234
u/Kike328 Aug 08 '24
i didn’t dig deep, but the “cpu/embedded” part are just random words pointing each other
56
u/hidude398 Aug 08 '24
It’s not much better around encryption or protocols
35
u/kraemahz Aug 08 '24
It also doesn't make any sense for there to be a bunch of pictures about coax and fiber optics cables in a computer science map.
There's also no discussion of error-correcting-codes that would have made far more sense to go in that place.
And we're missing the entire field of machine learning and any discussion of algorithmic complexity. So this is like saying you have a map of Europe and only putting in a map of Paris.
3
u/MaxTerraeDickens Aug 09 '24
Maybe a map of Mediterranean countries. ML and complexity theory can be the Nordic countries, and those fiber stuff are Middle Eastern ones.
19
u/RajjSinghh Aug 08 '24
Isnt all CPU/embedded just random words pointing to each other?
5
5
u/Lucky_Squirrel365 Aug 09 '24
This comment deserves more upvotes. Should've put pun intended though, I feel it went above many heads.
108
u/ywaltjs Aug 08 '24
91
u/pixel-counter-bot Aug 08 '24
The image in this post has 8,847,360(4,096×2,160) pixels!
I am a bot. This action was performed automatically.
59
56
u/Ok-Interaction-8891 Aug 08 '24
I’m amused to see that artificial intelligence is listed under “emerging trends” despite being an active field of research and development since the 1940’s, at least.
13
Aug 08 '24
It does kind of redefine itself every 10 years or so :)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect9
u/Ok-Interaction-8891 Aug 08 '24
I’m unsure what the AI effect has to do with my comment, tbh, as I’m not discounting the capabilities of past, present, or future AI systems.
I just think it’s amusing that AI is listed on this chart as an emerging trend despite it being a part of computer science research and development for nearly a hundred years.
Neat article, tho.
2
Aug 08 '24
I should have wrote more haha
Ya I agree. I'm in KRR and I've learned to not let it get under my skin when people synonymize "AI" with "statistical machine learning".I don't think AI really is a well defined field other than "AI is whatever hasn't been done yet" (Tesler's Theorem on that page)
It's even more amusing that the problem of people saying AI is new isn't even a new one :)
2
1
u/lizardfolkwarrior Aug 09 '24
I don't think AI really is a well defined field other than "AI is whatever hasn't been done yet"
In Russel and Norvig, they give 4 definitions:
AI is (artificial) agents acting rationally
AI is (artificial) agents acting in a human-like way
AI is (artificial) agents thinking rationally
AI is (artificial) agents thinking in a human-like way
This is a super broad, all encompassing definition; and even this is way, way more specific than what you said. I would even say that only 1) and 2) are enough (especially the 4)th definition is more related to cognitive science, which might study AI, but it isn’t CS). But this is already not a weirdly broad definition; not much broader than the definition of other major areas of CS, like “software engineering”, “theoretical CS”, etc.
1
Aug 13 '24
Yeah part of the difference with AI from other CS fields is that the main topics of study have changed radically over the years.
Software engineers are still building software, theorists are still doing computability...But years ago, the state of the art AI was converting an assembler program to machine code.
AI seems to reinvent itself every 10 years or so.
There are certainly parts that don't change though.I'd even argue that the Russel and Norbig definitions are also too narrow; there's a good chunk of AI research that does not strictly deal with agents (such as KRR)
19
23
u/ButchDeanCA Aug 08 '24
Why are there terms to do with practical computing in there? These days people just don’t know what computer science is, or maybe it changed since my day.
12
u/MooseBoys Aug 08 '24
Yeah I’d say this is more of a chart of technology literacy. Many people interested in CS will also be interested in tech in general, but you don’t need to know how twisted pair works to understand computer science.
4
Aug 08 '24
Right? Twisted pairs in eth aren't CS :P
Though some programs at technical schools will blend CS and IT
18
5
5
4
u/Trivial_Automorphism Aug 09 '24
It is missing the entire part of theoretical computer science
3
u/srsNDavis Aug 11 '24 edited Aug 11 '24
Yeah it's more of a cross between CS and IT that drops a lot of the mathsy parts of CS.
Even the 'algorithms' section is wayyyy simpler than what I studied in my CS mods - 'algorithms' meant 'algorithm design paradigms' such as dynamic programming, D&C, greedy algorithms, some graph theory, and likely some complexity theory.
A more advanced take on algorithms would probably include randomised, approximation, and concurrent algorithms (... but I'm not holding that against the OP because it says 'basics').
7
u/Aaron1924 Aug 08 '24
I feel like this would be a really cool community project if we could turn this into an interactive website that people could edit
5
3
4
u/Nico_792 Aug 08 '24
The programming section looks like a scientists look into python. This is pretty mid at best
2
u/pseudo_space Aug 09 '24
Am I the only one who feels this looks suspiciously like the map of France?
2
2
2
3
3
u/zagriouso Aug 08 '24
OP send the link/file of the post pls
P.S is there any way to view this one like the posts on r/coolguides ? Like zooming doesn't change it's quality?
3
1
1
1
1
u/MoonTrooper258 Aug 08 '24
Ah, I see the issue here. The image rendering node passes into the JPEG area and outputs through a potato.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/gnash117 Aug 08 '24
When I zoom in on my phone it is almost unreadable. Is the because of my phone? Anyone have a higher resolution link?
1
1
u/zenos_dog Aug 08 '24
The definitive model is here: https://www.dmtf.org/standards/cim/cim_schema_v2550
I worked on a small part of it.
1
u/Much_Highlight_1309 Aug 08 '24
I really enjoyed the part about a "technique" called "comments & indenations". Superb.
I have to agree that this is definitely "basic".
1
1
1
u/GCSS-MC Aug 09 '24
Stop, don't tell the people with zero experience that want a cybersecurity job that it is actually an advanced domain near the edge of this map.
1
1
u/laughinbuddha2 Aug 09 '24
Remind me! In 2 days
1
u/RemindMeBot Aug 09 '24
I will be messaging you in 2 days on 2024-08-11 01:23:30 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.
Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback
1
1
1
1
1
u/transtrudeau Aug 09 '24
I’m a random layperson that doesn’t understand what I’m looking at, but it’s beautiful
1
u/blackerbird Aug 09 '24
How on earth does stuff like this get upvoted? It’s not remotely useful or interesting. I’m sure it’s a good study aid to the particular person who made it for their high school exam but that is all it’s good for
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Character-Education3 Aug 11 '24
And if you follow our new plan you can learn it all it just 14 days
1
u/srsNDavis Aug 11 '24 edited Aug 11 '24
Saved. I don't see a few things (e.g. ECCs, computability and complexity), but I'd give the benefit of the doubt to the OP because a 'typical' CS curriculum varies a bit across the world. This looks like a cross between CS and IT for the most part.
The one thing I'd cavil at, though, is that this map risks miscommunicating the mathematics you might need for any serious understanding of some of these subdomains, e.g. AI/ML, QC
1
1
1
1
u/supabadbrutha Aug 12 '24
This is a word for word repost from a few years ago https://www.reddit.com/r/computerscience/s/Dn9f8zVN7j
1
u/tech_enthoosiast Aug 13 '24
I think the map is trying its best to cover everything, but it does feel like it missed a few exits on the computer science highway. Maybe a sequel could zoom in on some of those finer details?
1
1
1
1
u/random9s Aug 08 '24
In the words of Edsger Djikstra, “Computer Science is as much about computers as astronomy is about telescopes”.
You’ve conflated computer science with software engineering and programming. They’re separate concepts with independent but related basics.
1
u/Badner_Bueb Aug 09 '24
Programming-> data types-> data structures->the bigger picture -> environment -> waste -> toxic heavy metals
What are you smoking? That’s useless.
-5
u/amarao_san Aug 08 '24
A descent classification of random things should not ignore those belonging to the emperior and looking like a fly from a distance.
If you want to put defgramentators and ROM | Virtual memory in a single chart, better to remember include those broken the porcelian vase.
1
u/one-trick-hamster Aug 08 '24
Ok, so what is the porcelain vase in this case
Is it the unreadably low image resolution?
1
u/amarao_san Aug 08 '24
1
u/one-trick-hamster Aug 08 '24
Huh, that's interesting.
I mean for all I know the ones who broke the vase could be in that image, I literally can't even read the words!
kinda like the joke shirts with complex circuit diagrams for no particular reason, the 'basics' of cs being portrayed as a convoluted mess must've tickled OP's funny bone.
0
u/mwcz Aug 08 '24
I can imagine showing this to a mentee and saying "What would you like to talk about today?"
0
-2
u/Unclerojelio Aug 08 '24
I'd cross post this to r/learnprogramming but they don't allow cross posting.
6
u/BackendSpecialist Aug 08 '24
In this instance that’s great cause this is a useless graphic, especially to that audience.
1
u/Unclerojelio Aug 08 '24
That audience is, for the most part, comprised of people that think that one or two online courses makes you a programmer. This graphic might help to illustrate what they are getting into.
-1
-9
-5
90
Aug 08 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
47
u/DevelopmentHumble299 Aug 08 '24
Am I the only one that gets a crisp image when zooming in? Mine looks perfectly fine when I zoom in more, does yours not?
30
u/Vivorio Aug 08 '24
I'm on phone and I can't see it crisp sharp. I download and saw and was perfectly crisp. I assume reddit is not loading the full qualify.
6
4
1
u/SnooAdvice1157 Aug 08 '24
You use pc?
1
1
1
7
3
1
1
-1
1
Aug 08 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/computerscience-ModTeam Aug 09 '24
Unfortunately, your post has been removed for violation of Rule 2: "Be civil".
If you believe this to be an error, please contact the moderators.
172
u/diegoasecas Aug 08 '24
this is awful