We are trying out "Reveal Three" Fours! Fours now have the effect: "Your opponent reveals three cards from their hand, and you choose two of them for your opponent to discard." This is the second variation on fours we're trialing out this season as part of a series of betas which we will vote on to finalize the ruleset for the next Cuttle World Championship. This is largely motivated by the perspective that fours are by a large amount the weakest overall card, and that the effect of nine's is by far the weakest effect (though their rank makes them inherently more valuable overall). The hope is that well considered buffs to these cards could give each their proper time to shine in the overall game balance.
The plan was previously to try each variation for several weeks to give players a good sense of how it played before we vote at the end of the season, and this change accelerates that timeline somewhat. We tried out "Random Four"s starting two weeks ago and generally...people disliked them! That's okay; it's a key part of play testing to get feedback and see how things resonate. The most common feedback that we got during the shortened two week trial of Random Fours was that players largely disliked the randomness itself, as it increased the role of chance, perhaps reducing player control and the power of effective strategy.
It wasn't all bad though. Some productive conversations were sparked and interesting things discovered about the impact the change had on the flow of the game. Random Fours are a much stronger threat against larger hands than classic fours were, and can even threaten both queens and twos, encouraging a more aggressive play style that may have been positive for the pacing.
Still, this is an experiment for the community to decide upon, and it became clear quickly that Random Fours weren't going to be it. So we're trying the second idea out, Reveal-Three fours. These increase the power level of the four (compared to classic, "Victim's Choice" Fours) without increasing the randomness by forcing your opponent to discard better cards. Will that make Cuttle more fun to play? Try it and see! This is a chance for the Cuttle community to come together to try something new and to decide collectively what we want this amazing game to be. Should we keep Reveal Three fours or stick with classic Victim's Choice? Only time, and this amazing group of humans, will tell.
Sometimes you try something that just doesn't work out. Sometimes that leads you to a new and better idea, and sometimes it leads you right back to where you started. That's okay. Moreover, that's life. Not every idea can be a winner. The trick is to try things out in a safe and understanding space where failure is not only illuminating, but a damn good time. Know anyplace like that? Sure you do. We all do. It's right here, for Wednesday Night Cuttle tonight at 8:30pm ET. Come try something new, see how it goes, and have a blast either way.