r/codex • • 2d ago

Question Codex App or Cli

I've been using the cli for a while and wondering if any of you guys prefer the app? I heard that the app lacks some features but is that still true?

4 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

7

u/Huntware 2d ago

Third option: any other harness of your choice.

I prefer something agnostic so I can swap models and providers, and to keep the chats and memory locally.

I'm using Openchamber (based on Opencode v2) so the codemode saves tokens while it has every MCP and skill available. It uses them on demand! Same as Pi. And the cache hits still over 98% on long tasks.

PS. I've used ChatGPT app more than CLI, and the RAM usage is quite a lot for my office desktop PC...

4

u/ramishka 2d ago edited 2d ago

CLI all the way. I have quite a lot of customizations done to my terminal with iTerm , Oh My Zsh, etc, and the cli fits natively wIth my working style. And i multitask a lot with this setup.

1

u/EmbeddedSwDev 2d ago

I believe you would love Oh My Pi then

3

u/dvduval 2d ago

I actually have Claude code using the codex cli. This makes for a better communication between the agents. I still use codex directly for many things too

2

u/Dangerous-Cheek-230 2d ago

I have not noticed any functionality missing in the app. I think it is better.

0

u/FullBar613 2d ago

Hows the ssd excessive writes issue?

3

u/Dangerous-Cheek-230 2d ago

I am not aware of such issue. How could we check if such problem exists?

2

u/bitconvoy 2d ago

I’m on Linux and I complained a lot about the lack of the official UI app on this platform. Then they finally released it and … I’m still on the cli. There’s just nothing in the UI app that I miss in the cli.

I recently started to build devcontainers for specific tasks (often with different OAI accounts and got repos) and use the cli in them on YOLO mode. I’m not sure this is doable in the App.

2

u/Huge-Asparagus891 2d ago

CLI just feels more complicated for no reason to me. I'd pick app

1

u/Thyrfing89 2d ago

CLI feels to easy for no reason for me, pointless with an app.

1

u/GreenFuturesMatter 2d ago

Cli is the way. Don’t be afraid of terminal

1

u/Alternative_Equal864 2d ago

cli because i feel like a crazy hacker

1

u/jwink3101 2d ago

I am only a hobby developer but I use both:

  • Home: App for real work and CLI when I want to quickly drop in to a directory, make a small change, and be done

  • Remote (from work): I use the CLI on my VPS usually in a GNU Screen session either directly or inside Jupyter Lab.

I will also occasionally use pi.dev when I want to play with a different model (via openrouter) but since that costs money on top of my ChatGPT subscription, it is more rare.

1

u/HookedHavoc 2d ago

Codex Cli inside Rex

1

u/verycoldpenguins 2d ago

I use the cli, remote-control to the app or computer. There are definitely restrictions there which are not present if you are just app, or just cli.

Mostly I don't mind because I also use claude in the same way with similar restrictions.

The ability for me to easily copy/paste and move between mobile and computer makes it still advantageous to me, but I mention it in case you are considering it as a half-way house

1

u/lowkeynull 2d ago

i think it depends on how you work. cli is nicer if you live in the terminal, the app is easier when you're running a few threads side by side and want to review diffs

1

u/mettavestor 2d ago

These days I'm in Claude Code for almost everything, but when I do use Codex it's the CLI and for adversarial review. The cli is great for tool orchestration and scripting.

What made you curious about the app? Something specific you're missing?

1

u/chrislauinger 2d ago

I started using paseo. Have codex pro and claude pro. https://paseo.sh/

1

u/Specialist-Royal4408 2d ago

CLI = Less RAM ❤️

1

u/DukeSlammington 3h ago

I might be a scrub, but I switched to the app because viewing UI mockups was a lot easier. When I’m making a new feature I like asking for a few example mockups first before we implement.