r/copywriting • u/DRCopySmith • Oct 06 '23
Discussion What "happened" to r/copywriting; a diagnosis...
Off the bat, the DR in my username stands for Direct Response. I am not a Dr. and this does not constitute medical advice. With that, let's jump right in.
As we all know, Scientific Advertising was first published in 1923 and its principles are truly timeless. What has changed since then, and where the waters have been muddied to the point nobody can see - thus the "blind leading the blind" phenomenon we have going on here, are the myriad forms of online writing that are now taking place.
We are a top 1% subreddit, with over 167k members, who forgot what copywriting was. It says it right in the subreddit description - "advertising copy."
It IS selling using the written word.
It's NOT just any writing online.
I got invited to a "copywriting job board" subreddit that was 100% content writing and blog generation jobs. This is commoditized now due to the proliferation of AI. You will be paid peanuts to edit AI blog posts (we all know this is how you write them).
This is not copywriting.
Neither is feeding an AI bot copywriting frameworks.
Copywriting is ALWAYS measurable.
That's how you know people both asking for and giving copy critiques on here are amateurs. I might tell you your copy sucks, but who says I'm part of your target market? I might be a 37-year-old neckbeard in my mom's basement cosplaying as a real-life cross between David Ogilvy and Don Draper.
The only opinion that matters is the market's.
Did the copy achieve its intended outcome (sign-ups, sales, votes)? At what rate? Great, now beat that.
That's why professional copywriters can charge such high rates - they have the track record to justify it. My copywriting "portfolio" doesn't even have any of my copy in it. It has short briefs on the company's industry, the objective we were trying to accomplish, the mediums we used, and the results.
Professional copywriters are obsessed with delivering the best possible results to their clients. I tell my clients straight up I am a COPYwriter, if it's not intended to sell something I am not your guy. I am NOT going to go research dog shampoos so I can write a blog post for your website for $1000. I will generate an offer and the related advertising copy for you so you don't go out of business in two months.
Copywriters don't give a shit about "creativity" or grammar or punctuation errors. They care about profits. So in today's day and age to be a great copywriter you need to know about metrics like: CTR, CPM, impressions, AOV, LTV, CAC, etc. (digital marketing).
As a professional copywriter, I solve big problems and make big dollars for my clients, and I am compensated fairly for doing so. The market is the only critic I take feedback from and it can't give me feedback on the copy I am handwriting in my spiral-bound notebook.
If you want to get better at writing copy you write copy and constantly test it against the market. If you haven't gotten your teeth kicked in by the market, spit them out, and kept going - you're probably not a copywriter yet.
So, TL;DR, copywriting is measured quantitatively with numbers. Blog posts and other writing meant to inform more than sell is just that, writing. You will struggle to make six figures writing for other people. Copywrite for other people, write for yourself. Great copywriters don't "make" money, they earn it.