r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 02 '14

The Problem with Building 7 Theories

31 Upvotes

Ok, let's talk about building 7 .. in a classy way! Somehow this subject has persevered since 9/11/01 and was even the centerpiece for this year's anniversary "awareness" campaign ("Did you know a third building fell on 9/11?" billboards, etc.) My problem with building 7 theorists mainly falls into two major categories: fire fighter testimy and the misleading nature of building 7 theories.

Firefighter Testimony

Or, as I sometimes call it, Armchair Theorists vs Qualified Professionals. I've never encountered a building 7 theorist who has countered this problem in a satisfying way. I'm sure we can all agree that an argument from authority by itself is not good evidence. But in this instance we're talking about individuals trained in assessing building damage who were actually on the scene vs individuals who weren't there and probably know little about building damage. In particular I always point to Fire Chief Hayden's testimony, especially the following passage:

"Hayden: Yeah. There was enough there and we were marking off. There were a lot of damaged apparatus there that were covered. We tried to get searches in those areas. By now, this is going on into the afternoon, and we were concerned about additional collapse, not only of the Marriott, because there was a good portion of the Marriott still standing, but also we were pretty sure that 7 World Trade Center would collapse. Early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors. It came down about 5 o’clock in the afternoon, but by about 2 o’clock in the afternoon we realized this thing was going to collapse."

The day of 9/11 a large number of responders on the ground were able to observe signs of impending collapse and predicted the event before it happened which is a big problem for building 7 theorists. In fact the impending collapse was such common knowledge on the ground that it likely led to the infamous "collapse reported early by BBC". Or in other words: the lack of a conspiracy led to more theorizing!
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/february2007/280207timestamp.htm

So my question to theorists would be the following: 1) Do you find Hayden's testimony to be noteworthy/trustable? 2) If not, why? 3) If so, how do you reconcile what you're saying with what he's saying? 4) Why do you feel you're qualified to assess that building damage beyond what he assessed?

The misleading nature of Building 7 theories

The "collapse reported early" thing already touches on this .. in that these articles almost never point out that the feeling on the ground was that building 7 was coming down and that information was making its way to the media that afternoon which led to the premature reporting. There are numerous other examples but I will touch on two of them.

  1. The collapse video, like the one featured here is misleading in that you only see a small portion of the building, an undamaged portion, so that it appears like the building was almost pristine and then just collapsed. But when you start to look at other angles you can start to see various damages, like here:
    http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/WTC7Corner.jpg

  2. "Pull it" - Probably the most obnoxious thing related to this theory. Awkward wording? Ok. Conspiracy? Really? Video can be seen here. The vast majority of theorists have a problem with referencing the full quote and noting the nuances of this. The full quote below:

"I remember getting a call from the fire department commander, telling me that they were not sure they were gonna be able to contain the fire, and I said, 'We've had such terrible loss of life, maybe the smartest thing to do is pull it.' And they made that decision to pull and then we watched the building collapse."

And the nuance ... he says "it" because he's referencing the "recovery effort" and not the "people" involved in the effort which would explain why he says "pull it" and not something like "pull them".

It becomes clear that a lot of the "evidence" for this theory is either presented in a very biased manner or purposely leaves out relevant information. Such behavior leads to questionable credibility.

Why do theorists think this is some sort of game changer?


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 11 '14

A simplified explanation of objective reasoning, a key "tool" in your belt if you want to be analytical about conspiracy theories, or anything.

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

What do you guys over at /r/conspiratard think is wrong with the world?

24 Upvotes

People like me think there are powers working to create plunder of massive proportions. What I mean by that, is I think there are psychopaths with power and money, that fuck with the world on grand a scale. I think scarcity and population as a whole play a big part in the worlds problems, but a few billionaires and politicians are making it worse with their psychopathic games.

From the sound of things the users of /r/conspiratard love the way things are going in this world. They don't care about centralized power, individual liberty, privacy, or the current distribution of resources.

What I don't understand about /r/conspiratard is the motivation. You guys poke fun of people for believing in chemtrails, false flags, and grand schemes. When I hear about a new conspiracy, I am interested in it because I know humans do some crazy fucking shit. We are fully capable of almost anything, including committing a crime and framing someone else.

It seems like you guys live by Hanlon's razor,

Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

I think malice often uses stupidity as an excuse, making stupidity look like the more popular phenomenon. I think humans, even the incredibly stupid ones, often act dumber than they really are.

So, with all that said, what do you think is wrong with the world?


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 03 '14

Sovereign Citizens, Free Men on the Land, and OPCAs

23 Upvotes

This is my favorite conspiracy theory to watch.

Sovereign Citizens are a group of individuals who believe a host of strange things about the law. One of the most common is that all law is somehow contract-based -- often they'll claim that the US is a corporation, or that all US courts operate under admiralty law, which they allege (incorrectly) is entirely contract-based. Thus, by refusing to consent to jurisdiction, or "refusing the offer" of criminal charges, you can avoid legal repercussions. They love using phrases they don't understand, like "without prejudice" and the Uniform Commercial Code in general.

There's a lot of other stuff under the broad banner. Free Men on the Land (FMOTL for short) tend to focus more on strange readings of property law and get-rich-quick schemes. One of the more popular ideas here is the "straw man" -- another way of avoiding legal consequences for your actions, as well as a method of getting money. The theory is that your birth certificate represents a corporate entity, and that "shares" in your life are sold to investors elsewhere to fund the government. Your "straw man" is the only thing that is implicated in criminal cases, so you can just "sever" your straw man and walk away free. The story goes that you can get access to these funds through some complicated legal procedure. This is accompanied by some bizarre things, like the idea that spelling your name in all capital letters means it refers to a different entity altogether, or that adding random punctuation or saying that your last name is your "clan" frees you from the jurisdiction of the court.

And here's where we get to OPCAs: Organized Pseudolegal Commercial Arguments. All of that stuff I described sounds pretty complicated, right? Everything relies on weird readings of statutes you've likely never heard of, and complicated procedures ("severing" the straw man, or making the UCC filings to collect your straw-man funds, or filing quiet title actions against absentee owners). OPCAs are where this complexity comes from. Sold to the desperate and gullible, OPCAs are the complicated rituals that will supposedly free you from debt, criminal charges, and generally any laws you don't feel like following today. Some helpful "guru" has put everything you need to know about the UCC into a book, and created forms to file to get at your straw man's cash. If you have time, the Canadian decision that created the OPCA label for these tactics is an excellent read (PDF). These arguments became a lot more common during and after the recession, as a lot more desperate and unsophisticated people got pushed into court. Back in 2009-2011, I worked on more than a few foreclosure defense cases. I often saw clients who had started their foreclosure proceedings relying on OPCAs, found they did not work, and only then found the money for an attorney.

To me, the weirdest part about this is the inherent logical dissonance at the heart of these views. For instance, OPCAs will assert that the government lies and covers up all this "straw man" stuff, that lawyers are members of a foreign guild and that all law is guild law, and that judges are corrupted by the American corporation. However, they will also assert that, if you just follow these easy and official-sounding scripts full of lots of technical jargon, lawyers will obey the "real" law; the government will stop covering things up and lying; judges will apply the "real" law fairly and accurately. The existence of OPCAs relies on a concerted, hypercompetent conspiracy; the effectiveness of OPCAs relies on that conspiracy being totally incompetent. It goes much further than the "Bush could plan 9/11 but not cover it up" objection -- here, it requires that the agents of the coverup are acting illegally right up until they're called on it, and then have to throw their hands up, say "All right, you got me" and suddenly become law-abiding.

Has anyone out there run into OPCAs? Ever attempted to use arguments from the Sovereign Citizen/FMOTL movement yourself? Are there any current believers in SC/FMOTL legal theories among us?


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

Users From /r/conspiracy, What Made You Start To Believe In Conspiracies, Which Ones Do You Believe In, And Are You Still A Believer Or Not?

23 Upvotes

Something that has always intrigued me is how someone gets involved into the ideas of a conspiracy theory and gets to the position that they are in. Being a member of /r/conspiratard, I often see posts with everything running from anti-vaccination proponents, anti-GMO advocates, 9/11 Truthers, etc., and sometimes I do wonder about these people and why they started to believe in the theories that they talk about.

So, are there any stories that anyone would like to share about how they got involved, when they did and what convinced them of the proof of a conspiracy theory, etc.? Despite being a nonbeliever in conspiracy theories themselves, I'm interested in what other users have to say about their own beliefs, what convinced them, etc.


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 04 '14

Peer-review

19 Upvotes

Recently on /r/conspiracy, while advocating scientific methodology and peer-review for evaluating truth claims, I encountered pushback from several commentators that can essentially be summed up in the following argument

Scientific Methodology is at best superfluous or at worst pernicious towards one's ability to establish the veracity of a truth claim. Each individual should form his own conclusion based on his own experiences.

Now I will be the first to admit that there are certain claims that the scientific method isn't suited for merely in terms of practicality, but these cases lies almost entirely within the realm of personal day to day affairs for the individual. The problem is however that the people espousing the above viewpoint don't seek to limit such non-scientific thinking to such a remit. They see no problem making generalizations about such topics and drug efficacy, vaccine toxicity, GMO safety, chemtrails, and anthropogenic climate changes based entirely on their personal experience and then much worse, evangelizing their conclusions to other people.

I'm also not denying the current issues that are facing peer-reviewed science and journal publishing at the moment, but I don't any of the ones were currently seeing are an inherent an incorrigible part of process.

So, I guess the point of my post is to ask two questions, one for each side of the aisle on this issue.

For those skeptical of scientific methodology (an apparent contradiction, in my mind), what led you to reaching the conclusion that personal evaluation of anecdotes is a more reliable tool for evaluating truth claims?

For those more accepting of it, what do you think can cause such science denialism in a subset of a relatively educated population that has greatly benefit through the use of peer-review throughout history?


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

After seeing how r/conspiracy has reacted to this new sub I must say as someone from r/conspiratard I will keep things clean and will address claims in a mature manner.

19 Upvotes

I know /r/conspiratard has a bad rep among those at /r/conspiracy but the same is true the other way around. /r/conspiratard is a place to make a few jokes and point and laugh at a few conspiracy relate things. However if conspiracy theorists are open for an honest discussion/debate then I am all for it.

I just wanted to post this for all the /r/conspiracy users who think this will just be a big downvote fest, to let them know that we on the other side are willing to debate in a civil manner if you are as well.


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 31 '14

This subreddit is dead.

18 Upvotes

This subreddit is dead.


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 02 '14

[META] Assuming Good Faith

18 Upvotes

I made a few comments about this concept in /r/conspiracy in the past I think, but I thought it might be worth posting here... Perhaps the idea could even be incorporated into the sidebar in some way?

Basically it's this: This sub will work best if we all assume good faith from other users

One of the most unpleasant parts of /r/conspiracy is the tendency of many people to assume those with differing opinions are lying, or deluded, or shills..

If we assume the people we're talking to are genuine and have good intentions - that they are posting in good faith - then it can positively color our interactions.

I think we should all try to do assume good faith and, ideally, such an approach should be promoted as the ideal in this sub.

(Assuming Good Faith is a core principle of Wikipedia)


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 01 '14

Twenty police-state/collapse predictions for 2013 by Natural News [What does a natural health website run by a scientologist have to do with conspiracies anyways?] which never came true.

Thumbnail
conspiracies.skepticproject.com
18 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 31 '13

9/11 - No Planes (September Clues etc)

17 Upvotes

I'm slightly fascinated by what I see as the extreme craziness of the no-planes theories proposed by the likes of Simon Shack (September Clues) and Ace Baker (The Great American Psy-Opera)...

If you're not familiar with these ideas and have A LOT of spare time, you could watch the 90-minute-long September Clues or Chapters 6 and 7 of The Great American Psy-Opera

Does anyone here buy into any of this stuff? It's bizarre to me, as someone who's worked in video and TV, that anyone believes any of this.


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 30 '13

January 4th 2014, Planetary Alignment Decreases Gravity. Float For 5 minutes! – This is the type of pseudoscience you can't help but laugh at.

Thumbnail
news-hound.net
17 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 07 '14

Fact-checking r/conspiracy

16 Upvotes

Gentlemen from r/conspiracy, please do something about grossly misleading and patently false titles and "facts" submitted to your sub.

As of the moment of writing this an article named "Marijuana: So Evil, the U.S. Gov’t Owns the Patent “Cannabinoids as Antioxidants and Neuroprotectants”" which links to this article at dailysheeple sits at +504 on yourfrontpage.

I took the two-click effort to read the article and see the patent application.

There were two especially interesting sentences in the patent application

The method of claim 1, wherein the cannabinoid is nonpsychoactive.

and

The method of claim 15, wherein the cannabinoid is not a psychoactive cannabinoid.

And not a single comment saying anything other than "big pharma killing our natural medicine, maaaaaaaan"

I've messaged the mods there, so we'll see if anything comes from it.

EDIT:

from AssuredlyAThrowAway

Hi, THC is one of more than 70 active compounds in the cannabis plant. I fail to see why you believe that the absence of psychoactive cannabinoids in the patent would somehow imply the US government does not own the marijuana patent in question.

The patent in question being about administering cannabinoids and not giving patients a prescription "smoke weed erriday, neffew"


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 31 '13

[Suggestion] Sticky-posted list of all banned users on this sub

16 Upvotes

Pretty self-explanatory. In keeping with the "mindset" of the sub, I think it would be a good idea to have a stickied post that would be regularly updated with the usernames of people who are banned. In terms of format, it'd be a simple list along the lines of:

thisuser (12/31) (modname) -- threatened to kill someone for supposedly shilling for the NWO.

Thatuser (12/30) (modname) -- turned out to be reincarnated Hitler; posted anti-Semitic comments.

So--username, date of ban, mod's username, and reason. The last two would be optional, although strongly encouraged (especially the reason).

This would help promote transparency on the sub and would probably help with future accusations of unfair bans (from either end of the spectrum). Oh, and it'd also be kind of interesting.

What to you guys think?


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 01 '14

Obama: "There continues not to be evidence that the [metadata surveillance] program had been abused." Guardian insists that this is false.

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
15 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 31 '13

On Invasions and the Deletion of History...

15 Upvotes

http://www.sunnyskyz.com/blog/28/An-Ancient-City-Is-Discovered-Underwater-What-They-Found-Will-Change-History-Forever

In this article they claim they found something that COULD be a "new rosetta stone." I find new archaeological discoveries such as this extremely fascinating. They discovered another ancient egyptian city, thst has been underwater for 1500 yrs (so they say.)

Anyhow, i decided to take this as an opportunity to share a theory of mine to you guys. I have always been suspiscious of western invasions as having some alternate motive. In fact, plenty of invasions, i feel, have a common motive.

Often times, when one empire invades another, part of their plundering involves the destruction and burning of the latters librarys and books. Precious artefacts become booty for the victor. I can reference the Library of Alexandria in egypt, and the texts of the incas and other south american indians when the conquistidores all but wiped them out.

I was intrigues to find out, that when the US and her allies invaded iraq, there were simultaneously reports of libraries and museums being ransacked. The interesting thing about that is, most of the relics were left alone. The perpetrators, wearing microphones in a coordinated action, seemed to be after something more precious--the written word, ancient texts. The authorities wrote it off as a mob induced hysteria, i believe, but usually during flash mobs and whatnot, there is no microphones, no coordination, and they grab everything they can of any value. I have a suspicioin, and i admit, i am speculating on this, that the invasions of the US and her allies in recent memory have been focused on gathering ancient knowledge and texts. Oil and WMDs are used as distractions, as the information in these texts can prove to be more valuable, or evem prove to he detrimentsl to their agenda by uprooting their "established and accepted history" they sell to us nowadays.

Like the knights of the holy crusades, i feel our government is hunting down any word thst may be against what is currently accepted as historic fact, inborder to suppress the knowledge of an alternate history.

I included this link above for your perusal, and if america suddenly decides egypt is next for invasion, or wherever these new discoveries end up, then you heard it here first.

Again, this is speculation. Lets discuss these possibilities, whether you believe it or not, just be respectful and explain why. I find this all very interesting. Thanks!


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

How 'gamed' do you think reddit is? (post from /r/conspiracy within)

15 Upvotes

Saw this post today. Much of it seems like a commentary on /r/conspiracy to me. Seems like every other day, a thread is brought forth from somewhere else on reddit that had a lot of upvotes but got removed. To me- this could just be moderation at work rather than some sinister plan. Having modded many subreddits, I have never once gotten the impression that my fellow mods were removing content because of some conspiratorial prerogative to do so. But maybe I am naive/oblivious. Any thoughts on this?


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 03 '14

Are we really as bad as 1984?

14 Upvotes

I often hear about how the USA has become so corrupt that we have finally reached Orwell's nightmare, even Snowden came out and said that we had exceeded what is portrayed in the books. In my opinion what has been released and verified does not come close to the novel so I have to ask to the theorists out there are we really at that level? And if so is it just what has been exposed by Snowden and other leaks as fact or is there more that is going on that we haven't had released yet?


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

What is your default presumption?

14 Upvotes

People are biased, let's admit it. When assessing the claims of conspiracists, my base presumption comes from Hanlon's Razor and, of course, Occam's.

Others here must have different basic assumptions. How do you approach new information, and how do you evaluate claims?


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

In all seriousness and with respect, what do members of r/conspiracy think of logical fallacies?

14 Upvotes

Here's the list of logical fallacies - https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com

I'm curious as to what members of r/conspiracy think about logical fallacies. In the past, I'd be more likely to satirize your apparent lack of knowledge regarding logical fallacies, but considering that this awesome new sub exists as a neutral zone for us to garner more knowledge about each other, I'd like to posit the topic for civil and intelligent discussion.

Thank you to members of both r/conspiracy and r/conspiratard and to u/solidwhetstone for setting up this sub. Hopefully we can work through and remove the stigma of SRD that surrounds both of our subs.

Have a pleasant weekend and a very happy New Year's!


r/conspiratocracy • • Feb 18 '14

Can /r/conspiratocracy Be Revitalized?

13 Upvotes

Just a question, as I enjoyed it a bit here during the early days; obviously content has dried up recently to talk and debate over, but I'd like to know what the opinions are of anyone that is still here currently.


r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 03 '14

Conspirators, is there any instance of a mass killing that WASN'T done by the government?

13 Upvotes

When conspirators are claiming that everything from the Oklahoma City Bombing to the Aurora Shooting was done because the government was controlling someone or whatever, that eliminates almost any instance of someone snapping and killing others. So do conspirators just believe that people never go crazy, or what?


r/conspiratocracy • • Dec 29 '13

Where does everyone think /r/conspiracy will land on rule 1?

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
13 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 10 '14

I think this article addresses perfectly, the reasons for conspiracy theory and the reason why people are so against it.

Thumbnail
alternet.org
12 Upvotes

r/conspiratocracy • • Jan 06 '14

Michael Springman, hijackers passports and censorship!!

12 Upvotes

This article was posted in /r/worldnews... Unsurprisingly it was deleted - /r/conspiracy unsurprisingly sees a conspiracy in that deletion... And, of course the story was also popular in there...

So let's talk about Michael Springman....

He issued visas (not passports) in the Riyadh consulate for about 18 months in the late 80's - during that time he claims he was instructed by superiors to issue visas to unqualified applicants that he subsequently claims were Mujahideen fighters being trained/sponsored by the CIA.

Clearly the timeframe doesn't work for 9/11 so the connection to 9/11 ends there - even if his account is absolutely accurate there's no chance he issued the visas for any of the 9/11 hijackers 12+ years before the event.

But could it demonstrate the existence of a CIA program that may have been in place a decade later when the hijackers were issued visas?

Sure, I guess, but more likely it had to do with the fact that during the timeframe in question the US, Saudi Arabia and others were funding and supporting the Mujahideen in their fight against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan.

And seriously - passports aren't visas - it's amazing how frequently that mistake is made the reports of this story.