r/clozemaster • u/[deleted] • Apr 01 '21
My 1 year GENERAL review of Clozemaster - just my opinion
(NOTE: UPDATED TO 3 YEAR REVIEW)
MY BACKGROUND AND SPANISH JOURNEY:
I'm just an average guy. I took 3 years of bad high school spanish about 17 years ago (about 15 years ago from the start of this post), and I was decent, but nothing really stuck. I think I got a B in the class. I lost interest in Spanish.
2-3 years later, during 1 summer while working a boring seasonal summer job at an amusement park's customer service, I couldn't be on my phone. I was allowed to read, but I didn't have anything to read, so I became interested in Spanish again and downloaded and printed out a packet of a random spanish I II and III PDF online and read it while working to pass the time. Several years later, I cross-referenced with google, and turns out that PDF was "Galeno Natural Method: A Conversational System of Teaching Languages by Oscar Galeno". Then I quit Spanish again.
Years later, COVID19 came. I had nothing else to do. Videogames were getting boring. I decided to better myself, someway somehow, and that's when I got back into Spanish. I wasted months trying different apps, websites, services, etc ... and then I finally came across Clozemaster. Seemed sketchy. No one talked about it. And then after 3 years of inconsistent use, here we are! :)
My lifestyle (mostly job) gives me less free time compared to most/the average but I make the best of it. What I've done in 3 years can be done in 1 year for a disciplined teenager who goes to school but doesn't work and has no responsibility to stay alive. What I've done in 3 years can be done in 2 years for someone 18+ who does have to take care of themselves. If you don't know any Spanish at all, then this app is not for you. If you know minimal spanish, then it will be definitely be hard, but it's possible.
MY CLOZEMASTER ADVICE:
1 You must purchase the pro version:
-The human voices are much better and natural than the robotic voices. Sometimes the robotic voices are bad or not good enough to hear everything. -Being able to favorite clozes is important to reference later. I basically use it as a substitute to take notes. -It's cheaper to buy the 1 year package than the monthly package. If you can’t afford it then buddy up with someone who does a different language so then you both can enjoy the app lol. If you like the app, then buy the LIFETIME PACKAGE, which is a package that they offer on the website ONLY (it's not available through the iPhone app store).
2. How to most efficiently and most effectively use the app:
-Definitely do the "essentials" collection and the "most common" collections up to the 20,000 most common. This is required, I strongly recommend evertything up to the 20,000 most common. -The 50,000 most common is OPTIONAL. This was very annoying and hard for me to complete. Learning this section is inefficient. If you don't have the time, or feel like you're about to quit, then do NOT do this section. This section is full of NUANCE. There's too many words in here that not even native speakers know or use. I don't like this section because there are alternative and secondary and tertiary words. The only good part about this section is that you definitely learn a lot of words to fill in the gaps. If you have the time, then it's worth it. You will be upset because there are words that native speakers in their 20's don't even know. Basically, I got around this by cross referencing every word that I've never seen or heard before. Search the word on google translate, and then reverse search the English translation. This process up to 2-3 minutes for each word. If it's not the most common for the meaning, both ways (from english to spanish and then from spanish to english), then that means it doesn't matter and mark it as "ignore". It's a lot of work, to be honest, and I hated it. -Don't do the >50,000. Way too random. Not worth it. -Skip the fluency fast track. There's no fast track to fluency. i'm not sure, but apparently it may only use up to the 20,000 most common? -Skip the other random collections (para vs por, estar vs ser) because you'll see that in the most common collections -When doing the most common collections, I basically immediately mark each cloze as "100% mastered", regardless if i've mastered it or not. You'll see variations of each word in there, and you'll never finish the app if you don't. I also mark ignore to the clozes that are either way too simple or contain only 1-2 words. and I ignore most idioms, names of countries and languages, and names of animals that a 5th grader can't identify. Never click the brain symbol ("known") on anything.
3. Review is key. I set my options to 15 days for 0% mastered, 30 for 25%, 60 for 50%, 90 for 75%, and 120 for 100%. Honestly I can’t even keep up with these settings! My goal setting is 1000 (insane), review setting 0 per round, and 100 count (max) per round . Every day I do 1 round of review + 1 round of new - I did this for year 1 and year 2. My problem is that I'll take long breaks of variation days/weeks (and one time for like 4 months when my life was chaotic). There are rare translation errors, but the amount of them is very small compared to what’s correct, therefore these are insignificant. During my 3rd year (currently), I realized that "reviewing" was great, and still is, but now it's actually holding me back more than helping me, so I haven't reviewed anything in my 3rd year. Once I finish the most common 50,000, I'll be just reviewing everything!
4. Don’t pay attention to the points and the leaderboard. All that is bullshit. Doesn’t matter if it’s real people, or fake bots. This is just the game element. But You’re not competing with them, you’re actually competing with yourself! Besides, if you really wanted to get points, then you could just turn your review settings to 0-7 days and just review review review . But you wouldn’t get anywhere. You wouldn’t learn or expand your vocabulary. Only use the points for daily personal goals. Edit 1/23/23: The statistics feature is pretty useful for monitoring your progress. Ever since they came out with it, I haven't paid any attention at all to other users.
5. ONLY DO LISTENING MULTIPLE CHOICE MODE. Then set translations to VISIBLE. When you do Clozemaster, first listen. Try to “identify” each word. Then try to understand it. Repeat it as many times as you need, but do NOT slow down the speed. Once you get better and better, try to repeat the cloze less, then try to understand it on the first try. The app naturally speaks slower for under 3000, and as the clozes get longer (above 3000), then it speeds up to natural. Don't waste your time writing/texting in things.
6. Edit 1/23/23: The update that introduced the Clozemaster radio is amazing! In the settings, remove all of the options in the "playback pattern" and only keep "1. Text". I like to warmup with this, or listen on the road. It forces me to stop dwelling and to think and process spanish faster. Edit 8/20/23: I wish the app would give you 1 point for each cloze on the radio ...
MY OVERALL REFLECTIONS:
I do think that this app is the best app ever. I learned more Spanish with Clozemaster in 1 month than I did in 1 year of high school Spanish (which was 15 years ago for me). Clozemaster is the way. It’s comprehensive. But it does require you to have the very basics of Spanish down first. If you can decently pronounce words, and somewhat understand sentence construction, then you’re ready. It’s definitely a grind though. The clozes are so easy that a toddler could get them right...but that’s NOT the way you learn with Clozemaster. You don't learn from answering 99% correct (literally it's that easy). You learn with Clozemaster by LISTENING to human speak. READING what you just heard. At first it’s torture , but trust me it gets better month by month.
Clozemaster will satisfy your "classroom" Spanish, you'll learn the language with Clozemaster alone. However, CLozemaster will NOT satisfy your "immersion", which is required for fluency. You need to fill the immersion experience for language fluency, and if you don't, then you'll end up like me in spanish intermediate purgatory. Which sucks. The only other resource besides Clozemaster that you need is some conversation resource (like real life person to person conversation). Which one? I don’t know yet. You tell me! 😃
I scored C1 on a CEFR 4 months ago, but the website was sketchy/cheap, and there wasn't any of me talking. Most recently, I scored B2 on a legit site, however there still wasn't any of me talking. Clearly, I know a lot of Spanish, but all of that doesn't matter because my most severe deficit is talking! :( Which makes sense because I don't "talk" in Spanish lol! So embarrassing. That's what I'm looking to do next.