I’m a long-term reader of this subreddit and wanted to share what we’ve learnt over the past few months.
I know what you're thinking; this is clickbait. But I thought I’d share our SEO journey:
SEO as an acquisition channel is perfect for startups or solo entrepreneurs looking to make an impact and have more time than money.
Rewinding to September 2021, the CPC (Cost per click) in Google Ads had almost quadrupled in our market, and we were struggling to keep up with competitors.
Forward to March 2022, and we were ranked no.1 for 10 of the top highly converting terms in our industry.
This provided us with 162 organic leads in just a month, significantly reducing our acquisition costs.
At this point, we decided to keep at a low volume, high conversion strategy with Ads while partnering it with a long-term SEO strategy.
This post will outline how we did it, including tips and actual results. This post is to help inspire small businesses like us on how to make an impact with SEO as a customer acquisition channel and the overall benefits it provides.
This case study shows what worked, what didn’t, and the lessons we learned along the way. (It wasn’t always plain sailing, we promise).
TL:DR:
We got F%$@%d by Google Ads as our competitors had far more money, and we couldn’t afford to pay for the clicks they could, so we adjusted and began our SEO journey. Fast forward nine months, and we are top of the rankings of our highest converting keywords and have significantly reduced the cost per acquisition doing so.
We’ve written a full case study on this, with a more detailed outline and tips; if you DM us, we will send you a link if interested
EDIT: I had a few DMs, so here is the full link to our case study: https://www.aquaswitch.co.uk/seo-case-studies/
Anyway! Without further ado, let’s have a look at what Google looks for.
What does Google look for?
Here are the basic ranking factors Google looks at to determine where you sit per search. Here’s the list of factors we personally focussed on to help us achieve the number 1 spot.
Content quality
Quality of content is a stone-wall basic. You have to build well-structured content that is useful and easy to understand.
Start with a strong page structure; this includes:
In-depth keyword research
Exciting page titles, and solid meta descriptions.
Well-written paragraphs that educate the reader and inform.
Well-researched keywords and frequently asked questions are imperative.
This, paired with a fast, optimised site, will help you go a long way to achieving organic success
Refreshing content
Refreshing content was key during our initial months. Information in the water market is constantly changing.
Freshness is a ranking factor.
For example:
If you post a guide on IOS, you will need to keep your content up to date with the new updates they release; or your “Everything you need to know about IOS” will quickly become out-of-date .
You need to update pages to keep the content accurate and relevant.
If you don’t, your exit and bounce rate will increase - signalling to Google that you’re no longer relevant and demoting you in the rankings (aka, our worst nightmare).
Site speed
Post-Millenials have no time tolerance. If your site is slow, people will leave your website immediately, signalling to Google that your site isn’t relevant.
Not being relevant = instant demotion in the rankings.
To overcome this, optimise your site. Reduce your 301s and use quick-loading HTML. The easiest way to achieve this is using a simple WordPress template with a simple structure.
For more in-depth tips, read the guide over at Moz.
Search intent
We focused on high converting search terms: Those that stated the searcher intended to “compare” or “switch”.
We then built our content around that, which proved valuable to our placement as we answered users' key questions, built trust, and converted.
Mobile optimisation
If your website is not mobile-friendly, you have no chance. Most WordPress and Shopify templates are mobile-friendly and adjust to pretty much any device.
If you’re unsure, you can check on Google Search Console.
Crawlability
What the hell does this mean?
Crawlability is essentially how easy Google and other search engines can scan your site. By adding clear sections and a sitemap, you’ll be able to easily direct Google to the pages containing the correct search terms.
Backlinks
These are crucial. Think of backlinks as references. A high authority website ranking to one of the pages of your website signals to Google that your website is legitimate and uses this as a trust mechanism.
For example:
Website A: 50x paid link referrals from spammyspamspam.com
Vs.
Website B: 2x organic referrals from bbc.co.uk and theindependent.co.uk
Website B would be considered the more trustworthy site and would have more value than website A. Quality over quantity.
E-A-T strategy
E-A-T stands for Expertise-Authorativeness-Trustworthiness. It’s something Google has stated that they take into consideration.
E-A-T is essentially used to promote content written by experts.
For example:
Content written in the field of medicine - they would prefer an actual medical expert to rank highest in providing help and valid information to others.
Domain authority
This is a bit of a vanity metric, but still important.
Remember: Domain Authority is a metric that was created by Moz. It’s a prediction of how likely a domain is to appear in search engine results vs competitors.
But it does have value!
It can be a measurable metric to compare page performance to competitors.
Next, we move on to a few technical basics:
Technical basics for SEO
Here are a few tips and basics to implement when setting up your site, ready to take on the search engines:
Use SSL
SSL is a security technology that creates an encrypted link between the web server and browser.
You must set one up; no SSL will harm your site significantly. Use this guide to set it up.
XML Sitemap
A sitemap is a no-brainer. A site map essentially helps search engines understand your website and what it’s all about.
The sitemap will provide useful information on the priority of your site.
For example: when a page was last modified and how frequently your website is updated.
When building a sitemap, you have two options;
You build one manually, or;
You use a simple sitemap plugin.
Ensure your site is mobile-friendly (As mentioned above)
As mentioned previously. Ensure your site is optimised for mobile. If not, you’ll suffer huge consequences in your rankings.
It’s simple to check whether or not your site is mobile by using the tool provided by Google. Most CMSs will offer responsive templates, so the likelihood is your site will be mobile-friendly, but worth checking!
Set up Google Search Console
You must set up Google Search Console.
It’s important as you want to submit your website to their platform and a sitemap. This helps with indexing. This will also allow you to monitor your site's performance and organic growth.
You can learn more here.
Site speed
Ensure your site is quick, as mentioned above!
Here are a few tips to ensure super fast speed for your site:
Ensure you have fast hosting.
Use a single CSS sheet. This way, the browser displays the page quickly and correctly.
Use a decent domain name server.
Compress all webpages. You can do this with plugins like “Fastest Cache”.
Minimal image sizes. If you’re using images, ensure they’re compressed and use a web-friendly file type.
How we researched the pages
We used the free tools available to us, these were as follows:
These allowed us to understand what the high intent keywords were and the different longer-tailed questions associated.
With this, we began to build out our page.
How we built the page:
First, we built a skeleton answering all of the above questions in an easy-to-use format. You can see our first outline here.
*We’ve come a long way since, but it was still super effective!
Remember: Page structure is incredibly important when it comes to on-page SEO. Google crawls each page to understand it completely, and the layout of the page, from the headings to your meta description, every small piece adds value to your SEO strategy.
We focused on the following after:
Writing the content for the page. Focusing on informative, well-structured content to advise and answer users' frequently asked questions.
We would then write the Title and Meta Description for the page.
The URL Structure.
Internal linking.
Once this was all implemented and the first draft was ready, we would share it with one another and review it. Then uploading onto our CMS for one final review, ready to set live into the wild!
Once we followed through with the key pages, we began to implement the following:
Rebuilding the pages. e corrected existing pages to ensure they fit in with the basics above.
Consolidating failed pages. Any pages that were poor at converting or were causing keyword cannibalisation we killed off.
Creating new URLs. For old pages to shorten or to look better.
Changing the site build. This allowed us to build pages quicker using a toggle builder (Drop and drag).
Building out a full content schedule. This was key - we created an in-depth schedule to follow around key topics in our industry and
Building out page refreshes on a consistent basis
Posting to industry publications (Smart water magazine etc.). This allowed us to get some key backlinks back to the most important pages on our website.
Focusing on meta descriptions. Improve the meta descriptions for users and for Google. Make them short, to the point and inviting. They help with search queries and people clicking through, as well as Google understanding the page in detail.
Title tags improvements. Reviewing old H1 titles - aligning them to the page's content and search terms/intent.
Before we get to the results, here’s what didn’t work!
Waiting to start our SEO strategy. We waited far too long to start working on our SEO strategy. Hindsight’s a great thing!
Buying links. Total waste of money. Did more harm than good.
Broken backlink building. Such a waste of time. No webmaster actually cares, and if they do find your email, they’re not going to put you as the link. Hours wasted on this. Much better to outreach and partner on a blog!
Sending chocolates to John Mueller. Turns out John is, in fact, lactose intolerant, and we nearly left him on the throne for 24+ hours. Next time we’ll send him dairy-free chocolates.
The results:
You can see the in-depth version of this in our full post - we can DM you it (Just don’t want this to look like self-promotion for our brand).
Here we will show the results and key updates we made.
September 2021 - October 2021 - The big shake-up.
For the first two months, we decided to make the following updates:
Rebuilding the pages, creating a toggle builder - faster page load speed.
Consolidating failed pages - to avoid any keyword cannibalisation.
New 4-step postcode function to improve conversions (A good conversion rate keeps Google happy).
Creating new URLs and redirects to match what the page is about to help improve Click Through Rates.
We moved from the page /switch-water-supply/ and split it into four new pages:
November 2021
Here are the key changes to our SEO strategy:
Monitored UX closely and adapted. We implemented Microsoft Clarity to an advanced level.
Page refreshes. We kept on top of the ever-evolving markets. By consistently updating our core pages to be as accurate and relevant as possible. This helped us improve our standing on the “freshness” factor.
Solid content schedule. We militantly stuck to a content schedule to build the best content for our readers and customers. We unwaveringly decided on becoming the Wikipedia of the water world.
Here’s the average performance of our key search terms from each page:
Full results here:
December 2021
We made a few huge changes this month. These were:
Consolidated the failed pages.
Continued strict posting schedule.
Introduction to our newsletter.
Continued page refreshes.
Partnership outreach.
Tweaks to the user experience.
Full results available:
January 2021 - February 2022
We were actually preoccupied with other business matters, so we stuck to the core basics.
Full results here:
And then, in March ‘22, we hit no.1 for our five highest-converting keywords.
March 2022.
Full results here:
These positions equated to a stark increase in organic leads:
Our final thoughts
There were two of us who implemented the plan with no budget, using the free tools available. It took time, it was difficult, but we persevered and continued on with the plan. We finally got to the no.1 spot acquiring leads at a much lower cost per acquisition, making it far more feasible for us as a small business.
Happy to document part 2 for the future. How we kept the number 1 positions and what else we’ve attempted to improve our SEO and overall marketing performance.
Happy reading!