r/cpp • u/eric_niebler • Jan 16 '13
Are the Java vulnerabilities actually C and C++ vulnerabilities?
http://isocpp.org/blog/2013/01/are-the-java-vulnerabilities-actually-c-and-c-vulnerabilities4
u/eric_niebler Jan 16 '13
Short version, for those too lazy to RTFA: this vulnerability, no; others, yes. Security is hard, regardless of the language you use. Get off yer high horse and review some code.
32
Jan 16 '13
Some other exploits have indeed used vulnerabilities in Java’s native C code implementation
I don't know if that's as simple as "other vulnerabilities are actually C vulnerabilities," it sounds to me more like "other vulnerabilities were caused by bad C code."
C will let you shoot yourself in the foot with a nuclear warhead but I don't think it's fair to call a Java VM bug (which is what that snippet sounds like) a "C vulnerability." Perhaps I'm misunderstanding
3
u/nahguri Jan 16 '13
"C vulnerability."
I hear you. Since C/C++ are not managed languages, there are no C/C++ vulnerabilities. Sure, there may be vulnerabilities in your code but they are caused by your bad coding, not C/C++ itself.
1
u/m42a Jan 18 '13
Untrue. If you did
string s; cin >> str;and it caused a buffer overflow, that would be a C++ vulnerability. It wouldn't be caused by your bad coding.-7
u/pjmlp Jan 16 '13
It is a C vulnerability because they make use of the typical C errors of buffer overruns and dangling pointers.
They mostly relate to code exposed via native methods.
11
u/Xetick Jan 16 '13
By that logic all C / C++ vulnerabilities are machine code vulnerabilities and not the fault of C / C++. Great, then I don't have to take the blame for my own coding bugs. I'll just blame the machine code.
8
u/ZMeson Embedded Developer Jan 16 '13
Answer from the article itself:
The answer is no, these particular exploits are pure Java. Some other exploits have indeed used vulnerabilities in Java’s native C code implementation, but the major vulnerabilities in the news lately are in Java itself.
21
u/btown_brony Jan 16 '13
Pure, shameful linkbait.
16
u/repsilat Jan 16 '13
Betteridge's Law of Headlines:
Any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no.
7
2
u/elperroborrachotoo Jan 16 '13
Frankly, if it was for visits, they'd posted a Java kitten in a major subreddit.
28
u/calum8991 Jan 16 '13
The crucial difference between C, C++ and Java is that C and C++ are unsafe languages. Any undefined behaviour in C or C++ is therefore the fault of the code, not the fault in C and C++. (Unless there are compiler or standards bugs but I've never seen these exploited.)
Java does however claim to be a safe language, so therefore any flaws are in its implementation.