r/comicbookcollecting • • Jan 02 '23

Question Does this decrease the value or increase it because its only there because this comic is from before pence was used in England

Post image
4 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

Would you spend extra money on a book with scribbles on it?

11

u/jb126798 Jan 02 '23

There’s no way that will increase the value

10

u/GotNothingLeftToSay Jan 02 '23

Its pretty much never a good thing to have something on the cover that doesn‘t belong. Even a not-witnessed signature can be a hard sell. Only thing I know of that seems to not decrease value are the army-base stamps. I dont think its standard newsstand condition as they could have just as easily written it on the back or put a sticker on it or just memorized the price 😄

1

u/DarrenThong Jan 02 '23

How about a price tag?.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

I bought it for £55

2

u/SharkForce_12 Jan 02 '23

Value is set by desirability for collectors. They do not want writing on the cover so they will pay less for this book than a book in similar grade without the writing.

Because writing is common for golden and silver-age books, the writing does not decrease the grade unless it’s too large or has obnoxious placing.

2

u/KryogenicWAR Jan 02 '23

Decrease. Not so much because its a price stamp in my opinion either, just the fact the price isn't "stamped" but has had a pen gouging into the cover.

2

u/fenway206 Jan 02 '23

It probably decreases it but I would want it !

2

u/fenway206 Jan 02 '23

I have my original childhood collection of bronze age horror in a spinner rack in my living room . It makes me happy every time I look at it and everyone is welcome to handle and read whenever .

2

u/Sexy_Man798 Let's get Chaotic! Jan 02 '23

Definitely won't increase the value lol, but writing on comics 'sometimes' don't affect the grade or value.

2

u/canis_artis Jan 02 '23 edited Jan 02 '23

Pence were used long before this comic came out. Maybe you were thinking of when they were decimalized around 1966-71?

The writing might be by a retailer or reseller, either way it does not add value. Quite the reverse.

Added: I just noticed, it was rubber stamped around the numbers. You can see the word 'PRICE' by the ankle.

4

u/_GI_Joe_ Jan 02 '23

Decrease

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

The fact it’s very near the crotch definitely increases the value … pence near penis = gold

1

u/tikivic Jan 10 '23

The Overstreet Guide to Grading Comics Sixth Edition Softcover https://a.co/d/2K2i7mC

1

u/ColdWarVet90 Jan 02 '23

I find writing of any kind a massive downer. It besmirches the artwork and every time my eye crosses the marks I'm pulled out of my reverie with the artwork.

1

u/Dee_Gener_8 Jan 02 '23

decrease exponentially

1

u/Adventurous_Lime1049 Jan 02 '23

It's only more valuable if it's a pedigree

-2

u/BackgroundPossible56 Jan 02 '23

If a stupid fucking jewelry ad. can increase value,then why not this?

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

Or a dumb-ass barcode in the corner instead of some art.

-1

u/BackgroundPossible56 Jan 02 '23

Agree completely.

0

u/herring-net Jan 02 '23

There’s plenty of idiotic trends (ratio variants, newsstand, Scott Campbell), so I wouldn’t be surprised if certain stamps or writing by clerks becomes desirable.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

I lol at Scott Campbell. Gotta agree. We make fun of Liefeld because of his female anatomy but give Scott Campbell a pass?

-28

u/Anxious_Ad_5127 Jan 02 '23

Oh that’s an incredible question! I’d think it makes it a little more valuable because that’s the standard news stand condition for the books I assume

0

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

[deleted]

-34

u/Anxious_Ad_5127 Jan 02 '23

Op’s question is legitimate don’t be a buzzkill bro

0

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

[deleted]

-25

u/Anxious_Ad_5127 Jan 02 '23

I’m sorry I’m gatekeeping being an asshole. My bad, continue about your day yah prick

-34

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

I mean because of the fact that there was no other way to show the price of the comic because pence wasn't invented back then

26

u/uncreativeusername31 Jan 02 '23

Writing of any kind decreases the value. Doesn’t matter the historical significance. The only writing on a comic book that would increase the value is a signature

2

u/BADFiSH_c137 💀Deadpøøl🏊‍♂️Cøllectør📚 Jan 02 '23

There’s a lot of pedigree collections that have writing on the covers, like the Circle 8 collection. Not that I’ve been in the market for any of these books, but I imagine they might increase in value with that gold label. 🤷🏻‍♂️

0

u/uncreativeusername31 Jan 02 '23

I’m sure there are a few exceptions. But most of the time when someone writes on a comic with pen it decreases the value, that’s more what I was getting at.

0

u/BADFiSH_c137 💀Deadpøøl🏊‍♂️Cøllectør📚 Jan 02 '23

Right, but you said “Writing of any kind decreases the value. Doesn’t matter the historical significance.” There’s a little nuance here that absolutely could include this particular book. Most likely it isn’t part of a pedigree, but I wouldn’t just flat-out deny the possibility.

1

u/LongTime20 Jan 02 '23

Or a blank white variant with an original art work from a reputable artist.

1

u/Brontards Jan 02 '23

What about the newsstand date stamps from way back?

I have one that I actually like, not writing per se though, but curious.

3

u/uncreativeusername31 Jan 02 '23

Yup same thing. It would lower the grade/value.

I have a book stamped too and I like it a lot. It was stamped with the location. It was stamped in Saskatoon and I bought it from a dealer from New York City at the montreal comic con. I think if it’s journey every now and then.

6

u/BigBeagleEars Jan 02 '23

Not invented? The 3 pence coin was first minted in the 1550s.

4

u/Cruel-Tea Jan 02 '23

Dude - pence existed. Pence/Pennies have been around for over a thousand years. This was printed and sold during the transition from pre-decimal pence to decimalized pence. I don’t think it will add anything to the value - it’s just a product of the time.

Stop worrying about value and enjoy your book

2

u/enjoiYosi Jan 02 '23

It’s worth whatever you feel it is to you