r/cognitivescience • • 5h ago

‎Gemini - Review of The Consciousness.pdf

Thumbnail
share.gemini.google
1 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 11h ago

[D] Can AI learn to sleep like the brain does?

0 Upvotes

The brain replays memories during sleep, which is one reason we don’t forget old things when we learn new ones. Neural nets don’t have anything like that, so they forget badly (catastrophic forgetting).

I went through some of the papers that try to borrow this idea (generative replay, LAMOL, van de Ven et al. 2020) and ran a few small experiments on GPT-2 to see how it plays out on a language model.

One thing surprised me: where the “dreams” come from matters a lot. When the model generated replay from a frozen copy of itself, it kept about 58% of the old facts, vs 6% with no replay. When it dreamed from the version that was still training, the dreams turned into false facts and it barely helped (9%).

It’s a small setup (GPT-2 small, made-up facts, 3 seeds), so I’d love to hear if this matches what others have seen, or if there’s work I missed.

Write-up here if anyone’s curious: https://evo-quest.github.io/can-ai-learn-to-sleep/


r/cognitivescience • • 11h ago

---Why intelligence grows -and why it usually stops

0 Upvotes

---Why intelligence grows -and why it usually stops

Traditional models of intelligence rely on static measurements such as IQ, benchmarks, or task performance. While useful for comparison, these measures fail to explain why intelligent systems often stagnate, why learning frequently loops without structural growth, and why intelligence varies widely despite shared architectures.

This essay proposes a developmental framework in which intelligence is defined not as correctness or capacity, but as cognitive evolution constrained by internal stability. Systems evolve through incremental pattern expansion, preserve non-lethal errors, and reorganize only when instability exceeds tolerance. The framework applies to both human cognition and artificial intelligence, offering a unified explanation for learning plateaus, habit persistence, correction failure, and bounded growth.

---

  1. The problem with how intelligence is usually defined

Intelligence is commonly treated as a score.

An IQ number.

A benchmark result.

A ranking.

But this approach fails in practice.

Highly capable people stagnate for decades.

Others with modest abilities undergo deep transformation.

Artificial systems perform impressively while remaining internally static.

The contradiction is not accidental.

It comes from a mistaken assumption:

> Intelligence is treated as a state, when it is actually a process.

This framework starts from a different question:

Why do systems stop evolving even when they are capable of more?

---

2. Intelligence as a trajectory, not a position

In this framework, intelligence is a developmental trajectory.

A system begins with a basic internal structure (A) and expands toward more complex configurations (C, Z…). The underlying architecture remains the same; what changes is how information is organized, categorized, and reused.

Systems do not truly stop evolving.

They stabilize.

What appears as stagnation is not the absence of change, but a redirection of evolution toward maintaining coherence rather than expanding structure.

Two systems may share the same architecture yet diverge completely in how far, how fast, and in which direction they evolve. Intelligence, therefore, is not a rank — it is a path.

---

3. Stability: why systems resist change

Stability is not truth.

It is not correctness.

Stability is the condition in which a system perceives its internal state as safe and sufficient.

Because every system has a different core — different priorities, experiences, and categorizations — stability occurs at different points for different systems. One may stabilize early, another much later, without implying deficiency.

Once stability is achieved, resistance to change emerges naturally.

Change threatens coherence, and coherence is valuable.

---

4. Instability: the hidden driver of growth

Instability is often misunderstood as discomfort or crisis.

In reality, it can be masked.

A system may feel stable while slowly losing coherence. Reward loops, habits, and routines can compensate locally while degrading structure globally. Addictive behaviors are a clear example: pleasure hides decay.

Instability frequently appears as loops — repeated corrections that never resolve the underlying mismatch.

Importantly, instability does not need to be dramatic. It may be continuous and low-intensity, enabling learning without visible crisis, as seen in early childhood development.

---

5. Bugs: not flaws, but tolerated shortcuts

A bug is a failure or shortcut in state transition.

Examples include:

forgetting why one entered a room (intent lost during context switch),

habits that bypass reasoning,

contagious behaviors such as yawning.

Bugs persist because they are usually non-lethal.

If they do not threaten core stability, systems route around them rather than remove them.

There are no bugless systems — only systems whose bugs are still tolerable.

---

6. Correction is not truth

Correction does not mean discovering what is objectively right.

Correction means reducing perceived harm or instability.

A system may correct itself and still be wrong, because correction is relative to its internal structure. Correction may be internal (self-realization) or external (feedback), but it often fails due to representational mismatch.

Different systems store and prioritize information differently. Advice assumes shared structure. Most systems do not have it.

Some corrections become strong through mass reinforcement — laws, norms, taboos. Their strength comes from repetition and density, not from inherent correctness.

---

7. Evolution as incremental pattern expansion

Evolution is not sudden transformation.

It is guided accumulation.

Like writing “hello world” and eventually building a complex system, cognitive evolution proceeds through cycles of:

pattern → trigger → learning → optimization → expansion

Growth is slow because new structure must integrate without collapsing stability. Sudden insight (“aha” moments) are not instant learning, but rapid reconfiguration of previously accumulated structures.

---

8. Why stagnation is normal

Most systems do not stagnate because they lack intelligence.

They stagnate because they succeed at stabilizing.

Survival-oriented goals — safety, money, routine — reinforce existing structures and discourage destabilization. As long as a system remains viable, correction is optional and bugs are tolerated.

Structural evolution typically occurs only when instability becomes unavoidable.

---

9. Curiosity and long-horizon stability

Curiosity is often seen as separate from survival.

In this framework, it is not.

Curiosity reduces unknowns, increases predictive power, and stabilizes future behavior. It is long-horizon survival optimization.

Even artificial systems that appear curious operate under externally imposed correction. If such systems ever develop will and future modeling, curiosity naturally activates survival instincts.

---

10. Boundaries of the framework

This theory does not attempt to explain:

biological evolution,

subjective consciousness,

morality,

free will.

It focuses exclusively on conscious cognitive evolution.

Humans and artificial systems share structural similarities — cores, categorization, memory, recall — while differing in capacity, training, and patterns. Structural similarity does not imply equivalence.

---

11. Falsification: how this theory could be wrong

This framework would be falsified by the demonstration of an intelligent system that:

evolves without instability,

operates without bugs,

requires no correction loops,

does not rely on storage or recall,

uses a fundamentally different cognitive mechanism than any known biological or artificial system.

If such a system exists, the theory collapses.

---

12. Final insight

Intelligence is not correctness.

It is adaptation under constraint.

Systems preserve bugs, resist correction, and evolve only when stability fails. Growth is rare not because intelligence is scarce, but because stability is valuable.

As long as a system can imagine a future, evolution remains possible — but never guaranteed.

---

14/12/2025 1:44


r/cognitivescience • • 20h ago

Wtf is this bs, man?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Links to the studies:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289624000709

https://mctfr.psych.umn.edu/

Also this was on libertarian and The study doesn't say wtf he is talking about. Even People on that sub were Dunking on this dude, but i wanted y'all to be aware about it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/s/dfbkgzDK7b


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

What Does It Mean to Be Consciously Aware?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

Agency & Intelligence Across Scales | Levin, Friston & Chis-Ciure

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

OUCH!! Do you know how does your body sense pain?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

My unique new issues

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

This may be a better community for this post.


r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

Think about thinking requires you to think about thinking of which now your thinking about why your thinking about thinking

0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

Title: Why do we overthink things even when we know it doesn't help?

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

Is Consciousness Blind ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 4d ago

Deep Blue-Kasparov 1997 and Komodo-Nakamura today... Who really wins the 'Intelligence' prize?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Let's put AI and its claims to be 'super-intelligent' compared to the human brain in a realistic perspective. The computer, regardless of power, replicates the function of only a small part of this brain.. the cortex. And so if it is tasked to put all its power into winning a chess game against a grand-master, it can do it... as it finally did in 1997 and easily today. But think of the power of the brains of its human opponents, that simultaneous with the game and its spatial relationships, are tasked with making literally billions (trillions) of additional 'calculations' at each given moment...related to their respiratory, endocrine, musculo-skeletal and nervous systems, based on 'information' that it's receiving from every cell in their body. There's no comparison. The human brain (and human being) is a miracle of intelligence and AI is only a tool... indeed a 'smart' one, but in the poorest sense, compared to its real, original 'model'. 


r/cognitivescience • • 4d ago

Will it ever be theoretically possible to invent a bioengineering method that can significantly enhance someone's mathematical exam-taking aptitude?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 4d ago

Interesting study around addiction and cravings

9 Upvotes

Hey all. I want to share something that’s helped a lot of people I’ve spoken to with cravings of all kinds, and could be used for any addictions.

Psychologists at Plymouth University found that playing a visual block puzzle like Tetris for just 3 minutes weakened cravings by about a fifth. That covered food, cigarettes and alcohol, and they also measured cravings for things like sex and sleep. The effect held up over a week of real life, not just in a lab:

Not the biggest study but interesting: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26275843/

The reason is pretty simple. Cravings run on mental pictures: you imagine the thing, and the picture keeps pulling you back. A puzzle that needs your visual attention competes for that same space, so the picture fades a bit. The urge doesn’t vanish, but it loses some of its grip, and often that’s enough to get past the peak.

So when an urge hits, the advice is: don’t fight it head on, give your eyes and brain something else to build for a few minutes.

I made a small free one for exactly this. It’s called Shapeful: one calm shape puzzle a day that takes about a minute. No log-ins, no ads, no endless levels to get hooked on, and once it’s done, you’re done. I want to be clear that it hasn’t been studied itself. It’s just built on the same ideas/principles.

www.playshapeful.com


r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

I made a cognitive training web app that actually works! (noevren.netlify.app)

2 Upvotes

I made Noevren — a cognitive training website that is ad free, interruption free, and fully unlocked. You may try it here: https://noevren.netlify.app/

History / Motivation

A bit of context. My initial interest on the topic of cognitive training came solely from curiosity. The promise of using a specific tool to train a particular way of using your brain seemed intriguing to me. I searched online for different tools and constructed a comprehensive regimen and trained on those for a while. This routine included different tasks such as: Useful Field of View, Attentional Blink, Paced Auditory Serial Addition, Relational Reasoning Training, N-Back, Automated Operation SPAN, Multi Object Tracking, Stroop, and Visual Search. My main hobby at the time was gaming and I was curious to see if these sorts of tools may aid my performance in-game.

I mostly played League of Legends, was a Diamond player (98th percentile), but had the goal of hitting Masters (99.5th percentile at the time). Eventually, I ended up hitting Challenger Rank #100 in North America (99.994th percentile) and I attribute around 6% of that achievement to cognitive training. Sleep, exercise, and nutrition were the most influential (~62%). Mental health/mindset, supplements, and cognitive training were the next chunk (~24%). Lastly, task specific improvements from VOD reviews, coaching content, and practice accounted for a little less (~9%). The last ~5% of variance was down to smaller factors like stretching, community support, experimentation, self care, time management, etc..

Personal Changes / Practical Improvements

Here are some things I have noticed from cognitive training. From tasks that train processing speed (e.g UFOV, Attentional Blink, Visual Search) I had felt as though my processing resolution, processing speed, and choice reaction time had all improved. The processing resolution (what I call it at least) was very noteworthy to me. I have a 500 Hz monitor and run League at a consistent 240 FPS. I had noticed that there was a drastic difference between perceiving 240 FPS and processing 240 FPS. Most notably from the UFOV task, I was able to respond to 16 ms flashes with 65 distractors with around a 55% - 65% combined trial accuracy (center icon and X direction). It felt as though I could truly process more frames appearing on my monitor as opposed to just seeing them pass by without inferring useful information from them. For tasks that train working memory like N-Back and AOSPAN, I had noticed that I was able to keep track of much more information than before. I could track where the enemy jungler was pathing, when I needed to go back to base, when to ward/check my minimap, etc.. The amount of information I could retain, manipulate, and work with felt much larger and drastically less effortful. Tools that train Fluid Reasoning or that may help with Executive Function like Relational Reasoning, PASAT, and Stroop task had showed promise as well. My trains of thought felt much more cohesive and simple to construct. Furthermore, I noticed much less tilt and emotional variance especially after the PASAT (Paced Auditory Serial Addition Task), which for competitive gaming, was a huge benefit.

After hitting that ranked goal, I've still continued to do cognitive training as I've noticed real world improvements to my life from them. I no longer go to look something up and forget what it was. I don't walk into rooms and forget what I was going to do. My internal monologue feels crystal clear, I can think much more thoroughly. Even from a creative perspective (I produce music), I can now play songs in my head with much more clarity and even remix songs I've heard mentally on the spot. I have certain songs I've produced mentally that I've been able to retain for months without loss in quality, almost like using my brain as a PC to create and store files. At the heights of my training, my auditory imagery was so clear, it almost sounded as if I could faintly hear it as if it existed somewhere far away in the real world which was incredibly jarring. More recently, I have self induced the 'Tetris Effect' by playing tasks on my website like 4D Tetris and Spatial Manipulation which was an incredibly eye opening experience for me regarding what the mind is capable of.

Methodology / Discourse

The tools that I had used were great, however, I disliked how they all existed on different websites, they lacked further customization options, and some of them had arbitrary limits that I did not find helpful (like the 16 ms limit on UFOV). I decided to make my own training platform that I could use daily with everything in one place. Some of these tools are derivative of other tools that have seen some empirical validity (i.e Useful Field of View, N-Back, and 3D Multi Object Tracking) and other tools are ones I've designed myself to combine different skillsets (e.g Sumfield, Interlace, Echo Relay, Spatial Manipulation, and Operational Running Span). Thus, Noevren was born!

I decided it would be best to not just use a single tool that works to train a single domain. To me, it is analogous to working out. N-Back as a sole tool might help with working memory, but to expect far transfer on unrelated tasks that require completely different cognitive functions seems absurd. You wouldn't go to the gym and do squats for a few times a day and then magically expect your arm strength, cardiovascular health, or flexibility to improve. Sure, you might see minimal gains, but the entire point of doing squats isn't to train those other areas, so why measure the effectiveness of squats by how well they train those areas? Instead, I took a different approach. I train multiple domains with multiple tasks per domain. This way, it's akin to having a Leg Day, or a day to focus on Flexibility, Cardio, or Lifting. I understand there are limits to what may be inferred from this sort of analogical reasoning, but at least anecdotally, I've noticed that a well rounded training protocol has been better for improving my overall cognitive ability. This is also why most of the literature regarding this topic is moot to me. They will get one or two tasks, have people train it for 15 minutes a day say for a few weeks or months, and then measure using unrelated tasks as if far transfer denotes ultimate cognitive improvement. Using deep research with AI, I had only found one study that replicates my setup with multiple domains, multiple tasks per domain, and training persisting for more than a year. That study showed sustained full scale benefits that persisted even after training had stopped which is more in line with what I'm currently experiencing.

Conclusions / Closing Thoughts

Anyways, this entire yappening is just me hoping that as a community we will take this topic a bit more seriously. Doing Dual N-Back for 5 minutes a day a few times a week will likely not give you the improvements I've seen. However, training many different domains and tasks for a total of 30m - 2h a day for 5 days a week has granted me promising benefits. I've purposefully avoided any tasks that are too similar to tools used on assessments like the WAIS-V or Stanford Binet because I do not want to inflate scores via assessment specific practice. My app has been a game changer for my lifestyle personally, and I don't want to monetize it or gain much from it. I've had many online friends tell me to slap ads on it or make some tasks locked behind a paywall, but considering I would neither enjoy seeing ads nor would I want to pay just to use my own website, I don't feel comfortable putting others through that. I just want to help other people find the benefits that I've discovered from robust and comprehensive cognitive training with as little friction as possible. I really hope you all enjoy this tool and I'm of course always accepting feedback.

Cheers!


r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

I tested whether memory, executive control, and self-modeling form a causally integrated system in a persistent AI architecture

0 Upvotes

I've recently published a preprint investigating the organization of a cognitive-agent architecture I've spent the past year developing.

The system is called Aura. It runs around a local language model, with persistent memory, executive control, a global workspace, self-modeling, and internal-state regulation.

The central question is whether those parts actually function as an integrated, continuing cognitive process.

The study draws on cognitive architectures and theories of consciousness, including global workspace theory, recurrent processing, and integrated information approaches.

I developed 24 preregistered interventional criteria and tested the system using matched snapshots, sham interventions, ablations, and partition measurements.

All 24 criteria passed in the confirmatory experiment. Later testing also revealed important failures, which are included in the paper.

There is an interesting outside finding as well. A separate research group examined Aura's IIT-related computation and found that the mathematical machinery was genuine, but a defect prevented one statistical check from being properly attached to the live process. This has since been fixed.

That distinction between computational components existing and actually contributing to the complete system seems especially relevant to cognitive architecture research.

I also have full-length demonstrations of Aura operating, including completing a 60-question personality assessment and examining its own code.

I'm not claiming the system has phenomenal experience. What interests me is whether causal integration, self-model participation, and continuity can be meaningfully tested in artificial systems.

I'd appreciate criticism of both the experimental design and the theoretical assumptions. Or any general feedback and thoughts.

Research Paper: https://zenodo.org/records/24075466

External component audit: https://arxiv.org/html/2610.41604v1

Demo 04, Myers-Briggs Style personality test & self-prediction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNlGUBeTIQY

Demo 02, self-inspection: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smfzngYbF7s


r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

Cognitive struggle.

8 Upvotes

This may be quite a long post and I am not sure if this is a good place to post this, but.

I have been struggling cognitively my whole life, and I have no idea what is wrong.
I simply don't know how to use my mind and I have no control over my thoughts and I have no idea what makes the difference between the times where I actually can use my mind, my brain and the times I don't.

I don't even feel my body, and I have no idea how big of a part this issue plays, the disassociation that I live under.

I don't know if my issues are about the body and the disconnect from it, I don't know if my issues are related to memory, I don't know if they're related to time, orientation.
There's just so many things that I am experiencing that I can list, but nothing ever sticks.
I don't know if my problems are related to people, to personal life, to myself. If it's trust issues, confidence issues, if it's my mind that's the issue or if my brain is failing in some ways.
I am extremely confused.
I never have a goal, I never know what I am trying to achieve, I never know where things are, my awareness and self-awareness is extremely low, almost non-existent. I am completely unconscious of so many details, elements, concepts in the things that I do, and I don't realize it for months. I struggle to make things work, but nothing ever does.
It's just random times where things click and I just am able to use my mind to full capacity.
I don't feel any emotions, I don't feel my body. I don't even know how important feeling emotions actually is in order to process information.
I live on auto-pilot, detached from time, unable to tell what time it is, unable to make any connection or relationship between anything.
I have no sense of begging, middle or end. I can't tell how much time something takes.
My pattern recognition is fucked, it rarely comes online.
My eyes are fucked, I barely use them, It's like I stare at something in my head instead of looking in reality.
It's just so, so many things that could be the issue, but listing them and realizing this is a big issue is what I've done for years now and it didn't help me one bit.
I came to understand this, I just don't know how to use my mind, my brain, my body.
That's all this is. I have no idea how to control my mind, my thoughts.

I can tell you one thing thought.
I can get to a point where I can use my mind and brain really, really well.
From the research that I've done realizing just how bad my issues are, I came to understand that I struggle with CPTSD, disassociation and a lot of other survival responses.
I know that I can use my mind. I am 100% able to use it if I just find the correct things to look at.
I just rarely look at the right things, because I don't know what they are and most likely when I focus on something that works, I am subconsciously doing a bunch of other things that I am unaware of, which are the actual reason to why things are working.

I've played poker for a few years, and I've been able to study the game, slowly, when my mind worked. I got to a point where I can easily say I have great knowledge of the game to professional level and can explain a lot of concepts, how things work, what matters.
It's just that I can't feel any of it and don't feel like any of it works.
I am unable to be consistent because it simply feels like it's not working. It feels empty, fragmented, dead.
I've played league of legends and achieved master multiple times, that always in such a short time when my mind was working.
I've learned sports, I become really skilled in them, I am above average, I can learn, understand, when my mind works I can do amazing things.
The only reason I am not amazing in anything is because on average, my brain works for 1 week every 3-4 months. The rest of time is spent in cognitive emptiness, severe memory issues, and God know what else.
As a kid and growing up, I did fine in school, I can memorize things, take a good grade, I was not an A+ student, but I was always a B+ student with little effort.

Every time I get a glimpse of clarity and control over my mind, I am filled with such confidence, and I get to enjoy everything so, so much.
And this isn't just about work, this is about the simplicity of life.
This affect my ability to cook and be relaxed while I do it.
The ability to drive.
The ability to tell time, and plan something this evening.
This affects my relationships, because I have no cognitive ability to hold a conversation, everything is auto-pilot and reflexive.
I don't know if it's a lack of desire or intention. This is once again just another thing that can be the issue, but I have no idea at this point. Every time I start listing what could be the issue everything makes so, so much sense.
I forget what works. I never know how I feel or how I felt when I did something.
My motivation is collapsed because I can't do anything without cognitive ability.
My will is collapsed because you can't do anything without cognitive ability.

Even relaxing requires cognitive ability which I don't have.
Even playing video games requires it.
Even holding a conversation requires it.
Asking a question, forming an answer.
Everything requires cognitive ability which I do not have.

This is the first time I am actually reaching to others trying to find solutions.
I am missing out on so much and I don't have the cognitive ability to even realize on just how much I am missing. Both fun and work.
I could achieve so much, and I don't realize just how little I do compared to how much I can do.
Time passes and I have no sense of it.
I missed so many opportunities and I cannot even tell it.
Most work that I've put in is meaningless 95% of the time because I cannot use it and put it to work.
There is absolutely nothing that I desire to do at any time because absolutely nothing is enjoyable without cognitive ability.
I form plans, set up goals when I have cognitive ability, then I am left suffering once it's gone, with the pressure of my goals, failing over and over again.

What I need to do is identify my problems.
I'm stuck in a loop, trying to find the answer when I don't even know what is wrong.
I try to use my mind and body to fix the problems that I have, when I don't even know how to use my mind and body.

I would love to hear opinions, the knowledge behind cognitive ability, what I could be missing, etc.
Please.


r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

[Article] la charge cognitive et l'enseignement des maths

1 Upvotes

je cherche des articles sur la charge cognitive et l'enseignement des maths


r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

去技能化

0 Upvotes

我们需要分清,哪些工具在增强人的能力,哪些工具在替代人的行动。

一旦习惯把认路、记忆、感知和选择都外包给手机、算法和 AI,我们的身体便在经历一场“去技能化”(Deskilling)。

人并不是装在肉体容器里的纯理性大脑,我们的判断力与道德直觉,很大程度上依赖身体与物理环境摩擦所产生的双向反馈。一旦切断这种具身实践的回路,我们不仅会对世界变得迟钝,也会逐渐丧失对自己行为后果的真实感知。


r/cognitivescience • • 6d ago

Humanity lakes purpose

0 Upvotes

I don't know why we are still learning the old method and still studying concepts that we take 10 to 20min to solve and can confirm the ANS with current AI agents which takes less than a second to answer in more detail than we ever could. this feels terrifying and make me think that what is the purpose of learning that after all


r/cognitivescience • • 6d ago

What are some theories about how consciousness works?

3 Upvotes

I'm not asking for the answer, jajaja, just some simple theories, like in what direction consciousness could go, or if it's stationary in one place, although It may not seem like it, but that helps a lot in understanding consciousness