactly the same things is a huge part of why customization options are irrelevant. If the task is to drive nails into the enemies' forehead, all the way down to the boss, and I'm rewarded for doing precisely that... Why would I choose anything other than a hammer?
Traveling
We venture blindly forth, at the mercy of the road and its myriad dangers.
The stagecoach is absolutely pointless. What a boring, unfun way of forcing me to drive over stuff to get small rewards. No secrets, no alternate paths. Driving the stagecoach is the least interactive way of moving ever. I drive over stuff to get stuff, but even though I can stop by this flaming pile of books, I can't get anything out of it unless I drive over it? Give me the choice to stop and get the shit instead of forcing me to play medieval initial-g. Make me fight for it or something. So much wasted potential there. Unless I'm missing something. Someone tell me if I'm missing some kind of off-road driving thing. I'd be delighted to hear it. Which leads to the next point. No surprises.
No surprises
Ruts in the roadway - there is a barricade ahead.
0 surprises. I will always know what the next encounter is and when is it coming. One of the greatest things about the original DD is the tension of going down a hallway without having a clue of what was in store for you. Even when you knew an encounter was coming, it could be one of the random minibosses coming to turn your happy little run into a tough choice between pushing with a half-crazed party or take the hit and return to the hamlet.
Remember what I was saying about the death encounter? The game lacks surprises and fails to build up tension. I can literally see what's coming down the road. No ambushes, no surprise traps, no moments where I clutch my controller and curse my rotten luck. Everything is expected. Even the death encounter is like an additional phase to combat. I'm already on a combat mind set and it can be a challenge if I'm in a tight spot, but the encounter itself flows seamlessly becomes I'm already in combat mode and I know precisely the state of my party.
No party investment
Fellowship forged through toil.
For me, there's no investment at all in my party. Who cares if they all die by the end of the run? Ooooh, they can have memories? The memory system is absolutely underwhelming. Original DD, there were times in which you would make poor tactical decision in a boss fight just to try and save Dismas, who is your dude and who has been with you from the very beginning -and on whom you've invested a lot of money and has a bunch of carefully curated positive traits-. DD2? Who gives a crap. Let's just kill the boss, as long as 1 guy is standing at the end of it the rest is inconsecuential. Even deaths during the run are not that impactful, as long as you aren't too far away from the inn.
Not a bad game
To attempt and fail is no shameful thing.
The new combo system is better. The hit, dodge and dmg reduction system is nice, as is how buffs/debuffs now work. It gives tactical agency back to the player, removing the bullshit xcom 99% shit element to it while preserving the tough choices of "do I go for a 50% killshot risking going into death door, or do I heal/guard?". Combat in general is very much improved, new enemies bosses are cool, new death door system on enemies is a nice addition. Which is a relief, since it is the core of the game experience after all.
You slap any other name in the box and I'd be eating this cereal without complaints. I'd be praising it for the things that does better than the original DD. But the whole time I'd be thinking "this is a poor man's copy of Darkest Dungeon, some Iratus shit or something". It doesn't help that Black Reliquary came out around the same time, and it is everything that I had hoped for. It is what I would have expected out of a sequel. I love the story in DD2 and I love all the improvements, but I feel like there's a lot of wasted potential. I really hope further development down the road will make things better, but as things stand the game will be likely shelved very soon. I'd rather play the original.
Conclusion
Ringing ears, blurred vision - the end approaches...
At the end of the day, each of us have our own preferences, and even if I think some of my criticism may resonate with others, or that some of my suggestions are legitimate improvements -Real secondary objectives! Milestone linked progression!-. The truth of it is that I'm bored, and I wanted to structure my impressions of a game that's been an anxiety outlet for most of my adult life. It was bothering me not being able to articulate what I disliked about the game and this has been catharthic or something.
I understand that Red Hook likely wanted to do something different, not just FIFA the shit out of the original game, and I have no qualms about that. You can have something amazing and build on it while changing elements, or straight up switching genres. Hell, look at Supergiant games, each game they release is a completely different beast. Even if the base mechanics at the core are very similar, they find new way to implement them while doing whatever the fuck it is they do to their games that makes me want to snort them up.
Finally, if you read all the way to down here I'm honestly surprised, you must really love this game if you are willing to read such a rant about it. Thanks :D
r/darkestdungeon • u/Mr_Pepper44 • Jun 01 '24
[Mod Release] In celebration of pride here is a Trans Bounty Hunter skin
r/darkestdungeon • u/Classic-Vermicelli72 • Nov 19 '23
DD2 relationships are a blight on a fantastic game.
I waited a long time for the exclusivity on DD2 to end, when I finally got my hands on it I was blown away. Immediately loved everything about it, there was a lot more to understand and it was daunting, but it all seemed for the best.
Then I encountered the relationship system.
I don't understand how the same people who made every other part of this game also made that part.
It quite frankly kills the game for me, I get really invested in a run, get some cool items make a bunch of progress, and then a bunch of dice get rolled on weather the run is a success or not.
Real shame, I came back to the game for the first time in months tonight.
During a run in progress, had some really good stained item combos and I was genuinely excited to play again.
So, I clicked rest and we set out.
The entire screen, from top to bottom, was all negative relationships.
Every single decision I made was going to cause at least 2 people stress.
I alt + f4 and uninstalled.
I want to play this game, but that's quite frankly bullshit.
r/darkestdungeon • u/benjamarchi • Dec 28 '23
[DD 2] Discussion DD2 is not a Slay the Spire clone, it has an original identity and play style
Specially in the last few days, with the steam sale going on, I've seen a lot of people recommending DD2 to other people by saying things like "it's similar to slay the spire" or "if you liked slay the spire, you'll enjoy DD2", as if DD2 is some sort of "slay the spire"-like or a clone. Saying that DD2 is like StS is a disservice to DD2, because people who dislike StS won't give DD2 a chance, and people who love StS for its own original style will get frustrated with DD2.
On a superficial level, you could say that DD2 has some elements present in slay the spire, such as areas composed by branching nodes, end area bosses and mini bosses, and a roguelike structure: if you die, you can unlock content and you have to restart.
Those, however, are characteristics that define roguelikes in general. A lot of games are built like that and it doesn't make them like StS. What makes StS its own thing is the fact that, with each passing battle/node you get the opportunity to evolve and change or reinforce your current play style. As a deck builder, after each encounter the game rewards you with new cards and relics that help you develop how you play the game. You are constantly mutating and evolving. At the end of a run, you are a COMPLETELY different beast from what you were at the begining.
DD2 is different from that, because it is much more rigid in what you can change about your characters, and the rate of change/mutation/evolution is a lot slower when compared to StS. That makes for a more oppressive experience, which is in line with the DD universe, but may displease people who go into DD2 expecting something StS.
Because of that, let's stop saying DD2 is like StS. That's true only at a glance, and really doesn't help newcomers much. It may even hurt DD2. When recommending DD2 it's better to talk about it in its own merit. Or maybe compare it to DD1, since its a numbered sequel. At least that's more helpful to an outsider interested in the game than comparing it to a completely different experience at core, from completely different franchise.
TLDR: saying DD2 is like StS is true only superficially, and it might hurt DD2, because those are widely different games.
r/darkestdungeon • u/D-Ursuul • Sep 17 '23
Is it just me or is DD2 kinda..bullshit?
I have hundreds of hours in DD1 and while I completely acknowledge they are different games, I've now got about 20 hours in DD2 and cannot even get past the first zone in chapter 2. It just feels like every single enemy attack simultaneously does significant damage, inflicts DoT, stresses, stuns etc. and by comparison your own moves are generally shit unless you place a combo token, but moves that place combo tokens either do nothing else (meaning you take 2 moves to do what the enemy does every move), or they only have a tiny chance of placing combo tokens
The tokens also seem waaaay RNG in the game's favour. They say something like "50% chance to dodge" and yet it triggers every time for the enemy and barely ever for my characters?
It feels like one round into any combat my entire team is bleeding or blighted, stunned, and already lost a quarter of their HP? I have to use turns healing blights and bleeds which means those characters can't use combo moves meaning the ones left free to attack are doing piddly damage against enemies that are just applying another 100 bleeds the next turn. If I ignore the DoTs to try and do damage I just end up on deaths door every turn and all my characters proceed to have meltdowns constantly.
I know I need to unlock shit to get stronger but I've unlocked half the upgrades in the game and I'm still getting absolutely shit on before I'm even halfway through the first zone in chapter 2.
Is the game just generally more RNG and bullshit than DD1? I can do Stygian playthroughs no problem in DD1 but this game just feels so unfair
r/darkestdungeon • u/AMP3412 • Sep 26 '24
[DD 2] Meme I would rather use a bad character than spam the same move over and over on a good character
r/darkestdungeon • u/CutestGirlHere • Jun 03 '24
[Mod Release] A Pride Month Skin Mod to replace all the Crusader Banners with Pride Flags.
r/darkestdungeon • u/Basic-Cloud6440 • Sep 25 '24
is someone able to explain to me, why this community is so outraged about THE news?
i mean. its not that i like it. i strongly believe that the dbd devs only managed to do one thing right in their career. it was creating dbd. everything else they have done is garbage. but the way i see it, there had to be a reason. and the reason cant be beneficial for rh. so it could very well be an attempt to save rh. it is probably more beneficial for us aswell, since the probability of something good happening with red hook increased, considering the circumstances and the few things we know. (ofc my asumption could be wrong and rh are just sellouts. but i dont want to believe this)
edit 1. Thank you for your answers. you should really watch the q&a from redhook. it was a big relieve to be honest.
r/darkestdungeon • u/MalefactorX • Feb 05 '24
[DD 2] Discussion Darkest Dungeon 2 is horrible.
Just had an amazing run, with great trinket synergies.
Just to get Crusader killed from full health to dead within a single turn at the oblivion ingress right before the mountain boss.
3 hours down the drain.
Fire everyone involved in this shit.
r/darkestdungeon • u/Ajv45 • Jul 21 '23
[DD 2] Discussion Death's Door on enemies is the most unfair mechanic ever
Call it skill issue I don't care.
It is grade-A bullshit that they took a mechanic that was there to help players and give to the enemies. I got one of those undead knights endure like 5 or 6 hits and killed all my team. At this point just remove their fucking health bars, they dont really matter and enemies will die whenever they feel like it.
I can't be the only one mad at this.
EDIT: Seeing a bunch of comments saying that there are ways to get around this. That makes it a bit better. I'm just starting the game and hated the mechanic right off the bat, but knowing that there's stuff that can be done, "The loathing abates"
ANOTHER EDIT: It seems that this Knight that hefted my party actually gets stronger on Death's Door and perhaps I overreacted to the whole mechanic with one of the extreme examples of it.
r/darkestdungeon • u/SireCannonball • Nov 05 '21
Stop crying about the new patch
For fs sake, I read the same complaints over and over before the patch. First Plague Doctor was too strong and there wasn't a reason to not pick her. Now ounce got nerfed. Barks interrupted combat too much, now they don't. Kill stealing was annoying, now it doesn't proc that much. Jester's Inspiring tune was too weak, so they buffed it. The game was too easy and people cleared it on their first run, now many enemies are buffed. The 5 round system made some fights impossible, so they removed it for these fights.
Jesus christ, this is Darkest Dungeon, is asking for a sliver of adaptation too much? So what if characters do negative barks on 4? it's still easy to keep positive relationships with stress under 6. Laudanum costs 3 gold, buy a shit load if you want to keep stress at 3 or lower at all times. If characters have negative relationships, guess what? You don't need a full party of positive relationships to win the game.
They fixed a lot of the community's perceived issues, just roll with the punches and stop whining or go play another game.