r/computerscience • • Jul 18 '21

Discussion Software development vs Software engineering vs Computer Science

I want to know the difference between these. Here is what I think but please correct me and improve me.

Software development - it is just using high level frameworks like react or flutter to make apps or express to make a backend.

Software engineering - is building solutions to complex problems. Like building react or building a os or kernel something like that.

And

Computer science - is the science behind working of stuff like the compilers, like how computers work. This would include hardware and software both.

So that is what I think. It is just a rough idea I want to learn more.

157 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

119

u/Phantomhexen Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

I am a computer scientist and mathematician. I see software engineering and software development as the same thing, the field of building software.

Computer science is a subset of mathematics. At a high level you can divide mathematics into two disciplines, theorem proving and computation. Computer science is the study of the computation discipline. Let me use a mathematical example, the integral from calculus. Theorem proving would prove the existence of an integral (Fundemental Theorem of Calculus). Computation would prove ways of computing the integral ( Finite Difference Method, Finite Element Method, etc) aka algorithms.

3

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

Thanks for the CS part. Makes sense to me now.

7

u/outoftunediapason Jul 19 '21

Cs also kinda overlaps with theorem proving doesn't it? You do a ton of that with computability, recursion theory, type and logic stuff etc.

1

u/davidds0 Jul 19 '21

What about the subject of computational models? It is very theorem like. Example proof that a certain language can be computed by a turing machine etc

9

u/jnalanko Jul 18 '21

I think software engineering and software development are basically synonyms. Computer science on the other hand is the branch of mathematics that studies computation. This includes models of computation, algorithms, data structures, etc. As Dijkstra said, computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes.

8

u/MentallyWill Jul 18 '21

I think software engineering and software development are basically synonyms.

I think these terms are colloquially synonyms and used that way in practice because they're closely related but I think if we wanted to split hairs they are different. Imho software development is quite literally developing code whereas software engineering is more the application of the engineering mindset to software. Things like scalability, throughput, fault tolerance, availability and so on. Those problems are generally solved by developing software (hence the close relationship b/w the terms) but the difference is still the mentality and approach taken to the software being written. Just my two cents though.

-2

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

What I think is that

A software developer is a person who would develop software for a business like an app or an website or something. But a software engineer is someone improves upon the solutions in computer science field or create solutions to new problems.

Like making git is an software engineering cause it solved a huge problem (they engineered a software) in the cs field but making a website for some company like making the amazon website is software development.

A engineer would create new algorithms which developers would use.

Again I am just a kid in cs. So I can be completely wrong.

1

u/GoBucks4928 fang dev Jul 19 '21

There’s a lot of innovation and practice that goes into building a large scale, high tps e-commerce site like amazon. With a lot of engineering decisions and trade offs. Also a fuck ton of teams that work on the retail site

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted]

1

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

Understood. Thanks for correcting me.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Computer Science is much more about algorithms and the mathematical aspects to analysing and solving coding and data related problems than it is about how computers and compilers work on a technical level.

2

u/tcpukl Jul 19 '21

Especially since writing compilers is actually software engineering.

7

u/gbbofh Jul 18 '21

Your question has been answered, but I feel there's a really simple analogy to be made to something that most people are at least slightly more familiar with.

Software developer - a construction worker, responsible for actually building something.

Software engineer - an architect, responsible for designing things to be built by construction workers.

Computer scientist - a materials scientist, responsible for developing novel materials which can be specified for use by architects and used in construction by construction workers.

Computer scientists develop the theory, and design algorithms. Engineers specify the architectural details for a project. Developers build the projects.

Sometimes, engineers and developers overlap -- typically when the company is small, as it is where I work, and all of the software development team also works as engineers for the projects. But it doesn't relate to high or low level, as you've already learned in this thread.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Software development and software engineering are more or less synonymous. I'd you have to be more precise, the engeniering component is more about deciding what software is needed for solving a certain task, how fast it needs to be, how much computational error is tolerable, how well does the code need to scale and even some hardware considerations. The development is just marking the product. These things are generally done by the same people nowadays so the distinction is obsolete.

Computer science is the study of computational machines. Usually the hardware part is studied in computer engeniering and computer science is more of the abstract mathematics. The two are intertwined of course, for example, error correction theory is both an engeniering and a mathematical question.

4

u/Special_Rice9539 Jul 19 '21

In Canada, software engineering and software development are more distinct, while they’re interchangeable in the states. In Canada, you have to be an accredited engineer trained in standard engineering courses like ethics and technical communication in order to hold the title of software engineer, as well as have a certain number of years of work experience, and pass specific tests.

If you’re going to be working on software that has a lot of potential risk if it fails, like airplane navigation software, then you’ll need to be an engineer or have an engineer sign off on it. Most projects aren’t life-or-death and don’t need an engineer though, so regular developers are fine. I don’t think the United States are as strict about qualifications.

2

u/wsppan Jul 19 '21

Software development- writing code

Software engineering - writing code over time

Computer Science - the language of the problem space

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

At a commercial level, software dev, and software engineering are the same thing.

2

u/GoBucks4928 fang dev Jul 19 '21

Software development and software engineering are the same things. If you’re doing no design you’re either a fresh junior dev or really need to switch to a real tech company.

1

u/zabardastlaunda Jul 18 '21

Remind me! 2 days

1

u/RemindMeBot Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

I will be messaging you in 2 days on 2021-07-20 20:17:48 UTC to remind you of this link

2 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

"Software engineering is programming over time."

-1

u/endeesa Jul 18 '21

In the real world they all relate to the same thing, solving problems through programming languages and other supporting technologies

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted]

4

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

It seems a bit confusing to me. I am just confused with what I want to learn.

I like building apps but I want to also learn low level stuff.

Do you mind giving advice on how do I shift from Software development (currently I just use high level frameworks and make mobile apps or web apps or a backend) to software engineering.

I don't know exactly what I want to learn. But I just want to learn that thing I just can't express in words properly.

I always have a guilt feeling of calling myself a app developer instead I want to be called and engineer. I want to do those complex thinking instead of just reusing the same code every time to make projects which are of no use.

2

u/Phobic-window Jul 19 '21

Generally you will start as a developer, and as you advance along your professional development you will gain the knowledge to break down larger and larger systems. Engineering is just good development, but you have to understand the software as well as how to implement scalable configurable solutions before you can be a good engineer

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted]

1

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

Whoo. That was nice.

So I want to be an engineer. I want to know the insides of why the code works and why is this better than that even if both work.

So, How do I make a move? From using others algorithms to making my self.

Everywhere people are just selling on learn to build apps, learn building websites etc.

But I don't want to do that.

I don't want to learn making apps in flutter I want to make flutter. (example)

I want to build something which will help people for years.

In short I want to go low level (i guess, I am yet confused on what I want to do)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

I am valiant but want direction ***

3

u/deelowe Jul 19 '21 edited Jul 19 '21

Let's take this to it's extreme to see if it helps drive the point home:

A computer scientist writes papers on how to best design computing systems and may never touch a real programming language or real piece of hardware. They are primarily concerned with theory. Entire courses may be taught in languages that are made up or only useful in academia. Linux grew from an early OS that was only used by computer scientists for school. Also, it's a math major at it's core.

Probably the most misunderstood degree, a software engineer creates the plans for how to best build a computing system for a particular task. They'll draw block diagrams, do calculations to understand the limits of the systems they are building. They are well versed in the latest software stacks and may even be creating their own. Most importantly, unlike the computer scientist, they understand how the physical world affects the potential solutions they can choose from. Software engineers are sometimes called "systems engineers." Other disciplines use the same term and they are analogous if you want to do more research. It is an engineering major at it's core.

A software developer takes direction from others on how to best architect a system and focuses primarily on the code itself. Their day is spent writing, testing, and fixing software. At smaller companies they may do it all, but at a major cloud provider, they'll usually be working under a software engineer. Developers may eventually get into site reliability, security, or network engineering positions. A software developer is a technician or mechanic at their core as they are very hands on.

A computer engineer is very different from the ones mentioned above in that there's a strong emphasis on hardware. A computer engineering degree is basically 50% software engineer and 50% electrical engineer (with a focus on digital electronics). Computer engineers usually work as part of hardware design teams. A lot of times, they'll work on things like firmware, bios, bmc, or FPGAs. With enough education and/or experience, a computer engineer may get into chip design and start working as part of a team working on ASICs. Unlike the 3 above, a computer engineer likes making hardware.

None of these are firm rules, but it helps to give some insight. Any of these degrees are fine. Just pick your school and degree based on your interests and you'll be fine. You'll likely learn a lot more by looking at their curriculum than asking here btw. Ask what their Jr and Sr classes are and what the senior project is if they have one.

2

u/primary157 Jul 18 '21

That's computer science. Understanding the innermost parts of software development and its relationship to math.

On the other hand, low-level programming is somewhat an intersection between all those subjects. It's like the center of a Venn diagram: 1) if you dive into lower levels you reach hardware and computer engineering, 2) if you go deeper in its math theory you reach computer science, 3) if you want to learn the best way to develop a software that mostly fits the customer requirements (not necessarily to develop a better software in general) you reach software engineering, 4) if you stay in the surface then its solely software development.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted]

3

u/sake679 Jul 18 '21

K. Makes sense now. Thanks This made soem clarity.

3

u/smokejoe95 Jul 19 '21

While it's not uncommon, that an engineer is a developer of a product as well.

IMO Software Engineering is all about the planning of a project, and the development is the actual coding.