I’ve been a longtime fan of Criminal Minds, but Evolution is really testing my patience, and honestly, I might have to step away if the writers don’t turn this around.
First off, Elias Voit (aka “The Void”) is one of the most boring villains the show has ever had. He’s not scary, not interesting, and certainly not compelling enough to carry two full seasons. They’re trying to build him up like some epic nemesis, but there’s just nothing there. Now we’re doing soap opera-tier amnesia plots where he thinks Rossi is his father? Come on. This guy couldn’t hold a candle to the better killers from earlier seasons.
And because the writers are obsessed with Voit, every new “killer” is just some cardboard cutout from his little network. No mystery, no psychology, no suspense, just one-dimensional weirdos like the guy who kidnaps women to feel powerful. It’s like the show forgot how to build good standalone cases.
Meanwhile, the relationships have completely fallen apart. Every straight relationship has been killed off or written out: • JJ and Will? Gone. • Rossi’s wife? Dead. • Luke and Garcia? Ended. • Prentiss? Always single.
And why kill Will, he was never important, now we have to waste an entire episode watching JJ grieve. Boring, contrived, no fan is interested in this. And of course the one surviving, front-and-center romantic arc is Tara and her girlfriend, which feels like it’s being treated with extra care while the rest are left in the dust. It’s not that I need a straight relationship to be front and center… I just want balance. Right now, it feels forced and agenda-driven, not organic.
The show has also ditched some of its most interesting characters. Reid is gone. Gideon was never replaced. And while I like Garcia, they’ve cranked her quirks up so far that she feels like a parody of herself. The new guy feels shoehorned in, and Luke’s still kind of a blank slate.
Bottom line: the heart of the show, smart profiling, intense cases, sharp character dynamics, has been buried under bad writing, boring villains, and awkward identity politics. It’s like they’re doing everything they can to wreck what made the show great.
I feel like I am watching the current batch of writers just drive a once-great franchise into the ditch… and for no good reason.
I’ll give it a little more time, but if it keeps circling the drain like this, I’m out.