r/computerscience • u/sltinker • Sep 22 '21
General Computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes, biology is about microscopes or chemistry is about beakers and test tubes. Science is not about tools. It is about how we use them, and what we find out when we do. — Edsger W. Dijkstra
23
u/og_m4 Sep 22 '21
With all due respect to Dijkstra (and there's bucketloads of it), this is an ill-fitting analogy that is starting to age. His statement made sense for his time. He wanted people to know that there's fundamental science and math to computer science and that he wasn't just a technician hammering away at a system until it starts working but someone who deals in theories, hypotheses and proofs.
A lot of early computer science was stuff that was very independent of computers. You can run Dijkstra's algorithm on a mechanical computer made of sluice gates and water wheels, etc. if you're motivated enough to make the contraption. Similar to how you can study astronomy without telescopes if you have super sharp eyesight.
But today things are too intertwined between computer science and engineering for Dijkstra's analogy to fully hold. It still holds for some topics such as the theory of computation but that's the extent of it. Take cybersecurity, for example. It doesn't exist without actual digital computers and not just any digital computers but ones running modern operating systems and modern network stacks. A lot of the field has turned into the "science of computer engineering" as opposed to being strictly in the computer science or computer engineering realm. Take this paper for example: "Design of a security and trust framework for 5G multi-domain scenarios". It's neither purely astronomy nor purely telescope engineering.
It's a bit of a double standard for people to say "stop making car analogies to operating systems" but still keep worshipping this old quote from Dijkstra. All this quote has become is a badge of elitism for people with CS degrees to use in looking down upon PHP/python programmers who make CRUD applications for a living and are often making better money due to market forces than those who know more about theoretical CS.
2
2
u/HumunculiTzu Sep 23 '21
I agree with everything, but I think changing "science of computer engineering" to "science of software engineering" would fit better as, at least in my experience, it is more about applying the concepts to developing software to solve some problem, and less about the hardware. Hardware still plays a roll, but seems to be less about designing the hardware for the software, but instead the other way around. It is just symantics, and my limited view though. I'm sure it can change depending on the role you typically fill.
3
u/og_m4 Sep 23 '21
I agree with everything, but I think changing "science of computer engineering" to "science of software engineering" would fit better as, at least in my experience, it is more about applying the concepts to developing software to solve some problem, and less about the hardware.
That's fair. Things are also a lot more software oriented now than before. Von Neuman introduced programmable computers and we're undergoing almost a second Von Neumannification with things like Cloud computing, Software Defined Networking, FPGA programming and even Arduino style programmable hardware.
The hardware guys aren't sitting silent and they are working on stuff such as shrinking the die size of chips, inventing sensors, accelerating matrix operations, and working around energy consumption and dissipation limits, but their focus is on increased performance for the most part, and not actual use cases for the technology.
1
Sep 23 '21
well, I studied technical computer science, which was much more hardware focused.
1
u/HumunculiTzu Sep 23 '21
Genuinely curious, how is that different from Computer Engineering? I've always heard Computer Science as being software focused and Computer Engineering as being hardware focused. Granted, where I graduated from there was a lot of overlap. Comp Sci & Eng were both considered engineering degrees with Comp Sci essentially being software engineering, and Comp Eng being hardware engineering. We all also took all the same Freshman and Sophomore level classes, and we only diverged for the Junior and Senior levels. Even then though, we could take each other's classes as electives.
1
Sep 23 '21
The difference boiled down to the focus after the 3rd semester. While the applied CS people went more towards Software-Dev stuff, my peers and I went more towards the hardware-software interface, with a bit more hardware. Think drivers, operating systems, controllers, and headless CPUs or microcontrollers. Also, a bit on the CPU from the logic gate perspective.
1
u/HumunculiTzu Sep 23 '21
Ah ok, that is very in between Comp Sci and Comp Eng. I (Comp Sci) did have to do classes on operating systems, and what not, but no microcontrollers or CPUs. I did take a computer architecture class (basically high level CPU stuff) though as an elective and was the only Comp Sci person there.
1
u/ProfessionalMoose123 Feb 24 '26
I disagree with everything you said.
Unless you are referring to the pre-World War II period, the relationship between Science and Technology/Engineering has always been the same. You argue that today, fields like Cybersecurity and 5G are intrinsically linked to the machine (the computer). However, you could have said the exact same thing in 1946 regarding programming languages and compilers.
Claiming Cybersecurity 'doesn't exist' without modern OSs is a category error. Cryptography is pure Mathematics (n = p.q). The hardware is just the host; the logic is the soul.
We don’t call Biology 'Microscope Science' just because we use tools to see cells. A field is defined by its laws, not its gadgets. 5G is just an application of Shannon’s Law—the theory existed decades before the antenna.
Calling Dijkstra's quote 'elitist' is just a defense mechanism for those who mistake 'knowing how to use a tool' for 'understanding the science.'
32
Sep 22 '21
A decent chunk of astronomy's existence is due to telescopes and vice versa.
8
u/FleetStreetsDarkHole Sep 22 '21
Yeah but the telescopes are basically about engineering. Trying to see farther better. That is promoted by astronomy, but the science of astronomy itself is about examining what you can see with the telescope.
Similarly, I don't build computers. It's in my interest to help advance the engineering of computers, but my focus is not to do that myself (unless I so choose). Computer science is about using the computer to build better automation software more efficiently. Or, depending on the subfield such as A.I. building a smarter program.
3
u/gabrielesilinic Software Engineer Sep 22 '21
Weirdly computer science it's probably one of the most dogfooding-like fields
As you build the computer you use the computer to build a better computer (which part of it really depends as you said)
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
4
u/pomegranateseasquid Sep 22 '21
That might be true for a lot of theoretical fields. However, software engineering, human computer interaction and many other disciplines would not exist without actual computers.
4
u/slicky6 Sep 23 '21
I had a professor that always said Computer science was the study of problem solving, and math was the study of truth.
3
3
u/SteeleDynamics Sep 23 '21
Astronomy -> Telescope Science
Biology -> Microscope Science
Chemistry -> Beaker Science
OK, it's fixed. /s
2
u/orbit99za Sep 22 '21
I can see where he comes as he came up with the foundational network routing Algorithms
7
Sep 22 '21
More than that - he was the guy who fought to get Comouter Science recognised as a new academic discipline worthy of being studied at universities, with its own standards and methods. Before that, any work with computers was done in Electrical Engineering.
2
2
Sep 23 '21
Same statement in so many sub-reddits. Either I am in too many similar subreddits or someone is farming karma.
Kindly remove the post.
6
u/GeorgVonHardenberg Sep 22 '21
It honestly should be called computer engineering, in fact, that's what it's called in my country. There's no "computer science" here. And engineering is about technology and problem-solving, so it perfectly fits.
5
u/seshlordclinton Sep 22 '21
I suppose it depends on the location and the curriculum, but in general, the two fields are not the same. While codependent, Computer Engineering and Computer Science generally have differing focal points in the academic, industrial, and institutional realm.
3
2
Sep 22 '21
Well, take a look at sensitive dependence on initial conditions, aka chaos. Basically would not have been discovered without computers, although the general notion was known to mathematicians of the late 19th century like Poincare, they just didn't have the tools to investigate it. So is that pure mathematics, or is that computer science?
I understand why academic institutions created 'computer science' and 'computer engineering' departments, but they could easily be grouped under applied mathematics and applied physics instead. A lot of that is just about how to distribute resources and jobs in the best manner - the universe cares not at all about the political and financial (and social) dividing lines within academic institutions, but professors looking for resources care a lot about them.
1
1
1
u/ConfidentCommission5 Sep 23 '21
Why do some people need to separate "engineering" (ie the practical aspects) from "science" (ie the theory)?
Using the same analogies, astronomy would barely exist without telescopes, we would not know much of biology without microscopes.
Without these tools, we would know little more than the Mayas about astronomy, and even them were using (crude) tools.
Scientists need tools to practice science, to experiment, to measure, to test hypothesis.
Both are intertwined and complimentary, one is not better or purer than the other.
Our natural senses are too limited and subjective to be used as reliable measure systems, which is why we need tools.
Many scientists ultimately design and engineer their own tools to push their research further, using both theoretical and practical knowledge.
1
u/ThrillHouseofMirth Sep 22 '21
Astronomy is about the stars. Optics is about telescopes. You might very reasonably call it telescope-science. This isn't a real statement, and it is not deep. Its a boring, tedious fuzzing of what words *actually* mean.
Sick algorithm though.
-1
u/Tai9ch Sep 23 '21
If you need to put "science" in the name, you're admitting it's not really a science. Same as putting "democratic" in the name of a country.
-7
Sep 22 '21
Tbh there should only be computer science and engineering schools. You can't abstract computer science away from its comouter roots, and when you do it a terrible thing called python emerges.
5
u/TheMcDucky Sep 22 '21
You can't abstract computer science away from its computer roots
No, but you can abstract it away from physical computer machines.
-1
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
22
3
u/joshuajy03 Sep 23 '21
what do you mean? if i can make a dynamic program in the language, it should count.
3
u/AlexReinkingYale Sep 23 '21
That is an extremely low bar for any language, and completely meaningless for some... writing a DP in C++ does not mean you know C++.
2
u/joshuajy03 Sep 23 '21
2
u/AlexReinkingYale Sep 23 '21
Doh! I've spent too much time around people who actually believe this...
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
4
u/NamelessVegetable Sep 22 '21
Science is about about The Scientific Method...
I'd argue that only applies to the natural and social sciences. Computer science is a formal science, like mathematics.
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
1
u/adrunk_mathematician Sep 22 '21
So you are saying social sciences aren’t actual sciences? What is your definition of a science?
-3
u/dontyougetsoupedyet Sep 22 '21
I mean, I definitely say that social science is rarely scientific. Most of the field is summed up in analysis of data from online polls given to sets of students. I'd laugh, but it's far from amusing. Science needs more than statistics, especially stats almost no one attempts to corroborate. Inb4 we all pretend social science fields aren't in crisis over bad research.
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
7
u/adrunk_mathematician Sep 22 '21
Uhhhh, things like psychology and sociology definitely use the scientific method.
0
Sep 22 '21
[deleted]
2
u/Dragonvarine Sep 22 '21
Formal sciences are still the same type of science as natural sciences; a science doesn't necessarily mean it has to have the scientific method to it, that's just one definition of science.
When we say [topic] science, we don't necessarily mean "[topic] with the scientific method" - that's just false. Here's one definition of science:
"A systematically organized body of knowledge on a particular subject".
There is no mention of the scientific method. Computer science is essentially a systematically organized body of knowledge regarding computation. This includes math, or social sciences, or criminology, etc.
Natural sciences just naturally (lol) use the scientific method due to the nature (lol) of how they work. Whereas formal sciences like math don't necessarily need the scientific method but rather proofs instead.
Edit: words.
2
u/caykroyd Sep 23 '21
Why do people argue so much about the meaning of words? Words are just conventions made by men, and many times these conventions aren't consistent or differ among groups of people.
Should I care if I call such or such a field "science" or something else? Ultimately, it's just a label.
1
2
u/ochi_simantiko Sep 23 '21
The existence of a replication science extends to far more fields than just to psychology and sociology. Equally affected is e.g. medicine. But even physics is.
This has nothing to do with a lack of scientific method in either field - but rather with a refinement of it over the decades. Human biases and limits of knowing are the determining factors here - not some supposed lack of scientific thinking in psychology or other fields.
47
u/pram-ila Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21
Hence why I think the name "Informatics", which some degree programs call themselves, is a more apt name than "computer science". We don't call "astronomy" "telescope science".