r/coding • u/creaturefeature16 • 6d ago
no, code is not "cheap"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66O6zpPpG5g26
u/ModernRonin
6d ago
•
Bad code has always been cheap. Offshoring of software development proved it beyond any shadow of a doubt. And today it's even cheaper that it was before, with LLMs writing nearly endless amounts of bad code.
Believing that you can fire all your Coders and replace them with an LLM is:
Misunderstanding what an LLM actually is (hint: not conscious, therefore not capable of actual reasoning)
Falling prey to the Doorman Fallacy.
And of course, dipshit Executards in the C-Suite have done both of the above - to a remarkably excessive degree! Because they have never been either smart, or technologically literate.
2
u/Savetheokami 5d ago
Great post. The last part about not being in a hurry because it’s your life’s work is a bit out of touch though when it comes to delivering efficiency to hit quotas. For some people if they don’t reduce costs and/or address inefficiencies quick enough they are out on the street without a job which impacts their livelihood. Whether that is right or wrong is subjective.
2
u/chroma_shift 5d ago
What if you're an indian company offshoring to USA?
1
u/ModernRonin 5d ago
Still depends a hell of a lot on the people you pick. There definitely are talented SW.Engs in India. But when US corpos intentionally try and pick the cheapest people in India? It's not very ikely they're going to get top-tier talent.
Same thing happens when an company from India hires inside the USA. Are they going for the lowest price employee? Then it's not very likely they're going to get high quality.
2
u/chroma_shift 5d ago
That is a very solid point :)
I totally agree with prices being relative to location, and as usual, higher quality will mean higher prices-5
u/Serengade26 6d ago
You don't need consciousness to approximate the function of symbolic reasoning to be economically useful
1
u/ModernRonin 5d ago
Actually, I agree with you. For whatever your point is worth.
But I think my point also stands. Something conscious, and capable of reasoning, is required to do all the work that a SWEng does.
19
u/conicalanamorphosis 6d ago
For people that don't work in the tech space, it's important to understand the cost of the code is almost never a large factor in technology choice, it gets overwhelmed by other systems costs. If cheap or free worked in technology the way it works for, as an example, basic consumer goods, Microsoft would have been crushed by Linux nearly 2 decades ago and Oracle would never have gotten past Postgres. You can argue over whether or not Linux is better than MS or Postgres is better than Oracle, but the reality is neither product base cost nor even quality is the most important factor in these decisions. It always comes back to some combination of total cost of ownership (the lifetime cost of a system) and the ability to support and maintain the system (whether vendor support contract or in-house). As an example, if I can have MS support a product for less than the cost of hiring my own people to support a "free" version of the product, it's not a difficult decision. Even if hiring my own people to support the product is cheaper, I would still have to find them and that isn't always possible.
7
u/wnoise 6d ago
It mostly comes down to bribes and network effects, with TCO used as obfuscation to cover that up.
7
u/TimMensch 6d ago
Bribes. Yes. Exactly.
Oracle is the worse choice by effectively all measures, including support costs. Especially support costs.
Postgres just doesn't have salesmen taking executives to fancy restaurants or golf...
2
u/chigunfingy 1d ago
In terms of Software Engineering the building of a thing is about 10% of the cost, most of the rest of it goes to maintenance. Vibe coded slop, with minimal review that “just works”. Is extremely hard to maintain.
-8
u/HasFiveVowels 6d ago
The parallel between what LLMs generate and "a gibberish book" simply doesn’t hold water. Code is cheap. Words are cheap. Good stories and good code have become dramatically less expensive this past year or two. You’re saying "code is cheap but intelligence is expensive" but intelligence per dollar is skyrocketing. The rest of the argument amounts to "context is important" but providing sufficient context is a problem is actively being solved.
0
u/drifterpreneurs 6d ago edited 6d ago
I think this is kinda more of a space for actual developers ( subject matter experts) not vibe coders.
No offense, however - what would you know as a vibe coder (non-technical individual)?
The reason, you sound like a 100% vibe coder that doesn't know how to read, understand or write code.
Where's the value within regards towards writing your opinion in a developer space?
Does Ai informing us about science or medicine turn us into doctors or scientists? No, it doesn't, your opinion is null & void.
0
4
u/creaturefeature16 6d ago •
"Code is cheap" and "code is free" has been a relentless slogan which has propagated across the industry ever since generative code became a thing. Outside of a catchphrase for social media posts, I don't think it really holds up under scrutiny and when doing real work.