r/coldwar • • May 12 '25

Should we blame the US for the Cold War?

Thumbnail
thetimes.com
0 Upvotes

The Russian-born historian Vladislav Zubok makes the provocative case that western leaders exaggerated the threat from cautious and conservative Soviet leaders


r/coldwar • • Aug 09 '25

Henry Kissinger was brilliant and complicated. Why deny that?

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Sep 20 '20

Snowmobile Goes Boom

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Jan 07 '22

Did in 1953 the CIA make a coup in Iran?

3 Upvotes

In the popular media the Shah of Iran is often potrayed as a puppet of the West, argueing he was installed by the CIA in an illegal coup to overthrow the "democratically-elected" Prime Minister Dr. Mohammad Mossadeq for Nationalizing the British-owned Oil industry in Iran.

However there are several flaws with this argumentation. To clear up this misunderstanding, I made a documentary on Operation Ajax to show you what the facts and the media myths are about the events that happened in Iran in 1953.

https://youtu.be/4WAMTfWp0_E

#1 Mossadeq was NOT a democratically elected leader. According to the Iranian constitution the Prime Minister was appointed as well as dismissed by the Shah.

#2 Both Mossadeq AND the Shah wanted to nationalize the oil industry, but they had DIFFERENT methods in mind.

-Mossadeq wanted to suddenly expell all the British engineers and workers when Iran had only one university, very little expertise and the whole economy was dependent on Oil exports.

-The Shah wanted to discuss a FAIRER deal until Iran is capable of managing the oil industry on its own, which eventually Iran did under Shah's rule in 1973.

#3 The CIA did not "put the Shah in", he was already there. He became the Shah in 1941 when his father abdicated and handed over the throne to him. When the parliament approved Reza Shah's abdication his son swore the oath of allegiance to the Qur'an before the parliament and took over the affairs of government as the Head of State on September 17, 1941. NO coup. No violence.

#4 The CIA had no role in the overthrow of Mossadeq on August 19,1953. According to declassified CIA reports the Americans ceased all activities against Mossadeq on August 16, 1953.

#5 Mossadeq's removal was legally justified. Mossadeq was impeached by the parliament and according to the Iranian constitution the Shah was OBLIGED to dismiss Mossadeq after Mossadeq had dissolved the parliament. The Shah, as the guardian of the constitution and of the law had to replace Mossadeq with an interim prime minister until new parliamentary elections would be held.

#6 The Shah rejected cooperation with the CIA. Even though both the US and the Shah were in favor of removing Mossadeq, the Shah categorically rejected all plans and no part of Operation (TP)Ajax could get operationalized. The Shah argued that he would dismiss Mossadeq under 2 conditions:

-Mossadeq's removal should be through legal means, NO coup

-If the new government does not immideately receive financial assistance (desperately need thanks to Mossadeq's insane economic policies) he would rather keep Mossadeq as Prime Minister.

These were the most important misunderstandings in my opinion. What do you think?


r/coldwar • • Jul 21 '20

"The Truth About The Vietnam War"- A Response To Prager U

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Nov 11 '21

What was the role of capitalism during the cold war?

1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Jun 19 '23

Why did the United States want to even contain communism to only the Soviet Union and I heard that it was because of the “domino effect” but how would it even affect the UNITED STATES?

1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Jun 29 '21

Domino Theory: Hold Back The Night

3 Upvotes

I am reading Pat Frank's Hold Back the Night, a book set in the Korean War during the 1950s. One of the characters, an American Marine is discussing why they are fighting there in the first place with his platoon mates. In discussing who sent the Marines there - "I don't give a damn who put us here-MacArthur or Truman or the UN- I say it was right. Because if we lost Korea, we'd lose Asia. All Asia. India. The N.E.I. Hong Kong. Malaya. Inso-China. The Philippines, and finally Japan. know what would happen then?" - later on - "If we'd folded without a fight here in Korea, we'd have folded everywhere. If we didn't fight here, the the French would know we wouldn't fight for Indo-China - or France - and the Italians would know we wouldn't fight for Italy, and the Germans-hell, they'd be speaking Russian. You know what Churchill said about the Germans -"They're either at your throat or your heels.' Well, they'd be at our throats again, if we gave up Korea."

I found this interesting since Pat Frank wrote the famous Alas Babylon, one of the first books about living after a nuclear war. It also peaked my curiosity since HBTN was written in 1951/1952, early on in the Cold War and it illustrated the Domino Theory very well way before that theory became more popular during the Vietnam War. It led me to think too, that what if we'd had given up in Korea? Whether on June 25 1950 or later on once the Chinese had entered the fight. Would countries have fallen to the Communists so early in the Cold War? Whereas once Vietnam fell in the 70s, it was established that the United States was leading the race in the Cold War. However, how would things have changed had we decided not to fight in Korea, one of the Cold War's first hot conflicts?


r/coldwar • • Jul 13 '24

Looking for books/sources with similar jokes about the CIA blame and the USSR

0 Upvotes

Quotes such as

  • If it rains during a parade, it's because the CIA is conducting weather experiments.

  • If a factory misses its production quota, the CIA must have infiltrated the workforce

  • If a car won’t start, it’s because the CIA put sugar in the gas tank


r/coldwar • • Dec 02 '23

Kissinger and the true Cold Warrior (discussion).

1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This is not the usual content for this sub, but I believe it's on topic.

You are probably aware of the hate Dr. Kissinger has gotten since the announcement of his death this past week. I can't claim to be an authority on this sort of moral judgment, however I wonder whether people would see his career differently if they considered the historical context within which it took place.

To my understanding, to a true Cold Warrior, the agenda for the day was to do whatever was needed to counter the Soviet Union. As few Cold Warriors received guidance direct from God, they had to make judgment calls about how best to do that. So carpet bombing the area of Cambodia through which the Ho Chi Minh trail passed may seem "genocidal" to us nowadays, but the military probably advised that as the best course of action at the time. In Kissinger's position, would you second-guess them? Or encouraging right-wing takeovers of Latin American governments, especially Chile (which is a complicated topic I don't want to get into here). The general rule at the time was to anything to limit Soviet influence world-wide. In retrospect, it seems extreme. Arguably Dr. K had blood on his hands, but in what universe would he have done otherwise? Yeah I wish some of those things hadn't happened, and in all honesty I don't think we've ever achieved a reckoning as to whether the Soviet Union was as serious a threat to our well being as we were given to believe at the time, but maybe he either had to do some of those things or sincerely believed in their necessity. We are talking about a Jew who witnessed the Holocaust first-hand as part of the liberating US forces at the end of WWII. He knew what can happen when a government resorts to raw brutality and wasn't about to let it happen again, whether or not it was really going to. Or at least I'd like to think he felt that way, and wasn't simply using the Soviet threat as an excuse for senseless brutality.

I also can't help thinking about the nuking of Hiroshima. Yes that was an atrocity, but once the US developed the atom bomb, it was going to happen. We don't piss on Truman's grave because if it.

I know some people have very strong feelings about this, but can we talk about it from the point of view of the world in which Kissinger lived, rather than the one we live in how?


r/coldwar • • Jun 19 '21

US Communist Paranoia

1 Upvotes

So as people on the sub-reddit the USA was paranoid of the USSR so i have to ask...

  1. Where did the USA's paranoid and frankly delusional conspiracy theories of ‘communist takeover of the world’ start?

  2. How realistically plausible was USA's conspiracy theories of ‘communist takeover of the world?’

  3. Did the USA's paranoid and frankly delusional conspiracy theories influence other nations?

  4. When did the USA realise the paranoid and delusional communist conspiracy theories were frankly stupid?

  5. Why didn't the USA's paranoid and frankly delusional conspiracy theories of Communist takeover of the World take hold in the UK?


r/coldwar • • Oct 19 '18

This is interesting

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Jun 20 '19

Was McGeorge Bundy refeeding hairline a factor of the cold war?!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Feb 21 '25

Cold War Cinema

0 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Jun 04 '24

First post on Reddit. Need help finding the right trousers to my East German border guard. This one is a wool-like texture.

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Feb 18 '24

Ronald Reagan when strategic defense initiative:

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • May 09 '26

Is there something about most if not all coups America has done or supported during the Cold War, which most people are unaware of?

10 Upvotes

I’m a progressive who’s been lately coming into terms that most of the online left is largely just anti-America and anti-west and that they hold onto narratives that are often twisted if not outright false.

One of these narratives is about how pretty much everything wrong in the world is because of American imperialism, which is of course tightly related to the topic of the Cold War.

There are narratives like that Iranians chant “Death to America” because of American backed coup that toppled Mohammed Mosaddegh in 1953 and that South America is behind North America because the US toppled or supported toppling of any leftist leader that gets elected like Jacobo Arbénz in Guatemala in 1954, Joao Goulart in Brazil in 1964, Salvador Allende in Chile or Isabel Perón in Argentina (both in 1973), etc.

I follow subreddit called r/NewIran, where I learned that the story about the toppling of Mosaddegh is largely an anti-American myth, because:

A. He was no good guy. He was a populist who took advantage of Iranian population’s ignorance of oil and its extremely low literacy rate to become a dictator.

B. He was about to put Iran under Soviet sphere of influence and the Cold War was all about keeping Soviet Union from getting too powerful.

C. Despite the narrative that he was toppled because he wouldn’t let the UK and the US have Iranian oil, Mohammed Reza Pahlavi actually didn’t let the West loot Iran dry. He kept oil partially nationalized and used its revenues to develop Iran.

What about other regime changes that America was involved in throughout the Cold War? Is the idea that the US is an evil empire responsible for all the ills in the world to enrich itself just an anti western propaganda meant to empower authoritarian socialists and Islamists?

What is there to say about these leftist leaders that were toppled during that era?


r/coldwar • • Nov 27 '17

If most Americans knew of Soviet contributions in WWII, do you think the Cold War would have happened?

2 Upvotes

My theory is that the US and USSR were enemies because of mutual misunderstandings. If they knew each others experiences during the real war, then maybe a lot of hostility wouldn't have existed.


r/coldwar • • Nov 19 '23

Help me find the original owner of this.

Post image
2 Upvotes

This is a cold war U.S helmet that I picked up at a millitary surplus today. Please help me find the original owner. The owners name and state is in the helmet.


r/coldwar • • Aug 14 '15

45 Stunning And Bleak Photos Of Life During The Soviet Union

Thumbnail
buzzfeed.com
2 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • 14d ago

Why was it "capitalism vs communism" instead of "democracy vs dictatorship"?

53 Upvotes

This has been bugging me for a while, and I don't understand it - when the Cold War started, why did Western powers (or at least the US) focus on the opposing ideology being "communism" instead of "totalitarianism" or "dictatorship"? My (largely uninformed) opinion is that the Cold War would have done a lot less damage, within the US and in the places we tried to influence around the rest of the world, if we had focused it this way (for example, we presumably wouldn't have supported third-world dictators just because they claimed to be anti-communist). Obviously there's nothing that can be done to change it now, but maybe it would at least feel less frustrating if I understood better why it was framed the way that it was. Can those of you who have studied this period seriously help me understand it?

EDIT: a depressing number of people are completely missing the question. If you're about to post just to say that the US was fine with dictators during the Cold War, don't waste your time - I know that already, I'm asking why. And if you're just going to post about the thing you don't like in 2020s US politics, that's an even more irrelevant response (even if I agree with your opinion), so don't waste your time with that either.


r/coldwar • • Mar 12 '19

so can you give me some topics

0 Upvotes

so can you give me some topics that I should talk about, give some topics about the cold war


r/coldwar • • Apr 03 '15

Cold War mystery: Israeli spies may have stolen US uranium to build the bomb

Thumbnail
afr.com
1 Upvotes

r/coldwar • • Mar 06 '21

Who do you think started the Cold War? Churchill, Stalin, or Truman?

1 Upvotes

Opinions on this question would be greatly appreciated! This is for my personal project, thank you ❤️