I made a post a few days ago about wanting to ask my ex-wife for a child support modification. I since deleted the post once I felt the conversation run its course. I didn't want her to possibly run across it.
Background. Her income has significantly changed since the court-ordered child support when we divorced. ($0-->$60k---$86K). Mine went from $112K-->$125K--$132K.
I used the state provided child support worksheet calculation and turns out I am now paying approx $650 more than I need to. I got a lot of comments on here arguing that I should leave it alone and I make enough and I am going to ruin her QOL and she deserves it...etc etc.
Well, I got emboldened by the pettiness from being on here to approach her about the topic. She came over to drop some stuff off for our son. So I asked to talk about it. Her immediate response was "Well that is what you owe me for being able to build her career and not mine".
I was going to remind her that she is remembering our marriage very differently from me, but...that would have just ruined what I was trying to accomplish so I just pulled up the state calculator.
Showed her worksheet calculator and the math I used and assumed bonuses from either of us. She accepted that a little more but said going from $900/month to $250 was too low.
I told her I'd be willing to phase it and not go that low, but I wanted to regain some of my finances so I can continue digging myself out of a financial hole just as she is doing.
She was baffled as to how I didn't have enough money to just be living much more comfortably. So I just said eff it and pulled up my excel file where I track all my finances. I showed her high level my net income vs expenses.
She looked puzzled and asked how I make less than her monthly. I told her I didn't, but she claimed I did.
Turns out, she somehow nets ~$500/month more than I do (if you account for child support). She claims head of household and our son on her taxes AND her company pays for her benefits fully.
I claim single and no dependents and I pay for my son and my benefits ($450/paycheck).
We just kind of looked at it said wow, and then she left saying she is going to think about it more.
Texted me later that she is ok with phasing it if we can stretch a year or so. Also going to look at how much more it would cost to have him on her healthcare plan. we have not decided on anything final or talked much about it, but we will look at it after the holidays.
So, I am happy the conversation went better than I expected and she was not as angry and mean as I would have predicted in previous situations.
EDIT: We split custody 50/50 and I pay for 60% of his shared expenses. Also, for those who just see big number salaries and not think further before commenting. (Copied from my excel file for you)
Annual: $132,000-->Bi-Weekly Gross: $5,076.93--->Bi-Weekly Net: $3,126.32 - which is about $6,250/month.
Rent: $2,392 (HCOL)
Utilities: $120
Student Loans: $330
Personal Loan (all debts absorbed from marriage): $400 (~two years left to pay)
Car Payment: $478
Car Insurance: $150
Groceries: $450
Dog Care (senior) $95
Phone Bill: $160 (me and my son)
Subscriptions: $57
Internet: $70
Fuel: $80
School Lunch: $50
Misc (storage unit, etc): $68
Basketball for son: $75
Net: $1252
Child Support: $900
Left over: $370.
For a month I have $370 to put towards savings, eating out, and doing anything fun for myself or son.
Two months out of the year I get an additional paycheck which I try to fund towards debts or savings. The personal loan absorbs all of my previous debt when married including her student loans. Family member consolidated all of our debt (minus my student loans) and gave me a family loan that I pay.