r/criminalminds • • Feb 15 '23

Minor Spoilers Reid is soooo gender! (trans rant)

0 Upvotes

I mean, look at the man. He's so gender. My sister walked behind me while I was watching criminal minds and did a double take and said "that guy is so gender." Y'all, who is you're most gender envy character on the show? Reid is obviously mine, but what's a bit funny is my sister is a girl and yet still thinks MGG is gender. Anywayyyy, he's so fucking gender. I want to be friends with him so badddd


r/criminalminds • • Feb 02 '25

Season 3 & Below Spoilers What did Mandy Patinkin expect? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Mandy Patinkin says he left the show because of the dark subject matter and violence. I mean, it’s a show about profiling serial killers who commit murder! It’s not sunshine and rainbows, picking daises or singing songs. Like what was he expecting? Did he not read any of the scripts? There’s been so many actors on the show over the years and none of them said the subject matter was that difficult. Dark at times yes but not just bailing on over night. Patinkin then joined Homeland, a show about terrorism. Terrorists murder more than serial killers, how was that any better?


r/criminalminds • • Jul 20 '25

Season 18 Spoilers Criminal Minds: Evolution Is Losing the Plot… Literally and Figuratively Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I’ve been a longtime fan of Criminal Minds, but Evolution is really testing my patience, and honestly, I might have to step away if the writers don’t turn this around.

First off, Elias Voit (aka “The Void”) is one of the most boring villains the show has ever had. He’s not scary, not interesting, and certainly not compelling enough to carry two full seasons. They’re trying to build him up like some epic nemesis, but there’s just nothing there. Now we’re doing soap opera-tier amnesia plots where he thinks Rossi is his father? Come on. This guy couldn’t hold a candle to the better killers from earlier seasons.

And because the writers are obsessed with Voit, every new “killer” is just some cardboard cutout from his little network. No mystery, no psychology, no suspense, just one-dimensional weirdos like the guy who kidnaps women to feel powerful. It’s like the show forgot how to build good standalone cases.

Meanwhile, the relationships have completely fallen apart. Every straight relationship has been killed off or written out:    •   JJ and Will? Gone.    •   Rossi’s wife? Dead.    •   Luke and Garcia? Ended.    •   Prentiss? Always single.

And why kill Will, he was never important, now we have to waste an entire episode watching JJ grieve. Boring, contrived, no fan is interested in this. And of course the one surviving, front-and-center romantic arc is Tara and her girlfriend, which feels like it’s being treated with extra care while the rest are left in the dust. It’s not that I need a straight relationship to be front and center… I just want balance. Right now, it feels forced and agenda-driven, not organic.

The show has also ditched some of its most interesting characters. Reid is gone. Gideon was never replaced. And while I like Garcia, they’ve cranked her quirks up so far that she feels like a parody of herself. The new guy feels shoehorned in, and Luke’s still kind of a blank slate.

Bottom line: the heart of the show, smart profiling, intense cases, sharp character dynamics, has been buried under bad writing, boring villains, and awkward identity politics. It’s like they’re doing everything they can to wreck what made the show great.

I feel like I am watching the current batch of writers just drive a once-great franchise into the ditch… and for no good reason.

I’ll give it a little more time, but if it keeps circling the drain like this, I’m out.


r/criminalminds • • Aug 04 '24

All Spoilers I hate Jemily with my heart and Soul! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Watching CM, I hate how many people hate Will because he's with JJ, I believe the Writers are just pushing Jemily because Fans don't shut up about it.

When I heard that Will wasn't coming, I felt so upset for JJ to the point I refused to watch Evolution.

Putting in real life, JJ will never leave her husband and kids for Emily…shes not the home wrecker Type, She would save Emily from things but if Emily asked JJ to be her girlfriend JJ is shutting her down, Will is the thing that makes JJ feel safe and I’m not gonna Emily is the last person I want to be with knowing she's a spy and that.

I’m not living my life having to be paranoid bc someone is watching me…Yes i’m Jemily Number hater. 😆


r/criminalminds • • Jun 14 '23

Minor Spoilers Still Upset at CBS, Regarding Prentiss Sexuality

5 Upvotes

There’s no specific reason I’m complaining about this now, I’m just watching criminal minds and I got angry again. Here’s the thing, if Prentiss remained single, like she had been the entire show, it would be fine. In the last or second last season though, whenever she starts seeing that one guy, it just seems sooooo inorganic! If CBS is going to be homophobic at least let her stay a strong, single woman. On a positive note, it’s impressive to me how Paget Brewster/the shows writers, portrayed her character so well that it has always been clear she’s a lesbian. Also, maybe it’s not out of now where that this is triggering me now… I live in Florida: I’m sure if you’ve been generally following the news, I don’t need to elaborate on how this connects.


r/criminalminds • • Sep 23 '24

MEME (spoilers) JJ and Reid should've ended up together 😶‍🌫️

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/criminalminds • • Jun 05 '24

Minor Spoilers do people only like JJ because the actress is attractive?

0 Upvotes

don’t get me wrong, in the earlier seasons JJ was a great character but ever since she stopped being a liaison, in my opinion she’s become very very bland and lacks any type of personality outside of being a mother. even her husband is bland. i struggle to understand the love she gets because there’s just nothing much to her, and the only conclusion i’ve come to is that she is liked because AJ happens to be very attractive. do you guys agree or do some JJ supporters have other reasons for liking her?


r/criminalminds • • Aug 10 '24

Actor Shenanigans Penelope Is An Overgrown Child

0 Upvotes

In season 1/2 I didn’t mind her as much but in later seasons she just develops into a snivelling baby. Like she starts shaking or panicking and it’s like “this is your job, be fuckin for real.”

I liked when Gideon was there or in the beginning Hotch would remind her to behave more professionally, but they just stop after a while.

I have no problem with one of the characters being more sensitive to violence or gore, especially since she’s not a field agent, but eventually you have to deal with it & become desensitised.

Also I just don’t like how she treats Luke, don’t find it funny or charming at all.

Maybe I’m just a hater, but like I truly detest her.


r/criminalminds • • Apr 21 '26 Mindblown

Season 4 & Below Spoilers S4:E7 MEMORIAM, Reid was a jerk Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just rewatched this episode and realized how much I hated Reids pompous attitude trying to punish his Dad and then put a man in jail for killing his sons predator. I know there is a lot of moral ground on this one, but still Reid was a self centered jerk IMO.

Thoughts?


r/criminalminds • • Nov 13 '24

Season 9 & Below Spoilers islamophobia in the show

2 Upvotes

something ive noticed while watching the show (esp since i'm watching it when i'm a bit older, 18, and am pretty aware of the way the western world views my religion) is the sheer amount of islamophobia in it, lemme explain:

- the terrorism episode with gideon interviewing the muslim guy: hello???? reeks of islamophobia, i had to do chores while watching it on the tv cause i was so angry. its just weird. one of my least favorite episodes. i do understand this was after 9/11 & that america was idk, weird, after that, but it just is weird & insane to me.

- morgan's abuser reverting to islam??? there was no reason for that & i dont understand why they did it all.

well aware this post may not be received very well but i just needed to get this out. this is my favorite show so far (i'm on season 11) and these things just bothered me.


r/criminalminds • • Mar 04 '24

Season 3 & Below Spoilers Haley

2 Upvotes

Holy hell I forgot how much I hated Haley I. The earlier seasons. I get not having you husband there, but to guild trip him into trying to give up the job he actually loves doing, and the job he feels that he's making a difference, it fucking infuriates me. Especially when he got suspended, and he's trying to figure out the case, and she's getting pissed off at him, calling his suspension a "Blessing in disguise." Holy hell was I somewhat relieved when she died.


r/criminalminds • • Mar 14 '24

All Spoilers Am I the only one who's annoyed with Garcia?

3 Upvotes

It's just, uh. She's too infantile, and very often behaves unprofessionally. While in the first seasons (1-8) it's still tolerable, in the last few seasons it's like a reason for me not to watch the show anymore. I understand that they wanted to make her a nice and empathic character, but for a show with this kind of theme, it's too much. JJ's horror at the murders and sympathy for the victims and their families is much better. And probably a very scary thing to say right now - I don't like her dynamic with Derek and most of the screen time they make me roll my eyes. And her attitude towards her coworkers' personal lives leaves a lot to be desired.

But that's just my opinion, first of all


r/criminalminds • • Nov 16 '23

Reboot 16 & Below Spoilers evolution ruined everything

1 Upvotes

i’m watching evolution and dude they ruined everything… no theme song, rossi going mad, them ruining garcia n alvez’s friendship and completely ruining their date from season 15, the weird dynamic shifts :(( everything is just ruined and idk if i wanna watch anymore, does it get better or is it just like this for the rest of the episodes

update: i finished it and i completely take this back oh my gosh it was so entertaining. only two critiques i still have are the ruined dynamics between emily n jj, and them scrapping garvez but i understand it was cause of the whole tyler green storyline. anyone who’s holding back on watching it because of ur love for the first series, WATCH IT! it’s wonderful once you get past the 1st episode


r/criminalminds • • May 21 '23

Minor Spoilers characters tier list

0 Upvotes

DON'T HATE ME PLEASE I'M SORRY (also idk if minor spoilers would be the right flair sorry lol)


r/criminalminds • • Nov 07 '24

Season 12 & Below Spoilers Garcia

0 Upvotes

Its grating how annoying Garcia is when under the kosh, the frantic panicking is so jarring to watch. I know she isnt 'one of them' but surely after 12 years she would have some semblance of being able to hold it together. Maybe Kirsten doesnt know how to act sad/upset as she is great in every other facet 😆


r/criminalminds • • Mar 06 '25

All Spoilers JJ

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one that got irritated with JJ always making a case, personal and almost about herself, like any case that revolved around a small town or a college girl or a kid it all had to be about JJ and her getting emotional and making it personal


r/criminalminds • • Apr 06 '25

Season 2 & Below Spoilers Minor grievance about Hotch’s worst qualities

6 Upvotes

I must’ve rewatched the full series every single year since I was about 14 and without fail this scene irritates me every time. When Reid is abducted by Tobias Hankel and he communicates via the webcams that Hotch is a narcissist, Hotch asks everyone what his worst quality is. I absolutely hate that JJ and Prentiss say he’s a “bully” and he doesn’t “trust women as much as men”.

The bully comment is a really hurtful thing to say to a friend (and they are friends, not just colleagues), but the not trusting women as much as men comment?! That’s calling him sexist and 1. I don’t believe there is ever an example of him being sexist and 2. They are all so aware of what real sexism and misogyny looks like through unsubs so implying that Hotch also thinks men are better than women is such a bold statement.

The script could’ve come up with 500 better “worst qualities” for JJ and Prentiss to give in that scene, and they chose two that actually paint Hotch is a really horrible light, and which are not true at all. Bugs me every time that scene lol


r/criminalminds • • Aug 23 '24

Season 4 & Below Spoilers Do not come for me BUT REID IS ANNOYING!

12 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out. This is my second time watching the show 'cause the first time was ages ago. I swear I was chill with Reid back then, but NOW?? Nah, it's not the random facts he drops on the squad, or the fact that he's always getting thrown into traumatic situations, or even the immaturity, or any of the other reasons people talk about online. It's literally the way he talks! Like, bro, why are you whispering in that weird way the whole time? I can LITERALLY hear his saliva swishing around with every word. I've legit started pausing the episodes, reading what he's saying online, and then skipping his parts. PLEASE tell me someone else has noticed this!


r/criminalminds • • Aug 14 '23

Solved Reid. Should. have. been. Bisexual.

28 Upvotes

Can we start a petition to make the writers of criminal minds evolution decide to make Reid Bi in evolution (if he comes back. Please let him come back) like they originally planned to do from the start?


r/criminalminds • • May 24 '24

Season 2 & Below Spoilers Pretty hard to buy into the “we’re a family” thing when you remember what happened with **** Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First of all let me say the fisher king episodes were a hot mess. The way she was treated after doing what she did? Other characters have done so much worse and been covered for, but with Elle? They treated her like trash. She’d just been shot, barely survived, and shot a rapist who walked free, a man who was raping girls at a Bible college causing one to become pregnant and commit suicide. The guy was literally guaranteed to rape again and he said so during this interaction. She took care of a problem. The hate for her online just seems like misogyny.


r/criminalminds • • Jul 21 '22

Unpopular opinion: Garcia is a cartoonish character that gets annoying very fast and Kirsten Vangsness over acts a lot. Her storylines are very annoying.

Post image
229 Upvotes

r/criminalminds • • Aug 13 '24

Fanwork Real life JJ???

Post image
0 Upvotes

Was watching Law and Crime ( The Mo Wilson Case) and this beautiful woman just kept reminding me of JJ. Her and AJ could be half sisters or at least cousins. What do you guys think? (I’m now on the hunt for more doppelgängers ☺️)


r/criminalminds • • Jul 03 '25

Season 4 & Below Spoilers I hate how weakly women are portrayed in the show

1 Upvotes

Been binging Criminal Minds and can’t unsee how female victims are always shown screaming, sobbing, and tied up, waiting to be rescued. I get it’s a crime show, but five seasons in, it’s nonstop damsel-in-distress for shock value. Male victims die fast, but women get dragged through scenes of fear and torture every episode. It’s like the show needs their terror for tension but never gives them a chance to fight back or do anything. Not expecting them to john wick their way out, but damn, some variety would be nice.


r/criminalminds • • Oct 22 '23

All Spoilers Unpopular opinion. Elle is much better than JJ and Garcia

0 Upvotes

I don't know why this sub loves using Elle as a toilet. But I think JJ and Garcia are much worse characters than her. JJ is a bland Mary sue character who seems to be good at everything. Garcia is an immature obnoxious brat who can literally find information about people going to the beach and a couple having an argument while it happens 🙄. And Garcia is also a bitch towards new members of the team and has a hate towards people for no reason.

With Elle she may be a frustrating character to deal with. But I find that a character with flaws is much more interesting than a perfect Barbie character who can somehow be generically awesome at everything or someone who is just to over the top and unprofessional