I wanted to know what my subscription actually delivered against the discounted credit offer I was shown, rather than compare plan marketing pages.
For my 8–14 November usage, the $500/month OpenAI plan corresponds to roughly $5,010/month of discounted Codex top-ups, or $10,698–$13,456/month at current API prices for the eligible recorded models. Those are different accounting systems. The API number is a counterfactual estimate, not a bill I paid.
WHAT I MEASURED
The wider report covers 21 September–15 November 2026: 850,097 router records, 9 providers and 56 provider/model routes. There are 285.89 billion measured input-plus-output tokens, mostly repeated cached context, not unique content. The workload is coding-agent use, not a controlled model-quality benchmark.
For the last seven complete Sydney days, native OpenAI usage works out to 53,341 Codex Standard credit-equivalents. My extra-credit balance was unchanged across that interval. Multiplying by 365.25 / 12 / 7 gives 231,937 credit-equivalents per average month. That is observed use projected forward, not a guaranteed monthly allowance or a claim of unlimited access.
THE THREE COST COMPARISONS
• Subscription: $500/month, the confirmed current plan price.
• Credit offer: 25,000 credits for $540 if the 40% bundle discount and additional 10% auto-reload discount stack. That values this usage at about $5,010/month, around 10× the subscription price. Stacking was NOT verified at checkout. With only the 40% discount, the comparison is about $5,566/month.
• API replay: $10,698–$13,456/month, using recorded model/context lengths and current Standard rates. The upper sensitivity assumes cache-write premiums the ledger did not meter separately. Daybreak, images, tools and failed/missing usage are excluded from this API subset.
The plan changed from $200 to $500 on 26 October Sydney time, and a promotional credit grant existed earlier in the history. I am not describing the whole September–November window as subscription-only. Unknown historical speed-tier surcharges are also outside the API reconstruction.
WHAT CHANGED OVER TIME
Holding current prices fixed, Terra 6.1's modeled dollars per million tokens fell 8.9%, alongside input cache hits improving from 98.27% to 99.02%.
Sol 6.1 went the other way: +33.6% per million, even though cache hits improved from 97.49% to 98.78%. The share of its input in requests above 272k tokens went from 0% to 60.73%, activating long-context API pricing; output share also increased. These compare first/last blocks of seven complete active days, which are not necessarily consecutive calendar days.
So “my cache hit rate improved” does not by itself mean “my workload got cheaper.” These are workload trends, not evidence that the vendor raised prices during the period.
HOW THE OTHER PROVIDERS FIT
At one common numerical mix — 98.73% of input cached, output 0.164% of all tokens — the current short-context price scenarios per million total tokens are:
• DeepSeek 1017 on PrimeIntellect: $0.0043.
• DeepSeek direct: $0.0058 off-peak / $0.0117 peak.
• OpenAI Luna: $0.0119; Terra 6.1: $0.0702; Sol 6.1: $0.1403; Astra: $1.1946.
• Anthropic Opus 5.5 API: $0.2807.
OpenRouter includes a modeled 5.5% funding fee. These are arithmetic price scenarios, NOT proof those models achieve equivalent quality, tokenization, context fit, cache reuse or latency. The PrimeIntellect scenario is not retroactively assigned to old OpenRouter requests.
Claude's shared annual Team billing and missing cache-read/write breakdown prevent an honest exact personal subscription savings multiple. Credit-only Fable usage is kept separate. Cursor Credits Grok is also separate from Grok OAuth; Shannon variants and free routes are not pooled into paid model claims.
METHOD / LIMITS
The analysis reads numeric usage only, deduplicates exact events and preserves legitimate cross-provider failover rows. Input includes cached input. Reasoning is already part of output and is not added again. Failed/aborted requests, provider-estimated input and missing usage are excluded from the main totals; failed requests may still cost money. HTTP200 does not prove a coding task succeeded. Funding/top-ups are not the same as inference consumption.
I used AI assistance to analyze and chart the aggregates and draft this write-up. The shared figures contain no conversations, account identifiers, credentials or invoice links. This is a personal workload study, not a general savings guarantee.
Pricing sources (15 Nov 2026 snapshot):
https://developers.openai.com/api/docs/pricing
https://learn.chatgpt.com/docs/pricing#token-rates
https://api-docs.deepseek.com/quick_start/pricing/
https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/about-claude/pricing
https://openrouter.ai/pricing