r/cursor • u/posthubris • 2d ago
Question / Discussion Cursor >> Claude Code
I cannot imagine how an experienced developer would prefer Claude Code over Cursor. I’ve been using Cursor since it came out for both personal and professional work and I’ve been a SWE for over a decade.
New employer makes us use Claude Code extension via VSCode and to me it is incredibly inferior. First, no tab complete which was my favorite way of pair programming with AI once you get it dialed. Second, no right-click to add context to the chat, you have to @ a non ambiguous path by hand. Finally and most annoying is the stupid Flbergating, Fistulating, Garblabing, made up words that literally tell me nothing. This is more useless and frustrating than the spinning rainbow wheel on Macs.
Am I missing something obvious or has my employer nerfed certain settings? Anyone with over a decade of experience recently switch from Cursor oto Claude Code and actually prefer the workflow? I’m talking specifically workflow and not quality of models. Please let me know.
1
u/dvduval 2d ago
Yes, I agree with you from the standpoint of if you’re actually still writing code that Claude code would probably not be the best fit for you.
I also think that a lot of developers have completely stopped writing code and do not need a code editor at all. Coding with an AI agent has become a conversation with coders and testers and reviewers with coordinators, bringing it all together.
What I don’t like about cursor is the ownership of the company and we all see what’s going on with grok and I just can’t imagine this product is gonna be competitive long-term.
3
u/posthubris 2d ago
Don’t get me wrong I still single shot a ton of code via prompts but there are many instances where I’d rather update code inline to make edits rather than keep prompting and watch Claude “Smooshing”.
1
u/tnamorf 2d ago
Developer with more than three decades of experience here. I agree with everything you've said, buuuut right now the Claude models are just better, period - and IMHO that makes up for shortcomings in the workflow. I realise it's not what you asked for, but that doesn't make it less true.
That being said, I still use both. I have an OG Cursor subscription and am not giving it up any time soon.
1
u/posthubris 2d ago
We’re restricted to a subset of OpenAI models via Claude so I can’t speak for all available models. But not noticing anything better than Grok yet.
1
u/Mawk1977 2d ago
Cursor is designed to charge credits and pound cash.
1
u/posthubris 2d ago
The irony is my employer pays more per token from Claude than I do with Cursor.
1
u/Mawk1977 2d ago
If they are dumb enough to allow everyone to use the latest Claude frontier model, then they deserve to go broke.
1
u/JaredReabow 2d ago
Cursor and codex are on par i feel
1
u/posthubris 2d ago
Codex has all the missing features I mentioned above? Might have to give it a try.
1
u/hermit-the-frog 2d ago
I don’t think you can separate quality of models from workflow. The quality of the model affects the workflow IMO.
I think the quality/intelligence of Claude Opus 5.5 for example makes coding by hand or even autocomplete unnecessary and a thing of the past for our team. We all care very deeply about the code and have a really high bar there, but we can say what we want the agent to do instead of doing it ourselves.
We define lint rules, harnesses, and refactor bad code/patterns all the time when they are spotted so that best practices are easy for the agents to use and verify.
Life is code review now. So it was very easy for me personally to transition from Cursor back to VSCode + Claude Code Extension.
My workflow with Cursor was basically link a ticket or prompt with instructions, review code before commit, iterate etc locally, stage the good parts, iterate more, then finally commit, see code in totality in github, iterate, ask agent to review, iterate more. It’s basically the same now but much tighter loops.
Opus 5.5 was the turning point for me, basically converted me from Cursor. Opus can one shot a ticket in a matter of minutes, put up a draft PR and iterate a bunch without us having to babysit anything. It’s also good at breaking down heavy changes into smaller chunks so it’s easy to review. Great at resolving conflicts. Great at review, great at debugging, writing thorough tests, good at building infra.
Remote Control is also a game changer. I can keep iterating on stuff without being tied to my desk.
Basically all the work I found tedious to getting actual work done it is doing and doing well.
The one thing I’ve found to be lacking Compared to Cursor is the multi session management. It’s just not as good to keep track of multiple agents working on different things. Could be an easy fix for Claude Code though.
PS on adding context, I agree that it’s not as easy or nice as Cursor or even the Antigravity extension. But you can select lines or a file and it can automatically get added as context. It’s an option in the extension settings.
1
u/posthubris 2d ago
Ah thanks for the tip re: context addition. I couldn’t believe it only adds the current file to the prompt and any others you have to @.
1
u/Anti-Matrix66 2d ago
You're not crazy — they're honestly two completely different workflows, and the VS Code extension makes that gap feel even worse.
Cursor's Tab is built for tight, low-latency in-editor pair programming, whereas Claude Code was designed around terminal-first agent delegation. Most people I know who love Claude Code don't use it as a Cursor replacement — they run it in the CLI for larger multi-file tasks while keeping a dedicated autocomplete/Tab tool in the editor.
And yeah, hard agree on the whimsical spinner verbs — when you're waiting on a refactor, seeing actual step/file progress beats "Fistulating..." every single time 😂
2
u/posthubris 2d ago
Right?! At least with cursor you have the option to actually see the chain of thought while it’s fistulating.
1
u/Anti-Matrix66 2d ago
Exactly lol — watching the actual reasoning stream beats staring at a mystery verb hoping it didn't just rewrite half the wrong file 😅 Hopefully your team at least lets you keep Tab autocomplete alongside it!
1
1
u/ALargeSpork 2d ago
You can use Claude Code + VS Code. That’s what I do.
If you really want one GUI and you still write code, then yes: Cursor (or any other IDE-focused AI tool) would be the way to go.
1
u/Conza89 2d ago
Why not use Claude Code in the Claude Desktop app?
Tab complete, I mean if the old way was stone and chisle, tab complete is a jack hammer, but llm generated is like a nuclear bomb, just pointless the other ways? I mean for making money I don’t mean for enjoyment.
2nd point already addressed. I think, remove the vscode and just unlock the full power of either, good model in a real harness.
1
u/WC_FUN_2026 1d ago
Yes Cursor has better UIX, but Claude has 10x better models so you can even not link files in the chat and it will figure it out better anyway ans do better job.
0
u/x021 2d ago
> Am I missing something obvious
Yes, I switched to Claude Code Desktop and almost never use any IDE anymore. The only thing I need is something to review code efficiently.
The agent-only view Cursor is building is a poor copy of Claude.
If you told me 12 months ago I don’t need an IDE anymore I would’ve called you crazy. Now I think anyone still writing any line of code is crazy.
You’re worried about what text it shows while generating? Yes, you really are missing the point.
5
u/Blazr5402 2d ago
Cursor wins in UX for anyone who actually writes code. They're way ahead of anyone else in terms of UX and just generally having a platform for software development that feels good to use. It's unfortunate that their models are behind the frontier labs and the pricing structure for third party models is exorbitant.