r/computerscience • • Nov 15 '20

General The first computer "Analytical Engine" was designed in 1837 however due to a lack of funding it wasn't constructed so it was not until 1941 that the first general-purpose computer, Z3, was built

/r/UnpopularFacts/comments/iwzab6/the_first_computer_analytical_engine_was_designed/
148 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

13

u/CavemanKnuckles Nov 15 '20

I posted this in the original, but this had two good reasons for never being made: expense and Babbage's personality.

While the Analytical Engine was never made, his Difference Engine.... Also was never* made! The British government gave Babbage £1700 in 1823. For reference, the Vulcan locomotive cost £1,669 in 1837.

Why would the British government give Babbage the equivalent of a train worth of money? Well, he had done some calculations with logarithm tables in the back of some naval reference manuals. It turns out some were incorrect! These calculations were crucial for the British navy for some reason I'm not sure about. Well, I mean, the government was £1700 sure this was something they should invest in.

It seemed like a safe investment. After all, Babbage was the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge, a position previously held by Isaac Newton. And he had published a paper earlier describing his machine. Unfortunately, he was an ass and a procrastinator. Apparently he has gotten in a feud with the brass machinist working on his parts, and he melted down some parts I think? Also he already had other plans on his mind, the Analytical Engine shared here.

Until a couple years ago, you could see a working instance of the Difference Engine machine at the Computer History Museum in Mountain View, California, just a stone's throw away from Google HQ. And I did! The gentleman operating the crank showed all the different parts, and explained that half of them were actually in the printer. The "difference" in difference engine is a way of calculating polynomials called the method of difference. And polynomial approximations of important functions were readily available and had reasonable error bounds.

Unlike the Difference Engine, no Analytic Engine has ever been made, in Victorian or contemporary times.

6

u/SV-97 Nov 15 '20

These calculations were crucial for the British navy for some reason I'm not sure about.

If I remember correctly they were (maybe among other things? I could imagine that navigation also uses logarithms in some places) used for ballistics calculations.

1

u/Broad_Project_87 Sep 19 '26

necro, but yes, Ballistic calculations, also known as "fire control" in the navy, was not only see major benefits from this device, but historically, the most advanced, accurate and precise mechanical computers were Battleship fire control systems. Infact, somewhat famously, when the Iowa class's mechanical computers were so advanced and accurate that they were *completely untouched* when retrofitted in the 1980s, the navy literally looked at them, asked "do we need to make an upgrade?" and then determined the awnser was a shocking "no"

1

u/Chinohito Jun 06 '24

But could it have been made? With the technology and resources and knowledge of the time, assuming these interpersonal problems didn't get in the way and more funding was received?

1

u/CavemanKnuckles Jun 06 '24

The difference engine absolutely could have been made with the technology of the time. I don't know about the analytic engine, mostly because, to my knowledge, nobody has actualized the designs for the analytical engine yet.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '20

Weren't a lot of these first computers invented for the purpose of counting the census? I think I remember hearing that in one of my Comp Sci classes but that could be wrong.