r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 24 '24

Other Ban of Winston_Wilhelmus

2 Upvotes

u/Winston_Wilhelmus, is banned for a period of 21 days from all CMHOC platforms in accordance with section 9(B)-Harassment: directing or targeting toxicity towards a person or a group of people in the simulation. (i) Harassment can include hunting down the posts of an individual outside the simulation in order to humiliate or berate them; the constant picking on or pestering of an individual; bullying; as well as other things.

As this is a ban Under 1 Month, no Parole Period is Applicable, and no probation period is applicable.

Per Section 14, multiple aggravating factors were considered such as

(i) committing multiple offences simultaneously

(v) prior records of poor conduct

(vi) encouraging or leading others in committing offences

The user may contest the punishment to the Ban and Appeals Commission within 7 days (By December 1, 2024).


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 25 '24

Ban of FreedomCanada2025

1 Upvotes

u/FreedomCanada2025, is banned for a period of 7 days from all CMHOC platforms in accordance with section 11(b) of the CMHoC Code of Conduct. Which is a 3rd tier and States: Being overly abrasive, promoting toxicity, engaging in flame baiting, or creating a hostile environment

As this is a ban Under 1 Month, no Parole Period is Applicable, and no probation period is applicable.

This Ban is moved to a Tier 2 as a result of Section 13(a)(iii)Subsequent tier 3 offences may be considered Tier 2 offences in their own right.

This is due to the member having several 3rd tier offenses to their name.

The user may contest the punishment to the Ban and Appeals Commission within 7 days (By December 1, 2024).


r/cmhocmeta • • Mar 24 '24

Town Hall Ban of /u/Sephronar - 30 Days

1 Upvotes

It has come to my attention recently that Artifical Intelligence was used in the creation of several campaign posts attributed to /u/Sephronar.
Upon investigation, I found that the weight of the evidence was too much to ignore. This evidence can be found Here. AI usage is not taken lightly, and I am setting a precedent of 0 tolerance for AI usage. I'm not a fan of taking actions without 10000% certainty, but in this situation every piece of evidence we could possible have points to it being AI.
Therefore, with the powers vested in me as Head Moderator:

I find that /u/Sephronar is in violation of Tier 3 offenses (b) and (c), namely creating a hostile environment, creating a negative atmosphere within the community and the pirate party, as well as the fact that these actions had serious negative rammifcations for the pirate party as a whole. The use of AI resulted in increased tension and toxicity within the sim, and the perpetrator of this controversy bares responsibility. While a tier 3 offense on its own would not warrant more than a mute- I find there are several aggravating factors as listed in our CoC. I find these factors to be the following:
(I) committing multiple offences simultaneously
(II) breaching a position of trust within the simulation
(IV) the presence of severe harm caused by the offence in question
(VI) encouraging or leading others in committing offences
In addition, /u/Sephronar repeatedly lied to the moderators of the simulation, which leads me to this conclusion:
Therefore I am planning on instituting a ban from both the discord and servers for a period not to exceed 30 days. Wanuke shall issue a statement about how this impacts the campaign. Please remove this user from all servers within 48 hours.
The moderation team, after numerous discussions, has come to a consensus on this. We respect your right to disagree, but we ask that you do so respectfully.

It is important to note- CMHOC is not a court. We do not have the obligation of proving beyond a reasonable doubt. It is in my opinion that the weight of this evidence, although lacking in direct confirmation, is too strong to dismiss. A lack of action tells the public that this behavior cannot and will not be punished. Thank you


r/cmhocmeta • • Apr 09 '26

Hello from your Head Moderator

0 Upvotes

Members and Guests of CMHoC,

Thank you to the community for electing me as your Head Moderator.

Canon Reset and Continuity

The canon cutoff has been established as March 24th. Mark Carney has resigned for personal health reasons (akin to Shinzo Abe's reasons for resigning), along with the leaders of all major parties. All canon events, legislation, and actions prior to that date are recognized; anything occurring after that date that has not been formally adjudicated is under review. One of my first tasks will be to conduct a thorough audit of the canon record to confirm what stands, what requires clarification, and where any gaps exist.

Federal Election

We are looking to hold a federal election soon. This is subject to the Electoral Moderator's jurisdiction and timeline — I will not be stepping into that process. However, as Head Moderator, I will be coordinating with the Electoral Moderator to ensure that the canon groundwork on my end is in order. Specifically:

  • Governor General actions — Under Section 39(1)(a), I will be responsible for the dissolution of Parliament in canon and the commissioning of a new government following election results, in accordance with the Conventions of the Westminster system.

  • Swearing in — Under Section 39(1)(c), all oaths and swearing in relating to the federal cabinet and Privy Council for Canada will be handled promptly once a new government is formed.

Community Management and Conduct

A healthy simulation depends on a healthy community. Bans, appeals, community management, and regulation of conduct fall under this office. I intend to:

  • Review any outstanding ban appeals or conduct matters.

  • Ensure that community standards are clear, consistent, and fairly enforced.

  • Maintain an open line of communication with the membership on moderation decisions where appropriate.

Recruitment and Onboarding

Growing and sustaining CMHoC requires bringing in new members and giving them the tools to participate meaningfully. Recruitment and onboarding are within my mandate. I plan to:

  • Review and improve onboarding materials so new members can get up to speed quickly.

  • Explore outreach strategies to attract new participants to the simulation.

  • Ensure new members are welcomed and integrated into the community effectively.

Record Keeping

Under Section 39(1)(i), record keeping in relation to all subjects is a core duty. I will be working to ensure that records are properly maintained and accessible. Something that hasn't been done in a long time.

Foreign Relations

The foreign relations of the simulation to any other simulation, person, or organization are within my jurisdiction. I will be reviewing our current external relationships and considering how best to engage with the broader model parliament community.

What This Post Is Not

I want to be clear: this post is about the steps forward within the Head Moderator's mandate. I respect the exclusive jurisdictions of the Electoral Moderator and the Parliamentary Moderator under the Meta Constitution, and I will not be encroaching on their areas of responsibility. You elected them to do their job, I shall do mine. The election timeline and mechanics are for the Electoral Moderator to determine. Parliamentary procedure and House business are for the Parliamentary Moderator. I am here to do my job, nothing more, nothing less.

Open Door

My approach to this office will be grounded in transparency, collaboration, and respect for the Meta Constitution. I look forward to bringing some changes to the Meta Constitution after the weekend. In the meantime, if you have questions, concerns, or ideas that fall within the Head Moderator's mandate, I encourage you to reach out. This simulation belongs to all of us, and I look forward to working with the community to move CMHoC forward.


r/cmhocmeta • • May 03 '18

Resignation from all meta positions

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 23 '24

Petition: Continuing to ensure the nonpartisan nature of petitions

0 Upvotes

The Conservative Party's leader has begun weaponizing petitions for her and her party's own benefit. By painting the entire moderation team, composed of people from all across the political spectrum, as a biased entity specifically out to get them, they are degrading trust in cmhoc's institutions. This petition aims to temporarily ban their leader from creating new petitions for one month following its passage.


r/cmhocmeta • • Aug 13 '19

Suggestion CMHOC Meta: A Modest Proposal.

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 24 '24

Ban and Appeals Commission Decision - In the matter of the ban of /u/Winston_Wilhelmus

0 Upvotes

The Ban and Appeals Commission received an appeal by /u/Winston_Wilhelmus against his 21 day ban for a Code of Conduct violation.

The judgment of /u/Dyslexic_Alex, /u/model-wanuke and /u/Chishti351 was delivered by /u/model-wanuke.

/u/WonderOverYander recused himself from the judgement.


Judgement

Winston is found guilty of breaking the code of conduct under section 9. c (i) and 9. d for his jokes about saying a slur and changing a members name to match a slur. We uphold the Decision of the Head Moderator that the party is guilty of the Offences he was punished for, and therefore refuse the application.

Sentencing

The Commission disagrees with the sentence imposed by the Head Mod, and pursuant to our powers under section 20.2(6)(b) of the Code of Conduct Modifies it.

The user in question has a half decade long history of Poor conduct on other political simulations (See Citations), under section 14(a)(v) of the code of conduct prior poor conduct is an aggravating factor in sentencing.The user has a long track record of similar behaviour, getting banned from other sims for it, then jumping into the next sim and repeating the behaviour.

This includes an incident in July of 2022 (Appeal of Ban into WW, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on July 1, 2022), when he supposedly "he pledged to act better", and then was then permenently banned from AustraliaSim (Permanent ban of WW, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on September 11, 2022) for high level abuse.

Given the Repeated bans, appeals, agreements with moderation teams then proceeding to break said agreements, and joining of new simulations, and then being banned again for similar offences, repeatedly, it is found that a 21 day ban is not sufficient to reflect the aggravating factor of his prior poor conduct.

The Commission Further agrees with the Reasoning of the Head Moderator under Sections 14(a)(i) - Multiple Offences, and 14(a)vi), Leading others in Committing Offences to treat those as aggravating Factors for Punishment.

Given these aggravating Factors, the Commission finds that a sentence of a permanent ban would therefore be appropriate.

As this is now a permanent ban, the Ban and Appeals Commission, pursuant to the code of conduct further Modifies that the offender may apply for Parole after 6 months (May 24, 2025). If the Offender receives successful parole, they will be subject to a 1 year probation period.

Citations

Ban of WW, Chretien, Mattsthetic (moderation 18/11/2019), /r/ModelNZMeta on November 18, 2019

The ban of Winston_Wilhelmus, /r/ModelNZMeta on August 26, 2022

Ban Announcement - winston_wilhelmus, /r/MHOCMeta, on December 30, 2021

Ban Announcement: Winston_Wilhelmus, /r/MHOCMeta, on September 1, 2022

Various punishments following yesterday., /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on April 20, 2020

RE: WW Appeal May 3 2020, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on May 3, 2020

Ban of WW, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on July 1, 2022

Appeal of Ban into WW, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on July 1, 2022

Permanent ban of WW, /r/AustraliaSimMeta, on September 11, 2022


The Head Moderator is directed to modify /u/Winston_Wilhelmus's ban to be Permenent.

/u/model-wanuke

For the Ban and Appeals Commission


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 25 '24

Ban of mysteriously_anonymously

1 Upvotes

Discord User mysteriously_anonymously joined the CMHoC Discord on November 24, They proceeded to join voice chat and stream pornography.

Discord User mysteriously_anonymously, is banned for a period of 1 month from all CMHOC platforms in accordance with section 9(a) Posting pornography: sharing printed or visual material containing the explicit description or display of sexual organs or sexual activity

As this is not a ban over 1 Month, no Parole Period is Applicable, and no probation period is applicable.

The user may contest the punishment to the Ban and Appeals Commission within 7 days (By November 21, 2024).


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 24 '24

Update on Ban of Winston_Wilhelmus

0 Upvotes

Per the direction, of the BaC , shall be changed. They are now deemed permanently banned from CMHOC platforms.

As this is a permanent ban, the offender may apply for Parole after 6 months (May 24, 2025). If the Offender receives successful parole, they will be subject to a 1 year probation period.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 24 '24

Petition: Moderators should not be allowed to "joke" about inflicting a punishment upon someone, ESPECIALLY if they are involved in roleplay.

0 Upvotes

An occurrence of argument happened earlier today (10 minutes ago), one that I consider gross, in which a moderator who is involved in the roleplay of cmhoc (Not naming names) joked about banning members, specifically those of a Conservative nature. Given the current sensitive climate surrounding meta and roleplay bleeding into one another, I figured I'd make a petition for something I believe strongly in. I'm new to reddit polsim so please bear with me;

  1. Mods shall not make jokes about inflicting a punishment upon someone that has not done anything that would warrant such a statement if it were a serious context.

  2. Mods shall not tell other users that they will use their powers against members of cmhoc unless they are actually considering doing so for legitimate reasons.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 23 '24

Petition: Ensuring Punishment Transparency

1 Upvotes

Petition that cl 19 of the Code of Conduct be amended where "when a punishment beyond a mute is issued" that it be re-written to read "when a punishment beyond a mute of 1 hour is issued".

The mutes today would be of negligible concern if they weren't over a prolonged period, however the lack of a requirement for mods to be transparent about days-long mutes/timeouts is a loophole that we're just now seeing being exploited. Regardless of intent, partisan or non-partisan, it's important that the mods are acting transparently so we don't run into any issues of trust again :)


r/cmhocmeta • • Jun 05 '21

Election Notice of Meta Election: Speaker of the House of Commons

1 Upvotes

A Vacancy has occurred in the office of Speaker of the House of Commons, therefore per Section 31 of the Meta Constitution, a Meta Election to Elect a New Speaker will occur.

Nominees do not need a platform of any sort, but they may make one if they please.

Duties for the Speaker of the House of Commons:

  • Has overall authority over the processes and functions of the House of Commons Chamber.

  • Has the right to select anyone in the community to serve as a Deputy Speaker.

  • to facilitate all general and by-elections.

  • manage the day-to-day handling of the House of Commons by delegating responsibilities and jobs to their Deputy Speaker(s).

  • resign from all other positions in CMHoC, leave all parties they may belong to, as well as remain politically neutral during their term.

All members of the simulation may vote.

The Election will Function as Follows, in Accordance with Section 8 (c) (iv)

If there is only one nominee, an Approval vote of Confidence in the Nominee will be head.

If there are two nominees, the election will be a simple plurality election.

If there are more than two nominees, the election will use preferential voting.

Nominate yourself or someone else (provided they accept) below! Nominations will be open until 12:00 on June 7, 2021, only 1 Nomination is required to become a Nominee.

Head Moderator - Flarelia


r/cmhocmeta • • Oct 29 '24

Suggestion Petition: Remove Speaker, and remove speakership from canon

0 Upvotes

Recently in my observations the speakership position has become increasingly politicized and used in a partisan manner. If this petition passes, then the speaker is immediately removed and the speakership merges back with the clerk of the house and becomes a meta position again.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 25 '24

Resignation

2 Upvotes

I resign as Member of the Board and Appeals Commission and as Electoral Moderator.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 24 '24

Other Noting Petitions as Invalid

2 Upvotes

Whereas Section 9.1 of the CMHoC Meta Constitution states;

9.1 (1) If a Meta Petition includes the requesting of any change to anything falling under section 80 of the Meta Constitution, or to amend the Meta Constitution, it must include the text of a proposed by-law to effect the changes proposed.

Imperfect or blank Meta Petitions. (2) No Meta Petitions may be deemed valid that are blank or in an imperfect form.

Whereas, multiple petitions have met the seconder requirement that include requests for changes of issues falling under section 80 of the Meta Constitution, that do not include the text of proposed by-laws to effect the changes proposed.

The Moderation Team finds the following petitions to be invalid, as they do not include the text of a proposed by-law to effect their proposed changes.

https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gy28lb/a_formal_petition_to_ban_umodeljordology/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gy0uaf/petition_condemning_partisan_rule_enforcement/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gy5xj8/petition_continuing_to_ensure_the_nonpartisan/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gy7ki4/limit_meta_petitions_to_one_daily_per_person/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gyk29p/petition_to_require_anti_bullying_and_toxicity/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gy6xtd/petition_change_the_requirements_for_a_petition/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cmhocmeta/comments/1gyh7y0/petition_moderators_should_not_be_allowed_to_joke/


r/cmhocmeta • • Oct 04 '20

Suggestion Proposal: Institute permanent, immutable parties

2 Upvotes

Previously, for various reasons, one of the three major parties (Conservatives, Liberals, and NDP) have folded into others. This was done, in most cases, because the parties were uncompetitive on their own (for example, the Liberals and NDP quasi-merging to form the Liberal Democratic Alliance, or the Conservatives recently folding into the Liberals). Although this led, ostensibly, to the survival of the parties in question (no control group demonstrates that they would not have survived otherwise), it has always been bad for sim health as a whole – in each case bringing about calls for sim reform to revitalize the sim. In order to prevent this, I am proposing that these three parties are institutionalized as permanent parties: parties that must exist at all times in the sim, may not be dissolved or merged out of existence, and may not enter binding agreements with other major parties to give up part of their independence.

Transformation of existing parties into permanent parties

Under my proposal, the Liberal and New Democratic parties would continue in existence as themselves, while the Progressive Conservatives would become the Conservative Party.

No interdiction on other parties’ existence or freedom

This proposal would not change any of the meta regulations or bylaws of the sim not relating to these three permanent parties. In order words, this should not be taken to imply that parties other than these three would not be allowed to form, nor that they would not be allowed to merge out of existence, dissolve, or enter into binding agreements with other parties, including major parties. Parties that are not the major three (Conservatives, Liberals, and NDP) would function by existing rules.

Permanent parties’ mandatory constitution

Previously, we have had issues with individuals taking over major parties and not allowing any challenge, for example by denying votes of no confidence constitutionally, among other measures. In order to prevent this, and to ensure the continuity of these parties, a single mandatory constitution would be applied to all of them, as to be written into the set of meta regulations and bylaws. This mandatory constitution would have provisions for regular leadership elections and an accessible way for the membership to remove any leadership member.


r/cmhocmeta • • Oct 29 '24

Town Hall Petition: Take Away Hayley182_'s Ability to Present VONCs

3 Upvotes

This petition basically just calls for Hayley182_'s ability to present VONCs to be taken away. If this petition passes, Hayley_182 can not present any more VONCs, effective immediately. Please second below


r/cmhocmeta • • Aug 16 '25

Other PLEASE OPEN!!! Announcement from Stargirl

0 Upvotes

Hi, i’m so sorry this had to be posted on cmhoc meta, but it just is a meta issue.

I’ve lost access to discord for 2 weeks moving ahead because I am on a cruise ship! The wifi doesn’t let me access it because of my plan. Luckily, I can access Reddit. I’m afraid I didn’t reach all my friends and partners so I just want it to pop in your reddit feed channel.

To contact me over these 2 weeks, please use the messaging feature on reddit. Thank you and sorry if I left you on delivered.

P.S: congrats to the forward party for doing so well in their campaign

P.S.S: my trip is super duper fun:)

  • lots of love and many thanks, stargirl


r/cmhocmeta • • Dec 02 '24

Ban of EpicMFan

0 Upvotes

EpicMFan is banned permanently from all CMHoC platforms in accordance with Section 4(d) Terms of Service violations: Violations of the Reddit or Discord Terms of Service, the Reddit Content Policy or Serious Breaches of the Discord Community Guidelines


r/cmhocmeta • • Dec 13 '24

Suggestion Petition: Improve Consequences of Failure of Emergency Bylaw

0 Upvotes

Replace section 79.1 of the Meta Constitution with the following text:

79.11 If an emergency bylaw is rejected by the community via the meta vote, the bylaw is treated as having never been enacted, notwithstanding that actions carried out pursuant to it remain lawful.

79.12 For greater clarity, if the effect of an emergency bylaw is to remove an officeholder, the effect of the emergency bylaw being rejected via meta vote is that the officeholder is restored to their office as if they had not been removed.

EN: Currently, it is ambiguous whether the effects of an emergency bylaw that is self-executing can remain in force despite the bylaw itself being rejected by the community and automatically repealed. This amendment fixes that problem by specifying that it is regarded as having never been enacted.


r/cmhocmeta • • Mar 04 '25

Meta Vote (4th March 2025) — Parliamentary Moderator Vote

1 Upvotes

Vote Here

You may find the Q&A here.

This Meta Vote has been released at 9am (0900 hrs) (GMT-5), Tuesday the 4th of March, 2025. It will conclude at 9am (0900 hrs) (GMT-5), Friday the 7th of March, 2025.

Disclosure: I did not do a Q&A this time, violating section 16(c) of the Constitution. This is because nobody asked questions the last time, and I am pretty sure nobody will ask them this time either. I have cleared it with the nominee and he is satisfied to proceed straight to a vote. I hope this does not cause any controversy.


r/cmhocmeta • • Jan 31 '25

Determination of House Activity Check 1-2 — January 31th, 2023.

1 Upvotes

Consideration has been made on those in breach of participation requirements within the period.

Determination

  • /u/PapaSweetshare, the member for Alberta South, had a submission made on his behalf, I find that this submission does not meet the “out of control of the parliamentarian” and "not foreseeable" criteria. The member failed to meet Requirement (a) to debate once per 14 days and is given a first warning.

  • /u/burglars11, list member, failed to make a submission. The member failed to meet Requirement (a) to debate once per 14 days and is given a first warning.

  • /u/Model-Jordology, list member, failed to make a submission. The member failed to meet Requirement (a) to debate once per 14 days and is given a first warning.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 23 '24

Limit meta petitions to one daily per person

1 Upvotes

Since we have seen the press spam as of late, I propose the following:

A) Limit petitions to once daily per person, B) Limit petitions specifically relating to moderators to one per person per week for three months following the passage of this petition, and then applying the blanket rule following that period, C) Limit amendments to petitions to twice daily per petition, D) Allow moderators to apply discretion to determine any workarounds, such as asking another member to post your petition, E) a) Impose a warning on first offence, one-week petition ban on second offence, one month on third offence, six months in fourth, and permanent with opportunity to appeal on the fifth, b) A first offence if a member is determined to have used workarounds is counted as a second offence, F) Exempt the Head and Electoral moderators from these rules, allowing them to post three times daily if they wish.

I believe these rules are a fair way of preventing further degradation to the meta community, while but targeting one person in particular as my last petition did.


r/cmhocmeta • • Nov 23 '24

Suggestion Petition: Condemning Partisan Rule Enforcement

1 Upvotes

Over the last several weeks I have noticed an unfair application of the rules, namely with regards to section 11 of the Code of Conduct. Throughout the last several weeks tensions have been high in CMHoC, but in every instance the conversation fizzled out within minutes or an hour at most. This week, however, the CoC has been applied much more stringently. Yesterday night there was a disagreement over a canon issue that spilled over thanks to jordologys penchant for not letting anything go. Neither me nor crazygamer initiated the conversation, and I especially have been trying to engage in good faith with them. Ever since their arrival to the sim jordology has constantly caused fights over canonical nitpicks and their bizarre statements. Jordology has hid behind the veil of canon to lob personal attacks and insults, the very same thing my party is being accused of doing now. Additionally, this comes on the heels of even more personal attacks that were lobbed several weeks ago by the Loberal leader, discord moderator and ban and appeals chair member wonderoveryander. He was not scrutinized or even warned for these statements which are a clear and egregious violation of the code of conduct, and all my attempts at raising the issue were completely ignored by all moderation and staff members. I’m honestly at my wits end and it’s insulting how I’m allowed to be constantly personally attacked and the second I even respond with half of the level of pettiness that someone engages me with, it’s only me that gets in trouble. Therefore, this petition if passed will call for several things, including:
After the section titled Meta Enforcement in the meta constitution, insert a new section titled 'Fair Application of Rules', with the following subsections: A. The moderation team must issue an immediate apology for their failure to fairly and accurately apply the CoC to all members, including the government.
B. /u/WonderOverYander must issue an immediate apology for his toxic comments and failure to prevent his members from constantly instigating fights.
C. /u/Model-Jordology is to be placed on a ‘last strike’ basis, and any future CoC infractions cannot be dismissed with simply a warning.
D. The executive is committed to appointing one member of the Conservative Party to either the discord mod team or Ban and Appeals commission.