r/consulting • • 12h ago

Is it just me, or has AI set the bar unrealistically high when it comes to actual output and speed?

84 Upvotes

So I’m in my first year at a Tier2 firm in a fairly senior role. I have received a pretty difficult year-end feedback which caught me by surprise. I’ve always had a very steep development curve at my previous firms (MBB, Tier2). One thing that is frustrating me is that my superiors seem to be of the opinion that, with AI, my impact should be 10x higher. To be honest, I feel like I cannot manage all the different projects and work streams they are expecting me to complete very quickly. I am also leading a fairly large team internally and things have been very unstable this year. Whenever I argue that I feel like I’m expected to deliver results that none of my predecessors could achieve, I always hear: “But you have access to AI tools now”.

I’m self-aware enough to know that some of the feedback is probably justified. However, I kind of find myself wondering if this is the new reality we all face that expectations on delivery and speed have become unrealistically high. I talked to some of my friends who work in management positions in non-consulting firms and they have similar experiences.

Is this the new reality we just have to accept?


r/consulting • • 15h ago

How do people who are all talk and no substance survive in consulting?

146 Upvotes

Curious how common this is in consulting. Have you ever worked with a colleague who consistently fails to understand urgency, needs constant handholding, struggles to structure their thoughts, and rarely takes ownership of deliverables?

Yet somehow, they’re incredibly smooth talkers and know exactly how to sound competent in meetings.

Do these people actually progress into senior roles, or does the lack of substance eventually catch up with them?


r/consulting • • 2h ago

Anyone at a smaller firm happy with how the admin stuff works?

3 Upvotes

I wanna hear from people at smaller firms because most of the discussion here is about client work and getting staffed but I want to know about the admin that eats up the rest of your week. Expenses and approvals don't sound like much until you're sorting them out on a Friday after spending the whole week on a client deliverable. I'm looking at options like Ramp for the spending side but the part I'm trying to figure out is how much comes down to the software versus who still insists on approving everything. If a partner signs off on a client trip and the spend stays within that budget, I'd rather not need another email from them before the expense can move forward. I get checking exceptions but asking twice for the same decision feels unnecessary.
For those who've helped clean this up at a boutique, what made a difference? Interested in changes that saved the team time after the first month when everyone stopped paying attention to the rollout.


r/consulting • • 20h ago

Developing Critical Thinking & Rigour as a Junior

21 Upvotes

Hi all,

Does anyone have tips on how to develop critical thinking as a junior? What I mean by this is going through the reps of thinking what should go onto a slide, building a model, etc.

I find it hard to carve time to truly sit down and think through the problem / task at hand. My seniors expect tasks to be delivered much faster through AI. AI is great, but I don’t want to atrophy my brain or find out in a few years that I do not have the innate “muscle” because I’ve outsourced all my thinking to LLMs. I will try to fact check the output, think about how to improve on it etc, but I am worried about not developing depth in my analysis.

At the moment, I typically use free periods (eg weekends, at the end of the day) to re-examine the tasks I’ve worked on and try to reverse engineer it, but this doesn’t feel like the most efficient method. If anyone has any tips on how to build this rigour in spite of AI, I would love to learn more :) thank you!


r/consulting • • 1d ago

Has anyone successfully "demoted" themselves?

31 Upvotes

Im a director at a boutique. I was an internal promote for one job but they slide me into a predominantly BD role after year. I hate this role. I honestly hate the company but the market has been a nightmare and I've had more than one offer pulled due to funds and others have bait and switched me for way less money than I agreed to (im fine with a pay cut for peace of mind but not when told one thing then offered another) or a different position than I applied to.

Point is I can't keep up the bullshit changing goalposts with a VP that has the personal skills of Patrick Bateman. So I've thought about demoting myself until I find another job but I know it could be a big problem.

Thoughts?


r/consulting • • 14h ago

Inverto SEA

0 Upvotes

Hi all, in the final stages of interview with Inverto SEA (BCG)and wanted to understand what the company culture is like. Would like to understand what the difference from core BCG vs Inverto from a comp and overall exits POV?


r/consulting • • 1d ago

Where do you find the time and energy to leave

112 Upvotes

Been at a B4 strategy firm for the last 2-3 years since undergrad. Recently been through an absolute grind of projects and feeling the burn worse than ever. Not able to do the things I need to take care of myself physically. Feels like all my free time on the weekend is spent just trying to rest up for the next week.

I think overall I’ve realized just this work, and more importantly this lifestyle, is not for me. I can do it, I perform, but I’m not happy by any stretch of the imagination. Time to leave for some internal role for hopefully not a huge paycut and have some WLB I guess.

But where do people find the time and energy to even leave? How do you network and put time and care into applications and prep while working 80+ a week? Just feeling like there’s no light at the end of the tunnel here. The thought of replacing my little free time with more work (leaving) is depressing. But guess it’s the only way out?

Curious how others have managed in similar situations.


r/consulting • • 2d ago

Should moving into industry feel easier?

48 Upvotes

Hi all-

I recently left a manager level role (EM/PL/M) at MBB for a Senior Director role within a PE-back CPG company. I'm about a month and a half in and have been surprised how challenging I am finding it...the hours haven't been terrible, but I feel like I am stumbling constantly to understand the company (somewhat new sector for me) and meet the mark on work quality (e.g., materials getting told they lack depth/rigor, not enough turn time to QC things leading to mistakes, navigating complicated politics).

I was a high performer in consulting for the most part so wondering if this is an outlier or on me versus a common experience - would love to hear other peoples' experiences!!


r/consulting • • 3d ago

Why are we pretending we care about efficiency now?

355 Upvotes

Did we not all just spend 40 years of our lives sitting in meetings where we discuss font selection in slide decks nobody would ever look at?

I thought we were all on the same page about this.

Nobody was saying it aloud, but I just assumed that, deep inside, we all knew that America had exported all of its jobs out of the country and now we were all just doing made up bullshit to pass the time.

We're we not all thinking that? It can't just have been me.

So why in the world are we all of a sudden obsessed with doing it faster?

Good God, it's a footrace to nowhere. What does it matter how fast we go?


r/consulting • • 2d ago

Advice

3 Upvotes

I work at a consulting firm and it feels that no matter what I do, I do everything wrong. My boss gave me a midyear review in October and stated that I didnt meet a goal that was never communicated to me. I have made mistakes and have always done my best to fix them but now close to a year in, I am constantly told that everything I do takes me too long or that what I've done was unnecessary or I did it wrong and I have to apply all the time to training. Moreover, if work has to be redone it is done by the PM so I never get a chance to learn by trial and error. Whats even more frustrating is that the principal is billing over half the budget and the PM is also billing, which means when there is budget I am being scrutinized for how I use the time. I'm so over it! The principal isn't bringing in enough work either. On top of that, all the work that I do ends up being put under a training code that looks like I'm not productive. It's not even being put towards a non-billable code towards the project. Its literally going towards a training code which I believe does not get recovered anywhere else. My UT% is in the teens. I want to leave but am scared that they will give me a bad reference if I had to out either one down. I don't know what to do. Any advice from anyone ia greatly appreciated.


r/consulting • • 2d ago

Are consultants good startup founders?

37 Upvotes

As a strategy consultant one gets an array of business-related skills. But do those make you good at running a start-up?

Curious to hear opinions and stories out there?


r/consulting • • 3d ago

Joined a senior corporate strategy role 1 month ago, major leadership shakeup, potential layoffs. How would you handle this?

24 Upvotes

Looking for advice from people who've navigated executive leadership changes shortly after joining a company.

Background: Former MBB consultant, now working in corporate strategy in financial services. About six weeks ago, I left a stable role at one firm to take a more senior strategy position at another. Significant increase in compensation, broader responsibilities, and what looked like a great career move.

The situation: Within weeks of joining, the senior executive leading my division was unexpectedly replaced. The new leadership team is coming in, bringing some of their own people, and reevaluating the organizational structure.

My immediate boss is well-regarded, has substantial tenure, and seems reasonably well-positioned, but there's uncertainty about what the new organization will look like. My team has been somewhat sidelined from planning discussions recently, and there are rumors that restructuring and layoffs could happen imminently.

I have no direct indication my specific position is being eliminated, but given that I'm a relatively expensive, newly hired strategy executive without established relationships with the incoming leadership, I don't love my odds if significant cuts happen.

The complication: A recruiter from another major FI reached out unsolicited a few days ago about a potentially interesting role. I haven't responded yet.

I'm torn between wanting to protect myself and not wanting to look like someone who's already trying to leave a job six weeks after starting. I'm especially conscious of the reputational implications at this level.

If I engage with the recruiter, I'm inclined to be upfront that I recently joined a new company but that unexpected leadership changes have created uncertainty around my position. I don't want to exaggerate the risk or appear desperate, but I also think that's a more credible explanation than pretending I'm casually considering another move so soon.

A few questions:

  1. Has anyone experienced a major leadership change or restructuring immediately after joining a senior role? How did it play out?

  2. Would you proactively start looking now, or wait for more clarity?

  3. How would you handle the recruiter conversation? Would you disclose the uncertainty or keep things vague?

  4. At the director/VP level, how damaging is a tenure of just a few months if the circumstances are genuinely outside your control?

I'm not unhappy with the role itself and would prefer to stay if the situation stabilizes. Just trying to balance protecting my career with not overreacting to rumors.


r/consulting • • 4d ago

"You don't have a plan until I approve it." - Is this a client red flag?

62 Upvotes

So I do operations consulting. I just got a new client and part of my process is employee interviews. I've gone and and done that and have the feedback I needed to do an analysis and develop the next steps.

I got on a call with the owner today to schedule time to go over the analysis. While speaking to him I said "I want to get on the same page so we can present this to leadership. I have a pretty good plan..."

He cuts me off and says, "You don't have a plan until I see it an approve it."

This caught me off guard. I was able to reiterate that of course I want him to see it. I've only been consulting for 2 years now, but this feels like a red flag.

One of the most common complaint among staff is how controlling this owner is.

I've have built in cancellation policy in my contract and I also have now added a note in the analysis that if me and the owner cannot align on what is the best plan of action it may be worth a conversation to see if it is worth moving forward.

Is there anything else I should do to protect myself?


r/consulting • • 5d ago

Story time: Contract expiration

13 Upvotes

Figured you guys would appreciate this one from a few years ago when I started my own consulting biz for the first time.
I didn’t know what I was doing on the biz ops side for the most part. I had boiler plate contracts and rate sheets that I used when I got new business.
I landed an Ivy League school as a client and they wanted to buy a bucket of hours to draw from as needed. They paid up front which was amazing. As I was working through contracts with their legal and contracts team, THEY had me modify my contract to include a 1 year expiration on the hours they purchased. I had retained a law firm just for a 2nd set of eyes so I had them review everything and they gave me the green light.
Started out great. They were burning about 120 hours a month. After a few months, their requests started slowing down and I began checking with them on their burn rate. They had competing priorities, escalations etc and admitted they couldn’t devote the time to working with me so I stood down. The last 3.5 months of the contract, they consumed 0 hours and stopped responding to my emails altogether except the project owner who said they’d come back to me the following cal year.

The following May, he schedules time with me to discuss new projects. I was stoked. So we discuss the work and the number of hours they wanted and all that. So I come back a few days later and being the new biz owner and all-around nice guy that I am, I have them the unused hours from the previous year at a 40% discount. Then the rest of the hours at full price.

This douche comes back and challenges me that he doesn’t want to pay for the discounted hours and that I should just carry those over. I told him his hours expired and I couldn’t do that. He also said this in a rude manner and I was put off by the attitude. He said he’d take legal action.

I immediately reached out to my attorney who reviewed everything again and was like, “This university is just trying to bully you. You can legally tell them to fuck off.”

So I went back and told him to let me know what his legal team said and he never responded. That was the end of that relationship.

Looking back, should I have eaten the hours that they didn’t use? Maybe? I just stood more on principle, I guess.

What would you folks do?

Thx for reading!


r/consulting • • 5d ago

Client said there were no concerns, then criticized my work after the project ended

84 Upvotes

I recently completed a 7 month consulting engagement. About a month before it ended, my team leader directly asked the client whether they had any concerns. The client said no.

During the final in person phase, the client shifted from warm and engaged to noticeably distant towards me, communicating only when necessary and avoiding eye contact. Still, no concerns about my work were raised, even though my team leader was onsite and available to address any concerns.

After the project ended, the client said I had not taken enough ownership and that they did not receive the value they expected. By then, I had no opportunity to clarify expectations or correct anything.

I understand that consultants are responsible for maintaining alignment. But when a client is directly asked and says there are no concerns, what responsibility does the client have to raise dissatisfaction while it can still be addressed?

How do you protect yourself from being blindsided by end-of-project feedback?


r/consulting • • 6d ago

Why are there no Chinese consulting brands? I bet those STEM Chads can actually be useful?

28 Upvotes

Literally the title


r/consulting • • 6d ago

Seeking a little advice

34 Upvotes

I run a solo GIS (geographic information system) firm, basically mapping data, doing data analysis, building pipelines, and web apps.

I have one major client where I’m the solo guy on the project and I have a lot of free time. I’m trying to grow my firm and looking to expand my network. My main connection has come through word of mouth with civil firms.

Most GIS firms win contracts with local, state, and federal government. Which i have submitted on previously. I would love to build a better lead pipeline, I would love to hear how you guys build your current lead pipelines for B2B and B2C sales. From finding your ideal client to scaling to multiple. Open to correction and advice!

Btw I’ve been a consultant for firms for the last 7 years and i have worked on multiple projects at a time. So I’m very good with workload management.


r/consulting • • 8d ago

Left my consulting job to start my own consulting firm – looking for advice on getting the first clients and scaling

104 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
A few months ago, I made the decision to leave my job at an established consulting company and start my own consulting business. I’d love to hear some advice from people who have been through something similar.

A bit of background:
I have a pharmaceutical background, with experience in pharmaceutical MES. My approach is to combine practical pharmaceutical manufacturing knowledge with technical MES expertise, rather than looking at digital transformation purely from an IT perspective.

But:
I’m currently the only person in the company. I have one client secured, which gives me a starting point, but I obviously don’t want to build a business around a single client.
Finding clients, building a sales pipeline, positioning the company, managing cash flow, and eventually hiring people are all new territory…

Question: If you started your consulting business from scratch again (or worked for brand new company), what would you do differently?
Thanks!


r/consulting • • 8d ago

Why should you consider corporate strategy post MBB?

81 Upvotes

5+ years at MBB and learnt about a few strategy roles in industry (eg Director / Senior Director at an FI). Next level up would be Partner but the road appears quite uncertain, not sure how strong the pull is, don’t feel high levels of belonging. When exploring exits, what’s the appeal for corporate strategy roles? Sounds like it will require a pay cut for better work life balance but don’t want a ceiling on wealth potential. Is there a dream exit, that’s not tech? North America.


r/consulting • • 7d ago

7 Years as Data Scientist at MBB - what next?

17 Upvotes

Wanted to get this community's thoughts on something. I've been working as a Data Scientist at MBB in Toronto for last 5 years (2 years in Asia in similar role). It was my first data science job but not my first job. Previously I was an engineer in energy sector for 6 years.

I have been making steady progress for last 5 years in Toronto in this role but also feeling a bit burnt out with the usual: long hours, deadlines, just overall stress. Looking for suitable exit opportunities. Would prefer to stay in Toronto, and preferably move into tech space, or industry (my experience is mainly pharma/life sciences). I am currently a Principal Data Scientist

My experience has been traditional predictive modelling, and storytelling with data, with extensive client and business stakeholder exposure. Have recently worked on GenAI solutions as well, so have exposure to that too, although not as much as traditional machine learning.

What are some good avenues to explore in terms of good pay and work life balance? I am 35, with 7 YOE in Data Science. I want to continue doing something in that space, maybe IC roles or maybe leading small teams/data department. Don't really have grand ambition of running a big team or something.


r/consulting • • 8d ago

BCG under scrutiny from UK tax authorities over partner pay

Thumbnail
afr.com
63 Upvotes

r/consulting • • 9d ago

Back to boutique consulting after a few years... is it just now AI all the time?

67 Upvotes

I've worked a few years in a small consulting firm and then the development sector (before the AI era), but now my unemployed ass is applying to a lot of places, one of them is a boutique firm focused on decarbonization. I have learned a lot in using AI in my job search, so I am preparing my deck for the interview with the help of AI to sharpen my insight... but then I feel like my insights are not sharp at all and I'm actually just feeding a rough guess and have AI (with its massive power to gather and digest knowledge) hold my hand towards a smart "insight". Is it just gonna be like this all the time?


r/consulting • • 9d ago

Moved into consulting after 10 years in industry. How do you deal with the constant availability?

170 Upvotes

I could use some perspective, especially from people who moved into consulting later in their careers.

I spent about 10 years in supply chain management on the industry/client side and felt like I’d hit a ceiling. I wanted to move toward management, debated an MBA versus a large consulting firm, and went with consulting. I took a pretty significant step back in title and a 20%+ pay cut. I knew I was making a career change and couldn’t expect all my experience to translate directly.

I’m about three months in now, staffed on one client project, and the constant messaging is wearing me down. Requests can start at 6 a.m. and continue until 11 p.m. It’s “can you do this,” then 15 minutes later, “can you also check that,” then another message saying the client gave feedback and something else needs to take priority. Shortly after that, I’m getting asked for a status update on the thing I barely had time to start.

I can handle busy periods and occasional late nights. What’s getting to me is feeling like every hour I’m awake is potentially a work hour. I’ll think I’m wrapping up, then another request comes in, followed by a few more. Everything seems urgent, and I’m having trouble figuring out what actually needs to happen tonight versus what can wait until tomorrow.

Most of the work so far has been slide changes, chart updates, formula checks, wording edits, and updating numbers. I get that this is part of the job, and I’m happy to contribute. But between that and the hours, I’m starting to question whether this move is getting me toward the kind of work I wanted to do.

To be fair, I haven’t had a direct conversation with my manager about availability yet. Maybe some of these messages aren’t meant to be answered immediately, but the follow-ups make it feel like they are. Lately, I’ve been checking less often in the evenings and generally stop responding around 8 p.m. I’d rather set expectations openly, though, instead of just becoming less responsive and hoping they get the hint.

For anyone who’s been through this, how did you approach that conversation? Is this something you managed to work out with your lead, or does it mostly come down to which project you land on?

I’m willing to put in the effort and learn a new field. I’m just struggling with the idea that being available all day and night is the baseline expectation.


r/consulting • • 9d ago

Protecting assets from AI ingestion?

20 Upvotes

Tried searching but couldn't find a similar thread.

We've had the common problem start to ramp up that clients are taking our work product, uploading it into their own AI, and then mindlessly sending the feedback to us.

I have no issue with clients using AI to review, analyze, etc. information but the problem is what we provide to them often includes proprietary data (benchmarking, comp transaction summaries, advisory resources, etc.)

We have no control over whether they are using an enterprise model with training elections turned off, or how their own applications may be using our assets. We're updating our service agreements to include AI usage and written consent by us to try and verify this, but that's near impossible to enforce and people don't read contracts.

Is anyone else currently addressing this? Have strategies?

Are there approaches? techniques? or things we can consider including in an asset that would tip an LLM to treat an asset a certain way? Otherwise we are resorting to video delivery of assets and then white washed or redacted versions being emailed.