Hi Conan,
I am and will always be a devoted fan. You are my favourite comedian by far. That’s why this situation is so especially hurtful.
As a highly respected, wealthy white man with a huge platform, deciding whom to elevate is inherently a political choice. You might not like it, and it might be uncomfortable for you to hear, but denying it goes beyond naïveté into willful blindness.
You are not a stupid man. We know you understand how this works. You chose to platform a rapist on your podcast. You need to ask yourself why you and your team made that choice. Whom did it serve?
Your intention with avoiding political topics has always been, so you say, in service of your fans. You’ve said that the joke should come first, and you’re not here to proselytize to your audience. That would be fine if it were true! Not great, not brave, but fine.
But you and I both know it is not true. Your statements are morally inconsistent with your actual behaviour. You want to create a safe space for your fans so they can forget about the terrible things in the world, but Inviting a rapist into that safe space has the exact opposite effect. Your decision was alienating, it was cruel, it was careless.
It may surprise you to learn that many of your fans are survivors of rape. We do not have the privilege of choosing whether or not to care about this topic. None of us are laughing at a rapist’s jokes.
Those jokes are made automatically unfunny by the fact that a rapist has said them.
How do you think it feels to hear a sexual predator joke about the MeToo movement on your podcast? With no challenge from you, or Sona, or Matt? What kind of person finds that funny?
You DID make a political choice, Conan. You chose NOT to side with rape survivors.
You chose to support a rapist instead. You, Sona, and Matt chose to give him a platform, and laugh at his jokes, knowing that he is a rapist. That is a reflection of you and your values, no matter how much you wish you could shirk that responsibility. Conan: You can’t.
You’ve had a rapist on your show, you gave him a platform and you let him sell his side of the story. Let me know when you’re ready to give an actual victim of rape that kind of platform and power. We need it a whole lot more than Dustin Hoffman does. Rape survivors are funny too! We just usually make rapists the butt of the jokes instead.