r/computerscience • u/WSTEMadvocate • Aug 26 '20
Computer Science is not just Programming!!!
I am tired of hearing Computer Science being referred to as a programming major and computer scientists as programmers!
270
u/RockleyBob Aug 26 '20
My wife calls me an IT guy to fuck with me. She says things like âcan you fix my printer?â Sheâs an asshole.
But seriously though, itâs not that big of a deal when people donât know these things. Donât wrap your ego up in your title or intellect.
45
u/TheMusiKid Aug 26 '20
Donât wrap your ego up in your title or intellect.
As someone who wrapped my ego up in my intellect, and then got schizophrenia and lost my intellect, I can confirm this advice.
Don't solidify your identity or sense of self in superficial shit that can go away at a moment's notice. Better yet, keep no labels for yourself or anyone else!
And don't sweat shit that doesn't matter.
16
u/Name_Zam37 Aug 26 '20
I want to give you a medal, really, man! But instead I'd donate the same amount to the needy â plenty out there in these Covid times.
This donation is inspired by you, so that's a medal, no? :)
Cheers to you, valuable advice this.
2
u/Iusmani Aug 26 '20
Lol. I used to be the IT guy of my high school when it came to fixing the teacherâs computers and projectors
0
33
u/mondaymorningCoffee Aug 26 '20
do you mean my 1 week bootcamp does not qualify me as a computer scientist? I watched a video on linear algebra!
0
82
u/IntelInFolsom Aug 26 '20
It would be like if we called Biology "Microscope Science". Computer Science is the science of computation. It is not programming, it is not IT, it is not Information Systems.
7
Aug 26 '20
In Mexico we call it sciences of computation and in my University they refer to us as computologists. "Ciencias de la computaciĂłn y computologos" But it's a small niche, most people think we're engineers
34
Aug 26 '20
[removed] â view removed comment
27
u/SandboxingViolence Aug 26 '20
Fun fact, in many languages it's called either computing science or informatic (for science of automatic information).
4
u/kedde1x PhD in Linked Data Aug 26 '20
Here in Denmark we call it "Datalogy" since it can also be seen as manipulating data
1
16
u/konbik Aug 26 '20
Indeed its a gross misrepresentation and public misconception. Donald Knuth thinks of programming as an Art. I think of it as a crucial skill necessary for Computer Scientists to be effective. If you have a hypothesis, you still need to know how to code and implement it in a properly tested way to verify it. Programming is indeed a core part of computer scientists and engineers. If someone is working on purely theoretical aspects, they probably identify themselves more as a Mathematician than a Computer Scientist.
âą
u/kboy101222 Computer Scientist Aug 26 '20
Also programming questions aren't allowed on this sub. Please stop posting them. Thanks!
4
u/east_lisp_junk Aug 26 '20
The sidebar could use some revision on this point.
1
u/kboy101222 Computer Scientist Aug 26 '20
Definitely, but I'm too new to do it
1
u/goomar420 Dec 28 '20
Which immediately begs the question, is this actually a rule of the sub or just your invention?
1
u/kboy101222 Computer Scientist Dec 28 '20
It's an actual rule, but at the time I posted that comment I was too new to just be updating the sidebar
28
u/Peter_See Aug 26 '20
Computer science is about programming in much the same way that biology is about microscopes.
45
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
Upvote for awareness when all of the programming jobs and a lot of tech jobs prefer CS degrees. And schools talking about career paths that the degrees absolutely do not prepare you for.
But this is kind of a chicken and an egg problem. CS was an invented degree for the emergence of consumer computers and software companies. The professors holding PhDs and teaching the courses are in Physics, Electrical Engineering, Math, etc., and have been teaching since floppy disks. CS is a joke of a title.
The degree is in computational theory. Then they sprinkle programming electives on top. Data Science should be itâs own degree. Computer Engineering should be itâs own degree. Software Engineering should be itâs own degree. Some of them are degrees, but the job postings will always say CS.
20
u/sharar_rs Aug 26 '20
So with a software engineering degree would you apply for a job that asks for a CS degree. Not trolling. It's a legit question I have now.
14
u/wsppan Aug 26 '20
Yes. HR says CS but we care if you can do the job regardless of the exact degree. Can you talk the talk and walk the walk?
15
u/fzammetti Aug 26 '20
Hell, most of us barely care if you HAVE a degree of ANY kind, period. Like, seriously... it's WAY down on my list when I'm interviewing candidates (now, the HR drones may have a different view, and that's unfortunate as far as I'm concerned because it means some good candidates were missed). Sure, it might be the deciding factor between two strong, otherwise equal candidates, but other than that, I really couldn't care less.
2
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
Exactly. Iâve had people who were new to coding, but had a psych degree and they would get further with my 6 years of experience in software development before my degree. I mean, they got weeded out in the technical interview, but I was getting shot down without any interviews. Itâs the HR resumĂ© screen. But to the original point Software Engineering > Computer Science for most regular dev skills for jobs. Universities are just slow as molasses. When I was deciding to finish my bachelors there were only 7 schools that had accredited Software Engineering as a major and not as a concentration. And they werenât well-known schools at all. I just ended up going CS and self-taught the skills.
20
0
Aug 26 '20
[deleted]
4
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
The degrees are all over the place. And they really overlap all over the place. Software engineering concentration is usually just choosing 2-4 classes which is a bootcampâs worth of instruction.
But you will get weeded out in HR sorts when you have 200 applicants and 30 have CS degrees. And there are a ton of CS blowhards that prefer CS degrees as necessary for minor coding jobs. Hiring managers glance at resumĂ©s because they donât have time when they have 150+ applicants. If you think they are going to 150 githubs youâre crazy lol.
On the college level, degree updates take years of approval. I had a DevOps teacher on the first approved DevOps class and I swear he asked us what we wanted to learn and asked us what DevOps means to us on the first day. This guy had his PhD for 12 years and spent his entirety in academia. That proves that the permanent professors arenât ready to teach the skills people think come with CS degrees. Adjunct professors do, but they are usually assigned Intro classes.
There are just two sides, the university and the job market. Universities are slowly adopting Software Engineering concentration and Data Science concentrations, but think about the past 20 years of CS graduates out there. I took ONE web programming class that didnât go past vanilla JavaScript. I took ONE database/data management course. ONE class focused on software engineering practices. The rest were math and logic and theory. But I am somehow more worthy than someone who has been messing around and doing data science for years without a degree? One class I took 4 years ago and only got a C? Iâm agreeing with you. And when I have actual hiring power, I vow to interview equally non-degrees/unrelated degrees and related degrees.
8
u/microchipsndip Aug 26 '20
My take is that before we start teaching about for loops and programming concepts and whatnot, we ought to teach students about the actual theory of computation. Automata, groups and universal algebra, lambda calculus and its friends, even simple category theory.
3
Aug 26 '20
It is being taught, just in parallel. Shamefully though (in my opinion) both maths AND programming/practical courses sacrifice the precious credit points (and with it, time) on some useless shit like basic economics (same shit taught in school for at least 90% of the course), business management (should be an optional course, besides nothing useful is getting taught there - you are just cramped with the task of "making your startup idea"), and couple others like, in my case, "English for computer science", which is taught buy a guy/gal who obviously has troubles with *both*.
5
u/microchipsndip Aug 26 '20
I'm a maths major and computer researcher, and I can assure you it is not taught in parallel. I write papers on category theory at work, but I won't have the prerequisites to study it in school for a couple more years. The really fundamental stuff is usually reserved for graduate-level or at least 3rd and 4th year maths courses.
I think that's bass ackwards; I wouldn't trust an engineer who hasn't studied physics, and I think we should apply the same concept to computer science.
9
u/-I-D-G-A-F- Aug 26 '20
Huge Upvote for data science needing its own degree.
8
u/proverbialbunny Data Scientist Aug 26 '20 edited Aug 26 '20
It has it's own degree.
Though, imho DS degrees have a long way to go. When SICP came out in 1979 it was amazing and ambitious. To today it is still considered one of the best, if not the best CS course you can take. In comparison 6.0002 (MIT's data science) is a cram of facts, one stacked on top of another, in a rush, without any real world connection or examples of how to use those tools or why you'd want to use them. It's a total mess. When comparing to when CS started DS has a ways to go.
(Universities all over the world copy MIT's classes either directly or as inspiration for what topics should be taught to get a degree. Because MIT is the gold standard, it can be inferred that if MIT is struggling to teach DS other universities are too.)
1
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
The majority of colleges today (I have free time so I still look) only offer BSCS with a concentration or Graduate Programs. Itâs a great business model for milking CS students into specialization. But think about the skills our jobs are requiring versus other fields. Accountants handle some pretty big stuff with a bachelors degree because they learn what they need. An engineer is usually ready to engineer their subject. Data Science could easily be a split of Stats and Software. I could even take most colleges and their catalogs and just tie already offered classes together. I agree DS has come a long way, and if your college offers it, great, but thereâs still a huge disconnect between slowly adapting universities and the hiring/applied skills expected. But schools have concentrations and Masters in Data Science.
3
u/proverbialbunny Data Scientist Aug 26 '20
Give it a few years. It will trickle down.
DS is nothing but stats but DS classes are quite a bit different from typical stats classes. There is a benefit in taking actual specialized DS classes, even if imho atm they aren't great classes.
3
Aug 26 '20
In my university, Computer Science, Software engineering, Computer Engineering, Informational Systems, Networking and, IIRC, Didactics, are offered as branches of Comp.Sci degree.
1
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
That was the same when I graduated a few years ago. The thing is, only 1-2 teachers teach the classes and can actually be a huge barrier to the concentrations. I wanted a SE concentration, but I knew the guy teaching half of the SE concentration classes so I avoided them. The people who have the experience and applications arenât the PhDâed permanent faculty. I had an adjunct professor teach OOP and above that, they were old fogies who have been doing nothing but teaching and a tad of research for 20 years.
3
u/kedde1x PhD in Linked Data Aug 26 '20
Many professors in CS have also been researching and teaching since floppy disks. Hell, floppy disks are for the most part a product of CS. I don't understand your point?
CS is applied mathematics. When people have a hard time comprrhending what I do, I just tell them I'm a mathematician. Because that's really what I do mostly. CS is broad, but then so is physics.
1
1
u/Chi-Cam Aug 26 '20
Tbf I think most accredited CS programs at least mine. Has a required Software engineering classes. We usually learn the theory than we learn the programming.
2
u/Tomato_Sky Aug 26 '20
Yeah, mine had 2. I also took 1 web programming course and 1 database course. In no way does that make me superior to someone who has been working for years or months. All of my skills are self-taught. The degree is just to get me interviews. None of my CS comes to play while I work. In peer review, if something isnât optimal, we have a team looking at it rather than writing code thinking about BigO. My CS degree had 60% of my courses just building things in C which already exist everywhere. Like building custom data structures, writing compilers, drawing automatas and sets.
Someone on here said itâs like if Biology was just Microscope Science, but most of what you learn in Biology and Chemistry are foundations for what you do. Modern CS students do not need a lot of this theory. They need theory, yes. But they can definitely trim the fat. The microscope science really gets to me and I love that analogy so it would be like learning the different kinds of microscopes, doing the math to determine light angles and degrees of refraction.
CS originated as a way to understand how computers work and how to utilize them. Then Computer Engineering came out and separated itself as hardware, processors, and the like. There is only now, very slowly, getting the software side with Software Engineering. Most of it is politics inside universities. How do you slowly downplay the CS degree to encourage Software Engineering if all job postings are still asking for CS degrees. What do you do with the department chair? Do you have all new classes? Information (fill in the blank) is a degree everyone offers, but they are all drastically easier than a CS degree and usually toss in Business as a core. Information Science/Systems/Technology degrees are great imo, but if they could offer something like it, but more programming focused. You donât need Calc 3 and Physics 300 to do any of these upper level CS classes. I could write a book about all the wacky things colleges do for more money, for professors, or to climb in rankings.
The best programmers I ever met were non-degree holders. I learned a TON from a bootcamp that was taught by professionals instead of professors. And everything I use for my job has been self-taught and none of my upper level degree courses are applicable anymore.
16
u/realsidg Aug 26 '20
Omg yes. A post this sub needs.
Specially with the hundreds of abstraction layers and way too developed frameworks. One can become a developer/programmer without studying any computer science. That's what is becoming popular and then being labelled as computer science.
4
21
u/sphrz Aug 26 '20
Literally didn't program for the majority of my junior and senior years of college. Was mainly theory.
12
u/ColdPotatoFries Aug 26 '20
Thats where ive been.
Freshman year was intro to java and data structure stuff.
Sophomore and junior/senior year is all theory, and i hate it.
Im not good at math and theres just so much, its overwhelming.
6
u/sphrz Aug 26 '20
Yeah I was never good at theory. Especially the discrete math, algorithm analysis (lots and lots of math) and automata theory. But I really enjoyed my senior compiler project, even through covid. It gets better!
6
Aug 26 '20
Automata theory and dicrete maths are the most fun I've had with math-oriented courses. I also think they are sort-of the easiest bunch. (Linear algebra comes second, it gets a bit tedious later on, past eigenvalues/vectors)
Now, *calculus*...
3
u/sphrz Aug 26 '20
I enjoyed calculus and linear algebra. Discrete math kicked my ass. Automata showed me how bad I am with language creation..
3
u/ColdPotatoFries Aug 26 '20
Yeah ive got Software as a Service, my senior capstone, operating systems, and an internship.
Safe to say im going to be doing a lot of coding this semester.
3
u/sphrz Aug 26 '20
I loved OS. We worked on the xv6 is which was really cool and informative. That is a cool capstone! I wish you the best of luck man (or girl) and hope you love what you do after college.
7
u/ColdPotatoFries Aug 26 '20
Yeahhhh, wish I knew this before i went to school for computer science.
I honestly have no interest in how turing machines work, mathematical proofs, set theory, etc etc etc.
I just wanna tippy type and make things happen on my computer. But here i am, $80k later and a senior, getting a degree in CS.
Oh well, i just hope it comes in handy some day. If it does, itll be worth it.
4
Aug 26 '20
Well, it will surely come handy in getting a job where you Tippy type and make things happen(SDE), I guess
7
u/kedde1x PhD in Linked Data Aug 26 '20
I've resorted to just telling people I am a mathematician at this point. That's what I do 90% of the time anyways, and I won't get asked to fix peoples printers.
5
13
u/joerefe Aug 26 '20
Amen, there are operating systems too and they make me want to kms
6
u/misterforsa Aug 26 '20
Kms?
15
10
3
2
u/SO012215 Aug 26 '20
I think it is important to remember that CS is an abstraction ontop of mathematics and engineering, similar to how programming is abstracted ontop of CS.
You can peel layers and add titles and labels but in the end it all boils down to first principles.
2
2
u/Suvo004 Aug 26 '20
CS is field of computer where computer enthusiast learn about in and out of the computer. But lots of people thinks it is just a subject for grabbing a software developer job and earnings thousands of dollars.
1
1
1
u/academic_and_job Aug 26 '20
Itâs because the misleading of major establishment
I could be wrong, but AFAIK thereâs no SDE major in the state so of course people often regard CS as SDE
Some countries have both SDE and CS majors
1
1
Aug 26 '20
"Computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes."
(Attributed to) Dijkstra.
1
1
u/Monstot Aug 26 '20
The only people saying that have no understanding what all goes into a CS degree. And if a CS student is saying this they aren't paying attention.
People outside the field are just ignorant. Just as much as we are to their field I'm sure.
I've never heard this said though.
1
u/helium-glycerol27 Aug 26 '20
not only is this true but its extremely confusing to new college students and Im still not entirely sure what to do this has to be changed!
1
1
Aug 26 '20
Computer science and Information technology degrees are almost identical at my state university literally with only about 5 different classes. Both program, both need the same math, the only difference is those 5 extra classes give or take are on theory when IT does information science classes. I know someone here is gonna get butthurt but look at college required courses and most of them overlap.
1
-2
u/mondaymorningCoffee Aug 26 '20
there should be state/federal licensing procedures for being a computer engineer.
0
188
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
Yeah uhhh mathematics is just calculator science