r/criterion • u/Nick_Tinoco • Apr 05 '26
r/criterion • u/[deleted] • Mar 21 '24
Discussion Trans/Non-Binary Directors
Are there Trans or Non-Binary directors who's work is in the collection. Other the the Wachowskis with the newest announcement? The movies subject doesn't need to be, just who's behind the camera.
r/criterion • u/laptoplasane • Feb 10 '25
Artwork What film should Mikey Madison be holding? (The Criterion Art Project)
I don't normally post unfinished art but I'm curious what other people think...
My latest work in progress for The Criterion Art Project. What film should I paint into her hands? Also would you paint the individual spines in the closet behind her? š¤
r/criterion • u/bananabread9876 • Nov 10 '25
Discussion Any good trans coded films in the collection?
As a trans person I think itās really cool to see people like me in film, and since the sale is going right now itād be cool to pick up some trans coded films, or films with good trans rep.
r/criterion • u/beardedsailor • Dec 06 '24
Memes Alright, which one of you did this? Reveal yourself.
r/criterion • u/Wide_Craft_9765 • Feb 23 '26
Discussion After the Kpop demon hunters announcement, my idea for this doesn't seem far-fetched now to be honest
I mostly thought of this because of how experimental the show is, from the magical realism, the rashomon-esque storytelling and the use of different animation styles. It is truly the best thing pixar made in a while and this is the kind of project that should be celebrated, not the unnecessary sequels. I also think that this could be a perfect opportunity to release the cut trans storyline. This could also be the Criterion's first miniseries in a while like how somebody pointed out. Plus i don't really trust Disney to keep this show under its umbrella, so i feel like a release under Criterion could save it from a possible removal from any streaming platform. But these are just my thoughts, though i's really like to see this one day.
r/criterion • u/[deleted] • Sep 23 '18
Which filmmaker currently working do you feel is the most overrated?
Christopher Nolan is the most overrated filmmaker currently working in my opinion. His screenplays always have the plot drive character instead of the other way around. His editing is choppy and follows no rules of cinema without reason. Like Michael Bay his films are meant to be watched passively not actively.
Iāve been hated for this opinion in the past so Iād like to hear others opinions on this subject.
EDIT: I have seen a lot of criticism of talking about overrated directors or about negative talk as a poor form of intellectual criticism. This is not true. Understanding why you dislike something and analyzing and discussing a negative reaction to a film is an incredibly important way of figuring out what you value in cinema. A huge part of my development as a film viewer and occasional critic was my negative reaction to Inception it led me to discover film critics who also disliked Nolan and why they disliked him. It also led to read through and see what others liked about it and where we diverged. This is healthy to an intellectual view of cinema.
EDIT 2: Talked with a lot about the perception and framing of my question coming across as bitter and leading to poor or nonexistent criticism and instead just complaints. That was not my intention but I think is fair and accurate. I will work better to engage the group in the future.
r/criterion • u/SignificantWar3140 • Aug 11 '23
Discussion Fucked Up Filmmakers
Iām curious if anyone else has ever thought about this. Why does the film community still celebrate so many morally bankrupt filmmakers? There are plenty of actors and producers who fall into this category as well, so Iāll include a couple of those in this list after the directors.
Bernardo Bertolucci - coordinated the on screen rape of Maria Schneider with lead actor Marlon Brando for Last Tango in Paris. Maria was not aware of the true plans for this āsceneā, and was left traumatized by the experience. Bertolucci himself admitted it was wrong and yet Tango in Paris is still widely celebrated.
Luchino Visconti - scoured the world for a young boy that would be the āembodiment of youthful beautyā for his film Death in Venice. Visconti chose 15-year old Swede Bjƶrn AndrĆ©sen for the role, who he later called āthe most beautiful boy in the worldā. Visconti took 15 year old Bjƶrn to a gay sex club after the filmās premiere, where Bjƶrn himself claimed that he was too intoxicated to look after himself and therefore could not remember anything. A 65 year old man bringing a 15 year old boy to a sex club is beyond fucked up, regardless of whether it was a gay club or not. Thereās basically no way of knowing what happened to Bjƶrn that night, although he claims it humiliated him.
Pier Paolo Pasolini - charged with sexual misconduct with a minor in 1949 (he was masturbating with three children aged 16 and under, Pasolini was 27 years old at this time). You know someoneās fucked up when theyāre too devious for the damn Communist Party (he was kicked out of the ICP after this). Pasolini was a demented pedophile. The ālove of his lifeā was a 15 year old boy. His death is a whole other story, but I wonāt go into that here since thereās too much speculation.
Roman Polanski - drugged and raped a 13 year old girl at Jack Nicholsonās mansion. 13 year old Samantha Geimer was invited to spend time with 43 year old Polanski, believing she would be a model for a Vogue Magazine photo shoot. He then drugged and sodomized her. Hours before being formally charged, Polanski fled to England and then France, where he has since resided to avoid extradition. Six women have come forth with additional allegations since then.
Woody Allen - molested his 7 year old adopted daughter Dylan Farrow, then married the adopted daughter of his ex Mia Farrow, Soon-Yi Previn, who was 27 at the time, while Woody was 62. Unfortunately Woody did a damn good job of grooming the children he adopted, who now believe nothing was inappropriate between them (Stockholm Syndrome).
Harvey Weinstein (producer) - probably donāt need to say much here, the man was accused of sexual misconduct by over eighty different women.
One thing I will point out is that these people are much more celebrated in France than they are here in the States (especially Polanski), and I wonder why that is? Why do so many people make excuses for these dirtbags?
And just so yāall know where I stand:
Iāve always struggled with āseparating the art from the artistā, especially when the artist is a demented piece of shit (best example would be R. Kelly). Although, I do enjoy at least one film from each of these directors (The Last Emperor, The Leopard, Chinatown, The Pianist, Manhattan). The only problem is, I almost feel guilty watching these films. Knowing what these guys did in their personal lives makes it a lot more difficult to notice their āartistryā. Itās absolutely absurd to me that the same people who call Stanley Kubrick āabusiveā for making pampered actors shut up and do their jobs will also completely ignore the actual abuse that other directors inflicted upon their cast and crew. How is Stanley Kubrick considered abusive for yelling when he never laid a hand on any of his cast or crew? Why do so many ignore the sexual misconduct of other directors and instead focus on Stanley Kubrick making Shelley Duvall do her job? This has always baffled me. Thoughts, anyone? (Feel free to let me know if Iāve forgotten anyone here)
r/criterion • u/[deleted] • Dec 03 '22
Relax about āMuh woke BFIā
The norm has been to primarily watch and celebrate films from white men. Any shifts to the norm will trigger a reaction. As we start to see how our systems perpetuate a norm that leaves out other groups, we try to find a way to solve that. Naturally, we see an issue, weāll find a way to solve it. So as we have become more conscious of this issue, we have put more spotlight on films that are made by groups that typically havenāt been included in the norm, and as a result more people see these films and more people will find that they really like some of these films. Calling the BFI S&S list āwokeā or āpoliticalā reinforces the idea that the norm is to celebrate films from white men, and any shifts to that is just āwokeā or āpoliticalā. Sooner or later, more films from underrepresented groups will have been seen, enjoyed, and celebrated. It shouldnāt be āwokeā that these films are celebrated. It should be the norm :)
r/criterion • u/doodles2112112 • Mar 21 '25
Pickup Ok fine, Iāll post my flash sale haul as well.
r/criterion • u/PalpitationOk5726 • Jul 29 '23
Criterion snobs ruining things?
Having watched this posting by a YouTuber, I wanted to get other perspectives. I agree that attacking someone especially online for their tastes is completely ridiculous, but completely shutting out an entire section of film is also wrong, not everything is a 3 hour documentary from Belgium 1956.
r/criterion • u/brickunlimited • May 01 '25
Discussion The Inland Empire Blu-Ray is bad and you shouldnāt buy it.
Usually, I just trust criterion and I donāt read reviews- but in this case it was a mistake. Several months ago I bought Inland Empire. I watched it, having not yet heard of the controversy surrounding the use of AI upscaling (and other effects) and I loved the movie and thought it was a fine transfer.
I discovered the controversy and debated buying the DVD. After watching it again and realizing itās a movie I would watch many more times I pulled the trigger on the Rhino DVD (20$ shipped).
I popped it in my player and holy shit it looks so much better. It looks naturally digital, with none of the fake film grain and no weird artifacting. Arguably the most noticeable thing is how much better the color grading is on the DVD which is vibrant compared to the utterly washed out blu-ray.
In conclusion: YouTube nerd is correct and the difference is more pronounced then it even comes though in the compressed YouTube video.
My advice: if you havenāt bought the BR yet, donātā buy the dvd instead. If you have bought it, but love the movie and plan on rewatching, buy the dvd instead.
As a David Lynch and criterion fanboy, there was a lot of cope, but eventually I came to the conclusion they really messed up on this one.
[Yes Iām aware Lynch approved the transfer, doesnāt matter it looks worse].
r/criterion • u/Eitanr199 • Sep 17 '26
Discussion The comments on Criterionās Instagram post about āShoahā is truly disgusting.
I was hoping this community was more intelligent.
r/criterion • u/FiveLiterFords • Mar 20 '26
News R.I.P. Chuck Norris (1940-2026).
The legendās sole entry in the collection is contained in this incredible compilation. In 1972ās āThe Way of the Dragonā, Norris depicts Colt, an American Karateka hired by the syndicate to eliminate Tang Lung (Lee) and proves to be the most worthy of āFinal Bossesā in the iconic showdown in Rome.
Rest in Peace to the Master.
r/criterion • u/Accurate-Chicken-323 • Oct 17 '25
Discussion The problem with Paris, Texas Spoiler
Now before I get downvoted to hell, because this film has such an touchable status in this community it seems, I think the cinematography is amazing, I think the music is amazing, I think the overall direction is amazing until the very problematic ending, and this is where I truly donāt understand why people call this film beautiful -
Travis has taken his son out of his finally stable life, to be then reunited with his mother who obviously cannot afford to look after him, and then abandoned again by his deadbeat father and the child is no better off, if not worse, than before, it must be extremely traumatic to take a child out of his stable life at such a vulnerable age to then be abandoned again? Despite his father showing him HE could be there for him (appearing in his life), yet decides to leave anyway. The ending just left me really angry and Iām extremely confused why people call the film so beautiful when to me the ending was really emotionally awful and anyone whoās been in a similar situation growing up knows how devastating Travisās effects are.
Feel free to offer insight on why you love Paris Texas. One of my favourite films is Wings of Desire also.
r/criterion • u/fabulous-farhad • Feb 19 '23
Discussion Who do you think are the WORST modern working directors today?
My pick would be the russo brothers there film's feel like they were ai generated to be the most bland lifeless films imaginable and their constant bashing against auteur driven cinema is just pathetic. I also quite dislike adam McKay , hes films are so unbelievably ubnoxious and up their own ass and very very very unfunny
r/criterion • u/SnowyBlackberry • Mar 04 '25
Anoraās big Oscar win and sex worker backlash, explained
r/criterion • u/oftheplains • Jan 16 '25
Lynch is dead. Never seen his films. Where do I start? I just got the channel.
r/criterion • u/[deleted] • Mar 15 '24
Discussion In defense of Querelleās cover
With the look of the film and the fact that itās done by artist Astra Zero. I feel itās a perfect fit and I donāt get the complaints at all
r/criterion • u/Ecstatic-Listener222 • Mar 24 '26
Discussion Comment your hauls!!!
As an avid Criterion Closet watcher and reddit page reader, I would love to hear what everyone picked up and which ones they are most excited about!
r/criterion • u/turnidoff • Aug 24 '25
Discussion Explain to me 4K like I'm 4 years old
I'm a bit bewildered about this obsession with seeing every film in 4K. Why 4K? I get that its a higher resolution but is there really a difference? I'm old enough to remember the jump from VHS to DVD and that was mind blowing. Then Blu Ray was just a bit better but not by much. Is it because of TVs? Everyone seems to be frothing at the mouth to watch every film in 4K like it's the final cinephile boss. Help me to understand the importance of it all.
r/criterion • u/cherken4 • Feb 08 '23
Off-Topic Name an actor or actress that you find annoying!
No hate or discrimination, just a personal taste: name someone that makes you skip the film
r/criterion • u/ggroover97 • Apr 16 '24
Discussion What is your favorite Roman Polanski movie?
Your choices:
Knife in the Water (1962): A couple pick up a hitchhiker on the way to their yacht. The husband invites the young man to come along for their day's sailing. As the voyage progresses, the antagonism between the two men grows. A violent confrontation is inevitable.
Repulsion (1965): A sex-repulsed woman who disapproves of her sister's boyfriend sinks into depression and has horrific visions of rape and violence.
Cul-de-sac (1966): In search of help, two wounded gangsters on the run find refuge in the secluded castle of a feeble man and his wife; however, under the point of a gun, nothing is what it seems.
The Fearless Vampire Killers (1967): A noted professor and his dim-witted apprentice fall prey to their inquiring vampires, while on the trail of the ominous damsel in distress.
Rosemary's Baby (1968): A young couple trying for a baby moves into an aging, ornate apartment building on Central Park West, where they find themselves surrounded by peculiar neighbors.
MacBeth (1971): A ruthlessly ambitious Scottish lord seizes the throne with the help of his scheming wife and a trio of witches.
What? (1972): During her Italian vacation, a young and beautiful American tourist finds herself as a guest in a coastal villa inhabited by some odd people.
Chinatown (1974): A private detective hired to expose an adulterer in 1930s Los Angeles finds himself caught up in a web of deceit, corruption, and murder.
The Tenant (1976): A bureaucrat rents a Paris apartment where he finds himself drawn into a rabbit hole of dangerous paranoia.
Tess (1979): A strong-willed young peasant girl attracts the affection of two men.
Pirates (1986): The adventures of pirate Captain Red and his first mate Frog.
Frantic (1988): In a hotel room in Paris, a doctor comes out of the shower and finds that his wife has disappeared. He soon finds himself caught up in a world of intrigue, espionage, gangsters, drugs and murder.
Bitter Moon (1992): After hearing stories of her, a passenger on a cruise ship develops an irresistible infatuation with an eccentric paraplegic's wife.
Death and the Maiden (1994): A political activist is convinced that her guest is a man who once tortured her for the government.
The Ninth Gate (1999): A book broker discovers his latest find may summon Satan.
The Pianist (2002): During WWII, acclaimed Polish musician Wladyslaw faces various struggles as he loses contact with his family. As the situation worsens, he hides in the ruins of Warsaw in order to survive.
Oliver Twist (2005): An adaptation of the classic Dickens tale, where an orphan meets a pickpocket on the streets of London. From there, he joins a household of boys who are trained to steal for their master.
The Ghost Writer (2010): A ghost writer, hired to complete the memoirs of a former British Prime Minister, uncovers secrets that put his own life in jeopardy.
Carnage (2011): Two pairs of parents hold a cordial meeting after their sons are involved in a fight, though as their time together progresses, increasingly childish behavior throws the discussion into chaos.
Venus in Fur (2013): An actress attempts to convince a director how she's perfect for a role in his upcoming production.
Based on a True Story (2017): A writer goes through a tough period after the release of her latest book, as she gets involved with an obsessive admirer.
An Officer and a Spy (2019): In 1894, French Captain Alfred Dreyfus is wrongfully convicted of treason and sentenced to life imprisonment at Devil's island.
The Palace (2023): A drama set on New Year's Eve 1999 in a luxurious Swiss hotel where the lives of hotel workers and various guests get intertwined.