r/composer • • Apr 24 '26

Meta New rules about the use of AI in the sub

184 Upvotes

If you look in the sidebar where the rules are, there is a new rule about AI. Here is the text:

  1. You may not post music generated by AI using apps like Suno.

  2. You may post computer generated/algorithmic music.

You may use AI to create the text for your posts.

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

4. You may not post apps generated using “vibe coding” where AI writes the entire program.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Reddit does not supply enough room to provide explanations for all of these rules so if you have questions, comments, or suggestions please don't hesitate to comment below.

Here are some notes about some of these:

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

Posts are not art. Using AI to create a text post isn't taking any money away from another composer or artist. Some people just aren't good at writing and/or don't speak English natively. Using AI is one way to improve their chances at communicating clearly.

That said, we strongly encourage everyone to not use AI in this instance. A significant number of users here will react badly to this and you won't get the kind of responses you are hoping for.

Unfortunately it's a Catch 22. People also react badly to posters who are poor at communicating. For folks like that there is no winning.

Update: We've changed the wording to reflect some of the comments below. We still have very limited space but hopefully admitting to using AI and providing an explanation will, in a subtle way, discourage people from doing so (for their own sake) or perhaps they will have a good reason that will mollify the crowd.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

It is standard today for programmers at all levels to use AI to assist in some aspects of programming. In the past people would ask questions at places like Stack Exchange or Reddit but now it's so much faster to ask an AI. The results often aren't great but they provide a good start toward a solution.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Almost all discussions about AI in this sub go horribly wrong. However, there is nothing inherently bad about discussing the subject and we will try to allow those discussions. There are interesting discussions to be had.

However, we will remove all posts that ask whether AI will replace composers. This has been asked many, many times and because those posts generally go badly we're just not going to deal with them.

Posts asking for links to AI apps to use will be removed. While AI has its uses, asking for or providing links to AI that generates music are not allowed.

A final note. The rules of civility apply when responding to questions, comments, posts, etc, about AI. We remove lots of comments where people attack others with accusations of AI usage or whatever. Don't do this. If you have an actual useful comment about someone's use of AI then please express it in a civil manner.

Update: I asked Google Gemini to clean up that rule. Here is the result:

AI Content Guidelines

  • ❌ Banned: Music fully generated by AI (e.g., Suno) and "vibe-coded" apps where AI writes the entire program.

  • ✅ Allowed: Computer-generated/algorithmic music and apps where AI is used as a tool (standard for 80%+ of devs).

  • 📝 Posts: AI can be used for post text. Discussions about AI and music are welcome.

  • 🚫 Note: Threads asking "Will AI replace composers?" will be removed.

We're going to stick with what I wrote.


r/composer • • Jul 29 '25

Resource Updated and expanded Resources Section at r/composer

28 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Just a quick update: this sub now has an updated and expanded Resource Section!

It includes a curated list of helpful materials for composers of all levels, including books, YouTube channels, websites, and more.

It can be accessed here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/composer/wiki/resources/

...or by clicking on 'Wiki' at the top of the sub (in the mobile app) or by clicking 'Resources' under Community Bookmarks (on desktop).

Thank you to those who gave suggestions for new additions to the Resource Section.

If anyone else spots anything that needs correcting or has suggestions for additional resources, feel free to let us know!

P.S. The Resource Section can also be found at r/composition, a smaller "sibling" community to this one. If you're not a member there yet, do consider stopping by!

Thanks,

u/RichMusic81


r/composer • • 9h ago

Discussion What do you wish you learned?

14 Upvotes

If someone was putting together a book on ideas and practical advice about being a composer, what ideas or advice would you have benefited from learning through a book earlier?

I have a lot of thoughts on making composition your “business,” but curious what others think, or if there’s significant gaps in information new or experienced composers are seeking.


r/composer • • 11h ago

Discussion One last chord before you die

13 Upvotes

If you had to play one last single chord before you die, which one would you chose and why?

Optional information: any particular instrument, gear, set or effect to play It.


r/composer • • 4h ago

Music Beethoven Symphony 5 Mvmt 2 piano duet

2 Upvotes

I posted mvmt 1 of my bar-for-bar re-imagining of this symphony a few weeks back. Here is mvmt 2.

https://musescore.com/user/40546707/scores/40497078?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 6h ago

Music Short Minuet for Piano

2 Upvotes

Hello all, this is a short minuet I’ve written over the last couple days. The musical material is not the most interesting as this was a study in form rather than creating exciting music.

But I hope you all enjoy it, and I would love any feedback you may have.

Minuet Score

Minuet Audio


r/composer • • 9h ago

Music Grace notes - imperceptible?

1 Upvotes

Can a professional oboist play these (transposed) English Horn grace notes fast enough so that they're practically imperceptible? That is, can they take up the time of one 16th at the tempo provided Thanks https://imgur.com/a/dkzSFss


r/composer • • 10h ago

Music Minuet C dur

1 Upvotes

Here is my minuet. I would like for feedback. (Sorry for the link i accidently mistaken the file)
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ihJe0RqnFyU1xjs65g57EyPZ6xQgGwTV?usp=sharing


r/composer • • 22h ago

Music Advice for a piece

3 Upvotes

I have spent a couple months working on this piece as my first big piece I’ve ever written as a student in high school and was thinking about entering it in a competition but wanted criticism first, heres the piece: Rhapsody in Brisk


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music My holiday piano solo

4 Upvotes

A pianist friend heard my demo of this and wanted to play it for the holiday season, so I wrote it down.

https://musescore.com/user/40546707/scores/40460169?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music I wrote a lyrical trombone and piano piece for my friend's senior recital

9 Upvotes

I would love to hear your thoughts! You can find it here


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion What pair of monitor speakers would you suggest for a hybrid orchestral composer under $350

9 Upvotes

I just started composing music but mixing the music on simple headphones is not my cup of tea, could you guys suggest some pair of monitor speakers under my tight budget of $350


r/composer • • 21h ago

Discussion lotusmusic.com is down - searching for an alternative

0 Upvotes

IYKYK - lotusmusic.com had some fantastic browser-based tools that I would use regularly, but now the site is down. If you know of any sites that offer the same level of description and interface, please share. Thank you.


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Liminal harmony exercise (31edo)

2 Upvotes

Video with score: https://youtu.be/969DhujgO1k?si=H0kpfdJ_dv2U4shY

Not too different from the one I posted here a couple of days ago, although this one is less serious.

Most of the exercise is typical 4 part choral writing but in 31edo and using some quarter-tone sonorities. Harmonics 7, 11 and 13 are the main notes that step outside the diatonic scale.

In this example I wanted to play more with the diesis "enharmonic" motion. At the start it appears between measures 2-4 in the bass, and close to the end it plays between measures 9-12 outlining a major 2nd interval (similar to that piece by Cavalieri).

Right at the end I use a strange cadence that utilizes the diesis motion in contrary motion to resolve the dominant.


r/composer • • 19h ago

Discussion How would I go about writing an actually somewhat accurate Celtic-based orchestral piece?

0 Upvotes

I want to try writing an orchestral piece based on English Celtic folk music (English only used to refer to the general region of modern-day England, I’m aware the name ‘England’ comes from the later Angles), but since we don’t really have much info on what it actually SOUNDED like (i.e. no written melodies or structures or anything), I’m not sure how to do it without just relying on cheap tropes. I’ve done a bit of research and know that they used modes, drones, vocal chants and a few different types of instruments, but I feel like if I tried to apply the kind of style it had into an orchestral piece it would most likely just sound like a bad pastiche with a bunch of “Irish folk” type stereotypes in it, like something you’d hear in some novelty piece from a century and a half ago or something that kind of just romanticises the culture in a patronising way.

I guess I’m just asking how I would do this without just creating a superficial, Anglicised imitation of Celtic music, as well as if there are any relevant examples you would suggest I listen to/research?


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion EastWest Sounds Cloud Black Friday deal

6 Upvotes

EastWest is having Black Friday deals on its VSTs. One of the things I see is that for $99 you can get access to everything for a year, and if you're a student, it's $49. I was looking at Symphonic Orchestra Platinum which you can buy outright for $89 but then I realized the company has so much stuff beyond that.

I'd seen the company mentioned on here from time to time and so after some investigating, I'm liking what I'm hearing, at least from the orchestras. Some of these orchestras sound like the ones I would always hear in movies in the '80s and '90s (my movie heyday). More of the Williams, Newton Howard, Newman (Randy or Thomas), Shore vibe that I love, etc.

Any EastWest users with thoughts on its subscription bundle or maybe just individual VSTs?

I should add that I'm currently using an M4 Mac Mini with 24 GB of RAM just case there might be any CPU issues I should know about.


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music First time posting! Wrote some sketches last night and wondering what people think

4 Upvotes

Hey y'all! here is some background about me: I started to take music pretty seriously during COVID times (was pretty bored...) In high school I went to a college summer program where I met some friends who composed while I mainly did electronic production, I learned alot from them, but I am basically self-taught. I am now working on a Bachelors degree in music and compute science at a college with a conservatory, and I plan to apply for composition lessons at some point.

I am sketching something I wanna turn into my first symphony at some point. I will probably rewrite it all at somepoint, so these are basically like rough sketches where I can learn from in the future.

My idea is one late night was to spell my best friend's two names in notes sort of like DSCH, they moved far far way a few years ago (moved from America allll the way to Australia) and I do miss them. The horn solo is about longing for someone who is far way, and the climax idea i wrote is the reunion (something I can imagine playing as I step off of a plane and seeing them in an airport terminal) where both names sound together. Super inspired by the symphonies of Mahler, operas by Wagner, and Early Schoenberg. (Specifically Gurre-Lieder)

Now what would be nice is some feedback:

Does the horn solo hold together as a melody?

Does the climax earn its ending, or does it arrive too easily?

Where is the orchestration unplayable or unbalanced?

What would you change first if I were rewriting it?

Notation. I know there are countless mistakes, so point out anything or not! I will talk to my composer friends and professors about it.

Thank you so so much! Can't wait to hear what you guys have to say :)

Link to score video and score PDF


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music First time posting here- what do you guys think of my four hands piano piece?

4 Upvotes

Here's my piece with that instrumentation (underrated, in my opinion), premiered over a year and a half ago but still proud of the form and development. Always welcome feedback as well. let me know what you think!

Youtube link

Score link no cover page


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Make American music great again

0 Upvotes

But written in another country https://youtu.be/t4HR9b3tIL4


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music How do you notate sostenuto pedal?!

2 Upvotes

Hii! I spent the last few hours composing a short piano piece inspired by Scandinavian folk music. To make it playable you would need to press down an octave before playing, and then hold the sostenuto pedal throughout. How would one notate this? I have just tied the notes.

Any other advice is of course also welcome! I'm 16 and have only had piano lessons, not composition. I'm however eager to improve :)

Link: https://musescore.com/user/80055844/scores/40423197


r/composer • • 2d ago

Discussion What type reverb sends do you keep in your orchestral template?

8 Upvotes

I wanna know the types of reverb sends you keep in your project and their decay time as well


r/composer • • 2d ago

Discussion Anyone have recent experience with Pond5? How are stock sales and pricing going in 2026?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I wanted to check in and see if anyone here has recent experience with Pond5 lately.

  • Have you managed to make any stock music sales recently?

  • What genres or styles are currently performing best for you?

  • How do you approach and manage your pricing strategy on the platform nowadays?

Overall, I'd love to hear your honest reviews or thoughts on how Pond5 is holding up in 2026, or if you feel it's worth shifting focus to other alternative platforms.

Thanks in everyone for sharing your insights!


r/composer • • 1d ago

Commission Music composer

0 Upvotes

I need a music composer who can make music for my 3d animation works I can't pay anything right now ,I need passionate people The only thing I can give is credits.

Any interested people dm me


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music What if a Big Band and a Full Orchestra could play the same arrangements? Two free arrangements for you!

0 Upvotes

Hello, everyone!

My name is Thiago Ribeiro, and I am an amateur arranger. I would like to share two musical arrangements that I have prepared with great care and am making available for free, hoping they will be performed by orchestras, big bands, and other musical ensembles.

These arrangements have a special feature: they are written in a hybrid format, meaning they can be performed by either a Big Band or a Full Orchestra, making them suitable for different ensemble configurations.

🎼 The two free arrangements are:

1. Joshua Fit the Battle of Jericho — Swing

A lively and energetic interpretation of this traditional spiritual, featuring the groove and vibrant character of swing. The arrangement is designed to bring out the musical possibilities of both a big band and a full orchestra.

2. Amazing Grace — Samba Jazz

A fresh perspective on this beautiful and beloved hymn. In this arrangement, the familiar melody takes on a samba jazz character, combining Brazilian musical influences, sophistication, and a distinctive personality.

🎧 Would you like to hear the arrangements?

The YouTube links below will take you to demonstration recordings of both arrangements.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWXDRKqV_xo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5J9hkc6to8Y

📥 Download links for the full scores and individual parts are available in the description of each YouTube video.

My goal in sharing this material is simply to contribute, even in a small way, to the musical community and give these arrangements the opportunity to come to life through the performances of musicians and orchestras.

If your orchestra, big band, conductor, or musical ensemble is interested in performing either arrangement, I would be absolutely delighted!

I have just one small request: if possible, whenever you perform one of these arrangements, please tag me or mention my name in your posts. It would mean a lot to me to be able to see and enjoy your performances!

I sincerely hope you enjoy these arrangements and that they find their way to many musicians, rehearsal rooms, concert halls, and stages around the world.

Music becomes even more beautiful when it is shared!

Best wishes,
Thiago Ribeiro