Masterpiece.
I completed The Histories by Herodotus, the "Father of History," last week and there is no other way to describe it. In not just his, but the entire subjects', debut Herodotus has captured the entire field. Much has been made of the breadth of this work, but I want to talk about the depth.
Herodotus is shockingly even handed in his treatment of barbarians and Hellenes; at Plataea he attributes the Persians loss in the melee not to some moral failing of theirs but to their inferior armaments and even compliments their valour. It completely shatters the pop-history conception of all ancient history as nothing but flatterers blowing smoke up someone's ass. When he discusses the Scythians or the Egyptians he recounts customs completely at odds with those of the Hellenes, but he doesn't condemn them; rather he actually points out that all people would find their own customs best!
He also critically engages with his sources. Infamously when he describes the voyage of the Phoenicians around Africa he dismisses it as nonsense because it is said that the sun began to rise on their left rather than right at one point, which is exactly the fact which confirms the veracity of the story to modern scholars. At many points he recounts a story from multiple viewpoints and explicitly labels each viewpoint so the reader can assess their biases, and sometimes addresses the biases himself. Occasionally he even cites his specific source by name.
I have heard much made of his tendency to digress and how it bothers some. Frankly I find that ludicrous. Herodotus clearly loved learning and wished to share that with his readers, so anything he had learned he wanted to put in the text. Sometimes we get imperial Persian love affairs and sometimes we get stories about Scythians hotboxing tents. It's all riveting. In many ways the digressions are the soul of the text. They are where he shines the brightest.
Similarly he infamously bears the competing sobriquet "Father of Lies" due to some of his more outlandish statements. This is unjustified and is motivated, I believe, by the desire to be iconoclastic on the part of his critics. Sure, ants aren't digging gold out of hills in India and chasing horses that enter their territory, but there have been claims that marmots do occasionally unearth gold nuggets there, and that in translation a wire could have been crossed. There are no giant flying snakes eating locusts in Egypt, but how was he to know? He was reporting what he was told and he was determined to include as much information as he could. It's absurd to condemn someone for getting a fact wrong when they couldn't possibly know otherwise. And, given his determination to write as wide ranging a book as possible, it would be actively counter to his intention to leave out pieces of information which are unverifiable to him, Many of his correct assertions are equally unverifiable!
The translation I read was The Landmark Herodotus and I found it to be excellent. The prose was easy to read, there were many footnotes with extra information, an extensive glossary, and a whole series of appendices regarding different topics which the reader may have more questions about.
There is a reason we still talk about Herodotus and this reddit post cannot possibly do him justice. If you have any interest in the classics you must read The Histories.