r/commandandconquer • u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer • Oct 11 '18
Verified C&C Update from EA
Fellow Command & Conquer fans,
My name is Jim Vessella, and I’m a Producer at Electronic Arts. Ten years ago I had the pleasure of being on the production team for Command & Conquer 3 and Red Alert 3, along with being the Lead Producer on Kane’s Wrath. During those years, some of my favorite moments were interacting with our passionate community, whether at our onsite Community Summits, on the forums, or while attending various events such as Gamescom.
As most of you may know, we recently announced Command & Conquer: Rivals, a mobile game set in the Command & Conquer universe. Following the reveal of Rivals, we heard you loud and clear: the Command & Conquer community also wants to see the franchise return to PC. And as a fan of C&C for over 20 years, I couldn’t agree more. With that in mind we’ve been exploring some exciting ideas regarding remastering the classic PC games, and already have the ball rolling on our first effort to celebrate the upcoming 25th Year Anniversary.
We are eager to hear your feedback to help influence our current thoughts for PC and what comes next. Over the next few weeks we’ll be talking to fans in a variety of ways. In the meantime, please share your thoughts here on the subreddit.
As a long time C&C fan and developer, I am just as passionate about the C&C franchise as you are, and look forward to hearing your thoughts as they help us shape the future of C&C at EA!
Thanks!
Jim Vessella
Jimtern
2.2k
Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
As far as I'm concerned, the closer to the originals, the better (to a reasonable extent anyway).
Here's what I won't buy:
Online only with no single-player campaign (learn from the Generals 2 debacle)
Lootboxes in any form. Andrew Wilson can shove it, end of story.
Pay-per-faction/commander (again, learn from Generals 2)
A "reimagined" RTS which in reality is just a bad MOBA/RTS hybrid that nobody wanted.
"Starcraftification," or in other words blindly focusing on APM gameplay and macros at the expense of everything else in order to "foster competitive gameplay".
Here's what I will gladly buy and continue to support:
A competently built game, with minimal bugs and maximum polish upon release.
A functionally complete RTS with the traditional mechanics intact.
A single player campaign with online multiplayer.
A game that isn't build around "being competitive" in a genre that has essentially no eSports market relative to the rest.
I'm sorry for sounding so harsh/terse but this is the genre, and the specific game series in fact, that got me into gaming as a kid in the first place. What EA has done to Westwood's wonderful creations is horrible, and you should be incredibly thankful for any fan of the series willing to give you another chance.
That said, a proper remaster of the originals up to and maybe including Generals would be a good first step towards putting your company back in our good graces. I'd certainly buy them.
edit: dogshit reddit list formatting requirements
787
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Thanks for the perspective Robord, these types of posts are super helpful to inform us of exactly what you're looking for.
→ More replies (44)39
u/Kered13 Oct 11 '18
"Starcraftification," or in other words blindly focusing on APM gameplay and macros at the expense of everything else in order to "foster competitive gameplay".
There has never been an RTS where "APM" (multitasking really) hasn't been the key to success. This includes all the classic CNC games. The UI in those games was very clunky and if you wanted to do well had to be constantly microing your units while building out your base.
→ More replies (4)32
u/saroph Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
I agree completely. Keep the MOBA elements to MOBA games, and don't try to force an RTS to have a competitive eSports scene. These couple of reasons alone are a major part of why many recent RTS games have failed, especially since overemphasizing them leads to the neglect of the things that many RTS players actually want in the first place (e.g. good single player campaign, strong gameplay foundation, player agency/choice in building bases, etc.).
→ More replies (3)14
u/thelittleking GDI Oct 11 '18
This is incredibly 1 to 1 with what I want out of a new C&C game. I hate how the RTS genre looks these days, and I long for a return to what I consider the heyday of Tiberian Sun/ RA2.
→ More replies (8)28
u/j3radw Oct 11 '18
This!! Sums up my feelings to a "T" :)
I have so many fond memories of those early games. They were special for a reason, I think its time for developers to take a serious look at what made those games special. They dont have to re-invent the wheel here, I truly feel like the communities of the world are just looking for tried and true RTS gameplay without any gimmicks, tricks, paywalls...etc/
16
Oct 11 '18
Even if it sounds a bit harsh, that's exactly what needs to be said. C&C is what got me into RTS games and a C&C built on these points would get me buying em again.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (62)20
286
179
u/kostandrea Kane is all! Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
What I would like to see is the first decade remastered in a 3d engine with better controls a better hud. What I think should be the goal is the HUD being something close to CnC3 with production tabs and so on, multiple build cues would be great with also a toggle for those that don't want that
EDIT:OMG first gold!
→ More replies (2)177
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Hi Kostandrea, thanks for bringing up the Sidebar and build tabs. The UI for C&C3 was the feature I produced, and I loved many of the updates we made. But we're curious to hear if people want to see that replicated in the classic games. What does everyone think about adjustments to the classic Sidebar?
53
u/c0mmander_Keen Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
Hey Jim, super exciting to hear you guys talk about C&C! Here are my 2 cents on the UI.
I've played about 1000 hours of C&C3 (~600 of which are with KW) in online multiplayer and the way hotkeys could be used for tab switching and construction was fantastic - and essential. At the same time, I think the sidebar was also a perfect mix of accessability and visual appeal with the great unit icons and quick tooltips. The game was abandoned all too soon IMO (as you know better than most I assume) but I do not remember any gripes we had with the sidebar design!
In my opinion, the best overall UI & control scheme in any RTS is found in Supreme Commander, but C&C does not require that many controls and is much more streamlined in terms of production options. One thing from supcom might be useful, however: in multiplayer (C&C3), we would simply shift+leftclick spam to queue more units than would expire to build the line units such as main battle tanks, rocket squads, bikes etc, and then cancel whenever. This ensured continued production while the mind could be occupied with other matters. A similar modifier for "infinite", i.e. the ctrl key, might be handy! The venerable C&C clone "KKnD" also had this way back when and it was very useful.
Corresponding changes to the classic sidebars - especially as an option - would be great. At the very least, I would welcome the option to queue unit construction the way the newer games allow.
EDIT Appreciate the gold, good sir or madam! <3
45
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Awesome to hear your thoughts on the C&C3 UI! There's a lot of similar sentiment happening in these posts, so this is great insight for us.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (54)5
u/Jonny_dr Oct 11 '18
The UI for C&C3 was the feature I produced, and I loved many of the updates we made.
Jim, you are my hero. I played a ton of RTS-Games, but i keep coming always back to CnC3:KW multiplayer to this day and one of the reasons is the amazing UI. There are so many RTS-Games out there where when i lose a match in MP i always think "if i only could click faster and actually do the moves and strategies that i wanted to do". In KW i lose matches ONLY because i made the wrong decisions.
The CnC3 UI is so intuitive to learn and with just q w r t z and the F-Keys i can do almost everything i need to do while simultaneously micro my units.
7
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Thanks for the comments, Jonny! Greg Black was our designer on the UI so he deserves some good credit as well :)
→ More replies (2)
170
u/Just_Tank Oct 11 '18
Command & Conquer community, this is your time right now to band together and help uplift one of the greatest franchises in PC Gaming history. Please support the C&C Legacy of past and present, and the incredible team working on this beloved franchise. I have the utmost confidence something great awaits, and even greater with your input.
Well said Jim =)
-APOC
66
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
APOC!!! Thank you my friend : )
→ More replies (1)25
u/Zaptagious Command the future. Conquer the past. Oct 11 '18
Wow, it's Apoc! Hey, you sent me a C&C graphics card back when The First Decade came out, I've still got it :)
→ More replies (2)14
u/TheWobling Oct 11 '18
Great to see you still keeping up with C&C Apoc, fantastic to see you :D
→ More replies (1)25
u/codename_john GDI Oct 11 '18
holy crap. i remember you from the old C&C forums. glad to see you around
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)9
77
u/KommanderSnowCrab87 Oct 11 '18
If you change any of the balancing, please make a separate game mode that replicates the original. It's my only real problem with the otherwise excellent openRA.
→ More replies (2)68
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Hi SnowCrab, this is another topic we would be eager to hear more about. Should the balance stay the same as the classic versions, or should we rebalance it to make them more appropriate? You mention a toggle or separate game mode which is also an interesting suggestion.
→ More replies (33)
17
u/Into_The_Rain That was left handed! Oct 11 '18
What are the limitations on the remasters? Is this going to be like the Starcraft remastered where they limit the updates to graphics and the backend or are you open to rebalancing and updating the UI? Also would there be further mod support possibly added to the engines?
→ More replies (1)24
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
You tell us! Would you want to see updated balancing or a more robust UI? For example, would you want to see the C&C3 style tabs and unit selection sidebar in one of the classic games?
→ More replies (14)
10
u/DeathRay2K Oct 11 '18
I've been a C&C fan, community member, and mod maker for about 20 years. I was in the cancelled alpha too, and there were enough problems with that game that as big a fan as I am, I'm glad it was cancelled.
That said, regarding remastering the games, and working on new ones, it's essential to actually go back and remember what those games were. As much as EA pushed the "Fast Fluid Fun" thing towards the end of the franchise, the early games were in some ways the opposite. The maps were expansive, units moved slowly, and there were serious consequences to sending units out, because you couldn't easily and quickly pull them back if they came into harm. Most buildings didn't just crumble at the first touch of a bullet either, so you had some time to react if you found yourself with the enemy in your base.
This encouraged variety in a way that the later games didn't do. Because some units were so slow, the fast units were relatively faster. Because some buildings could withstand a huge assault, it made the more fragile buildings more important to protect.
The later games were so obsessed with making games fast and fluid, chasing the eSports angle of making matches exciting to watch, that they lost the appeal of building big armies and sending them out. They missed the crushing pain of having your huge army that you spent half an hour putting together arrive at your enemy's base, only to find their army in yours now that you're essentially defenseless.
The later games lost the pacing, and they lost the variety in unit attributes. They tried to make up for it in variety of abilities, but that's not really the same thing, and when the goal is to defeat the enemy, having 20 different-looking weapons doesn't really matter if they all deal the same amount of damage. What's more interesting is the rock paper scissors both within a faction and without, of having truly different strategies, and different unit attributes.
In the early C&C games, you had the slow, plodding, but methodical and effective GDI against the fast, cheap, but wimpy Nod. In the later C&C games, every faction was Nod.
Now, more specific to remasters, I think HD (Better yet UHD) graphics would be great, mobile ports would be awesome (RCT Classic showed that old-school PC games can work remarkable well given the proper care), improved video and audio quality would be amazing if the originals are available, and new missions would be most welcome as well. Just keep the gameplay true to the originals.
→ More replies (2)4
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Thanks for the perspective DeathRay! That's a great analysis of the franchise and we'll certainly keep all that in mind.
→ More replies (1)
25
u/TheWobling Oct 11 '18
Really really hoping for a TS/FS and RA2/YR remaster!
Really appreciate you reaching out Jim, I'm sure it means a huge amount to the C&C community to know that you guys haven't forgotten about the games or the community!
17
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Thanks Wobling, it's great to re-connect with the community again : )
→ More replies (2)
6
u/b1gl0s3r Oct 12 '18
This is probably my favorite announcement of a game series I've seen or heard this year! C&C was my first video game (apart from Jump Start Kindergarten and First Grade) and I"ve loved it ever since. Rivals was such a disappointing announcement and has destroyed hope that C&C fans didn't know they still had. If this is followed through and done right, it'll be a strong first step toward regaining the community's trust in EA in regards to the C&C franchise. Here's some thoughts on things I'd like to see:
Absolutely no gameplay-impacting microtransactions. I think I speak for everyone when I say I'd gladly pay out $60 or more for a proper Remaster, especially a set of them like how The First Decade was released. But I wont' be nickle and dimed after buying the game, even if its FtP, to be able to play the full game. I think many FtP games, like Dota2, do the model the right way. You get access to the entire game and purchases you make are limited to cosmetics and "Fantasy Football"-like items.
Frank Klepacki's music is a mainstay of the series. Even if the tracks are all remasters, I think him being on board for the music is a big deal to all of us.
Single-player campaigns must be a focal point. As much as I love competition, I really enjoy the challenge of completing missions and seeing a story fold out because of it. The campaigns are the reason I replay the older C&C games. I think the majority of the community also wants this.
On this, I may be in the minority, but I want the game rebalanced where necessary in terms of gameplay. I think it'd also be a good idea to have an eye toward the competitive scene. I used to love watching competitive SC2 until Blizz ruined it. It'd be great to see a new RTS sweeping competitive gaming. If the idea is to remaster multiple games, I think choosing just one to be the eSport game would be great. That way, competitive players, who are more interested in balance and gameplay, and less in which C&C game it is, will get something for them.
Hotkeys are a huge plus and go a long way towards a game playing smoothly. The C&C3 styled HUD was very intuitive for both new and veteran players. I'd personally love to be able to bind hotkeys or at least have the option for a "qwerty" style setup for unit abilities. It can be tiresome to memorize each hotkey for each unit like in WC3.
Lastly, I want a game that is stable upon release with minimal bugs. Of course, you can't find every issue with a game-test team in years that you'll find in days once a game goes live. I think the important thing is to be proactive should issues arise.
Thanks for coming and talking to us and hearing our feedback, Jim. I think the most important thing a community desires in transparency and timely communication. If the game takes longer than expected or if a game-breaking bug shows up after a patch, just acknowledge it and let us know what's being done. I think a weekly update on the process would be huge and a fun insight into the process.
I'm so excited and can't wait to once again hear, "Welcome back, Commander".
5
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
Thanks for the post and outline of your top items, b1gl0s3r! I'm also glad you appreciate the communication here, as it's certainly something we'd like to continue. Cheers!
16
u/_UniQ_ Oct 11 '18
One of the things I want the most is to simply be able to install from origin and play the games. Please just start with patching all the C&C games for current OS capabilities and screen resolution so we can just download and play, instead of having to do all kinds of tricks and community patches!
→ More replies (4)41
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
Modern system compatibility will be a top priority for any Remaster. And a huge shout-out to all the community modders who have helped keep the old games playable over the past many years.
→ More replies (2)
5
u/pavelblink182 Oct 13 '18 edited Oct 13 '18
[HI Jim and C&C fans, Try not to cry while reading the email I sent to EA back on 2015 titled '' Important question from C&C still believer''] (https://imgur.com/a/4duj9TE)
Back then I was still improving my english, sorry for the typos.
I'm one of those people that every 2 months searches google for news on Command and Conquer. When I heard about Generals 2 cancellation and the studio closed with nothing incoming for the future , my heart was broken. Command and Conquer is my favorite pc game of all times and the genre is very much needed because there is absolutely nothing like Command and Conquer out there, I'm not only speaking from nostalgia but from a consumer and gamer stance. I never once lost hope that my favorite game might eventually return, imagine my surprise when I found this thread after years and years. I'm so exhilarated right now that I don't really know what to write. How do you express everything you have waited to express for years on a single Reddit post, I always though I was the only one and seeing so many fans rally here with me makes me incredible sad and happy at the same time, to know I'm not the only one that still had hopes.
More than any requirement in specific, I just want to play Command and Conquer so make it happen! If I wanted to go into any details:
-Please stick to the C&C formula , stay away from C&C4 FOREVER. -Make or add new stories and missions, playing the same exact game again after years and years of waiting would be disappointing. -Red Alert 3/2 or C&C 3 is what you want your new game to look and feel like. -If you can remaster or remake new complete AAA $60 game ( a la Resident evil 2 remake) , with modern graphics, core mechanics intac with small additions, and new stories to play, do it. This is every C&C fan's dream.
Thanks for listening, 3 years after that email , my hopes and believe in EA are gone, but My love for C&C is intact and I would love for EA to prove me wrong and deliver. Cheers for making my month!
→ More replies (3)6
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 14 '18
Thanks for keeping the hope alive all these years.
5
u/Lameminator Oct 16 '18
I've made a reddit account to make a comment here. I'm not the oldest veteran of the series, but from Tiberian Sun I've been enjoying the series, with the exception of this decade... What should be remastered and how? CnC 3 not, bc it's new enough:) A Generals zh would need a lot of rework, because the balance is so broken there, that only a redesign would help it. The economics would be fine, if hackers/black markets/drop zones were limited, so camping wouldn't be that viable. A Tiberium Dawn or RA1 with a better engine would be the most fun. But I would rather talk about a new CnC.
As for Single player, whichever universe will be chosen for a new CnC (and I don't mean a remastered one), I'd make the campaign like in CnC3 where as the losing faction we're fighting a war with minor victories, but Nod/GLA/SU still gets rekt in the long term. It's way better than everyone having a campaign where they conquer the whole world.
Sorry for the long post, but I think I need to express myself about the cancelled Generals 2, since the game deserve more justice, than what the so-called fans talked about it in various forums, and I'll be the attorney standing up for it, because I was, and still, passionate about the game.
As for game mechanics, I liked where Generals 2 was heading, and not talking about the f2p model, even though it might have worked okay, especially after CnC 4. Some maps were a little too Starcraft like, but that was being changed so I approve that, and the removing of the second resource (oil). Gen 2 also had a healthy mix of Cnc3 and RA3. First of all, a bit depressing atmosphere instead of a cartoonish one (like in RA3) was a good thing, also the unit squads, since after playing CnC3, CoH and World in Conflict, give a more professional look for the game in my opinion. Just imagine CnC3 now with standalone infantry units only... kinda bad, right? A lot of people might not find any relation between the f2p Generals 2 and RA3, but there was one important one. It's unit line ups in the different tiers, since in Gen 2 and Ra3, when you had no tech buildings, you would only have access to light vehicles (with the exception of some APA Generals, where the MBT was the lowest tier units in the WF, but it only made it more interesting). The way the armies of the generals was set up is also interesting. Those who don't remember Generals 2 had no standardised sub-factions, like in ZH or KW. In these games the difference between the vanilla and the others was having a handful of units and upgrades replaced, removed or added. In Gen 2, there weren't really many unique units, instead often were they used by ~30-50% of the generals in the faction. For example, the APA as an AA tank, either had rocked or gatling tanks(50-50%), In terms of infantry 33% (2 out of 6) of the generals had access to rocket infantry, to flametroopers, urban assault teams (red guard replacement) and mortar crew, and 50 to saboteurs. Not counting the commando, they had 2-4 units per barrack, which was made up of 6 possible units. You can check the lineups here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sOK26DVECw&list=PLsl2kik2lchti_7jGvtVLbz2_8NPtmJa4&index=6
This made some generals having some really weird combos, where infantry or vehicle focus was low or non-existent, or just simply flopped. Notable examples are the Recon, Railgun (high tier barrack only, and that was t1!), Air force(barely any vehicles), Espionage, Atomic (no barracks) generals. Check the link. This also made certain generals kinda weak at certain points of the game, which could be utilised well, so it's not only about countering the gameplay, but how to counter the tactic that is utilising the weakness of our general - somewhat weak or mediocre performance for early, mid or in late game due to weaker than usual AA (lacking quad cannons, or having rocket inf and helicopters as some EU generals), lack of firepower for certain tiers.
Also not starting with command center and a lot of money gave a tactical diversity for the game. For example, you can start with a command center to cloak your base, then go for the WF/barrack, or go straight for a rush, or a second supply stash, decide if you should invest in the cheaper oil derricks and if you should tech up. You had to decide according to your general, and to the opponent's general and build order. For example, when playing with Recon general and had an APA one against you that has MBTs as lowest tier, you really have to tech up in the beginning to get some tanks before he reaches you, bc MGs won't help that much, but can be effective against low tier GLA units (rabble squads, technicals, etc) without teching.
→ More replies (3)3
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 17 '18
Hi Lameminator, glad to see you engaging in the conversation and thanks for your insight on both fronts!
5
u/methrulz Oct 24 '18
Hi Jim, methuselah from gamereplays.org here. I apologize if this has already been addressed, I tried the search function and so many results came back it made my head hurt. How will you address online play with GameSpy shuttered? I don't mean balance, focus, etc. I simply mean how will you host that part of things? Online play has been a critical part of C&C for a long, long time I can't wait to no doubt reconnect with some old mates.
Thanks!
4
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 24 '18
Hi methuselah, GameReplays.org was always a strong partner of ours during our work at EALA ten years ago. While I can't answer your question directly, we are certainly hearing all the passion around both single-player and multi-player as part of these discussions.
4
u/yoursunk Oct 11 '18
Great news!
By all that is holy let it be phenomenal.
Keep the games as true to their original form as possible. The sidebar can be updated to C&C3 standards absolutely. If you really want this C&C geek freak, purge C&C4 from the timeline while youre at it.
Jim if you want more specific feedback, just ask, I think you've got a lot of now energized C&C enthusiasts ready to help.
6
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
We appreciate the support! Definitely hearing a consistent theme around bringing the C&C3 style UI to the classic games...
→ More replies (6)
4
u/Reapr Oct 12 '18
Hi Jim, whatever you do, please make her say: "Welcome back, Commander"
Family still plays Generals ZH, there are so many maps online, we love playing local skirmish against the AI. So my first choice woould be a remaster/new version of that, but frankly any C&C game will do, as long as you keep to that original formula - hell I'd even pay for the exact same games with updated graphics and improved AI.
Thanks for getting community feedback Jim, we're counting on you
7
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
While I am no replacement for EVA: "Welcome back, Commander"
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Lithious86 Oct 15 '18 edited Oct 15 '18
Hi there, this is my first post ever on Reddit and i created a account just for this post. I am glad to hear your planning a remaster of one of my all time favorite game IPs. C&C Red Alert was one of the first game i played and i can even remember the day me and my dad walked in to the games shop that now have been closed many years ago and asked for a fun game with tanks and military equpiment, and the Guy took that red big box down from the shelf and said that the game was new and that it was fun, and it sure turned out to be! Been spending probably over 1000h Playing it, and to do it in LAN mode was just awesome with your friends.
So what did Red Alert to one of the best games ever? It had a great setting, the war between the sovjet and the allies.
The music! Omg Hell March is just epic and the others are just great! You should consider have the original music and sound artists on board for the developement!
The specific feel of the cinematics and the acting i think is something that defines the whole series. Its just sooooooo good.
Straight forward gameplay with different types of units with character. It was made for the one man person to play and with some friends over LAN and internet in Classic game modes. it was Not made for e-sports, No MOBA type of play and No micro transactions or pay to win of any kind.
I rather go for a little more dark type of graphic scheme, the original RA was good, not RA3, Think it was too much lollipop effect in that one :P
Theres of course more i could Point out that i would like to see in a new game but this is the main thing that you should try to work on.
Of course its business but EA please just dont think of making a big profit on this game because then you will just ruin your reputation even more in the long run and lose costumers. I think we all, the C&C IP and even the original founders of Westwood Studios deserves something far above what you given us lately. Its sad to see that whats could have been a really huge and popular IP, today is almost totally gone and forgotten. I can just hope that you listen to the fans this time.
4
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 15 '18
Welcome to the subreddit, Lithious86! Thanks for sharing your story about discovering Red Alert. I also remember the first time I found C&C in the store and how much it influenced my gaming journey.
→ More replies (2)
7
u/wildwoodgamestudios Oct 11 '18
Heya Jim,
First of all, thanks for reaching out to us! Glad to see someone's still thinking about the game.
Before I reply, I'd like to point out my username. That's no coincidence. You have one of the most influential franchises over there, and your userbase is crazy-ready for another C&C.
Rather than express what minutae I'd like to see in a remaster, I'd like to talk about the theme of C&C, as compared to other RTS games, just in case you're testing the water for the viability of a completely new product with this post.
The Big Competitors produce these inaccessible, 100% brainpower, adderall-driven games that no adult gives enough shits to immerse themselves in. They've gone from the tongue-in-cheek approach to the "THIS IS ESPN" approach. C&C, by contrast, has always been a celebration of the genre. It's a celebration of the trivial, of the stereotypical. If Starcraft is "Blackhawk Down", C&C is "Hot Shots! Part Deux".
C&C wasn't just a great game to play with your friends, it was counter-propaganda. It let us approach this super-grave topic of war with a light heart. The FMV is absolutely critical to a proper C&C. NOT with excellent actors, mind you. We want the Starship Troopers feel, we want the ridiculous, over-the-top, refreshingly non-pretentious characterizations.
We want Red Dawn, in which all sides are portrayed as a bunch of soap opera goons. Allies and Soviets alike.
C&C touches on the political, the ripped-from-the-front-page, and riiiiight as it gets to the point where it's about to "take a stand" or try to "teach the user a lesson", a bunch of time-travelling psionic commandos show up with Albert Einstein, and then Italy clones Da Vinci and now they have a bunch of wooden helicopter units, and then an Ion Cannon blasts Canada's capitol into the ground.
C&C is, to put it simply, the 'fun' RTS. That's a lot of responsibility, if you take it seriously. So don't take it seriously. At all. Make sure you guys are putting in place a culture that facilitates fun, as you go forward.
I'll end this post with a quick tale. There's these Russian dudes who chill at my local Starbucks. One of the dudes is pretty nice, dude called Alan. We connect over 2 things: our grandfather's experiences fighting Nazis, and our love of Red Alert. It's so beautiful to see all this inter-national hate on the TV, but then be shooting the shit in the parking lot with these supposed 'enemies,' laughing our asses off about Kirovs reporting, or Mammoth tanks with 2 turrets.
Your product is critically important, but it's important in a silly way. I'm shit at ending letters so pretend this is a good ending.
→ More replies (2)3
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 11 '18
This is an awesome overview, Wildwood. Thanks for sharing!
→ More replies (5)
3
u/Ltghavoc Oct 12 '18
Im late! i know, i still hope someone at EA reads this as C&C was a huge chunk of my child hood and i have bought so many copies of these games.
this is a list of all the C&C games i enjoyed and would love to see remastered(yes even renegade is on the list).
Command & Conquer
Command & Conquer: Red Alert + Expansions
Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun + Expansion
Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 + Expansion
Command & Conquer: Renegade
Command & Conquer: Generals + Expansion
Command & Conquer 3: Tiberium Wars + Expansion
Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 + Expansion
First and for most if you are unsure if or how much you should change with a remaster definitely stick closer to the StarCraft 1 remaster and go for a graphical remaster VS a full overhaul of the entire game that changes everything.
Things i potentially would like to see from remasters:
-A bit of re balancing could be interesting but as commander u/KommanderSnowCrab87 noted please provide an options to toggle the balancing used.
-improvements to the way that move/attack/patrol orders are given and allowing order queuing using shift+click, best example would be supreme commander (this may constitute a major change to the way the game feels but it could also be an amazing QoL change)
-Lan play without an internet connection
-being able to zoom out just a little bit more
Things i would never like to see from remasters:
-anything that completely changes the way the game plays
-loot boxes the provide anything other than cosmetics and cant be earned in game (yes i know you guys(EA as a whole) catch a lot of flak for this but i want to reiterate it)
-always online requirements
-do not bother remaking c&c 4 do with it what was done to Atari's ET, if it had been named anything other than c&c 4 it would have fared even worse.
Thing i potentially would like to see from new games:
-Lan play without an internet connection
-strategic zoom(all of the zoom levels)
-improvements to the way that move/attack/patrol orders are given and allowing order queuing using shift+click, best example would be supreme commander
-c&c renegade 2 - Tiberian Sun/Tiberium Wars era - so sue me i enjoyed being able run around on foot and jump in all the vehicles and it fits the battlefield style ok-ish with a few tweeks to the formula.
-for the more modern era i would stick closer to your C&C 3 UI or the Generals UI than the older sidebar UIs
-C&C 3 was to me a great step in the modern gaming and i think you should look to build upon that, to me the things that made C&C great were most of the things left out of C&C 4, I.E. proper base building, resource management, tech tiers and so on.
-full co-op campaign, red alert 3s co-op campaign was a little clunky but if it was refined a bit more i think it could work.
Things i would never like to see from new games:
-loot boxes the provide anything other than cosmetics and cant be earned in game
-always online requirements
-multiplayer only games
-c&c 4 - two things on this
no rock paper scissors balance
game play wise supreme commander 2 made a better c&c game than c&c 4(yes i said it)
-Units with toggled modes ala RA3 japan, i forget use them and find them clunky and gimmicky
Edit: i would love to assist this process as much as i can let me know what i do to help.
2
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
Thanks for the detailed outline, Ltghavoc. Super helpful!
3
u/C0UNTZER0INTERRUPT Oct 12 '18
Thank you Jim for putting yourself in front of the firing line. I know there are a lot of critical fans of such a storied franchise and quite a few who feel burned by previous iterations (myself included). But, hearing that there are plans to remaster the original games gives me a bit of hope.
The original series C&C and C&C: RA will always hold a special place in my heart. As a kid, my dad and I would spend hours playing against eachother with a clunky LAN connection strung through our living room. While he would repeatedly win until I was crying tears of frustration, it is still one of the fondest memories I have with him. The games were always fun and I would spend days practicing to beat him.
That being said, please don't crap on my memories. Do your best to keep these remasters just as fun as the originals. And, please give me the chance to beat my old man to tears.
You hear that dad? 20+ years later, I'm coming for you!
2
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
Thanks for sharing your story, Countzero. It's great to re-connect with the community, and we'll do our best to honor those memories with an authentic experience.
3
3
u/xieliming Oct 12 '18
Great to hear that EA s looking to remaster the classic PC games. A remaster of the originals in the same vein as Blizzard's Starcraft Remastered would be amazing in itself. However as much as I cherish the original games, they do have flaws. So I greatly appreciate the many ways OpenRA delicately improves (without breaking what ain't broke) upon the classics (unit/multiplayer rebalance, unit and base controls etc.) whilst retaining what makes it feel 'right' (visuals, sound, core gameplay loop).
You should consider how EA's interest will/can complement the fantastic work (and community built) by CnCNet and OpenRA and not conflict with it, which neither helps EA"s commercial interest nor the community. One suggestion is to make OpenRA a 'thing' and give it the resources to make it the proper 'remaster' of the classics. For instance whilst I like multiplayer, I'm dying to replay the original C&C Tiberian Dawn single player campaign with all the FMVs, map/mission selection screen etc. which is not possibly right now. Plus since OpenRA is designed to be moddable, it should be easy to appeal to the purists (CnCNet) who probably want only cosmetic changes (e.g. no unit/multiplayer rebalances, control improvements etc.) and those that want to see the classic games refined as OpenRA has done. It would also be a great starting point to remaster all the classic games.
Doing something complimentary this would create huge goodwill in the community, PR, and draw more players into it... which would then make a fantastic launch pad for a true reboot of the franchise.
Lastly, whatever you do, make sure you capture the 'feel' of C&C and what originally made it such a runaway hit. Maybe it's nostalgia, but the original C&C Tiberian Dawn has certain 'feel' to it that I just don't feel as much with the later games. Gameplay, visuals and music aside (these are still important!), I think it's to do with world building and drawing the player in so they feel less like they're playing a game, and more like they're the commander determining the outcome of a mission/war. Specifically, the modern setting with futuristic elements and light sci-fi is relatable yet intriguing, there's world building (something Generals lacked despite its modern setting) in FMVs e.g. briefing on Tiberium, TV ads, news reports (heck even the flashy original MS-DOS installers contributed to this!), units modeled after real-word counterparts (e.g. Bradley Fighting Vehicle, M1 Abrams etc.) and being believable/not too 'zany', theater of war map/mission selection with branching missions and continuity (e.g. GDI mission 6), and small details like Nod SAM sites taking less damage when not exposed, mammoth tanks firing tusks missiles at any target and not just infantry/aircraft as they did in Red Alert 1, infantry men doing exercises when idle, score screen showing how many men died under your command etc. I've played all the C&C single player campaigns (except for C&C4 lol) but I've replayed the original C&C campaign more times than I can remember.
The last time I got hyped for C&C was when I saw the Tiberian Dawn Redux sneak peak. This trailer nails the 'feels'.
PS I know you wanted thoughts for PC, but seriously, a faithful (complementary) remaster on mobile (without microtransactions and other mobile game BS) would be incredible. I replayed the original Dune 2 (not 2000) on Android before it got pulled from the store, and it worked amazingly well with a touch screen!
4
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 16 '18
Hi Xielming, thanks for the input. Both OpenRA and CnCNet have been great at maintaining the classic games, each in their own way. Capturing that "C&C feel" will be vital, so thank you for emphasizing that.
3
u/Veni_Vidi_Legi Flaming APC *Boink* *Boink* *B-b-b-boink* Oct 15 '18 edited Oct 15 '18
Just a small request, could you make sure that left click move/attack (Classic C&C mouse controls) is in the game? Right click move/attack is very awkward. Thanks!
5
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 15 '18
Hi Veni_Vidi_Legi, thanks for bringing up mouse controls! What type of control options would people like to see?
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Pred0Minance Dune 2 Oct 11 '18
Just thank you, really, thank you so much. You just made me, and the kid of the 90s still in me, really really happy. Thank you sir.
3
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
As someone who discovered Tib Dawn when I was 12 years old, I feel the same way :)
2
2
2
u/______DEADPOOL______ Oct 12 '18
EA_Jimtern
EA Producer
Damn, you can intern as a Producer at EA now? Where do I sign up?
5
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
Fun fact, Jimtern was the nickname given to me when I was an intern 15 years ago on BFME :)
2
u/DarkHyudrA Oct 12 '18
I'm bit late to the party but first of all, thank you so much Jim for your time listening us here and all your work towards the C&C series.
Now, about proper feedback, what I can say is that the first C&C were good, and after that the ones I most loved were C&C:Generals and C&C3:Tiberium Wars. What all those games had was less micro and more macro, something that you hardly can find nowadays. The good design of each faction (except for Scrim, they were just obnoxious to play against even though they were indeed a cool addition to the series) and the unique, memorable units are something that cant be lost.
3
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 12 '18
Thanks for the kind words and feedback, DArkHyudrA!
2
u/mahdi71 Oct 17 '18 edited Oct 17 '18
hi,
so happy to hear this
from a c&c fan and an RTS game developer :
every c&c game is almost the same thing with different story and units and we really wants that so...
in this remaster just do this :
1- make the fundation: its really a good idea to make a new modern game engine or improve the old ones or even customize other engines for c&c (once you do this you can make any c&c game in less then 6 month)
2- keep it small: its really important to go small, don't remaster all of c&c games , remaster only one like tiberian sun with that amazing environment (different lighting colors for different parts of the map and a really harsh and war environment)
3- keep story-skirmish-multiplayer(on LAN and online)
after you just do this 3 things:
-you have a modern RTS engine with no bug and ready to go. so you can make c&c games faster
-you keep it small so its ready by the time and not being cancelled and you have what the fans want
-you are in a good place so you can make more RTS games and after remaster every other C&C game you can make it bigger and even try new ideas after getting approval from us :D
4- don't make units look like toys : units must look realistic even scifi units must don't be too much scifi so users can understand them
5- don't add each unit selection border (its make the game look bad) ! : when we select units just show units health bar like generals
6- factories must be built! they don't have to appear from dust! like c&c3 (generals have a good factory built system but Empire of the Rising Sun in red alert 3 have the best factory built system but make it like this: when you build a factory a dozer/builder from command center go to that place and then change to construction system and start to make that factory like generals dozers)
7- make a community request/vote section in c&c website so we can make a request then others can vote that request
8- keep connect us and don't surprise us !
9- look how realistic c&c generals units (air and tanks) are moving! compared to red alert 3
* its almost clear we going to have c&c3 UI : its really good , but make icons better with their own backgrounds
thanks i will be really happy if you reply me EA_Jimtern
2
u/EA_Jimtern Jim Vessella, EA Producer Oct 17 '18
Thanks for all the suggestions, mahdi71! Which icons are you referring to in your last line about the C&C3 UI?
→ More replies (2)
345
u/The_Wkwied Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
If you don't remaster the games (which, I totally believe you should do anyway!), please make a new game that has the gameplay mechanics of the old games, CNC1, RA1, Tiberium Sun, RA2, and Tiberium Wars.
Base building, ore fields. No MOBA style gameplay. No gimmicks.
Oh and for the love of Kane, if you give a name to the player character other than "Commander" or "General", I'm out. CNC4 gave the player character a name, family, backstory... don't do that. That was one of the reasons that game was bad.
Edit
Thanks for Gold! KANE LIVES!
179
83
u/Canadian_Ireland Oct 12 '18
Plus, I really want to hear "Battlefield uplink established. Welcome back Commander." no sound effects behind it or music playing. (Was my fave thing hearing when starting up the game)
→ More replies (2)24
u/Nimonic Oct 12 '18
I mean, don't you basically play a named character in Tiberian Sun?
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (12)31
u/Aerolfos Foreman Oct 11 '18
Eh Anton Slavik was fine. It's not impossible to pull off.
Plus on the pedantic side, "Foreman" is a perfectly acceptable title too :P
533
u/LogicCure Soviets Oct 11 '18
Whatever you guys do, you gotta bring Frank Klepacki on board for music.
24
u/Autoxidation Oct 11 '18
He did the music for Grey Goo. The game didn't seem to do real well, but the music was awesome.
→ More replies (2)31
u/Tleno Oct 11 '18
A remastered soundtrack would be pretty welcome for older titles, yeah. I mean, they're still nice but they were made in the times of way lower bitrates and greater compression.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (25)9
537
u/CFC509 Allies Oct 11 '18
I would pay a small fortune for a remastered Red Alert 2. Just FYI.
36
u/GodzillaFiresox Oct 11 '18
I try to always go back and play RA2 every few months, but the graphics and more importantly the engine crap out after too many things appear on screen. Would love to keep playing this game for hours again
→ More replies (1)19
u/SgtRicko Oct 11 '18
This would probably be the second easiest remaster of the bunch, aside from the Generals franchise.
The balance still holds up well, the gameplay was simple yet fun and fast-paced, and most importantly it was well-received and fondly remembered by the fanbase. They might need to make some tweaks to a handful of units (I'm looking at you, Iraqi Desolator...) but beyond that the biggest effort would just be in upgrading the game into a 3D engine and updating the live-action cutscenes to a higher resolution, if possible.
Now, notice how I didn't say Yuri's Revenge... that sucker is gonna need a faction overhaul to have any hopes of balancing Yuri, probably akin to what the Mental Omega mod is doing. Case in point, Yuri's Boomer subs; they're just too good at everything and literally the only naval combat unit he has.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (19)77
u/10z20Luka Oct 11 '18
THIIIS
I'm 100% sure it would as much of a success as AoE 2 remaster, if done right.
→ More replies (3)
436
u/PigletCNC Oct 11 '18
Just pretend C&C4 never happened and make Tiberium be the old tiberium again and we're probably good for the most part.
73
u/ChosenCharacter Oct 11 '18
Honestly the hype for a proper C&C4 could be through the roof at this point.
68
u/abcde123edcba Oct 11 '18
God Tiberium 3 was so damn good I don't understand how they made 4 NOTHING like 3
→ More replies (6)35
u/NuclearPasta95 Oct 11 '18
This alone could do wonders for EA. No one liked Twilight as a C&C game, no one liked it's shitty ending to the Tiberium universe. They don't even have to remove it from their stores or anything, just declare it a non-canon spinoff of what could have happened. I, and I think most of the fanbase, would see this as a sign they're actually doing what the fans want for a change.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (4)15
u/GodoftheGeeks Oct 11 '18
10000000x this. Lets all just forget that ever happened and give us the C&C4 we deserve!
81
Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
I was raised on C&C. I want a sequel to Generals or anything set in the modern/near future. Give us a true $60 game with legit expansions, no ftp/ptw bs. Old-school build mechanics, RTS not MOBA, tons of units, deep tactics, SP and MP. It is much needed on PC, C&C 3 TW/KW has no need of a remaster. They looks great still.
→ More replies (2)
713
u/XMAN2YMAN Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
Generals zero hour, seriously GENERALS ZERO HOUR!!!! Also Red Alert 2 was Awesome so please remake that. But not just a 4K update. I want new updated engine and he’ll add an expansion while at it. Seriously ZERO HOUR!!!
Thank you kind stranger that took my gold cherry away. I had no idea that soo many people felt like I felt in regards to this amazing game. Off to Disney world I go with this gold!
265
u/maximusdrex Yuri Oct 11 '18
Zero hour is a great RTS and if they remastered it and added new graphics, I’d play it every fucking day.
→ More replies (30)101
150
u/BritishPenguin Oct 11 '18
This. Absolutely this. A Zero Hour remaster would ruin my life in the best possible way.
69
u/UniqueSnowflakeN27 Oct 11 '18
Yes, Generals Zero Hour remastered! I'd buy it for myself and my friends.
Big bonus if you add ships/destroyers and Russia as a faction. I'd buy that DLC.
→ More replies (1)45
u/Nico1300 Oct 11 '18
Yeah that would be awesome. Hopefully in a better engine which doesn't crash and a multiplayer save function :D
→ More replies (3)36
u/Everspaced Oct 11 '18
Our crew plays Zero Hour to this day. Instant buys from us for a remaster or a sequel.
34
u/ElTorroR32 Oct 11 '18
I'm not really keen on whole remaster money-grabbing, but to hell with it, I'll pay for a C&C Generals: ZH remaster in a second. That was an AWESOME fucking game, still got it on my pc, and it STILL rocks, after all these years. No RTS like ZH.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Xyrom Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
Modding tools... Generals has one of the largest modding scenes still around keeping the game alive. From gentool for online play to shockwave, etc adding new units and factions.
→ More replies (32)7
313
u/Sanderson96 Oct 11 '18
Generals and Zero Hour!!
Please
Generals 2!!
39
u/SpoonBasim Oct 11 '18
And Please just bring back the original teams! If you are going to include Europe as a faction, DONT REPLACE US OF A!
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (12)80
•
u/klandri I'm a mechanical man Oct 11 '18 edited Nov 14 '18
EA_Jimtern has already sent proof to the mods. We'd like to thank him for communicating with us directly here!
Edit: For those still checking the thread keep in mind you can always sort by 'new' instead of 'best' above since there are still definitely a lot of comments coming in.
Edit 2: If you're linked to this post from another site be aware there's a newer one here.
→ More replies (10)
44
u/CovertFlobert Oct 11 '18
Good to see EA reaching out to the community again!
The original games, in all their cheesy 90's glory, were so good and memorable they stood the test of time - as is evidenced by the existence of multiple fan communities that are trying to keep their spirit alive. Trying to rehash that would in my opinion be a fruitless endeavour, because Red Alert 1 is still very much alive thanks to projects such as OpenRA or Cncnet.
If someone were to ask me which direction C&C should go, I'd want the Red Alert universe to expand further rather than implode into itself by trying to reiterate on the classic games.
A brand new Red Alert, complete with classic gameplay, FMV cutscenes and a classic over-the-top story with memorable characters and just the right dose of insanity would be a surefire way to get my attention!
73
u/NextWithNita Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
PLEASE make a C&C Generals 2!! The mod and online communities are still very strong for a game that came out 15 years ago. The proof is all over YouTube and ModDB!
→ More replies (7)
69
u/Vector_Strike GDI Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
Call everyone from the old C&C teams and see if they're interested in the project. Put everyoe that accepted inside a room, grab some snacks and a beer or two (not too many because you guys will need to pay attention to the next step). Oh, and call in some new faces that have good ideas and/or are really good at their jobs.
Watch these videos VERY CAREFULLY. Write down their tips, what went right/wrong, etc. Read the comments. Learn with previous mistakes and bring back successes.
Why Was Generals 2 Cancelled? - Investigating Command & Conquer
História de Command and Conquer (1995-2013) (despite the video title language, it's in English)
The Rise and Fall of Command & Conquer [REDUX] | Documentary
Tell EA to NOT mess with the production. Follow the Deadpool 1 movie idea - the less publishers force their ideas, the better. EA must understand that a project done for players primarily should have time and resources to do it, instead of impossible deadlines and stuff executives that don't know anything of the game want in. EA's job is to sell the game, not to make it.
Listen to the feedback people here and in other C&C-related communities are giving you. Do serious market research (here EA an help a lot, but avoid biased conclusions) and discover what the players out there really want - both veterans and newcomers (the RTS genre today isn't the same as it was back in the 90s, after all).
Don't lie. ALWAYS tell us how things are going. A good example of excellent dev-to-consumer relations in this matter is the new Paradox game Age of Wonders: Planetfall. Every week, they roll out a dev diary and they try to answer as much as possible to inquirers. Oh, and have an official forum for more direct contact, but don't forget the big communities. Hire good social media people (that also have contact with the devs to reduce conflicting information).
Test, test, TEST. Do a lot of alpha and beta tests. Should I tell you guys again to TEST A LOT? Less bugs, happier players. They will never be 100% eliminated, but they must be hunted and exterminated!
If possible, release the game in other platforms (GOG, Steam, etc); I use Steam everyday, but barely touch Origin. Ah, cross-platform between PC and Mac, at least. Linux and consoles would be nice, too (if the latter prove to be profitable; I'd watch Stellaris launch on consoles to get an idea).
On Tiberian Sun remake, if it comes to light: ditch Hunter-Killer drones (I seriously freakin' hated them) and AI gobbling on the player in Skirmish games.
Give GDI a charismatic face. As much as James Earl Jones was (and still is) a badass actor, the young fella that remained GDI commander-in-chief after the destruction of GDSS Philadelphia wasn't relatable at all (all fo this in Tiberian Sun). On a more general matter, keep the live-action videos. And the smirkness, the cheesyness: C&C should be FUN!
If range measurement will be in, please show both US and normal units.
Good story. One of the most important things that differentiate C&C from other strategy franchises was the story. Make it good, make it fun, make it relevant. Also, soundtrack - another defining C&C feature.
Modular code: easy to make, easy to fix, easy to replace. Mod support. Good multiplayer systems (for God's sake, no P2P garbage) and matchmaking. Casual and Ranked systems. Graphics not only should be good, but also kept updated. Oh, and most important of all: OPTIMIZED CODE! Noone wants maps needing 2 minutes to load.
RA3 caused some rumbling regarding the female cast skimpyness. Give them 2" longer skirts :P
Localization. German, French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Japanase, Korean, etc. Let us choose different audio and written languages, if possible.
Final note: thanks for giving the franchise a new breath. I speak this not only as a consumer (played C&C1, RA1, TS, RA2, C&C: G/ZH, C&C3, RA3, Renegade), but also as a beginner game dev in the videogame industry. Seeing C&C flourish again would certainly inspire my little company to go forth and try to have the same excellency in videogames.
Damn, I still remember the first game I bought (with my school lunch money): Tiberian Sun, in that big box games from the 90s used to have. The smell, the manual, the disk, the first boot up... ah, those were the times.
Real-Time Strategy is my favorite game genre. Make it great again!
→ More replies (7)
31
u/Nizar_Haddad Oct 11 '18
That's a very big, huge news. And i really hope to see the game finished and released, unlike what happened with Generals 2..
But before i finish, i'd really like to clarify some points about C&C remastering in general... I've been playing C&C games for over 10 years already, and started with ZH (Zero Hour) specifically, and i'm still playing it to the day in MP (Multiplayer), though not the original, but a very famous mod for it called "Contra", the mod at which i personally contribute to - because i'm also a modder of ZH mastering +90% of INI coding + being a debugger and finding detours to solve & avoid bugs.
Now what i really want from the new C&C game team is to keep in touch with the community, we're living in 2018 and heading towards 2019, international communication is now easier than making a phone call back in the years of C&C games production, so it's better to preserve contact with C&C community big fans in order to create the game that all C&C fans wanted, and it's best to keep contact with modders specifically, because their love for the game exceeded the limits of just playing it.
I personally have a lot of ideas for you to add to new C&C Games, but it's best to keep them until the actual work on the project starts. Also i don't want just to add, but also to insist on making the game modder-friendly just as in ZH, unlike what happened with RA3 & CnC 3, because mods are what keep the game alive and fresh.
At Last, i really wanna thank you in advance for working (or planning to work) on this project, and i would like if you make some contact with Contra community on Discord from this link:
https://discord.gg/015E6KXXHmdWFXCtt
30
u/VijoPlays SPACE! Oct 11 '18
Generals and Zero Hour is a game I still boot occasionally (at least two times a year) and when I do, I play exclusively it for a few days.
I have fond memories of RA (and the main line of CnC games) as well, but I looooove the open aspect of Generals, how you can just build anywhere by sending a Dozer/Worker there and just toy around with it by using all of the units and their special interactions. It felt like a sandbox strategy game to me.
29
u/CaptainLord Oct 11 '18
I'd love a C&C Generals ZH re-release with a more stable engine and maybe improved modding support.
10
68
u/Wyatt1313 I got a present for ya Oct 11 '18
Verified Jim Vessella, EA producer. This is a thread for discussion, please keep your comments civil.
22
u/isko990 Oct 11 '18
Thx you so much. I was asking my self what happened to C&C.
Please make a new C&C: Generals 2. With a lot new ideas and good graphics. Yes, we need classic RTS but still new gameplay. New things like world map conquer, new gameplay mechanics and much more factions.
And after is good to make some Remastered games and best is Red Alert 2 + Yuris Revenge in same engine like new Generals 2.
43
u/dvs8 Oct 11 '18
I was lucky enough to play in the Generals 2 alpha test - and was absolutely devastated when it was shuttered. There may have been some pockets of players grumbling but overall I thought it an excellent return, sticking to a formula that works but updating & refreshing just enough to keep it interesting. New visuals bring new light into games, and support for things like VR and audio commands (see F1 2017 for examples of how immersive this can be) would work very well in this genre.
Experience: I played the original C&C as a 10 year old, then Red Alert, RA2, RA3 - the whole roster pretty much, and yes, wasted far too many hours on Zero hour :)
::edit:: Just please, please stick to an upfront purchase and don't try to play the game for the user / provide some kind of fixed static enjoyment goal. The game is a tool, the player playing it and making their own fun with that tool IS gaming.
→ More replies (2)14
u/Wyatt1313 I got a present for ya Oct 11 '18
I remember seeing that red alert fan made game for VR. I believe it was shut down but I never realized how much I want an RTS in VR.
→ More replies (4)
21
u/SirGhostt Oct 11 '18
Another generals game would be brilliant. I feel like the generals series needs more love, even something like a modernised generals:zero hour would be great
93
u/timewaves Oct 11 '18
Red alert 2 and 3 are some of my favorite games of all time, please remaster them for pc and especially Mac!
56
u/mdegiuli Steel Talons Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
tiberian sun and firestorm PLS!!!!
edit: I would happily pay full AAA price for Tiberian Sun, RA2 and/or Generals Remastered. and something close to that for the original C&C and C&C:RA
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (3)10
20
u/Belcaster The Ore Must Flow Oct 11 '18
Awesome to see one of my favorite franchises of all time getting some more juice. Remasters work for me!
57
19
u/Game-Sloth Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
Put Command & Conquer™ The Ultimate Collection for PC on GOG (it’s one of the most requested titles on their wish list). Be honest on the store page that a remaster is in development.
Use the Paradox model: Offer remaster on Origin, Steam and GOG. Use Origin servers for cross-platform multiplayer & leaderboards.
→ More replies (4)
34
Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
C&C IS what made me a PC gamer. Any HD remake or new installment would be fantastic. I loved the old school aesthetic for tiberian sun!
→ More replies (1)
46
u/dangrullon87 Oct 11 '18
Command and Conquer needs to return to triumph as the real time strategy game it was meant to be. PLEASE do not go the MOBA route like Dawn of War 3 did nor the Company of Heroes route.
It needs to be a game that focuses on large scale battles with diverse armies ala Tiberium Wars. Bigger battles, larger scale super weapons and explosive combat. One of my biggest lasting impressions when playing CnC 3 was the first time I fired the Ion cannon, that moment left me speechless and awe of what a super weapon should look like.
The music needs to be engaging, I still to this day listen to the hell march and Mr.Klepaki is still making great soundtracks.
Story wise, people love the old school style campiness and it should be embraced. Real world actors reacting and joining in the crazy in game action.
Please disregard everything done in CNC 4 it was an experiment that failed drastically.
CNC could learn alot from Starcraft II's story telling. Imagine CNC 3 where as you progress through the story your choices change the outcome drastically, you can choose different paths that provide you different technologies and unique units of which some are locked for not going through certain paths. EX: Path A) Grants your orca bombers a lasting fire/ion pulse on the ground that continues to hurt units in the area B) Your Orca bombers now carry a single warhead that devestates buildings / heavy infantry C) Your Orca bombers are now Orca Support which instead of dropping as single bomb stay in the area for X amount of time attack units in the vicinity but have a much much longer reload time.
My two cents, back to work!
→ More replies (1)
25
u/TotesMessenger Oct 11 '18 edited Nov 14 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
[/r/games] EA considering remastering Command & Conquer games, plans for series' 25th anniversary
[/r/italygames] EA sta raccogliendo feedback per un nuovo titolo di Command & Conquer!
[/r/pcgaming] EA considering remastering Command & Conquer games, plans for series' 25th anniversary
[/r/realtimestrategy] EA producer is asking for feedback on franchise return to PC
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
→ More replies (3)
24
Oct 11 '18
Best thing I would want is a remaster of the original command and conquer games.
19
u/Epithus Oct 11 '18
I agree. The first C&C and Red Alert are still my favorites of the franchise. C&C1 has less replay value, however, due to a lack of a singleplayer skirmish option. Adding that feature into a remaster would be awesome!
→ More replies (2)
11
u/Tleno Oct 11 '18
Hi, I'm very glad to hear you're going to show some love to CnC series outside of Rivals!
Okay, first thing first, would you consider contacting the more prominent modding teams of titles you intend to remaster, like SWR productions, Twisted Insurrection team, Mental Meisters and such to ensure nothing gets broken? Over the years modding has become a very important part of CnC community, and it would be a shame if remasters were to break compatibility. Would also be fantastic if you were to, if possible, expand modding capabilities of some of titles - similarly to how Blizzard treated recent Warcraft 3 updates,adding features and expanding engine limitations as requested by modding community.
Also, I really don't know if you intend to create a yet another PC RTS, but in general greater modding support would be most appreciated, extending the game appeal, especially in a genre whose mods have spawned entire new genres.
Another thing, for remasters, I already seem some folks commented on it, but interface improvements would be very welcome. Tiberium Sun's unit lists are massive and cumbersome, and waypoints aren't a very comfortable alternative to genre standard shift-order queuing. You could also consider looking into pathfinding if you intend to revise game code, some games like Generals have major issues with it, which takes away from experience, in particular comparing to later games. 3D titles in general could use a memory expansion, as they're limited by 2Gb, whereas 64bit is a current standard for systems and thus it's more than possible to allocate twice or thrice the memory without a hassle.
EDIT: some people brought up putting up older CnC titles on GoG or Steam. I wouldn't expect it to ever happen considering EA policies, but that would be most wonderful.
→ More replies (1)
11
Oct 11 '18
Seems a lot of people want more Generals. I'd far prefer more RA2/CC3/Kanes Wrath. Regardless though, pls for the love of god dont make anything new to be in the vein of RA3/CC4. And overall more SP than MP focus.
→ More replies (1)
11
Oct 11 '18
PLEASE go back to the Red Alert 2 style instead of the cartoonish style of Red Alert 3. I couldn't get past the look of the game and never finished it. Also, PLEASE REMASTER the older titles. Take Command & Conquer Decades and remaster the entire thing and I will buy it as soon as pre-order opens up for it.
→ More replies (1)
20
10
u/Crono121 Crono Oct 11 '18
Hi EA_Jimtem i love the CnC it was one of the game that I grow up on i like the CnC 3 UI is there a way we can add some disability support like color blindness and closed caption for the Deaf and other things that I can't think of right now getting back to me when you can and your thoughts you think would be good for the game for these disability players like my self.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/IsmoLaitela But what about the Tiberium? Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
I'm a big fan of C&C: Generals & Zero Hour and we still play it occasionally. What I'd like to see, is...
C&C: Generals 2 done right. Wacky stuff, colors and easy shapes to recognize units and buildings from each other and terrain. I feel like due to advancement of graphics, we've lost those little things that helped us to easily see what was going on the battlefield. Many modern RTS games have units way too similar to each others and you can't easily tell them apart from each other or the terrain. That's one thing I love in C&C: Generals, because it's all really clear.
Stable networking code which wouldn't instantly cut the game due to sync error, but would try its best to update it with all participants. I'm looking at you, C&C3!
If and when you decide to shut down official servers, I'd like to be able to enjoy some features, like co-op campaign in RA3. Thanks to community, we managed to get it working again, but I don't want it to be a thing anymore. Allow us to play through local network everything we would be able to play through online match making.
So far no complaints about modding tools, but I still hope this will be continuing trend. I love to play custom maps in C&C: Generals!
→ More replies (1)
9
u/ChiisaiMurasaki Oct 11 '18
These games have a special place in my heart and have been with me throughout my childhood into adult life. I still like to spin up the games now and then and play eith my friend.
I want a true cnc game and there is clearly a gap in the market for this style of game. Bring back the classic formula of base building is my only request!
Cnc3, red alert 2 and zero hour are my favourite from each universe
9
Oct 11 '18
Hi!
Thank you for coming onto the command and conquer subreddit. Command and Conquer Tiberium Wars and its associated Kane's Wrath expansion are excellent games. Kane's Wrath has aged very well and still looks pretty good, even compared to today's standards. The community has refined the game immensely; they've rolled out patches for bug fixes and more recently balance changes. For the refresh it would be a AMAZING for the franchise if you could:
Re-introduce server support for C&C 3
Incorporate the existing community bug fixes and balance changes into a new patch
Upgrade existing graphics and such to current standards (Do not use C&C 4 graphics they are too cartoony - maintain the realism just refine existing models and effects)
Use C&C 3/Kane's Wrath to gain insight into what the player base is looking for in the next C&C
Host a few small-ish tournaments to see what pull exists
I think there's a great market opportunity for EA at the moment. Nobody is releasing RTS games that live up to the C&C standard and a small but very strong community exists.
The BEST thing EA can do at this stage is LISTEN to the community when developing a new C&C. The potential for an incredible game with a HUGE competitive scene exists.
9
u/Suds1979 Oct 11 '18
Remasters I'd like to see: (in no particular order)
C&C Tiberium Sun
Generals Zero Hour
C&C 3 Kanes Wrath (has aged great but why not. It was fantastic)
C&C 4? But done right? But that'd take a complete overhaul and probably couldn't be called a remaster.
Random Remaster Request: Learning AI: Yes that sounds wild but lets give these classic games some real legs. What plagues all RTSs? Player base dies off quickly and a lot of people are afraid to play 1v1. What if there was an AI that was really good that didn't have to cheat (extra $$, etc) to compete with you? Something you could play vs the AI well after the majority of the MP crowd has died off.
I know it's a pipe dream but figured I'd throw it out there.
And no garbage micros transactions, GEMs, etc, please. If you want more $$, then just charge us what you think it's worth.
9
u/Defiant001 Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
Generals Zero Hour remaster and finishing Generals 2 gets my vote. Seeing CNC 3 Kanes Wrath in that pack would be great too.
Played these games with friends for years, would love to have them again.
Something else to consider would be a Origin version of the Steam workshop, there a lot of mods for the CNC games and it adds a ton of value for people to grab a game just for a mod.
8
u/cheeuschrist Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
Anything remotely close to tiberium twilight is a deal breaker.
I paid 90 bucks when it first came out ( aussie dollars ) and i got more enjoyment burning the disc then playing it
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Gunship_Mark_II Oct 11 '18
I've been a C&C fan and a modmaker of 11 years, C&C games got me into serious modding and established modding as my hobby. Whatever you decide to re-make or make new game entierly - don't ditch the modding aspect, C&C games are still alive just because of huge modding scene. People STILL make mods for Red Alert 2, C&C Generals, Tiberium Wars and Red Alert 3, they keep these games alive and attract more fans and sales of original game. This brings me to my second point, the SAGE engine.
SAGE is ( was ) highly versitile and modding friendly engine with a lot of possibilities, it allowed modders to do many works of art, make their own games even, not only that, but it also runs great, especialy its lattest iterations, if there's a slight chance of reviving it from its demise that would be fantastic for all of us. Seeing how EA forces devs to utilize frostbite for all their games scares me, considering how messy, clunky and lifelesss Generals 2 beta was. SAGE is more than the engine, it's C&C's heart and soul, it is what shapes C&C games into what they are on technical level.
C&C Game SHOULD have singleplayer campaign with FMV in them, it's what makes a C&C game a C&C game.
As for the game I would love to see remade or have a sequel it's going to be either Tiberian Sun or C&C Generals.
Whatever you guys do, best of luck to you, and thank you for your initiative of bringing real C&C back, we're all for it.
7
u/whileFalseSemicolon boink Oct 11 '18
I just hope the art style of new 3d models look less like toys.
7
u/codename_john GDI Oct 11 '18
C&C is the first PC game i bought as a kid, I'm now in my mid 30s. With that said, I'm extremely passionate about C&C and sad to see it neglected. Some ideas I'd suggest is to look at what Blizzard has done with Starcraft. Doing a remastered version would probably be quite popular if managed well. I'd say the majority of fan-made mods is just updating older C&C games to new graphics engines and platforms. If C&C/Red Alert was redone with modern graphics, modern AI and had an option to play original and remixed missions I would buy that in a heartbeat.
I would also suggest that EA TAKE CARE OF THEIR IPs. It's nice to build a great C&C game and get it out there, but leaving it to wilt afterwards is the most likely fate from any game from EA. Blizzard has done a wonderful job maintaining a core set of games lively and interesting. Doing that doesn't happen overnight, but the care and attention to detail IS noticed by fans.
C&C3 was a great return to form, but trying to replay it now, the mechanics seem dated compared to StarCraft 2. SC2 has so much more replay-ability I've to expect units to behave in certain manners at this point. Path-finding, auto-attack, reaction times, etc. C&C3 feels clumsy now. Realistic graphics don't always equal better also. SC2 has a great balance between a serious style yet still being able to distinguish each and every unit quickly and easily.
Whatever direction EA decides to go with, stick with the core gameplay, updated to modern game mechanics, with modern graphics, it should do well. But focus on the core customer, a good game can't be a jack of all trades and master of none.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/LordOmacron Oct 11 '18
Don't let EA put their nickel and dime microtransactions in a full PC CnC game if they are in it I won't buy it. If you want my money Want I want Is a Well Structured campaign with those Glorious FMV Cutscenes that only CnC seemed to be able to pull off. I crave a Great RTS Single Player Campain. And don't make me Use Origin just to play the game that is another deal breaker for me. Now since CnC 3 and Mass Effect 3, I've not felt inclined to give EA any of my money but if you can give me what I have been looking for then I will happily give you my money. I know what I want and if it's not forthcoming why should I give you any money?
7
u/JacopKane Oct 11 '18 edited Sep 15 '19
This is the greatest news from video gaming scene I've heard in a decade!
Please, make Tiberian Sun first, pretty please!
12
Oct 11 '18
A new Hell March would be nice! Also, please, don't fuck it up like you did with C&C 4. Generals and Red Alert, maybe taking bits and pieces off CnC 3 would be great!
→ More replies (1)
6
u/Zaptagious Command the future. Conquer the past. Oct 11 '18
Wow this is great news! Thank you for taking the time to do this, Jim! We really appreciate this!
I don't know the ambition which would go into this project but if you're gonna remaster anything I think a good choice is to go for either C&C Red Alert 2 or C&C Generals, seeing as how those games were the most popular ones if memory serves. Those games had really strong multiplayer components which I think is an important factor in this genre. It could really help in bringing in both a lot of C&C veterans as well as new players.
To be honest, I'd say that Red Alert 2 has aged rather well actually (same with the preceding games TD, RA1 and TS). There's a certain charm with the pixely graphics. Generals has not aged as well and could use a facelift, but is not as iconic a C&C game as the other games. Tiberium Wars and RA 3 still holds up. Seeing how we have OpenRA, there's less need for a remake of the older games.
In any case I would personally be happy with anything we get which can call itself a true C&C RTS.
6
23
u/BobTheB1Bomber Oct 11 '18
I've played almost every single C&C title from the very beginning. So it holds a special place for me. My brother and I still on occasion spin up OpenRA to do battle.
First off I'd like to thank you for reaching out to the community and sincerely hope this might lead to a renaissance for the franchise after what seemed like an eternity stuck in the dark ages.
That being said I'll be honest. I am not EA's biggest fan and I am not going to jump up and down at this post in excitement. Although EA was able to produce many titles which I enjoyed I've had to see many more kill off franchises I loved.
Forgetting all that if you want to bring it back to the PC I think there are a few things to consider about C&C that I think many loved:
It use to thrive at simplicity. It had mechanics that were easy to understand and easy to use. Having a simplistic building system and ui made it easy for any player to pick up and get going.
It had a certain charm about it. Never took itself too seriously.
The stories were fun and interesting.
Base building... DON'T take it out
Interesting and unique units
Battling for scattered resources and fighting for map control
Some things away from the old games:
I'd suggest creating a new universe or going for a new Generals again. I think you need something fresh.
Something I'd love to see in an RTS again is some proper physics such as TA and Supreme Commander. Being able to use the terrain to block projectiles was really cool. Planetary Annihilation attempted this again, but it just didn't have the charm for me (Bland and boring units) and as bold and cool as the idea of a sphere for a map was it just didnt work for me (Perhaps with VR it could work, but for me it felt awkard)
Whatever you decide to do I hope it ends up changing my current opinion about EA. I'd like to the remember a company where "Challenge Everything" was about user expectations and not Belgium gambling laws.
11
Oct 11 '18
Honestly, it's refreshing to see the EA team reaching out to the community before announcement. I know we can be a picky, recalcitrant group (C&C Online) but we've seen some less than stellar efforts from EA (Killing Westwood, EA LA, etc etc.)
As several others have mentioned, modern stability and play-ability of all the originals would be a high priority. I've been playing these since C&C 95 and it kills me that it's nigh-impossible outside of the "Open" efforts to keep these games alive. Personally, I think Sole Survivor and Renegade should get included in whatever package, as these are pretty unique to C&C. Along with that package, high-res FMVs if possible from the originals. (I do understand that if the files are unavailable that'll be impossible.) And don't rake us over the coals for the price. C&C is almost abandonware, it'd be pretty hard to justify charging us $100 at this point.
Moving forward, I think the C&C brand has a lot to offer. Maybe not super-camp, but lean into the sci-fi. Maybe give us a "core" C&C game, then a Generals or "new story", then an RA. Incorporate what is working in modern strategy games but keep it C&C. Look at what Petroglyph, Harebrain, Paradox, Stardock, and Blizzard get right. We love the past, but if it's a new game with tired gameplay *cough* Rivals/C&C4 and mobile gameplay *cough* it won't go over well.
Joe Kucan and Frank Klepaki are pretty much staples of the franchise. Some may understand why either can't or won't contribute or EA doesn't decide to include them, but others will have issue if they're missing.
Having an EVA that is "smart" might be pretty cool if you want to push the technology. What with Alexa, Siri, Google etc, an actual "AI" that can dynamically advise and comment beyond pre-recorded lines would be a serious advance and definitely put EA/C&C in the spotlight.
New games should have deep personalization/rpg mechanics when it comes to the development of forces. Allow us to research/combine/steal more than superficial or limited stuff (eg RA2's spies, Starcraft 2 campaign force improvements.) And I'm talking about the single-player campaign.
Lastly, and this is only my opinion, but I really don't think a multi-player focused C&C will sell. A, RTS/Grand Strategy is a limited market. B, the last C&C online effort bombed before alpha. C, even StarCraft 2 is losing players.
Thank you so much for your time, u/EA_Jimtern and we really do appreciate you coming here and seeking input. I'll be definitely sharing this with my friends with whom I grew up playing LAN Tiberian Sun games into the wee hours of the night.
KANE LIVES IN DEATH!
→ More replies (2)
5
5
u/LogicCure Soviets Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
The Homeworld Remaster from Gearbox a couple years ago had a neat gimmick in that it had a merged multiplayer in which the factions from different games could be played against each other. It might be neat to have a standalone multiplayer client that can have factions from the different series branches battle against each other.
Could also potentially sovle a playerbase fragmention problem you'd run into with haveing each game or series segregated.
5
u/reinierdash Oct 11 '18
if going back to the GDI and nod timeline make a new story line thats after C&C 3
and bring the scrin back please everyone likes them
→ More replies (2)
5
u/AlphaMarker48 Oct 11 '18
I would love to see a remaster of Generals, Red Alert 2 & 3, along with Tiberium Sun and Tiberium Wars.
5
u/znx91 Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
If you want to do nice things for the fans I would start remastering all the old C&C games, from the original C&C95 to RA2, and price them reasonably. I hope you actually listen and this is not just all talk :)
5
u/502apples Oct 11 '18
Command and conquer generals zero hour remaster for the love of God make this.
5
u/Dionysus24779 Oct 11 '18
Now if only the games wouldn't be exclusive to the Origin launcher...
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Escurik Oct 12 '18
As a longterm fan fan of C&C I would add this to the pool (probably mentioned millions of times before me)
Fast paced RA gameplay
Keep mechanics simple - stick to the classic gameplay
A good story campaign
Klepacki for the music
No lootboxes, microtransaction, MOBA style gameplay. However, for online play we could live with somekind of matchmaking, just to keep online play fun.
LAN PARTY SUPPORT. Don't fix it online play only - RA is famous in my country for being THE lanparty game, where my friends could bring their laptops, beers and a pizza and have tons of fun.
So make sure we can run it on below average machines. 3D might not be needed, who needs 3D in RTS? :D
5
u/tredbobek Oct 12 '18
What games are you planning to remaster?
I, for one, love C&C: Generals and would love to see a remaster. But anything is welcome. Remasters are so rare.
.
.
Can I have some shoes?
5
u/HomburgPokes Oct 12 '18
I just want to play C&C with my kids.
LAN play with mods is the best, but I just want to play C&C with my kids without worrying about other players.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/BracerCrane Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
I've been playing the First Decade almost constantly for the past decade (and a couple years plus). Here's my hot takes, in order of importance to me.
High Resolution support. Generals and Zero Hour have aged horribly and they even look worse than they play while the earliest C&C titles were designed for displays one quarter the size of modern displays. Resolution settings should be handled within the main launcher (if we think how The First Decade handles single game launches) and the resolution settings should default to your current resolution with the option to select a lower resolution for those nostalgia moments.
Option to play with "Legacy" input settings or "Unified". It's horribly disorienting trying to play C&C, RA and Generals back to back because they have such different keymappings and control schemes. Extra points if it's possible to select a games control scheme and use the same control scheme across all titles. At minimum it should be done like OpenRA does control scheme selection.
Fiddle-free Windows 10 implementation, but this is probably a given. Things like the VideoBackBuffer issues that make RA2 unplayable need to be resolved straight out of the box.
Like with the Secret of Monkey Island remaster, you should be able to switch between remastered and original graphics. Some people do still enjoy the crisp voxelwork of C&C and RA2, and this is extremely important if you decide to rerender any old cutscenes for the remaster.
Official mod support. Services like CNCNZ need to be acknowledged for their decades long service to the community and people like Lion from RA Den / CNC Den should get official acknowledgement for fostering a community who've kept the oldest games interesting and in playable condition. Implementation and activation / deactivation of mods should be done within the launcher and without any need to alter .ini files by hand, mods should be browseable from within the launcher. MODS ARE WHAT ALLOW TODD HOWARD TO PUBLISH SKYRIM FOR EVERY DEVICE WITHOUT HAVING TO DO ADDITIONAL CONTENT.
5
u/_Constellations_ Oct 12 '18
Regarding what comes next, I find myself in a tricky situation here. Like when a crime novel writer writes himself in the corner, I think that's where the CnC franchise is at the moment. First of all, I played only 4 CnC titles: Red Alert as a child, which I loved, Tiberium Wars (+Kane's Wrath) that is very dear to me to this day, and Tiberium Twilight which could have worked if not for the awful progression system and LEGO-like graphics. The last is Red Alert 3 that I tried to like but absolutely hated because of the forced-coop/shared resources part, and the yet again too cartoony graphics. I like my CnC gritty, dark, and real, like CnC3 was. From a game that is about war and an alien terraforming invasion, I want the feeling of *size*. That just how massive that spine-like scrin mothership is where the ribs are all detachable fighters. That what terrifying power the scorpion tail-like defensive towers of NOD represent, it's oppressive height towering above the infantry.
Once you go cartoony, you just kill it all. Which brings us to another important part of the presentation of the franchise, story.
You have to decide what is the definitive face and continuation of the franchise is. We have alternative history, sci-fi future, different timeline alternative history, different timeline future, across the whole franchise I think I'm seeing 4 maybe 5 individual microuniverses. Times have changed since the 90s and early 2000 years, it is no longer considered normal - sadly - for people to stick to a game several years unless it's an MMO. Which means if you want to sell something to me at least on a bi-yearly basis if not yearly already, it has to be familiar, has to be a continuing thing. To this day I want Tiberium Wars' story to continue somehow while I ignore the existence of Tiberium Twilight.
Next, you also have to understand who you are making a next CnC for. Today, 15ish year old teens propably have not heard about RTS games outside of StarCraft 2. Almost nobody makes RTS games like that anymore. Everyone is looking for a unique gig, some game breaking feature that fundamentally changes up how we play. To include buzzwords like personal, customization, your unique experience. See, those who loved Command and Conquer back in the days are old enough today to not buy any of that marketing bs and outright hate it even. Just see what happend to the - assumed to be legendary - return of Dawn of War III, that pulled the "make your own loadout, we move to a bit of a MOBA structure, and here is cartoony graphics" card in Blackjack when they already had a 20. Or see what happend to the always online free to play cartoony Age of Empires game Microsoft did a few years back. Or to your own CnC4 Tiberium Twilight, that threw out the RTS formula for something that could have possibly worked (Dawn of War II worked great too), introduced locking content and technology behind leveling up, that today I can imagine you'd repeat and add microtransactions on top of it, and made a cheesy brazil soap opera family drama bullshit of a random soldier the central piece of the story that was supposed to be the grand finalé of Kane, the scrin tower, and a dying planet.
Forget, all of it. Please. Unless you just want to put another nail in the coffin of the once legendary franchise's name. No leveling up, no content locking behind leveling, no unique player skills. Make a classic, old school RTS, like CnC3 was , like StarCraft 2 was. Make a worthy campaign story for it. Have 3 different factions and at least 1 central character that is NOT the player, but a face like Kane was. Have realism based graphics. And release it. That's it. You don't have to reinvent the wheel, or paint it rainbow coloured.
And for the remakes: if I see, ANY, but ANY way it is changed to support microtransactions, or box opening, or leveling, or whatever cancer that defines games these days I wouldn't want it for free let alone pay for it.
5
5
u/spinalscratch8 Oct 12 '18
First of all this are great news. Just a few ideas:
-4k and support for windows/mac and ultrawide.
-Focus on generals at least but I would love all of them.
-Keep it simple, same formula than before. Base building. Unlimited units cap. Same OST.
-Cosmetics are fine. We are grownups with good incomes and we are ready to support what we love. (treat us with respect though).
-This one will be really difficult but launching it Steam would be a killer move. Don't be greedy.
best regards
5
u/acrynom Nov 03 '18 edited Nov 03 '18
A few things.
Uncapped FPS. At least 60 frames/sec, higher is better.
Minimal UI. No huge thick beams around radar, etc.
C&C 3 realistic graphics. (shadows, clouds, hot air ripple effects)
Nod, GDI, Scrin
Listed above in one game.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/yiorgiom Oct 11 '18
A remaster would be a true love letter to the fans and the franchise. I am so on board for this.
The whole spectrum of games deserve it. Tiberian deserves its own, Red alert its own, and generals its own.
But personally I would be most content with something like how age of empires and age of mythology did it. Updated graphics and textures, dedicated servers, and an overall smooth experience on new hardware. Less is more (in regards to a remaster)! Then maybe it can be realistically done for all of them (maybe maybe)
→ More replies (1)
11
u/NuclearPasta95 Oct 11 '18
I'm sure you can understand if I say I'm a little apprehensive about this. I've been a fan on C&C since my early childhood and it has shaped a lot of my tastes in gaming and general entertainment as I've grown up. I think we can all agree EA, to put it lightly, has ignored their fans when it comes to C&C. That said, if EA is finally ready to give C&C the shot it deserves, I won't be against that.
Here's what I would personally want to see:
-Tiberian Twilight removed from canon. I don't hate this game. But it's not a C&C game and has always been a smack in the face to the dedicated fanbase. Don't even have to do anything major, just declare it a side-story "what-could-have-happened". This alone would do a lot for not just myself but a lot of other fans in giving EA a chance at this.
-As a side not of the above, no games that require internet to play the damn single player.
-Bring back old names for any new games that get made. Frank Klepacki and Joe Kucan are part of what made C&C what it is. I can't think of C&C without them.
-No loot boxes, micro transactions, pay-to-win, or any of that nonsense.
-Leave modders alone. This is the one thing I can actually say in favour of EA, they haven't gone after any modders in the C&C community. I don't think this is something that needs to change. This also includes groups like CnCNet or OpenRA, which have been the only way for many of the fans to play the old games online for years now. Just leave them be.
-Updated patches for many of the games. Some of these games are horribly unbalanced. Yuri's Revenge Battle Fortresses are absolutely ridiculous, Laser and Super Weapons generals are basically unfightable, and RA3's resource collection is disgustingly broken. Again, some new patches just fixing some things like this would go a long way in getting old fans on board with EA moving forward.
-Classic C&C gameplay. Base construction, fast game speed, miners collecting resources from ore fields, futuristic and sci-fi tech, these are all staples of C&C games and should be included in any new games, and remembered to preserve in any remasters.
I could probably think of a whole crateload of other things I could list, but for me those are the most important things. No, I don't expect some of them to happen, like new patches for 15 year old titles, but they are examples of the kind of thing I want to see. I can't say I'm excited at the idea of EA touching C&C yet again, but I am hopeful. As are a lot of other fans are I'm sure. Please don't let us down yet again with some bs game no one asked for.
As an aside, what has changed at EA that you're now looking to revive C&C as an RTS franchise? Is Microsoft developing a new AoE game, a classic competitor of C&C's, part of that decision?
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Squirrel09 Oct 11 '18
A lot of good points, I'd like to include keeping 2d games 2d and the 3d games 3d. Very rarely have I seen a 2d->3d / 3d->2d conversion end up good.
Thanks for doing this, looking forward to see what's to come!
4
u/dolfan4life2 Oct 11 '18
Please continue to utilize the B-movie style cutscenes. I love the characters and how they drive the stories.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/TberDurron Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
Just make another game EXACTLY like Tiberium Twilight. I think that was everyone's favorite.
/s
→ More replies (2)
4
u/colebygr Oct 11 '18
Jim if this Command and Conquer remastered project goes through will you be doing a cease-and-desist on the openra community I'm kind of worried about that situation
4
u/vikingzx Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
I thought this day would never come ... But I do have some thoughts and observations that I am more than happy to give you.
First of all: Things that really matter—
Atmosphere. This is one thing that the original games had in spades (and 3 did really well visually). They just had a solid, really good feel that put you in the game. Sun did it best, but they were very focused on providing sound cues, visual cues, interface, etc, that put you in that universe. As a kid, and even as an adult, I felt like I was a commander in the Tiberium War. Like Tiberium was encroaching on my home. The atmosphere was phenomenal. For a modern RTS that matches this atmosphere, check out Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak, which worked really hard to bring its atmosphere to life. More than anything, C&C games lived and breathed their atmosphere, whether it was the stormy, gloomy future of sun or the manic, sunny half-goofy/half-serious shine of Red Alert 2. Atmosphere really is king. (EDIT: The GDI evacuation mission of C&C3 with the Scrin and GDI AI battling all around you was excellent for this)
Campaign Design. Mission and campaign design seem to have sadly gone out the window in a lot of RTS games (though not all), but one thing C&C really did well was give players cool missions. And the options! Who doesn't remember having a single commander and no idea what to do with them? And then being penalized with a second half if you didn't figure it out? Or choosing between branching mission choices, some of which opened or closed further branches? C&C was famous for those, and they need to be back. Let us weigh some choices, try some variety! For that matter, missions themselves can be creative. Don't fall into the Starcraft 2 trap of just putting a countdown clock on it and calling it good. Think outside the box! And while you're at it ...
The AI Plays by the Rules. In the Campaign at Least. Look, one thing C&C did right (among many) was making the AI play by the player's rules in the campaign. Take out a tech building? The AI isn't sending those units at you until it rebuilds it. Take out their power? Down the power goes. Take out a construction yard? No new buildings until it's replaced. Up against 2 bases? Take down the satellite, and you won't face attacks from there anymore. I bring this up because in Starcraft 2, the "big" RTS, it's not true. Enemy units just spawn in bases (or where the base was) and rush the player. You can spend your time wiping out satellite bases just to watch enemy units appear out of thin air and move toward you in predetermined patterns. Not cool. Let the player think strategically.
AIL C&C 3 was a step in the right direction. You know what I loved about C&C3? How smart my units were. Watching a Titan in Kane's Wrath decide that it would be easier to stomp the lone enemy vehicle it was facing and walk over it before returning to guard? Awesome! Watching my infantry try to avoid being run over? Awesome! Watching my Orca on guard run out of ammo, rearm, and return to their post? Awesome! I LOVE SMART UNITS! They weren't smart enough that you could leave them alone all the time, but they were smart enough that you could give them some leeway not to commit suicide in dumb fashion. I loved this. It let me fix on a strategy and more important battles, rather than always microing everything (unless I wanted to). And while we're on that topic ...
Armor-Facing was BRILLIANT, and should forever be in C&C. Armor facing was one of the best inventions 3 brought to the series. Combined with formations, it make tactical positioning incredibly important. With it, real-life maneuvers like splitting your forces for a pincer maneuver valid strategies. Combined with formation movements and reverse move, it made battles a lot more varied. It should absolutely return and NEVER leave, in my opinion. That doesn't mean it was perfect: being able to lock formations for line-of-sight purposes and cover would be nice (also so that you could more orderly swing forces around), and easier "reverse move" clicks would be nice. And while we're at it ...
I like Squads. There. I said it. I think the C&C3 squads were the best approach yet, and want them back. Combined with armor facing and formations? And cover? Awesome! But with them we need ...
Better Terrain and Maps. C&C3 kind of flubbed this one. A lot of modern RTS games have. Give us some real terrain! Remember how units moved slower in trees in Sun, faster on roads in RA? Or had different speeds for up and down hills, etc etc? That was GREAT! Crud, maps used to be teeming with trees, cliffs, and hills! Bring that back! Not only was it great for atmosphere, but it was great for working across and through. For example, check out these maps from the Twisted Insurrection mod. They look like cool places! Also, those pictures are huge. Just a warning. This goes great with ...
Classic Shroud. The Shroud was great. There was uncertainty to the battlefield. I feel like a lot was lost with having the whole map revealed and just under fog of war. Even if it's the same map every time (and I'd like to suggest a little randomization here and there) the shroud left you feeling constrained until you explored.
The Economy. And here we get into something that some might disagree with but ... limit the economy. I've watched tourney games for C&C3, and it was amazing how runaway the economy became. All that cool stuff like smart units and armor facing? It stopped mattering because money stopped mattering. I watched a game where one player casually queued up fourteen more harvesters after one field got wiped out and in the voice over wasn't even concerned. That's ... not great. The problem was that the economy was runaway. My suggestion? Limit it somehow. Restrict the number of harvesters or refineries that a player can have and set a cap. Make their production time long and laborious. Something that forces players to make more meaningful decisions about where their funds go. A game where a player thinks "Should I buy this, this, or ... wait, I'll just order all three!" has less decision and strategy where a player thinks "I can afford this and this ... or one of those ... Hmm ... what first?" Maybe look at how Dune 2 handled harvesting with the base harvester always being replaced free of cost while extras died. And in that vein of dying ...
Hard Counters SUCK. They're easy cheese from a design perspective, but not the greatest from a gameplay perspective. Dawn of War 2 did this very well, IMO, in having counters that did not exceed a 25% bonus against their effective type. Meanwhile, SCII has units that deal 250% bonus damage against type in straight-up "Rock-Paper-Scissors" approach. Now, does it work? Yeah. But personally it makes for a sucky strategy game, since the strategy becomes "Meta counter micro" and balls of units. Now, C&C does have some harder counters (AA units, for example, or infantry vs vehicles in some cases) than that, which is fair as DoW2 has a smaller, more tactical field and tends to adjust damage to compensate, but making more units viable in combat against one another doesn't mean players will throw blobs at one another, especially if formations and terrain are an important part of the game. Sneaking infantry through woods to flank a tank? Awesome! Letting Mammoths soak up all kinds of fire while pounding away with guns and rockets? Awesome! Blobs of same-unit types winning or losing based on counters? BORING! Let players strategize!
Upgrades: I liked upgrades in 3. My only suggestion would be to give players variety and let them pick between options for upgrades. Like the Overlord tank in Generals, but maybe even army-wide.
Sub-Factions: Yes please. Love the lore, love having variety to play with.
Music. Bring back Frank Klepacki, and bring back the music-player with tracks and shuffle. It was iconic to C&C.
EDIT: Tough Units: The janky, cartoony units of RA3 sucked. Hard. They looked like poorly-animated toys, not machines of war. C&C4 had the same issue. Atmosphere problem. Fire that studio. Again, look at Deserts of Kharak and how those units move and behave with the sand, environment, and one another. Sun and Wars had it.
And ... Crud, I think that's it. I may think of more. But off the top of my head, that's it.
Look, I love C&C. My whole family does. It was iconic to us growing up, introduced all of us, my dad included, to PC gaming, and set the stage for a love that we'll probably pass onto our kids. We stayed up late playing the campaign so many times my mother was unhappy with my father for playing so late. All of us still have at least one C&C game installed to this day. Some several, and two all, along with more than one mod. We all have favorite units, factions ... This series defined our childhoods.
I'd love to see it come back and do justice to C&C and the genre it built once more. Good luck, and I hope my advice gives some ideas. And thanks, by the way, for Kane's Wrath.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/kalivon Oct 12 '18
This comment might get buried, but please keep in mind that we are not all 200apm korean pro gamers.
Some of us look fondly on the days before e-sports, where we built a giant army and sent them into other giant armies to watch stuff get blown to bits.
Building things up and then watching it get blown all to pieces was a strangely cathartic experience.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Gloryboy811 Allies Oct 12 '18
Thought. As a fan since the original CnC and RA1.
Every game since Red Alert 3 was a cancer to the franchise and should be removed from existence.
Red Alert 3 was not amazing. Stop trying to be so different. RA2 YR was amazing.
2.1. We don't want cartoon graphics.
2.2. We don't want wildly different base building mechanics. We want classic "Construction Yard" and click in the surrounding area to place building.
2.3. We want defined universes... Red Alert is basically like an alternative cold war with crazy tech. We don't want a zany Asian faction that leaked from Generals. CnC is the very futuristic one. More dark mood. But as I said.. we still need bases! Don't take away what makes the games great. ie the core game mechanics!Generals and Zero Hour were very different to traditional CnC but were still very fun! Generals 2 was heading in a decent direction (besides the free-to-play model) The graphics and art style were perfect. The timelines are good
Don't ever make a mobile game or web game again. It is insulting to any real CnC fan.
If you are going to make a remake of a game, red alert 1 and CnC 1 are old and their factions were basically exactly the same. So after the sequel games we can't go back to that.
In the single player, we need live action cut scenes.
This is a side note.. But if you make some kind of combination of Company of Heroes and Red Alera/Command and Conquer.. that would be lit af.
4
4
u/Dereaper89 Oct 13 '18
I wish for a remake of Zero Hour.
Slow Gameplay for intensive base building (no quick esport Matches)
LAN Support with AI Skirmish (no asynchon error pls)
Solo campain
NO Microtransaktions, maybe dlc/addons to buy but one price for full game!
easy MOD Support
take the Original Zero Hour, Port it to a better Engine, make it HD and clean the bugs, that will be the perfekt Game
i wrote it already but its important: Skirmish LAN with AI Players!!! We Play Zero Hour so often at a friends place on LAN and that in 2018. best Game ever but it laggs and with to much Units the asynchron error appears
4
u/walksonpoo Oct 14 '18
CNC core elements, but NOT continuing from CNC4. I played the Generals 2 alpha, and it was going great until it was just stopped. I would love another CNC game, but it has to be done right.
4
4
4
u/annoymousrightsuser Oct 28 '18
Hi Jim thanksfor contacting us! Is the intention to remaster the oldgames on a modern engine like frost bite? Or will you be doing something close to an updated version of the old game engine? Will the game use a different engine and therefore feel and look different to the original or will it be more or less the exactsame game and engine with minor updates?
4
u/eadem Oct 29 '18
Didn't expect to see this!
I think everyone here's basically said what I want to say, but I want to add--please keep LAN functionality!
I'm sorta attached to the big clunky sidebar in the older games, but replacing it with the C&C3 one wouldn't really bother me at all, especially since hotkeys are nice.
4
u/XonURhed Oct 31 '18
Please for the love of C&C do not work years on a new game just to cancel months before release.I was so excited about the new "Generals" game. Bought the Ultimate edition only to never see any beta play or invite. I have been playing C&C since PlayStation 1.Multi-tap was a must weekends at my house.I have been let down time and time again by EA. The most important thing I would suggest is to not rush a product just to meet deadlines. Please take the time to finish the game and balance it. Microtransactions are gonna rule a new game out from the jump.I believe EA really owes us an awesome game at this point.I would even love to see an FPS...as the Tiberium game never saw the light of day. Please please don't let us down. And give everyone possible the opportunity to get into the Beta.
XonURhed
7
u/tore29 Accessing Brotherhood Archives Oct 11 '18
If a new C&C game is in the works please do not fall into the trap of making an "eSports game". Keep in mind that the "eSports community" does not usually choose "eSports games", it chooses fun games that are easy to learn, but hard to master.
But eSports features such as replays and observer UI's are a great things and do not underestimate the value of a LAN mode even in todays online era.
Also do not fall into the trap of making StarCraft 2, maybe look at the services surrounding it, but do not look at gameplay that much.
Do not make a A-move to win game, this may sound a bit weird, but do not make the auto targeting AI too smart, require some manual targeting of important units.
Please do not disregard features or characteristics of the classic games because "they are old" or go against "what is fashionable". Try to look at how these games are played at higher levels, you might be surprised and implement some quirks that may make the games more interesting for players who have mastered it, however do not go too far that is alienates newer players. Remember "easy to learn, hard to master".
Singleplayer campaign and skirmish mode is of course a must.
One last thing, you might want to consider console releases too. The UI's of C&C3 and RA3 for console seems like a good starting point for gamepads, but don't forget consoles do support keyboard and mouse too, see RA1 and Dune 2k for PS1 (mouse only) and Age of Empires 2 for PS2 (supports keyboard and mouse))
→ More replies (1)
3
u/ConscriptDavid Oct 11 '18
Oh my god, big if true!
But like, Seriously? This is exactly the sort of news that should ahve arrived ALONGSIDE Rivals. I promise this would have made Rivals go down our throats much easier (it's like Bethesda announcing fallout shelter but there would not be fallout 4 coming afterwards, imagine the shitshow!)
3
u/LaughingCheeze Oct 11 '18
For the 25th Anniversay (WOW) I think the best thing you could do would be to release the original franchise to GOG, let them update it and everything.
Also agreeing with the other comments, we can forgive and forget that C&C4 never happened. If it is another Tiberium game, it really needs to have the fauna and flora created by Tiberium as well. C&C3 and Kane's Wrath, while great games, lacked the atmosphere that Tiberian Sun/Firestorm had. Please also support 21:9! Thanks and its great to hear theres some life in C&C!
3
u/GAGAgadget Oct 11 '18
A remake of the classic games is the thing I always needed, but didn't know until now. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE get Frank Klepacki and Joseph Kucan back to the series somehow!
3
u/nikkity1017 Kane Oct 11 '18
If they are bringing the CNC franchise back to PC what world might it be in? Generals Tiberium Red alert (New one that comes up?)
3
u/MathDotPi Oct 11 '18
I'd recommend keeping the games balance and models/maps the same, but upgrading/reworking the UI, networking and community support, for example keep the map sharing and allow for custom game balancing, to be dictated by the host.
Quick Matches and a tournament system seems to be a requirement these days..
The music selection was always great in c&c, and the ability to change tracks and etc. was a feature missed in the later games.
Other small additions such as chat history, a handy way to switch between global and team chat, colourblind/team colour options and changing superweapon times into realworld times would be great.
I'd also love VR support, but that'd be asking a lot.
3
u/Paper_glasses Oct 11 '18
I really like the live actors for the little pep talks and storyline acting the cheese really makes the game feel like a well deserved break from the fun base building and very unique and still useful units with clear top but slow and pricey end units.
3
3
u/TheStrangeDarkOne Oct 11 '18
I am the maker of one of Kane's Wrath biggest Mods (called One Vision). I have had deep insights into the XML code of your game and I cannot help but to wonder: WTF happened? xD
A lot of content was either cut or rearranged. Some examples:
Repair APC for ZOCOM (instead Steel Talons)
Improved shatterers for Steel Talons
The Black Hand Mantis was called "Tank Tank"
A cut upgrade for Marked of Kane Fanaticsto disguise them as militants
or a cut "turbo boost" ability for Reckoners.
Black Hand Venoms which can be upgraded with Particle Beams
Can you give some insights into the creative process behind Kane's Wrath? It seems you were having difficulties and changed many aspects while working on the game. Was this because of your cooperation with the external studio or were you struggling to find the content for all factions?
Would love it if you could check out my mod! I've been working 5 years on it: https://www.moddb.com/mods/cnc3-kw-one-vision
3
3
3
u/TribbleTrouble1979 Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
What are your thoughts on re-releasing console games or creating new console ports? Like many others my favorite game is RA2 but my first C&C experience, which will always have a special place in my heart, was C&C Red Alert Retaliation on PlayStation 1 (Retaliation being an oddball compilation of RA1 expansions).
PS4 unfortunately doesn't do backwards compatibility so well, skipping PS1 and PS3 entirely, but Xbox One has its growing Backwards Compatibility program (which does not yet feature any of the Xbox 360 C&C games!) and as for Nintendo Switch, "Switch Port!" is practically the platforms tagline haha.
→ More replies (2)
3
3
u/Rockstar256256 Oct 11 '18
Make Renegade 2 comeback please. It was first Tactical First Person Strategy. As a mod of MultiPlayer Forums i have to be honest, we still have huge community around playing. There are 3 active servers where MPF is most played. It has modded maps and units a little bit. Here is our site https://multiplayerforums.com/
If not a FPS , at least a RTS game based on Tiberian Sun/ Tiberium Wars Universe. We need Kane, Tiberium, McNeil.
However most important thing that people would like to see
-Units sizes, tanks at least twice as big as light vechicles, maybe even stronger but easier to destory with rocket infantry. Hard counter system with at least few different typos of armour
- More than one resource , some kind of starcraft resource system
- Focus on less units more strategy, veterancy system, ranking system.
You can have my 300 Bucks if it will be decent like Tiberian Sun, Red alert 2 or Renegade
Sincerly MPF Team, Raphael "Rockstar"
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Jamesryko Oct 11 '18
Anyone who wants to play the classic games online with over 500 player community please check out Cncnet.org
3
u/fuzzy6776 Oct 11 '18
Ive never bought a game from EA in like 15 + years... since origin has been implemented... and im not planning to.
4
u/WNxServer Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18
Hey Jim,
It sounds like birthday & christmas present together for the C&C Community.
What many don't know - this is the way to the next level of programming & producing. Companys do now Gap Analyse + UX Analyse later on. (I'm part of a big Softwarecompany aswell and know it from there ;) )
Sooo.. I'm glad to see that we aren't forgotten and there's still a part which counts on us. :)
My first C&C was Tiberian Dawn, the first part with the matchstick units xD Have you played all the classic games aswell? (Ps.: I've had every CnC which was ever released!)
On one side it's surely important to make a continue of the typical RTS C&C because most of the people played it.
On the other side the C&C Universe has something special in it aswell. It was C&C Renegade! It was and STILL IS the first and only one FPS shooter where the target is not the same like at Counter-Strike, Battlefield, and all the other shooters in killing the enemy Unit. No, it's much more! You play the little soldier of the C&C Imperium on your own and it's a fight Base vs. Base where you directly respawn when you die.
The game is already going to his 17th aniversay and has still a big great community! Renegade had a great story and the multiplayer is the perfect continue after the single player.
The big keyword in the game isn't the graphic, it's just the fun-factor. The gameplay was balanced EPIC! The 5 buildings every team had, had their own use and when something died of it - the gameplay changed! Like when Baracks or WeaponsFactory died, you had only Infantry or Tanks left on your side, but still were able to win! It really makes you addicted because every round is special and has it own flow - it's never the same. :) Not always scheme A.
If you look at the original Ren and the Renegade what the community made out of it - it's wow - 14 out of the box maps and over 400 Maps made by public ppl. The communities created own Bots on the servers with kind of veteran systems which brought it up to a new level. (https://multiplayerforums.com/topic/7012-veteran-system/?tab=comments#comment-60651)
Maybe Renegade would also be a possible candiadte for a big remake! At least already because this is still a UNIQUE gametype. No other game is like that.
You can count on us and we would love it, if we can help you to improve the new RTS game and also FPS if you consider that.
If you like, you can hit us up on our community: https://multiplayerforums.com/
Here are some impressions of Renegade these days :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3r1C1EWv9N0
Would be great to hear from you!
Thanks and greetz,
Andy (WNxServer - MPF Admin of Renegade)
→ More replies (1)
3
u/aviloSC2 Oct 11 '18
The RTS Market is ripe for a new RTS title to take over from SC2's latest massive failures.
Moba is over-saturated, FPS is over-saturated, new Battle Royale game type is also being over-saturated.
The only currently "alive" RTS game is Starcraft 2 at the moment, and that's barely hanging on due to developer negligence when it comes to patching.
So yeh...remaster CnC3/RA3 and have some dedicated servers up again? Or make a brand new CnC game and don't focus on e-sports, just make a really good RTS game and people will rally behind it. Pretty sure many casual and competitive CnC fans were hyped and then equally disappointed when Generals 2 was scrapped. And then even more pissed when the CnC Rivals mobile bullshit came out that no one wanted, and no one still cares or wants (being real here, that was a cash grab using the CnC name).
Why not just make a new CnC that is a well designed RTS in 2018 and then support the game afterwards... :)
→ More replies (1)
2.4k
u/Electrifyer No one escapes the heat. Oct 11 '18
Please no micro transactions... that’s all I want. I want to enjoy a game I pay for without having to pay more to keep enjoying it. I don’t wanna have to rebuy a game unless you’re giving me a complete expansion pack such as Yuri’s Revenge or Kane’s Wrath.