r/climate_science • • Dec 29 '19

The climate has always changed. What do you conclude?

Thumbnail
realclimate.org
3 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Aug 01 '22

Nuclear Power Plant Meltdown Post Collapse

9 Upvotes

Guy McPherson insists that climate change will escalate exponentially once we have an ice-free arctic, which could happen in then next decade or so. Or maybe much sooner. This will cause a collapse of civilization. That, in turn, will cause many of the 450 nuclear power plants around the world to be abandoned. He says that there is no fail-safe, and that once the diesel generators that run the cooling pumps run out of fuel, the plants will melt down, causing huge release of ionizing radiation. That, in turn, will destroy the ozone layer, making the planet uninhabitable for all life, not just human life.

So, are nuclear power plants really designed so poorly? Are some fail-safe and some not? Any idea what proportion this would happen to? If this is indeed a big risk, is anyone in the nuclear power industry working on remediation? If not, who needs to be pressured to make it so?


r/climate_science • • Jan 14 '21

Multiple regression analysis of anthropogenic and heliogenic climate drivers, and some cautious forecasts-Frank Stefani

Thumbnail arxiv.org
0 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Jan 06 '20

Challenging the CO2 minimum hypothesis

3 Upvotes

I would like some clarification of the following claims if some of you could spare the time:

We are at a CO2 minimum for geological time scale. As in 99.9999% of Earth's history had more CO2 than present.

When the Earth had 3,000 ppm (About 7 times the total concentration of present) there was more diversity of life, large plants, larger trees, and thriving eco systems.

The Earth literally had an atmosphere primarily composed of CO2 for the first billion years of its history. Algae in the oceans formed and absorbed it and turned it into O2.

The entire history of industrial activity for humans we have gone from 280 ppm to ~410 ppm. So we haven't even seen a single doubling of CO2 in our atmosphere.

The most CO2 has been released in the last 20 years than previous decades, yet global temperatures stagnated. Meaning CO2 sensitivity is greatly out pace by natural factors such as the PDO cycle.

The Earth saw cooling for 3 decades during 1940 to 1970 even though we saw CO2 rising across the globe. This is part of the reason people feared an "Ice Age" (Glaciation period) for returning.

Warming is not equally distributive, and actually happens more so towards the poles. Meaning even if the "average temperature" goes up, if you're close to the equator you will see no temperature change. This also means large swathes of areas in Russia and Canada go from being Tundra to farmable land. As in more food for the entire planet.

Plant life grows better at higher CO2 concentrations. Ideally 500-600 ppm would be where we slow down, as that will lead to better agriculture.

A glaciation period (some would call an Ice Age, even though we are in one right now) would result in vast death across the globe. Some estimate nearly a billion people would die. Meaning we should hope we are warming the planet to avoid another glaciation period.

Sea level rise has been going on for 20,000 years. And it is not accelerating. The current rate of sea level rise is 1-2mm per year. Meaning by the time populations are displaced will be over centuries, not years or even decades. Meaning humans who are good at adapting will adapt without even realizing they are doing so. --------‐----‐----------------------------- I pulled these quotes from another reddit thread. I don't accept them, but want a little more understanding about how they can be disproven by someone with a better understanding of the science of AGW than I currently have. They have been copied without the original authors permission, so I want to be courteous to the original author by not linking to the post or the author here.


r/climate_science • • Dec 06 '19

89% of NWS/NOAA temperature station data is likely compromised from being in close proximity (<30m) of artificial heat sources

0 Upvotes

Edit: I'm not here to troll. I'm a firm believer in climate change.

My brother sent me this Heartland Institute article and I want to know your thoughts on this (I'm not a climate scientist). The article basically asserts that because 89% of NWS/NOAA temperature monitoring stations fail to meet the NWS's own siting requirements that stations must be 30 meters (about 100 feet) or more away from an artificial heating or radiating/reflecting heat source. It also sites the paper Impacts of Small-Scale Urban Encroachment on Air Temperature Observations that validates that stations within 50m of an artificial heat source can skew temperature measurements.

The final conclusion is that US ground temperature measurements are unreliable. What are your thoughts?


r/climate_science • • May 21 '18

Read an article that has made me question a few assumptions - would love to know how to counter these points.

0 Upvotes

The article here addresses a few points on the trust we can place in climate modeling. It does not attempt to negate any climate science, but is rather a critique on the models.

  1. It draws into question our historical temperature data. A Stanford scientist claims that the Earth has warmed 0.8C with a +- of 0.98 with 95% confidence interval. This obviously brings into question the accuracy of our temperature tracking over the past hundred and some odd years since the temperature rise is within its margin of error. Are current models placing too much faith into the accuracy of historical data?

  2. Our calculation and record of the sun’s energy needs to be accurate within 0.1% or the variation would swamp the heating contribution of the CO2. See article for more details here.

  3. Clouds are the most difficult thing to model and the more we learn about atmospheric physics we add more and more parts to the equation. But clouds are a major contributing factor to climate change. It quotes the IPCC report talking about the difficulty of cloud modeling. And if our calculations are off by just 0.9% - that difference swamps the added heat from CO2.

So if we’re scrutinizing just those 3 factors - how do we know that the models are taking them into account within the required margin of error?


r/climate_science • • Feb 08 '22

Climate model ?

8 Upvotes

Is it true that pur current knowledge of climate science is based on old models that don't include the forces of the Sun? I am a layman that is trying to understand the science.


r/climate_science • • Jun 14 '19

So.... Not a climate denier but still confused

0 Upvotes

Not attaking anytime I completely she with the fact that is humans are ducking our planet.... But I am confused by how the story keeps changing how we are going to die. I remember when I was young that it's a second ice age... Than it was we are going to slowly due from the rising temp... Than it was the rising ocean and now I see this......I would like some solid source on what is actually happening not just the next Doomsday. Thank you everyone. Below is the article I am referring to. Thank you

https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1139691/Ocean-sinking-Earth-mantle-oceans-consumed-dead-supercontinent-Pangea


r/climate_science • • Sep 11 '18

Can any of you debunk this paper?

0 Upvotes

Its called The Harsh Realities of Now, and its by David Wasdell. Its been worrying me a lot lately, so id appreciate some feedback


r/climate_science • • Jan 12 '18

Seeking Raw Data.

0 Upvotes

Trying to find actual numbers on how many scientist support human caused climate change vs scientist who don't and of those numbers how many are actual climate scientist and how many are not. Thanks


r/climate_science • • Mar 12 '19

How to change the discussion on climate change policy.

Thumbnail
self.environmental_science
0 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Aug 18 '17

After a trip to Iceland and learning about how overdue volcanoes Hekla and Katla are in erupting, I'm convinced that the Earth potentially has a feedback loop to delay eruptions when CO2 levels start rising.

0 Upvotes

By delaying eruptions, they become stronger, and the ash would have a more significant cooling effect on the planet.

Is this possible or is this sounding like too much of a Gaia-related hypothesis? (ascribing some form of intelligence built into the Earth)


r/climate_science • • Oct 14 '17

Hypothesis: Ice caps help in global temperature regulation (Latent heat of ice keeps temperature relatively constant), and if the ice caps melt, there would be a significant increase in the rise of climate change afterwards.

1 Upvotes

I see a lot of people complaining that if the ice caps melted, there would be flooding. But from my background in chemical engineering, while ice melts, the temperature is at a constant 0C. Once the ice is fully melted, there is an actual increase in temperature of the water.

Do you guys think that once the ice caps melt, that there will be a significant increase in climate change? Why don’t I see this anywhere. But I personally feel like it’s going to be significant in the future as the ice caps slowly go away.


r/climate_science • • Sep 10 '17

Climate Change and Hurricanes - (NOAA says no evidence of connection can be made at this point.)

Thumbnail
gfdl.noaa.gov
0 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Oct 31 '21

Climate scientists, do you think hyperbole by groups such as Extinction Rebellion is justified?

98 Upvotes

As a PhD student in climate, I have an internal conflict about the namesake message of groups such as Extinction Rebellion that I am sure other climate scientists are familiar with. On the one hand, as we all know, climate change is a crisis of enormous proportions and I completely support their intentions (I do not want to get into a discussion about methods).

On the other hand, something that troubles me is that their namesake argument, that climate change represents an "extinction level threat" to humanity (with similar messages consistently used in their campaigning) or will lead to the collapse of human civilization is, to put it mildly, not supported by the evidence. In Global Catastrophic Risks (2008), Frame and Allen conclude that, whilst immensely damaging, climate change "would not necessarily be catastrophic in the sense of being a terminal threat" and since this book's publication, I have yet to read a paper arguing that climate change represents an extinction-level threat for humanity.

Of course, the error that Extinction Rebellion (and similar groups) is making is the assumption that the threshold of a catastrophe is human extinction. This is clearly not true because something can be catastrophic to human society (which climate change is) whilst not posing a literal threat to our existence (which climate change does not, or at least there is no evidence for this).

My question is, is this actually a problem, or is this just academic pedantry? Putting my role as a scientist aside, my worry is that making claims that are technically incorrect (even though the broad message that climate change is catastrophic is correct) makes it easier to deny campaigners' arguments over technicalities rather than actually engaging in the substance of the argument. Or similarly, that laypeople will just dismiss them as fanatics/hysterics. On the other hand, their campaigning does seem to be quite successful (a lot more successful than us climate scientists making technically correct statements on twitter and university press releases) and I haven't actually seen anybody using this counterargument I'm worrying about.

What do you think?


r/climate_science • • Oct 25 '15

I am VERY worried about climate change

2 Upvotes

I have 95 acres in south west Iowa with about 40% being farmed of soy beans and corn. The other 60% I use for other homesteading uses (some cattle, pigs, greenhouse, ect) and a pond. I use to live in Florida but moved to our land in the mid-west out of fear that if we lived on land in Florida then our children or great grand children may one day become climate refuges. Things that are likely to change in this region, especially for later generations, are drought, dust-bowlification, and other heat related events. What are steps that I can be taking now to assure that my land is effected the least by future climate related events. Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated! Thanks for your help!


r/climate_science • • Jan 18 '19

Ok so I know this is technically arctic news, but this studies author is different so I thought it was worth asking about

Thumbnail
arctic-news.blogspot.com
2 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Jan 06 '20

Are the fires in Australia related to global warming and climate change? If so, how?

2 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Oct 20 '15

So Hear Me Out

0 Upvotes

The temperature at the surface of the earth can vary wildly from season to season. But, under the surface, the temperature is more reflective of the average yearly surface temperature. As you go further underground, the temperature becomes more stable. In the heat of summer, the surface temperature may be 104F but at 10ft below the surface the temperature may be 60F. The same for winter when the surface temp may be 20F, 10ft down the temp will still be 60F. So this is where it gets interesting…

If plants are approximately 60% water, then you could imagine a field of knee high grass as a small layer of water covering the ground. But not only covering the ground, the roots of the plants grow deep into the ground, pulling the cool water from under the surface, to the surface, where it evaporates to cool the plants, thereby extending the temperature stability from sub-surface earth into the atmosphere.


r/climate_science • • Nov 20 '17

Ocean's rising: a solution?

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I have been thinking about this for some time and wanted to share it. As Oceans are rising, I was wondering if "digging holes" would be a solution. I know it sounds a bit stupid/extreme, but why don't rich (and polluting) countries pay poor countries to actually dig huge holes in the desert, for example, so the extra water could transfer into brand new interior seas? Would it technically solve the problem? I know there would be a huge impact on ecosystems, etc... But I don't believe in the COP23 anymore!

Please let me know your thoughts.


r/climate_science • • Sep 12 '17

Can a hurricane be disrupted by a massive cooldown?

0 Upvotes

What if a wall of ice or liquid nitrogen was placed in a hurricane's path? Granted, it would have to be on a massive, unprecedented scale. Laws of thermodynamics? #science #non-fiction #thermodynamics #hurricane


r/climate_science • • Sep 10 '17

Found an article claiming that GISTEMP didn't support the heat records...any explanation as to how this is wrong?

Thumbnail
americanthinker.com
0 Upvotes

r/climate_science • • Dec 23 '15

Is there a graphic depicting evidence for and against climate change?

0 Upvotes

I am hoping to find a graphic the shows the # of scientific articles supporting climate change and # refuting it, or whichever the anti-climate people use to refute climate change.


r/climate_science • • Jun 25 '18

Question about climate data sets.

0 Upvotes

I was watching the Weather Channel, and it's been told that temperatures are going to be above average in the Northeastern US. The CPC's 6-10 Day/8-14 Day Outlooks agree with this, yet Climate Reanalyzer's page shows that 2-meter temperatures are actually below average in the same area.

https://my.mixtape.moe/mcoiqi.png

Which one is correct, and what causes this discrepancy?