In the popular media the Shah of Iran is often potrayed as a puppet of the West, argueing he was installed by the CIA in an illegal coup to overthrow the "democratically-elected" Prime Minister Dr. Mohammad Mossadeq for Nationalizing the British-owned Oil industry in Iran.
However there are several flaws with this argumentation. To clear up this misunderstanding, I made a documentary on Operation Ajax to show you what the facts and the media myths are about the events that happened in Iran in 1953.
https://youtu.be/4WAMTfWp0_E
#1 Mossadeq was NOT a democratically elected leader. According to the Iranian constitution the Prime Minister was appointed as well as dismissed by the Shah.
#2 Both Mossadeq AND the Shah wanted to nationalize the oil industry, but they had DIFFERENT methods in mind.
-Mossadeq wanted to suddenly expell all the British engineers and workers when Iran had only one university, very little expertise and the whole economy was dependent on Oil exports.
-The Shah wanted to discuss a FAIRER deal until Iran is capable of managing the oil industry on its own, which eventually Iran did under Shah's rule in 1973.
#3 The CIA did not "put the Shah in", he was already there. He became the Shah in 1941 when his father abdicated and handed over the throne to him. When the parliament approved Reza Shah's abdication his son swore the oath of allegiance to the Qur'an before the parliament and took over the affairs of government as the Head of State on September 17, 1941. NO coup. No violence.
#4 The CIA had no role in the overthrow of Mossadeq on August 19,1953. According to declassified CIA reports the Americans ceased all activities against Mossadeq on August 16, 1953.
#5 Mossadeq's removal was legally justified. Mossadeq was impeached by the parliament and according to the Iranian constitution the Shah was OBLIGED to dismiss Mossadeq after Mossadeq had dissolved the parliament. The Shah, as the guardian of the constitution and of the law had to replace Mossadeq with an interim prime minister until new parliamentary elections would be held.
#6 The Shah rejected cooperation with the CIA. Even though both the US and the Shah were in favor of removing Mossadeq, the Shah categorically rejected all plans and no part of Operation (TP)Ajax could get operationalized. The Shah argued that he would dismiss Mossadeq under 2 conditions:
-Mossadeq's removal should be through legal means, NO coup
-If the new government does not immideately receive financial assistance (desperately need thanks to Mossadeq's insane economic policies) he would rather keep Mossadeq as Prime Minister.
These were the most important misunderstandings in my opinion. What do you think?