r/columbia • • May 08 '24

hard things are hard In Our Name: A Message from Jewish Students at Columbia University

879 Upvotes

Aside:

*The first post from a different user was removed for being spam. Then my post was removed "pending moderator approval", I messaged the mods and they told me my previous post was removed since "*Links to Google docs are often used to unmask and dox users by scraping their Gmail account ids. This is a security issue. Post whatever you want as a link to the open web, or not at all."

Obviously nothing is more doxing than the Gmail account ids (despite the Jewish students literally signing their names below), so I have posted the letter directly here instead. I removed the 322 signatures as well since that is dox-like as well.

I expect nothing but rational and civil discourse in the comments below.

To the Columbia Community:

Over the past six months, many have spoken in our name. Some are well-meaning alumni or non-affiliates who show up to wave the Israeli flag outside Columbia’s gates. Some are politicians looking to use our experiences to foment America’s culture war. Most notably, some are our Jewish peers who tokenize themselves by claiming to represent “real Jewish values,” and attempt to delegitimize our lived experiences of antisemitism. We are here, writing to you as Jewish students at Columbia University, who are connected to our community and deeply engaged with our culture and history. We would like to speak in our name.

Many of us sit next to you in class. We are your lab partners, your study buddies, your peers, and your friends. We partake in the same student government, clubs, Greek life, volunteer organizations, and sports teams as you.

Most of us did not choose to be political activists. We do not bang on drums and chant catchy slogans. We are average students, just trying to make it through finals much like the rest of you. Those who demonize us under the cloak of anti-Zionism forced us into our activism and forced us to publicly defend our Jewish identities.

We proudly believe in the Jewish People’s right to self-determination in our historic homeland as a fundamental tenet of our Jewish identity. Contrary to what many have tried to sell you – no, Judaism cannot be separated from Israel. Zionism is, simply put, the manifestation of that belief.

Our religious texts are replete with references to Israel, Zion, and Jerusalem. The land of Israel is filled with archaeological remnants of a Jewish presence spanning centuries. Yet, despite generations of living in exile and diaspora across the globe, the Jewish People never ceased dreaming of returning to our homeland — Judea, the very place from which we derive our name, “Jews.” Indeed just a couple of days ago, we all closed our Passover seders with the proclamation, “Next Year in Jerusalem!”

Many of us are not religiously observant, yet Zionism remains a pillar of our Jewish identities. We have been kicked out of Russia, Libya, Ethiopia, Yemen, Afghanistan, Poland, Egypt, Algeria, Germany, Iran, and the list goes on. We connect to Israel not only as our ancestral homeland but as the only place in the modern world where Jews can safely take ownership of their own destiny. Our experiences at Columbia in the last six months are a poignant reminder of just that.

We were raised on stories from our grandparents of concentration camps, gas chambers, and ethnic cleansing. The essence of Hitler’s antisemitism was the very fact that we were “not European” enough, that as Jews we were threats to the “superior” Aryan race. This ideology ultimately left six million of our own in ashes.

The evil irony of today’s antisemitism is a twisted reversal of our Holocaust legacy; protestors on campus have dehumanized us, imposing upon us the characterization of the “white colonizer.” We have been told that we are “the oppressors of all brown people” and that “the Holocaust wasn’t special.” Students at Columbia have chanted “we don’t want no Zionists here,” alongside “death to the Zionist State” and to “go back to Poland,” where our relatives lie in mass graves.

This sick distortion illuminates the nature of antisemitism: In every generation, the Jewish People are blamed and scapegoated as responsible for the societal evil of the time. In Iran and in the Arab world, we were ethnically cleansed for our presumed ties to the “Zionist entity.” In Russia, we endured state-sponsored violence and were ultimately massacred for being capitalists. In Europe, we were the victims of genocide because we were communists and not European enough. And today, we face the accusation of being too European, painted as society’s worst evils – colonizers and oppressors. We are targeted for our belief that Israel, our ancestral and religious homeland, has a right to exist. We are targeted by those who misuse the word Zionist as a sanitized slur for Jew, synonymous with racist, oppressive, or genocidal. We know all too well that antisemitism is shapeshifting.

We are proud of Israel. The only democracy in the Middle East, Israel is home to millions of Mizrachi Jews (Jews of Middle Eastern descent), Ashkenazi Jews (Jews of Central and Eastern European descent), and Ethiopian Jews, as well as millions of Arab Israelis, over one million Muslims, and hundreds of thousands of Christians and Druze. Israel is nothing short of a miracle for the Jewish People and for the Middle East more broadly.

Our love for Israel does not necessitate blind political conformity. It’s quite the opposite. For many of us, it is our deep love for and commitment to Israel that pushes us to object when its government acts in ways we find problematic. Israeli political disagreement is an inherently Zionist activity; look no further than the protests against Netanyahu’s judicial reforms – from New York to Tel Aviv – to understand what it means to fight for the Israel we imagine. All it takes are a couple of coffee chats with us to realize that our visions for Israel differ dramatically from one another. Yet we all come from a place of love and an aspiration for a better future for Israelis and Palestinians alike.

If the last six months on campus have taught us anything, it is that a large and vocal population of the Columbia community does not understand the meaning of Zionism, and subsequently does not understand the essence of the Jewish People. Yet despite the fact that we have been calling out the antisemitism we’ve been experiencing for months, our concerns have been brushed off and invalidated. So here we are to remind you:

We sounded the alarm on October 12 when many protested against Israel while our friends’ and families’ dead bodies were still warm.

We recoiled when people screamed “resist by any means necessary,” telling us we are “all inbred” and that we “have no culture.”

We shuddered when an “activist” held up a sign telling Jewish students they were Hamas’s next targets, and we shook our heads in disbelief when Sidechat users told us we were lying.

We ultimately were not surprised when a leader of the CUAD encampment said publicly and proudly that “Zionists don’t deserve to live” and that we’re lucky they are “not just going out and murdering Zionists.”

We felt helpless when we watched students and faculty physically block Jewish students from entering parts of the campus we share, or even when they turned their faces away in silence. This silence is familiar. We will never forget.

One thing is for sure. We will not stop standing up for ourselves. We are proud to be Jews, and we are proud to be Zionists.  

We came to Columbia because we wanted to expand our minds and engage in complex conversations. While campus may be riddled with hateful rhetoric and simplistic binaries now, it is never too late to start repairing the fractures and begin developing meaningful relationships across political and religious divides. Our tradition tells us, “Love peace and pursue peace.” We hope you will join us in earnestly pursuing peace, truth, and empathy. Together we can repair our campus.

Signed:

322 Jewish students


r/columbia • • Apr 23 '24

Totally Anti-Semitic and Extremely Offensive

0 Upvotes

r/columbia • • Oct 14 '24

Israel-Hamas War jewish student life

0 Upvotes

would a jewish student feel unwelcome at columbia?


r/columbia • • Apr 25 '24

Speaker Mike Johnson’s remarks was nothing more than warmongering.

0 Upvotes

r/columbia • • May 04 '24

tRiGgEr WaRnInG We Columbia University students urge you to listen to our voices | Columbia College Student Council | "Please, listen to us – not political figures, radical fringes and misguided media"

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
291 Upvotes

r/columbia • • Apr 30 '24

hard things are hard Anyone actually pretty happy with Shafik's response?

0 Upvotes

I am pro Israel, and I think Shafik handled her position very well. She was caught between a rock and a hard place from all sides - students, faculty, alumni, donors, the freaking US government.

She listened to & negotiated with the protesters, and allowed all but the most radical to skate free. She communicated very clearly what protests were allowed and what weren't, and stuck to her guns (for the most part). She did not let a fringe group dictate Columbia's endowment, but instead agreed to invest in Gaza - a principled stance of being pro-Palestine without being anti-Israel.

Columbia students will have their commencement. They will not have their campus half destroyed by protesters like at UC Humboldt, or be under police lockdown like at UT Austin.

Neither side truly "won" or "lost", but the overwhelming neutral majority who just want to live their life and go to class can hopefully breathe freely soon.

UPDATE: I um... have definitely spoken before everything was over. sorry! pretended I posted this yesterday. peace and love to all


r/columbia • • Nov 06 '24 Helpful

alumni How much do you think the protests on campus helped Trump win?

55 Upvotes

MSNBC is mentioning the protests at Columbia right now.

Edit: Here's the video of MSNCB talking about Columbia around 1:25.


r/columbia • • Oct 21 '24

Israel-Hamas War Do you have your plan to vote ?

0 Upvotes

Please vote Columbia students.. your vote is your voice and your voice is your power…. The fight was real for women and people of color to gain the right to vote….. it might have been before your time but it was real. If Israel’s atrocities are keeping you from voting …. Trump would love that ! He doesn’t give a shit about you or anybody outside his circle of white, rich, assholes…. The Green Party unfortunately has been infiltrated by Russian operatives… the only decent choice is Harris….. she is NOT Biden… she is a tough, principled, smart individual that will stand up for those that are being persecuted..make a plan, vote- ask your friends and family to voter……


r/columbia • • May 06 '24

Police presence on campus

67 Upvotes

I'm referring specifically to the current police presence on campus, not the two police raids that occurred.

Broadly, it is to me antithetical to the mission of a university to have police have free reign over campus.

Specifically, through channels, there have been reports of catcalling (verbal sexual assault) of students, NYPD expecting dining staff and other staff to afford them privileges that are simply not theirs to demand, and in general having more access and privileges than any other member of campus has.

No matter what you think about either the issue in the middle east, or the protestors actions, the whole idea of NYPD being the force that enforces these rules is horrifying. If you have been able to get into campus recently, it is dystopian and off-putting to witness.

I cannot think of a reason that continuous police presence on campus is justifiable, so long as campus is only accessible to current faculty, students, and staff.

I also think that historically when a group of people gain control over a place, when those people have both intimidation and guns at their disposal to enact their will, they tend not to leave.

I'm not going to argue about whether police presence on campus was justified on those two times when atrests were made. I do, however have a strong emotional and intellectual revulsion to their continued presence.

Police do not belong inside a campus which priorities the ability to learn without constraints on speech.


r/columbia • • Apr 27 '24

Is this sub being brigaded?

0 Upvotes

In the last few days, almost every post has gotten a lot more upvotes on average than posts have been getting in the last year. Yes, we're in the news so it makes sense, what i dont understand is how in the last 2 days, there have been multiple pro-israel posts getting upvoted to high hell yet almost every comment is pro-palestine. Shit, even before the sub got locked under the new rules almost every pro-israel comment and post was in the negative downvotes.

Before you start attacking me (which will happen), notice how im not refering to any political opinion or stating my own or talking about anything. I simply would like to know if theres an explanation for the disconnect in sentiment between the post upvotes and comment upvotes.

As for examples, lets go down the current hot posts

  1. The post asking for people to just leave columbia if they arent happy. 236 upvotes on the post, every single comment is calling the poster a dumbass. Im not saying the poster isnt a columbia student, but this is about the sentiment.

  2. The 4 months later one, check out the posters account and comments. Every single post/comment and i mean literally every single one is israel/columbia/palestine/jewish related. Not a single post, comment in columbia before the recent events.

Like, im fully disclosing that i support palestine. But this is reddit, anyone can post, anyone can comment, and this is our university subreddit. Its clear that we have multiple actors from outside this campus trying to stir shit up. I fully sympathize with seniors trying to graduate and get a commencement and i sincerely wish this gets resolved soon. But i can not ignore that this subreddit is being swarmed with outside actors trying to write a narrative.


r/columbia • • Mar 13 '25

campus events Israelism and the October 8 Film

7 Upvotes

——Update——

I just saw the Film. It was very well done. Obviously hard to digest, but I would say sums up what a lot of us “Zionists” have witnessed on campus. Pure hatred and justification of violence.

——

I’d like to point out that the October 8 Film is released today in NYC. This film was directed with the intent to address a campaign that was prepared and launched following the October 7 massacre to rebrand hamas as “freedom fighters”.

I’d like to share with this group specifically because we pride ourselves in being academics, and in doing so, we must research and evaluate different sides of every argument. Furthermore, I distinctly remember various student and faculty promoting the film Israelism following the Hamas-led attack in Israel (it was also shown on campus on more than one occasion), and the film provided a very unilateral perspective on what has been considered a “very complex conflict.”

I’m am therefore sharing to help provide perspective to both student and faculty interested in the conflict and are still unclear about the impact of the events occurring on October 7 and thereafter to the Jewish population.


r/columbia • • May 01 '24

I am largely apathetic to thus Israel Palestine conflict I just want to graduate and get my degree

1.8k Upvotes

Just to vent. I’ve no affiliation with either side whatsoever, never been to either country, and this conflict has been around since earlier than when I was born. I also paid a lot for an education at CU so I really really just want to go to class properly and get my degree get a job. This is my main goal, and my student debt is my main concern, I am also similarly apathetic to the war in Yemen, insurgency in Paraguay, conflict in Somalia, etc. Do protesters understand that the longer this chaos goes on, the less sympathetic most people will be about their cause, especially the people directly affected by the accompanying interruptions and nuisance?


r/columbia • • Feb 15 '25

safety is columbia really as dangerous as it's being portrayed online?

7 Upvotes

hey everyone, senior who applied to Columbia this winter here. I've been lurking on the sub for a few months and following Columbia in the media and I've seen a worrying trend of political instability and protests on campus.

i don't want to get involved in any sort of politics or the israel-hamas war - as an international, I think I might have enough on my plate anyways. my parents did specifically beg me not to get involved with any sort of controversy, just for my own safety, and keep views to myself, which is my plan.

I've seen that a lot of Columbia students are really active, whichever side they identify with, and I was wondering if it is possible to just... stay out of it? or if I might be targeted for my racial identity (I'm neither jewish nor Muslim, etc.).

i guess I'm asking for what the general take on safety + political activism is on campus

thanks so much! :)


r/columbia • • Jul 08 '24

coming right up! Three Textgate deans have been removed. Can anyone explain what they said that deserves this punishment?

45 Upvotes

r/columbia • • May 01 '24

Faculty Statement on Imminent Police Action at Columbia University

0 Upvotes

Faculty Statement on Imminent Police Action at Columbia University

The American Association of University Professors, Columbia University Chapter

For immediate release: April 30, 2024, 8:00pm

At this hour, the NYPD is massing on barricaded streets outside the gates of Columbia University. Columbia faculty have spent the day offering our help to defuse the situation on Columbia’s campus and have been rebuffed or ignored. We have been locked out of our campus and have demanded to be allowed back in, and have been rebuffed or ignored. This is not new. Columbia faculty have attempted for the past two weeks to intervene in the situation, only to be shut out by senior University leadership.

NYPD presence in our neighborhood endangers our entire community. Armed police entering our campus places students and everyone else on campus at risk. That is why University statutes require consultation with faculty — statutes which appear to have been ignored since April 17, and again tonight. We hold University leadership responsible for the disastrous lapses of judgment that have gotten us to this point. The University President, her senior staff, and the Board of Trustees will bear responsibility for any injuries that may occur during any police action on our campus.


r/columbia • • Oct 02 '24

do you even go here? Most of the active members on this subreddit are alums

0 Upvotes

I have been a lurker on this subreddit for a while as a student and I feel like I notice that the replies in the comments of a lot of posts don't really actually reflect the views of current students. Then I read their flairs or they mention that they are an alum from like 15 years ago and it makes sense. Columbia is a very different place then it was that long ago and its kinda crazy that the alums are in the comments sections shitting on current students asking questions or discussing our school without even going here anymore.

I just wanted to make this post so that other current students who aren't aware of this now can be aware. Genuinely asking a question on sidechat might be a better place to ask.


r/columbia • • May 21 '25 Helpful

columbia news A student confronts the Israeli-American dean of SIPA, Keren Yarhi-Milo who is a former Israeli military intelligence officer.

23 Upvotes

r/columbia • • May 08 '24

Conservative judges blackballs Columbia undergrads and law students for a movement that master students led

0 Upvotes

https://www.wsj.com/us-news/education/conservative-judges-plan-to-blackball-columbia-university-graduates-2e99c279?mod=hp_lead_pos8

“Considering recent events, and absent extraordinary change, we will not hire anyone who joins the Columbia University community—whether as undergraduates or law students—beginning with the entering class of 2024,” the letter said.

my question is, aren’t the protest leaders Mahmoud Khalil and Sueda Polat both master students? Why are we undergrads again the collateral damage in a movement DISPROPORTIONATELY led by master student? I also doubt how many law school students actually joined the protest.


r/columbia • • Oct 13 '23

FYI to everyone out protesting “for” Palestine on campus yesterday

Post image
44 Upvotes

This is how the group that you’re throwing your support behind characterizes the terrorist attack and massacre that occurred over the weekend. 1000+ civilians slaughtered, 100+ abducted, and SJP won’t even condemn Hamas (So much for “human rights”). Instead, they are actively conflating the actions of terrorists with the will of the Palestinian people. I just hope y’all realize who you are marching with and supporting, because not considering this weekends’ events an atrocity is pretty f*cked up


r/columbia • • Mar 10 '25 Love

nyc Free Mahmoud Khalil and Fight Fascism! Public Meeting on Friday

25 Upvotes

The outrageous arrest of Mahmoud Khalil for exercising his First Amendment right to protest the genocide is part of the Trump administration's frontal attack on democratic rights. Historic levels of social inequality and the continued rule of the tiny capitalist oligarchy can only be maintained by a resort to fascism. The Democrats, who represent the interests of Wall Street no less than the Republicans, are not only incapable of fighting Trump, but also complicit in his policies. The only social force capable of defeating fascism and establishing democracy is the international working class. The International Youth and Students for Social Equality, which is the youth section of the Socialist Equality Party, will hold a meeting at 6:30 pm on Friday, March 14 at the Center (208 W 13th St and 7th Ave) to discuss the fight against fascism. Anyone who is serious about fighting fascism should attend.


r/columbia • • Mar 19 '25

Israel-Hamas War Letter from Mahmoud Khalil

Thumbnail
instagram.com
0 Upvotes

r/columbia • • Mar 16 '25

Israel-Hamas War Face Coverings on Campus - Long overdue time to ban them ?

3 Upvotes

When we watch protesters, either outside the gates on Broadway on on the plaza outside Low Library so many people are hiding their identities. There are calls for hiding one's identities on campus and face masks to be outlawed, but also calls that they shouldn't.

It's important to correctly identify those who cross the line from peaceful legitimate protest into hate/incitement/intimidation/crime and to avoid misidentifying people. When the protest groups call another protest their instructions to their minions are clear " Wear all black, hide your identity, cover your faces".

They argue it's to protect the minions, but it's also more about group cover - the real troublemakers are can use the masses as cover for their misdeeds. Human shields if you will. I have seen people saw awful things which they wouldn't dare say if their identity wasn't concealed. People wouldn't say and chant certain things if they thought they might be held accountable or if their friends/family/employer might see it. Ordinarily, I wouldn't be in favor of a face-covering ban, but we're so past that. The privilege has been so abused to hide misdeeds and to protest in bad faith, is it time to ban face coverings?

One of the common arguments 'against' a ban is in regard to 'immunocompromised people'. Well, someone with a medical certificate clearly wouldn't come under any such ban, so that's a smokescreen and, although I'm not aware of any condition which necessitates covering your entire face, forehead and hair in a kheffir or balaclava.

In every hospital, businesses and many other institutions, anyone on-site is required to prominently wear their ID badge so that everyone else knows who they are and that they belong, so people could be allowed to wear a prominent ID if they're too sick/vulnerable to expose their face. You can't enter airside at JFK with your ID concealed, why should you enter a protest cordon? The other argument against being able to hide ones identity is the fear of doxxing. Identifying someone to then publish private information (phone, home address) that isn't in the public domain is wrong - but that's only an argument for clamping down on doxxing.

The organizers also encourage people to tailgate others onto campus and try to come onto campus long before the protest so that the CUID is harder to match. Apparently, what I learned from Instagram is the best place to enter campus without swiping or valid ID is through NWC building on 120th St. When classes end, those doors are swarmed by hundreds of students who have to swipe their CUID on the side of the building, then walk to the doors. The guard there, normally inside so can't see anyway, is overwhelmed so can't check that everyone actually touches and even then he doesn't have a computer with people's faces so I can scan anyone's or no-one's CUID and they've no idea. I'm not revealing any secrets here - the troublemakers already know and share this and other tricks. Hopefully someone reading this has the ear of public safety and they'll close down these flaws.

If people are covering their faces because they just don't want to be embarrassed by their youthful exuberance in 10 years when they've graduated, grown up and have a respectable job, then no deal. Surely it's the risk of accountability that will make people think twice before they open their mouth or choose who to stand with? If I was a university, if you apply, I'd want to know if you're applying to come and study or prone to disrupt and exploit our campus. This applies to people on both 'sides'.

This is why people are so shitty on the Internet. Do you think everyone here would write everything they have done if their real name was shown instead of some weird handle? Hiding your identity on a protest, for many, is the equivalent to posting on Reddit from the safety your Mom's basement. Of course, people will say that Khalil's arrest is exactly why you need to hide your identity; so that you won't be held accountable for crimes or visa breaches. Dialogue might actually be a lot more productive without hidden identities.

No American is getting arrested for protesting. If you're here as a guest, a visitor and not a citizen, you have no place being an organizer of protest or apologist/spokesperson for criminals.


r/columbia • • Dec 08 '21

UAW are self obsessed

12 Upvotes

I’m not here to judge or even to fully understand every move that’s been made and the complexities of the situation. I’m just a student who deals with their own stuff, and whose life is being disrupted by this movement in often tactless ways.

A few points

  1. The demands

The movement has done a poor job of communicating their demands and putting them front and center in their struggle. Their website is mostly donation prompts and student testimonies, and within all the chanting, picketing, disruptions and slogans, the actual demands rarely seep through. (I know they are not actually hard to find but I’m communicating to you what the experience of almost every student around me is)

2)You are a part of a huge community with many moving parts, even if we support your demands, it doesn’t mean you can make everything about yourself.

3)the tree lighting 🌲

I and many others found it very tactless and unnecessary for the strikers to take THE ONE EVENT we had as community together and to make it about themselves. And what for? We all already knew you’re fighting and supported the general cause.

Also, that night they held up a giant ‘get the NYPD off campus’ sign, and made SURE it is the background in the video of every Acappella group. And that night one of their own and our own was violently murdered. You are fighting for better working conditions, please don’t think you have any right to dictate how public safety is conducted.

4)shutting down the last day of some classes.

We won’t have our last class, won’t get to wrap up the semester properly, and to say thanks to our professors and classmates. Do I understand the entire rationale behind their decision? No I don’t. But do they have the right to do whatever they want just because they can justify it to themselves?

I am not 10 feet deep in this, I don’t know or particularly care to know about every detail of this struggle and this back and fourth.

You have the right to fight for better wages and working conditions, and that fight can be disruptive. But have some tact and some respect for regular students and their experience.


r/columbia • • May 01 '24

war on fun Opinion: Minouche and Rosenbury Must Resign.

123 Upvotes

In their first months as respective presidents of Columbia University and Barnard College, they have failed us. They have not defined what constitutes antisemitic speech as a basis for disciplinary action. If they had, they could have allowed the protestors to express their views and addressed any antisemitic issues from the start. That way, freedom of speech expectations would've been consistent all along.

Instead of explaining why they will not divest from Israel, they have alienated themselves from both pro-Palestine and pro-Israel groups. When the situation escalated, they remained silent. That is until eventually relying on the NYPD to clean up their incompetence tonight.

Minouche and Rosenbury do not have the required integrity to lead this very special institution. I have met the most brilliant students and faculty here from around the world; they deserve better leadership than this. Action must be taken to ensure the Columbia community is in trustworthy hands going forward.