r/computerscience • • Jan 11 '24

Is computer science dying?

I’m a highschool senior that is planning on pursuing computer science in college and as a career. i’m starting to learn more and spending more outside time on watching coding videos and such. But as i’m spending more time in this field, I keep seeing my people saying “coding is dying” or “if you don’t learn ai now you’ll be behind everyone” which is worrying me quite a bit. Is this field really dying or being taken over by ai? Or is there still an incredibly large field that will still demand people for some time to come?

10 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

106

u/tenfingerperson Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

Programming is not Computer science , AI is a field within computer science , along with tons of other things … CS is a field of applied mathematics

Computers implement concepts of CS, not the other way around

3

u/General-Ad3307 May 13 '24

Yes. Its true. The math behinds cs is so beautiful. I felt in love with math when I realized the power of math. From big data to NLP. Its really hard but interesting to learn from the first principle.

-10

u/ent1pe Jan 11 '24

Thank you, that makes a lot of sense. I guess my question is more are computer science-related jobs dying or harder to get because of AI?

22

u/TangledGoatsucker Jan 12 '24

The issue has been outsourcing of jobs or insourcing cheaper labor.

10

u/ninjadude93 Jan 12 '24

Search this sub for your question because its probably been answered about a thousand times now. Short answer no it isnt going anywhere

3

u/istarian Jan 12 '24

If there are fewer jobs available it is because most of the work being done is in/for the corporate world where maximum profit is the driving objective.

Every additional employee adds cost and doesn't necessarily produce returns in excess of that cost, unless you exploit them by forcing them to work long hours for as little payment as they'll accept.

23

u/SexyMuon Jan 11 '24

They’re full of shit. I opened an Instagram a couple of days ago to watch some videos my girlfriend likes to share with me, and there is soooo much bs there, so much misinformation, so many people posting how gpt will replace all programmers. I think it’s hilarious. Don’t waste your time with these people, and let them assume whatever they want. Learn a language and learn it well, eventually you’ll know under which side of the CS umbrella you’d like to stand under

2

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

I see, thank you very much. this was really reassuring

3

u/SexyMuon Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

I use LLMs for things like translating a cURL request to axios, for writing a scheme, writing the base of a bash script, and little things along those lines. Essentially, things I don’t wanna do and things that are trivial. Should you use whatever output you get? No, you polish the output until you know it’s safe and not too redundant at least. These things are powerful indeed, but we shouldn’t be worried. Finally, you’ll be fine and welcome to cs.

6

u/istarian Jan 12 '24

The only reason you can do things like that at all is that there is a massive pool of code and programs that a real human programmer wrote.

Your LLM has been trained by feeding it that pre-existing work. Then it is able to generate plausible code to solve the same problems.


It's kind of like training construction workers to build a house that will be earthquake resistant (based on a plan that architects and civil engineers design and checked) and then sending them out to build new and different houses.

Hopefully the other homes they build will be earthquake resistant by virtue of incorporating similar design elements despite the fact that they do not understand complex math or physics.

3

u/SexyMuon Jan 12 '24

That’s a fantastic definition - I know you are not expecting a compliment, but I truly agree.

Artificial intelligence is merely stochastics and mathematics. These things shall only do one thing: find a function f that can map f(A) = B given a pair of input and output signals.

There’s this marketing overhype or whatever, and people now mistakenly believe that they can speak with them directly.

// - - -

I think this is from Programming Pearls: “Coding skill is just one small part of writing correct programs. The majority of the task is problem definition, algorithm design and data structure selection."

1

u/Proper_Guarantee_650 Jul 29 '24

Yeah but a LLM can store and access all that data at once.

LLM can read an API it’s never seen and learn it on the spot then spit out code a few seconds later. Then if I don’t like it, I can say what I don’t like about the code, tell the AI to change it so that this particular issue that I pointed out no longer happens anymore, and it will usually do that.

Humans can’t do that within seconds.

10

u/gboncoffee Jan 11 '24

who develops AI? computer scientists

1

u/ent1pe Jan 11 '24

right but if AI advances to the point where it can write more complex code, wouldn’t companies use more ai over actual programmers?

9

u/gboncoffee Jan 12 '24

if you want to study computer science to become an average programmer you should actually take a technical degree

I don’t know how it works in your country but in mine, Computer Science is an academic field and former students are expected to go to research instead of working as programmers

5

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jan 12 '24

In the United States (where OP appears to be from based on their post history) software engineering degrees are uncommon, and most professional programmers have a bachelors in "computer science." It's primarily at their graduate and especially PhD level that the fields diverge more significantly.

2

u/gboncoffee Jan 12 '24

Thanks for the explanation. So the confusion between the computer science as a science and as a technical profession is understandable

1

u/istarian Jan 12 '24

Try creating code with ChatGPT and see how fast you run into a problem... Even better, see if you can fix the problem.

Most "AI" people talk about today is some sort of ML (or 'machine learning') and it needs to be providing a set of "training" data.

The top scenario will probably work out okay for simple "problems" where many solutions already exist and can be given to it as a data set to train on.

If you can't google search your way to working code that serves your needs, then AI probably isn't going to turn up any better results.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '24

I don't think it will reach that point, there is still a very big ethical debate about AI and a lot of people are actually against it. Steven Hawkins warned that full AI could be the end of the human race which doesn't seem too farfetched imo.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/gboncoffee Jul 28 '24

Lmao at first glance I though you were being serious

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '24

And these business people usually have a computer science background.

7

u/Trump_Did_Benghazi Jan 12 '24

I am begging you to stop watching comp sci YouTubers/influencers and just focus on your class work

1

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

It’s more of the comments I see when i watch coding tutorials and what not, not necessarily the people themselves saying that it’s dying. And id say im doing pretty well in school considering im top 20 in a class of 500 and already got into my top schools. But i agree that social media puts false narratives into my head

3

u/broshrugged Jan 12 '24

There is an extremely outsized representation of fear and uncertainty on the internet. You are going to be absolutely fine. If you want to reassure yourself, look at the top earning bachelors degrees. CS is up there.

1

u/Trump_Did_Benghazi Jan 12 '24

https://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/home.htm

There’s plenty of jobs in the field, it’s all good.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '24

Yeah, but what proportion of them are actually good, desireable, well-paying jobs? Plenty will exploit you and stress you out and leave you an eternal renter, perhaps even living with your parents in your 40s.

When selecting a career path, personal excellence is a MUST for success.

1

u/Trump_Did_Benghazi Jan 13 '24 edited Jan 13 '24

Well, I just plugged “software engineer” into zip recruiter for my city (not a tech hub) and only let it show jobs within 25 miles of me. That narrow search gave me ~6000 jobs with not a single one offering less than 70k/yr, with most offering more. Given that the median US income is 31k/yr, yeah I’d say you’ll at least be doing okay

And even besides that, big tech is gonna go back on their old hiring spree inflated to the moon salary ways the very second interest rates fall back down and debt becomes cheap again. This shit is all cyclical. Just handle your business and control what you can control. You’ll be fine

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '24

What is definitely true is that the competition is stiff.

Realistically, 3/4 of the students at your high school are irrelevant academic and economic competitors.

the top quartile is what you will be competing against in the relatively near future( within 10 years)

There will be a bloodbath. And like the layoffs now, there will be more.

Such is the inevitability of capitalism.

But its gifts are great. The question is: are you able to win it?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

We do not have AI yet by a long shot, and when we do it will cause a 100x expansion of software into all industries. That AI will make terrible bugs, and you will be paid handsomely to fix those bugs. You'll be paid even more to know *why* those bugs got in there.

If you're hearing this stuff on youtube, tiktok, etc. then try my strategy for learning programming from social media: don't do it unless it's concrete, practical tutorials. Those platforms are not capable of delivering higher-level ideas in rapid short-form content. If they venture into that territory, they can only use big concepts to elicit fear, which is what you've caught. It's a good way for them to keep you watching even though they have nothing to say.

Listen to an hour long interview of some of Comp Sci's greatest thinkers, Dijkstra, Ritchie, Kernighan, Thompson, van Rossum, etc. The creator of your favorite programming language is a good place to start looking.

And please read the textbooks when you get into college. Like actually buy the book for the course, unless it's a manual you can download for free in ebook format. My biggest mistake was thinking I could learn it all from the internet for free, when a lot of the theory of Computation is best learned in book form. I'm 29 now and my programming skills jumped the most about 3 years ago when I found a reading list of must-read Comp Sci books and powered through them. The first practical book I recommend is of course Pragmatic Programmer.

1

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

Ah okay thank you very much for your suggestions. I guess my concerns more lied with a bunch of comments from people saying these things but I should know better than to listen to some random youtube comments. I’m currently watching the full harvard CS50 course but as soon as i finish, I’ll take your channel suggestions as well. Thank you very much!

3

u/SnooDucks7641 Jan 12 '24

We have less people who really understand what is going on as we keep building on top of abstractions. I would say the field is very much alive for those who want to solve real-world problems in computer science. I think that the education quality in CS has gone down a lot since back in the 80s though.

2

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

I agree. My ap comp sci class has an awful lesson format and awful unqualified teacher that i haven’t learned a single thing from. Everything I’ve learned has been from self teaching. I also think a lot of people are getting into this field because it ranks as one of the best paying jobs even if it isn’t their passion

2

u/irish-sinner Jan 11 '24

As others have said. Computer science is not the same as ai nor vise versa. Plus, AI is only ever going to be as good as it's best programmer. There will always be a need to bring new and more to the table.

But I will counter your worries with, why computer science? It's a great field with tons to learn. But did you choose computer science because you like working with computers or because you like the concept of how they work. If it is the former, then don't limit your options thinking computer science is the only way to go. If you have an interest in computers maybe try Networking, there is and always will be a need for Network Admins. Every business has a need for networks. Interested in the world of hacking? Get your hands in to Cyber Security. Interested in data? Try looking in to data analytics and cloud computing.

1

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

Thank you. I guess my main concern is that fact that not only is AI developing very fast which could potentially take jobs but also that the field in general is becoming extremely competitive and hard to get a job. I find coding and developing software very fun but i haven’t even thought of those things you mentioned. I’ll definitely look into those things. Thanks again

2

u/voidsifr Jan 12 '24

Someone has to build the systems for AI to run in in the first place to be of any use to anyone.

AI in general has always been overhyped. There was a paper I read about the cycles AI hype goes through, I'd have to look for it. But the gist of it was this.

We had symbol manipulation techniques and rule based systems. Then we went into an "AI winter" where no significant research was done for 2 decades. Then all of sudden we had hardware innovation in the 80s and we thought expert systems and machine learning was going to replace everyone. Then we had an AI winter. Then we had enough compute power to do meaningful things with neural networks in the 90s. And everyone swore neural networks were the end all be all.

There's a couple more cycles I'm forgetting, but I suspect LLMs are the next boom for now. Eventually it'll run dry until the next innovation.

My personal experience with coding and LLMS is that you can't trust it to produce good reliable code. I have a coworker that will blindly trust it and we can tell when we do the code review cuz it's just so bad lol. So you have to know what you doing already in order for the AI results to be meaningful. I use it for work to explore ideas, but that's about it. 99% of the code I ask it to generate is really bad lol.

1

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

Ah thank you so much for your input. And I totally agree about it being overhyped. I saw a CES 2024 review and it seemed that a lot of companies would use “AI” in order to demonstrate their advancement compared to the rest of the industry, at least on the surface level, but it didn’t seem to actually do much compared to what’s already out there. Thank you again!

67

u/Lahimasdisciple Jan 11 '24

“Computer science is dying” and “if you don’t learn AI now you’ll be behind everyone” are two statements which cannot be true simultaneously. The success of AI necessitates the longevity of computer science as a discipline. Generally this kind of inflammatory, sweeping statement should raise red flags. 

5

u/JairoHyro Jan 12 '24

A simple correct answer

2

u/RSNKailash Jan 12 '24

I think at most CS jobs may change and focus more on designing, implementing, and using AI. But the way I see it, someone has to actually write all that ML and AI, the more these things integrate into people's lives, the more demand there will be.

31

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jan 11 '24 • Bravo

Is computer science dying? Is coding dying?

No. Generative AI is good at copying text it's seen before, and tweaking it to match a prompt. It's quite good at regurgitating simple boilerplate code that's been written countless times before, like "read a CSV file and get me a particular column."

Generative AI is not creative. It cannot solve novel problems, and it cannot design software, and it fundamentally does not know what it's doing. If we widely adopt generative AI into the workflow of developing software (which seems like it could be likely!) we will still need humans to design the software, break it into building blocks, identify the building blocks that are simple enough for generative AI to solve, and verify the solutions we get back.

Generative AI can't understand if the code it produces works or is bug-free, and definitely can't understand more conceptual tasks like how to design a program, because Large Language Models don't "think." We've produced an incredibly powerful autocomplete, but its role is still to predict the next token based on prior tokens and a context window, and to mistake it for a reasoning consciousness that can "take over" the field would be a mistake.

All of that is just speaking to writing code. As others have pointed out, computer science is much broader than programming, and LLMs are no substitute for human thought.

If you don’t learn ai now you’ll be behind everyone. Is there still an incredibly large field that will still demand people for some time to come?

Now these are very different questions. If we use generative AI to automate writing simpler code, then fewer programmers today can finish the same work that would take more programmers just five years ago. You can't replace a whole human with AI, but maybe a team of eight people plus AI can do the work of ten people without AI. The labor market could shrink considerably, especially for entry-level software engineering.

2

u/Proper_Guarantee_650 Jul 29 '24

Most of CS is not inventing a solution, it’s editing something that’s already been solved to your liking. Exactly what generative AI does.

When was the last time you made strides in computer science solving a problem that’s never been solved before? I don’t get this argument.

1

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jul 29 '24

This is a rather old post, so I doubt you'll get responses from anyone but me. First, it sounds like you may be conflating computer science and software engineering. Within the design of new software, I'd argue that a bigger part of the job is thinking about how to approach a problem and what building blocks you're going to need and how they'll fit together. Once you get down to implementing those building blocks, then yes, you're often repurposing things that have been solved before for your use-case, and that's the part of software engineering that LLMs are best suited for. In other words, we've built LLMs to write code, but most of software engineering is not writing code; the engineering is the planning and design, not the construction.

When was the last time you made strides in computer science solving a problem that’s never been solved before?

Quite recently. I'm a research scientist, so working on novel problems is my day job. Computer science as a field is about knowledge representation and manipulation, and involves a lot of invention and analysis. Most of the computer scientists I know are closer to mathematicians and physicists than software engineers, and aren't all that great at writing code.

1

u/Proper_Guarantee_650 Jul 29 '24 edited Jul 29 '24

I agree with your perspective. However, AI can assist by suggesting how components fit together, so you just need to focus on defining the building blocks.

If you run the AIs code and it doesn’t match what you originally wanted, you can tell the AI what went wrong & it will generate a fix.

Your experience with computer science is likely influenced by your work in a research field. I would like you to give me a detailed description of a problem you want solved, and how you want something to work and I’ll test if I can use AI to generate it, with only 1 year of CS schooling (changed degrees)

I believe AI can solve the task if you describe the task for both you and other people to understand in full.

1

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jul 29 '24

I think you're describing the best we can hope for from LLMs: shifting more of the engineer's work from writing code to design. There's a question as to how well you can separate those components; we don't want to describe each block in such detail that it would be as fast to write the code yourself, and we don't want an "AI" (if we're counting token-prediction as intelligence) to implement a buggy block or one with unclear assumptions or side-effects because the agent isn't aware of the higher level design and how the blocks will integrate.

Certainly, my experience has been influenced by my work. I'd assert that computer science is a research field, and that science and engineering are distinct pursuits. There's certainly a lot of overlap between the disciplines, in part because both fields are young, and because many software engineers have computer science degrees in the United States, but we're slowly seeing a distinction emerge akin to physics and mechanical- or civil-engineering.

I am not going to spend the time to build an LLM test scenario with you. This is a fun high-level conversation, but if you want to go into that level of detail it will take much longer to specify the details of the problem and the criteria for correctness and analyze what the LLM does well or poorly with, with very little in it for me ;)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jan 14 '24

Not at all, for a variety of reasons. We could make arguments about free will and self-drive or the nature of creativity, but the difference I would like to focus on is that word 'token.' An LLM does not see words, it cannot see letters or shapes or sounds, but tokens - if this were a word embedding, each word would be a literal coordinate on the surface of a sphere - the context windows for an LLM are much more complicated, but not fundamentally different. Running vector math on coordinates in word embedded space can give a facsimile of understanding, but it falls short in a variety of contexts as described in recent papers here and here.

Ultimately, our understanding of reality is dependent on our bodies - a topic known as embodied cognition. You can't understand what an apple is by reading about it, you need to hold one, feel its smooth skin and heft, smell the barely sweet scent permeating the skin, feel the sensation of biting into it, the juice pouring out, that taste and crunch. If I try to describe a fruit you haven't eaten to you in text then you try to relate it to the closest experience you have had, and this goes for reading about anything you haven't experienced. Crucially, an LLM doesn't have any true experiences to relate to, its perception of reality is limited to a stream of tokens, and so it fundamentally does not and can never understand what it is talking about.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nuclear_splines PhD, Data Science Jun 01 '25

My opinions on individual models don't differ. I think this essay summarizes it well. Software engineering is much more about social problem solving - understanding how processes work, how decisions are made, how a given design provides agency to different parties - the code is almost a byproduct of the problem solving, rather than the main work. A predictive text model is ill-suited to that kind of sociopolitical problem solving, even if its ability to solve isolated technical tasks improves.

1

u/ElderberryCalm9625 Jun 04 '25

Hello buddy I really liked and appreciate your responses, I was wondering if you still have the same thinking about CS being worth it based on the evolution of AI and what should be expected for the following years, I am turning into a junior by next fall and I would also like to know which branch of CS would you recommend me, since whenever I talk with someone they offer me the worst perspective about this major but I am still in love with this major even though I am an average student (just does class material, and does not expand knowledge that much outside class). I see that you have a PhD in Data Science, would you recommend me going into the same field after my CS bachelor's? I am also thinking to get a minor in Data Science if possible, I do not go for the data science BS because it would be a waste of time for me since I am closer to achieving the CS rather than the DS, on the other hand I am planning on persuing higher education related with it or even cybersecurity

37

u/JmacTheGreat Jan 11 '24

“Computer Science” is not “Writing Computer Code”

It is a science, and will always have a use.

8

u/Zippy0723 Jan 11 '24

Large language models have a lot of unfounded hype behind them. We're many years off from an AI that can actually write code at a meaningful level, if we ever even get there. 

7

u/captain_ahabb Jan 11 '24

No. It's all hype.

1

u/Square_Inspector6691 May 22 '24

Computer science is dying because of bootcamps not for AI, it's sad because this year I going to graduate from informatics engineering and I think my degree it's worthless

1

u/Proper_Guarantee_650 Jul 29 '24

, if you provide detailed and specific requirements for your project, AI can assist significantly in writing code that aligns with your plan. This process involves you detailing your project specifications and correcting or refining the AI-generated code as necessary. Here’s a step-by-step approach to effectively collaborate with AI on coding a project:

1. Detailed Specifications

Provide comprehensive and detailed project requirements. Break down your project into smaller, manageable components with clear specifications for each part. Include:

  • Functional Requirements: Describe what the system should do.

  • Non-Functional Requirements: Describe the performance characteristics and constraints.

  • Business Logic: Clearly define the rules and logic that need to be implemented.

  • Edge Cases: Outline scenarios that might cause issues and how they should be handled.

  • Examples: Provide examples of inputs and expected outputs.

2. Iterative Development and Refinement

Use an iterative approach where you continually refine the AI-generated code based on feedback and testing:

  • Initial Implementation: Have the AI generate an initial implementation based on your detailed specifications.

  • Review and Feedback: Review the code, identify any discrepancies or areas for improvement, and provide feedback.

  • Refinement: Use the feedback to refine and improve the code.

3. Using AI to Generate Code

Here’s how you can use AI tools like OpenAI Codex to generate code based on your detailed plan:

Example Project: E-commerce Order Processing System

Detailed Specification:

  1. Order States: Define states such as “Order Placed,” “Payment Pending,” “Payment Confirmed,” “Order Packed,” “Shipped,” “Delivered,” “Returned.”

  2. State Transitions: Clearly specify conditions for transitioning between states.

  3. Business Logic: Define business rules, e.g., “Order can only be packed if payment is confirmed.”

  4. Edge Cases: Handle scenarios like payment failures or cancellations.

Example Implementation:

public class OrderStateMachine {
    private OrderState currentState;

    public OrderStateMachine() {
        this.currentState = OrderState.ORDER_PLACED;
    }

    public void transition(OrderEvent event) {
        switch (currentState) {
            case ORDER_PLACED:
                if (event == OrderEvent.PAYMENT_RECEIVED) {
                    currentState = OrderState.PAYMENT_CONFIRMED;
                } else {
                    handleInvalidTransition(event);
                }
                break;
            case PAYMENT_CONFIRMED:
                if (event == OrderEvent.ORDER_PACKED) {
                    currentState = OrderState.ORDER_PACKED;
                } else {
                    handleInvalidTransition(event);
                }
                break;
            // Add more transitions and conditions as specified
            default:
                handleInvalidTransition(event);
        }
    }

    public OrderState getCurrentState() {
        return currentState;
    }

    public enum OrderState {
        ORDER_PLACED, PAYMENT_PENDING, PAYMENT_CONFIRMED, ORDER_PACKED, SHIPPED, DELIVERED, RETURNED
    }

    public enum OrderEvent {
        PAYMENT_RECEIVED, ORDER_PACKED, ORDER_SHIPPED, ORDER_DELIVERED, RETURN_INITIATED
    }

    private void handleInvalidTransition(OrderEvent event) {
        // Log or throw an exception
        System.out.println(“Invalid transition: “ + currentState + “ -> “ + event);
    }
}

4. Correction and Improvement

Review the generated code and refine it:

  • Correct Errors: Identify and correct any logical errors or omissions.

  • Enhance Features: Add additional features or improve existing ones based on further requirements.

  • Testing: Thoroughly test the implementation to ensure it meets all requirements.

5. Continuous Feedback Loop

Maintain a continuous feedback loop where you provide specific feedback to the AI, leading to iterative improvements in the code.

Conclusion

By providing detailed specifications and continually refining the AI-generated code, you can effectively leverage AI to assist in complex coding projects. While AI can handle many tasks, human oversight and refinement are crucial to ensure the code meets all requirements and handles edge cases appropriately.

Sources

1

u/Proper_Guarantee_650 Jul 29 '24

I don’t understand. How can people say that AI has sped up and made coding easier, then at the same time say it won’t impact the job market.

If AI is solving problems automatically that had to be manually solved before, people spend less time coding = less people to do the same job.

Your job is to solve problems. If AI is solving 25% of the current workload, then it’s going to take 25% of the current jobs EVENTUALLY. However, if AI creates new problems to be solved, that can’t be solved by AI, then the industry may grow or maintain.

1

u/Dread-light-8 Jan 04 '25

Computer science is far from dying—it’s evolving, and its potential is greater than ever. You can push your limits by diving into fields like computational physics, artificial intelligence, computer graphics, and systems programming, which solve real-world problems and drive innovation. Explore cutting-edge areas like quantum computing, robotics, or space exploration to work on transformative technologies shaping the future. Build a portfolio of impactful projects, such as realistic simulations, AI-driven tools, or advanced systems, to demonstrate your expertise and passion. Stay curious, keep experimenting, and embrace the vast opportunities in computer science to make a lasting impact on the world.

1

u/P-Jean Jan 12 '24

Technical trades are another option. There’s CS components in a lot of electrical work. I’d talk to several advisors before making a decision.

1

u/Prestigious_Wheel128 Jan 12 '24

it's not the AI. it's the outsourcing I would be worried about.

much better career wise to get a degree in something with a license of some sort which is a government enforced monopoly.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

No. It’s the fastest and most accelerating field there is

1

u/cnervip Jan 12 '24

not by a long shot, you still have scientific uses that need coders, game making, developing new OS, maintaining the AI, gamification of complex problems, etc. btw: computing is a part of maths (commonly, or initially used to measure what informatics was capable of), informatics is about automatization the treatment of data. maybe IT should be a better word (or pair of char) anyways 15 years ago they(engineers in informatic and alike) said than desktop/laptop computer where dying, that mouse and would be a thing of the past, that now all will be touchscreens, still not seen anyone (seriously)coding on a mobile or tablet over a pc

1

u/somever Jan 12 '24

That's something parroted by grifters who think AI and bitcoin are the future.

1

u/Oof-o-rama Jan 12 '24

this question comes up every few years. CS is evolving and continues to evolve. For the people who know what they're doing and embrace the subject matter broadly, there is likely to be work. For those are here because they think they can make a quick buck who have no aptitude or interest... who knows.

1

u/mental_atrophy666 Jan 12 '24

No. Nooooooo! Just. No.

1

u/Even-Inevitable-7243 Jan 12 '24

CS as a field is not dying. The theoretical knowledge will always be needed to move the field forward. What is going to die is low-level applied CS aka "Software Engineering". This will be replaced by AI. People doing a BootCamp and finding a job paying in the 1% of salaries will no longer be a thing. Engineers will need to build products and take them end-to-end. Domain knowledge will be key.

I would short pure SWE as a job. I would go long CS theory, Math, Physics. I would go long engineering that builds products (EE, BME, ME, CE). I would go long soft CS skills (Human-Computer Interaction).

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '24

AI is just the flavor of the season. Computer Science evolves fairly often. You'll be learning for your entire career so don't stress out too much right now. Focus on the foundation firsthand and then you can branch out into something more specialized.

1

u/zombieregime May 21 '24

Also, the misguided youth geek chic nerd cosplayers seem to have been convinced that all algorithms or code that evaluates a state to determine the next task is AI... So, i mean, if someone is going to say "learn AI" it might be important to ask them "what exactly do you consider AI?"

Its like ships and boats, all ships are boats but not every boat is a ship. All AI is algorithms, bit not all algorithms are AI....unless we are REALLY playing fast and loose with the word "intelligent". Because, I dont care if little Caleb knows what a neural net is, "if sensor ≥ value; light_off else; light_on" is not an example of AI....And yes, I have had these arguments before with a disturbing number of squeakers trying to defend "its totally AI"...and it just isnt...thats like saying your fridge has AI to keep cold. Also, speaking of, when did fuzzy logic stop being a thing? Am I really that out if touch.........No, its the children who are wrong

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

AI can’t do new things yet. Just reproduce what’s already out there. You just have to be smarter than the AI.

1

u/CarrotCakeX-X Jan 15 '24

It is not a science, its not based on science

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

Yes it is dying. There are too many cs grads, so too much competition for cs jobs.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

[deleted]

1

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

alright will do. thank you for the advice

1

u/CarrotCakeX-X Jan 15 '24

It was never real. I hate hos it trys to scam people

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

[deleted]

2

u/ent1pe Jan 12 '24

Thanks a lot. This perfectly answered my question. I completely forgot about double majoring so I’ll definitely look into that