r/criticalthinking • • May 28 '19

7 linguistic tricks people use to deceive and manipulate you

Thumbnail
lifelessons.co
2 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Nov 20 '17

Healthy eating is not inherently true, but rather is a personal and subjective interpretation within an abstract idea

1 Upvotes

I posted this a couple of days ago to r/changemyview (CMV), in the hopes of some rich and meaningful discussion, but wasn't very impressed with the responses/insights. I am new to Reddit, and had heard about CMV through a podcast I like ("You are not so smart"), and decided to give it a try. I have since done some more research through sub-reddits and have found this one - and I am again hopeful that there might be something interesting/meaningful that comes out of it.

This is my argument:

Both media and public health discourse have a tendency of presenting healthy eating as thing that exists (i.e. as an outcome of effort, as a knowable and do-able paradigm), but I believe that it can only exist as a subjective and personal rationale and practice. In other words, healthy eating cannot be prescribed because:

a) It doesn’t have any one inherent form, it is iterative both on personal and cultural counts, but also over time as knowledge and ideas change form;

b) It is an abstract idea and not a tangible, singular mode of practice (like many other abstract notions born out of human language [e.g. love, faith, good/evil]);

c) There has been a chronic failure to concretely define what healthy eating is, and articulate the exact, specific, and concrete rules required to accomplish it;

d) There are no adequate measures of success from a healthy diet (and while weight loss is often used as a proxy, it is a faulty instrument for measuring health, especially considering that: i) Malnutrition and other infirmities also result in weight loss; ii) Weight is correlated with illnesses as a risk factor, not as an absolute cause [e.g. the way that fire on the epidermis is an absolute cause for first, second, and third degree burns]) and; iii) The objectives for focusing on weight loss as a measure of health seem to consistently point to an implicit concern for bodily-aesthetic (see: healthism, and also Foucault’s body politic).

e) It is biologically unreasonable for a one-size fits all paradigm for any health-promoting intervention (e.g. not all adults are lactose intolerant, but many are, so weather or not milk is good/ok/bad will depend on personal genetics, and this is reasonably true for other variables as well, both the ones we understand such as milk, and the ones yet to be understood and discovered); and

f) There remains the paradox of: how people can be in reasonably “good health” (by medical standards) in spite of eating “poorly”, and how people can develop illnesses (that are ostensibly related to diet) in spite of eating “well”.

Having said all this, it seems that all that’s left are the ontological iterations of healthy eating as subjectively defined through personal values, goals/objectives, knowledge, cognitive biases, and cultural influences. Healthy eating is therefore amorphous and multiple.

Further, research on personal perceptions of healthy eating seems to be increasingly indicating that people will define healthy eating in whatever way best suits the narrative that makes them the most comfortable (i.e. fits their ethics [e.g. veganism, local, community garden], fits their fears/concerns [e.g. must be natural, GMOs are bad, eat organic, whole foods are best, no processing], etc.). This is not to critique individual iterations, but rather to acknowledge them, and to point out that they are the driving force of the actual way health eating is defined, ideologically furnished and subsequently executed through personal practices (which change over time, and are therefore also not stable or constant).


r/criticalthinking • • Oct 23 '18

Slippery slope

0 Upvotes

Some thoughts about "slippery slope" argument.

I was having a discussion with a person about banning certain types of cars. Their argument for banning that type was, "it's less safe than this other type". So <category 1> is less safe than <category 2>, so we should ban category 1.

So my thought was - If your only argument for banning <category 1> is that "it's less safe than <category 2>" - what is the harm in challenging the speaker to apply that same argument elsewhere?

I feel that challenging the speaker with this was reasonable, since they didn't provide any other rationale for their argument. However, the speakers response was something along the lines of, "you used the slippery slope fallacy, so this discussion is over". However, I'm still unsure that its a fallacy in itself. Rather, I feel that the "slippery slope" in this case is a mechanic that illustrates that there must be more reasons that haven't been discussed yet. Such as, "i'm willing to accept the reduction liberty for people who own cars in <category 1>, in exchange for more public safety, because I dont value that liberty as much as the resulting improvement to safety ."


r/criticalthinking • • Jun 10 '21

Examples for Ad Hominem help

5 Upvotes

I am writing a piece on Ad Hominem fallacy(Personal attack). As in most things, examples help us seep in the concept more.

So far I have these examples.

Example #1

Mark said, “We should eliminate the death penalty.”, but Mark is part of the KKK so I must disagree with him.

Example #2

James said, “College is not the best investment of your time and money,” and he never went to college so you can't make that claim.

Example #3

Trump said “The USA is the best place to start a business,” since Trump is a liar I can’t accept anything he says so it must be false.

Would you change something about these examples? Do you have any strong examples that I can use in the post?

Thank you in advance.


r/criticalthinking • • Feb 09 '18

doubts about first principles thinking

1 Upvotes

FPT (ala Elon Musk) is a nice concept, but I think it boils down to just really going backwards quickly until you hit axioms, so it's less originating at first principles and more just being willing to get there faster. Is this accurate?


r/criticalthinking • • Aug 13 '18

Why if the premises of an argument CANNOT all be true, then said argument is valid?

1 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Nov 28 '18

Why do people use propaganda techniques?

1 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Jan 15 '18

How to analyze person's intimidation and discouragement techniques employed by them to generate self doubt?

1 Upvotes

I am starting my journey on path of critical thinking and as I move forward I remember the challenges and push backs I had to face due to other's personal beliefs and stupid me that I didn't probed further with question to determine the real motive and validity of their responses. This is a recurring phenomenon in my life and kind of a cause for fear in my life to stay focused on my goal since mind needs focus to solve tough problems but adding the biases of people to that due to reasons such as jealousy, ego, personal beliefs, prejudices, sense of superiority etc adds a mental challenge that I am not yet up for.

Any references and books would be helpful. I am reading "Thinking Fast and Slow" but considering I am not yet sharp for Critical Thinking as the evidence suggest should I consider a more basic book as a beginning step.

My profession as a junior s/w engg. requires me to solve tough problems which are mentally challenging and even get insurmountable when people start projecting their partly useful partly harmful bullshit on me. I had to deal with arrogance, disapproval (due to my relatively older age with younger colleagues who are working for longer periods), sarcastic all knowing looks which may or may not be genuine. All these factors make my job and life difficult and significantly affect my competence.

I am not in the clear too but where do I draw the line or keep a analytical mindset uninfluenced by emotions and also set priorities not spreading too thin around various issues.


r/criticalthinking • • Jul 16 '20

If police in the US kill more white people than black people, then a white person is more likely than a black person to be killed by the police, right? Wrong. That’s an example of the base rate fallacy. This post explains the fallacy and suggests how to avoid it.

Thumbnail
byrdnick.com
35 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Aug 30 '18

What is a 'peasant mindset'?

2 Upvotes

Can someone explain this to me. I don't mean the literal definition but I mean how there are higher class people and then there are peasants and I am talking about today's day and age, what is a peasant defined as and what are constant thoughts they think to make them in that mentality?


r/criticalthinking • • Apr 05 '20

Using extreme examples in hypothetical situations

2 Upvotes

I took critical thinking a loooooong time ago so I apologize if this is a silly question.

When is it appropriate to use extreme examples when defining an argument? I

For instance I believe that if someone feels they know better they should act on there beliefs, but obviously only to a certain point. I’d use a rape as an extreme example, because most everyone would stop a rape if they could. However on the other side of the spectrum we should let everyone live freely to do as they want. I’m not going to tell someone they must say bless you when I sneeze.

In between these two examples is a grey area we’d call “life”. As there are very few moments where anything happens that is purely one sided; like an oversimplified black and white western movie.

So do extreme examples have a place in critical thinking? If so, where? I’m aware there’s a difference between causation and correlation. Thanks in advance for taking the time to read this!


r/criticalthinking • • Jul 28 '18

Why do we fail at communication?

2 Upvotes

When we choose the best possible words to describe a concept, someone always asks what do you mean by “any-word” so, if so many words are open to interpretation, should we always attempt to explain more thoroughly?


r/criticalthinking • • Feb 04 '18

Arguments with low instances of fallacies

2 Upvotes

Are there arguments that can have very little to no fallacies? What are the example of those? From shallow to deep, whatever it is.


r/criticalthinking • • Mar 20 '17

What kind of argument is this?

2 Upvotes

I have a friend that has a particular argument style. If I ask a question, he basically says "I think a better question is X" as opposed to answering my question. Essentially he refuses to answer the question if he believes there is a better one. In addition, I believe he thinks my question is invalid unless his premise is fully investigated and answered (to his standards.)

What would you call this?


r/criticalthinking • • Nov 28 '18

Why are there are a lot of people who can't or won't differentiate real information and clear-cut, by-the-book instances of propaganda techniques?

2 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • May 04 '19

Is technology limiting creativity?

3 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Jun 23 '18

This arguement in standard form?

3 Upvotes

I'm a little confused on how to put this argument in standard form. Can someone please help me?

"Chimpanzees today are in danger of extinction; for with the spread of agriculture and forestry, their habitat and their lives are threatened, as their forests are cleared to make way for cultivation and their food trees are poisoned to make space for timber trees. Moreover, since chimps are susceptible to all the infectious diseases of man, wherever their populations are near new human settlements they are endangered by epidemics."


r/criticalthinking • • Sep 16 '20

Is the meaning of life dependent on if you have an open mind?

3 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Apr 24 '18

Problems with critical thinking

3 Upvotes

May sound like a dumb question or two, but is the main problem we have in society these days being that people lack sufficient critical thinking skills? Is there such a thing as having too much critical thinking skills?


r/criticalthinking • • Jan 16 '18

What is it called when you form an opinion about yourself based on your prediction of other's opinion about you?

3 Upvotes

Based on their reactions towards you. What is it called when you get carried away in thoughts thinking about what other's think of you and you intuitively start forming an attitude which is a direct result of accepting and then reacting to those thoughts.


r/criticalthinking • • Jan 23 '17

Think about this..

4 Upvotes

Just because a group of people or person is labeled a terrorist.. It doesn't mean that they are. You should investigate every instance of someone being accused of terrorism.. But especially those with "Middle Eastern" sounding names. The media likes to lump every Muslim and group of Muslims as terrorists when they could just be defending themselves. Don't let the biased media twist you up. Judge everyone for what they do, not what the media tells you they are. They call Snowden/Manning traitors when they simply exposed corruption..its easy to see that they're not.. But it's not so easy to discern if someone Muslim (named something like) Muhammad Bali is or isn't because they paint every teen/adult Muslim as if he's a radical Savage. Do research on everybody/everything before coming to conclusions about an entire group of people. Stay woke


r/criticalthinking • • Dec 04 '17

Where to start? Please recommend book on critical thinking

5 Upvotes

Hi,

I want to improve my critical thinking skills. I am new to the subject. Can you recommend a book about the subject that is preferably both easy to read and concise. Something I will be able to read during the holidays.

I have been looking at these on goodreads but is not sure this is the best place to start.

Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking by M. Neil Browne, Stuart M. Keeley

Critical Thinking by Brooke Noel Moore, Richard Parker (at almost 600 pages it is a bit intimidating...)

Advice is appreciated. Thanks.


r/criticalthinking • • Jul 31 '18

Does the religious mind have greater problems with critical thinking?

5 Upvotes

I refer to those who are indoctrinated as a young child that can be convinced to believe by faith and not ask questions, also would this also affect a child's natural curiosity?


r/criticalthinking • • Jan 10 '26

Please sign this petition! Cap all lottery jackpots to $9 million, but RAISE the chances of winning jackpot!

Thumbnail
c.org
6 Upvotes

r/criticalthinking • • Apr 29 '20

Which questions would you ask a new doctor in an interview?

7 Upvotes

Lets say you are looking for a new a doctor and you get to interview them.

Give me some covert questions you would ask them that will:

  1. Reveal if they have a massive, sensitive ego.

  2. Assess their capacity for critical thought

  3. Reveal if they care at all about you and your health, or if you're just another wallet $.

4 & 5: Your choice, what would you find critical to discover about a potential new doctor? And, what covert questions would you ask to get that info?

(Most doctors are trained to gain the trust of their patients. If they haven't been trained, they picked up on what works and what doesn't through experience. There is also the power of authority that has influence on our minds... that comes with the title of doctor and white lab coat. Which would make assessing them early on... difficult. Looking for original, creative questions here. not the stuff you find from a quick google search like "What drives you!" which can easily be lied about and seen as an assessment question from miles away)

Excited to hear what questions you come up with!