I know there are probably dozens of posts like this out there, so I'll try to be brief. I just wanted to put my thoughts down on metaphorical paper.
WARNING: If you are absolutely loving C4, and have zero notes, this post it not for you. I'm genuinely happy you're loving it and I wish you the best.
Priors: Been watching CR for 5 years. Have watched C1 and C2 two to three times each, and all of C3 once with specific re-watches of some parts. Loved 1, adored 2, was mixed on 3.
Going into C4, I was excited. A mix-up was needed, and the new folks were all people I liked (with the exception of Whitney, who I hadn't seen beyond Birdemic, so I was neutral). The multiple tables thing was a good idea to help with the problem CR has always struggled with, the big cast at one table, and Exandria was getting a little long in the tooth (bloated, if I was being uncharitable), so again, all looked good.
But I'm 20 episodes in now, and it just hasn't clicked for me. Like...at all. The characters, the story, the setting, the action, none of it. The overall feeling I have is supreme boredom. I find myself tuning out and having to rewind to catch what happened. For the the first time I have to check out previous episode summaries before livestreams because I have COMPLETELY forgotten what happened or was happening.
I don't want to itemize every little thing, but broadly:
Brand new world, but we're getting PILES of new info. New places, people, religions, factions, are being introduced constantly, before a lot of it has a chance to settle. I'm feeling overwhelmed in a way I have never experienced in an actual show setting (CR or otherwise, I've watched a LOT of them).
Most of the Main Characters are already influential people with MANY pre-existing relationships, both to PCs and multiple NPCs each. There are no fish out of water for the audience to cling to like in other fantasy stories. They're nothing like the vagabonds, outcasts, and runaways from every other CR campaign.
NOTE: I know some characters are borderline for this description, but compare, say, Percy to Wic, Julian, or Octis, at campaign starts. I'd say their positions are quite different.
3. Plotwise, there was almost no buildup. No low to medium stakes adventuring that gives the group(s) time to feel each other out and get to know each other. No saving villagers from gnolls or dealing with the Slayers Take. Even C3 had smaller challenges like Ira and the Shade Mother. Nope, it's straight to the big bad. World ending calamity RIGHT NOW.
All 3 of these things compound each other. If only 1 or 2 of them were happening, I could deal, but all 3? Giant, brand new world that needs explaining, combined with very complicated characters with LOADS of pre-existing history with each other and dozens of other people, AND a world-shaking calamity involving tons of new lore and metaphysical concepts, AND we're jumping between 3 separate groups doing completely different things?
Also don't misunderstand! If this was happening, say, halfway through? I'd probably be LOVING it! But right out of the gate? I haven't had a chance to form attachments to players, NPCs, places or historical events. It all means nothing to me, and I get even more detached when the players are reacting with such huge emotions. Azune and Hal had a very emotional scene recently, and Luis/Liam played it wonderfully. But I felt nothing. I've barely spent any time with these people. The scene just did not feel earned to me.
And finally...and most/least important, I'm just not feeling the joy any more. Everything's just so damn serious. Sure folks crack a joke here and there, but the vast majority of it is the players, not the characters. I was hopeful during the Solders arc. Thimble fighting with Wic was great. Kattigan is a total delight. But so much of the vast majority of the in-game events are so DOUR and GLOOMY. Is this what CR wants to be moving forward?
I guess I'm just feeling drained. CR has been moving away from the stories they used to tell for some time now; if C4 is their vision of the future, if this is CR firing on all cylinders? I don't think it's for me. I've just been feeling a mixed of bored and sad whenever I tune in.
AAAAAAAAAANYWAY, that went on longer than I meant it to. If you made it this far, thanks for reading! If anyone has struggled with C4, I'd like to hear. Even more so if you've found ways of overcoming that and now are enjoying parts of it more after that initial struggle. And, if you just want to vent/agree with me, hey, I'll take that too.