Hi everyone!
I recently purchased a hoard of Barber coins, and the photos I've uploaded show only a few examples from the lot. I'm particularly interested in submitting the Barber half dollars and the 1896-S Barber quarter for professional grading. However, they have what appear to be stubborn mineral deposits on their surfaces.
According to the previous owner, these coins were originally buried in fertile, mineral-rich soil. He mentioned that he soaked them in a rust remover to remove the thick green encrustations that had accumulated on their surfaces, which I assume were verdigris.
The remaining deposits appear as dark, hard encrustations, with what looks like white, powdery mineral deposits underneath and around them, scattered across the surfaces of the coins. These deposits are particularly noticeable along the reeded edges, where they can be seen more clearly. I'm not entirely sure what these substances are, but they appear to be firmly attached to the coins.
The first photo shows a sample of the encrustations that flaked off the surface of some of the coins.
My questions are:
What could these deposits actually be, and is there a safe way to remove them without damaging the coins' surfaces?
Would attempting to remove these deposits affect their chances of receiving a straight grade from PCGS or NGC, especially considering their previous exposure to rust remover?
Would professional conservation be the better option in this situation?
Has anyone encountered similar deposits on previously buried silver coins? If so, how did you deal with them?
I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from experienced collectors or those familiar with coin conservation.
My main goal is to preserve the coins, avoid causing further damage, and hopefully improve their chances of receiving straight grades when submitted for professional grading.
Thanks in advance!
Note: I documented my conservation journey with another hoard of coins three years ago, but this is a completely different case. I tried the same method on one of these coins, but it failed to remove the white mineral deposits.