r/computerscience • u/_ArseniyKD_ • Mar 07 '21
Why computer architecture does not suck
Hello,
I hope that this post does not break any rules (I checked the sidebar and didn't see anything against this). I just made a video talking about computer architecture, false sharing, and showed a practical example of how much of a performance degradation false sharing can cause.
I believe that computer architecture is an incredibly dope area of computer science and found that too many people hate it for the wrong reasons. If this sounds like it would be up your alley, then feel free to check out the video here: https://youtu.be/BJ2mwsXjleM
I am open to criticism and other feedback. I am very new to making videos and video editing, so any feedback on how I can improve my content is welcome :)
~ArseniyKD.
9
u/cameronb222 Mar 07 '21
This was very enjoyable to watch. I couldn’t stand my Computer Architecture course at my university. Maybe a different teacher would’ve done it for me; mine was the worst professor I’ve ever had. Hearing all this technical stuff gives me hardcore imposter syndrome and makes me just want to be a simple website dev 😂
18
u/_ArseniyKD_ Mar 07 '21
You have no idea how much I suffer from impostor's syndrome myself. It's the blight of cs students, there is always someone that seems to know everything you know, and then some.
Trust me, I find webdev to be seriously difficult. I managed to successfully do a bit of webdev, but none of it seems intuitive. But put me behind a computer systems problem (networking, os, etc.) and I'll be able to handle it. Different skill sets, so don't be afraid.
Also, computer arch is just a topic that is very dear to me. Unlike you, I had an insanely good prof for that class that really opened my eyes to how god damn cool this topic can be. That prof knew how to teach, and I ended up taking 4 courses with them, even one grad class. The difference a good prof can make is crazy.
Lastly, the phrase "don't compare your chapter 1 to somebody's chapter 25" rings truer every day for me. I heard it many times, yet only finally managed to internalize it.
:)
5
1
u/zeeblefritz Mar 07 '21
Did you attend UWP?
1
u/cameronb222 Mar 07 '21
Not sure what that is - I go to Florida State University
1
u/zeeblefritz Mar 07 '21
It's where I go. University of Wisconsin Parkside. The comp arch prof is not great.
1
u/_ArseniyKD_ Mar 07 '21
I worked with one of the TAs from UW Madison for the computer arch course there. She was great to talk to.
I assume you guys also use GEM5 for the advanced computer arch class?
1
u/zeeblefritz Mar 07 '21
GEM5
nothing of the sort. Wow, that program looks really cool. My prof is old and apparently not keeping up with the times or talking to her peers for stuff like this.
1
u/_ArseniyKD_ Mar 07 '21
GEM5 is neat, but setting it up and using it has quite the learning curve. I think that you should use at least some cpu simulator for an advanced computer architecture class. Anything else would be way too complicated, anything less wouldn't really make the course "advanced". But hey, that's my opinion, could be wrong
1
u/zeeblefritz Mar 07 '21
oh sorry, I don't know if we have an "advanced" comp arch. Just the course required for the degree.
1
u/_ArseniyKD_ Mar 07 '21
Yea, for regular computer arch we used mips, and the year after they switched to RISC-V in our uni. Regular computer arch usually involves assembly programming.
We did some nutty assignments, like rendering fractals, doing liveness analysis, simulating the game of life (with graphics), and doing an assembly code optimization based on dead code elimination. So much mips, so much pain, but I did love every minute of it.
1
1
u/usernameistakencry Mar 07 '21
Hearing all this technical stuff gives me hardcore imposter syndrome and makes me just want to be a simple website dev 😂
there is no such thing as simple web developer it is also an extremely complex field in 2021.
0
12
u/buildingnemo Mar 07 '21
Computer architecture is the fundamental layer of many concepts you learn in computer science. Learn comp architecture and you surely have a greater insight into programming of all levels. Let us not forget the hardware side of the computers we work with ;)
4
u/matschbirne03 Mar 07 '21
Computer architecture is like the most interesting topic in computer science imo.
3
u/wiriux Mar 07 '21
Computer architecture is awesome. Doing projects for school (worrying about running out of MIPS registers) when you're juggling other projects and assignments sucks!!
2
u/editor_of_the_beast Mar 07 '21
For me, most of computer science assumes that there is a machine that works that is executing the algorithms we’re talking about. Of course, that line gets blurred, because advances in hardware can change the software algorithms we create. The biggest example of that is threads / concurrency.
So mostly I put hardware under the field of computer engineering and not science, but there’s always going to be crossover between the two.
1
1
Mar 07 '21
Computer architecture is not my area of passion or expertise. But I thought the 2 classes that I was required to take were enjoyable. It was tough but that just meant I really needed to comprehend what was happening. I also had a good professor which always helps.
-4
Mar 07 '21
If you don't know comp architecture you don't know anything about low level details
-8
Mar 07 '21
Did someone here ask you now?
-10
Mar 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/MadScientist2854 Mar 07 '21
lmao this thread is the epitome of childishness
1
Mar 08 '21
I was just joking. Actually, I'm a very mature person. I have spectacles
2
u/MadScientist2854 Mar 09 '21
ah, then i was obviously mistaken. i apologize, carry on
1
Mar 09 '21
Don’t apologize, this is a good place to have fun😉 but don’t forget to downvote @no-cobbler55😛
-6
3
2
Mar 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/_ArseniyKD_ Mar 07 '21
Holy crap, thanks for the feedback. I'll provide some context you may be missing, as it'll make some of your feedback a bit funny.
Re 1: I am reading off a script. I am incredibly bad at being concise while improvising, and I really like writing. I legit have my phone sitting on my laptop with the laptop working as a makeshift teleprompter. I am hoping to get better at this, but it'll take a whole bunch of time.
Re 2: you can see a microphone in the background of the video, I just couldn't be bothered setting that up at the time of recording (long day at work). Also, if you watch my other video (which isn't related to CS, so it's up to you) you'll know that this is pretty much an empty apartment for now. Once I get furniture, the echo should get better, and once I set up my "home office" in the den, I'll likely move recording to there.
Re 3: I wish, but I got nothing to put up, and nothing to place it on. I think that my switch in the background is the most colorful thing I currently have lol.
Re 4: The source footage was 24 minutes. And there are some nutty jump cuts already. Just look at the 4th comment in the middle of the video. My hand appears in the shot, and then disappears right away. I cut out a decently big bad take there. I need to learn to keep a balance between natural looking and sounding video and limiting pauses. Also, I am editing on kinda shitty hardware, so I have to make cuts based on audio, not audio and video lol (the timeline lags so bad that I can't see exactly what I am cutting out).
Either way, seriously thank you for the feedback, I'll work into incorporating it into future videos over the coming months.
:)
22
u/ripperroo5 Mar 07 '21
Love the spirit of what you're making, nice