r/coinerrors • u/ak_plumber_1971 • Sep 28 '26
Advice Is this real?
Is this real? I've never seen anything like this.(Only been in this for a few years)
5
u/ak_plumber_1971 Sep 29 '26
I want to say thank you to the commenters that gave me "real" advice. They kept it direct and to the point. You see, a friend brought that to me asking me advice on the coin because they know I got into coins a few years ago. So I thought I should post it on here and get some advice from some individuals with more experience that me. Didn't think I would get all these sarcastic comments. Even got a "pompous" one. So thank you to the ones that kept it educational
4
u/No-City783 Sep 29 '26 •
![]()
I don’t know, the guy that called you a morron definitely is a avid learner of speling
123
u/Active_Vegetable8203
Sep 28 '26
•
21
13
u/Mobile_Coyote_267 Sep 29 '26
I think they misplaced the decimal
5
u/Local_Escape_8689 Sep 29 '26 •
![]()
Exactly. That guys a morron
4
Sep 29 '26
It's... An Etsy ad? Like someone made this and is selling it for fun? I'm confused why move the decimal and why is he a moron. Maybe I'm the moron lol
8
u/Street_Marsupial_538 Sep 30 '26
The ad calls it “rare.” A novelty item you make and sell on Etsy shouldn’t be titled that.
1
1
Sep 30 '26
Ya your totally right, it should be correctly advertised like everything else on Etsy TOTALLY is. Definitely isn't something we see every day
1
0
62
u/HPDopecraft
Sep 28 '26
•
I don’t know why so many people are leaving the door open for this to be real. The 1893 S Morgan is THE key date and even in terrible condition, is worth thousands. This is ludicrously fake and if it were real, it would be well documented, extraordinarily rare, and worth a small fortune.
23
u/Ender_2_Ender Sep 28 '26
“small fortune” probably well over a million
19
u/HPDopecraft Sep 28 '26 •
![]()
I have bad news for you about what a fortune is these days….
10
u/Bonk3rs1 Sep 28 '26
To be fair, they said "small" fortune...
14
5
u/bentrw Sep 29 '26
1
u/Davodudeguy Sep 30 '26
This is the first meme I’ve ever seen and wanted to steal. It ain’t my thing, but thanks for sharing it, stranger.
1
2
2
2
1
6
4
u/RickySpanishEOD Sep 29 '26
Best I can do is an 1879-CC that was unfortunately cleaned before I came across it.
2
u/No_Desk_4921 Oct 03 '26
On the top where the second strike occurs, I would expect the outer edge of the stamp to cut through the outer edge of the original stamp. Same on bottom.
1
u/Fuzzy-Fun-6418 Oct 04 '26
Don't the Morgan collector's have all of the VAM's complete for all years? There are no more surprises in this category since the 1970's or even earlier.
9
u/fenton7 Sep 28 '26
Of course not. Your first clue it's entirely fake is that the coin is an 1893-S. Unless you paid $3M for a previously unknown rare date error coin, it's Chinesium.
1
5
4
4
3
3
3
3
u/Vivid_Anyth4 Sep 28 '26
If it were real why is the overlay perfect, there would be details from the first strike in there that another strike wouldn't magically clean up like you copy pasted it like this.
3
2
2
u/Kendrajames508 Sep 29 '26
Honest answer is a 2 part answer.
1st, if it's sold on Etsy, it's almost always a fake non collectable coin, I would say, if anything it's a souvenir.
But honestly #2 The surfaces displayed here show an artificial, uneven, or "muddy" finish with dull toning and a grainy texture. This is characteristic of modern reproduction of cast/transfer-die counterfeits commonly mass-produced overseas to deceive casual buyers.
So, no it is not real, and please keep up the good work asking the right questions before buying coins, there are too many fakes out there.
2
2
1
1
1
1
u/rubikscanopener Sep 29 '26
It's real, you're not imagining it. But it was made at some Temu factory in China, not struck at the US Mint.
1
u/givpilot Sep 29 '26
It is real alright, not just not a Morgan silver dollar minted in 1893. Probably cast in China in 2026....
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/VacantBasement Sep 29 '26
I've seen 2 real 1893 S in my life, I was able to buy 1. This is clearly fake.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/RankinPDX Sep 29 '26
My immediate thought, knowing literally nothing about this topic, is "That is way too cool to be real."
1
u/Street_Marsupial_538 Sep 30 '26
If a coin was struck again off center, the first strike would still be visible in the high relief area.
Even ignoring the weird font and uneven denticles, this can be ruled out as some sort of novelty item.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Comprehensive-Ear238 Sep 30 '26
All jokes aside. If that is a “Real” double struck coin. That thing would be worth Millions.
1
1
1
u/dogturd21 Sep 30 '26
I actually have a few double-struck coins that I picked up back in the early 70’s. It’s easy to tell they are fake, as the 2nd strike deforms the blank and it sticks out further , so the shape is not even close to being round. I have not seen them in decades , I might have lost them (they are not worth much if I recall )
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Getitgotitgoodgod Oct 03 '26
If it were real it would probably be the one of the rarest pieces of US currency.
But money is all imaginary anyway. We just agree (or disagree) on its value. Who’s to say what’s real?
1
1
1
u/Fuzzy-Fun-6418 Oct 04 '26
The two faces of Liberty are so different it's a joke. One is chubby with a short jaw line while the primary is thinner and the jaw line is longer. I frickin hate Morgan's but this was so ludicrously impossible and fake that I had to stop in and bag on the idiot who did this.
1
u/Demeter_Crusher Oct 04 '26
Likely its a real, modern reproduction of a period error-produced not-a-coin.
But what real means here is fascinating - if someone struck a period not-a-coin like this, would it be real?
1
1
1
1
1
u/Fast_Teaching_6160 Sep 28 '26
As in, not imaginary. Yep, it's real. And if you drill a hole through it it'll have value as a washer. $0.02 :)
-1
u/mightyminnow88 Sep 28 '26
I compared it to my other 1893 s Morgans and it doesn't look like either one
0
0
0
u/epSos-DE Oct 03 '26
If real, that would be very valuable, BUt it is NOT real !
Coins of that age are more worn out !
0
0
u/mtn2sea1960 Oct 04 '26
It's a special coin made for a special machine. If you find the machine, insert the coin and inside is a small fortune.
-1
u/Secret_Register_6925 Sep 29 '26
Yes, that is real. It’s double stamped and it could be worth quite a bit if you get it appraised by a professional.
1
-6
u/mistermoondog Sep 28 '26
If it was real, or is real, it would be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.
-4
u/SugarWataSloth Sep 28 '26
They make a silver round just like this. Not sure if this is the case though since the rounds will typically have some sort of indication that it's silver. This could just be a cast fake tho. Not sure.
0
0
u/TypingM111 Sep 30 '26
It's called a misprint most are "recycled" I have a few coins similar to how that looks not the same though and not that old wish I did though. In addition I haven't seen a misprint like that but my best guess is it probably a fake sadly.
2
1
0
12
2
0
Sep 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ak_plumber_1971 Sep 30 '26
It's obvious that you don't know the full definition of "Real".
1
u/nolegeskr Oct 01 '26
Damn!!!! Chill bro.
1
u/blueballz2235 Oct 05 '26
Since i cant respond to the coin team moderators of this group which I think is totally unfair and when u call me out and I cant respond I'll say my piece right here all I did was question the true meaning of the word " FAKE " and apparently some these stuck up way to serious groupies attempted to belittle me and question my character so no matter where im at or what group im in im gonna defend myself
3
u/herpetologydude Sep 30 '26
Semantic schmuck.
1
u/blueballz2235 Sep 30 '26
Not familiar with those big words dont know if i should thank u or be insulted
1
u/simplywalk Oct 01 '26
Familiar and insulted have the same number of letters as semantic. Ur just being argumentative.
1
u/blueballz2235 Oct 01 '26
Argumentative now thats a big word i hope I spelled it right I do know what that one means though and im anything but, I think im gonna have to bail out of this one, u pocket protector wearing ivy league graduates are way to serious for me, I eat cold pizza for breakfast and cereal for dinner now thats something u all can argue about
1
2
u/simplywalk Sep 30 '26
“ I “ think “ you “ are going through a little something called “ psychosis “
1
u/blueballz2235 Sep 30 '26
Why are all u people using these big words, people are so gosh darn sensitive now a day, smile more, laugh at yourself trust me the world would be a much better place if people laughed more and didnt take life so seriously
1
u/blueballz2235 Sep 30 '26
If i didnt know any better and im not one to judge but if i had to guess all u big word using show offs probably still use a pocket protector when u go to work, I bet all u smarties didnt know this it takes 3× as many muscle movements to frown then it does to smile, so relax and try smiling a little more
1
u/simplywalk Sep 30 '26
“Big word using show offs” sounds like a phrase someone who’s cosplaying as a midwestern farmer would say. Learn the language. I smile all the time usually when I’m not talking to people that think big words are theatrical.
1
u/NewIndividual5979 Sep 30 '26
All he said was, define real.
2
u/simplywalk Sep 30 '26 •
![]()
No he poorly debated the semantics of a word that is already defined. The quotations were hilarious to me. I’ll no longer debate semantics yall are incapable of using Google. Or reading beyond your own regurgitation, because he clearly explained what he meant and you can also use context clues to understand meaning. Beyond that he even replied to a comment with the exact and common definition he was referring to.
1
1
Oct 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Oct 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Oct 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Oct 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Initial_Row_6400 Oct 02 '26
It’s really fucking weird you’re that defensive about it. Like who the hell cares? No one here gives a damn about your house, or what you do for work, or your union.
1
Oct 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/coinerrors-ModTeam Oct 02 '26
Behavior that is unkind and unhelpful is not allowed here. Don't make fun of new collectors. Do not bicker. Don’t threaten. Don't name-call. Don’t shame. Don’t harass. Don’t be a jerk. Don’t create or respond to drama. Don’t troll others or let yourself be trolled. Don’t engage in uncivil exchanges. You do not "have the right to defend yourself" verbally here. Know when to disengage. Violation of this rule will get your post or comment removed, and repeated offenses will result in probation.














62
u/Pwnedzored Sep 28 '26
Fake fake fake