r/dadsarmy • u/rbdaviesTB3 • Sep 07 '24
r/dadsarmy • u/DynastyHeroes • Dec 12 '20
The Making of pvt Pike continuity error?
So I just finished watching episode 2 of season 9 in it Mainwaring gets given a staff car yet in episode 5 of season 7 he gets given a Rolls-Royce to use as a staff car so why does he need another one and if he doesn't have the Rolls-Royce anymore what happened to it?
r/dadsarmy • u/brucep26b • 2d ago
Missing Episodes
The missing episods series 2 could surely be replicated now via AI
About 8 series to learn the actors characters maneiams and speech patterns
I guess it would depend on how popular it would be
8 s
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Mar 30 '24
Boots Boots Boots is a great episode with a flawed 3rd Act
There are so many great moments in Boots Boots Boots. Mainwaring’s obsession with the 3 Fs, Walker drawing faces on Pike’s and Frazer’s soles, the football match, the hole in the beach and Pike’s nightmare. On the whole, the first 2 acts are 10/10 material.
Then the 3rd Act happens.
On the face of it, the 3rd Act seems rather amusing with the shoe shop and the swapping of the boots, the shoe salesman seeing it all before from Walker etc when Wilson and Pike arrive, however there are many flaws with this ending.
It ultimately leads nowhere. When the two teams go to swap the boots, in the end Mainwaring just ends up with his 6.5 boots again at the conclusion anyway and it makes it all null and void.
The fact both teams do it cancels the other out. There really is no need for both Walker etc and Wilson/Pike to each swap the boots as it does little in the end to drive the story on.
The resolution of the shoe maker fixing the situation seems unearned. What would’ve been better scripting wise, especially to make the two teams situation work better, would be for one team to go in and swap the boots, say Walker goes in, swaps the size 8 boots given to him for a pair of size 6s. Later, Wilson and Pike go in, they take the size 9s and swap them for a box of size 6s, however they actually contain the size 8s that were already swapped out. (To make it better, it could work too if one of characters such as Godfrey was a size 6.5) or something.
It just feels to me that the 3rd act is too convoluted and could have worked better had a different resolution occurred.
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Mar 24 '21
In your opinion, what are some underrated episodes or moments from Dad's Army?
r/dadsarmy • u/Visible_Wealth9578 • May 08 '24
Dad’s Army Alternative Timeline (September- October 1940 - 1960).
Operation Sea Lion is launched and is an immediate success.
Nazi Germany has won the Battle of Britain. England lies defenceless, the RAF is utterly defeated. The Nazi hordes swarm across the channel and although they are met with fierce resistance, British morale is low and without air support the British Army is overwhelmed and defeated in a shockingly quick time.
London is encircled and Churchill surrenders. He is sent to the Tower of London and held, awaiting trial as a war criminal.
The King and the Royal Family are smuggled out of the country on one of the last boats to leave a free Britain, bound for Canada.
Meanwhile, in Walmington-on-Sea, the Home Guard, a motley collection of old men; sickly mummies-boys; medical exemptions and conscientious objectors are the small seaside town’s last and only line of defence. The order comes down the line to surrender but the Platoon’s leader, a crazed patriot called Captain George Mainwaring, refuses to acknowledge this and orders his men to fight on, if need be, to the death, rather than laying down their arms.
Accepting that his men have little chance in facing down battle hardened SS troops and Panzers, Mainwaring orders his men to quickly forage for as many supplies and weapons as possible and to head for the countryside from where he intends to fight a guerrilla war, causing as much disruption to the enemy as possible.
Realising that this means certain death, private Joe Walker immediately surrenders to the civil authorities – the local police constable – and accepts the cease fire. The Nazi tanks roll into Walmington and the SS and Gestapo quickly establish order. Mainwaring convenes a court-martial in secret in Walker’s absence and imposes the death penalty. At the same meeting, a death list of local collaborators and Quislings is drawn up who must be executed at the earliest opportunity. Among those earmarked for death are The Vicar (Rev Timothy Farthing), The verger (Maurice Yeatman), The Air raid Warden (William Hodges) who have collaborated with the Nazis by supplying them with comforting religious services and fresh vegetables from Hodges’ greengrocer shop.
Mainwaring orders one of his crack troops – Lance Corporal Jack Jones - to sneak into Walmington and post a notice in the town square advising that collaborators will be shot on sight without trial. Jones risks capture by paying a visit to his lady companion, glamorous widow Mrs Fox. However, he is devastated to find her in the arms of a German officer. In a fit of rage he shoots them both dead and escapes by the skin of his teeth pursued by a German patrol. Jones unwittingly leads the Germans to Mainwaring’s hideout. However, Mainwaring has planned ahead and his redoubt is well defended. After a brief skirmish, five of the Nazis lie dead, one is seriously wounded and one taken alive. Mainwaring realises that they have no facility for taking prisoners and orders the prisoner to be taken outside and shot. Jones volunteers but Mainwaring, wary of the blood-lust in Jones’ eyes orders Private Fraser, a dour Scotsman to carry out his orders which he does without hesitation realising that the same fate would await him if the roles were reversed. Mainwaring administers the coup-de-grace to the wounded German with his pistol. With this act, the platoon realises that there is no going back now.
When the German patrol does not return, the Nazis unleash a terrible vengeance. Mr Godfrey’s cottage is burned to the ground and elderly Mr Bluett is tortured for days by the Gestapo. Bluett refuses to divulge any knowledge of the home guard and throws his torturers off the scent by going on for hours about his bunions.
Realising that they are unlikely to gain any intelligence from the old man, Klaus Von Macheim, the newly appointed Gaulieter of Walmington-on-Sea, orders the entire town out of their homes to the town square where they are forced to watch Bluett’s execution. A proclamation is read holding Mainwairing’s platoon responsible and Bluett is shot by firing squad. His last defiant words are ‘but what about my roses? I've just mulched them’ which causes Von Macheim to fly into a rage and to mutilate Bluett's corpse.
The townspeople are stunned into silence until a lone voice from the middle of the throng starts singing in a plaintive voice ‘who do you think you are kidding Mr Hitler?’ A couple of voices join in until the whole town are singing the defiant statement of freedom at the top of their lungs. Von Macheim fires his luger indiscriminately into the crowd and several people are killed. The townspeople flee and Von Macheim orders a total lockdown of Walmington-on-Sea.
News of this horrific event spreads along a secret network of gossiping housewives, delivery boys and spivs. Meanwhile, the people of Scotland still hold out against the invader, who soon realises it's just not worth invading the land to the North as the natives are too insane and warlike to ever be subjugated.
Months pass and Mainwairing and his crack platoon of misfits are still in hiding, plotting a plan of attack. Meanwhile, the Americans hatch a plan to secretly reinforce and arm Scotland with a steady supply of weapons and ammunition from disguised fishing boats and submarines. When the time comes, American troops will flood Scotland and attack Nazi occupied England.
The resistance groups across England listen to US forces radio for coded messages in-between the incessant Glen Miller records.
Mainwairing appoints himself Prime Minister of Free England and forms a war cabinet. Jones is appointed minister for War, Sgt Wilson is Foreign Secretary, Pike is minister for Intelligence , Fraser is Chancellor of the Exchequer and Sponge is Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster.
The US enters the war after Pearl Harbour and the platoon’s assassination campaign is put on hold.
Pike attends a resistance summit and returns with the news that a US backed attack from Scotland is imminent. When the message ‘Oh Lady Melton-Mowbray, what a lovely pair of pomegranates’ is broadcast the invasion will begin. The platoon begin training in earnest. Jones suffers a bout of malaria and imagines he is in the Sudan.
The platoon’s morale suffers a serious blow when their beloved medic Mr Godfrey passes away in his sleep.
Mainwairing asks for volunteer for suicide mission and Jones in his demented state volunteers. He walks into the Walmington-on-Sea tearoom frequented by Nazi officers with several pounds of high explosives under his clothes. He detonates his device and twelve Nazi officers are killed. Somehow Jones survives and stumbled out with his clothes in rags his spectacles hanging from one ear and his face all covered in dust. He is quickly hidden by the townspeople.
Fraser is sent to Scotland to liaise with his countrymen and to secure military aid.
A Mass invasion is launched from Scotland supported by American air power after Fraser’s pleas for help are accepted. Those Scots not armed with American weapons charge behind with broken bottles, bricks and home made ‘chibs’, united in their desire to ‘malky’ the Germans and free the Sassenachs.
Mainwairing orders a massive campaign of destruction and sabotage. The Nazis retreat back to fortress Europe. News reaches Hitler who delares Mainwairing an enemy of the Nazi state and orders his arrest and murder. Mainwairing has recently had posters put up describing the Fuhrer as a ‘madman who looks like Charlie Chaplin’.
Von Macheim, attempting to flee dressed as a nun, is captured by Private Sponge. Mainwairing orders that Von Macheim be taken to the exact spot of Mr Bluett’s murder and reads a short proclamation that the Gaulieter will be summarily executed. The platoon form a firing squad and Von Macheim is shot despite pleading for his life in a last cowardly act. His corpse is dragged through the streets of Walmington-on-Sea and mutilated before being hung from a lamppost.
The remaining surrendered German troops are then murdered by the platoon despite Mainwairing’s orders to take them prisoner under the terms of the Geneva Convention.
Collaborators are rounded up. The Vicar and Mr Yeatman are tied to posts, blindfolded and shot. Various women who slept with the Germans, including Mrs Pike, have their heads shaved and are tied to lampposts and tarred and feathered. Private Walker escapes. The bodies are buried in a mass grave behind Timothy White’s.
Mainwairing’s terrible revenge on the town’s collaborators is hushed up by the authorities desperate to avoid bad publicity and driven by a need for heroic tales of British pluck. The tale of 'Mainwairing's Marauders' is deliberately constructed.
Pike is elected MP for Walmington-on-Sea and is given a cabinet position as minister for reconstruction.
Mainwairing is promoted to full colonel and Jones awarded the VC in ceremony at Buckingham palace. Sgt Wilson is admonished for trying to chat up the Duchess of Gloucestershire.
Fifteen years later, a man’s body is found hanging underneath the pier at Walmington-on-Sea. Pinned to his chest is a message - ‘no hiding place for traitors’. The body is later identified as that of Eastgate resident James Beck - the post war identity assumed by Private Joe Walker. The murder is never solved.
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Mar 25 '21
Which Dad's Army character do you think would be the most fun to hang out with?
r/dadsarmy • u/igotsmeakabob11 • Oct 25 '25
"Bully bully sergeant" song from A. Wilson Manager?
Does anyone know the name of the song, where it can be located? It plays briefly about halfway through the episode, when Jones first walks into the hall with his new stripes.
r/dadsarmy • u/Valuable_Sherbet_483 • Aug 21 '24
What is your Dad’s Army opinion that would put you in this situation?
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Dec 18 '24
Pike
One of best lines in show was when pike sang and the German officer says what's your name and captain main waring says Don't tell him your name Pike.
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Mar 03 '24
Branded: a theory Spoiler
I was thinking about one of my favourite episodes of Dads Army yesterday, Branded, and I was trying to figure out how it was Captain Mainwaring ended up getting stuck in the burning shed at the end for Godfrey to come and save him.
My first thought had been that, due to Mainwaring’s bumbling nature, he may well have tried finding a sack in the shed, yet was unable to because most of them had, by then, gone, yet something tells me that this may not be the case. If counting Jones’s sack, there would still be, at least, 2 left in there, plus Godfrey too did not bring one out either which leaves 3. I doubt the Wardens would’ve miscounted the number of sacks.
My second thought was that due to the smoky conditions, his glasses may well have fogged up, or even fallen off, and as has been demonstrated numerous times, Mainwaring is practically blind without them.
However, as I tried to consider ideas, one came to mind which was almost a “eureka” moment, as if it very in fitting with Mainwaring’s character.
Mainwaring did it on purpose!
Here me out on this theory.
As was established, Mainwaring was extremely upset about Godfrey being a conscientious objector during the First World War, a fact no doubt which hit harder to home for Mainwaring considering his eagerness to fight in that war, only to join in during 1919. Mainwaring is a proud man, as is seen in Battle of the Giants, and resentful of the fact that he never got any medals for serving in the last war.
It can therefore be argued that Mainwaring would also be very proud of his platoon and it’s reputation amongst his peers like Captain Square and Colonel Pritchard. To have it be known, in his eyes anyway, that he had a conscientious objector in his midst would’ve been deeply embarrassing to him and his ego.
Therefore he conducted a plan, and a rather dangerous one at that.
Notice during the barn scene that Captain goes first before everyone else, before he comes back out and says that there isn’t enough smoke in there. He then sends the platoon through, leaving both he and Godfrey left to go last.
Mainwaring makes a point to make Godfrey go first and he follows behind him. Godfrey gets out okay, and then Hodges leaves, leaving Godfrey alone.
Godfrey, upon hearing no word from Captain Mainwaring, goes in to rescue him and is hospitalised as a result.
Yet, of note, Mainwaring isn’t hospitalised despite almost “allegedly” asphyxiating himself.
Of course, this would be a very dangerous and foolhardy thing for Mainwaring to do just to soothe his ego, however there is plenty of evidence during the series of Mainwaring taking dangerous options for the benefit of his men, including in Asleep in the Deep, where he hands out straws to see who will be at the head of the line, claiming the second short straw for himself despite it being long.
It makes sense to me that this would be a plan conducted by Mainwaring and Mainwaring alone. Discovering Godfrey’s true bravery during the battle of the Somme was an unseen benefit for him, however just having Godfrey “save face” was something he needed to prove for himself.
r/dadsarmy • u/cityspeak71 • Dec 27 '25
Jones eats an elaborate meal
So I am trying to find a particular clip that pops into my head every now and then:
Corporal Jones talks at length about a massive multi course meal that was amazingly cheap! Followed by a pause and then the punch line is "mind you, if wasn't very good..." with a slightly disgusted face from Jones.
It's just a random throwaway joke but I remember his delivery being funny...
I wondered if any of you might know what episode that's from and/or where I could find it?
r/dadsarmy • u/Gawain_Not_Wayne • Jul 29 '25
Pike's Potential
I listened to the radio episode 'If the Cap Fits' today, the one where Mainwaring makes Fraser Captain so he can see how difficult it is then stop complaining but demotes Wilson and Jones.
He actually promotes Pike, saying he sees hidden leadership qualities. I found this very interesting indeed and I feel that this should have been explored further.
Was Fraser right? What would a non-mollycoddled Pike be like?
Any thoughts?
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Jan 01 '22
Captain Arnold Ridley
Only quite recently found out that Private Godfrey, aka CaptainArnold Ridley, was a genuine war hero.
I apologise for judging you as as your character and would like to send you my respects. You achieved so much more than I ever could.
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Dec 16 '24
Dad's army
Dad's army must go down as one of the best comedy series ever made total gem
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Feb 16 '25
Difference between Mainwaring and Wilson.
I have been thinking about this for a while, it maybe a product of overthinking, but having recently gone through the series from start to finish again, I can’t help thinking how both Mainwaring and Wilson’s experiences in WW1 influence how they think/act/ and believe in the war effort. Obviously the class aspect is the thing that is highlighted within the sitcom, but Wilson having served in the trenches vs Mainwaring serving in 1919 May explain why Mainwaring is much more brash, much more ready to throw himself into action vs Wilson who is significantly more reserved. I guess my question is, do you think this is a fair assessment I.e. has any reality/ something Croft and Perry actively thought about in the dynamic between the two characters? Thank you and hope you are all doing ok 👍
r/dadsarmy • u/RangeMoney2012 • Aug 03 '25
A lovely photo of the cast outside the Imperial War Museum, London.
r/dadsarmy • u/[deleted] • Mar 09 '25
Top 50 TV Shows as Ranked by Various Sources (April 2023)... they are wrong! I don't see Dad's Army in the top 5! Dad's Army has got to arguably be one of the best comedies. 😁
r/dadsarmy • u/scarcitykills • Apr 03 '25
New DA audiobook on ebay?
This just popped up on my ebay feed
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/116546448496
Has anyone got this? I love the radio series so if this is legit then it would be absolute gold. For a tenner I might just risk it and see