r/classicwow • u/Richardik • Sep 27 '26
Forever Beta Feedback Raid composition problem
Followup on threads like:
https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwow/comments/1wmwau2/somewhat_concerned_about_the_raid_compositions_in/
https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwow/comments/1wjpad8/optimal_20ppl_raid_comp_in_classic_forever/
As it seems, WoW Forever is gonna carry the torch of TBC in how strict the raid compositions are gonna have to be in order to have optimal synergies and buffs present.
The bare minimum present 3 paladins, 4 shamans, 2 warlocks, priest, hunter, warrior, balance, feral druid, mage for 20 man, leaving at maximum 4 flex positions for when all raids buffs are accessible.
The most obvious glaring issue is the disproportionate requirement of shamans and paladins.
How to elegantly improve the situation?
1, Raid groups should feature 10man subgroup system

This greatly reduces the chore of micromanging groups, screwing people over not fitting a certain setups etc. Of course, this does not eliminate the issue entirely, merely diminishes it, but it's still a significant upgrade over current setting.
2, Remove Blessing of Salvation and rebalance tank threat without it's existance in mind. This makes getting more paladins a matter of accessibility and potentially required utility, not a raidwide powerlevel necessity.
To the people discrediting this by saying: min-maxer issue, content will be too easy... the current buff distribution withotu changes WILL affect you the second you try to pug outside of your like-minded guilds.
58
u/ppdwaswrong Sep 27 '26
You can cut three specs from your picture.
BM Hunter doesn't buff his party like in TBC. Shadow Priest only gives mana on kills and its Shadow Dmg Buff only applies to their own dmg. Ele Shammy doesn't have Wrath Totem.
If your main issue is managing a guild core, then just make sure you can split your 20 into two 10s without hassle. Have 2 DPS that can Tank and 2 that can Heal. That's the extent of your micromanaging issue if you're not speedrunning.
But if you wanna make sure you have all the raid buffs then yeah, gotta bring a bunch of different shit. Less than TBC but its still pretty locked in until speedrunners figure out which Raid Buff you can drop for +1 of The Busted DPS.
7
u/Uglifi Sep 27 '26
any and all talents that benefitted the raid are gone. So no need for 2nd warlock either. Feral and Balance druid auras don't stack.
4
u/TiltSchweiger Sep 27 '26
Isn't there curse of elements (magic dmg+) and curse of recklessness (phys dmg+) or sth? So you still need 2 warlocks to have both (de)buffs for the raid?
→ More replies (1)1
u/Birdyy4 Sep 27 '26
Given the armor debuffs aren't stacking rn we might want both warlocks for their curses since it's better than faerie fire
1
u/Azsune Sep 27 '26
With shadow priests healing from damage and their DPS buff and in a tank group, you might be able to cut a healer.
He also left warlocks out of the melee 10 man. My friends already theorizing this and they want reck with their warriors.
1
u/SimilarAd3309 Sep 27 '26
Yep, they will absolutely want reck. His 10 man comps are also a nightmare for loot distribution.
1
u/nbogie055 Sep 27 '26
I think you want Hunter for melee group since they have an attack power party buff from pet.
→ More replies (8)1
u/Eretol Sep 27 '26
you also have access to campfire, you can have the attack power buff/mp5 from campfire instead of a 3rd pala for example. there are 0 reason to bring a ret they will probably not be top dps and they have no unique buffs and you can have a prot paladin spec 16 points ret if your holy pala cant be bothered to keep their own judgement up, same goes for enhance you can just as well have a resto sham drop windfury. and max rank campfire gives what 5 exclusive buffs, meaning raid comps is actually not limited at all, if you can have it inside raids which we probably will end up having.
they literally went with the opposite of tbc design for forever, there are almost no reason to bring any specific specs to raids very few provide unique party/raid wide buffs. this will end up being class stacking of the highest dps class/spec in true vanilla fashion
3
9
u/Jonesalot Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
I talked with a guildie a bit about this
It isn't just about sweaty raid comps, its also about class balance. How are you gonna balance melee vs casters when melee can get
Debuffs: Sunder/Expose, FF, CoR
Buffs: BS, BOM, Strength totem, WF, Kings, Druid Crit
While casters only get
Debuffs: CoE
Buffs: Druid Crit (Mana buffs could be considered dps buffs if your really kind)
(A melee strength class can get around 380 atp + kings from buffs)
Either Melee will be overpowered in an optimal comp, or Casters will be overpowered in a none optimal comp
My idea would be something like BS, BOM and Strength totem doesnt stack. You can still have them but you only gain stats from the best. Same with FF and CoR and make druid crit and WF be raid wide (not sure about pala buffs. Maybe just remove kings)
Then you would just need 1 dps/tank druid, 1 lock, 1 rogue/warrior, 1 shaman and one of the 3 ways to give atp to the melee groups, a priest for stamina and a mage for int (+ pala buffs)
96
u/The_Dark_Tetrad Sep 27 '26
MAKE TOTEMS RAID WIDE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD
19
4
15
u/limitbreakse Sep 27 '26
Totems raid wide NOW. One shaman per group is thr worst part of TBC.
Baking in salvation to remove the min 3 paladin requirement is also a good idea.
We have 20 slots only. It makes no sense to force the stacking of that many classes.
→ More replies (11)-8
u/phl23 Sep 27 '26
Yes and one totem of each kind and not of each element. This way you can run two shamans. You could also make paladins have all buffs but with diminishing returns on each one. So you can still run more paladins but don't loose to much if not.
3
1
21
u/Kododie Sep 27 '26
As far as shamans go, you don't need 4 afaik. Right now different shaman specs don't provide anything unique and unless mana is an issue there little reason to have one in caster/healer groups.
So the only question is how many ppl in your raid would benefit from WF/grace? Which in most cases will be 1 or 2 groups.
3
u/Competitive-Tooth248 Sep 27 '26
With the new talents both resto and ele can bring mana tide totem, that's a big buff for all casters. Also no better guild will use anything else in melee grp as enha, so if you want resto you have to put them into caster grp.
→ More replies (15)2
u/Vodddddddd Sep 27 '26
We have to look into what campsites bring too in these discussions
It won't be necessary to bring a shaman if you can get 80% of their buffs outside of minmaxing (outside of mana tide totem - which is nerfed from all the 'regen while casting' talents everyone gets)
4
u/dm_me_pasta_pics Sep 27 '26
Ha, I made a post touching on this yesterday too and got some very angry redditors responding. Hope your messages are okay lmao.
Your comp is different from what we will be running at this stage.
In my opinion, the buffs should just be raid wide and they should be spread more across the other classes as they were in SoD, to alleviate the shaman/paladin issue.
4
u/Brave-Cranberry3026 Sep 27 '26
Since Enhancement Shaman gets no utility from his own WF totem because Flametongue is useless and he will be running his own WF anyway it makes no sense for you to take Enhancement. The 'optimal' is just to take 2 RShams and an Ele, even though Ele probably sucks too.
39
u/korean_kracka Sep 27 '26
→ More replies (2)4
u/ikitomi Sep 27 '26
Kind of, but really it's just making 1 physical raid and 1 caster raid within a raid and making just as many problems.
But like, it's an ok attempt.
1
62
u/Concurrency_Bugs Sep 27 '26
I thought one of the draws of Forever was people could just play. Like worrying about min maxing raids was gonna be overkill?
17
u/JeDi_Five Sep 27 '26
You don't have to do any of this. But people who do enjoy this should be able to.
→ More replies (4)26
u/Alexarius87 Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
Optimization is going to be looked for anyway because a lot of ppl like to have an easier time in raids.
Then there is the “first” crowd who will try hard no matter what.
12
Sep 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/ariveklul Sep 27 '26
Nobody wants to purposefully play below their skill level if they can easily do better. This just isn't how mmos or gaming in general works
Bottlenecking people over this raid comp shit is lazy game design I could understand in 2007, but not in 2026 lmao
0
23
u/galygher Sep 27 '26
The thing is, historically, group comps in vanilla and tbc tend to matter a lot more than gear upgrades. For an extreme example, in phase 1 tbc, a warrior in full bis in every slot except their trinket will gain 300+ dps from an enhance shaman in the group, but only gain ~50 dps from equipping dst, which is their bis trinket for the entire expansion.
Its going to feel really bad if you finally get that chase item the devs teased and equip it, then show up to raid the next week and your group's second enhance shaman quit and now you do less dps than before you got your chase item because your guild couldnt find a replacement enhance.
10
u/Admiralsheep8 Sep 27 '26
The real issue is that game was never difficult enough to demand this kind of serious play . And people still force people to play this way. Thats the point of this dudes complaint .
3
13
u/ariveklul Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
It's just dogshit game design. They're taking the worst part of TBC, which is already a mediocre expansion that aged poorly.
No shaman in your group in TBC = no fun. As a ret paladin it was the difference between green parsing and pink/purple parsing. I became a fucking buff bot because my entire class relied on windfury proc synergy with seals.
If you're going to rip game mechanics at least pull them from wrath where stuff was more interesting. TBC is just not a good expansion in 2026 outside of a few quirks
Edit: the people down voting me are people that either barely played TBC or quit after SSC/TK came out, god forbid actually lead a raid group. Nobody that actually played TBC all the way through unironically thinks groupwide shaman totems or bloodlust is a good mechanic. This is some shit they stumbled into when they were figuring out what to do with the game in 2007
5
u/FlubberPuddy Sep 27 '26
So in Season of Discovery because they kept Shaman unique to Horde, they gave Druids a Windfury rune which allowed them to bring Windfury on Alliance side pretty much.
For almost half of the SoD Phases (8) they had that Windfury buff be only party wide.
When they realized how bad it was for group comp in end-game raiding (P4 onwards), they went ahead and made it raid wide.
We can only hope they do the same here.
People gotta remember that Forever is going to keep getting iterated on, they already released patch notes last week with a bunch of changes.
There's the possibility of things changing in the future as well, it's just people gotta keep talking about what feels good and what just feels terrible.
Classic needs friction, but there's good friction (things that enhance socializing in the game) and then there's bad friction (crap like no dual spec, severely unbalanced classes like in Vanilla, etc).
→ More replies (8)2
1
u/chris92315 Sep 28 '26
Not standing in fire and doing the mechanics correctly matter a lot more than group comp.
6
u/Cartiere11 Sep 27 '26
No, certain people enjoy playing efficiently. Certain raid teams will try every week to lower their raid time to faster and faster and faster. Raid comp is extremely important for this.
You dont have to play with them. There is nothing wrong with it.
1
u/Concurrency_Bugs Sep 27 '26
I agree with you, but then why is this Beta Feedback? This post is intended to give feedback to balancing for the game. Make and balance the game for everyone, not just the optimizers, then let the optimizers do what they want.
2
3
1
u/leeuw1234 Sep 27 '26
High number and efficient clears is fun when content isn't that hard you find ways to make things fun for yourself.
But yes, you really do not need to optimize your raid. All you need realistically is windfury for the melee groups and a boomkin for the caster groups to make things feel more smooth. All the rest is just extra minmaxing that is 100% not nescassery to get good clears and runs.
→ More replies (1)-7
u/Nethias25 Sep 27 '26
It is really lame. I hate seeing a bajillion adds for niche things "LF survival hunter for gruuls" like bro just get a dps run the thing. Don't neckbeard to needing the max possible amount of buffs and debuffs.
5
3
2
u/OstrichPaladin Sep 27 '26
I honestly like the idea. I think it'd be easier though to just make totems raid wide and adjust salve a little bit. I don't think it needs to be removed, but make it less of a necessity. Being in a tbc karazhan and having 1 paladin, and your buff HAS to be salve? It sucks. It feels awful to not get your kings or attack power. Salve shouldn't be a requirement, it should be a nice to have for padding, or letting your dps open a little sooner.
That being said I've noticed almost every caster has some sort of blanket threat reduction, so maybe that will help a bit.
Raid wide totems just make sense though. Needing a sham for every group just doesnt feel good imo. I guarantee you 1/5 raiders doesn't want to play shaman. But 1/5 raiders needs to be a shaman.
1
u/RoundAffectionate424 Sep 27 '26
It does feel bad but not that awful, it's just salvation is that good of a buff and a better dps increase in real game scenarios (because uptime). In tbc BS and BoM stacked but in forever they don't so 3 pallies or 2 pallies + 1 warrior and you cover all blessing buffs.
1
7
u/Dkreapers Sep 27 '26
For melee DPS in general the reliance on windfury is extremely frustrating and requires at least one enhance in a group which is fine if that is all the melee you have. But it gets incredibly annoying for any additional melee so yes pls make totems raid wide
2
u/Mjolnoggy Sep 27 '26
>least one enhance
Doesn't need to be enhance, just throw a resto sham in there and rotate him out for mana tide.
→ More replies (6)1
2
u/Budget-Ocelots Sep 27 '26
They need to figure out paladin buffs, not shaman. Shaman is easily fixable with raid wide totems, but a paladin solution will require Wrath scrolls, and that isn’t fun spending hundreds of golds to buff the raid on each wipe.
3
u/Seamonsterx Sep 27 '26
Combine wisdom and might.
Combine kings and salvation, make the salvation effect not apply if you’re in def stance/bear form/ righteous fury.
2
u/Tekn0de Sep 27 '26
You really don't need a shaman in every group. Only in melee groups unless there's a fear mechanic
7
u/Arranoth1983 Sep 27 '26
I disagree I'm a shaman so you probably need 3-5 shaman per group at all times even when just questing. I'll handle skinning and take any loot I can win.
2
u/Apprehensive_Egg_857 Sep 27 '26
Hey atleast some sorry sap will get to play fury warrior to press battle shout every 2 min since that's all the rage hes gonna have over the fights
1
6
u/saxon_hs Sep 27 '26
ele shaman, boomkin, feral all aren't that important in terms of buffs. shadow priest brings no buffs. Definitely need 2nd warrior for battleshout 2nd phys group. So by my count that's 7/20 that are farely flexible slots right now which isn't horrible.
Also I doubt prot pal will be meta, the tool kit is bad compared to prot warrior. If things stay as they are, 2x prot warrior and 0 fury/arms, we might see double ret or even shockadin.
5
u/Falceon Sep 27 '26
Also camping is a thing
6
u/Kododie Sep 27 '26
If they us camp in raid. If not then it's going to be pretty annoying when you wipe.
3
1
1
u/Jaydave Sep 27 '26
Shadow priest probably in the tank groups realistically, if their DPS is going to be good than their VE healing is going to be insane, just like in SOD
1
u/saxon_hs Sep 27 '26
Could be but probably not. The shadow priest would be taking a spot in the phys group getting WF and battleshout which would be better served on a physical DPS, and the tank will be get heals but not extra threat which has been the primary issue with classic in the past. Warrior tank, Enh, Feral, Ret devo aura, 2nd ret/shockadin retribution aura is the likely setup I think. In TBC we don't put afflock in with the tank for extra stam any more, nor tree in with the tank for tree of life party healing, it's not good.
1
u/Jaydave Sep 27 '26
Ya will be interesting to see how things actually turn out, since everything is different and we're all just speculating
1
u/klanh Sep 27 '26
Zero chance it's going to be 2 prots, OT just wouldn't do anything when not tanking. It's going to be wprot MT and bear OT and the bear is going to replace a hunter by pulling with FF. 2 warriors, 1 feral, 2 ench, 1 retri and 4 flex spots. Maybe an extra warrior for faster sunders, 1 survival, and 2 rogues.
It's going to be very unfun when after every 10man wipe, maybe 20man also, people are going to run out of the instance to get new camp buffs. People will wish we had world buff meta instead.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)1
u/Damian2M Sep 27 '26
Even in Classic they bring at least 1 druid for Faerie Fire, Mark of the Wild, Thorns and Insect Swarm. With Thorns scaling off spellpower, 1 Balance Druid seems necessary.
1
u/saxon_hs Sep 27 '26
Resto druid looks to me like the strongest healer so thats your buffs, and thorns doesn't scale off spellpower anymore and even if it did you could have a spellpower set for that. Yeah I think you'd want to bring a feral and a moonkin but doesn't look like a tremendous loss by not having them.
3
u/Eretol Sep 27 '26
thorns doesn't scale off spellpower anymore
? they removed snapshotting last i checked not scaling which is why previous commentator specifically mentioned boomkin for thorns
→ More replies (1)1
1
u/Mjolnoggy Sep 27 '26
Not really, you can easily get away with just doing a resto druid which is both far more powerful as a spec and more beneficial overall.
1
u/Damian2M Sep 27 '26
How would you know, if resto is more powerful on 60 than balance in the first place. It's just baffling....
→ More replies (3)
3
u/Ptozzen Sep 27 '26
I'm not going to care. If I'm benched, I'll take the week off.
Pugging is god awful regardless of comp or minmaxing, mostly because the raid leaders are either awful people, mostly toxic, or half the groups will roll on YOUR gear to keep it in the guild, or there's some unmentioned hard reserve present. Genuinely fuck all of this. I haven't pugged since wotlk classic naxx, and I'm happier that way.
It's a game. It's meant to be fun. This is not, and I refuse to participate. Good luck to the rest of you, and hope you enjoy the journey, because I sure as shit won't be pugging any raids.
1
1
u/fohpo02 Sep 27 '26
GDKP being banned but not HR absolutely makes no sense. Raid organizers could just as easily HR mats/blues/etc, and sell them to RMT gold. You’ll also end up with gatekeeping or pugs thinking raid comps are far more strict than they actually are, and forming will just get dragged out.
3
u/zkyz Sep 27 '26
I hope camp buffs do work in raids just for this reason. Maybe a max level profession can create a consumable you can interact with for an instant buff?
I dunno, it’s not exactly immersive. But I do think raid comps in pugs will very quickly parody whatever the “BIS comp” is. Yes, you won’t need the perfect comp, yes you’re probably not good enough for it to matter. But the unfortunate reality is the raid organisers will likely be degenerate gatekeepers about shit like this.
3
u/Intel_Oil Sep 27 '26
How many raids did you organize that took whatever classes/specs were in the LFG?
3
u/Storage-Express Sep 27 '26
even without salv some classes will want wisdom, kings and might (enh shaman, hunter, ret), at least in an ideal world. of course that depends on the fight lengths and mana sustain in raids but still. and at the very least i think lotp/moonkin aura should be raid wide (maybe just moonkin aura would be fine too)
i also think it's bad that enhancement shamans can't benefit from their own air totem (expected to drop WF) and that BM/MM hunters will not get grace of air either. they could've just made grace of air raid wide or did something else (maybe remove it and put agi on the str totem at a lower value) and let it stack with WF. imo these two changes would already solve a lot of issues in raid comp min maxing - it wouldn't be perfect but it's not terrible to run 3 paladins and maybe skip one shaman because they're not that mandatory in some caster groups (like have warlocks and a couple others without mana spring/mana tide). you'd still have 2 slots for every other class in theory.
as it is right now i don't think you can even make a 20man roster where everyone gets all the buffs/debuffs for their class. running 4dps druids to get leader of the pack/moonkin aura on everyone is not feasible obviously, just to give an example. now of course you don't actually need that but it doesn't feel great to be at a disadvantage to most people i think. i can already hear the guys who have some sort of hatred towards any min maxing be against it but would it really impact them negatively to make some changes in that direction? no it wouldn't, it would actually benefit them too because min max culture is also present in pug raids and will affect most players to some degree anyway. with the changes to things like winter's chill, improved scorch, shadow weaving etc. i would've expected blizzard to do a better job with the group buffs too tbh, it seems in line with what they want (and what makes sense imo).
1
u/brothediscpriest Sep 28 '26
Enhancement shamans can benefit form their own WF totem now though, since its not excluse with the other weapon enhancements.
Its likely going to be wf totem + rockbiter/flametongue for enh
5
u/PS4bohonkus Sep 27 '26
The camping system is supposed to provide near equivalents of all major buffs so that say if you only have 1 paladin, you can get near equivalents of might, kings, and wisdom from camping buffs. That’s the way I understand it anyway. They aren’t identical, but they are close and they don’t stack. I think this is a good system cuz it gives us a lot of freedom for composition without being completely gimped. Yes, the sweatiest guilds and even sweaty pugs are going to try for the optimal raid comp first but I don’t think it’s gonna be that bad
7
u/DarkForgeJ Sep 27 '26
Camp buffs won't work inside raids. That is for sure.
8
u/JeDi_Five Sep 27 '26
Even if they did, one wipe and you're waiting til the next hour to buff again.
3
u/Spleenfull Sep 27 '26
U dont have to Walt 1 h. The 1h debuff is for the tent who give you 5% rested exp
→ More replies (1)5
u/Yawanoc Sep 27 '26
No, each player can only put down one thing per hour. If you put down a Kings buff now, and you wipe, you’re out of luck for putting anything down until the 60 minute cooldown expires. Sure, you could have a second chance in a large enough raid where different people than the first give their buffs, but if you wipe more than twice then you’re out of luck.
1
u/valmian Sep 27 '26
I think there are legacy talents (I forget what they are called) that reduce the CD of placing item.
We also don’t know if level 300 professions will allow the production of cooldownless items.
That being said, I don’t know if having them allowed in raid is a good or bad idea. They are essentially worse raid buffs so it’s not like the extremity of world buffs, but at the same time now people may feel pressured to take certain professions for the raid buffs.
2
u/PS4bohonkus Sep 27 '26
I’ve searched all over and I cannot find any evidence that blizzard has stated they won’t work inside raids. All they’ve said is that world buffs will not. We won’t know until they either say it or we get to one.
1
u/Eretol Sep 27 '26
they work in dungeons so why wouldnt they work in raid? it literally fixes the issue of "needing" 4 shamans and 3 palas per raid, instead we will have 1 prot or holy paladin raid slot (: and maximum class stacking of the highest performing spec
5
u/Ok_Review_195 Sep 27 '26
Trying to remove every piece of 'friction' from the game is how got to retail.
3
u/Brave-Cranberry3026 Sep 27 '26
Retail is also heralded for its excellent Raid mechanics and how every class is actually viable, completely the opposite of Classic where Warriors and Rogues are just leagues ahead of everything else.
1
u/Vyxwop Sep 27 '26
If you've ever formed a raid group then you'll know why raidbuffs are not meaningful friction. It just makes forming groups significantly more obnoxious.
2
u/Vysci Sep 27 '26
At same time though it means you don’t need every class to be perfectly balanced. For example in TBC I play Spriest, my DPS is fucking terrible yet I have a guaranteed raid spot.
1
u/Ok_Review_195 Sep 28 '26
It balances class representation in raids, so that raids aren't only filled with FOTM classes.
0
2
u/TehZiiM Sep 27 '26
Why do you want a Paladin in the melee group? Their auras don’t benefit them really or was retri aura reworked?
6
3
u/tomviky Sep 27 '26
BM hunter is in meele and you are questioning retri pali?
1
u/TehZiiM Sep 27 '26
Oh ye good call just saw Hunter and assumed it’s for trueshot aura
Edit: okay trueshot only gives ranged attack power now.
1
u/LuluIsMyWaifu Oct 01 '26
BM hunter would want bshout for pet and crit from feral. It's actually super awkward now because you can't have wf and agi totem, so if you want to parse you have to cuck your melee group by not letting them have windfury so that you can have full group buffs with agi totem
2
u/dualwieldingcats Sep 27 '26
You need 3 paladins for the buffs so might as have a ret in meele group to give him buffs.
1
1
2
1
u/Paradoxmoose Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
I suspect that people who over-engineer solutions to raiding will be the first to get bored and leave. Time will tell.
Edit- responses to the below replies: We'll see. I think they'll burn through the content and move on to something else to solve.
27
u/DINODOGO Sep 27 '26
Its usually the other way around. People who enjoy min-maxxing stay longer in my experience.
15
20
u/OstrichPaladin Sep 27 '26
The people that overengineer solutions and min max are the people that have been playing classic private servers for 15 years and will continue to min max and play some version of classic for another 15 years
6
u/Drew602 Sep 27 '26
The person who is creating spreadsheets and running sims is going to play longer than a casual player who cant even be bothered to read tooltips i can promise you that
1
u/Vyxwop Sep 27 '26
The people who put in this kind of effort are typically the ones who really enjoy playing the game and therefore stick with it the longest.
It's the casual players who get bored much faster than the dedicated ones.
2
u/EarlyInsurance7557 Sep 27 '26
lol. my guild is running 8 warriors 7 druids, 5 shaman,
-6
u/SheepherderBorn7326 Sep 27 '26
So because your guild doesn’t understand basic prep, the raid buff issue should just stay bad forever?
7
u/EarlyInsurance7557 Sep 27 '26
yes.
11
u/Falceon Sep 27 '26
Sorry to tell you but you cannot goof off when raiding. You must be srs business at all times.
0
2
u/Saaron-_- Sep 27 '26
Why do you need salvation? Horde always managed without it.
9
u/zerolion732 Sep 27 '26
Because furyprot warriors who put out awesome threat in classic don't exist anymore.
→ More replies (2)1
u/johntynz Sep 27 '26
but they got actual threat mechanics in a talent tree to negate the loss of damage by going into def stance.
2
u/RoundAffectionate424 Sep 27 '26
They managed despite not having it, but the issue is so glaring you end with era being 75% alliance on pve servers.
2
u/Fearless_Cover3459 Sep 27 '26
Really think this may be solved by camping. You pick a team, set up camp with the buffs you are missing per group.
2
1
u/arxaion Sep 27 '26
99% sure camping buffs don't carry in.
5
u/PS4bohonkus Sep 27 '26
Why are you so sure? It seems beyond foolish if they don’t. I haven’t seen anywhere where the devs have said they don’t work in raids
2
u/xMoody Sep 27 '26
A bunch of the campfire talents straight up say “inactive in raids or battlegrounds” on them
→ More replies (1)2
u/E6DON Sep 27 '26
I thought it was just world buffs that didn’t and the camping buffs did, not sure 100% but guess we will see!
1
u/FancyConfection1599 Sep 27 '26
Really hope they do, it’d be nice to have blizz to be able to balance dps classes solely on dps rather than on the utility / buffs they bring.
Parsing gets booed here but it’s a big motivator for a lot of players and it sucks when you go into a raid night knowing the one guy who plays the spec you need to maximize damage can’t make it so parsing’s just out the window
-3
u/SolaVitae Sep 27 '26
There's an exactly zero chance they rework the entire group system to work this way to fix an issue that isn't an actual issue. This would be a monumental change to how the game has worked it's entire lifespan.
There's an extremely easy way to not have to worry about this (realistically you won't have to worry about it anyways because pugs are already not this strict) and it's too just open the group finder and press "create group".
Your concept of "bare minimums" is legitimately not real lol. No one is going to be doing anything like that, especially in pugs, unless they are speed running or something.
13
u/Cwaghack Sep 27 '26
You are utterly delusional if you dont think people will minmax group composition
-1
u/SolaVitae Sep 27 '26
Well of course people will.
Enough people to justify massive changes to core functionality of the entire game, or make it impossible for people to get successful groups without doing this though? Absolutely not
5
u/Cwaghack Sep 27 '26
remind me in 3-4 months when people are crying about how they can't get raidspots because of group composition
→ More replies (2)4
u/Competitive-Tooth248 Sep 27 '26
While you might be right to say that you can find a super casual guild (there will be 100 000k+ of players so very likely) this is not 2004 and if any version of classic wow in the last years has showed use anything, then it is that from the guilds that survive first 3 months, 90%+ will care about comp, performance, optimized gear etc. Which is definitely not a minority as you assume.
1
u/Drew602 Sep 27 '26
enough people to justify massive changes?
Yes. You're the one in the minority here
20
u/Competitive-Tooth248 Sep 27 '26
You really don't know the majority of classic wow players nowadays. If you take tbc as an example, even the pugs are demanding as many shamans as groups. There is literally not a guild that doesn't aim to have at least 3 pala and 4 shamans
→ More replies (3)3
u/dm_me_pasta_pics Sep 27 '26
Your concept of "bare minimums" is legitimately not real lol. No one is going to be doing anything like that, especially in pugs, unless they are speed running or something.
Holy moly.
0
u/Illustrious_Sky5329 Sep 27 '26
That is the exact problem people will only want to min max. That is the only way they want to play wow
5
u/a_type_of_tree Sep 27 '26
I don't think it's minmaxing to want buffs. You don't want to be the melee without windfury. Wrath gave raid wide buffs and it resolved some issues but you still needed 3 palas for different blessings for example. Camp fires might help but some buffs are not campfire available.
1
u/Ahties Sep 27 '26
That is not a problem, unless you want it to be problem. Just play the game, you can't always have everything you want
1
u/HodortheGreat 2018 Riddle Master 7/21 Sep 27 '26
Based on this let’s appeal to everyone who might pug: consider not caring about optimal setup. Because it is very cumbersome to achieve.
I actually think this is good for the pug scene. Why? Because if the optimal setup is so strict, then it is much easier to be relaxed on when finding pugs to join your raid. And have only the serious guild care about it.
Here is hoping.
1
u/DafaleHeight Sep 27 '26
On one hand I dont think the difficulty of classic really mandate minmaxxing groups
On another, yeah it make kinda sense to reduce the tedium
You get half a point I guess
1
u/Sabull Sep 27 '26
Thats true just remove blessing of salvation. It's way too powerful but doesnt add anything to gameplay.
1
u/Spleenfull Sep 27 '26
Why shadow priest ? They bring nothing may be ok of they pump but no more shadow damage debuff and they dont have VT.
1
u/Droptoss Sep 27 '26
Yes this is a huge issue. Melee spots will be very tight. With improved expose armour gone there is zero spots for a rogue in raids.
1
1
1
u/herby_the_chef Sep 27 '26
They should make buffs raid wide. The party wide buff system would already turn me off from wanting to raid in this game. Tbc raid comp is the worst for building a raid across all expansions ive ever played
1
u/sikbo1 Sep 27 '26
Meanwhile som guys will get content dun with 11 paladins whom just 1is hitcapped and he da healer.
1
u/KforKaspur Sep 27 '26
I really like that suggestion, it allows players to fill 10 man group niches and then naturally bleed into 20/40 man raiding by combining the 10's, it solves the problem in a classic+ way without taking the friction away completely which I feel is the spirit of what forever is trying to accomplish
1
u/Dixa Sep 27 '26
People are sleeping on hunters because you got classic brain.
Of the phys dps they benefitted the least from world buffs and will not miss them much. Everything scales for them now and their RAP potential was increased even further. Entrapment offers cc if needed. Pets can bring mortal strike if needed, 1 minute duration furious howl instead of being consumed on one hit, and the same armor debuff as locks, Druids and rogues. All while being crazy mobile, and bringing fantastic 3 target cleave since multi no longer had a cd and decent aoe since volley also appears to have no cooldown.
1
u/ExtremePrivilege Sep 27 '26
Zero need for Spriest or Ele shaman. A holy priest can bring divine spirit and PW:F, for example.
There's no Misery, no VT, shadow weaving is now personal. VE has had it's uptime massively reduced.
1
u/_PPBottle Sep 27 '26
watch all this theorycrafting crumble when first Hyjal boss requires niche raid comp to clear on prebis gear, eg like the awful lock requirement for Garr lul
1
u/Outofmana1337 Sep 27 '26
They should've removed salv, 'needing' 3 blessings in a 20man is pure dogshit compwise and instantly makes a prot warrior way less optimal
1
1
u/Odd_Dragonfly_1834 Sep 27 '26
As a holy paladin I will bless you all with light to improve my healing parses!! /s
1
u/xmajson7 Sep 27 '26
Yeah the issue is your last part isn’t wrong.
Luckily my guild and others fix that issue because quite literally and objectively the only reason this is a problem is for people who want to parse. This isn’t a problem in those guilds because they’re willing to fill these roles regardless.
The issue is the pug portion of raiding will follow suit.
The best part is though is this probably won’t be a problem because no one can do raid testing so this is all conjecture on a game version that received no changes to the game via patches where this one will.
So struggle away by choice to chase parse numbers. Sorry for the pugs hope this gets removed because we’re definitely incapable of just playing the game anyways so the player base needs to be forced into having fun.
1
1
1
u/Groot_We_Are Sep 27 '26
I disagree that it's an issue. Baseline it's 1 of every class atm as fights may need a tranq shot(hunter) and there might be disarm mechanics(rogue) or similar like bwl trap room. This may change after we see raid mechanics.
That's already pretty good comp wanting 1 of everything. The stacking of classes is then only 1 more warlock for other curse, probably 1 more shaman if 2 melee groups for wind fury, and then the biggest offender of 2 more pallies for 3 pally buffs but pallies are the hero class so probably won't be an issue to find players interested in that.
This then leaves 7 flex spots when you are already bringing at least 1 of every class. The best thing is each class could be any spec as the buffs/debuffs aren't locked behind specs.
You could of course start to get very min max with wanting certain auras or totems but until we see how much damage the support specs do at end game it could be a nerf to bring them in.
Overall I think it's well balanced with plenty of space for class flexibility and people will still clear raids even if missing half of what I am saying is essential.

1
u/S0ld0ut Sep 27 '26
If you need to minmax to kill raid bosses then you really are dog shit. You'll get more dps by playing well then having the perfect comp.
1
u/thrillho145 Sep 27 '26
Delete salv and put it in tanks. Make totems raid wide.
Big problems solved.
1
u/Sensitive_File6582 Sep 27 '26
TBC raids are also gonna just have to get used to the fact that they will be dealing with suboptimal class ratios.
Provided you have enough for core boss mechanics optimal groupings are gonna just have to be considered a bonus as opposed to a necessity
1
u/The-Fictionist Sep 27 '26
I’ve never wanted to be a guild leader. I have too much responsibility already.
Stupid posts like this make me want to be a guild leader just so I can run raids that say idgaf about composition just show up and don’t be an asshole” because that’s literally how hard classic wow is.
1
u/Sad_Energy_ Sep 27 '26
When will classic players stop minmaxing an easy game?
YOU are putting this on yourself, not any of this is required. If you want to play "optimally" and with "challenges" go play retail. Classic is the wrong game for this....
1
1
u/Foodworkssupervisor Sep 27 '26
People cleared naxx with all dwarves on hardcore I don't think raid comp is gonna matter
1
u/RetPala Sep 28 '26
Bro just do what 99% of actual human beings are doing
Invite all the guildmembers you can and then just try not to stack like 4 of the same class. Unless it's already past time and you gotta get started
Literally who is even spreadsheeting this shit out?
1
u/Erramsteina Sep 28 '26
Am I the only one that thinks if 20man is the de facto raid size they’ll stick with that it will be even MORE sweaty than 40mans?
Like you can get away with having a decent roster of 30 people in a 40man. Hell with forever you can get away with brining 10+ bad specs/classes. But 20 man just seems WAYYYYY too fine tuned.
2
u/I_was_a_sexy_cow Sep 28 '26
What do you mean "even more sweaty then 40 man?" Bruh deadmines at level 45 is more sweaty then 40 man raids
1
u/PalpitationSubject44 Sep 30 '26
U probably want 2 warriors so both melee groups get battleshout (1 prot, 1 fury)
problably also 2 ferals for crit
what is that shadow priest for? There is no vampiric touch. Delete the shadow
group 4 looks good
probably holy priest > diszi
add 4th healer (resto Druid)
fill remaining 2 spots with melees (maybe rogues)
1
u/Vyxwop Sep 27 '26
Yeah, that's definitely looking rough. Camping should make this less of a problem, but that would still be a toss-up hoping that your raiders have the profession that your raid comp is lacking. Campsites also can't be placed inside of a raid and they have a 1 hour CD and they remove on death as well. So you wipe once and now you'll have lost the raid buffs that your raid comp was lacking.
Really hoping they'll take a look at this. Nobody likes dealing with raid buffs to this kind of extend. Even in later expansions when raid buffs were raid wide they were a pain in the ass to form a raid group around.
-1
u/First-Apartment2676 Sep 27 '26
Mf tryina min max the fun out of the game before it's even started. Extreme optimization of raid group has never mattered at any point in tbc or vanilla, please stop 😂
2
u/MrEnzium Sep 27 '26
Having an optimized group makes the run so much smoother and faster. You can take worse people and still have better/easier clears.
1
1
u/Calamari_Gourmet Sep 27 '26
But most people do it. That's the point. Most people play for efficiency. Even if you don't care it's going to affect most guilds and pugs. This is how MMOs have always worked
1
u/tacosdiscontent Sep 27 '26
It’s not just optimization it’s also (I’d say even more importantly) about viability. If you plan on doing any raids, you really don’t want to pick up a a class/spec that most likely will never have a chance at getting a spot in a raid. For example in TBC, even some random pug groups would like to have ideally 4-5 shamans, because who want to struggle to clear a raid when you have like 7 rogues in your group (just an example) people value their time and very rarely do charity cases.
The only non-optimal way to do raid, is if you have guild with irl friends and everyone plays whatever they want.
2
u/fohpo02 Sep 27 '26
I’m willing to bet there’s not a single person in this thread that would actually be impacted by not running optimally. It isn’t necessary to clear content, it’s literally only important for world first, speed clears or pushing 99 parses (and there’s a chance that this theory crafted optimal isn’t even optimal for that).
→ More replies (2)1
u/fohpo02 Sep 27 '26
I’m willing to bet there’s not a single person in this thread that would actually be impacted by not running optimally. It isn’t necessary to clear content, it’s literally only important for world first, speed clears or pushing 99 parses (and there’s a chance that this theory crafted optimal isn’t even optimal for that).
1
u/Dylanxz Sep 27 '26
The assumption will be that the fights aren't designed around your raid having every single buff and the most optimal comp
→ More replies (9)1
u/sneakerrepmafia Sep 27 '26
Yeah but parsers don’t gaf about design philosophy if their number goes up
1
1
u/Seamonsterx Sep 27 '26
The thing that stands out to me is the sudden need for both plenty of shamans and paladins. Previous you’d only have access to one of those classes per faction. And due to smaller raid sizes 3/20 paladonks is a lot more than the 4/40 required previously.
Meanwhile there are classes you can skip taking entirely like rogues, some classes which can be replaced by a scroll (mages) and some that are only worth bringing one of (druid/priest). As it stands optimal raid comps are in tbc levels of rigidity. Either you give these classes with few raid buffs new buffs or you reduce the need to stack the ones with a lot of buffs.
My proposed changes:
- combine wisdom and might into one buff.
- combine salv and kings, but make the salv effect not apply if you are in def stance/bear form/righteous fury.
- make at least some totems raid wide.
- combine curse of recklessness and curse of elements.
- make shadow priests apply a curse of shadow effect as well.
1
u/redux44 Sep 27 '26
In terms of pugs, the raid leader's own preference for loot will outweigh raid composition by a wide margin. After that gear score and prior experience will be next for consideration.
Finally you will get to specific raid compositions. They are probably going to make the raids similar in difficulty to what's found between LFR and normal. LFR for early bosses and normal for later bosses.
For pugs, raid comp isn't that important as the other factors mentioned before.
1
-5
u/Illustrious_Sky5329 Sep 27 '26
Aaaaaand we kill the game before it even releases, sweaty lords that have to min max everything
7
u/Thanag0r Sep 27 '26
Just because you don't raid or raid exclusively in super relax "we kill what we kill" type of guild doesn't mean everyone is the same as you.
→ More replies (6)
0
u/TheZag90 Sep 27 '26
Classic raiding is piss-easy (that’s not a criticism, I like it, but it’s a fact).
If you’re remotely competent you will clear every raid with any class combination you wish.
This is a non-issue.
-2
0
u/lightoo87 Sep 27 '26
Last night we spent 3 hours doing doing the same thing and I really hate this party wide buffs. If this was not the issue we won't need 4 shamans, and 3 or 4 dps Druids and makes raid groups so much easier to make.
2
Sep 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/lightoo87 Sep 27 '26
Just one word for you to show you how clueless you are; tremor.
→ More replies (11)
0
u/ViskerRatio Sep 27 '26
Before you start panicking about level 60 raid composition, you need to wait until we have the information necessary to make those sorts of decisions.
We do not have that information. We don't know about threat, mana management or even how level 60 buff stacking works. We don't have good sims to calculate the impact of buffs and the effectiveness of various specs.
We have a level 20 capped beta right now. All we know is how the game plays at level 20.
1
u/Vyxwop Sep 27 '26
I don't really understand comments like this. What makes you think that people don't already have enough information necessary to make these sorts of decisions? We literally have access to the tooltips of all abilities and talents that as of the beta every class has. These tooltips literally specify that they only affect people in your party. How does getting to level 60 change that?
People aren't looking at the abilities that are available to them right now at level 20, you know. They're looking at the abilities from the class trainer and looking at the talents in their talent tree to make educated guesses.
And what do you mean we don't have good sims to calculate the impact of buffs? Classes on retail have raidbuffs as low as 3% and that's already enough for people to want them in their raid.
1
u/ViskerRatio Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
How easy is it to pull threat off a tank on a raid boss? We don't know. No one has fought any raid bosses with max level characters in Forever. Knowing this is critical to judging the value of buffs like Tranquil Air and Salvation (as well as the value of certain talent choices).
How difficult is mana management in Forever? We don't know. Knowing this is critical to judging the value of abilities like Blessing of Wisdom/Mana Spring Totem.
What is the damage pattern of raid bosses? We don't know. Without this information, we cannot judge the value of HoT vs. direct heals vs. absorbs or the importance of abilities like Inspiration.
What are the actual dps metrics of various specs? We don't know. Adding +3% critical to an entire group looks very different when you've got 5 equivalent dps than if you've got 4 equivalent dps and one dps that lags by 15% giving the buff. We can't even attempt simming dps because we don't know what endgame loot looks like.
How do buffs stack? We don't know if Paladin/Shaman buffs stack. We don't even know what Shaman buffs stack with other Shaman buffs since the group buff totems haven't been released yet. Without this knowledge, any attempt at a 'comp' based on raid buffs is pointless.
Reading a bunch of tooltips gives us a fraction of the information we need to make the kind of predictions the OP is trying to make.
-2
u/Elendar37 Sep 27 '26
Game not even released yet and people trying to optimize and min/max the fun out of the game.
-1
u/PomegranateFast757 Sep 27 '26
Yeah, the game isn't made to be convinient for you. Find a solution. Also you don't need as many shamans
0
u/Varzigoth Sep 27 '26
Camping literally fixed this, the buffs are slightly weaker class buff so that you can bring different classes. Its the first thing people noticed since world buffs won't work in raids but camping does most likely.
And only heavy min maxer's are complaining, that's a you guys problems .
0
u/NegativeYou5539 Sep 27 '26
guys, the content is going top be piss easy, you don’t need min max group comp.

153
u/HokusSchmokus Sep 27 '26
In no world is what you have the bare minimum. This is literally minmaxed. This is the MAXIMUM