I'll avoid major spoilers, though I can't make any promises about the comments.
I just spent three months reading the longest novel of my life, famed cowboy soap opera Lonesome Dove, frequently mentioned in the list of books McCarthy fans should read after finishing his oeuvre. It was... definitely a decent, solid western, with some remarkable qualities.
I'll start with what I liked. McMurty does write characters very well, including giving very believable depth, ugliness, humanity, and very disparate personalities to the two major female characters. The book does a great job of depicting the starkness of male friendship without judging it. It simply is, and can even be beautiful in its austerity. The setting has no surprises, and the plot could be summarized on a cocktail napkin. Those aren't slights so much as an acknowledgment that this is very much a character driven book, and the characters here are up to the task of carrying such a work.
I appreciate the realistic constraints that McMurty keeps himself within for most of the book. Not everything that happens follows a glamorous path or ends with a neat ribbon tied around it. Though I do feel there was one scene in particular that delved hard into what I will call "masculinity porn." For whatever reason this genre is extremely vulnerable to male authors indulging in a silly, masturbatory power fantasy where their lead characters stroll into some town, disrespect everyone, beat the shit out of anyone who looks at them funny, fuck every woman in the universe, and then stroll off into the sunset right in front of the local sheriff who just watched them commit several felonies. It was the one cartoonish scene in the book that made me dislike both the author and the characters so much that I had to put the book down for several days. Especially given how starkly realistic the rest of the work is, it would have been nice to see one actual negative consequence happen to someone who acts like a complete asshole through a sequence like that, but I get the impression that the author expects the reader to enjoy watching old men bully younger men instead of sympathizing with a bartender who basically watched some arrogant, filthy stranger waltz into his bar and take a shit on the floor.
I did not like the ending of this book at all, and it made me long for the effort that McCarthy puts into masterfully crafting a thought provoking oddity for the reader to chew on for days. I can see McCarthy spending a month writing that last page, peering into his soul to get every sentence just right to drive an eerie reflection into the reader. This book by contrast just ends like he fell over dead at the typewriter. Some authors have used abruptness to inflict a sort of shock on the reader in the last page, but it feels like there is no intent with it here. The last page of Lonesome Dove feels like the proctor called time on the SAT essay and McMurty had to put his pencil down and hand it in. The final sentence is only tangentially related to one of the book's central themes and is written with zero punch or pizazz.
Which brings me to the worst aspect of all of this book: it has the single worst author forward I have EVER read in my life. It is so horrendous, so hilariously vainglorious, so utterly pretentious that I could scarcely believe it was written by the same man who wrote the book. I made the mistake of reading it before the book, and this moron goes and spoils several MASSIVE plot points as if his story is so essential to literature itself that he somehow expects everyone to have already read the book before they read it. He also bloviates at length about how this book put him squarely among the giants of the genre, even listing McCarthy by name, and then takes another sentence to assure the reader that he is a much, much better writer than most other notable people who have tried to author westerns before.
You are a decent page turner, Larry McMurty. I've read Cormac McCarthy. You are no Cormac McCarthy.