r/continentaltheory • • Mar 12 '13

Wikiproject Continental Philosophy: Devoted to improving and expanding Continental and Critical Theory articles on Wikipedia

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
37 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Nov 20 '12

90 boxes, 37 000 pages of Foucault's unpublished archives and manuscripts will be sold to Bibliothèque Nationale de France soon... (in French, use google translate)

Thumbnail
tempsreel.nouvelobs.com
34 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Jan 22 '22

Post-structuralism Guide-Map

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 11 '13

Is there such a thing as 'Continental Logic' as distinct from Logic in Analytic Philosophy?

27 Upvotes

I was reading this thread

and it was kind of my nightmare vision for the future of philosophy, teaching uninterested, apolitical, business majors some math-like logic to get them by their middle class jobs. Can't help but think American Beauty.

But it got me thinking, what exactly is the role of logic in continental philosophy? Logic has traditionally been a major part of philosophy, long before the rise of Logical Positivism.

Kant considered logic basically completed by Aristotle. And Hegel wrote his famous Logic, which probably isn't what most contemporary philosophers mean by logic today. And then Husserl and Heidegger studied meta-logic, without really writing any logic qua logic.

What is the role of logic in Continental Philosophy? Is it identical with logic as understood by Analytic philosophers? What is its relationship to symbolic mathematical logic? Or does CP simply relinquish logic as the domain of positivism?

Have any Continental Philosophers attempted to construct their own system of logic?


r/continentaltheory • • Mar 26 '13

Derrida: The Excluded Favorite, by Emily Eakin

Thumbnail
nybooks.com
26 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 05 '13

Anyone want to start a Being and Time reading group?

25 Upvotes

I'm rereading Being and Time, possibly accompanied by the Dryfus lectures. Let me know if you're interested and we can start a subreddit, or just discuss on /r/heidegger

Edit: There seems to be enough interest, so I created a subreddit- http://www.reddit.com/r/BeingAndTimeReading


r/continentaltheory • • Mar 29 '13

What is the use of Psychoanalysis today?

24 Upvotes

Hello, I don't intend for this to come off as combatative, I merely want to hear your opinions. Given there has been little empirical evidence (to my knowledge) of many of the claims made in psychoanalysis (the Oedipus complex, the sexual nature of desire, etc.), why are they useful? If it is simply for the vocabulary, what makes its vocabulary special?


r/continentaltheory • • Jan 11 '13

Help with Bataille's "The Accursed Share"

24 Upvotes

I'm not particularly sure if this is the correct place for this, but I lurk around here quite a bit and want to engage in the conversation. I looked around the subreddit and found nothing on a thinker who I have recently found very interesting, Georges Bataille, who developed multiple philosophical theories. Specifically I wanted to know of any secondary literature, reference works or just any advice when reading his work "The Accursed Share" and tackling the concepts of Expenditure and Consumption. Any help is greatly appreciated. Thanks so much!


r/continentaltheory • • Nov 10 '12

Manuel DeLanda - Deleuze, Subjectivity, and Knowledge (lecture, 2011)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
24 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Nov 23 '17

Simon Critchley recommends his favourite works of Continental Philosophy

Thumbnail
fivebooks.com
23 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Apr 16 '13

Hundreds of video lectures from on Youtube from the European Graduate School (De Landa, Virilio, Zizek, etc.) Enjoy!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
23 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Jan 07 '13

A History of Philosophy from a Continental Perspective

23 Upvotes

This is my "Dream course" of how I would like to see the history of philosophy taught, drawing on the insights of Continental theorists. Feel free to add your own Continental historians.

Basic method is take the great giants of philosophy and find a great Continental who wrote on him.

Pre-Socratics, Aristotle, Scholastics -Heidegger

Epicurus & Lucretius - Marx

Socrates - Kierkegaard

Plato, Wittgenstein - Badiou

Parmenides, Schelling - Zizek

Ancient Cynicism- Sloterdijk

Judaism - Levinas

Catholicism - Jean-Luc Marion

Renaissance - Agnes Heller

Descartes, Galileo- Husserl

Hobbes- Carl Schmitt

Machiavelli - Gramsci

Spinoza- Negri

Pascal - Lucien Goldmann

Empiricism, Nietzsche - Deleuze

Stoicism, Lutheranism, Idealism - Hegel

Enlightement - Adorno

Romanticism- Lukacs

Hegel - Kojeve


r/continentaltheory • • Feb 15 '21

"Even in a communist country, studying Marx is more potentially threatening to the government than studying Heidegger because the former deals with sociopolitical relations while the latter doesn’t care. For those looking to stay away from politics, Heidegger is their man."

Thumbnail
lareviewofbooks.org
21 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Feb 25 '14

Join Michael Hardt in Annotating Deleuze's "Postscript on the Societies of Control' on Rap Genius

Thumbnail
news.rapgenius.com
21 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 27 '13

What is the nature of desire for Deleuze?

21 Upvotes

I am currently reading through Anti-Oedipus and I am very confused about the nature of desire. I apologize if my confusions are something which is very elementary, but basically I find that there is some tension between Deleuze's materialism and his idea of desire as that which is productive. In other words, how can his materialism mesh with his constructivism?

To further elaborate, my point is the following: if desire constructs the Real as such, how can there be anything but desire? That question is perhaps a bit vulgar, and my proceeding analysis will be equally vulgar and obscene (I'm reading the book right now, I don't really want to look for page numbers).

Deleuze and Guattari are clear: desire is productive. What is it that desire produces? Not fantasy, which I take to be something deviating from the actual way that things are, but instead the Real, which I take to be the actual way in which things are actualized. I think I might be confused as to the Deleuzian conception of the Real, but with this as a basis I am confused. If desire is the productive agent (it, of course, must be used correctly according to the three syntheses of the unconscious: connective, disjunctive, conjunctive) then how can their be conditions for desire? Wouldn't desire in turn construct those very conditions? How can desire create the basis for its own existence?

If desire is productive, is everything desire? Being is univocal for Deleuze (something else which I believe I am very confused about, what, precisely, does this mean?), according to a quote that I liked a lot Deleuze and Guattari said something along the lines of: everything is differentiated by intensity. Perhaps desire concentrates to certain intensities at certain points, constituting an object?

But desire cannot be that which structures reality as such. This would seem to suggest a very postmodern and poststructuralist point: structures are not in the world, but instead are generated by the human mind. I don't remember where, exactly, but Deleuze and Guattari EXPLICITLY reject this point: they say that structure is in the world as such.

WHAT?!

If that's the case, how is desire something which is productive rather than representative? Moreover, how do we create concepts in the way articulated in What is Philosophy? Moreover, if there is a way that the world is apart from any interpretation (and this seems, to me, to be a profoundly anti-Nietzschean point) it would seem that truth shouldn't be cast aside in favor of use as they suggest in What is Philosophy? If there is a certain way the world is as such, it would seem that the question of what is?... need not be replaced by how does it work?...

IN sum, Deleuze and Guattari seem to undermine their own constructivist project with their metaphysical realism. I feel that the metaphysical realism must be thrown out, but how exactly does this occur consistently?


r/continentaltheory • • Jan 20 '13

The Body Without Organs

21 Upvotes

I am currently reading Anti-Oedipus and I was hoping r/continentaltheory could help me flesh out D&G's "Body without organs". It seems to me that BwO refers to the 'flows' from which singular entities arise as well as the potentiality for alternative entities (please correct me if my interpretation is inaccurate or lacking).

What then is the relationship between the desiring machine and BwO? If BwO is, if not the origin, than the 'grid' from which the desiring machine is manifested; is the process of making oneself the BwO not an attempt to revisit a forgotten place of origin? Is Oedipus the process of forgetting in this situation?


r/continentaltheory • • May 31 '13

Who are the big philosophers working today in continental theory?

20 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 21 '13

What is with all the hostility that I run into every time I mention anything about postmodernism?

20 Upvotes

I am something of an amateur philosopher, as it is something I toy with in my free time. I have found that I have a real affinity for postmodernist stuff. I have found, repeatedly, on both Reddit and on Facebook and IRL that when I mention postmodernism and/or postmodernist ideas they are often met with open hostility and derision. What gives? Have any of y'all run into this? Does anyone have any pet theories about why so many people find this so damned threatening?

I posted this over in /r/philosophy and got some interesting answers. It was suggested that I cross post over here as well.


r/continentaltheory • • Aug 17 '12

John R. Searle on Heidegger

20 Upvotes

It ought to arouse our suspicions that people who spend enormous efforts on interpreting [Heidegger's] work disagree on the fundamental question whether he was an idealist. For the purposes of this discussion, his lack of a resolute commitment to the basic facts is enough. Suppose you took the notion of Dasein seriously, in the sense that you thought it referred to a real phenomenon in the real world. Your first question would be: How does the brain cause Dasein and how does Dasein exist in the brain? Or if you thought the brain was not the right explanatory level you would have to say exactly how and where Dasein is located in the space time trajectory of the organism and you would have to locate the right causes, both the micro causes that are causing Dasein and its causal effects on the organic processes of the organism. There is no escaping the fact that we all live in one space-time continuum, and if Dasein exists it has to be located and causally situated in that continuum. Furthermore, if you took Dasein seriously you would then have to ask how does Dasein fit into the biological evolutionary scheme? Do other primates have it? Other mammals? What is its evolutionary function? I can’t find an answer to these questions in Heidegger or even a sense that he is aware of them or takes them seriously. But taking these questions seriously is the price of taking Dasein seriously, unless of course you are denying the primordiality of the basic facts.

John R. Searle, "The Phenomenological Illusion" (2005) http://socrates.berkeley.edu/~jsearle/PhenomenologicalIllusion.pdf


r/continentaltheory • • Jan 26 '22

Post-Structuralist Guide-Map (final and complete version)

19 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 17 '18

Gilles Deleuze from A to Z (Engligh Subtitles)

19 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Nov 17 '16

"Trump will complete the system of German Idealism"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
19 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Jul 18 '13

Deleuze and the Question of Desire: Toward an Immanent Theory of Ethics [pdf]

Thumbnail parrhesiajournal.org
19 Upvotes

r/continentaltheory • • Mar 01 '13

I'm really starting to feel like Heidegger is saying nothing and is a Wizard of Oz (and this is coming from a huge Hegel fan)

19 Upvotes

So I don't want to come off as one of those Analytic philistines who have IMHO gutted philosophy of anything meaningful, relevant or authentic. But I've got to say that having spent 2 years intensively studying Heidegger, it really is starting to seem like he was saying nothing and just covering up his emptyness with big words.

I guess I'll start with a Chomsky quote

Since no one has succeeded in showing me what I'm missing, we're left with the second option: I'm just incapable of understanding. I'm certainly willing to grant that it may be true, though I'm afraid I'll have to remain suspicious, for what seem good reasons. There are lots of things I don't understand -- say, the latest debates over whether neutrinos have mass or the way that Fermat's last theorem was (apparently) proven recently. But from 50 years in this game, I have learned two things: (1) I can ask friends who work in these areas to explain it to me at a level that I can understand, and they can do so, without particular difficulty; (2) if I'm interested, I can proceed to learn more so that I will come to understand it. Now Derrida, Lacan, Lyotard, Kristeva, etc. --- even Foucault, whom I knew and liked, and who was somewhat different from the rest --- write things that I also don't understand, but (1) and (2) don't hold: no one who says they do understand can explain it to me and I haven't a clue as to how to proceed to overcome my failures. That leaves one of two possibilities: (a) some new advance in intellectual life has been made, perhaps some sudden genetic mutation, which has created a form of "theory" that is beyond quantum theory, topology, etc., in depth and profundity; or (b) ... I won't spell it out.

Now I actually disagree with most of the quote as far as French Theory is concerned. I think most of French Theory (with the possible exception of Lacan, who might suffer the same defect) actually do have much to say that is meaningful.

But the point Chomsky makes that is true for me, is that I can respect that Hegel like Quantum Mechanics is very difficult for a layman like me to understand. And yet when I read the secondary literature on Hegel from Kojeve, Marx, Althusser, Hyppolite, Lukacs, Pinkard, it is clear that Hegel is speaking about something very meaningful and relevant to human life. Maybe Hegel was just a big fraud. Even if that were so, I would still say then the great genius lies with the Hegel scholars and commentators, but there is still great genius.

I really can't say the same about Heidegger. I've read a ton of secondary literature, including Hubert Dreyfus. And I think the critics might actually be right on him. The few commentaros who do make sense of Heidegger, have him saying platitudes. When sophisticated it is unintelligible, and when intelligible it is unsophisticated. After forcing my way through a truckload of both primary and secondary sources, all I've gotten out of it is "being is really really important for some reason".

I turned to Heidegger, for the same reason I think many people do, I was interested in the Existentialism of Sartre, Kierkegaard, Camus, Dostoevsky, but was told that they were primarily literary figures and rather amateurish philosophers. And that the REAL philosophy behind existentialism was Heidegger. But at the end of the day I would say, having studied Heidegger, Sartre actually has much more to say. What I loved about Existentialism and Continentals in general, was that it was devoted to the big questions of the meaning of life and death. And I had given Heidegger the benefit of the doubt that he too was addressing those questions, simply in a more abstract-ontological manner.

Perhaps it is a question of relevance? Critical Theory, Existentialism, Post-Structuralism, French Theory, does say something meaningful and has concrete relevance to human life and current political controversies. German Phenomenology is far more abstract and devoted to questions of epistemology, perception and mind, I'm rather uninterested in.

I guess I'll just stress again, that this critique is coming from a big defender of continental philosophy, who sees the merit in countless other continentals who a frequently denounced for speaking gibberish. I just think that in the case of Heidegger, it might actually be true.

Many great philosophers, I do respect, pay tribute to Heidegger, so I long figured he must be saying something, that I'm just missing. For a long time I felt the same way about Hegel, and slowly the secondary sources began to clear away some of the mist. But with Heidegger, I make no progress, and when someone does make him make sense, he says banalities. His celebrated being-toward-death is nothing more than "don't forget your gonna die."

One way I finally connected with Hegel is by reading his History of Philosophy and seeing how he re-interpreted philosophies I was already familiar with. I've tried the same with Heidegger's histories and gotten zilch out of it other than -being, being, being. Maybe I shouldn't be applying the paradigm that worked for Hegel in the first place, since Heidegger just isn't meant to click in the same way? I hope you get from all this ranting, that I really did want to like and 'get' Heidegger but never got anywhere despite an authentic openness.

This might sound crazy, but I wonder if the problem is that German Phenomenology is actually too Analytic for me? In that Husserl is actually engaged in addressing the same problems as Frege, which I'm largely uninterested in.

Ironically my history with Hegel and Heidegger actually reflects their own philosophies. With Hegel, I've slowly come to progress, understand and master Being, while with Heidegger there is no progress and Being is just as much a mystery to me as on day one.

Am I just really stupid or what? What am I missing?


r/continentaltheory • • Jul 10 '12

Freud, Nietzsche, Hegel & Kant Archive of Complete Bi-Lingual Translations

Thumbnail
freud2lacan.com
19 Upvotes