r/computerscience • • Oct 11 '19

Don't learn to code. Learn to think, A great read.

https://www.ybrikman.com/writing/2014/05/19/dont-learn-to-code-learn-to-think/
300 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

12

u/plappl Oct 12 '19

This is a fantastic article about the introduction to computer science and how it is distinguished from computer programming. I'm personally going to link to this when people ask advice about CS.

14

u/WilliamTheStressed Oct 11 '19

It's quite a nice read. I'm currently doing A-levels in the UK, one being CS obviously, but I did computer science at secondary school as a core subject and they didn't teach us any theory. It was more a software tutorial until I chose to do it as a GCSE. GCSE is basic but similar to what they describe in the article, focusing more on coding and algorithmic thinking.

2

u/Neu_Ron Oct 12 '19

He leaves out computation and the theory of computation in his article. The big learn is computation and computers existed before the invention of the processor and before van neumann model.

1

u/Misterbreadcrum Oct 12 '19

Nice article but I think it's biased. Hear me out: we see Cs fundamental concepts as important to our daily lives because we use them in our daily lives. I'm really not sure many people actually would be better off at the end of their day if they knew divide and conquer or recursion.

I think we find these things overly important simply because they're important to us. So I think that the bit about Jeff Atwood is just a bit off base, I dont think he does misunderstand the difference between CS and coding, I think he understands it very well, and I think he's right to say not everyone would benefit from it.

It's a bit like saying we'd all be better off if we learned physics. Are we surrounded by physics models in our daily lives? Of course. Do we need to understand them discreetly to better navigate said daily lives? Of course not.

2

u/plappl Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

CS is important if you believe it is important to understand the nature of computations. If your life doesn't require deep understanding of computations, then your life doesn't need the knowledge of CS; you can leave it to us CS geeks spend to our time contemplating the computations that humanity uses to process our information.

0

u/Tony2sf Oct 13 '19

US colleges and universities are now flooded by graduate students from China and India. American undergraduates have hard time finding job and internship even in science and engineering fields because foreign graduate students are allowed to work during school time and after graduation. Chinese and Indian students are abusing "Curricular Practical Training (CPT)" and "Optional Practical Training (OPT)" that allow them to work off-campus up to three years.

While encouraged to major in STEM, we are in a very helpless position. Our families can financially support us at most for undergraduate, and we don't go to graduate school due to financial burdens and have to work. US universities want to get easy and quick money from their tuition, but they will take away our jobs because employers want to hire master/PhD graduates due to huge supply.

Because they were brain washed in China, even though they came to US, became US citizen, or got green card, most Chinese are anti-American and support the totalitarian evil Chinese communist government. We don't want them to stay in US after graduation.

Please hire American students.

Call/write White House, US Citizen and Immigration Services, and your congress persons to revoke or put strong restrictions on CPT and OPT.

2

u/plappl Oct 13 '19

Having many people with a STEM education is a good thing. If there are not enough jobs to accommodate all the STEM graduates, it is their own responsibility to create new jobs to make use of that knowledge. They will need to study the basics of starting/running a business so they can start businesses to provide these jobs.