I have a confession to make, and I suspect it may cost me my membership in the Church of Classical Guitar.
I don't particularly like Bach.
There. I've said it. Someone alert the conservatories.
Now, before the high priests of counterpoint assemble their pitchforks, allow me to clarify. I recognize Bach's extraordinary contrapuntal skill, his command of musical architecture, and his historical importance. I've studied his music, performed it, and spent more than a little time examining its construction.
I simply don't worship at his altar.
And that brings me to something I've found increasingly peculiar about the classical guitar world: our seemingly compulsory reverence for a composer who never wrote a single authenticated work specifically for our instrument.
Bach has become something of a sacred measuring stick. Play Bach well, and you're a serious musician. Question his supremacy, and suddenly you're a heretic.
The guitar possesses an extraordinary repertoire spanning centuries, cultures, and radically different musical imaginations. Yet we sometimes behave as though its highest artistic achievement is reproducing the music of an eighteenth-century German organ player.
Perhaps the problem isn't Bach at all.
Perhaps it's our insistence that greatness must have a hierarchy, that complexity necessarily implies profundity, and that musical taste ought to submit to academic authority.
I can admire a composer's craftsmanship without finding his music particularly moving when played on the guitar. I can recognize genius without enjoying its expression. And I can question a tradition without being ignorant of it.
Music is not a religion. Composers are not gods. And the concert hall is not a cathedral.
So here's my heretical question:
If we stopped treating Bach as sacred, would we actually hear his music differently?
Or, more provocatively, might we finally give the rest of the guitar repertoire the attention it deserves?
Now, if you'll excuse me, I believe the counterpoint police are at my door.