r/computerscience • u/[deleted] • May 03 '23
General Computer Science is awesome
Recently I’ve seen some news suggesting Computer Science majors will become less valuable with AI advances. I strongly disagree.
I just want to tell every youngster who is now studying in college to keep grinding. AI is a byproduct of Computer Science and we are the ones that will enable its advances. Saying AI will make CS obsolete is a contradiction because CS is the fuel to AI development and digital solutions.
Don’t lose your passion or get discouraged to follow this beautiful degree. You will learn so much about computing (development of AI included).
Keep your head UP.
13
u/dzernumbrd May 04 '23
To replace a computer scientist you need AGI not just AI.
If a true AGI comes into existence then literally everyone's job is replaceable, not just computer scientists.
Humans are essentially redundant at that point because the AGI will be better than us at literally everything.
Computer scientists will be one of the last occupations replaced by advances in AI.
48
u/laidtorest47 May 03 '23
I was told AI would replace me as a linguist, and it hasn't. We were told art would be replaced by AI, and it hasn't. Not only has it not, but it shouldn't. Security-wise, having an AI manage code seems extremely bad, as any rampant bad data that gets into it could take someone's life.
Our current infrastructure would find AI to be a security flaw open to manipulation and we'd just lose to bad actors by default.
5
u/creativesolution May 04 '23 edited May 04 '23
People get excited/worked up prematurely, which is why you hear things like that and then it doesn't seem to happen. But AI advances are exponential. Your job won't be replaced in just a few years but the path towards that becoming reality is most definitely being paved at an ever increasing speed. Most big revolutionary things in our history didn't change the world overnight.
No point worrying about it though. Use tech advantages to your own advantage and keep on doing your thing.
4
u/PersonaUser55 May 03 '23
Me when the ai can't even draw hands right but is supposed to replace artists lol
4
u/lifeofideas May 04 '23
Gambling on what AI cannot do is the riskier choice.
Instead, think of AI as a tool-set. Being able to use all the tools available, in an effective manner, will be the key to success.
21
u/lpfan724 May 03 '23
Every major technological advancement brings our doomers with predictions of the loss of careers and the end of the world. It hasn't happened yet.
1
u/alagris12358 May 03 '23
What about nukes? Nuclear war hasn't happened... yet...
What about genetically engineered super viruses? It kind of happened with covid... but it would be easy to produce an even more deadly virus.
Lastly what about the damn combustion/steam engine? We have climate change now. That's as a doomsday, except a slowly progressing one. But hey, we have 6th mass extinction and anthropocene.
7
u/dontyougetsoupedyet May 03 '23
It isn't slowly progressing, we've done more in two hundred years than millions of years of flood basalt eruptions, while simultaneously pulling out more nitrogen from the atmosphere than all biological processes combined, while simultaneously fucking layers of the atmosphere sideways with chlorofluorocarbons and other chemicals, and so on and on and on.
5
u/alagris12358 May 03 '23
Yea, I mean, on geological scale it's super fast. On human scale it's slow progressing, which is why human psychology fails to see it as an emergency.
1
u/Twombls May 11 '23
What about nukes? Nuclear war hasn't happened... yet...
Uh the doomers were right about that one
2
u/spradlig May 03 '23
I agree with your main point, but not with what you write about “calculators killing mathematicians”. The number of jobs called “mathematician” is a tiny fraction of those for engineers, software engineers, computer programmers, and data analysts.
5
May 03 '23
Sorry, but I used “calculator killing mathematicians” as a metaphor because it is completely wrong!
Is you are saying that AI will reduce the demand for CS I agree, but will never make it obsolete!
1
1
u/Tomato_Sky May 04 '23
Hey bud. I think you are confusing computer science and computer science majors. BSCS has been increasingly unnecessary and unreliable in potential job candidates.
But with chatbots and coding assistants, they allow a person off the street to be able to do a senior level project.
I agree that CS is awesome. I also use the chatbots and tools. My favorite thing to do is asking the chatbots to explain something in different ways to help me understand. They go hand in hand with computer science.
The degree? It’ll get you more interviews. You have the advantage of understanding why you do things and you hopefully have a few group projects under your belt too. To get the job you have to be the best candidate they interview, for them.
The degree is absolute garbage. The profs are tenured in academia and haven’t done any modern private sector work. The classes and curriculum haven’t been updated in decades.
I got my degree after breaking through and I’ve been on hiring committees. CS is still really cool to study and is just one way to gain the knowledge and skills for a good foundation, but you can also get that foundation in other ways.
1
May 04 '23
It really depends on the college. Mine prepared me very very well. I got an AI research position immediately after graduating :)
1
3
8
u/chesquikmilk May 03 '23
We’re simultaneously seeing the crudest implementation of it and the maximum capacity of scale for the current hardware and models. It’s impressive out of context to lay people. There’s a “gold rush” happening, but it’s kind of vapourware. I wouldn’t waist any time worrying folks.
4
1
u/curatingFDs May 03 '23
I don’t have a formal CS background and just graduated a bootcamp. How do I get better? I’m struggling.
3
May 03 '23
I would recommend studying maths, stats and AI. A Computer Science degree would be handy, but if it’s out of your reach maybe you should try looking at some books. However, it’s fairly hard to work in AI without a degree :(
What are your career goals?
4
u/computerarchitect May 03 '23
Perhaps work with a tutor or mentor to identify your weak areas/things you didn't learn and go from there?
There's a reason that the four year degree is the standard and it's to avoid what you're encountering right now.
1
May 04 '23
Crash course computer science is very good for a high level overview. Im learning a lot and it's helping identify where I should go more in depth. There is also this build your own computer till tetris course somewhere. I think if you google. "build computer till tetris" you'll find it. (no parts to buy, its all with hardware simulation)
2
2
u/fuka123 May 03 '23
AI, in its current form, helps with things like rapid prototyping. Its cute, but is a very small portion of the development lifecycle.
2
May 06 '23
i’ve heard people who work in tech with ai who are much smarter than me say that ai is not replacing us any time soon, so I am relatively confident, most people who say ai will replace programmers have no knowledge to back it up, they just say what others told them without thinking
1
u/digital_dreams May 03 '23
The general masses have said all kinds of ridiculous things that never came to fruition.
1
-3
u/Imaginary_Passage431 May 03 '23
Again the “calculators killed mathematicians” fallacy? It’s actually “calculator killed human calculator” and it DID happen.
AI is replacing artists, will replace programmers and computer science will be irrelevant. In fact it was already less relevant than you expected, that’s why most jobs are terribly easy compared to the selection process exercises. The only thing that will matter will be mathematicians creating new models of AI , only if AI can’t do it by itself.
Remember when artists made fun one year ago that AI added too many fingers. Now they are crying and terrified to be replaced. In one year you will create a post saying that AI adds to many fingers to algorithms lol
3
May 03 '23
Computer Science has lots of math and computational knowledge. There is no better fit candidate than a CS major to create new AI :)
What do you mean by mathematicians? Computer Scientists working on AI?
15
u/barrycarter May 03 '23
I like your enthusiasm, and agree that people should continue studying computer science if only in order to kill time and avoid boredom.
However, if you accept that most human discovery and invention is based on prior discovery and invention, then AI will advance itself.