r/cognitiveTesting • u/willwao • Jun 28 '23
Puzzle A Multiple-Choice Probability Problem
What do you guys think? Please share your thoughts and reasoning. (Credits to the sub and OP in the pic.)
91
u/shykawaii_shark Jun 28 '23
Isn't this a paradox though? No answer can be correct.
If the correct answer were to be 25%, there are two options that correspond to that answer, which means you have a 50% chance to get it right. Therefore, the correct answer is 50%.
But since there's only one option that says 50%, it means you have a 1/4 chance to get it right if you were to pick randomly, which would make the correct answer 25%; that means the correct answer is 50%; which means the correct answer is 25%; and so on and so forth.
12
u/make-up-a-fakename Jun 28 '23
I dunno, I thought that originally however. If you assume the answer can't be 25% because that would break the structure of the test (as in you could pick the right answer, 25% but still be wrong because the answer key has A instead of D or vice versa) then that rules out 2 answers.
That leaves 2 answers which means you've got a 50% chance of getting it right.
I mean that's just one way to look at it, but at least it allows you to pick an answer!
10
u/mysteryo9867 Jun 28 '23
But then if there is a 50% chance, 50% is the right answer. Since there is only one 50 then there is a 25% chance of picking that, you chose to end your thought process early. That dosent make you right
11
u/make-up-a-fakename Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23
No that's not what I'm saying, I'm eliminating both 25% as possibilities, since it's duplicated it can't be the right answer because that's not how multiple choice questions work. That leaves 2 possible answers.
Like surely that's the point in these questions, to think about it in a different way because I can work out probabilities the same as anyone else here can, but assuming there is an answer means you have to think differently to just saying "nope, can't be done"
Edit: The flaw in this logis is that the answer says specifically if you select at random, which I'm glossing over 😂
6
4
u/StatisticianKey2323 Jun 28 '23 edited Jul 10 '23
Now, it said to choose one at random* not think about it first and then choose. Answer would be 33% chance; with a differential probability
Edit: after combining the two 25% answers; you’re rly left with 3 choices. But that simple fact can base it to 50% bc you can cancel the repeats.
I’m not smart enough to calculate that much percentages with all the factors included
3
u/MELONHEADS_OFFICIAL Jun 28 '23
The other guy is tripping, it’s most definitely a paradox or at the very least it’s a question with no correct answer
4
u/make-up-a-fakename Jun 28 '23
You know the whole point of these things is to come up with a creative way as to how you can make it make sense right? Sitting there saying "nah it's a paradox" is just shit. Like you know anyone can just work out the probability right?
3
u/MELONHEADS_OFFICIAL Jun 28 '23
Someone doubling down on a false answer by making up rules is something I’d hate as an interviewer. Someone taking in all the information and clearly honing in on the incoherence is what I’d want. Maybe I want the first guy at a party or in art school but trust me second answer is leaps and bounds better
→ More replies (2)3
u/moskusokse Jun 28 '23
Wouldn’t that make it more related to creative thinking. And not cognitive testing? Since it would just be brainstorming with no logic, as the logical answer is that it isn’t solvable?
Where does one draw the line between cognitivity and creativity?
→ More replies (2)3
u/Wild_Assistant_4104 Jun 28 '23
What is never talked about is this simply put with any desicions no matter the extra options you will always have a 50/50 chance because the question literally states right or wrong not averages so yes you will miss a 100 percent of all shots not take because it's a fifty fifty split you either will or won't.
On or off no variables
→ More replies (2)3
u/locosss Jun 28 '23
Its simply a paradox question. At first 25% will be the correct answer, but since theres 2 25%,since you can choose either A or D, the chance you'll be correct will be 50%.
But if you choose 50% as your answer, then the chance of you getting it correct is 25%. Its simply a paradox question.
You eliminate 2 answer and didn't prove the other 2, thats not how math works buddy. Every answer need prove, and in this question, all answers are wrong.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here for my attempt, I think it's free from paradoxes (hopefully), but it's in need of critical feedbacks
4
u/alex123444555 Jun 28 '23
But since there's only one option that says 50%, it means you have a 1/4 chance to get it rightIt's not how it works.
1
2
1
Jun 29 '23
No bc it either is 25% or it isnt. If it isnt theres two of that answer so the chance of u picking it is 50%, if it isnt 25% then theres two anawers that arent 25%, giving u a 50% of picking it, either way irs 50%.
1
u/shykawaii_shark Jun 29 '23
it either is 25% or it isnt.
That's not how it works lol, the answers that aren't 25% can't both be correct. One of them is 50%, one of them is 60%. They're mutually exclusive.
1
Jul 04 '23
The two remaining answers dont need to both be correct, bc we narrowed down the available answer pool from 4 (25% each) to 2 (50%) the answer is now 50%, if the two remaining answers that arent 25% were both correct, then the answer would be 100%, which isnt the case since the last two remaining answers are different from each other and so it cant be both of them.
1
u/willwao Jul 04 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comments, see if it addressed your concerns it's in need of critical feedback too
1
1
u/kingkyros16 Jun 29 '23
And on top of that, since it sort of switches between 25% and 50% at an infinite speed, that means each answer is correct 50% of the time which makes it half of 75% which is 37.5% because three problems in 4 makes 75% of random choices correct but since they are only correct half the time, that makes it half of 75%. Say you chose randomly 24 times, 12 of those times would be a repition of 25% which is right half of the time and 6 times out of the 24 would be 50% which is also right half of the time. So, a total of 9 random choices would be correct of 24 which simplifies to 3/8 which is 0.375 or 37.5%.
However, since 37.5% isn't an answer, the answer becomes 0% which is also not an answer and since the question specifies that it must be an answer that is an option, there is no answer.
1
u/TrigPiggy Jun 29 '23
Duplicated correct answer for "If you had 4 choices and picked one randomly what is the chance you would pick the right one?", 1/2 probability, therefore 50%.
1
u/shykawaii_shark Jun 29 '23
Yes, the correct answer is 50%; you have a 1/4 chance of picking that answer, therefore the correct CORRECT answer is 25%. But you have a 50% chance of picking 25%, so the correct CORRECT CORRECT answer is 50%. But you have a 25% chance of picking 50%, so the correct CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT answer is 25%. It goes in an infinite loop
9
u/SipexF Jun 28 '23
This is an impossible question where the answer is constantly fluctuating between 25% and 50% depending at what point in the logic you're examining.
7
u/OpeningScared8273 Jun 28 '23
The correct answer is dependent on the correct answer which makes it unsolvable.
15
Jun 28 '23
It’s a paradox
0
u/Superb_Excitement_67 Jun 28 '23
It is not a paradox. There is not a question in the first place that is talked about in the text. People just think that this is a question because it says "Q3", but world does not work in this way where you can just say what things are, and they just magically become it. It is not a paradox, it is just being plain wrong and confusing.
I offered a bit better explanation on the other comment, but it annoys me a bit that everything is branded as paradox nowadays, lol.
7
Jun 28 '23
it is a paradox because there's a self reference contradiction.
4 answer choices -->25% chance --> 2 answers with 25% chance --> more than 25% chance because 2 answers with 25% --> 4 answer choices --> 25% chance2
u/acuterotationpull Jun 28 '23
not true, if you take test 100 times with an equal representation of each option you got it right 25% of the time. this doesn't mean the right answer to pick given the question is 25% because the question is referring to two different variables, the percent of times recipients choose the correct answer, and the right answer. confusing but not paradoxical
2
u/JNtheWolf Jun 29 '23
The question itself is asking you to answer IF you were to take it randomly, how likely are you to be correct. However you can't formulate a correct answer because the answer itself is a paradox. If all answers are unique, then whatever the correct answer is it's a 25% chance, which is then the correct answer. However, because two of the answers are the same, unless those two answers are both 50%, the question cannot be answered. If the answer is 25%, then it's actually 50% because two of the answers are 25%, which then makes it 25% because only one of the answers is 50%, and it eternally fluctuates. There is no correct answer.
2
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
You, I like how combative you were on the other post, search for my comment here for my attempt, I can use some critical feedbacks
→ More replies (1)1
Jun 28 '23
That's not what the question wants your to do, clearly it wants you to answer by picking
You are assuming there is a right answer when there isn't one. You already changed the problem statement with this assumption.
1
u/acuterotationpull Jun 28 '23
from my earlier comment
your selection isn't what counts, it's what the chance is you pick the correct option. there is 4 options and one of them has the correct option, so the chance of getting the answer right randomly is 25%. that makes the only answer possible 50% because there are two out of four answers that give you the correct option. another way to explain this would be if you are asked to guess a whole number with a range of 4 your odds of guessing the right answer are 25% (their test), but if you are tasked with guessing which number will follow next in a random sequence of four numbers where there are two options for the same number (25, 60, 50, 25) the odds of you getting 25 correctly are 50% (your test).
it's worded in a way to confuse the reader so you think your answer and the likelihood of choosing that answer are the same. you can prove it to yourself if you want to. take a 4 sided die and write a number on each side. does it matter which number is which for you to get it? so if you write two of the same number on different sides, and two different ones on others, does it matter which side is facing up? you're still going to get a 50% probability of rolling a variable that is the same as another variable
→ More replies (5)8
u/RedShiz Jun 28 '23
Nah it's a paradox. The answer changes as you evaluate it. Like "This statement is a lie."
2
Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23
I haven’t used the word paradox in like 10 years because of how easy it is to misuse. I think it applies here.
Also, it’s not a question because it says “Q3”. It’s a question because it is phrased as one.
→ More replies (5)1
1
u/willwao Jun 29 '23
Alright, it seems that both the interest and the range of conclusions drawn for the problem have gone past its peak; as far as I can tell the problem is still open but I will share my thoughts about it soon.
I shall post it here in the comments as you apparently can't edit posts with images.
Thank you all for those who commented and who gave it a real try, it was interesting reading even the most controversial takes as they always have something to offer.
1
u/willwao Jun 29 '23 edited Jul 04 '23
This is a more polished version of my attempt from a post from another sub:
We shall assume that each of the four options available, (a), (b), (c), and (d), is equally likely to be picked by random selection. And we shall also assume that both of the "you"s from Q3 are referring to the hypothetical you who will be picking from the available options randomly (so when you pick an option as an answer to Q3 you are essentially making a (meta-)statement about Q3 itself, where "you" are just a constituent of it; so there is no equivocation fallacy to be made).
Now, either Q3 has no solutions or it has solutions (among the four available options, that is). These cases together cover all possibilities regarding the solvability of Q3.
Suppose first that Q3 has no solutions. Then the chance or probability of picking a solution by random selection is 0%. Now since none of the available options were assigned the value "0%", which is consistent with the fact that Q3 has no solutions (in fact, even if there were options with the assigned value of "0%" they would still be non-solutions because there would be at least a 25% chance of picking one of them by random selection), we cannot rule out the possibility that Q3 has no solutions.
Suppose next that Q3 has solutions. Then Q3 must either have only one solution, only two solutions, only three solutions, or (only) four solutions exhaustively (it clearly cannot have more than four solutions to be picked from the available four options).
Suppose that Q3 has only one solution. Then the probability of picking the solution by random selection is 25%. But since both (a) and (d) were assigned the value "25%", we must have either (a) as the solution or (d) as the solution, but not both at the same time. Now to check if the aforementioned probability is altered by this fact (and therefore a contradiction) we see that:
P(picking the solution by random selection)
= P(picking the solution (a) by random selection or picking the solution (d) by random selection)
= P(picking the solution (a) by random selection) + P(picking the solution (d) by random selection)
= P(picking (a) by random selection | (a) being the solution)P((a) being the solution) + P(picking (d) by random selection | (d) being the solution)P((d) being the solution)
= (25%)(X%) + (25%)(100% - X%)
= 25%
where X% is the probability of (a) being the solution, and the probability sum and chain rules were used while keeping in mind that (a) being the solution and (d) being the solution are mutually exclusive but collectively exhaustive events. Hence, given the consistency shown above, the possibility of either (a) or (d) being the solution, but not both at the same time, cannot be ruled out.
Suppose now that Q3 has only two solutions. Then the probability of picking a solution by random selection is 50%. Since (c) was assigned the value "50%", it is one of the solution. But we see that none of the other options were assigned "50%", hence Q3 has only (c) as the solution, contradicting the fact that it has two solutions. Thus Q3 must not have (only) two solutions.
Similar arguments to the one made in the last paragraph could be made for the cases of only three and four solutions; we can clearly see that none of the four available options were assigned the value "75%" or "100%". Hence, Q3 must not have only three solutions or four solutions.
As mentioned before, these cases together cover all possibilities, hence Q3 either has no solutions or exactly one solution, that being (a) or (d) but not both simultaneously.
TL;DR: Attempting to solve Q3 led naturally to a (meta-)problem about its solvability: "Is Q3 solvable, if so what are the possible solution sets?", and my argument above was an attempt to resolve it, with the conclusion: the solvability of Q3 is undeterminable as it may not have any solution, and in cases where Q3 is solvable its solution set is either {(a)} or {(d)}; i.e. the set of all possible solution sets of Q3 is {{}, {(a)}, {(d)}}.
Edit: removed spoiler marks + grammar
Edit #2: just to note that this is just my take, AFAIK no one has the "official" solution to this problem
Edit #3: TL;DR
2
u/Rotund_Gentleman Jun 30 '23
This is very well written - understandable and very thorough.
I like how you chose to make a bulletproof-proof with the assumption that there may be no solution, in contrast to my method where I forced a set a parameters completely disregarding the idea that there may be no solution.
I think it's interesting the different methods people take to make their own solutions to problems like this.
What's your level of education if you don't mind me asking, cos as I said, very well written?
1
u/willwao Jul 01 '23
Thanks for the kind words and I'm glad to hear that it's accessible.
I saw you noticed that the probability distribution for the options weren't a given (as you can have random selection predicated on an arbitrary probability distribution), and thus adjustable, and even gave a case where (a) and (d) (those assigned "25%") are together the only solutions. Had the others noticed this too they could've justified the options for any of the existing assigned values as solutions e.g. setting 50% for (c) and 16.67% for the rest gives (c) as the solution, and setting 60% for (b) and 13.33% for the rest gives (b) as the solution.
I did a BSc a while back with a minor in math, that's where I was formally introduced to proof-writing, and I have since held a casual interest in math but I know very little about mathematical logic otherwise.
1
Jul 01 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/willwao Jul 01 '23
Let me also add that (a) and (d) are not equal. They are equal insofar that they share the same assigned value of "25%" but they are still distinct from each other as options to be picked; if they were actually equal then there would only be three options available to choose from for Q3 . Hence, if Q3 must have exactly one solution with the assigned value of "25%" then we must choose between (a) and (d) but not both together for a given solution set, and since they are not equal we commit no contradiction in doing so. The solution sets in question are {(a)} and {(d)}.
1
Jul 01 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
5
u/New-Sun-5282 Jun 28 '23
Since everything else has been addressed... there's no correct answer to choose from. You choose the probability for an answer that doesn't exist. Even if theres was the 33.33 figure there you would be correct about the probability of choosing a correct answer not to THIS question but to a hypothetical or non existent one.
4
Jun 28 '23
Is says "What's the chance you will be correct" to which the answer is 50% cause you will either be correct or you won't.
If it said "what's the chance that you'll guess the correct answer?", That's where it gets confusing..
2
u/JNtheWolf Jun 29 '23
Those are the same question though. It's not a 50% chance of you being correct or not. It's only a 25% chance if all the answers are unique. For you to be correct, you need to pick the correct answer, so saying those two questions are different is pointless.
1
u/Fgamervisa Jun 28 '23
Now I want the answer, because I spend a good hour trying to figure this out
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here, I tried to be as comprehensive as I could and I think it sums up the general consensus here, it's in need of critical feedbacks tho
1
u/KoobeBryant Jun 28 '23
The odds of you at random picking the correct choice in a multiple choice problem are 25% regardless of the answer choices.
So the answer to this question would be 25% if all the options were different but since there are two 25% the odds of your random guess being either of those 25% is actually 50%
So the answer we choose is 50% because there’s a 50% chance our random guess would fall on 25 or 25 we are making an educated guess and don’t have to choose randomly.
Edit: I think people think this is a paradox because you are assuming you have to pick a random choice when picking your answer. You don’t. The question is asking you if the choice was random but you don’t have to randomly pick.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here and have a look at my attempt, I hope it addressed some of your concerns, and it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/BoredDebord Jun 28 '23
The question is self-referential. It’s a paradox lol. “If you pick an answer to this question….”
1
u/KoobeBryant Jun 28 '23
Yes but when you pick your answer you don’t have to randomly guess. It’s just asking you if you were to randomly guess. You as the person answering this actual question do not have to guess it’s just asking if you were to.
1
u/LearnDifferenceBot Jun 28 '23
were to
*too
Learn the difference here.
Greetings, I am a language corrector bot. To make me ignore further mistakes from you in the future, reply
!optoutto this comment.1
1
u/BoredDebord Jun 28 '23
In order to make a conclusion, we first of all have to determine what the correct answer to this question is. Since we can’t determine that (the question being a paradox), we can’t determine what chance you have of guessing correctly if you answered it randomly.
If the answer to this question is 25%, you would have a 50% chance of answering correctly if you answered randomly. But we can’t determine that the answer to this question is 25% (because it is a paradox).
1
u/KoobeBryant Jun 28 '23
The answer to this question would be 25% if there was only one 25% but because we have 2/4 chances to get that the actual answer is 50%. The question is not asking you to make a random guess when you actually guess the answer
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Kdtito Jun 28 '23
It's not the same picking at random and picking knowing the answers, they are two different cases that are related, based on this, here's my proposed answer:
The first case you have to pick a random answer out of 4 options, but considering it's random it doesn't matter if you know the answers or not, and you will either be right or wrong, since you have to pick randomly.
Let's assume you did know the answers that this question had. Even so, since you had to pick a RANDOM ANSWER, you had 1/4 of being right or wrong, or 25% chances, and in this questions there are two options with that value, so you can add them up to 50%.
Finally, knowing this, now you dont' have to pick randomly, you can choose c. Even you know the right answer is 1 of the 4 optios, it wouldn't matter, because now you are not pickin randomly.
In the case you didn't knew what the answers were, the same applies. Therefore the correct answer is c).
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here for my take on this, it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/HalfDozing Jun 28 '23
The assumption that all test questions have a correct answer is the faulty one. This is not a paradox. It is a question written with 4 choices, all of which are incorrect. You could make several assumptions beyond that with various scenarios in mind but none of them could validly answer the question, which is no different from any other question being asked with 4 invalid answers.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here, I tried to be comprehensive with my approach but it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/BoredDebord Jun 28 '23
People so desperately want there to be an answer. It’s definitely a paradox lol. If it’s 25%, then it’s 50%. If it’s 50%, then it’s 25%. Infinite loop, caused by the self-referential nature of the question.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Look up my comment here for my attempt, I hope it's comprehensive enough to be void of any paradox but it's in need of critical feedbacks
2
u/Aspirience Jun 28 '23
Isn’t the answer zero? Because when ever a choice is made, it is wrong?
2
u/BoredDebord Jun 28 '23
If put into a calculator, maybe we would get “undefined” lol. There can’t be an answer. Also, 0% isn’t an option, so we can’t technically respond to the question as such. Not sure though lol.
2
1
u/Coises Jun 28 '23
If ______, what is the chance ______?
The answer to this question will be a probability, hence a real number on the closed interval [0,1]. Call any potential answer x.
If you pick ______, what is the chance that you will be correct?
A method for making a choice will be proposed. That method will have some probability of picking each possible answer. Call that probability p(x).
We are told only that the correct answer is the chance of picking the correct answer. Thus, the question is asking for x such that x = p(x).
If you pick an answer to this question at random, what is the chance that you will be correct?
Four choices are given beneath the question. With no further information, we must assume the proposed method is to take the value of a uniform random variable n over the domain {1, 2, 3, 4} and assign the nth element of the sequence (.25, .60, .50, .25) as the value of x.
Thus, p(.25) = .50; p(.60) = .25; p(.50) = .25; and p(x) where x is any other value is 0.
Accordingly, the only value of x for which p(x) = x is 0.
Depending on whether an answer which is not among the multiple choices can be considered valid, either the answer is 0 or there is no correct answer.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
I like the formalism, search for my comment here for my attempt I hope it completes your take, it's in need of critical feedback too
1
u/Rotund_Gentleman Jun 28 '23
It does have an answer.
When the question was written and the answer was decided they used the following possibilities:
12.5 chance of being a) 37.5 chance of being b) 37.5 chance of being c) 12.5 chance of being d)
By picking an answer at random (with 25% for each) you have a:
50% chance of choosing 25 which is correct 25% of the time 25% chance of choosing 50 which is correct 37.5% of the time 25% chance of choosing 60 which is correct 37.5% of the time
Making the answer 25% so, a) or d).
This is not possible to do with 50% because even if the answer was 50% you would only have a 25% chance of picking it to begin with and this can not be increased. The same is true for 60%.
Side tangent: I don't believe in paradoxes, I think that with sufficient complexity any problem can be solved. Which is how I found this solution to the problem - by increasing complexity.
Zeno's paradox of motion is a good example of this (and worth a look at if you're interested). I am a firm believer that all paradoxes are just questions, that can be solved with the sufficient math.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here to check out my take, see if you could spot any paradox or contradiction, it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
1
u/_hancox_ Jun 28 '23
Most people are assuming that a) and d) are the same answer but if that were the case it wouldn’t need to put it twice.
Im going to state 25% is the correct answer, but my guess is pointless unless I don’t know what’s behind doors a), b), c) or d) - because that wouldn’t be a guess, it’d be an informed decision.
1
u/willwao Jul 01 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comments, I hope I was able to address your concerns but it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/KantDidYourMom doesn't read books Jun 28 '23
The answer can only be either A, B, C, or D. The percentage numbers are meaningless. If you were to answer this question randomly, you have a 1 in 4 chance of getting it right. This also assumes that A and D are different answers despite them having the same context, so only one of them can be right. I feel like this post and the responses are gaslighting me.
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment here for my take on this, I could really use some critical feedbacks
1
Jun 28 '23
Imo the answer is 25%.
"Random" is the key word. If you were blindfolded and didn't know the possible answers you have 25% chance of choosing correctly.
The 50% is deceiving because 50% of the options are the same. But it can't be 50% because if you think about the options you have 3 possible answers and won't choose randomly.
1
u/willwao Jul 01 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comments, I hope I was able to address some of your concerns but it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/KOD10107 Jun 30 '23
I think that the correct answer in this situation is not obvious in the question, I’ve seen the comments about it being a paradox, but the real answer is actually just not picking an option, because all of the options are incorrect therefore making the question unanswerable, and the only way to win this game is by not playing
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Search for my comment for my take which i think summarizes the general consensus albeit without the paradoxes (hopefully), but it's in need of critical feedbacks
1
u/Neat-Sprinkles-4875 Jul 02 '23
The answer is 0%. None of these answers can be correct.
1
u/willwao Jul 02 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comments to see if it matches up with your thought process, it can really use some critical feedback too
1
u/TheSmokingHorse Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23
The answer is 33%. Here’s why.
As many others have pointed out, the wording of the question and the answers provided sets it up as a paradoxic and therefore, an unsolvable multiple choice question.
However, if we consider the possibility that the question is not actually a multiple choice question (meaning that the right answer is not selected by choosing one of those four options), but rather, the question is a non-multiple choice question about calculating the probability of selecting the correct answer for a multiple choice question, the paradox suddenly disappears. We know that a random question with a random set of four answers, of which two are the same, results in a probability of randomly selecting the correct answer being 33%.
For a more detailed proof, we can take the answers provided as an example and construct the following arguments:
If the answer is ‘25%’, there is a 2/4 chance of getting the answer correct when selecting an answer at random.
If the answer is ‘60%’, there is a 1/4 chance of getting the answer correct when selecting an answer at random.
If the answer is ‘50%’, there is a 1/4 chance of getting the answer correct when selecting an answer at random.
We can calculate the probability by averaging the numerators of the arguments: (2 + 1 + 1) / 3 = 1.33
As shown, the probability is 1.33/4, which is 33%.
1
u/willwao Jul 17 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comments and see how it compares to yours; I can use some critical feedbacks.
1
u/Substantial-Rain-602 Jul 19 '23
25%
The answer choices are: a) b) c) d)
There are 4 choices. You RANDOMLY pick 1 choice. You pick 1 of 4. 1 of 4 is 1/4. 1/4 is equal to 25/100. 25/100 is equal to 25%.
Your answer is 25%.
1
u/willwao Jul 19 '23
Search for my attempt here in the comment and see how it compares to yours, I can use some critical feedbacks too
1
u/Substantial-Rain-602 Jul 19 '23
Your suggested solution removes random selection.
Suppose the same question was asked and all of the values were covered up and to had to randomly select 1 of 4 unknown numbers. The probability would be 25%. It doesn’t matter that the values are shown. You can still ONLY pick 1 of 4 choices and you have to do so randomly.
The only way that you arrive at 50% is if you remove the randomness. 50% is the actuality.
Suppose you flip a quarter 10 times. 4 times it lands on heads. 6 times it lands on tails. If I ask what is the probability that you will get tails when you flip the quarter, it is 1/2 or 50% of the time because there are 2 possibilities. Just because you did a series of 10 flips and 60% of the time it landed on tails doesn’t the probability. The probability is still 50%. The actuality of your series is 60%.
1
u/alex123444555 Jun 28 '23
It's 1 out of 4, so 1/4 is the answer. However, since there are two 1/4s, the correct answer is 1/2. However, under the assumption that 1/4 is the correct answer, the correct answer of 1/2 is meaningful, so 1/2 is not the correct answer. If 1/4 is correct, 1/2 is correct, and if 1/2 is correct, 1/4 must be correct, so based on the logic that there must be one correct answer, 1/4 and 1/2 not all correct So there is no correct answer because there is no example with a 100% probability. Even if there is a 100% answer, 50% is the correct answer, so the correct answer does not come out. This does not seem to be a problem because the problem itself was created using the characteristics of the problem.
2
u/alex123444555 Jun 28 '23
Anyone thoughts? Are my reasoning great?
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
Try comparing them with mine, search for my comment here for my attempt, it's in need of critical feedbacks too
4
u/rajrohit26 Jun 28 '23
Answer is C 50 percent . 25 percent in ideal scenario with no options but here there are two 25 percent, this increasing the chance to give correct response to 50 percent
1
u/Liquid_Magic Jun 28 '23
But then it’s a one in four chance of picking the 50% answer and so on and so on. It’s recursive.
1
u/JNtheWolf Jun 29 '23
Except that if the answer is C, or 50%, the chance of the correct answer being chosen is now 25%, which means it's 50%, which means it's 25%, and it continues to repeat over and over. It's paradoxical, there is no correct answer. The 25%s and the 50% need to be switched in order for it to not be paradoxical.
2
u/ForsakenInspector407 Jun 28 '23
25%, but since there are 2 that are 25%, 50%. C
3
3
2
u/Suspicious-Method-49 Jun 29 '23
No, there are 4 questions 2 of them 25%, so there are 3 answers, 25, 50, 60, so is it 33.333?
1
u/ForsakenInspector407 Jun 29 '23
By that logic it would be 37.5% since there are 2 ways to select 25%. There would be a 50% chance of A and D being correct and 25% chance of B and C
2
2
u/O77V Jun 28 '23
GPT-4:
This is a variation of a well-known paradoxical question. Let's analyze the options:
If the answer is 25%, then there are two options that are 25% (option a and option d), so the probability of picking 25% randomly would be 50%. But 50% is another answer, and it leads to a contradiction.
If the answer is 50%, then there is only one option that is 50% (option c), so the probability of picking 50% randomly would be 25%. But this leads to the first case, and it's also a contradiction.
If the answer is 60%, there is only one option that is 60% (option b), so the probability of picking 60% randomly would be 25%. This does not match the value itself, so this option is incorrect.
This question is a paradox, as none of the provided options can be consistently chosen as the correct answer.
1
u/gekko513 Jun 28 '23
GPT-4 is able to phrase it much better than I am, but the question is also lacking in the definition, as it doesn't state any constraints on possible answers. With the given wording, the answer could be anything, e.g 8%, as there's nothing saying the answer is among the options.
3
u/Every-Tradition-8030 Jun 28 '23
Self-referencing questions tend to do it. Here simpler version:
If you answer this question wrong than you are:
a) wrong
b) right
2
u/Make-A-Con-Save-034 Jun 28 '23
50%, only one answer can be correct meaning that you have a 25% chance to answer correctly, but as there are two 25% options, there’s is a 50% chance of picking 25%, the correct answer
2
Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23
25% because only one option can be registered as a correct answer. Not a paradox
1
u/harlsey Jun 28 '23
The answer is C. Because you’re not picking randomly right now. It’s asking “if” you did, what are the chances you’d be correct? Which is 50%.
1
Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23
My best bet, if I have to give an answer, would be 50%, because if 25% is duplicated, it means that none of them can be the right answer, so we remove both of them, which leaves us with only 2 choices. Therefore, the correct answer is 50%.
1
1
1
u/Rafados47 Jun 28 '23
27.77%
We have 3 unique answers, two with chance 1/4 and one with chance 2/4. So average chance per answer is cca 27.77%
1
u/leukosaraphs Jun 28 '23
The question clearly states what's the chance to pick the right answer. There are two 25%, so the chance to pick one of them is 2 out of 4.
Sooooo C)
1
1
1
u/piraattipate Jun 28 '23
Basically every 1/3 is right because there are two wrong answers and two right ones which are the same. Therefore the right answer should be 33.3333%
1
u/Mathematicus_Rex Jun 28 '23
As what happens with alarmingly high frequency with standardized exams, the correct answer of 0% is not among the options given.
1
u/Jake1279 Jun 28 '23
It's not asking what the correct answer IS, it's asking what the CHANCES are of randomly picking the correct answer. The correct answer is 25%. The chances of randomly picking 25% is 50%, so it's C.
1
1
u/Ace_Plaze Jun 28 '23
if its multible choice then its 25% i think. if its onky one choice then its a 50%
1
1
1
u/S1L3NCE120384 Jun 28 '23
There is no correct answer.
Normally, it would be a 25% chance, but that’s half of the answers, so it would be 50%, but the answer is also 25%, so the answer is 25%, 50% and 75% all at the same time.
1
u/Ok-Name5709 Jun 28 '23
I feel like the question is badly phrased. A more precise alternative in my sense would be: Assuming that the answer to a hypothetical question q3 is contained in the following four possibilities(a,b,c,d), what is the probability of picking the right answer?
It's more complex, perhaps, but less blurry.
1
1
u/GothaCritique Jun 28 '23
Self-reference tends to create such paradoxes.
So "this sentence is false" has no definitive answer.
1
1
Jun 28 '23 edited Sep 29 '25
telephone bright repeat dinosaurs plough abounding literate depend history friendly
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
1
1
u/Heart2Break4 Jun 28 '23
It states “IF you’d pick one of these at random, then what’s the chance it correct?” Well, judging by 2 chances of 25%, which would be the correct answer if you’d choose it at random, chances are in fact 50%. C is your answer
1
1
u/Lordscallywag Jun 28 '23
The problem is, there is no question. If the question is, what are the chances of guessing the right answer to a multiple choice question with 4 answers, the answer is 25%. If the question is ,what are the chances of guessing the right answer to a multiple choice question with 4 answers where 2 of them are the same (and correct) than the answer is 50%. But this is not stated clearly so there is no right answer.
1
1
u/acuterotationpull Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23
your selection isn't what counts, it's what the chance is you pick the correct option. there is 4 options and one of them has the correct option, so the chance of getting the answer right randomly is 25%. that makes the only answer possible 50% because there are two out of four answers that give you the correct option. another way to explain this would be if you are asked to guess a whole number with a range of 4 your odds of guessing the right answer are 25% (their test), but if you are tasked with guessing which number will follow next in a random sequence of four numbers where there are two options for the same number (25, 60, 50, 25) the odds of you getting 25 correctly are 50% (your test).
1
1
1
1
u/Knottanerd Jun 28 '23
I think its trick logic, the simple question is it's asking if you pick at random, random means that the answers are irrelevant it's A, B, C, or D, what the answers specifically say are moot. 4 options only 1 correct answer, 1/4 = .25 or 25%.
1
u/speed150mph Jun 28 '23
C is the correct answer, because I was taught in high school “when in doubt, go with C”
1
1
1
1
1
u/Horny_boy55677 Jun 28 '23
50%
A) It's one of the 25% in which case 50/50 to get the right one
B) 50% because I'm either right or wrong
1
u/glass_apocalypse Jun 28 '23
I mean, technically, this test has 3 available answers. So wouldn't it be a 1/3 chance, or 33%? but that's not an available answer.
1
u/SavSamuShaman Jun 28 '23
It’s up to interpretation. I think the point of this is not to give the correct answer but to see how one TRIES to solve it.
1
u/KnifeBlade_Playz Jun 28 '23
The answer is actually 33.3333333333333% if you didn’t have multiple choice and the abcd were in the question itself
1
u/Travelman44 Jun 28 '23
50%
Because the correct answer is 1/4 (25%).
But which 25%?
Since there are two choices of 25% it is a toss up which is the correct 25%.
Therefore, the true chance is 50% (for picking the correct 25%).
1
1
u/iknet Jun 29 '23
an answer at random seems too random(~0%), but if the options are limited to integer percentages I think 3/101 so ~ 29.7%
1
Jun 29 '23 edited Jun 29 '23
0% is the answer. It never says my answer has to be one of the 4; it only asks what are the chances of getting it correct if one randomly chose from the 4. Or in other words, no matter what is chosen, it's wrong, and so 0% are the chances of getting it right.
1
u/Simono20788 Jun 29 '23
How do they/you want the answer to be given? As an absolute (in which case it would be 50%) or as an option (then you would have to take a punt at either a or d). The ambiguity in the question suggests that the absolute would be correct.
1
u/bwbright Jun 29 '23
All of those answers are incorrect; you have a 33.333333333333333333333333333333333(etc) percent of getting the correct answer.
1
1
1
u/kapsnik ni... Jun 29 '23
It's edited/flawed/unsolvable. The original question asks the probability of picking the correct answer (so you are not forced to pick from the list).
1
u/MadMik799 Jun 29 '23
The answer is zero as there is not question to warrant an answer IE there is nothing to validate your answer as being correct or incorrect! It is nonsense!
1
1
u/botti3333 Jun 29 '23
50 percent.
option a and d are same so we have a total of 3 options to get right in total. apply basic math and 3/4×100 = 75% , which isnt a given option. so 60% is out of the scenario. only left with 25% and 50% so, yea. 50%
1
1
Jun 29 '23
Explanation is simple When some options have same value, it is just collapsing in one (because answer variants is unique set by meaning)
So, there is three choices and probabiliry is 1/3 if there is right answer at all Since there is no 1/3 option, means thete is no right answer at all and probability of randomly choose right andwer is 0, which is consistent, since there is no 0 option
This is not paradox, this is just undifined if there is right answer or not
1
u/Suspicious-Method-49 Jun 29 '23
import solution
If the quiz specifically states that there are two instances of "25%" as separate options, then there is indeed an error in the quiz.
If we consider the options as they are given, we have: a) 25% b) 60% c) 50% d) 25%
Out of these options, there are two instances of "25%". Therefore, the chance of randomly selecting the correct answer is 2 out of 4. Thus, the probability is 2/4, which simplifies to 1/2 or 50%. (ChatGPT said)
1
u/VisualClean7249 Jun 30 '23
33%. We don’t know what the “correct” answer is. The question asks what is the chance you pick the correct answer at random. There are only three possible selections, so whichever option you randomly select, there is a one in three chance it is correct.
1
1
u/Cultural_Occasion185 Jul 12 '23
There are 4 options, a,b,c, or d, but 2 of the options have the same answer, 25%, this makes 25% chance wrong because 2 of 4 options say 25%. What that means is that if 2 of 4 options say 25%, there is a 50% chance you will get 25%, which makes it impossible for the odds of being correct 25%. But there are still two options left, yet picking any of them would still end in being wrong, because there is only one that says 50% and 1 out of 4 is not 50%, and 60% is wrong because 60% is also not 1 out of 4. This results in a paradox, and a paradox has no answer, so that should mean that the answer to this question is 0%.
1
u/Open-Entertainer6031 Jul 14 '23
ITS 25% BECAUSE YOU ARE TO PICK AN ANSWER TO THIS QUESTION AT RANDOM. Either of the 25% works
1
1
u/Few_Manufacturer_747 Jul 23 '23
I would say 50 as 25% is an invalid choice being two choices the same. Therefore you are left with 50 and 60 in which you have a 50 percent chance of answering the question
1
u/Mrawesomepants1 Jul 24 '23
Well jokes on all of you I picked B at random and after reading all the comments is apparently the only wrong answer on here.
1
1
u/anonymus_the_3rd Oct 12 '23
depends on what is considered the "answer" is the answer the letter (ABCD) or the number (25 25 50 60). in the first case its a or d, in the 2nd case a=d so it does not break the test, making it c. answer is c as case 1 no longer makes sense in the case of a MC. case 1 is like a math function that fails the vertical line test
1
1
u/Fragrant_Hippo_2487 Dec 20 '23
The answer is C, it says IF you were to. It doesn’t say pick an answer at random. Right ?
1
Jun 28 '23
50% since there are four options and two are identical
If not, a paradox or free game
I'm going to say 100% for optimism :)
2
u/Successful-aditya Jun 28 '23
Since two are identical it gets consideration of 1 option it means we have visible 3 option in whicb 1 might be correct so 1/3×100 = 33.334 %
2
Jun 28 '23
So I did wonder this but that came down to the particulars of the answer being "25 25" or "a or b" since there is no question to prompt, to me it's p much unclear how to metric and properly determine an answer at it's most technical level
3
u/Successful-aditya Jun 28 '23
That doesnt seems right i dont know why maybe because it wants to know how many percent or chance i dont think they are different 25 %'s like a or b
2
Jun 28 '23
I agree your way definitely sounds more probable! The metric makes sense and if my life was on it I would still take your paradigm over the latter
I just ruminate on details with genie bottle questions LOL
3
u/Successful-aditya Jun 28 '23
This kind of questions can never have same or perfect answer but we can definitely find the best one so by my opinion i would stand with my answer . It seems more straight forward and onpoint . All this is my opinion you can have different views upon that as well
1
u/willwao Jun 30 '23
I like your spirit, search for my attempt here in the comments, I can use some critical feedbacks
2
1
u/Superb_Excitement_67 Jun 28 '23
Something is not a question just because it says it is a question. Something is not a duck just because you say it is a duck.
The text tells you a question about some other question, but there is no other question to begin with. Just because the text says that this is "Question 3" doesn't magically make it a question. So it is just a bunch of confusing bullshit.
It is very simple, but I guess I have never seen this explanation ever when people talk about that problem.
Question 4: screw you.
Now what is the right answer to question 4?
1
u/Ok-Name5709 Jun 28 '23
That's why I am simply unable to comprehend the whole paradox thing. Like there are no questions in the first place!
They say "If you pick an answer to this question" but which question ?
1
1
1
u/PierG1 Jun 28 '23
I’m gonna pick 25%.
The question ask you to pick at random, and that pretty much means that you have to pick as if you don’t know what each choice is or mean.
So if all the answers are a)? b)? …., and there are four of them, it’s 25%.
0
u/stroganoffbeeef Jun 28 '23
but dont u actually have a 1 in 3 chance? U have 3 eligible answers to choose so at random its 1 in 3 shot?
1
u/UnusualDisturbance Jun 28 '23
Not really, there are 4 answers but 3 are unique. This means that if chosen at random, the non-unique one has a higher probabilty to be chosen than the others: 1/4 vs 1/4 vs 2/4.
1
u/Honeymunchko Jun 28 '23
Yeh and if you do the fraction you just listed its 1/3
2
u/UnusualDisturbance Jun 28 '23
If you have a bowl of 99 green skittles and 1 red skittle, the odds of taking the red one is not 1/2, it's 1/100.
In a pool of 4 answers where there is one duplicate answer, the chance of taking the duplicate answer is not 1/3, it is 2/4.
1
u/PierG1 Jun 28 '23
No, because a and d, while being the same answer, are still two different answers.
1
u/Vharkhan Jun 28 '23
That’s my thinking. You have a 33.3% chance
1
Jun 28 '23
if it's not the 25% choices you have 1/4 chance of landing on the correct answer if it exists, but that makes the correct answer 25% which is a contradiction.
0
u/Successful-aditya Jun 28 '23
Each of the options must have different probablity i would go with either 25% or 50%
0
0
u/Weltgerichtchen Jun 28 '23
It's c, 50% And now listen... If I pick random, it's 25% (a and d), so the chance to pick the correct answer to THAT QUESTION is c), 50%. Because to pick c) has a chance of 25% which is the answer of 2, so the half of my options. So it's c). a) and d) is not the answer

•
u/AutoModerator Jun 28 '23
Thank you for your submission. Please make sure your answers are properly marked with the spoiler function. This can be done with the spoiler button, but if you are in markdown mode you would simply use >!text goes here!<
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.