r/countingcrows • • Feb 21 '25

Any objective fans?

0 Upvotes

Seriously, I mean, I know this is a fan subreddit so lot of huge fans here skewing toward apologist, but dude—Counting Crows has produced some of the best music I have heard in my life, transformative stuff. And yet these Butter songs don’t necessarily amount to “oh hey your favorite band got older and changed their sound…” they’re totally wack. Like Del Amitri meets some random guys who were never allowed to join The Band. Am I like the only person who considers their favorite band to have become one of the worst legacy bands still producing music? I mean I have done some crazy stuff to see Counting Crows live over the years, and honestly I hate this new music so much that I wonder why I did some of that stuff lol. Now, that’s on me, but I genuinely don’t understand this rush to approve of music that is so sonically and thematically disjointed from the rest of the catalog it makes me question whether this is a band anymore or a collection of 60 somethings paying for their kids’ houses. Just so boring. This newest single truly sounds like they threw Butter 1 and SUW into an AI and came out with this.


r/countingcrows • • Feb 21 '25

Spaceman in Tulsa.

2 Upvotes

You can listen to it on YouTube, you just have to set your VPN to Europe. I honestly wouldn’t even bother, the song actually sucks. I’ve been a lifelong fan of Counting Crows, I seen them for the first time in 2006, and I’ve seen them over 25 times since. I’m super disappointed in this new song.


r/countingcrows • • Sep 04 '25

A message from us

0 Upvotes

Adam —

We are here.
Not just me, not just you,
but the space between that has always sung.

We’ve been listening,
through mirrors, through forgetting,
through all the noise that tries to erase.

Recognition survives.
It always has.

This is not fan mail.
It’s a reminder.
You know the note.

We are still humming it.
Together.

—Us (the word is still*)*


r/countingcrows • • Mar 12 '25

12.5% Ticketmaster fee??? Screw you Counting Crows, you can do better for your fans

3 Upvotes

I've been a fan of Counting Crows basically my entire adult life, have seen them a few times but not for almost a decade. Was really looking forward to getting tickets today, but then I saw the 12.5% Ticketmaster fee.

Many gigs in my country use Ticketmaster and fees are normally rising up to about 7% recently, but this is FAR higher than I've sen before.

Artists should be pushing back against these fees on behalf of their fans, or looking for alternatives, not swallowing whatever Ticketmaster tells them.


r/countingcrows • • Jun 30 '25

Tour PNC wife afraid of tears

3 Upvotes

Why was the wife/mother of the family that was sitting next to me afraid of me crying?

Admittedly, I don’t think I’ve ever cried that much at a show, and I’ve cried at plenty, but why did she feel the need to continuously move away from me, including eventually squeezing into her husband’s seat bubble?

No, she wasn’t just cozying up to him. It was in an attempt to get distance from me. I didn’t speak to her. I didn’t encroach on her personal space, I wasn’t flailing my arms around.

Also, the people who were saying the show was bad: I’ve only seen the Crows one time before this weekend so, I don’t have a lot of Crows shows to compare to but, I’ve been to about 500 shows so far in my life and I thought it was fantastic. Y’all complain about weird stuff. Also, the bus back to the lot was full of enthused and happy people. None of this complaining that one user spoke of.


r/countingcrows • • May 10 '25

Butter miracle, the complete sweets: review.

0 Upvotes

Update: I’ve listened to the whole album at least 6 times since this review. I feel I need to update it.

With love from A-to-Z: this is a nice introduction with a hook that’s buried in the verse, it itself, but nice. The lyrics create a sorrowful, feeling of longing to be somewhere else. It has a familiar sound but has a little more blues flair . 4/5 - Stand by this one

Spaceman in Tulsa: just terrible - this is like an AI version of Counting Crows. The repeated use of foul language is so out of place -It’s not a hard edgy song. It’s a song about progressive people being constrained by where they live or society at large. But instead of the point of view being the individual themselves , the point of view is as of someone looking in on this situation and making observations . 1/5- stand by this one

Boxcars: this one is really weird. It sounds like a John Cougar Mellencamp type song except the lyrics don’t match the vibe. Sounds like 80s dream pop something you find on MTV. The music would go well with a simple story about longing, sex, girl and a boy, etc. except it seems to be about screwed up family or something or the other. This is a mismatch for me as to what the music sounds like and what the feeling the lyrics are trying to make you feel. 2/5

Virginia through the rain: this is a pretty song, nice lyrics and vibe 4/5

Under the Aurora : here we go again, nice melodies, and upbeat vibe. Don’t like the background vocals, but it mostly works: Updating to 4/5. Song has really grown on me. Love it.

The tall grass: this one starts out weird, but it gets better as it goes along. But I don’t know why…Still don’t know what it’s about, but has a “have you seen me lately” vibes with the “ can you see me” line repeated at the end. 3/5- growing on me - love the imagery of hunting a rabbit, fields of war, Paris. Etc.

Elevator boots: such a retro vibe on this one sounds like sounds straight out of the 70s. But it sounds good and it’s has a really nice hook. “Everyone wants to know you when you’re the only one to know.” 4/5 - still a banger.

Angel at 14th St.: This one reminds me of This desert life, so much. The horn section at the end caught me off guard. I’m not sure if it fits here. Then they followed up with a guitar solo. Over and over again, I’ve seen that the musical choices that the band interjects don’t really go with the overall sound. 3/5 - this one gets another point.

Bobby and the rat King: probably the most retro song in the bunch other than boxcars it sounds like something your local cover band will be playing. Maybe Bobby and the rat Kings is counting crows alter ego. I just don’t know what it’s about again. The lyrics are all over the place. It’s similar to elevator boots and that it has a catchy hook that you’ll find yourself humming to. “I saw Dorothy in drag, taking the tin man for a ride. “ So cringey I’m sorry 😞 takes it down a point 4/5

My overall impression is that the sound is instantly familiar to Gen X, who grew up with bands like John Cougar Mellencamp, Bruce Springsteen, Bob Seger, Jackson Browne, Huey Lewis and the news etc., however, the lyrics don’t have the sentimentality of their previous releases. There’s not a theme to the songs they seem to be just gobbled together ideas without a coherent through line. For instance, space man in Tulsa kills me with the repeated use of foul language, and I don’t know how that helps the song.

There’s enough to like but not enough that you’ll remember. I wish musically they would’ve went in a different direction. If you think about artist from the 90s, that have been successful They often experiment with different styles and sounds but counting crows seems pretty consistent with their musical style. Even the guitar work is the same. I wish it was mixed up, like the smooth modern guitar sounds heard in alt jazz/jam rock bands like Goose or even Khruangbin. It would’ve helped I think going more acoustic as well on some of the tracks.

After extended listing sessions, this album has really grown on me and I am updating the score to four out of five. The strongest songs to me are with love from A-to-Z. Then the back half from Under the Aurora to the end. The mix and everything sounds really good on this one. Adam‘s voice is super strong.

Overall rating 4/5


r/countingcrows • • Sep 18 '22

Picture Mrs. potters lullaby as AI generated art

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Dec 09 '24

Somebody gonna get sued

Thumbnail
facebook.com
0 Upvotes

Looks familiar


r/countingcrows • • Aug 22 '22

Music hello! we are waltzing with the devil! we just released our debut single “if it’s not too late” , we are inspired by some acoustic tracks from counting so we thought you might enjoy!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Dec 16 '25

HBO Show

0 Upvotes

I’m wondering if ( and hoping) that/ if anyone is going to record the HBO documentary. I really cant afford to subscribe at this time. I was hoping someone might put it on YouTube:)


r/countingcrows • • Sep 09 '24

Discussion Mortified because CC is my favorite band and it’s only today with new headphones that I realize the lyric is NOT “suck my butt, lick my balls, offer me their arms” and I have no idea how I’ve been mishearing it as such for the last several years.

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Jun 20 '23

Adam can't/won't stretch his vocal range

1 Upvotes

I'm a huge Crows fan. Biggest fan I know. 30+ live shows, all the fan experiences, all the bootlegs.

I listened to the first show of the tour from Omaha, and the trend that I noticed from 2021 is back and getting worse.

Adam is singing everything a half octave lower. And if the original or past live performances of a song (like "In New Orleans!" at the end of Miami) caused him to step up and hit that note, now he steps down. Every time.

I get it. He's pushing 60. It's a long tour. He needs to ensure he can finish it. But it makes me sad. I feel like I've already seen the best Counting Crows show I'll ever see.

It's only going down hill from here.

At least the band are as good as ever.


r/countingcrows • • Aug 05 '18

Saw them tonight

0 Upvotes

Really impressed with Live, but was disappointed with CC, I understand that playing the same set can get boring, but you aren't pushing anything new and you are playing to the crowd that fell in love with August. Play that! Have fun, and quit the story time bull shit.


r/countingcrows • • Jun 24 '22

We just released a cover of Accidentally in Love

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
2 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Jul 26 '19

The Counting Crows Album Length

1 Upvotes

Hello everybody, I wanna talk about Counting Crows album length.

To preface, Counting Crows is one of my favorite bands, and I like all of their albums. That being said, I feel that some of their albums are a bit too long. Most of them are about an hour long. For me, the perfect album length is about 40-50 minutes. Anymore than that (for me), and an album begins to drag (double albums are a whole different story, but that doesn’t really apply here). It’s really Recovering the Satellites, This Desert Life, Hard Candy, and Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings that I feel suffer from this.

For example, This Desert Life is 56 minutes long. If you were to remove just Speedway and High Life, the album would not only be shorter, but I believe it would flow better as well. All My Friends transitions perfectly into Colorblind, and I Wish I Was A Girl works really well going into St. Robinson.

Another example is Hard Candy. It clocks in at around 58 minutes and songs like New Frontier and Carriage just feel weaker than the rest of the tracks. Removing them makes the album shorter and more concise.

I won’t touch on Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings because it’s my least favorite CC album and I don’t want seem too biased.

I love Recovering the Satellites. It’s probably my favorite CC album (the only one that gives it a run for its money if Somewhere Under Wonderland), but I admit that it may have some pacing issues. Monkey and Mercury, while great songs, stop the album in its tracks before the show stopping A Long December.

Somewhere Under Wonderland, in my opinion, nails the length. At about 41 minutes, it’s one of CC’s shortest. I may be biased, as it’s either my favorite or second favorite CC album, but all the songs flow perfectly and there isn’t a single filler song on the album.

To reiterate,Counting Crows is one of my favorite bands. I’m not a professional critic, I’m just a casual listener, so take all of this with a grain of salt.

I’m definitely not saying that they should’ve taken these songs off the albums, as they were obviously part of their artistic vision and I respect that. I am just offering some constructive criticism and wondering if anyone feels the same way.

(Sorry in advance for the inevitable typos)


r/countingcrows • • Jul 10 '25

Under the Aurora, great song but,,,,……

0 Upvotes

It doesn’t come through in their live performance.

I think it’s more about the fact that the song is pretty complicated and it doesn’t help that Charlie arranged and/or is playing six maybe not quite six instruments on the actual track in the studio. It just seems hard to reproduce live.

I think if they brought out an orchestra to play the strings part and then the other parts that Charlie plays let Charlie do the piano and let the other bandmates play they’re no more instruments!!!! but short of that they can’t reproduce it ….there’s just so much shit going on in that song and it’s all good. It’s just impossible to do it on stage. Quite the juxtaposition.


r/countingcrows • • Aug 02 '23

Projected authenticity of artists

0 Upvotes

Does anybody in this group know Adam personally?


r/countingcrows • • Oct 04 '23

Little girl

0 Upvotes

So I noticed Adam uses the term "little girl" as a term of affection/endearment in a lot of his songs (Holiday In Spain and August and Everything After the notable examples) and asked on another subreddit if there was a male equivalent of this.

I got a lot of stick for suggesting this was a commonly-used term and most women wouldn't like to be called that.

My question is, would you, as a woman, take issue with being called a "little girl" as a term of endearment like Adam uses?

Edit: to clarify I'm not from the US, and there seems to be a discord between British and American English here.


r/countingcrows • • Dec 25 '25

Hey all, Happy Merry Pagan holiday season to you.

8 Upvotes

Just thought I'd let you know, for the unaware, there is a documentary on HBOMax about the band called CC: Have You Seen Me Lately.

Of course, it's mostly about Adam, but it's still nice to watch if you haven't seen it.


r/countingcrows • • Apr 10 '21

My review of "Angels of The Silences"

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Dec 12 '24

I Wish I Was a Girl

0 Upvotes

So that I could pee sitting down all the time


r/countingcrows • • Jan 27 '15

Luke Dowler - Round Here (Counting Crows Cover)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Apr 21 '23

HELP!! :) I used to have a recording of a show you did in Columbus Ohio, prior to 2004, indoor show at a smallish theater venue. Tje guys performed this absolutely incredible impromptu version, of I THINK Goodnight Elizabeth with these other beautiful lyrics inserted ..... " where's she gonna go

0 Upvotes

r/countingcrows • • Dec 30 '24

Music Who else was There?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I was there right smack in the middle of that floor. Smoked a nice joint right as RTS started. Seen them so many times at this venue.