r/coding • • Oct 19 '15

Online programming challenges for hobbyists and job hunters that want to show off their performances to tech companies

http://devdraft.com?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=coding&utm_campaign=oct2015
13 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

28

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

Did anyone actually follow the link before upvoting? This is literally spam - it even has the referral tags in the url!

/u/devdraft's (huh, I wonder how you decided on such an original name) sole purpose is to spam and promote this website.

Worse is the fact that I see no way this site is any different than any other coding test sites. The landing page gives no suggestion to how this is new or different or anything other than a bunch of academic type questions that make novice programmers feel good about themselves.

The type of questions these sites can handle are typically extremely limited in scope - often very academic in nature. While I think these types of questions are great for students or young programmers, I absolutely cannot stand when they get the "job hunter" spin on them.

While I know a lot of people hate whiteboard challenges, they are very good for one thing - allowing employers to have control over the questions and being able to see how a person works through a problem. It's not always about writing code that passes unit tests (which is important), but sometimes how you think about the problem.

3

u/fiercekittenz Oct 19 '15

Wholeheartedly agree. My company wants to start using a site similar to this to test candidates. I looked it over, and I just didn't see the purpose other than weeding out people who don't care enough to do a pop quiz. You can cheat on these things so easily. There has to be a better way of screening candidates than this. I get nothing from it.

-6

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

Hi, DevDraft challenges are much more than a pop quiz. We maintain high quality bar for technical content. The questions are typically more difficult than a whiteboard interview.

It may seem at the first sight that it is easy to cheat, but it is not the case actually. Aside from various plagiarism detection checks, the tech challenges are quite complex and take an effort to solve. Sure you can hire someone to solve it for you, but then what's the point? In any case, we have not seen anyone yet who faked it, got a job interview and got hired.

4

u/fiercekittenz Oct 19 '15

I'm certain you have taken cheats into consideration; however, it should be noted that these are outdated mechanics for interviewing technical people. Sure, they're great for new grads who have this kind of information fresh on their minds, but for senior people I much prefer architecture questions, debugging situations, and actually hearing about their projects. Most of the time sites like yours provide problems that, while technically challenging, provide zero context to the job the person is actually applying for. I'll take the most basic example -- atoi(). People still ask for this in whiteboarding. Why? It's in every interview tip book out there, and does not provide me with any insight as to whether or not the candidate can solve problems related to the job. There are also a lot of questions on these sites that rely far too much on "tricks" and "gotchas" to solve them. There's a brute force method and a tricky method for solving the question.

In short, companies may miss out on extremely talented candidates just because they can't answer a tricky question on a tricky coder website pimping itself on Reddit for more views.

0

u/devdraft Oct 26 '15

"In short, companies may miss out on extremely talented candidates just because they can't answer a tricky question "

On the other hand, companies may miss out on unique talent if they just look at resume / past projects. Most of resumes get lost in the shuffle before they get evaluated by a human.

DevDraft challenge is not just a quiz. Take a look for yourself.

6

u/shaggorama Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

So basically this is just another hackerrank or topcoder? Sorry buddy but I think you're a little late to the party with this idea.

-6

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Hi, DevDraft model is different from hackerrank / topcoder. We create coding challenge in order to connect devs with awesome companies. This is not a competition per say with one winner taking all. We look deep into code and uncover multiple dimensions of code performance; then companies custom select these dimensions in their search filter and connect with devs. Hope this provides some clarity. We welcome you to participate in the upcoming draft.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

We look deep into code and uncover multiple dimensions of code performance; then companies custom select these dimensions in their search filter and connect with devs.

Can you elaborate on what this actually is?

We look deep into code

What does this involve?

uncover multiple dimensions of code performance

performance is a vague term here. Are you referring to benchmarked optimized code? Or some other form of "performance"?

-2

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

We judge code based on qualification metrics. We allow companies to prioritize different metrics for the position they're looking to fill. For example, most jobs require a candidate with a good score in code correctness and attention to detail, while positions where efficiency is critical are suited for a candidate with a high advanced CS metric.

We test code using extensive test cases. When we say performance we refer to the advanced CS metric, which is improved by making good choices in algorithms and data structures.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

That still doesn't really answer my question - and based on the downvotes, it doesn't really answer this sub's question either.

You have a very week argument about how you are any better that your competitors or why people would be willing to take coding tests that the general consensus agree are a poor way to measure the effectiveness of developers.

I've done the other sites and at the end of the day it just feels like a gimmick with academic questions and some bullshit metrics to judge us on. From the sounds of your answer, it seems like I'll get marked down on the same bullshit metrics.

Even worse is the "one test" fits all approach. As you've said companies can request a bunch of different metrics to rank against. How can I as a developer (1) know what I'm being evaluated on and (2) actually write code that meets a wide and potentially conflicting set of requirements.

For example, myself and most developers can write clean, readable, maintainable code and highly optimized code - but optimization often throughs the prior to the side. This is how nearly every other site I've used has been and I don't see how this is any different in that critical (and core) regard.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

1

u/devdraft Oct 26 '15

Thanks for the link

1

u/devdraft Oct 26 '15 edited Oct 29 '15

Hey guys,

Thanks to all who've given the challenge a shot. The submissions deadline is 10/28 (updated from 10/27) at 6am pdt. The results will be made available on 11/2.

Happy drafting!

Regards, DevDraft Team

1

u/nycerine Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

There is already Open Kattis for that, with added points and university competitions. :)

1

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Hi, are you referring to this site: open.kattis.com? The URL that you provided does not work.

1

u/nycerine Oct 19 '15

Ah yes, thanks for the correction - I don't know why I appended a .org.

1

u/schm0 Oct 19 '15

Seems like this type of thing would favor a senior dev or someone with more experience over a junior dev or someone with limited experience... Doesn't really help someone like me (in the latter category) land a job.

-3

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Hi, actually we have quite a bit of participants that are junior devs with limited experience. DevDraft was built to give devs with limited experience a push in terms of visibility. With respect to getting contacted by companies, based on past drafts we see that devs with more experience get contacted more often. It all really depends on what types of companies come in to hire in a given draft and their requirements. We've diversified participating companies and now see devs with limited experience getting contacted more often.

We can not guarantee that you'll get contacted if you participate. But what we can guarantee is that if you do well on the challenge, we'll work hard to champion you in front of participating companies. Specifically, we'll provide personal recommendations to participating companies citing your strengths in terms of how they relate to company's requirements.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

DevDraft was built to give devs with limited experience a push in terms of visibility

You should really, really be marketing around this point exactly.

I think the reason myself and so many other developers are reacting badly to this is because the site doesn't solve a problem for most of us since most of us aren't junior devs.

I think you're trying to attack too broad of an audience and you really need to consider revamping your marketing to convey exactly what you and sites similar to you are trying to do (use simple tests to provide some sort of credibility for developers who don't have a resume to lean on).

1

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Appreciate your feedback. This is why we built DevDraft in the first place, which is to give more visibility to devs with limited experience. Over time though we've seen strong interest from more senior devs. Specifically, about 40% of our finalists in the last couple of drafts (those who complete the challenge) have 5+ years of experience in the industry. There are those with 10+ years of experience.

Great feedback, I passed it to the team.

1

u/ynori7 Oct 19 '15

Nice design on the website.

-1

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Thanks!

1

u/c-_-i Oct 19 '15

How can you judge someone on just one question ?

-3

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

There are typically 4 - 5 questions with various depth. Each question focuses on different aspects of software engineering. The goal of this is to get devs connected with awesome companies.

2

u/tdefarbus Oct 19 '15

Before you knock it, try it. For senior devs, this might not be your thing but junior devs really like it. I found a post from a past participant who finds it useful: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/3jn6l9/devdraft_promised_rust_support_for_the_september/

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

[deleted]

-6

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

Good point; I think DevDraft provides value to someone who codes a lot on GitHub. We maintain a high tech bar for DevDraft code challenges (you can see it by yourself). By completing a challenge you'd get an opportunity to connect with many companies that respect the high tech bar.

I think the combination of GitHub repos and a DevDraft challenge would make for a stronger case. BTW, the many devs already sign up on DevDraft via their GitHub accounts and present their GitHub repos to companies during interviews.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15 edited Oct 19 '15

By completing a challenge you'd get an opportunity to connect with many companies that respect the high tech bar.

I think the one thing you're failing to address is if that opportunity is any better than what currently exists for getting an opportunity.

When I apply to a job with a resume, I am applying to a position that I know is looking for me. They are quite literally saying, "Here's exactly what we need".

With your site, it sounds like I need to complete some sort of test just to have an opportunity to even be seen by some company. I don't even know if you have a job available for me.

You seem to have a great product from the business side (you solve a business need), but it seems like you've very much overlooked what's important to developers.

EDIT: I should also add that I've notice you seems to be marketing your value proposition as "connecting developers to awesome companies". I think this is missing the mark on what developer (any job hunter wants). I don't care that you can connect me to "awesome" companies. I evaluate "awesome" and can do that myself. What I really want to know is how your site is going to help me increase my chances of getting a job.

1

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Thanks for the feedback! Appreciate it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

[deleted]

-6

u/devdraft Oct 19 '15

Sorry that you feel this way. Can you please elaborate?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15

[deleted]

0

u/devdraft Oct 26 '15

Hi,

Quick review of your account shows the following:

1 link karma -4 comment karma

Please provide constructive feedback.

Regards, DevDraft Team