25
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
I fully expect to be banned for this, but whatever.
No one's asking for an apology for slavery. Slavery's done and gone.
What people want is for peolpe to acknowledge that not did slavery happen, but it was followed by a hundred years of KKK terrorism, Jim Crow laws and another 55 years of police brutality and targeted abuse.
Just an acknowledgement that after all these years of direct oppression and abuse, that maybe we need to dial back the militarized police and maybe make some effort to help the minority community catch up to the rest of America.
I am NOT saying that all white people are racist. Most are not.
I am NOT saying that all police are horrible power-tripping monsters who enjoy killing people. Most are not. Too many sit back and watch and let it happen, but I won't get into that here.
I am NOT saying that you personally are responsible for the oppression of blacks and other minorities. You, personally, are not. But you're part of a system that DOES do that on the regular.
I don't think that all of you are racist, but some racists do post here.
What you can and should do is call it out. If you're doing that, then great, you're an awesome American.
Because at the end of the day, these people, all of these people that are getting killed in the streets are AMERICANS and you should stand up with them, side by side, and demand better for Americans.
If only because, one day it might be you on the ground, struggling to breathe as a cop kneels on your neck and three other cops stand and watch you die.
Downvote me, ban me. Do as you will.
15
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
When you are asking for reparations for slavery...you are asking people who did not do the thing, to pay those who did not suffer from it.
People have also lost all sense of perspective. I'm seeing too many say that America is a rotten country that was founded on suffering and exploitation. There are lots of countries that shared the sins of America. In our remarkably short history we have worked together to self-correct the wrongs of the past. But there is a "no forgiveness, no mercy" mindset now. If we are all still guilty of the sins of the past, what point is there going-forward to try to work for greater justice? If thirty years from now another unforgiving horde is going to scream that you never did anything right?
But you're part of a system that DOES do that on the regular.
"Part of a system". Most of us here aren't really all that keen on government in general. We recognize that there are some things the government is charged with and some things that it does fairly well...but WE HAVE BEEN SKEPTICAL of the system for a long time.
We also know that this "system" has been working to better itself, something that the left's grievance mongers never recognize.
And when y'all have an anarcho communist community that has SECEDED from the USA in Seattle and this corrupt media is ignoring it and whitewashing the situation, pardon us if we say, "Da frikk?"
but some racists do post here
If you see racist content here, report it. We ALWAYS take action. Without exception.
If only because, one day it might be you on the ground, struggling to breathe as a cop kneels on your neck and three other cops stand and watch you die.
Everyone I know watched the Floyd tape and knew that it was wrong and that the police messed up. We have more cameras on cops. More programs to help them police BETTER.
Downvote me, ban me. Do as you will.
Do you admit that this meme is correct or no?
0
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
When you are asking for reparations for slavery
Reparations would never happen. But I'm not talking about those. I'm talking about community assistance, more college help, more jobs programs, tax incentives for companies to open up in black communities, things like that.
6
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Infernalism I don't know who you think you are zooming.
You know better and I know you know better.
https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/502582-california-lawmakers-advance-reparations-bill
And what's next?
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/14/opinion/gay-reparation-stonewall.html
Perhaps you've lost touch with your leftist community members and don't know what is happening?
tax incentives for companies to open up in black communities
I just need to say it.
This is going to be a challenge if communities seem keen to occasionally loot and burn businesses.
8
u/HappyNihilist Jun 13 '20
The issue here is that you can pump all the money you want into a community but nothing will improve unless the community is safe and more specifically safe to do business in. This would tend to require more police not less. However, demilitarizing the police force is not a bad idea.
1
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
The issue here is that you can pump all the money you want into a community but nothing will improve unless the community is safe and more specifically safe to do business in. This would tend to require more police not less. However, demilitarizing the police force is not a bad idea.
Chicken or the Egg? What came first? Oppressive policing and things like Red-lining and White Flight?
It's pointless to look for what started it, but what happens now is that heavily armed police are obviously not the solution to minority communities not having any jobs or colleges or serious help beyond creating Section-8 housing and putting everyone on welfare.
Personally, I think we need UBI, look it up, and not welfare. Something for everyone. it's also called a negative Income Tax.
We need a new nuanced approach to impoverished and neglected communities. Fewer guns and more specialists.
Of course, you don't send a domestic abuse expert to a spot where guns are being waved around, but many DA calls don't involve weapons, just arguing people.
5
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Personally, I think we need UBI
Socialism. The issue here is...and we ALL KNOW it: Some folks don't need help from the government. Other folks do.
So you do this UBI. We all know what happens, soon "I got the UBI, but I ran out of money for food"...then you get UBI-augmentation programs".
2
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
Socialism.
We've had socialism since the 1950s. Medicare and Medicaid and Social Security.
So you do this UBI. We all know what happens, soon "I got the UBI, but I ran out of money for food"...then you get UBI-augmentation programs".
Nah, the whole idea is to provide ONE stipend to cover all needs. If you run out, there are food pantries across the country to help.
And it wouldn't be the same for everyone, it'd be built around the cost of living for wherever you are.
1
2
u/HappyNihilist Jun 14 '20
And don’t forget we’ll also get all the town criers who will whine about how this person made $200 million last year AND got free money from the government. “They don’t deserve it. Rabble rabble rabble”
→ More replies (1)1
u/HappyNihilist Jun 13 '20
Chicken or the Egg? What came first? Oppressive policing and things like Red-lining and White Flight?
I want to note that redlining was practiced by the Federal housing administration, a government agency set up to try and fix the inequities of the past by giving loans to people who were unable to get loans from traditional banks.
It’s pointless to look for what started it, but what happens now is that heavily armed police are obviously not the solution
This is false. The answer IS more police. Maybe not such a heavily armed police but more police to create stability in these communities which would then allow businesses to operate and money to flow into these areas.
Personally, I think we need UBI, look it up, and not welfare. Something for everyone. it’s also called a negative Income Tax.
Getting rid of welfare as it is set up today is not a bad idea. There’s no reason we need 1000 different programs to give poor people money with 1000 different sets of rules to get the money and 1000 different administrative offices to hand out that money. We should be able to give money to people who need it and let them spend it how they choose, but once the money runs out they shouldn’t be able to come back and ask for more. We definitely do not need UBI though. Because people of all income levels do not need a government handout.
2
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
We definitely do not need UBI though. Because people of all income levels do not need a government handout.
Don't think of it as a handout so much as a means to keep the economy growing. It's the masses and their spending that is the grease and fuel for the economic engine.
What UBI/NIT does is ensure that money is out there, being spent 'and' it frees up the masses to start new businesses without the fear of complete economic ruination if the business fails. More small business is absolutely the solution to the mega-corporation and the power that they hold over the government.
2
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Money that you want to give people to spend does not come from nothing.
Money comes from people WORKING...and NOT for the government.
A government employee gets their wages from the taxpayer...when they in turn SPEND that money it's essentially the economy drinking its own pee.
UBI is money FROM the taxpayers.
-1
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
When you are asking for reparations for slavery.
No one is seriously asking for reparations. It'd be in the trillions and it'd destroy the country's economy. NO ONE WANTS THAT.
But, it'd be nice to give them more help to get up out of the economic hole that they've been in since slavery was abolished.
People have also lost all sense of perspective. I'm seeing too many say that America is a rotten country that was founded on suffering and exploitation.
Some people enjoy being dramatic. ignore them. We have them on both sides.
Most of us here aren't really all that keen on government in general.
Perhaps, but you DO enjoy the benefits that government brings. Stability and order and safety. Believe it or not, that's all that black communities want, as well.
as for the CHAZ people? They're a bunch of pampered progressive extremists. No one supports them except for the radicals who want to see the country collapse.
6
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
No one is seriously asking for reparations.
BULLSHIT!
https://www.newsweek.com/joe-biden-wants-see-studies-about-feasibility-slavery-reparations-1510096
WHO do you think you are bullshitting???!!???!!!
2
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
Recognize what he's doing here and why. What do politicians do while campaigning.
5
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Don't you tell me to deny the reality in front of my own eyes.
Even if it's a pandering campaign talking point, WHY is he doing it?
The DEMOCRAT candidate for President is floating the idea of slavery reparations and you are telling me that no one seriously wants reparations.
The drumbeat for reparations has gotten louder and louder.
IF it isn't serious and you think it's wrong... looks like you need to take it up with YOUR side.
1
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
Don't you tell me to deny the reality in front of my own eyes.
Even if it's a pandering campaign talking point, WHY is he doing it?
Because he can and people who vote for him will like it.
It's like Donald Trump's Wall. It's not going to happen, he's made some paltry half-assed efforts and that's it.
It's the same thing and it'll amount to the same thing.
4
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
It's like Donald Trump's Wall.
Trump 100% MEANT to build that wall and it is being built in places.
You are trying to tell me that "no one wants reparations" and it's just bullshit.
https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/502582-california-lawmakers-advance-reparations-bill
You are telling me to deny the reality in front of my own eyes.
That's what cults do.
4
u/JPEveryday Jun 14 '20
Economic hole since slavery ? From the end of the great depression till about the mid 1950s, there was an emerging and thriving black middle class in America. Over 50% of black households were nuclear families.
The early 60s brought wide sweeping liberal led "welfare reform" which was a grass roots push to make sure blacks knew how much they were entitled to under current welfare laws of the day. Of course it was a push to overwhelm government agencies with the underlying motive to make radical political changes. It had ltitle to do with actually helping the community. (Sound familiar?)
In thirty years these policies destroyed economic progress and brought the number of single mother homes up to over 90% in the community. Childhood poverty is the single biggest indicator of commiting crimes in adulthood.
The issues we see today are not necessarily from slavery as evidenced by an emerging and strong middle class for decades post the Depression that was effectively destroyed by the rise of the welfare state.
It was liberal democrat policies that destroyed that progress.
Finally if slavery equals poor economic advancement how do West Indian immigrants who also are descendants of slavery able to come here and thrive ?
Again I urge you to read the meticulously researched work of Thomas Sowell. He puts a lot of these myths to bed.
6
u/RedBaronsBrother Potato was good. Was life. Jun 13 '20
No one is seriously asking for reparations.
Oh?
https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/14/politics/slavery-reparations-explainer-trnd/index.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/23/business/economy/reparations-slavery.html
https://www.foxnews.com/media/bet-founder-bob-johnson-slavery-reparations
https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/28/us/reparations-poll-trnd/index.html
But, it'd be nice to give them more help to get up out of the economic hole that they've been in since slavery was abolished.
You seem to be under the impression that only black people suffered from slavery in the US. Many Chinese laborers were sold to the railroads. Many Irish came to the US as indentured servants, and even free Irish were explicitly discriminated against. Somehow, Chinese Americans and Irish Americans have managed to not be in an "economic hole" after their experiences. Perhaps part of the difference is in their respective cultures.
Interestingly, the first female millionaire in the US was black, and she was the first child in her family not born a slave.
There was even a brief period where black unemployment was actually lower than white unemployment - until the unions managed to get the government to restrict government contracts to union workers (and of course, the Democrat-run unions at the time barred black members).
Of course, all that was before Democrats began "helping" minority communities.
Stability and order and safety. Believe it or not, that's all that black communities want, as well.
I absolutely believe that the majority of people in black communities want this - but as the left does with the radical extremists in general, too many in the black community turn a blind eye to the criminals in their midst, and protect them from police - and vote into office people who ensure they aren't appropriately punished when caught. It isn't an accident that black people were over half the murder victims in the US in 2018 (hint: 90% are murdered by other black people). Stability, order, and safety starts at home.
2
u/Archer60x Jun 14 '20
The black communities do need help there’s a drug problem and they also are mostly fatherless homes as I have previously stated in the comment to you
61
u/Captain___Sassy Jun 13 '20
You're in r/conservative. We don't ban people for disagreeing with us.
26
2
u/skuhlke Jun 14 '20
I’m pretty sure I’m banned for saying I liked Kasich more than Trump. Edit: nevermind I realize I’m in a much better sub reddit
1
-15
Jun 13 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
20
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
I have not seen anyone demanding an apology for slavey from individuals
What do you think that telling people they must publicly acknowledge their "white privilege" is about? What are reparations for slavery about?
→ More replies (3)1
u/USAisDyingLULZ_bot Dec 10 '20
Check out r/AntiHateCommunities. That place is a cesspool of white guilt and racism.
8
u/HappyNihilist Jun 13 '20
I appreciate your point of view and think that you have reasonable expectations. However, this is not what we are hearing from the broader progressive population.
What we are hearing is that every single white person is guilty regardless of their own personal ideas or actions because the system has been built around this oppression of blacks and other minorities and white people (and only white people) have benefited from this system.
Therefore, it is not enough for an individual person to make the choice to act in a non prejudiced way. White people must admit their guilt and comply with whatever requests are made to help tear down the old system and replace it with one that the progressives deem acceptable.
This is what I and I think many other conservatives take issue with.
0
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
I appreciate your point of view and think that you have reasonable expectations. However, this is not what we are hearing from the broader progressive population.
IGNORE THEM. Change happens in the middle and BOTH sides have radical bomb-throwers who are more concerned with attacking the other side than making real NEEDED change.
Ignore the calls that all whites are racist. That's bullshit and the protests prove that out, considering how many white people are out there getting teargassed and shot at.
Not admit THEIR guilt, but accept and acknowledge that the system has been stacked against minorities for a fucking long time, and stand with them to demand that this system be fixed.
I realize you feel attacked. Liberals get attacked too, both from the far-left and the far-right. IGNORE THEM. Recognize what they're trying to do, that being to tear us apart. THEY BOTH WANT WAR. The people in the middle have to come together to rid ourselves of the radicals and fix the system for ALL Americans.
5
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
The people in the middle
Do the people "in the middle" say things like:
I love the Israeli people, but their government is a right-wing proto-fascist government.
Fuck the police.
I do. Unless they actively fought against the Confederacy, I consider all of them, from that era, to be traitors in action or inaction.
You come here NOW wanting to have your say with the post history ...
Infernalism, who do you think you are zooming trying to pretend that you are a centrist?
→ More replies (9)32
u/ThetaMeBitch Jun 13 '20
I'm with you until the part where you want a group of people to be given special treatment.
We're equal. All colors. Races. Sexualities. Ages. Etc.
If you keep separating groups into further oppressed groups, you get to the individual.
I mean, look, the most oppressed group by data are unattractive people. And it's not even close.
So yeah. Equality is important and I fight for it. But I vehemently oppose granting special privileges based on the color of skin. Because that is the definition of racist.
I mean, should I get reparations because my ancestors didn't have slaves and therefore i'm economically disadvantaged today? What about the black people who sold Africans to white people? This goes on and on. We're all here now. Let's make it great, but not by granting special privileges to anyone based on anything other than their capabilities.
1
u/bandittr6 Jul 02 '20
Gotta love that conservative spin...
iTs RaCIsT To hElP pEOplE wItH A DiFferEnT sKin CoLOr!
1
-7
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
I'm with you until the part where you want a group of people to be given special treatment.
I realize you don't agree, but the truth is that minority communities have long been neglected and NOT gotten what white communities have got. Intentionally? I don't know, but the simple reality is that black America does NOT look like white America.
They NEED additional help. Not to get above you, but to get up alongside you. Not above.
I mean, look, the most oppressed group by data are unattractive people.
I'm sorry, but ugly people are not getting murdered in the street for being ugly.
I mean, should I get reparations
No one is seriously asking for reparations. it'd be in the trillions and would destroy the country. They all know that. But, they DO deserve extra help in recovering from it.
You deserve the extra help, too. Because, yes, if your family grew up in the South, you likely are poorer than you should be, due to the economics of slavery.
We can't speak for the slave trade, only what's happening NOW and what we can do NOW for our fellow Americans.
5
u/ThetaMeBitch Jun 13 '20
Thanks for your comments. Let's explore this a bit. Based on that logic, I shouldn't be able to find a case of a successful (defined however you like) black person who came from poverty or less than ideal conditions, right?
If you answer ''no,'' then it doesn't seem like you have a coherent argument, but I am very happy to have my view changed.
Second question, based on your logic, I shouldn't be able to find a case of an unsuccessful white person who grew up in the north either, correct?
1
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
Based on that logic, I shouldn't be able to find a case of a successful (defined however you like) black person who came from poverty or less than ideal conditions, right?
No, even those who have the deck stacked against them will see some winners. People who have the sheer determination and refusal to surrender to the stacked deck. Those with the talent at something that can't be denied.
And, likewise, even those with the best of luck and most favorable conditions can and do throw their lives away. Most Meth addicts and alcoholics do this.
It's not 100% or 0%. There's a mix there where we see fewer black success stories because the system is actively working to either see them as criminals or NFL stars.
That said, you'd see more success stories if the deck wasn't stacked against them.
11
u/ThetaMeBitch Jun 13 '20
Thank you. I respect your opinion and how well you convey it. Thank you for civility.
We differ in opinion, and that is okay. The primary difference, as I can tell, is that it is my experience that everyone who is successful, literally everyone, has ''sheer determination and refusal to surrender to the stacked deck.''
Every single person has the deck stacked against them. Everyone. And everyone who amounts to basically nothing is absolutely full of excuses. Don't get me wrong, I want to help them all. But people don't flourish by the ways being discussed. People flourish by moving their feet, accomplishing things, making progress one tiny step at a time. Great people don't become great because of privileges. They become great because they work, learn, develop themselves, study great people, demand the best from themseves, etc.
Again, that's my experience. Yours is equally valid. I hope you help create change that is lasting and makes the world better for us all, as long as you don't infringe on others or demand racist, sexist, or otherwise unfair policies to accomplish it.
3
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
The primary difference, as I can tell, is that it is my experience that everyone who is successful, literally everyone, has ''sheer determination and refusal to surrender to the stacked deck.''
I don't doubt that in the slightest. At the same time, would you agree that there are places in this country where the odds of success are severely lower and it's likely because of a lack of options. A lot fewer job options, a lot fewer stores, a lot fewer community colleges, a lot fewer ways to better themselves so that they can get out?
Every single person has the deck stacked against them. Everyone.
I look at Donald Trump and I have to disagree with that assessment.
I hope you help create change that is lasting and makes the world better for us all, as long as you don't infringe on others or demand racist, sexist, or otherwise unfair policies to accomplish it.
You could literally be one of the protesters with that bit there. Especially the 'no racist policies' thing.
I think you have more in common with them than you'd think.
5
u/ThetaMeBitch Jun 13 '20
I believe I have much in common with the protestors. It is their solutions that are generally so aweful as to be near tyrannical in the long run. People aren't reading books anymore. And I have no desire to lead the protests or the solutions anymore.
Sure, your trump example is a okay one. There are better. The rothchilds, Rockefellers, etc. Dynasty families. But dont kid yourself, Trump has a big collection of valuable skillsets. But let's not hone in on that because I dont want to dialogue about trump.
I agree that the deck isn't well stacked in certain areas. And here again: it is the proposed solutions that are poorly thought through. People are not identifying actual causal variables properly, nor do they understand the implications of their halfcocked solutions. And even worse, anyone who speaks up about any possible variables that dont fit the mainstream are losing their jobs, getting death threats, etc. And it's really madness because the people who want to discuss this and help impliment actual solutions that will work are those with their careers being threatened by saying anything that they really think.
So yes, there is huge overlap between my views and that of the protestors. We have such an incredible country that needs to be nourished and improved. But we don't accomplish that by erraticating personal agency, responsibility, the police force, using violence or threats of violence, and especially not by refusing data based conversations with people who can offer better solutions than ''fuck the police'' and similar empty and incindiary phrases.
6
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
I believe I have much in common with the protestors. It is their solutions that are generally so aweful as to be near tyrannical in the long run.
MLK said, late in his life, that he was almost convinced that the white moderate was the biggest stumbling block in the march for freedom. Those men and women who said they supported him, but did not support his methods.
I'm not accusing you of anything or disparaging you, just noting that this kind of thinking has long been a problem when dealing with systemic racial issues.
Trump has a big collection of valuable skillsets.
Maybe valuable, but not moral or honorable.
And here again: it is the proposed solutions that are poorly thought through. People are not identifying actual causal variables properly, nor do they understand the implications of their halfcocked solutions. And even worse, anyone who speaks up about any possible variables that dont fit the mainstream are losing their jobs, getting death threats, etc.
What's important is getting together to hammer out a solution that works for them. Even now, projects and efforts are made, but the funding is removed or drastically cut until nothing works. This is indicative of Republican governance. Cut funding for public programs until they stop working and then point the failed programs and say that public programs don't work.
And again, you're getting worked up over radical lunatics on the left. You have to learn to filter them out and focus on the people standing in the middle, waiting to work with you.
But we don't accomplish that by erraticating personal agency, responsibility, the police force, using violence or threats of violence, and especially not by refusing data based conversations with people who can offer better solutions than ''fuck the police'' and similar empty and incindiary phrases.
Again, you're not wrong and THANK YOU for acknowledging that the issues exist.
No one worth listening to is suggesting eradicating personal responsibility or agency. But, the police force, as we know it, is broken. They're militarized and overly aggressive thanks to the 'warrior cop' mentality that's grown up over the last twenty years. It HAS TO BE FIXED. What does that mean?
Examine what Camden NJ did and what Minneapolis is looking to do. Stop treating the job as if every call needs two guys with military hardware. "When all you have is a hammer, every problem starts looking like a nail."
Lastly, as to the hot-heads, ignore them. The right has them, the left has them, and they all need to go off into the woods and settle their issues and leave the rest of us alone.
2
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
You came into this subreddit to make a point on a particular submission and we are entertaining you.
But when you decide that this is yet another place to soapbox and platform your views, we will show you the door.
I KNOW that you have no respect for those on the right nor our views and opinions. No, Republicans do NOT cut everything and then say programs don't work. I can't think of a single program Republicans have cut since Trump was elected.
And STILL there are these riots and leftists screaming that these communities are oppressed. These are all Democrat cities in Democrat run states. But here you are trying to blame Republicans in general for everything.
You know what you DO NOT do if you really want to meet us in the middle? You don't lie about us and blame us for everything.
You are NOT in the middle. I AM in the middle.
Examine what Camden NJ did
Do you know? They fired the old cops to save money and used that money to hire MORE new cops.
https://www.businessinsider.com/camden-new-jersey-police-disbanded-but-theres-more-to-story-2020-6
→ More replies (0)6
u/ThetaMeBitch Jun 13 '20
For no other reason than time, I am not going to respond to your well written comment. Thank you again for civil dialogue fellow American. I may not agree with all of your positions, or you mine, and I may not care about and fight for the things you care about and fight for, or you mine, but that is what makes this great. There is an appeal to overall principles of free speech, free thought, non violence, and overall similar goals for big issues.
With a light hearted tone and legitimate respect, as they say in ''The Princess Bride,'' have fun storming the castle.
→ More replies (0)2
u/Archer60x Jun 14 '20
We all have a lot in common just have to show that to one another in a good way burning building is a bad way to show that to another person walking up and having a simple conversation is a good way. beating someone’s head in with a crowbar is a bad way walking up shaking hands and excepting the fact that you’re on different sides is a good way. RIOTERS do the bad things what and I disagree with them for how they handle things. Protesters are the peaceful people who don’t bash people’s heads in and slash tires. I am fine with them peacefully protesting and showing their opinion to the world in a way that doesn’t promote violence.
3
u/Archer60x Jun 14 '20
The deck ISNT stacked against them. There is this thing in the police force ( at least in my time) where minorities have an advantage in passing a test to become a police officer. A white male has to make the score of a 94 out of 100 a black male has to make a 70 out of 100 and a black female has to make a 68 out of 100 to be a police officer now tell me again how the decks are stacked against them. This is also still present in colleges. Black people don’t have to be as smart as a white person to get into a college.
1
u/Archer60x Jun 14 '20
I kind of agree with you. This is not racist but when I look at a neighborhood with the majority of the population being African American, it doesn’t look as nice as a predominantly white neighborhood. What I think we should be doing is finding a way to help black communities with their own problems. 70% of black children are born fatherless. People could set up programs to have a good father figure in their life. Some things need to change, but it isn’t white peoples fault. I just want for all people to be in a good situation.
4
u/RedBaronsBrother Potato was good. Was life. Jun 13 '20
What people want is for peolpe to acknowledge that not did slavery happen, but it was followed by a hundred years of KKK terrorism, Jim Crow laws and another 55 years of police brutality and targeted abuse.
...by the same political party that fought a war to maintain slavery because they feared Republicans would end it, which incidentally, Republicans did. ...and Republicans were then forced to pass multiple Constitutional amendments to deal with the various ways the Democrats tried to maintain de facto slavery.
Just an acknowledgement that after all these years of direct oppression and abuse, that maybe we need to dial back the militarized police...
We're right there with you on de-militarizing police, and have been calling for it for a long time. Part of the process of addressing the issues with police is ending public sector unions - something the American left has been adamant about preventing.
...and maybe make some effort to help the minority community catch up to the rest of America.
Is that not what the Civil Rights Act was about? Affirmative Action? Race-based hiring and college admission that ensure the most qualified applicants will be passed over in favor of someone with the correct race, ethnicity, or sexual preference if the two don't happen to coincide? Race based minority scholarships, financial aid, business assistance, etc., etc.,... and of late, even race-based minority justice, where "disadvantaged" criminals are allowed to commit crimes while law enforcement looks the other way.
Lets face it here - you're not asking for equality of opportunity - you're demanding superiority of outcome based on things that the people you're demanding it from had nothing to do with.
If you want the minority community to catch up to the rest of America, there are a few things it can start doing that are pretty much guaranteed to work - and they don't have anything to do with race or Affirmative Action.
Pay attention in school and graduate from high school.
Get a job.
Wait until at least age 21 before getting married.
Don't have children before marriage.
I don't think that all of you are racist, but some racists do post here.
That's what the report button is for - of course too many leftists like to report everything they disagree with as "racism", but we do our best to remove actual racists.
If only because, one day it might be you on the ground, struggling to breathe as a cop kneels on your neck and three other cops stand and watch you die.
Nobody deserves to die in that way, and it is good that the officers involved have been charged. There is a lot of information about George Floyd's death that the media hasn't been reporting, because it doesn't fit the false narrative about racist police targeting black people, and the media, and Minnesota and Minneapolis officials have been feeding that narrative rather than trying to de-escalate. End result, more people dead to the riots than the number of "unarmed black people" killed by police all of last year, plus hundreds of injured and the livelihoods of thousands of people destroyed.
Bravo. Good job. You've ensured that many of those minority neighborhoods will never recover.
4
u/JPEveryday Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
What kind of acknowledgment are you looking for?
Also the kkk and Jim crow laws are the creation of Southern democrats. Redlining policies? A direct result of FDR. Democrat.
Why won't Democrats acknowledge this?
Or is their Kente cloth kneeling stunt supposed to be their personal mea culpa?
I'm still deep into my own research as I continue the process of unraveling the false narratives and it seems like every day I find more evidence that the prevailing stories are mythical talking points based loosely on kernels of truth without context or nuance.
Please I implore you to read Thomas Sowell and start with Black Rednecks, White Liberals. Eye opening.
2
Jun 13 '20
You seem level headed so I'll say this. As a country, we can do better. Black people should not be treated any different or better than anyone else, they should be treated equal. Once people see that, the racial divide starts to go away.
Media is to blame too. I live in a city with very few black people. I can go days without seeing one and weeks with little to no interaction with one. All we see is the news showing crime, mostly murders and robberies, committed by the small population of black people who live here. So a lot of people associate that behavior with that group of people. At what point does the media take some responsibility? They have the biggest role to play in the BLM movement. The media wants to get a reaction out of people so they show this crime targeting the black community overwhelmingly more than white crime.
You're first thought is probably going to be that I'm racist and you could not be further from the truth. I have a black Opa (by marriage) that I grew up with in the 80's and 90's that I loved very much. I've raised my daughter to not see color. If we are prejudice, it's towards thugs, white or black, who are involved in crime and bullying others. We prefer not to associate with those types of people, that is not bring racist.
We need change but we need to support our policeman. Some are racists psychopaths who love the position of power they are in. Weed those out by raising the standards, more training, accountability, body cameras, requirements like residency in the area they protect. Raise their pay to get a better pool of candidates, require college degrees. But the good cops need our support and appreciation they deserve for keeping America safe.
3
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
As a country, we can do better. Black people should not be treated any different or better than anyone else, they should be treated equal. Once people see that, the racial divide starts to go away.
Yes, absolutely.
At what point does the media take some responsibility?
RIGHT NOW. They're very much responsible for the portrayal of black Americans as a 'threat.' The TV shows that portray minorities as nothing more than a threat, the movies that do the same. Again, I agree. That has to be changed NOW.
You're first thought is probably going to be that I'm racist
Incorrect, thus far we're in complete agreement.
We need change but we need to support our policeman.
Now, we disagree. Our police are out of control. They don't need military hardware or armored vehicles or grenade launchers or even Snipers in most cases. Not the local police. Maybe some small allowance can be made for State police, but otherwise, no.
We need to make them accountable and we need to dispel this idea that it's only a few of them. It's a culture-wide problem brought about by the 'warrior cop' mentality that's grown up horribly fast in the last 20 years or so.
All the rest of your stuff about the cops? I agree. The biggest problem is that good cops who fight back against the racist cops get fired or killed.
You're a conservative and I'm not and We Are In Agreement on 99% of the stuff.
3
Jun 13 '20
You might be right but from what I see on the news these cops are dealing with violent people who aren't afraid to kill a cop. There's no way you can expect them to patrol an area with heavy gang activity without a gun. Gangs fight back now, imagine if they knew the police weren't armed. They'd go to work everyday knowing they can't defend themselves. And it's possible that they are increasing their tactics because of the rise in crime in certain areas. Where I live, I've never seen a cop draw his weapon. When people come in contact with the police, they don't resist and they're usually overly polite in hopes of getting out of a ticket. I'm sure police brutality goes on here but I'd say it's geared more towards thugs than just black people.
People who are conservatives are viewed as racist for the things I'm pointing out. People like to be around people with similar interests. I don't really have any black friends but if someone liked to hike or had an interest in traveling, I wouldn't care what the color their skin was.
Glad we could have a civil conversation. I try this in r/politics and I get blasted. Little do they realize I agree with them on several issues, just not enough to keep me from leaning right. No big deal, we just have a difference in opinions on topics that will always have two sides.
4
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
You might be right but from what I see on the news these cops are dealing with violent people who aren't afraid to kill a cop.
Yes, I'm sure you see that a lot. Think about that.
There's no way you can expect them to patrol an area with heavy gang activity without a gun.
You're absolutely right, but NOT EVERY CALL is going to involve gang violence. And the gangers RUN when the cops come around. These are American communities, not the 'no-go' zones that Fox News rants about.
I'm sure police brutality goes on here but I'd say it's geared more towards thugs than just black people.
but, we haven't seen that, have we? We've just seen civilians, working men and women, get murdered.
That black lady was killed in her own bed, sleeping
2
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
We've just seen civilians, working men and women, get murdered.
What?
You have some outlying cases where cops did a bad job OR were obviously criminally wrong.
And you are trying to say that day to day police only murder civilians and working men and women?
3
u/Infernalism Jun 13 '20
And you are trying to say that day to day police only murder civilians and working men and women?
Only? No. But are the vast majority of murders done in cold blood in the street for little to no reason at all? Yes.
3
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Let me make this clear to you...it is NOT true to say "Cops are murdering civilians in the streets." That is a generalization that does a disservice to the vast majority of cops who honorably serve.
You want to come to the center and discuss? Do it honestly.
3
Jun 13 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
6
2
u/AntiObnoxiousBot Jun 21 '20
I want to let you know that you are being very obnoxious and everyone is annoyed by your presence.
I am a bot. Downvotes won't remove this comment. If you want more information on gender-neutral language, just know that nobody associates the "corrected" language with sexism.
People who get offended by the pettiest things will only alienate themselves.
4
1
u/Kgwalter Jun 13 '20
I agree, I have yet to meet anybody asking for an apology for slavery. Just action to fully recover from it, which let’s be honest, we haven’t. On a side note I was in the Marine Corps stationed in Japan. While there I visited peace park in Hiroshima. Basically a park memorializing the people lost in the bomb and a large portion of it was dedicated to acknowledging their mistake. While I was visiting I had many people approach me and apologize for Pearl Harbor. I was 21 years old and Pearl Harbor was long long before I was born. I was visiting where our country dropped an atomic bomb and Japanese people were apologizing to me. The difference between Japan and us is Japan acknowledged their mistake, chose to try to correct it and apologize. We in the United States whitewash history and act like the past doesn’t matter because it’s the past even though we have not fully recovered from the past.
3
u/HitEmWithAHardRKappa Jun 13 '20
They didn’t need to apologize to you. That’s our entire point. They did nothing wrong, and I hope to god you let them know that. No one dismisses slavery, but no one in the US today was a slave or slave master, so why should we be punished or anyone else be rewarded simply because of their skin color?
→ More replies (1)0
u/Kgwalter Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
I did, and you completely missed my point. And you are wrong. One of the apologies did come from somebody that’s served in the war for Japan. Who is punishing you? Who is trying to punish you? How are you a victim? This whole meme is creating a narrative that I personally don’t think exists, and if it does it’s very minimal.
Edit: although no white person was a slave owner a lot of white people still benefit from slavery in the past while a lot of black people are still feeling the negative effects of that period in time. That’s not to say you deserve anybody an apology, a simple acknowledgement is all I see being requested.
2
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
although no white person was a slave owner a lot of white people still benefit from slavery in the past
And...
This whole meme is creating a narrative that I personally don’t think exists, and if it does it’s very minimal.
How to contradict your OWN self in one comment.
→ More replies (4)2
1
u/justaguy1973 Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
Thank you. I totally agree. The post itself is not a good comparison of slavery versus a military attack. The history goes far deeper than that. Equal treatment in a country that is supposed to be the greatest on earth is not too much to ask for and the nation should be ashamed of its treatment of its own citizens particularly in 2020. We are being looked at all around the world and should be the leaders of the free world. The country should lead in this matter also.
0
Jun 13 '20
[deleted]
6
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
It depends. This subreddit is for conservatives. Usually if someone is respectful, it's fine. But if a leftist comes back repeatedly to try to argue with those in the community, they are not respecting the purpose of the subreddit.
106
Jun 13 '20
What about the germans? Descendants of genghis khan? The egyptians? Hell, why we're at it, iraqis too.
Heck. I heard cavemen did some stuff too.
27
u/QueenRowana Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
descendants of genghis khan
yeah there are a lot of those. According to some sources while Genghis had 12 wives that we know of properly he likely had 500 women who were perhaps not his wives but more concubines or side-women and many many women who he raped while out conquering. It is a matter of guessing how many children he actually had.
An international group of geneticists studying Y-chromosome data have found that nearly 8 percent of the men living in the region of the former Mongol empire carry y-chromosomes that are nearly identical to those of Genghis. That translates to 0.5 percent of the male population in the world, or roughly 16 million .
So that means that, very broadly speaking, we cannot trust people from mongolia because a lot of them are descendants of the most ruthless conqueror ever.
But of course to say that would be hateful against mongolian people...
We denfintiely also wouldn't be able to trust anyone from Australia since most of them are descendants of convicts and look what they did to the aboriginals!
We couldn't go to Russia anymore for sure because of communism, soviet, stalinism, leninism whatever kind of stuff.
China would be right out as well because of mao, communism, tankman, censure and many more things.
Germany is right out and so is italy probably because fascism.
France rose up and killed the entire bourgeoisie and killed their king so they are obviously evil too.
All in all you'd never be able to visit any place in europe because every country has a dark past somewhere.
We couldn't go on holiday to basically any arabian countries because terrorists ( and before they whine "not all arabs are terrorists" I'll say: yes not all arabs are terrorists, but may have been, and if they get to generalize that everyone who was even alive during the time of slavery is evil incarnate then I think I get to say all arabs are terrorists too)
Can they even imagine how many places, things, people we would never be able to visit, use, or speak to anymore for fear of being seen as "hateful"
If they are so adamant to blame the sins of the ancestors on their descendant I'll just tell them straight up that is dumb.
The world becomes a very small place if you insist on hating people for what their ancestors did. And I, for one, would like to visit another country again some day in the future
14
Jun 13 '20
About France, they did not kill the bourgeoisie at the Revolution since the bourgeoisie is itself the revolution starter. They went after nobles and clergy.
4
u/QueenRowana Jun 13 '20
I stand corrected. Apologies. Been a while since I was in history class. I though "bourgeoisie" was another word for nobility.
9
Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
This is a frequent source of confusion since the French word itself “bourgeois” comes from the same root as -burg, ie city. “Of the city.” And so the bourgeoisie are urban cityfolk.
Marx and his followers used that term in contrast to the proletariat, to mean the wealthy holders-of-capital, which is likely why you have the connotation with nobility in mind.
(TLDR: Marx ruins everything.)
3
7
Jun 13 '20
This is such a brilliant response. Logical, analytical, reasonableness.
That's why I brought of khan. Dude was notorious.
Thanks for the information, too. My history is rusty.
5
Jun 14 '20
I agree it’s ridiculous! I
have a solution if people are so offended of the history of our earth ancestors why don’t we ship them to Mars ? 🤣
They can set up a new colony there of peace , love and cuddles with no bad history. 🤔
3
u/the0greatest Jun 14 '20
What about England's crimes in their colonies
3
u/QueenRowana Jun 14 '20
For sure! the list is endless. If you vowed to never go anywhere where “evil people” once lived we woud have no room on earth to live. I’m pretty sure my own country isnt wholly innocent. So where would i go?
Blaming descendants for the crimes of ancestors is a slippery slope.
→ More replies (3)1
u/AdorableSignature6 Aug 14 '20 edited Aug 14 '20
Here is another way to look at it. Slavery existed in every culture except Europe. This was because Europe had a feudal system where the peasant was tied to the land and thus had no need of slaves. In Latinized Europe (those that spoke Romantic languages based heavily on Latin ) serfs were little better than slaves. I am uncertain where Vikings, Slavs, Russians and Germans stood but in England over time the serfs gained more and more rights having their own shire and moot courts.
Slavery was introduced to Europe whole scale by the Portuguese. In the 1300’s the King of Mali was the richest man ever to live with a net worth at 400 billion in US dollars today. He made this money from Gold Mines and Slavery. Slaves in his day were used to support the Saharan trade routes a brutal existence resulting in many deaths. When he made his pilgrimage from Western Africa to Mecca he gave away so much gold he increased the GDP of every country he passed through.
The Portuguese went to the West African coasts looking for Gold and set up sea routes as a niche trading market. They built trading posts along the coast which marketed slaves along with everything else. The brought slaves to the Caribbean in the 1500’s.
So the west which leftists define as whites power, especially Britain, came late to the African Slave trade. Slavery at that point existed in every culture in the world even the native Americans Indians.
The British in the early 1800’s abolished slavery. They pressured other countries to abandon it and the abolitionist movement in the US was influenced by Great Britain. They went down the African Coast destroying slave ports.
In Brazil which did not abolish slavery until 1890 the Port in Suape their is a restaurant called “El Porto de Galinhas” which means Port of Chickens. This was a slave port. It was called such because on the sailing manifest the slaves were listed as Galinhas or chickens in order to fool the British. Britain would hunt slave ships.
So according to how the SJW wokearratti define it
White Power Ended Slavery in the Modern world, you’re welcome!
1
u/poeFUN Jun 14 '20 edited Dec 08 '25
crowd head wipe unwritten dazzling dinosaurs gaze station knee dam
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/TheRadMenace Jun 21 '20
Bad example with the Germans. They paid reperations to the Jews.
The rest are just bad examples
2
Jun 22 '20
My point was, the world's history is sordid. Slavery is in the past of mostly every culture, and people's. We humans have come a long way.
My examples were likely imperfect. But they were to simply express a point. As for the germans, I didn't know this. I like to have my facts correct, thus, thank you.
Now, it's just counterproductive to stay in the past.we have to move on in the present. The chains of the past only old us back from progression.
1
u/weearch Jun 23 '20
Who said anything about never going anywhere anything bad has ever happened, or did I miss something?
1
u/gildmanpaper Jul 22 '20
Germans paid repatriations against the murder of Jews in the genocide. There is clear evidence that the deep South state should also pay repatriations for all the slavery and continue oppression.
All GOP are backing this Fact.
1
Jun 30 '20
Isn't it strange that being a racist piece of shit goes hand in hand with conservatives?
I wonder why.
1
Jun 30 '20
I wasn't aware liberals separating races, harnessing cancel culture, self loathing, changing history, silencing other view points, was completely okay.
;)
1
37
u/Paradoxical_Hexis Jun 13 '20
Black Africans sold other black Africans as slaves.
25
8
Jun 13 '20
Not only black Africans, but yes
11
u/Paradoxical_Hexis Jun 13 '20
My point is really that every race has done awful things. None of us our guilty of our ancestors wrong doing.
11
Jun 13 '20
Every race has done bad things. I agree that we shouldn't feel bad for the past. The past is over, we should look at it logically and learn from it imo
7
u/JPEveryday Jun 14 '20
About that. Sowells essay on slavery lays out the case that European slave traders could not withstand the African continent for very long; they would likely catch malaria or other illnesses native to the area. So they stayed on the coast picked up their slaves and left. The African tribes did the work of catching and enslaving primarily.
Doesn't make it right of course but it obliterates the mythical notion that white Europeans were out there straight hunting Africans in the middle of the jungle.
1
0
34
Jun 13 '20
But, the liberal parents of the white girl will be sure to use her as a prop at some point in their virtue signaling to deal with their own liberal-produced white guilt.
→ More replies (8)
19
26
u/jusalurkermostly Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
Liberal guilt and victimhood go hand in hand, watching those white people wash the feet of black people was a fucking pathetic sight to see.
8
7
1
Jun 23 '20
Who’s asking for white folk to apologize for slavery? Just acknowledge that it’s terrible and it has a profoundly negative impact on our society today. Slavery-Black Codes-Jim Crow-Reagan Era- Prison System
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 23 '20
Why the hell are you folks suddenly showing up to a nine day old thread?
1
Jun 23 '20
You folks? And your 9-day old thread makes no logical sense.
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 23 '20
Yes. Today several of you folks have shown up to a 9 day old thread to comment, which is unusual.
1
u/SuedefootJones Jun 30 '20
The right cant meme
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 30 '20
Apparently we did it so well that it's still triggering lefties 16 days later.
1
1
u/MFrancisWrites Jul 01 '20
No one is asking anyone to apologize for slavery. We're asking that we are all aware of how that effects the present day.
Its hard to have a reasonable conversation when while people will do anything to IMMEDIATELY claim their the victim of [issue].
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jul 01 '20
No one is asking anyone to apologize for slavery.
What are reparations?
1
u/MFrancisWrites Jul 01 '20
Let's note that VERY FEW are even asking for that.
And they are an attempt to offset the massive head start that white people got on the backs of black people in terms of finances, wealth and property ownership. It's not 'oh shit sorry'. It's 'I'm aware that shit policies existed and that has been foundational in the stagnation of your local economies. And I'm willing to take action to reverse some of that.'
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jul 01 '20
Let's note that VERY FEW are even asking for that.
On the contrary. It's a major election talking point now.
https://www.newsweek.com/joe-biden-wants-see-studies-about-feasibility-slavery-reparations-1510096
1
u/MFrancisWrites Jul 01 '20
A single Newsweek article doesn't make it a major election talking point man. Cmon. Words matter.
1
1
u/thisonetimeinithaca Aug 02 '20
There’s a difference between apologizing and taking responsibility.
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Aug 02 '20
Why are people commenting a literal month after this was posted?
Where did this get linked?
I'm not going to apologize or take responsibility for anything I don't perpetrate.
0
u/thisonetimeinithaca Aug 02 '20 edited Aug 02 '20
Okay so you’re fine with ignoring historical context. Got it.
Edit: little bitches banned me because they can’t handle being rejected
1
1
u/ImUrCyberBF Aug 04 '20
Is that what proponents of reparations are suggesting? That children apologize for slavery? 🤔
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Aug 04 '20
You guys are showing up to this month old thread like it's on HOT or something...
1
u/HelloAvram Oct 23 '20
bruh, this is so true
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Oct 23 '20
This is FOUR MONTHS OLD.
Where are you people coming from?
1
1
u/cchloeflores Nov 04 '20
has anyone asked white ppl to apologize for slavery ?
1
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Nov 04 '20
WHY are you commenting on a four month old post?
1
2
u/gallaidh Jun 14 '20
Exactly, just get on with it. Gheezzz talk about cry babies that's all they do is stamp their feet and scream.
4
2
0
u/goldenarms Jun 14 '20
So y’all in favor of DACA then since it wasn’t their fault they were brought here as illegal immigrants when they were children?
1
1
2
1
1
u/WWpinkumbrellaD Jul 25 '20
No ones asking for an apology, we’re asking you to stop benefitting from it..
1
u/KolonelSanders Jul 30 '20
Is everyone missing the point here? The US Government/police have been and continue to be violating constitutional rights of Natives and blacks in this country. These violations continue to benefit whites alive today. That needs to be addressed. This comparison along with the other comparisons are just deflection.
1
u/AdorableSignature6 Aug 14 '20
“Men will soon forgive the patricide of their fathers but will never forgive the theft of their patrimony “ - Niccolo’ Machiavelli - The Prince
He was talking about taking over a conquered country saying if you left people their land they would quickly accept your rule but if you gave the land to someone else they would fight your rule for generations.
Blacks were taken from their land by the Empire of Mali and sold to the Portuguese who brought them to the US. The American black does not know the history of this and if he does he is taught his people were Kings and told to venerate the Mali Empire.
They only know the white man owned them and took them out of Africa. They don’t know where the land was, who there people really were or what was taken. The just know that it was taken.
As such reparations can’t be given back. No one knows what to give. So it will never be enough. No matter how much is given or has been given it can never be paid in full.
This is why reparations is such a useful piece of rhetoric for the left. It keeps the conflict alive forever so that they can use people.
1
Oct 19 '20
Well one was a single event that happened as part of a war against america and killed a few thousand people, and the other was systematic abduction of millions of people subjecting them to a life of literal slavery... one of these things is not like the other.
1
u/nonononono90 Oct 22 '20
Well let’s be clear: none of the blind hatred for X group having done something wrong will ever fall on anyone but the young men in the group.
1
u/Fatalis_Drakk Dec 01 '20
It’s the grandparents at fault for maintaining a crappy system of government putting minorities down. What happens when you put down a member of your team already in trouble? They stop trying to help and get themselves (and by extension the whole team) in a bigger hole.
1
1
1
u/nichols82a Jun 13 '20
I agree..this is nuts. But it is their ideology of trying to change our country into their messed-up vision for it. It is their efforts to erase the past so not only do we all not learn from such but we become truly immersed in their perspective without having the acumen to question it rather to align ourselves with it.
1
1
u/kydfyd Jun 15 '20
Look I understand that you feel like you are being blamed for something that you did not contribute too, but that is not the rhetoric being used. Even if that were the case, racism is still apparent in modern American society and the best way to fix it is to first address it.
I understand that there's a lot of information that feels like it's targeting white Americans, but rather than try to defend or get upset, why not try to read into it more and sympathize with the other side?
2
u/TrikStari Jun 19 '20
That is precisely the rhetoric being used.
Regardless of that, it's still important that people acknowledge these concerns (which we see nothing of, other than mockery and insults). If you expect one side to treat you a certain way, you must treat them the same.
You want civility and respect? Try giving some. Rather than rioting, committing hate crimes, and basically just generally villifying anyone and anything who disagrees with you.
Thid is of course ignoring the blatant and overt anti white racism coming from the left. To the extent that they are trying to change the very textbook definition of racism to basically say "only whites can be racist". Which is blatantly horseshit.
-5
u/MiyegomboBayartsogt Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20
White people ended slavery across the globe. If they should apologize for anything, it's not that.
6
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
Dude, look at what you wrote and how it reads.
If you meant to say that ending slavery is something to apologize for, I think you are on the wrong subreddit.
8
u/MiyegomboBayartsogt Jun 13 '20
Should probably proof read better, but it's a busy day and the news is sad and frustrating.
United Kingdom and United States uniquely fought to end slavery yet these two places are the places getting the most grief. Why is that.
1
11
u/classyllama88 Jun 13 '20
Did you mean for that to come across as bad as it does?
5
u/MiyegomboBayartsogt Jun 13 '20
We are living through interesting times. The enormous amount of unearned moral superiority passing back and forth is epic and threatens to drown us all. I should be more careful picking at these redden swollen outrage sores.
2
u/classyllama88 Jun 13 '20
Yeah I didn’t mean to sound patronizing or anything. But to add on some of my thoughts: I think it’s important to remember the left constantly flairs up the apologetic white rhetoric which I feel is like the uno reverse of what’s happening, creating racism the other way around. We all should just be mindful of our fellow American brother and sisters regardless of race. Including recognizing that some people still hold prejudices towards African Americans and other races. I say we just treat everyone as human and watch the issue disappear. Honestly would love it if that would happen then it’ll lessen the material leftist identity politics has to work with.
1
3
u/jamrev Jun 13 '20
Unfortunately slavery has not been ended globally. And your comment is also unfortunate.
13
u/nilremdrol Jun 13 '20
So when are we going to start boycotting all Muslims and all Chinese products since both are currently steeped in slavery? Where’s the protests over that? <as I post on my iPhone> if you have an electronic device in your hand, you support modern slavery. That is all.
6
0
u/bandittr6 Jul 02 '20
The straw man is strong with this one.
1
-1
-10
u/RyMontFlar Jun 13 '20
Who wants to ask contemporary white Americans to apologize for slavery? Acknowledge and apologize are two different things
13
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
You don't have anyone saying that slavery didn't happen and wasn't a terrible blight on the nation.
0
u/hinatah19 Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
At least use a comparison that makes sense. Pearl Harbor was one attack that was related to war. At that rate, you might as well ask every singe country that was in the world wars to apologize. And the US already bombed Nagasaki and Hiroshima and caused even more damage, nuclear damage. Pretty sure the nuclear effects are still there today, they fucked up those places so bad and killed so many CIVILIANS. The people who got killed in Pearl Harbor, at least some of them knew how to fight, they weren’t all just civilians. Slavery happened for a fucking while and dehumanized all of black people at the time. Half of the US saw n o t h i n g wrong with it.
0
u/OaklandBlackouts Jun 14 '20
Stop it...No one’s asking a baby to apologize for anything. It’s more so like asking for acknowledgement of systematic racism and how black folks were and ARE not given the same opportunities as white folk. Precisely
1
u/TrikStari Jun 19 '20
Unequal outcomes are not evidence of systemic racism. Correlation is not causation.
0
0
Jun 29 '20 edited Jun 29 '20
Use your brain and think harder. The idea of “apologizing” is more about recognizing that lack of wealth/lack of opportunity/criminality is disproportionally shifted toward black people as a result of their enslavement over multiple centuries. As white people, it’s not about apologizing for our ancestors potentially having enslaved their ancestors. It’s about understanding the unequal positions we have in present society, which is a result of the former, and working together to change that. I roll my eyes at a lot of thing people online do, but I’m so fucking depressed knowing that this picture resonates with anyone.
-2
-11
u/ban4chan Jun 13 '20
The difference is that Asians were discriminated against for Pearl Harbor while whites arent
11
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
while whites arent
Whites have never been discriminated against?
Talk to Irish Americans.
-1
u/classyllama88 Jun 13 '20
I love that point. Ya people are white but often times we all forget white isn’t a culture it’s just a term that groups all these different people together. Most Americans have German, Irish, Scottish, etc ancestry. These were all unique in culture and hence have been discriminated upon, some more than others. I think it’s less about pointing out oh “whites” have been discriminated upon on the conservative side because I think this promotes leftist identity politics instead of calling them out. It’s more powerful to recognize that at all points in history including the now all sorts of people have experienced some sort of prejudice against them and just focus on figuring out solutions instead of continuing this victimization of oh theres been prejudice against whites or there’s been prejudice against blacks scenario. It’s ridiculous doesn’t promote any solution.
5
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
I think this promotes leftist identity politics instead of calling them out.
It's more about correcting bad history and trying to bring perspective.
4
u/classyllama88 Jun 13 '20
Yeah as long as you’re pointing out other points in history to and correcting that, I just find some people just point that one point out and tend to just stop there.
7
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
OMG, polish Americans. For so long the narrative was that they were stupid.
Italian Americans were referred to as a couple of different slurs.
And females in general in America for a long time weren't really that in charge of their destinies.
We have worked to overcome these bigotries.
Honestly... we have really come a long way as far as racism.
No one's talking about Islamophobia anymore.
To be honest, I think that the fact that the USA has come so far to try to successfully integrate all sorts of different people is WHY this conflagration is happening.
The forces on the left do NOT want to see harmony.
2
u/classyllama88 Jun 13 '20
Absolutely because I soon as we all recognize we’re Americans their ID politics don’t work.
-8
u/ban4chan Jun 13 '20
And whites haven’t been discriminated against on a major scale in the USA since then
10
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
It's almost like we are, in general, attempting to REDUCE discrimination against groups of people.
→ More replies (1)
-1
•
u/IBiteYou Voted Zeksiest mod Jun 13 '20
You understand that at some point, when you keep pushing people to atone for sins that they did not commit, it goes badly right? And at that point, you will likely stop laughing abruptly.