r/criticalrole • • Apr 19 '24

Discussion [Spoilers C3E92] getting really tired of how the gods are portrayed. Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Wildmother in Campaign 2: benevolent, mostly kind. Takes in a PC who’s lost their way. Wildmother in Campaign 3: willing to let an innocent person be forced to become the champion of a betrayer god so she can have another meat shield against another threat.

I get that Predathos is making the gods scared for the first time in a long time. But these are the same beings who have resurrected non-believers from the dead. These guys went to work against the titans and their own kin to protect mortals. It’s too much of a stray from previous characterization. These aren’t the Greek gods that would turn you into a monster for looking pretty.

I think Matt and co. Are trying to make some grand point about religion, who is truly good and evil, etc. but they aren’t working with blank slates. They are working with Gods we have watched for years. And Wildmother’s, Changebringer’s, and Dawnfather’s actions in C3 don’t gel with that.


r/criticalrole • • Jul 03 '24

Discussion [No Spoilers] is this campaign falling off hard later on?

0 Upvotes

So I’ve not watched in a long while and started to pick it up again. I’m around episode 57. It got like over a million views+ each episode. But when I look at the later episodes it barely reaches half?

I know perhaps some reasons why this campaign isn’t like the others. Relationship seems pretty forced for the audience’s. The chose one, things that should be dead aren’t.

It honestly feels more of a TV show and they need to hit X points to hit with the viewers instead of… well, D&D game with friends. Perhaps I’m wrong though and I’m looking too much into it. Just curious and such!


r/criticalrole • • Jan 25 '26

Discussion [No Spoilers] Struggling to enjoy C4

3 Upvotes

Just wanted to rant a bit on C4....the following is my own personal thoughts and I'm by no way saying people have to agree or that CR needs to change or anything of the sort.

The I fell in love with CR is because it was a close-knit group of friends coming together to weave a story with dice rolls. It felt very much like a home game that I got to watch them play together letting the dice tell the story.

Campaign 4 hits different....there's a ton of narrative, Brennan talks a lot and IMO over explains things (I say this as someone who struggles in doing the same thing at work, and probably even in this post). He turns a simple thing into a paragraph long monologue...you don't just "see an empty box in the cellar", you see "a box put together with rusty bent nails, the wood swollen from the humidity in the dank cellar...it's color darkened from the mold beginning to engulf it. You peer over the open edge into an inky abyss as the box just sits there, empty".

It feels like I'm having someone read a book to me rather than listening in on a group of friends having fun and playing D&D.

Don't get me wrong, Brennan is a monologue genius and I love it in short bursts....or when he's representing a specific character/NPC. But I think him as the DM running every encounter, every response to the characters, every NPC, is just too much for me.

I also miss having a static set of characters/players at the table with the occasional guest player. Obviously not too late to see some of this, but I like when Aabria, Luis, Robbie, and others showed up out of nowhere for a few episodes (can we get Erika back plz....by far my favorite character across all CR campaigns). It was fun, it was a novelty to see different players and characters. Now, it just feels like there is no surprise and the fun of those players being there permanently (forcing less screen time of other players/characters over long periods) detracts from the experience.

Lastly, it just seems like a significant lack of dice rolls telling the story. I don't have stats for C4, but in earlier CR campaigns it was something like 1000 dice rolls in the first 10 episodes....now it feels like we're lucky to get 30 dice rolls in a 3-4 hour episode that isn't combat focused. Feels very much like the dice are taking a back seat to the story, rather than being a critical element of the story...and that detracts from the feeling of watching a D&D game. The soldiers table episodes were, in my opinion, by far the best subset of episodes thus far. If C4 was exactly that group of people and exactly that style of gameplay I'd happily watch a few hundred episodes of it (shout out to Whitney, absolutely adore her character and her energy with the rest of the cast - best new permanent player of C4).

Again I by no means am saying C4 is bad, or that people shouldn't like it or anything. If you like (or love) C4, great. I hope you continue to enjoy it through and through. It just feels like a very big shift away from the format I fell in love with and makes it much more challenging for me to enjoy.

/rant

I expect lots of people will disagree, I suspect some may agree (in whole or in part). Regardless I'm genuinely happy that CR is getting to do what they love to do, and that many people are enjoying C4. I just don't think it's for me in its current state and will probably skip it or at least de-prioritize watching it to the lowest levels of my backlog.


r/criticalrole • • Sep 19 '25

Discussion [No Spoilers] No Live Rebroadcasts is a Really Bad Thing for Fans

0 Upvotes

To Preface I've been a fan of Critical Role on and off since 2019 and I've been super excited for season 4. With the recent announcement of having no live rebroadcasts I'm really worried about the dangerous precedent that sets for the company's consumer practices. This is a deliberate anti-consumer move that will negatively impact many fans experience with critical role.

EU fans cannot reasonably catch the broadcast live. Many fans on the East Coast can not reasonably catch whole streams. The 7pm timeslot makes things difficult for many fans when it comes to experiencing streams live. It simply goes too late. The live rebroadcasts solve this issue so any fan can instead catch the streams in the morning.

Now no live rebroadcasts might be slightly annoying, but why is it "anti-consumer"? This is because Critical Role has a vested interest in people missing the live broadcast, the ONLY way to see the broadcasts after the fact are to PAY for access to them or WAIT until Monday. Now them posting the VODS for free on Monday is a very pro-consumer move, but there is a trade off. If you wait until Monday you simply miss the chance to engage in real-time discussion on the episodes in community spaces like here on Reddit. This is a restriction on community involvement locked behind a paywall, and that is deliberately anti-consumer. They are weaponizing FOMO to get you to pay money for faster access to the VODS, this is especially predatory for people in places that have no chance of catching the live broadcast like, those in the EU.

Now this is not an especially egregious move and many other companies continue to do much much worse, but as a company that markets and presents itself as very progressive and pro-consumer this goes DIRECTLY AGANSIT that messaging and I think it is important to call out and call attention to, especially because the solution to the problem is so simple, simply bring back the rebroadcasts.

I don't know about everyone else, but I hope this does not set a bad precedent for the future of how they treat us their fans of what a is genuinely a really amazing product.


r/criticalrole • • Aug 13 '23

Discussion [No spoilers] Concentration checks, spells and blunders between campaigns Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I’ve watched 70+ sessions of C1 all of C2 and C3 and a huge fan of the show like so many others which brought me to DMing my own group for 3 years.

Things are missed over the course of a session in all aspects of every table and it’s completely understandable. However… I was watching a combat from C1 yesterday and now the one recently in C3. That’s roughly 5+ years of playing dnd in between.

Why does the group fail to remember concentration almost every battle and further more Matt has apologized saying “I forgot to remind you” and often says “I have a lot to remember”. Now in no way am I getting on Matt whatsoever because he has wayyy to much to remember consistently. Remembering spells players have used and whether they have a reaction to use or whatever is not his responsibility… it’s the players.

Again I get it happens at every table but damn they are literally putting on a show and complete combats get completely turned around or massive misuse of spells happen that could drastically change outcomes. There are missed concentration checks almost every combat, Ashley has misused ice knife at least 4 times forgetting the explosion, etc. etc.

I just wished the players would remember what’s happening with their own characters more consistently and it would make combat much more enjoyable to watch. Like what happened to concentration rings around the mini, put a damn token of sorts in front of your dice tray or even better yet dndbeyond add a concentration code built in the the CS when you subtract damage it reminds you. It’s just such a bummer to be like welp they missed that again.

Anyways love ya CR and many blessings in the future and continued success! Matt as another Dm much love for all you remember and keep track of!


r/criticalrole • • Dec 26 '25

Fan Art [No Spoilers] “Nott the Brave” - furry version

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just a little fanart of my favorite character of the animated series ❤️ Love her so much 🥺


r/criticalrole • • Jan 13 '23

Discussion [Spoilers C3E45] My problem with this campaign Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Preface: I am from Germany, so please be a little lenient with spelling and grammar with me. I try very hard to stay as understandable as possible. In general, this post is also not meant to talk bad about Critical Role, but is simply a view from me on the current state. I myself became a big fan of Critical Role with C2 and later watched and loved C1 as well. ExU 1 hadn't been my cup of tea for various reasons, but the topic here is about Campaign 3, which I (and also part of my bubble) aren't really warming up to.

Why is that? It's difficult to give exact reasons. And in general, they are highly subjective. I'm also fully aware that there are certainly plenty of people who think C3 is great all around, or even the best campaign yet. They're welcome to think so. But why not me? There are probably a number of reasons that combine to make this happen. I'll just start with my thoughts and guesses so far:

First thoughts

The Setting

At the beginning I thought I would have problems with the very different culture and the language used to name things. The city, group and NPC names were all very foreign to my ears, where in C2 many things even had a German touch. Now I had a hard time telling everything apart - so who or what was this foreign word? Was it a person? Place? Has it ever been used before or is this the first time it's been mentioned? It became really clear with "Lady Emoth" for me, who was introduced (at the party) as if she had appeared before and was relevant. It didn't get any better after that.

The Characters

I'm not going to lie: Bringing in the ExU characters was a drag for me. Also, having them start at level 3 wasn't helpful, because you often learn more about the characters in just the earlier "mortal" levels as well. Nonetheless, at least after a short while it wasn't a problem because all the characters were funny and colorful and fun to watch. But more on that later.

The show

The new set is cool. Also having everyone at the table again is good and important. But the fact that there were planned character deaths (Bertrand Bell) was a bit strange, because it added to the general impression that everything seemed a bit slick. A bit too polished, too much according to plan. Too scripted feeling.

Current

My current thoughts, after 45 episodes, are a bit more expansive and deeper. And I'm also drawing some lessons for my own sessions.

The Setting

The foreign names are probably much less of a problem than that they remain just "names". For virtually none of the groups and places do you get a face or idea of what they stand for. Most of the authorities only serve as faceless blockers for content and stories, so that the characters have to go in a different direction. We know almost nothing about them. If we take C2 in particular as a counterexample here, we had a picture very early on of Cobalt Soul, Cerberus Assembly, Empire, Crownsguard, Mardoons, Revelry, and later Kryn Dynasty. The world consisted of living factions and groups with their own goals and interests. That - from my point of view - did Matt less good this time. Starting in a big city also contributes to this, because such big cities are often good in idea, but in game terms they are simply too big and thus too anonymous.

The Characters

The characters are all extremely colorful and "over-the-top". This makes it difficult to sympathize with them, because they practically don't feel like "real people" at all. Except for Orym, none of them are "regular dudes", but highly mysterious and special. And they are almost all above "worldly" things and problems because their problems are so blatant and otherworldly. But I like my stories in a way that I can empathize with them. The C1 and C2 characters were virtually all "normal". Prime example would be Keyleith, who is the most "over-the-top" per story and was on her way to becoming a demigod, but was so humanized by Marisha because she played Keyleith in such a way that she had major problems with responsibility and power. From my point of view, the C3 characters are basically caricatures that practically never break out of their roles and remain very superficial. If it goes a bit deeper and under this surface, the superficial role is then promptly triggered again, a joke is made and the topic is gone.

Both of these elements prevent me from immersing myself in this campaign because I can't find any points of reference. The characters are very pale and have little personality, but quite a lot of quirks. Where in C2 you could see the vulnerable relationships between Caleb and Nott, but also the rougher relationships between Beauregard and the others. Jester's Quirks lightened the whole thing up a lot, now these connections are missing on a level that makes you root for them.

And these over-the-top characters are now in a campaign where the story is also developing more and more as over-the-top. At least I can't find my way around it.


r/criticalrole • • Feb 15 '26

Discussion [Spoilers C4E14] Ashley/Vaelus lackluster in combat? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Maybe I’m crazy, but Vaelus in combat bugs me and I haven’t seen anyone talk about it. Just to preface, nothing against Ashley at all. I love her as a character and player, just not so much in combat.

To me, she seems so… confused in combat. Trying the same action over and over instead of giving someone the help action, using her paladin abilities, flanking, etc. There are actions you can take to help your team even when the dice aren’t on your side.

Half the time I forget she’s a paladin because it seems like she does too. I never forgot Teor was a paladin, and Travis never had to be reminded that smite was an option. But maybe it’s unfair to compare characters of the same class against eachother?

Near the end of combat the other players started giving her help on what she could do on her turn. I think this was because she was clearly getting frustrated, but some part of me was a little miffed she seemed so lost.

I’m sure there have been more examples, I’m just thinking of the bridge fight right now.

Vaelus is such a great character in concept and in RP, and she did great in her first combat against the crows, but it seems she hasn’t progressed at all since then. It seems how well she does is entirely controlled by the dice, rather than by skill.

I’m sure I’m being super nitpicky. She probably just isn’t used to Vaelus’s loadout yet. I’ve never played a wizard before but I’m sure it would take some getting used to. I’m sure I would need practice before I’m proficient. But seeing that Ashley is literally a professional and has been doing this for years and years, you think she’d be more accustomed to learning a new character’s skill set?

Again, this is not a personal attack against Ashely. I know it probably came across like that, I’m really not trying to be mean. I’m just wondering if anyone else has seen this, or if I’m delusional.

Edit: It’s clear to me now that this is just who Ashely is lol. That’s okay! I still love her character, I just won’t put as much effort into analyzing her combat strategy as I will for Matt lol.

Also yes, comparing her to Travis is unfair as it seems he’s a paladin junkie. We should make *him* play a wizard.


r/criticalrole • • Oct 21 '25

Discussion [No Spoilers] Is anyone else struggling with the scenes with Hal and Thaisha?

1 Upvotes

I'm struggling to get through their scenes, specifically the last episode when they were at the theater' it feels so slow... I just find everything else so much more interesting, especially loving the Wic storyline. It's nothing against the players here, just not as invested in this part of the story. Am I alone in this? I've basically just started reading the wiki whenever they come on now.


r/criticalrole • • Feb 08 '23

Discussion [Spoilers C3E45] Lewd humor, player characters, story are not meshing well imo Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First I want to preface this by saying this is from a viewer's perspective/opinion. This is their game and they should do whatever and play however they like.

I do like me some lewd humor. However, it seems like in this campaign it's beginning to get out hand, at least for me it is. With the previous campaigns, I found the balance between humor, story, and seriousness to be quite good. This time it seems like every other scenario there has to be lewd humor even if the situation is dire. I thought I'd be able to deal with it, but then the "making a porno" scene happened. I get it, they're friends playing D&D but it was so off-putting considering the situation. I had to take a break from watching after that (now, I am working my way back to being caught up, just finished episode 45). The amount/timing of lewd humor and how the player characters act don't mesh well with the story Matt is trying to weave in my opinion. I just can't take the plot, and high stakes seriously when we have stuff like that going on. I'm having a hard time getting invested in this group. Half the time I'm thinking to myself, I'd rather spend more time with the recurring or reappearing/callback npcs than the actual player characters. The humor and characters would be fine... if the story and vibe suited it, but I don't feel like that's the case with this one. Vox and M9 were a bunch of goof balls as well, but like I said before, I feel like they balanced the humor way better. I would like to hear the community's opinions/views on this.


r/criticalrole • • Jan 12 '25

Discussion [Spoilers C3E103] BH are hypocrites? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

In the middle of catching up to c3 and just reached their argument with Ludinus, am I the only one who feels that the arguments from Bells Hells were quite weak? I think among the whole group Travis was the only one who had kind if valid arguments against Ludinus, and he was not arguing against the gods or for the gods, he was actually talking about whats best for mortals, and what risks mortals would face in this upcoming battle.

I understand that Ludinus is an absolute piece of shit and should not be trusted with power, but I dont think any of them beat him at the argument. Ludinus' argument was that gods are absolute fuck ups and thats okay but nobody who is an absolute fuck up should weild that much power. Members of BH (laudna, imogen, orym) tried arguing saying okay but humans do that themselves, whereas only Dorian understood the idea of levelling the playing field. Ashton was curious about the idea, Fearne was taking a back seat like she always done during these moments, and Braius, to sam's credit, was roleplaying appropriately as a religious fanatic.

Their second argument was that its uncertain as to how Predathos would react. Valid point, but the way they argued that is 'whats to say predathos wont fuck everything else up', which is a stupid way of arguing? you cant really prove something wont happen, the burden of proof is on you when you make an argument, which ludinus did with the food chain theory, and they still keep saying "what if you are wrong". well then, prove him wrong. They also say "what if what we saw is one story and theres other stories to contradict that?" Well then find and recount those stories.

the whole episode felt like a 10 year old arguing with an adult about a topic he knows nothing about, which is annoying because they have good points they just dont use they properly. Orym can always call ludinus out specifically as someone who cant be trusted with this powers even if they agree with the means, given his past. There were no arguments from Essek, who arguably knows Ludinus the best(which i get because matt doesnt want to contradict his bbeg atp, but the group should always turn to essek to ask his opinion on the plan?). The best way to win that debate was to call out ludinus' flaws, and they went about instead defending the gods' flaws. yeah the gods are also frail emotionally and kinda like them (as laudna puts it), but that doesnt give them freedom from consequences? Because by that point of view, the gods are basically the bad guys, and so are the BH. I also find it incredibly hypocritical of Laudna to accuse Ludinus of risking it all by depending on a powerful evil entity who coild destroy everything to achieve his objective, when only 3 episodes ago she was willing to risk it all by depending on a powerful evil entity who would destroy everything to achieve her objective given the chance.

I feel travis came the closest to destroying Ludinus' good guy facade with his philosophical question of if ludinus was okay risking exandria on the offchance that predathos fucked them up too, which he conveniently ignored and ran away from as soon as he could. They should have pressed that line of thinking too.

I also dont understand why they are so against ludinus taking the orb of memories out and showing it to the rest of exandria? If they are so sure that the gods are just people and the story was nuanced and believed that the gods deserved their place, shouldnt they believe that the rest of exandria should be able to make that decision too? Why hide something if its not dangerous to the reputation the gods have crafted of themselves, right?

TLDR : Ludinus is a dick but he made sense, BH did not in that argument because they were defending 'people' who made mistakes and did not want to take accountability for it. Ashton, Dorian and Chetney are the only ones who were presenting valid points, while the rest were being hypocritical or unable to present accurate points.


r/criticalrole • • Apr 05 '26

Discussion [Spoilers C4E20] (current campaign)(all completed campaigns) C4 Feelings so far Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know there are probably dozens of posts like this out there, so I'll try to be brief. I just wanted to put my thoughts down on metaphorical paper.

WARNING: If you are absolutely loving C4, and have zero notes, this post it not for you. I'm genuinely happy you're loving it and I wish you the best.

Priors: Been watching CR for 5 years. Have watched C1 and C2 two to three times each, and all of C3 once with specific re-watches of some parts. Loved 1, adored 2, was mixed on 3.

Going into C4, I was excited. A mix-up was needed, and the new folks were all people I liked (with the exception of Whitney, who I hadn't seen beyond Birdemic, so I was neutral). The multiple tables thing was a good idea to help with the problem CR has always struggled with, the big cast at one table, and Exandria was getting a little long in the tooth (bloated, if I was being uncharitable), so again, all looked good.

But I'm 20 episodes in now, and it just hasn't clicked for me. Like...at all. The characters, the story, the setting, the action, none of it. The overall feeling I have is supreme boredom. I find myself tuning out and having to rewind to catch what happened. For the the first time I have to check out previous episode summaries before livestreams because I have COMPLETELY forgotten what happened or was happening.

I don't want to itemize every little thing, but broadly:

  1. Brand new world, but we're getting PILES of new info. New places, people, religions, factions, are being introduced constantly, before a lot of it has a chance to settle. I'm feeling overwhelmed in a way I have never experienced in an actual show setting (CR or otherwise, I've watched a LOT of them).

  2. Most of the Main Characters are already influential people with MANY pre-existing relationships, both to PCs and multiple NPCs each. There are no fish out of water for the audience to cling to like in other fantasy stories. They're nothing like the vagabonds, outcasts, and runaways from every other CR campaign.

NOTE: I know some characters are borderline for this description, but compare, say, Percy to Wic, Julian, or Octis, at campaign starts. I'd say their positions are quite different.

3. Plotwise, there was almost no buildup. No low to medium stakes adventuring that gives the group(s) time to feel each other out and get to know each other. No saving villagers from gnolls or dealing with the Slayers Take. Even C3 had smaller challenges like Ira and the Shade Mother. Nope, it's straight to the big bad. World ending calamity RIGHT NOW.

All 3 of these things compound each other. If only 1 or 2 of them were happening, I could deal, but all 3? Giant, brand new world that needs explaining, combined with very complicated characters with LOADS of pre-existing history with each other and dozens of other people, AND a world-shaking calamity involving tons of new lore and metaphysical concepts, AND we're jumping between 3 separate groups doing completely different things?

Also don't misunderstand! If this was happening, say, halfway through? I'd probably be LOVING it! But right out of the gate? I haven't had a chance to form attachments to players, NPCs, places or historical events. It all means nothing to me, and I get even more detached when the players are reacting with such huge emotions. Azune and Hal had a very emotional scene recently, and Luis/Liam played it wonderfully. But I felt nothing. I've barely spent any time with these people. The scene just did not feel earned to me.

And finally...and most/least important, I'm just not feeling the joy any more. Everything's just so damn serious. Sure folks crack a joke here and there, but the vast majority of it is the players, not the characters. I was hopeful during the Solders arc. Thimble fighting with Wic was great. Kattigan is a total delight. But so much of the vast majority of the in-game events are so DOUR and GLOOMY. Is this what CR wants to be moving forward?

I guess I'm just feeling drained. CR has been moving away from the stories they used to tell for some time now; if C4 is their vision of the future, if this is CR firing on all cylinders? I don't think it's for me. I've just been feeling a mixed of bored and sad whenever I tune in.

AAAAAAAAAANYWAY, that went on longer than I meant it to. If you made it this far, thanks for reading! If anyone has struggled with C4, I'd like to hear. Even more so if you've found ways of overcoming that and now are enjoying parts of it more after that initial struggle. And, if you just want to vent/agree with me, hey, I'll take that too.


r/criticalrole • • Jan 21 '18

Discussion [Spoilers C2E02] Some thoughts on Marisha's new character and her actions in this episode Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I know how polarizing Marisha is in this community so I've been struggling thinking how to frame this thought process.

For a TL;DR let me say that I think Marisha just likes to play exaggerated versions of herself, that therefore this new character will be overall extremely similar in behavior, mannerisms and tendencies to her C1 character and quite simply she's probably the "worst" cast member when it comes to making a likable character (someone has to be the worst in any group anyway) and in the end I think that's just fine and that she's still as much of a valuable part of the stream as anyone else.

Marisha seems to have some sort of concentration issue (I don't like to speculate on personal issues, but it seems to show very clearly during the games so it seems relevant) that causes her to miss pieces of information and then jump to wildly inaccurate conclusions regarding a given situation, leading her to make choices that seems completely absurd to everyone else (rewatch the episode and play close attention to the reactions of everyone else when she goes on her little solo mission and even how Laura threw playful yet very obvious jab at her afterward).

I 100% think that's just Marisha and that she would have done the same regardless of the stats or personality of the character she was playing. And again, I think that's fine, everyone has flaws, weak points and issues.

But I think the big problem during C1 was that she and her character were enabled and sometimes even encouraged to take the center stage when they really weren't protagonist material.

Marisha has her great moments but she also seems to lack a bit of a filter and she seems to throw everything that comes to mind out there and that has at times been disruptive of the game and this could have been one of those times, the only reason Mercer made her do that strength check was in an effort to avoid the massive derailment that would have resulted from attacking guards because then the whole episode would have been about finding a way to free her or required Mercer doing some absurd metal gymnastics to justify her not facing severe punishment in this apparently authoritarian society.

So what I'm hoping is that everyone else will reign her in more during this story by taking more of the spotlight (I specially would love for Laura, Travis and maybe Taliesin to take center stage this time the way Marisha and Liam did it in the alter parts of C1) before she does and that way allowing her to shine in more of a support role instead of just giving her endless rope with which to hang herself.


r/criticalrole • • Mar 10 '22

Discussion [Spoilers C3E14] CR and Guests Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Wondering if anyone feels the same. I’ve been a big fan of CR since the start of campaign 2 and I enjoy every champaign! But with the addition of Robbie in C3 the cast felt choked and most every scene felt slow. I like Robbie and Dorian, but now that he’s gone C3 feel like everyone has room to breath and their chemistry is back. Does anyone else agree?


r/criticalrole • • Jun 05 '22

Discussion [No Spoilers] Sustainability of Critical Role Merchandise

177 Upvotes

Edit: Since the discussion is getting a little heated I want to remind everyone of the Civility Policy. Treat each other with respect and kindness always. Don't forget to love each other.

My intention here is to inform, discuss and ask a company that has proven they're interested in what their community has to say to provide more information on their merch production and consider going a more sustainable route. English is my second language and I'm sorry in advance for any mistakes I made.

All of the recent merch drops look amazing and I'm sure they're good quality considering the price and mass production. I'm a little sad to see that a lot of the clothing items are polyester blends and the knits are mostly acrylic. There are shirts that are 100% cotton, but there isn't any mention of recycled or organic materials which is a little sad to see and probably not in the Wildmother's best interest. On the website I couldn't find any information on where the garments and items are being produced, I looked in the FAQ and I tried to zoom into the tags of a few shirts. After a quick search I found this thread from a year ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/criticalrole/comments/kpqfac/no_spoilers_is_critical_role_merch_ethically_made/

What "ethical" or "sustainable" fashion even means can be up for interpretation, but for those who never encountered the term before, it describes products, processes, activities, and actors (policymakers, brands, consumers) aiming to achieve a carbon-neutral fashion industry, built on equality, social justice, animal welfare, and ecological integrity. (Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_fashion)

While I understand that there can be no ethical consumption under capitalism, I think it's important to hold companies accountable and remember that merchandise is a want, not a need. I know that ethical manufacturing practices come at a higher price point but I've seen that it is possible to do better at least without making the merchandise unaffordable for larger audiences. I'd like to give examples but I don't want to advertise other brands - if you'd like to know the sustainability ratings of your favorite brands you can check out https://directory.goodonyou.eco/. What comes at no extra cost would be providing customers with more information regarding production so we can make an informed decision.

Is this something my fellow critters even think about or would like to see as well? There might be some who say that those who don't like it simply shouldn't buy it, but I don't think it's unreasonable to ask for improvement if that's in the best interest of the brand image, employees, customers and the environment.


r/criticalrole • • Mar 12 '21

Discussion [Spoilers C2E129] Yeza is a bad example Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Yeza is not a good example of a husband.

I think its concerning with how much the community touts Yeza as a positive example for men in relationships.

Veth is rarely present in their lives. Veth has emotionally cheated on Yeza with Caleb. Veth has privately derided Yeza's looks, lack of game, and lack of excitement.

Yeza is in a bad relationship and doesn't take steps to improve it. Never once has he ever taken issue with anything Veth has ever done.

He isn't supportive, he's subservient to his wife's wishes. A marriage is a partnership. Veth isn't perfect and Yeza should have the strength to prioritize his family and marriage rather then always trying to smooth things over.

Sweet, gentle, kind, good person and great father. But not what someone should be in a relationship.


r/criticalrole • • Dec 10 '21

Discussion [Spoilers C3E7] The idea that they don’t want us to know what to except with Campaign 3 is dumb Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I don’t know if this is a controversial opinion, but it’s pretty dumb to me that the attitude Critical Role seems to have for Campaign 3 is “don’t expect anything! Anything can happen!”

Like, what? I’m still enjoying the show but it’s bothering me that they’re being so secretive about everything. Tell us conclusively who Travis’ character is, no memes. Tell us if Robbie is gonna stay or go. Tell us when we should expect a post show. Tell us how these homebrew classes work so we can better understand what’s going on. Tell us what feats people got. Tell us things so we aren’t just left guessing and grasping at straws.

I don’t think I’m asking a lot. I obviously don’t want the literal plot to be spoiled, but there’s a difference between being clear with your audience so everyone is on the same page and ruining surprises.

If Chetney is Travis’ permanent character? Awesome. If he’s not? Also awesome. I’m sure it will be fun either way. But whats not fun is the constant vacuum discussions in the community. None of us know ANYTHING this season. And that’s not fun, that’s frustrating.

Again, not saying I want to be spoiled. It’s not as if I want them to reveal character backstories on Twitter before the show or something, but I would like to understand what’s going on with the show better so I can grow more attached to the story/characters.

Sorry if this is an unwanted rant. I needed to get it off my chest. And for the record I’m still enjoying Campaign 3 and have all the love for the show, this is just a grievance I have.


r/criticalrole • • Jun 22 '26

Discussion [Spoilers C4E30] I think if anyone is going to betray the party, it's Tyranny Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Multiple times now Tyranny has pressed Wic on if he really wants to do what he's doing. She double checked with him after meeting with the demon, and she asked him again if they were abandoning the plan after Wic successfully fooled Yanessa.

I could totally envision a situation where Tyranny decides to work against the party in the interest of covering Wic's ass. Entirely without his permission, of course, but with her believing its the only way to keep him safe.


r/criticalrole • • Mar 16 '26

Discussion [Spoilers C4E18] A Flaw with Brennans West March style Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First off I would like to say I really enjoy C4, its up there with C1 for me.

However there is a Flaw with how Brennan is executing an aspect of the West Marches Structure**( Yes I know its west Marches inspired not west marches straight)**

A key aspect of Westmarches campaign is that  they are designed to ensure  that all the adventuring Teams return to the Central Hub after their adventures.This allows the adventurers to exchange info, and more importantly swap teams if necessary

West March campaigns are constructed in a way to ensure there is a  powerful Plot reason for the adventurers to always return to the Central Hub city after every adventure.

For example

….The Hub might be the only Safe town near the Uncivilised Adventuring zone thus forcing the Players to always have to return after Adventuring .

…..The Hub might be the Mission Base for Adventurers thus forcing the Players to have to always return to obtain their next mission

…..The Hub might be the Home of Adventurers  civilian loved ones thus forcing Players to always return because of that

and various other reasons.

However.....

 Brennan did not build an Overwhelming Plot reason that forces the Player to always eventually return to the base like most West Marches, likely because he may have feel it was restrictive.

Instead it seems what he did was talk to the players to have their characters decide to return to the Base at the end of their arc for whatever reason they think makes sense with their characters

On Paper, I can understand Brennans intention by putting the agency in players hands.

In execution, though its come off as contrived because the Players are not coming up with good enough reasons for their characters to go to Dol Makyar.This is the FLAW i am speaking of.

It came off as contrived when the Soldiers deciding to go to Dol Makyar because they had multiple options to depetrify Cyd, other than going to the city which was declared too dangerous for them to stay

It definitely came off as contrived that the Seekers would ever decide to back to Dol Makyar when some of their key personal quests for leaving Dol makayar had not been completed.Julian hadn’t confirmed his Mum and sisters' survival and Thaisha hasn’t found Alogar.

 

My Solution to this issue going forward, is that Brennan needs to take charge of the Return to Hub Plothooks from now on instead of leaving it to the Players.Just like traditional West March dms do.He could create the plothooks per arc or maybe the whole campaign

For example Brennan could have made it clear that Cyds petrification was a special type of petrification that could only be undone with Wizard help thus making the return to the penteveral inevitable

Or Brennan could have made it that when the Seekers leave the Eternal night they immediately run into a Contingent of Davinos which includes, Julians Family and Alogar who are going on an important mission to Dol Makyar.This redirects the Seekers seamlessly to Dol Makyar whilst satifying the personal quests

Brennan as the god of this world is in better position to handle this.


r/criticalrole • • May 29 '26

Discussion [Spoilers C4E27] Unpopular opinion: Azune Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m dreading the discussion but am genuinely curious if anyone else feels the same way…

Luis was my favourite player in Downfall. Absolutely incredible. And then I’ve seen a couple of other things with him that made me so excited for him as a regular in C4.

I am sad to say, Azune is my least favourite character, to the point I wish he wasn’t in the party. He has broken down sobbing SO MANY TIMES that the emotion that would normally move me to see in a D&D player actually annoys me at this point. You’re level 4…how have you had 26 crying-level moments? (Exaggerating obviously). When he broke down yet again in this episode, I thought surely we’re going to discover he’s being manipulative I’ll be super impressed. Nope. Just another time of Azune being overly dramatic and constantly in tears.

I love when players feel the emotion so deeply it moves them to tears. But for some reason it’s just happening so often for comparatively little to what everyone else is also living through that it feels unearned and obnoxious. I either need this to turn into some master plan that shocks me greatly, or stop quickly. Azune just feels like he weighs down the party at the moment, and I know Luis is so talented that it just shocks me.

Am I the only one annoyed by the constant Azune tears?


r/criticalrole • • Aug 04 '24

Discussion [No Spoilers] Critical Role x Cultist Simulator, Ranking the PCs from all 3 campaigns into the Cultist Simulator principles

Post image
0 Upvotes

FYI: this was done fairly quickly but I thought it would be fun to make it.

For those who haven't played Cultist Simulator, there are multiple principles within the game which represent certain aspects. I just tried ranking each character into the base principle I think they represent the most.

Some characters represent multiple principles (e.g. Most characters also have the edge principle) but due to the tierlist maker's limitations I just picked what is, in my opinion the most fitting for each character. Lastly, some don't fit the character perfectly but are the closest to their core character.

Here's a list of what each principle represents:

Heart: The principle of life, preservation, protection, union, it is unstoppable in the face of adversity, and its followers are often characterized by relentless cheerfulness and obsessive determination.

Grail: The principle of desire, seduction, and thirst. Its followers are characterized by inhuman desirability and an irresistible charisma.

Moth: The principle of change, whimsy, unreason, secrecy, and nature. Its followers are characterized by stealth, erratic behavior, and agendas known only to themselves.

Lantern: The principle of light, knowledge, ascension, and occasionally unkindness. Its followers are characterized by mystically powerful dreams and a devotion to the Sun.

Forge: The principle of transformation, artifice, fire, and destruction. Its followers are characterized by ingenuity, mechanical thinking, and superhuman strength.

Edge: The principle of violence, betrayal, cunning, and pain. Its followers are characterized by cunning, bloodlust, and often a sense of artfulness in their violence.

Winter: The principle of death, remembrance, unlife, debilitation, and beauty. Its followers are characterized by remorseless misanthropy kindness through euthanasia, and silence.

Knock: The principle of openings. It is associated with wounds, locksmiths, burglars, and oracles. Its followers are characterized by intense dreams, visions of other places, perceptiveness, manual dexterity, and a disconnect with reality.


r/criticalrole • • Sep 10 '22

Discussion [Spoilers C3E33] I think some people are getting the Laura-Matt Moments Wrong Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Going to keep this short, just my view on this:
- I am very sure that Laura was aware of what Matt was suggesting as the NPC, to give into the storm.

- It's very clear to me that Laura was making a very conscious character choice to not do that because she felt like her character wouldn't and would go down with her friends before giving in to the storm.
- Matt is very much allowed to have NPCs be cruel and unreasonable and evil in any way the players are ok with, as Matt said in his tweet they have an understanding at the table that combats can be lethal towards their characters and I think that should be accepted.
- I am bothered by one very specific point though - that Matt called for multiple Wisdom saving throws for Laudna to give in, bypassing Laura's agency as a player. I disagree with Matt's decision here, though maybe it was his very last backup to the backup to keep the story going - I kind of understand the reasoning if so but I still disagree. This was, for every reason, a pivotal character moment for Imogen played by Laura. I think having multiple rolls of the dice called for by Matt is a breach of player agency, that's really the thing that bothered me about the session.

- Just my thoughts, Laura is a very smart person and I really don't think she was unaware of the hints Matt was dropping. I think she made a very conscious decision that Matt overruled with multiple calls for Wisdom saving throws, which imo is a breach of player agency. I have no issue with any of the other elements of this episode, was fully expecting a TPK and was impressed that that was on the table.


r/criticalrole • • Apr 25 '22

Fan Art [No Spoilers] Imogen pinup! Based on a classic pinup by Gil Elvgren.

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/criticalrole • • Jan 24 '25

Fluff [Spoilers C3E119] I don't want this campaign to end Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Ever since the last 4SD announced that the campaign was basically over I stopped listening. I am to attached to this story and this party to have their campaign end so abruptly. In my perspective almost none of these characters have travelled their arcs far enough to end right now, there is so much more to do.

I understand that most of them will probably survive and continue to make their way but there is just to much left to adress in a single 4 hour wrap up episode.

Laudna has just reached the starting line of honest character development after imprisoning Delilah.

Ashton is still raging against the machine and has only been delayed by all this moon stuff.

Orym has been falling into a bottomless pit of despair ever since the campaign began and even if he now has Dorian there needs to be something more.

We still don't know why the fuck Chetney is even there. After they solved his initial moonproblems he could've just left. Perhaps even with Diana.

Dorian is still reeling from losing the Crown keepers and his brother as well as his crappy upbringing. He may have landed Orym in a trauma romance but that can't be it.

Fearne is just Fearne, that's just fine.

Only FCG and Imogen seem to be getting proper payoffs. (Braius just might.)