r/circlebroke • • Mar 21 '16

dOK] Redditors said something I disagree with

0 Upvotes

One quote from a random person.

Another quote from some other guy agreeing

Bonus! Quote taken out of context

Something that is obviously satire

At this point the rest of us pretend like there isn't a many different opinions on subreddit and pretend there is a single hivemind!


r/circlebroke • • Dec 11 '12

Boring picture + sappy backstory = front page.

1 Upvotes

Fuck this bullshit.

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/14mvru/for_21_years_i_never_knew_who_my_biological/

Why the fuck do people not understand that /r/pics is for interesting PICTURES? How fucking hard is that to comprehend? Have an interesting story to share? POST IT SOMEWHERE ELSE. Jesus Fucking Christ.

I wish I could go to the house of every asshole who upvoted that post and take a shit on their bed. Then, when they freak out, I say "Oh yeah, I know there was some other subroom in your house specifically made for shitting and technically the bedroom isn't for shitting, but this is a bigger subroom where more people are likely to see it."


r/circlebroke • • Nov 24 '12

Reddit and porn

0 Upvotes

Two things:

One thing Reddit loves to circlejerk about is how breasts aren't shown on American television. Rabble Rabble "Censorship" Rabble Rabble "Free speech" Rabble. You know the drill. They love to talk about how breasts aren't pornographic, AmeriKKKans are afraid of breasts, etc. However, at the slightest mention of bare breasts in TV, you get a bunch of mouthbreathing neckbears ogling them. So which is it? Honestly, I avoid HBO and friends for this very reason. I'm not kidding when I say that I don't think I've ever seen an episode of a show on there that didn't have the word fuck or nudity in it. Pretty much the epitome of pandering. I mean, I've literally seen examples of nonsexual dialogue with women standing there, inexplicably shirtless. WTF does that add to the plot, or, anything?

Also, I've just about had it up to here with the -porn suffix. It's not clever or funny. It's just stupid, trite, and puerile. Things like justiceporn don't even make sense. Wouldn't the correct metaphor be justiceerotica?

In short, Reddit, stop sexualizing everything. Some of us aren't 13.


r/circlebroke • • Oct 23 '12

SRS-lite Approved The sublime banality of frontpage misogyny (i.e. have we mentioned today that fat women are disgusting?)

15 Upvotes

Absolutely everyone on reddit is straight, male, and has a crushing sense of penis-deflating horror at the sight of fat women. Or so we can be so generously reminded by today's lineup of frontpage posts, lovingly screenshot here for your enjoyment.

Without even pursuing the comments, these two frontpage posts, helpfully upvoted right next to each other, remind us of two things: nothing is more appalling than fat women, and nothing is more pleasing than Natalie Portman and Hollywood's cadre of impossibly thin women.

Actually, what it really reminds us of is that, of all the content on the internet, what reddit found the most interesting this particular day was that fat women are gross and thin women are hot. Upvotes to the left, fuckers, stroke your e-peens and pick that lint out of your ghostly white pudgy bellies, because you -- fine specimen of humanity -- are uniquely qualified to judge the worthiness of women! With science, no less!

Grab your smelling salts, circlebrokers, because here come the comments.


Let's start this out on a high(?) note, and wax poetics (beardy poetics) about Natalie Portman.


Our top comment lets us know that:

>Natalie, you are a bad ass bitch.

Because nothing says compliment like a slur. But below that, we really get reddit gold. Highest voted comment of the thread, reddit is invited to:

>"yo shut the fuck up and suck my dick" - Natalie Portman

"Yo, we are incredibly heterosexual men. And as such, we think vaginas are gross and assign penises to women we approve of" - Reddit.

Our second comment follows the usual script of such threads:

>Damn. I wanna be all up in Natalie's port.... maaaan

Expression of male heterosexual approval + asinine pun. Everything that follows is much of the same, so I'll spare you all the intellectually stimulating details.

Please note: Apparently I have overlooked some pop culture references I have never been privy to. My bad and all apologies. Still, my point that reddit likes thin women still stands, yes?


Now, we get to the fun part. Clutch your pearls, gentlemen, because we're about to discuss the most terrible of things. What is that, you may ask? The Holocaust? Black people? Romney? Gawker? SOPA?!?

No, I speak of something far more terrible. Fat women.


Top comment:

TIL: Fat people are ugly on the inside too!

Because thin people aren't unsightly sacks of blood and pus on the inside?

Another upvoted comment suggests that fat women have additional mouths.

One particularly nice exchange featured many cannibalism references, and one particularly confused person who thought that the black spots in the scan where feces, rather than trapped air.

We really approach the Supreme Jerk when we get to edgy "scientific" discussions of fat, health, and fitness. Someone observes:

proof that there is no such thing as big boned. The bones are the same size.

What follows is a nice informed idea what really goes on inside the human body. Similar "scientific" jerks happen here on bones and here on ankles.

Finally, we have a genuine fat person wander haplessly into the thread. What nuggets of wisdom can they impart that the hivemind will find relevant?

I wanna stop being fat now


And there you have it Circlebroke! A thread about how hot it is to be thin, and how terrible it is to be fat. And how very much we value the "science" you have to share with the community as a thin man on the subject of fat women. If you'd like to contribute to the discussion of hot women as a woman... well, you're kind of shit out of luck. If you'd like to contribute to the discussion of fat women as a fat person or a woman, please come prepared with your Thin PersonTM PhD or Fat Person's crippling sense of self-loathing for our appreciation. Thanks.


r/circlebroke • • May 21 '13

Brave Post /r/Games proves how completely out-of-touch it is with modern technology habits.

2 Upvotes

EDIT: Many of the comments I have outlined have now been deleted by the mods of /r/games. Way to go mods!

http://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/1ersld/official_rgames_next_genxbox_thread/

Today was the official announcement of the new Xbox platform, officially titled Xbox One. I was blessed to be off work, so I turned off Arrested Development for an hour to watch the press conference. At the same time, /r/Games was hosting a live discussion thread for the conference. It's as bad as you probably think.

The new Xbox is supposed to be an all in one entertainment system, on top of being a video game console. Seriously, this thing is fucking amazing. If it does half the shit that the tech demo showed, you'll cum right there on the sofa from just turning the damn thing on. Live TV, internet, sports integration with your fantasy team, voice and hand motions for even more shit. This is the fucking Enterprise of gaming consoles. BUT, since it's more than just a game console, /r/games can't help but hate it.

God for-fucking-bid a company use new technology to make it's products better and hopefully capture a new audience. This is designed for the new generation of gaming. One that encompasses multiple levels of technology, allowing for one system to manage your cable box, internet, video chats, social media, ON TOP OF being a video game system.

I was watching this thread develop in real time, so I decided to wait and let the dust settle before losing my mind in this post. Now, 5 hours later, the top comments have cemented, and we can accurately assess the circlejerk. I'd also like to thank the tireless mods of /r/games. When that thread started, and even two hours later, it was a shithole. Now, I'm looking around and seeing "comment deleted or removed" all over the place. That being said, there's still plenty to talk about.

“Xbox, watch ESPN”
“Sorry, ESPN is not available in your country.”
“Xbox, play music.”
“Sorry, Xbox Music is not available in your country.” (+1687)

This is a legitimate concern, for people in Europe and Asia. This is not, however, the fault of Microsoft. They cannot be blamed for content holders refusing the rights to their products, based on archaic and backwards system of content distribution. We cannot blame microsoft for including and developing these features because their largest market is the United States. Of course, this line of reasoning is completely lost on /r/games.

They should just rename it to the USbox One already.

This, When they said that it can control your tv I immediately said >out loud 'No it can't'. Because It can't in my house, as it stands my tv is connected to my ps3 via a hdmi. I don't have or want sky/satellite tv so it can't be controlled in the way Microsoft are describing.

Adam Sessler tweeted that they plan on having TV stuff in 41 countries. (this comment is at the bottom)

Shifting gears, lets tackle the line of reasoning in the next series of top level comments.

"Cloud-powered internet." I don't even. (+1204)

You don't even what? You don't even understand marketing? You don't even understand how to market to somebody other than you? You don't even need a valid reason to hate this thing, so you're just gonna make something out of nothing?

"Xbox is to become the next watercooler". Seriously someone on the stage just said that (+700)

"What's a water cooler? We don't have those at my high school. Is it like a Mountain Dew machine?"

am i the only one that doesnt wanna talk to my television like a crazy person? (+1127)

Everything sounds shitty out of context. Spider-Man is just this teenager who's body is going through weird changes and now he can shoot sticky white goo all over the place (Source: cracked.com).

Xbox infinity was a much better name.

No it fucking wasn't.

  • Xbox

  • Xbox 360

  • Xbox One

MS doesn't know how to count.

Neither does Valve, but you'll suck their cock all night long.

Sony Stocks going up

"I don't know shit about investing trends."

Cheering is not coming from the press. They pay people to do this.

That's just pathetic...

There's no proof that they are "paying people" for this. Chances are, everyone at Xbox went to the conference instead of working. If my company was showing off the awesome shit I was working on, I'd be excited too.

Stop acting like gamers like Kinect

"I don't understand other people's interests."

Instant bad vibes from this presentation. Games are gonna be secondary.

No shit, you dense motherfucker. This is a TECH DEMO. THERE WILL BE TECHNOLOGY DEMONSTRATED HERE. ANYTHING ELSE IS SECONDARY TO SHOWING OFF WHAT THE HARDWARE/SOFTWARE CAN DO. PULL YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR FUCKING ASS LONG ENOUGH TO THINK ABOUT THE CONCEPT OF OTHER PEOPLE AND THEIR INTERESTS. STOP PRETENDING TO HAVE ASPERGER'S LONG ENOUGH TO THINK OF THE BIGGER PICTURE, YOU GREEDY, IMPATIENT, WHINY LITTLE SHITS.

Christ, I need a fucking cigarette.


r/circlebroke • • Feb 03 '15

TLDR TIL didn't read the article again. xpost /r/ShitAmericansSay

0 Upvotes

Yesterday evening there was a post on /r/TodayILearned entitled:

TIL that the United States host by far more immigrants than any other country in the world at 19.8% of total. The next country is Russia, at 4.8%

The post was deleted because it was (R.4), political, and (R.5), inaccurate (a Murica circlejerk catalyst is inaccurate? You don't say!). The article shows that America holds 19.8% of immigrants in the world, which isn't surprising since America (and their runner ups, Russia and Germany), have massive infrastructure to support such a large population (they're just so BIG!), thus not that worthwhile of an achievement. Anybody who bothered to actually click on the link (and as you'll realize sooon below, nobody actually did) you'll see that a percentage of immigrants of the country can be categorized in the column to the right, where it shows Vatican City being no.1 at 100% (lmao), followed by a plethora of countries, including: United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Brunei, Hong Kong, Switzerland, Australia, Israel, Kazakhstan, Canada, Estonia, Sweden, Ireland, etc. The US is 14.3%, which isn't even in the top 50.

According to the populations of /r/circlebroke and the like, Reddit is such an anti-American circlejerk. While anybody who isn't a deluded, sheltered American Redditor can easily prove otherwise, this thread reaches critical pro-Murica jerking, with very little voice of reason. My thesis is that the thread was deleted before European Redditors woke up. No biggie, it helps us analyse the specifically American Reddit user otherwise.

So, let's dig in, shall we? WARNING: EXTREME MURICANNESS AHEAD. PLEASE WEAR ANTI-FREEDOM PROTECTION BEFORE PROCEEDING.

>We are a nation of immigrants. If at no other time am I proud to be an American, I am when this topic comes up. [+308]

Technically, we are all immigrants. Brits are just immigrants from continental Europe, Spaniards are just immigrants from Rome, etc. However, if you don't want to be pendatic, I don't see Canadians, Australians, New Zealanders, or practically every country mostly consisting of the descendants of colonizers beat their chests for their country over this.

>b-b-b-bu we're racist, xenophobic idiots, we hate non americans. [+6]

American persecution complex: exhibit 1.

>The United States has ten times the population, so its not a big deal at all that there are so many immigrants in the country. >>Are you assuming that I think it's bad? Because it sounds like you are insinuating something...... It's not a big deal at all- contrary to some who think otherwise, we have the infrastructure to support 45 million immigrants. [+26]

That's... not what he said... at all...

>People are pretty pissed off that others want to live in the USA and not Sweden. [+77]

American persecution complex: exhibit 2.

Also, lmao at the "SWEDEN" circlejerk, which is a strawman circlejerk at this point, like "fedora tippers" and the such. Half of Reddit hates Sweden because of acceptance of immigrants, while the other half thinks Reddit worships Sweden because they spend too much time on /r/circlejerk and not knowing about the world.

>Did someone say Sweden? to the top comment it goes!! [+14]

>Oh god who would want to live in such a cuck of a nation [+3]

Thus proving my point.

>There are tons of countries (like Canada) that host more immigrants as a percentage of their population. [+198] >>An Austrian moving to Germany doesn't fucking count. [+5]

And why the fuck not?

>And it would be much higher if we didn't have immigration controls. The United States is by far the most desirable place to live, despite the constant complaining of its residents. As of 2013, there were about 138,000,000 immigrants ready to move to the United States if they had the opportunity, more than any other country by far. Roughly 3% of the entire world would say goodbye to their homeland and move to the USA if they could.

More propaganda-like distortion. The Gallup poll in the link describes the ideal country each country would like to live, which is completely to "if we didn't control the immigration everybody would come here." and, frankly, has no strong correlation to immigration trends. Also to note that in the "Countries From Which the Highest Percentage of the Population Would Like to Move to the US" chart, most are from third world African or Central American countries where most exhibits of a better life outside the country comes from American media. Wanting to live in America because you like rewatches of Friends isn't the same as planning and plotting which country outside your country would be the best for you.

>ITT: Butthurt Europeans who want to use other metrics to show why immigrants love coming to their country. [+51]

HOW DARE THOSE DERN YURAPEENS USE ['MATH' AND 'READING' AND 'STATISTICS' AND ALL DAT SHEET], THIS HERE'S MURICA, WE AIN'T HAVIN NONE OF THAT!

And it gets worse:

>And their "immigrants" are about as thrilling and diverse as a Dane moving six miles south to Germany. They probably would consider Irish moving to Northern Ireland as "immigrants" too. It's like counting immigration to Nebraska by including anyone who moved there from Kansas. [+27]

Murica so diverse! It's already clearly obvious to anybody with at least double digit IQs on why US states are nowhere near comparable to different fucking countries so I'll leave that, but this perplexes me: "as thrilling and diverse as a Dane moving six miles south to Germany". What's wrong with that? How is that different from a Mexican, the biggest immigrants to the the US, moving six miles north to the US?

>"We're so open and diverse, why are Americans so- OH MY GOD A BLACK PERSON!" [+12]

Good old "Eurofags are racist!" bullshit thrown in for good measure. And when I mean "good measure, I mean 'facepalm-worthingly inaccurate and beaten to death':

>Yeah, way to use a minority view to represent all of us. [-8] >>Throws banana at black football player. [+6] >>>holds rally against entire muslim population. hopes gypsys get murdered while simultaneously acting smug about how progressive they are [+8] >>>>Has neo-Nazi political parties [+3] >>>>>bans religious wear targeting muslims "muh culture literally can't survive with kebab places in town" [+3]

What the fuck is this? Why are you proving the OP's point? Not only is all of those minority views, but they can all be disparged by the fact that the US does all of this and sometimes worse:

  • Americans throwing bananas at black players is not unheard of

  • Using racial slurs in the Premier League and other high British play is an easy fine or disqualification. In the US it's all fine and dandy because "muh free speech"

  • "Euros are racist banana throwers" is [essentially anti-soccer propaganda that comes from ESPN.(www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-iRLmaZf4A), notice how ridiculous the report is with similarly shared "Murica diverse, Yuropoors racist" sentiment.

  • Americans throwing rallies against Muslims. And another one.

  • In the first one they're rallying against Muslims donating to charity and supporting a woman's shelter. In the second they're protesting against Muslims marching for peace in remembrance of 9/11. As bigoted and toxic as EDL and PEGIDA are, they're usually rallies against events a bit more plausible, but still not justifiable.

  • Who the fuck are these "gypsies" I'm supposed to hate? I actually had to do some research into them and it seems that gypsies are a derogatory term (gg Americans, attacking racism by being racists, although that's what most "EUROPE RACIST" shitposters are anyway) that refers to any travelling group, including Roma (who I assume they're talking about) and Irish Travelers (which are more common in my country). They don't seem to recognize that Europe isn't one massive blob of socialism, but American Redditor ignorance of this scale isn't common.

  • Acting smug of being 'more progressive' is far more American, as all the evidence in this sub can state.

  • Americans would never have neo-Nazi groups! Nope! Never! American Redditors seem to have this bizzare opinion that the country of Yurope is dominated with far right political groups. With the exception of some Eastern European groups such as Jobbik and Golden Dawn, they are rare and/or a complete laughing stock. The policies of most European anti-immigration groups (which I in no way agree with), such as the Swiss People's Party or the Swedish Democrats, are more relateable to that of the Republican Party.

  • By banning religious wear I'm assuming they mean banning the burqa in France or the hijab in schools. You'd think by the resounding applause in /r/worldnews they'd actually like this, but the thing is that a) burqas are banned because of identification purposes, not anti-Islam ones - Muslim women can still wear hijabs or niqabs, and b) all religious wear, including cross necklaces or kippahs, are to be hidden in French schools and institutions, which is accordance to a policy of secularism.

There's more of this bullshit later in the thread:

>True. Or the exact opposite, they get the bottom of the barrel immigrants nobody else wants (one nice thing about having oceans on both sides of the US is that only the cream of the crop from other countries, excluding the Central American nations, get to come to the US). Very few highly skilled people from, say, China or India, want to move to most Western European nations outside of the UK. Why would they? The languages are hard to learn, and them and their children will never be truly accepted by their new nations.

America is diverse and totally not racist! It's because we have all the good immigrants see :^). Thus proving my original point of Murica diverse being a shadow of racism. Additionally: Continental European languages are hard to learn and they racist so that's why they don't want to go there. That's right! If you're decadent of somebody from an developing or underdeveloped country, you're not accepted! Doesn't matter how long you've lived your country and your experiences,

Muricans know your country better than you!

>This is always a great thing to bring up whenever Europeans hate on the US. "If the United States sucks so much, then why the fuck are there so many people that want to move here?" They never have a legit response besides fuck fat people or some such shit. [+30]

Ah, the effects of pro-Murican inaccuracy to the front page are strong! If you hate Saudi Arabia and Qatar because of their poor human rights, then why does everybody want to go there?? I mean, they actually have more immigrants in there than the US does.

>Because there's no fucking jobs in Europe. [+14]

All of Yurop is unemployed. Forget that the US has overtaken my country in unemployment, which is quite the accomplishment considering the amount of young people on the dole around here.

>>And it's full of Europeans. [+26]

Dat anti-American circlejerk! Truly, Americans are the most persecuted group of people on Reddit. I wonder how this comment's vote ratio would look like if it was with Americans instead of Europeans?

>>>And ultranationalist dicks who want to kill/deport anyone who is black, Roma, Muslim and not from their country. So Europeans. cough /r/european cough [+3]

Yes, 500 million people want to deport and kill minorities. Completely disregarding the Americanly ignored fact of European nations accepting more people in their country than Europe, why on earth is his proof for this an a white nationalistic subreddit with 1k subscribers? That's like saying the US is incredibly racist because of /r/coontown.

>Wait but I thought that everyone gets a job and a stipend and 9 months of vacation in Europe? [+5] >>its also a le atheist paradise [+4] >>>tips free healthcare [+2]

See my previous comment about the Sweden circlejerk for my thoughts on this bullshit. Plus, I like how they imply that paid vacations and universal healthcare is a bad thing because America has more immigrants, which isn't even true.

>Don't you know anything OP? If you put anything positive about the U.S. people will come from all over to give you shit. [+23]

American persecution complex: exhibit 3. Remember, this is the same kind of poster who posts "there is no such thing as a pro-American circlejerk" on /r/circlebroke.

>No shit. I love my country, and respect outside criticism....but god damn- I can't even call this hate. This is just stupid. [+24]

No, you're getting "hate" because you made an inaccurate thread to paint the picture of the US being #1 to rile up 'MURICA morons and use goalpost-avoiding tactics like earlier when questioned on this.

>I laugh when Europeans try to talk about how diverse their countries are because there's a lot of Scots living in England. [+17]

Link me one, literally just one post of any "European" saying that. Celts living in Anglo-Saxon territory could be considered proof of cultural diversity within the UK, but they're not immigrants.

>Uhm... switzerland checking in with with >28% foreigners (relative) compared to the lousy 14% of the US... Comparing absolute numbers is ridiculous... [+13] >>Yeah temporary workers from exotic lands like Italy and Germany. [+128]

What kind of bullshit is this? First, Swiss temporary workers aren't considered immigrants in the 28% statistic. Secondly, Switzerland has a lot of Turkish, Balkan and Asian immigrants, that's definently exotic. Second, "exoticy" is a stupid, invalid metric. The US isn't exactly "exotic" either. Its largest immigrants are Mexicans, also a bordering country.

What are you doing posting positive facts about the United States? Don't you realize how unpopular that is on the internet? Pssh this will barely get you 300 comments in 8 hours, loser.

American persecution complex: exhibit 487104.

There's even more in the thread that I can't be bother of laughing at. This is just the upvoted shit, responses to voices of reason which has been downvoted are too far gone (RIP ;_;). That's all for now.


r/circlebroke • • Jun 10 '13

Oh my f**k, this entire thread. I'm done. /r/atheism has truly outdone itself.

16 Upvotes

http://np.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/1fru5l/there_is_something_that_made_this_sub_the_first/

Holy fucking shit. The level of completely unironic jerking in that thread is too much for me to bear. I cannot handle it anymore.

However, let's examine probably the shittiest comment in the entire thread:

Maybe it's because I live in Europe, but for me /r/atheism is exactly like a bunch of 6 years old kid bashing the ones who still believe in Santa. It's neither fun, interesting or enlightening. It's just pathetic, annoying and boring. All the memes, the "So true" posts, the "philosophical" quotes on a hubble picture background, the "My 4yo kid" or "My granpa said this, I'm so proud". Seriously...

Because there are literally NO religious people in Europe! The Pope is clearly a atheist scientist, not like. . .Catholic or anything. Also The abrahamic God is LITERALLY metaphysically equivalent in every way to Santa Claus. Wow, for people who are so "logical" they sure do love those good old straw men.

Except that Santa's adherents are still lobbying for legislation on behalf of their Christmas carols, struggling against marriage and civil equality, retarding scientific and medical progress, attacking academics, shrugging off anthropomorphic climate change, shunning those who quit Santa's workshop, and building museums showing their ancestors living alongside long extinct reindeer. That's just in America. Bashing that is not only fun, but useful. When people do these things in the name of worship and scripture, they should be openly mocked.

where do I even begin with this shit. . .

Imagine those Santa believing kids trying to pass legislation based on a belief in him. Imagine them trying to control your life. It is actually brave in America for a politician to admit to being atheist. I'm sure there are several prominent ones who say the necessary "Christ is my savior" lines with a little vomit in their mouths.

DAE Obama is a closet atheist?!?!?

Fuck r/atheism, seriously.


r/circlebroke • • Jul 24 '13

Louis CK has a "take" on some serious business, isn't funny in r/funny. Cheering ensues, circlejerks in every direction.

13 Upvotes

While reddit's worship of Louis C.K. as an endless spring of social commentary and life philosophy is ridiculous, at least it's usually rooted in something funny. We like what he has to say because it is funny and relatable, while also a handy tool for confirming and justifying our weird agendas. You can't just call someone a faggot with a straight face - you have to be laughing while you do it, then everything is okay.

Thus, when there is no actual joke attached to whatever obscene new thing Louis CK says, I don't understand why anyone would be interested, let alone laud him for it. That's the whole point of a "take," right - a unique and (presumably in this case) funny perspective on a certain situation? One which is maybe enlightening, or at least amusing? But today, on the self-proclaimed "front page" of the world wide web, was the headline of the entire internet, the funniest thing in the world as we know it, "LOUIS C.K.'S TAKE ON ROLLING STONE."

The post is a screenshot with ugly text overlaid on it in which CK responds to a question by a popular interviewer (screenshots of comedy are popular because they capitalize via imgur on immense link karma, despite losing all of the important elements of comedy - like timing - in doing so). So what is CK's worthwhile, head-of-the-whole-internet, soapbox-for-a-generation-of-pop-cultural-armchair-activists, slightly offensive but humorous take on Rolling Stone that thousands of people just had to see?

"Well they put that kid on the cover that blew up Boston so Fuck them I don't care what they say."

That's literally it. That's the whole thing, the punchline. "so Fuck them I don't care what they say." That's the philosopher-comedian-king-poet's "take" on a super relevant contemporary issue.

I was underwhelmed. Not because I have a stake in the issue - the Rolling Stone cover is not an issue I am inclined to engage with, and wouldn't voice my opinion anyway because it's not like every issue (pun) is black and white, anyway. (So in true Platonic form of Circlebroke style, I really intend to discuss reddit's circlejerk itself, and not join it on one side. There are no sides here, except perhaps a smug and a smuggier side.) I was underwhelmed because there was just nothing to it - where was the joke? What was the point? Just someone saying "so Fuck them?"

So, anyway, these days reddit is pretty self-loathing and in some cases self-aware, and you can at least expect the top comment to call out the nature of the post in some way, whether it's a repost, based on false premises, a lousy submission, karma-whoring, etc. In fact, this aspect is so strong that it is now a regular attachment to posts - to the point where these criticism-comments are usually more inaccurate or low-quality than the posts themselves, which then garner respect sub-comments correcting/complaining the parent comments; on and on and on...

But Louis CK gets away this time. He just clean gets away with it! No smug, sardonic, cocky bastard steps in to say, "This post is not funny and has no content and exists expressly in the interests of feeding the hivemind the semen it needs to subsist on." Despite the highest submission to a place called r/funny, ostensibly meant to be one of the funniest places on the internet, and not actually being anyway remotely funny, and only playing into the hands of one side of a silly slightly-agenda-based circlejerk of epic proportions, no top comments - if any comments at all - have any criticism for this post, whether in form or in content. Louis CK is evidently so established in his domain of internet-king that he can simply utter a popular (if not controversial) opinion with the word "Fuck" in it, and no one even bats an eyelid, but instead propagate that quote for millions to see in endless love and adoration, as though it were funny - another stand-up bit or something that contributed to the culture of comedy and comedic appreciation.

Now the good part. The action-sequence of the circlejerk - the comments. And the top comment could not be better - I could not make up a more perfect, honest, non-ironic, redditor response to this submission. I honestly had to see if I was in circlejerk at this point, and for the brief moment I thought I actually was, I was actually laughing. But then I realized I was simply in /r/funny, and the laughter went away, and was replaced with amazed disbelief.

Glad someone with a following isn't afraid to say it +954

So that's what the tone for these comments are going to be, I see. Let me just run that by you again.

Glad someone with a following isn't afraid to say it +954

Literally no one on the entire media circuit - including the newspapers and blogs that feed reddit - have even once been brave enough to say "so Fuck them" to RS, who we hate of course forever and always, and anyone with a following who could stand up to the robber barons and Bildeberg group and say, just for once with a heart full of gold, "Fuck you" to the almighty empire that is Rolling Stone magazine, well, just frankly isn't brave enough to. But now that someone with a following was brave enough to say "it", maybe we, the proud followers, can finally rally to the cause of our glorious leader without having to really think for ourself or anything?

(Sorry, I tend to get carried away with this stuff. I realize it's all petty in the first place, and it's especially petty for me to get riled up over. Cut me some slack, I'm bored with my life and drunk.)

Really, why would he be afraid to say it? The press has done nothing but criticize that cover. It would be a risk if he defended Rolling Stone. +1973

Good, at least a comment to check the top sentiment before it gets out of hand. But here is simply the other side of the debate presented. The fact that it has twice the net upvotes that the other comment does suggests the hivemind agrees with the counter-sentiment more than the original.

But if there's one thing that we don't have enough of yet in this comment chain, it's opinionation.

As a non-American, I find it ridiculous that people are mad they put him on the cover, when he was on the cover of every fucking newspaper and his face shown on TV across hundreds of news channels across the United States. The fact that LCK has jumped on this bandwagon doesn't say much for his credibility. The RS story is also ten times better than most of the garbage presented as news throughout the Boston bombing coverage.

EDIT: Judging by the responses, I can see why people got mad. They've never read Rolling Stone, and really don't understand the magazine's heritage as a source of current affairs analysis and serious journalism. They just look at the pretty covers and think it's just about rock stars. +851

It's not that I disagree or agree with anything he's saying, really. I don't even need to read it, really, to understand what's going on. By the time I read "As a non-American," I just gloss over with familiarity. Please, tell us your opinion about this relevant non-issue as a non-American, and then, PLEASE, brush off all the dissenting replies you receive as people who "just don't really get it, man," that RS is a relevant source of "current affairs analysis and serious journalism." Yeah man, everyone else is like, shallow and pedantic. I bet they even read Playboy for the pictures. Faggots, amirite, or am I Louis CK?

There is a difference between the fear mongering news and glorifying him on the cover of a magazine. ...Isn't there? +413

CHA-CHING! C-C-C-C-Combo! A new jerk has sprung out of the old jerk! How many more will there be? Quick, while we're still hot, someone regurgitate something you read the last time this circlejerk started on a thread 2 minutes ago and spawn a new circlejerk!

Hitler was Time's Man of the Year. +340

Frankly, I'm surprised this one wasn't sooner, if not top comment itself. If I have to read this pithy, rotting-horse-carcass of a comment one more time on this website... (Second only to the infinite jewel of eternal wisdom, "Anyone who is willing to give up liberty for security, deserves neither"TM QED checkmate, niggers (yeah I said nigger, Y U MAD, u even Chris Rock bro?).

Anyway... some discussions take place, and they go on basically forever, with the same two or three sentiments repeated in unison ad nauseum, which is fair enough - that's how reddit works, I guess. Hell, that's how discussion works. There's two sides, firmly entrenched, and they angrily launch mortars at each other until one has more upvotes than the other, and then nobody wins and everyone goes home angry and still firmly entrenched.

The rest of the parent comments tend to, like the good bulk of comments, just espouse one side of the "issue," angrily denouncing the other half as obviously totally ignorant, while still ignoring how shitty and unfunny and completely irrelevant the actual post is.

I mean, c'mon. Let's go back to the post itself for a minute. It's just the ESSENCE of circlejerk. It's the pulpy, still-beating heart of the inane, politicized, thoughtless, ultra-consumable media culture of reddit. The Great European-American Louis CK Jerk. At this point it's even greater than the George Carlin super-jerk of the last generation. Literally everything he says is a "take," and is the most important and funny thing on the internet (so long as you can screencap it and host it on imgur, of course). It's a one-liner without a joke to it, and about as worthwhile as a reddit comment - "Fuck them, who cares what they say. +1588 Edit: thanks for the gold guys, but next time give it to someone who really needs it, like Wil Wheaton)"

"Fuck Rolling Stone." That's it. And it is literally the bravest "take" in existence. Finally, someone with a following is not afraid to say it!!! And the comments, as a whole, just go along with this premise, as though this post is implicitly worth engaging in! No one even simply says "That's not funny, it's not even a joke," as lousy a comment as that would be. Just more opinions about Rolling Stone.

Am I the only one who has no problem with the cover? +354

DAE other side of this issue?

Boston native here, no problem with it. +107

"As a gay man, I have no problem with faggot. Lighten up, faggots."

They can suck a bag of dicks. +35

A couple of people even dare to express a slight feeling of disappointment creeping in over the worship of their glorious CK, but for the most part 95% of the comments are restating the same opinions/counter-opinions to infinity and back. There are an awful lot of "the problem is," comments, which carry a haughty meaninglessness with them when every other post with more than ten upvotes tells us what "the problem is," as though we could finally put the issue to rest (god, I wish) because you told us what it is, and that's that, and everything is settled and morally is objective.

Also, needless to say, Osama bin Laden and Adolf Hitler are mentioned every chance someone gets, and always in the exactly same, slightly irrelevant, fashion.

But one clever cookie seems to see how futile these things are with reddit...

Boston bomber pics make it to the front page of Rolling Stone and Louis CK renounces it: reddit rejoices. Boston bomber pics make it to the "front page of the internet" : reddit rejoices.

+25


r/circlebroke • • Dec 04 '14

A perfect example of what is wrong with the gaming community

0 Upvotes

This image was posted on /r/xboxone, making fun of a marketing campaign made by Microsoft.

Basically, you receive the email at the beginning of your birth month (I got one on the first of this month), which tells you to take a selfie and submit it to twitter in hopes to get a retweet from Microsoft. I'll admit, it's kind of corny and cheesy, but it's not the worst campaign i've seen in my life.

Let's go through some of the comments:

As a thank you for being a loyal Xbox user for the last year, we're offering YOU the chance to do some unpaid social media work for US!

If you have Gold, you get a free game every month. I'm not sure why you expect more than that.

I fucking hate that email. Such a slap in the face.

A slap in the face? Really? Do you feel you're really entitled to anything?

People are actually doing this shit... https://twitter.com/hashtag/XboxLiveRewardsBirthday

Fuck them for doing something they want! Amirite?

They should just give out arcade games or 5 dollars in credit. shit, or even a theme or gamer picture.

Because it's your birthday? Do you know how much money they would lose if they did that for everyone?

I know, I was so pissed by this.

u mad bro?

Yeah I sent a letter back saying, how about an actual gift? I'm not going to advertise for your stupid company. How dumb do you think I am?

WAKE UP SHEEPLE.

This post is a perfect example of the self-entitlement and bitchy attitude of the gaming community. Especially on reddit. I love my Xbox One and games, but these toxic communities are just making it worse.


r/circlebroke • • Feb 02 '13

Redditors Confusing Reality with Star Trek, part 45 - The Google Car

0 Upvotes

Redditors are an easily distracted bunch. Underage boobs, a new minecraft mod, SRS doing something wacky, any of these things can be used to make them forget about the terrible and meaningless lives they live in meatspace. But it’s high technology that we’re here to discuss today, specifically the prospect of “self-drivable cars” that has thrown reddit into a fucking tizzy. Google, Reddit’s lord and savior after le Sagan and his sidekick NDT, has been testing a model for some time, having logged over 300,000 miles in ten vehicles, six being Prius (what’s the plural for Prius?) Is this idea cool? In some ways, yes, but not so much in others. That hasn’t stopped reddit from losing it’s shit in this weeks tech-themed Ask Reddit post, "Reddit, what new "holy shit that's cool!" technology are you most excited about that is actually coming out in the not so distant future?"

The top comment starts us off, but it's the top reply that starts the fantastic delusion of cars being more than cars.

This will be awesome and I don't think it's too far off. Imagine a world where there are no more traffic jams since everyone's car is networked and communicating to each other. No more more horrific pile ups on highways due to suddenly reduced visibility, no more drunk drivers, people texting, or old people getting the accelerator mixed with the brake pedal.

And imagine the change in car design itself. Since design won't have to revolve around operation you could realistically have a small car with a bed, large screen tv, mini fridge packed with beer, you name it. Also valet service everywhere you go, since the car could drop you off and go park itself. Then you could summon it like the bat mobile when you're ready to go.

Shits gonna be tits. (165|25)

Wow, you can't make this shit up folks. Where the fuck is he getting this information up? Oh that's right, his brain, likely fried on Mountain Dew and microwaveable taquitos, can no longer distinguish between reality and science fiction. Nobody, and I seriously mean nobody in any sort of place to actually do it, has even suggested that these things are even remotely possible with a Google car. What makes anyone think that this won't be any different than a standard car? Legally, it can't. You're still going to wear your seat belt, you're still going to have to be sober, and you sure as shit won't have a goddamn mini fridge there. Not everyone is going to have a Google car. They've got $150,000 worth of equipment in there. Hell, if they keep testing them on Prius, I don't fucking want one. This is going to be marketed to a specific population, dumbass redditors who will think they can take a nap while driving to the Wal-Mart in between WoW raids.

There's a handful of people calling for reason, but most are obsessed with the idea of never having to drive again.

you fire up the blender and enjoy your piña colada and light a joint. Then you bang your girlfriend as you watch the countryside roll by. (123|9)

DAE love getting blowjobs and blazing it [7]?

I hate driving. If I can ride my bike or walk I would rather. I don't mind the open road, road trips are fun, but driving in the city is just like standing in one like behind a bunch of fuckwits not paying attention to, minutes later, being behind the next buch of fuckwits not paying attention. I can't wait until cars drive themselves. If I never had to drive a car again ever I would be happy about that. (3|0)

I am the safest driver in the world, the rest of the old people (DAE 90s kid) can suck it.

to all the nay-sayers -- the only 2 times the Google car got in an accident was when a driver manually took over. If no one tries to purposefully ram them, these things are all but foolproof. (15|2)

Have they driven in blizzards or other extremely low-visibility weather yet? I had three hours of white-knuckle driving the other night. If I could safely pass that off to an autonomous car I would in an instant, but when things start to interfere with the sensors I'd be very hesitant to test it out. (2|0)

There you have it folks. I could announce a new model of desk chair and it won't be five minutes before some redditors pretends it's something it's not. I'm /u/NickWasHere09, drive safe folks.


r/circlebroke • • Nov 29 '17

Quality Post Reddit, meet [STUPID FUCKING PET NAME GOES HERE]

27 Upvotes

I get that you are excited about your pet. And you might even post about it in a pet subreddit. But every so often, the picture of a Floof/G O O D B O Y E/ Doggo (whatever childish bastardization is en vogue) gets posted in r/pics. And the title inadvertendly ends with "reddit, meet XYZ". See title.

  1. I find it hard to give a shit about your animal (i love dogs, but my fondness for them correlates with their physical vicinity to me)

  2. Stop presenting your fucking shitstain of a miserable pet to reddit as if you were a ringmaster presenting your big attraction. Everybody has a pet and every pet is cute when little. The only thing worse than posting generic puppies is posting generic older animals, saying you "rescued" them. You big fucking hero!

  3. I did not "meet" you pet. You posted a pic. Also, I am not reddit.

I want to punch everyone in their face who makes a post like that. I don't know if it shows but it makes me irrationaly angry.

Thank you for listening, please upvote this post to encourage me to post again sometime in the future.


r/circlebroke • • Feb 16 '17

Brave Post The name 'circlebroke' is the absolute fucking tackiest thing I've ever seen

0 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I have no idea who you guys are other than that you're somehow involved in drama somewhat often, and after doing some mild looking around I still have no idea what you guys do, but the name "circlebroke", ohh, god, that's just so infuriating to me for some reason. Any other name. Any other one.

I have no bias on whatever... drama, or whatever, is currently going on at any time, nor do I have any real disposition toward this subreddit or its users - just its name.

I saw it mentioned once somewhere and it's like fucking stones sliding hard against a chalkboard in an earsplitting woodshop where a baby is screaming for some reason. I've never even heard it pronounced out loud, but I can imagine pretty well how it would sound and I always end up infuriated trying to comprehend it.

If someone wants to give me a rundown of what exactly this subreddit is, I mean that'd be awful nice, I still have no idea what's going on, but... change the name, lad. It's just so... tacky. I don't know why. I took a graphic design class once, but I'm not sure how that pertains to names. I'm really good at eyeing the absolute worst design choices and what colors clash with what, but as someone who had a graphic design class once, the title stands out to me as red and blue together as a theme. Not like a dark blue or a light red, I mean the two bright-ass, eye-searing red and blues that fuck your eyes until there's nothing left in the socket and the eye goo is all over the red/blue element's penis.

I don't know where this is going. I just hate the name circlebroke.

I should probably be constructive here, because I'm not one to just complain and nothing else, it's seeing the words 'circle' and 'broke' together that just makes it go together as well as mint toothpaste mouth rinsed with orange juice.

EDIT: Now that I've been a bit more thorough with my search, and my opinion of the sub still remains neutral, since I don't really care about circlejerk subs, I just really hate the name.

The name Openbroke looks acceptable, almost nice, actually. 'Circlebroke' though, ugh.


r/circlebroke • • Jul 31 '14

Reddit on Israel and rampant anti-semitism (controversial)[High-effort]

2 Upvotes

(disclaimer: I consider myself to be pro-Israel. I agree with Israel's operation in Gaza to destroy the tunnels because the purpose of those tunnels was to massacre civilians on Kibbutzim. I am not a fan of civilian deaths and I do NOT think Palestinian are scum.)

I've tried to hold myself back but the geniuses over on /r/worldnews have finally pushed me over the edge. There's way to much to cover in this post, so I'll just be using some snippets from the past few days over in /r/worldnews.

Today on this Guardian(big surprise) article we got some really top notch comments like:

I came here to say fuck Israel. Upvotes to the left. [+134]

If you think he's being sarcastic, think again! later on in the thread when replying to the comment

Israel is disgusting

He says

And they suck baby penis too

of course referring to a circumcision practice performed by a few ultra-orthodox communities.

The article itself, like many Guardian articles, is extraordinarily biased. It's about an Israeli attack on a UN shelter, but it glosses over that Israeli soldiers were being fired at from the vicinity of the shelter. Of course, the morality of firing back with a mortar is questionable, but this article, and all top voted articles on /r/worldnews are completely biased. This article also mentions Israel killing civilians in a UN courtyard, despite it turning out the courtyard had been empty when the Israeli shell had hit! (it was an errant shell) The Guardian, in its attempt to appear professional, mentions this but makes it sound like an Israeli lie. Believe what you will.

Now onto the article about the UN courtyard attack. http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/2bld2f/israeli_shells_hit_un_shelter_in_gaza_killed_30/

Unsurprisingly, it's from Al Jazeera, who, of course, is completely unbiased against Israel, and is known for their quality reporting on the conflict. (Don't forget that Israeli sources are untrustworthy!)

This comment really exemplifies reddit's view on Israel's bombing

I honestly feel like Israel's just doing it on purpose now.

Real quality analysis.

Here's another great comment:

Netanyahu is a criminal [+630]

really? Is Bush a criminal for Abu Ghraib? Why don't you say the leaders of Hamas are a criminals for using human shields? For hiding rockets in schools? They want civilian deaths for PR! It's this kind of comment that really shows how stupid reddit is when it comes to Israel.

Now onto the anti-semitism (no, not anti-zionism) Here is what I consider to be anti-semitism, frequently disguised as anti-zionism:

  1. slanderizing Israelis and Jews.

  2. believing that Israel does not have a right to exist.

  3. claiming there are Jewish (sorry, Israeli) conspiracies.

  4. comparing Israelis/Jews with Nazis

  5. criticizing Israel for actions that other nations have committed and not criticizing those other nations. (Obviously not all criticism is anti-semitism).

Under slander, here's a great comment at [+306]

Racism is alive and well and about 60% of Israeli citizens are openly racist: http://m.thenation.com/blog/177697-racism-israel

The article linked to absolutely ridiculous, and has nothing to do with the Israel-Palestinian issue. It's about whether Israel wants, or doesn't want, to give citizenship to a bunch of Africans who entered illegally. While you may believe giving citizenship to them is the correct thing to do, not allowing free immigration for everyone does not make a nation "racist." If you're wondering how unbiased the article is, here's a quote from it

Israel is building refugee camps—let's not use the loaded term "concentration camps"—for many of the estimated 55,000 Eritrean, Sudanese and other African refugees.

This falls under anti-semitism type 4. You can also find many other comparisons of Israel to Nazis on reddit, although I haven't seen/saved any from the past few days. If you don't know the type of comment I'm talking about, keep your eyes open! you'll see them. Redditors also like to claim that Israel/Jews hide behind the holocaust to defend all their actions, which is preposterous. If you follow any Israeli news you'll never see an Israeli politician saying "we're fighting Hamas because the Nazi's tried to kill us."

Now back to more shitty comments:

On the Al Jazeera article at [+70]

Israel is such a disgusting little country.

Calling the entire Jewish nation disgusting is most definately anti-semitic, whether you agree with their policies or not. I don't think you could call any other nation disgusting on reddit and get upvoted, despite Israel really not being that bad (you know, being a democracy, not killing homosexuals, free speech, the things that make a country not evil).

The circlejerk that bothers me the most is the anti-semitic claims of Jews vote brigading.

EMERGENCY EMERGENCY. THREAD CALLING OUT ISRAELS BULLSHIT IS BEING UPVOTED. ASSEMBLE ALL JIDF ACCOUNTS STAT. YOU KNOW THE HANDBOOK. [+1500 and gilded].

Then this guy replies [+1188 and gilded]

In a couple hours this thread will look completely different and be largely pro-Israel. I guarantee it. The only reason it isn't pro-Israel currently is because the shills haven't made it yet in force and it actually reflects the thoughts of real people, not paid government goons. EDIT: It will be fun/depressing to watch all of our comment scores drastically decline in a matter of several minutes as they show up! EDIT 2: I'm actually pleasantly surprised so far. I've noticed a couple rounds of downvoting but nothing crazy yet... And no, this isn't "disproving" the fact that shills exist. Just that they aren't all-powerful.

On redditors defending the IDF

They're paid to.

Why believing that Jewish Israeli shills are controlling reddit is anti-semitic, you ask, when there was an article about the Israeli government paying a group of students to be pro-Israel on the internet? Well I'll tell you! The government program contained 400 people and mentioned Facebook and Twitter, not reddit. Yes, there may be some people who are pro-Israel who are given a stipend to spend their time on the internet being pro-Israel, but each top level comment in/r/worldnews has thousands of up/downvotes total. To think that the Jews have that much power to warp reddit's opinion is undoubtedly anti-semitic. Oh, and how the fuck can you call out shills, but said shills don't downvote you? To believe something so preposterous you'd have to be a complete idiot, or just a common redditor.

I'm getting tired so I'm going to stop here. I think I've shown some good examples, but there are hundreds of each of these types of comments just within this past week.

Oh, one more thing. There's a lot of criticism for killing civilians, which is obviously bad and is fine to criticize. But look in /r/worldnews history for articles on civilian deaths in Afghanistan (albeit they will be from 4+ years ago) then look up how many civilians America killed there, then tell me that the focus on the Jewish nation's actions is not at least partially anti-semitism.


r/circlebroke • • Dec 26 '15

Adult man living with parents upset he has to stop watching anime and come out of his room to interact with family on Christmas. Look at the average r/childfree user.

0 Upvotes

Reddit's wellspring of human compassion and communitarianism took a break today from posting jokes about murdering kids and using dogs to replace the children they can't don't want to have to offer sympathy to the model r/childfree user: an adult man living with his parents who floods his pants with ragepiss because he had to stop watching anime, come out of his room, and interact with family members.

Bear in mind that not a single person sees fit to mention to this smelly manchild that his behavior and life choices are anything but normal.


r/circlebroke • • Oct 30 '14

/r/worldnews reminds everyone about how bad people with money then them are

8 Upvotes

The post

An article entitled "The number of global billionaires has doubled since the financial crisis" hits the top of world news. Time for some critical and intelligent discussion.

How about we kick this off with a classic: the trickle-down jerk:

See, the recovery is going well! Look at that economic growth! All that wealth should be trickling down any day now (+787/top of thread)

Yes, everytime rich people make money, it's important to complain about how you aren't getting any piece of the pie. I mean for god's Sagan's sake I've been spending all my time masturbating to pictures of Jennifer Lawrence and then making lengthy posts about why stealing private nude photos of celebrities is ok! Don't I deserve the same money that CEOs and large business owners get?

In America, if you apply yourself and work hard, somewhere, a billionaire gets richer. (+252)

In Amerikka, there is no point in working hard! Because no matter what, all my money will go straight to the rich! I see no irony in wanting the rich to pay 90% taxes and yet complaining about them 'taking' my money away.

I take the stance that the American Dream is kept alive in order to pacify the have-nots. So the rich can feel justified in having more and tell the rest of society to "work harder". The truth is most of the top 20% did not start from the bottom 20% and work their way to the top. Yes you have to work hard to become rich. That is not the limiting factor though. (+66)

I was nearly going to give up on r/worldnews when finally I found the conspiracy theories. Thank god. We can jerk properly now.

The new "American Dream" is the myth of the wildly successful entrepreneur--and the accompanying wildly successful startup. The vast majority of startups fail. The vast majority of entrepreneurs go broke. And yet the media hold up people like Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Steve Jobs as examples of American success stories--and all it takes is hard work and you can be just like them too! The fact of the matter is that the only guaranteed way to get rich in America is to be born rich. And they'll tell you that all you have to do is pull yourself up by your bootstraps. In reality, they were pulled up by their umbilical cord. Most rich families can't attribute their wealth at any point in its history to a successful new business. It's almost always an inherited business or inherited wealth that grew over time. (+56)

Ah yes, another circle jerk classic: "My emotions are fact".

Almost 3/4 of the forbes 400 are self made, but never mind that. We must keep jerking and validating our frustrations with made up facts. ALSO, DOES ANYONE LOL REPUBLICANS HATE FACTS?

Glad the bailout hasn't gone to waste (+70) What? You didn't get yours? I mean I got my free sucker when I went to the bank last week... I assume that was it.(+17)

And it wouldn't quite feel like a reddit jerk without the complete misunderstanding of economics. No you see, we should have just let them fail instead! Remember how nicely that went in 1929?

And the masses just accept it. Many dipshits even defend it.(+25) Yep, capitalism seems to be working flawlessly.(+10)

Wake up sheeple! Capitalism is a secret system made to oppress us all! -Sent from my iPhone

well if you watch history you know this will not end up well for those billionares... (+21) I always joke around and tell my conservative dad that there's gonna be a civil war sometime within the next 50 years and it's gonna happen because of income inequality... But inside I'm like oh shit I could actually see that happen(+32)

Soon my comrades! We will be oppressed no further by people who make more money than us! How dare they not spend their days making brave opinion bears about how black people are bad (DAE?) and work instead! We will show them the way! Prepare the advice mallards!

And finally, the jerk to end all jerks, and really, maybe the most honest opinions on this thread:

I suddenly feel justified for hating rich people, even though it's based on irrational emotion instead of rational logic. (+35)

There is absolutely no rational logic in having someone owning million of times more money than anyone else. (+65)

Do I need to comment on this? Or are we at a clear understanding of how insanely critical and intelligent /r/worldnews can be?

Bonus comparison to Hitler, of course:

“So one might imagine that in these countries of freedom and wealth, unheard-of public prosperity exists. ... On the contrary, in those countries class distinctions are the most crass one could think of: unimaginable poverty on one hand and equally unimaginable riches on the other. These are the lands that control the treasures of the earth, and their workers live in miserable dumps. ... In these lands of so-called democracy, the people are never the primary consideration. Paramount is the existence of those few who pull the strings in a democracy, the several hundred major capitalists. The broad masses don't interest them in the least, except during elections." Adolf Hitler on Democratic Capitalism. (+11)


r/circlebroke • • Oct 29 '13

Reddit forgets all about how 'le Mormonism is stupid' when their favourite female cosplaying violinist comes along

0 Upvotes

Lindsey Stirling did an AMA today and for those of you that don't know her, this is all you'll ever need to know.

Dubstep, violin (le classical music is so sophisticated amirite?), video game theme tunes and fantasy cosplay all mashed up and played by a young attractive and totally nerdy woman? It's surely too good to be true...

This AMA is of course packed with enough white-knighting to keep /r/circlebroke going for years, and I can't be bothered to go through it all, but one thing really stuck out to me - this comment that is currently near the top at +450

How do you balance being a faithful Mormon with being a successful touring musician? What aspects of the business, if any, make it difficult to practice your faith?

It's a fair and reasonable question to ask a person. But wait, surely Reddit isn't being respectful and tolerant to someone who follows a religion as ridiculous as Mormonism, right? I mean just think of all the jokes when Mitt Romney was running for election! The magic underwear, the fact that it was literally invented in 1987 by JK Rowling based on the writings of a Chinese takeaway menu! Surely Reddit haven't changed their mind about that?

As a non-denominational christian, we have our differences in beliefs, but I have a lot of respect for a growing celebrity like you to keep your religious beliefs a priority and be public about it. It really shows in your personality how following your religion has a positive effect on your life. Keep it up!

.

Thank you for your quick answer! From a fellow Latter-day Saint, it's refreshing to see a celebrity so open and unashamed about being LDS. You're right up there with Ken Jennings in my book!

Yup, Reddit have stooped to actually upvoting Christians. It's almost as if the fact that she's an attractive, young, musically talented woman (who would totally go for a guy like me if she just got to know me) means her religion is now valid.

Its refreshing to see a celebrity be outspoken about something other than Scientology....I don't believe what you do, but I respect that you bring something unique to the conversation.

HAHAHAHAHA

You heard it here first, at least it's not Scientology.

Musicians are experts at ignoring reality, so I don't see it being any trouble for her at all.

This currently has a negative score. Replace 'musician' with 'politician' and it would probably be at +1000

Putting all cynicism aside, maybe Reddit is changing, maybe Reddit is becoming more tolerant of religion and moving away from the /r/atheism mindset. But part of me thinks they'd quickly change their mind if it was Mitt Romney doing the AMA.


r/circlebroke • • Oct 25 '14

Circumcision is basically a crime against humanity

9 Upvotes

Thread.

Found this while browsing /r/all. Plenty of jerks in only one thread.

Nice. It's barbaric to perform non-consensual genital mutilation. +522

Agreed. In Denmark it has already been ruled as such for girls – why not for boys too? For those inevitably crying about 'religious freedom', we have this written into our constitution, it does, however, not coincide 'freedom to perform child cruelty'. Edit: I have no longer time to read let alone respond to everything here but a common criticism is my comparison between male and female circumcision. I held the same opinion for a long while but it changed and, as I see it now, it is an ethical wrong altogether and should come to an end. In the same sense as it is also fair to compare shoplifting and commiting fraud on a large scale. I stand by the argument and acknowledge the obvious difference in scale. +259

DAE circumcision is child abuse?!

Article is misleading; the question is not about banning circumcision. It is about banning non-consensual circumcision. Nobody has a problem with circumcision, any more than they have a problem with any other form of plastic surgery. However, non-consensual removal of body parts for non-medical reasons is not plastic surgery; it is violence. +471

Let's clear up some misinformation since Reddit has developed an extremely warped opinion of male circumcision. I can forgive the fact that you all fell for the "Please! Think of the children!" bullshit, but it's time to evaluate the topic rationally: Circumcision doesn't decrease sensitivity or function: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23937309 studies uniformly found that circumcision had no overall adverse effect on penile sensitivity, sexual arousal, sexual sensation, erectile function, premature ejaculation, ejaculatory latency, orgasm difficulties, sexual satisfaction, pleasure, or pain during penetration. This is confirmed in another large randomized controlled trial (page 14) that found "adult male circumcision was not associated with sexual dysfunction and that circumcised men reported increased penile sensitivity and enhanced ease of reaching orgasm. Another study showed that male circumcision had no deleterious effect on female sexual satisfaction." The CDC lists numerous medical benefits for both men and their female sexual partners (the last bullet): A decreased risk of urinary tract infections. Protection against penile cancer and a reduced risk of cervical cancer in female sex partners. Prevention of balanitis (inflammation of the glans) and balanoposthitis (inflammation of the glans and foreskin). Prevention of phimosis (the inability to retract the foreskin) and paraphimosis (the inability to return the foreskin to its original location). Reduced risk of acquiring HIV and other STDs from an infected female partner For female partners, male circumcision reduces the risk of cervical cancer, genital ulceration, bacterial vaginosis, trichomoniasis, and HPV. The American Association of Pediatrics agrees that the medical benefits outweigh the risks The American Urological Association also lists numerous benefits while stating that "incidence of serious complications is extremely low. The minor complications are reported to be three percent." TL;DR: Calling male circumcision cruel, barbaric, violent, etc. or comparing it to female circumcision is a complete distortion of the truth. It has many medical benefits and essentially zero drawbacks. Edit: Thank you for the gold -- you've restored some of my faith in humanity (and this subreddit). +31 (and gold but still...)

This is such a load of trash but I'm at work and on a phone so I don't have time to refute your whole Gish Gallop. Instead I will just say this: almost all your sources are American. You conveniently ignore the fact that last year a number of national pediatrics organizations in Europe sent a public letter condemning the American Pediatrics associations stance on circumcision. Also how the fuck is 3% a 'small' complication rate for a surgery with no conclusive benefits? When you are advocating for a procedure to be done to all infants you had better not be condemning 30,000 out of 1,000,000 to face possibly disfiguring complications. +122

Research means nothing when it is from AmeriKKKa, amirite guys XD

There are many, many more comments explaining how barbaric the practice is, and almost as many "ITT: cut guys being butthurt" and quite a few Scandinavia>everything. It is amazing how such a tiny amount of foreskin can create such a huge circlejerk.


r/circlebroke • • Nov 05 '12

Bad Title Minor jerk about how nobody else in the world has free speech or freedom like 'MURICA FUCK YEAH

0 Upvotes

A poster points out that to give out free rifles for merely voting would be shocking for many people outside America.

And the jerk begins.

I suppose freedom might be shocking to those who have so much less of it.

Apparently nobody outside America is truly free.

It depends on what you consider the most basic freedoms. For instance, if you think freedom of speech is necessary to be free, then the rest of the world is decidedly less free than the Unites States.

ONLY 'MURICA HAS FREE SPEECH LOL

There is no personal freedom if you have no economic freedom. Slaves, for example, could debauch themselves after hours as long as they were productive. That didn't change the fact that they were slaves and someone owned them.

Is anybody else getting tired of this FREE SPEECH 'MURICA jerk?

EDIT: Fixed link.


r/circlebroke • • Apr 21 '13

Reddit exposes its lack of depth

0 Upvotes

The following askreddit (low hanging fruit, I know) thread - What is your favorite quote from a fictional character? - indulges in one of my least favorite reddit jerks.

If I had to put a name on it, I suppose I'd call it the Shallow Jerk. (Open to better suggestions).

More specifically, it's the baffling apparent truth that, on a site of thousands, the vast majority of users have only been exposed to about a dozen pieces of creative work.

Whenever a thread of this nature appears (favorite book, favorite character, etc.) it's always the same handful of works that get brought up. It's as redundant and boring as any other jerk that reddit has beaten into the ground.

But my explanation only accomplishes so much. Come, take a journey with me through the comments. As we go on this journey, be aware that I am not making value judgments about the works themselves, I'm merely pointing out the patterns that emerge over and over again when Reddit discusses its favorite media.

The top comment (out of 8086 at the time of writing) is:

"You want to know how I did it? This is how I did it, Anton. I never saved anything for the swim back." - Vincent Freeman, Gattaca

The best quote from the collected fictional works of humankind that Reddit can muster comes from a 1997 Ethan Hawke vehicle that is tangentially related to science. It's the perfect of storm of Reddit. A piece of genre fiction with a reference to freshman level biology in the title that is also an underrated le gem produced in the 90s. Ironically, the movie serves as an indictment of the eugenics that Reddit so loves.

On to number 2:

“They don’t know about real loss, because that only occurs when you love something more than you love yourself.” – Sean from Goodwill Hunting (Robin Williams)

Not a bad quote, but from a movie produced in the past 20 years that most have seen. I imagine this is what every friendzoning victim feels like.

3:

"Boobs are near the center of the universe, until you turn 25 or so. Which is also when a young man’s insurance rates go down. This is not a coincidence." - Harry Dresden

We've cracked our first book! It just so happens to be from a series that combines two of Reddit's great loves - pulp and fantasy. Bonus boob talk and machismo.

4:

“Kilgore Trout once wrote a short story which was a dialogue between two pieces of yeast. They were discussing the possible purposes of life as they ate sugar and suffocated in their own excrement. Because of their limited intelligence, they never came close to guessing that they were making champagne.”

Our first Vonnegut sighting. It may surprise you, but he'll come up again! (Vonnegut is a member of the Reddit holy triumvirate of authors, along with Martin and Tolkien).

"War is war and hell is hell, and of the 2, war is a lot worse." "Why is that?" "Who goes to hell father?" "Sinners, I suppose." "Exactly, in hell there are no innocent bystanders, war is chock full of them. In fact, aside from a few of the brass almost everyone is just an innocent bystander." - Hawkeye, MASH

This one's a bit of a curveball, as most redditors are probably too young for MASH. I deem this quote acceptable, with the caveat that it plays into the nebulous web of liberal attitudes that Reddit adopts when convenient.

Pride is not the opposite of shame, but its source. True humility is the only antidote for shame. -Iroh

This quote, which bear in mind that Reddit has voted as the 6th best fiction quote in human history, comes from a children's anime produced by Nickelodeon.

Y'all get the idea. For brevity's sake, I will go down the page and list some of the other gems that Reddit unearthed.

The Emperor's New Groove

The Incredibles

The Simpsons

Shawshank Redemption

Ron Swanson

South Park

Ender's Game

Tolkien

GoT

Tolkien again

Tolkien a third time

Anne of Green Gables (wildcard bitches!)

Mass Effect

Elder Scrolls

Half Life

The Fault in Our Stars (John Green gets another mention later on - it's that consummate frienzone quote from Looking for Alaska)

Fight Club

Sherlock Holmes

Terry Pratchett

Don Draper

Harry Potter

Batman (movie version)

GoT

Breaking Bad

PK Dick

Vonnegut

Pratchett again

Watchmen

The Big Lebowski

Game of Thrones

&c.

As y'all have probably deduced, with rare exception, every quote that Reddit finds exceptional occurs in a piece of fiction that either contains a wizard, a raygun, or both.

On the rare exception it's not from a sci fi or fantasy work, it's from a cartoon.

It may sound like I'm just shitting on genre fiction, but that's not what I'm trying to do. What I'm trying to do is point out how bizarre it is that Reddit (ostensibly a place of learned discussion) has been most deeply influenced by only a handful of creative voices, all within the past few decades.

It's the same garbage that is killing /r/movies and /r/books. Yes, I have seen Gattaca and yes, I have read Slaughter-House Five... so it goes am I right?

It's no wonder Reddit has disdain for liberal arts fools and their barista degrees. Their exposure to world media is spectacularly limited.

Of course, there could be another explanation. All of these works are fairly well known, so it's possible that the hive is just up voting out of recognition.

Either way - Reddit's shallow consumption always burns my bacon.


r/circlebroke • • May 21 '13

Brave Post I've been on Reddit for a month, I'm so fed up with the preteens on r/atheism.

14 Upvotes

I'm convinced everyone on /r/atheism is 14 or possesses the mentality of a 14 year old. That's why so many atheist advice animals are like "I was kicked out...for being atheist." Yeah. If your parents are really that religious maybe you should just keep your own beliefs to yourself until you are no longer depending on them for subsistence and shelter. As a gay person, it pisses me off to NO FUCKING END that these kids think they're "coming out" as atheist, as though it is some sort of fundamental, biological aspect of their being rather than a fucking opinion they have. I'm not even Christian, I'm agnostic, and I find this sub-reddit incredibly, mind-numbingly stupid. It is the antithesis of logic and reason. These people completely fail to understand science on a BASIC, FUNDAMENTAL level. It's just so fucking rage inducing. I needed to vent. Sorry.


r/circlebroke • • Sep 23 '12

r/wtf becomes yet another forum for complaining about how evil Israel is.

0 Upvotes

A link to the post

It seems that any sign supporting Israel is now "bigoted" and wtf worthy enough to be put in r/wtf rather than say r/pics or any more relevant subreddit for, you know, pictures. No it seems that a pro-Israel ad is equal to a rotten deer carcass in the mind of these redditors.

In the first comment we have a very brave redditor with his opinion on the ad, the Arab-Israeli Conflict and those fundies.

The ad attempts to portray supporting Israel as the opposite of supporting the savage's holy war. Those two things are not the opposite.

I oppose religious fundamentalism and ethnic nationalism in all forms.

Go get them fundies, trying to turn us into a theocracy and lead us astray from the glorious Sagan and the promise of paradise in Sweden.

The next comment down is just as bad.

I have yet to hear a coherent explanation of how israel's formation and continued existence is not just a prolonged holy war against an indigenous people.

Probably because you've only heard about the Arab-Israeli conflict from reddit, and you've never bothered to actually read about it from any other source.

Fortunately there seems to be a large number of more level-headed redditors on this thread, but this wouldn't be circlebroke if we didn't complain stuff.

It's not black and white. Anyone who believes "Israel deserves the land" or "Palestinians deserves the land" clearly does not understand the conflict at all. The barren pieces of land they fight over is just the tip of the iceberg. It is kind of like saying world war 2 was a conflict over poland.

There seems to be hope yet for this woefully misplaced post, but then we have another comment that clearly defeats the whole "Jewish were there originally" argument.

Oh look I have an ancestor who was a Roman patrician during the late Republic, I'm going to go expel some Lombard from their home and claim my birthright.

You are indeed right brave sir, and I bow to your nuanced and definitely not over simplified understanding of the situation.

Further down we have a gem of a comment, both implausible and slightly racist.

There's no good reason we can't just airlift the jews out of Israel and hire them as executives for a number of our large media conglomerates here in America.

Everyone wins.

Then we have another comment on that particular argument.

By that rationale we should be handing everything back to the natives of Australia and America. Dangerous path to go down, unless there a is a more consistent rationale I'm not getting.

At least he's willing to admit he could be wrong. And again, with an even stupider comment.

You are uneducated if you think that anyone is indigenous to anywhere other than Africa.

Gentlemen of circlebroke, do you truly believe that this one picture was even remotely relevant to r/wtf? Regardless of the comment content of this post, I believe that the post itself should have at least been posted in another subreddit. I need an AdvilTM.


r/circlebroke • • Dec 01 '12

About the Chris Brown bashing.

0 Upvotes

I don't ask for everyone to like the kid. It's not that i particularly care about him. If you believe a guy who committed a crime shouldn't be working in entertainment, it's your opinion (and not a reasonable one at that, imho).

What Redditors should stop doing is pretending they hate Chris Brown because they really care about Rihanna (repeatedly called "whore" or "retarded", often in the same threads) or because a superior sense of morality drives them to do so, and not for the classic "Reddit celebrity bashing" thing. Chris Brown is just the latest tabloid scapegoat the media uses for selling their magazines. From Micheal Jackson to Lindsay Lohan, those "journalists" can't wait to document and contribute to the fall of public personalities. Joe on the street enjoy when the rich and famous have flaws just like every regular person. It's reassuring . And Reddit, despite thinking of itself as the super-intelligent-rational-people's lair, can't help but falling in this shit-spewing hate machine called gossip. (some good point about this here).

So Reddit, stop pretending you dislike Chris Brown because what he did.

Because we perfectly know that if Zach Braff went through the same quest, those threads would be filled but "it was just a teenage error", "he paid for his mistake, he was sentenced by a court", "well, she attacked her first...","we don't know how things really go between couples", "he acts like an asshole because he is constantly provoked and he is very young".

Because redditors acted like screaming fans when a friend of the women beater Charlie Sheen showed up a few days ago. Because this community justified rapists. Because when some user dare to bring up the likes of Hendrix, Connery, Dr.Dre or other celebrities (often habitual offenders) , said user is downvoted to oblivion, while someone promptly build a confused reply about how "it's different, man", with unsourced, often fake "facts" about how said offenders "changed for the good" or "sincerely asked for forgiveness".

Chris Brown acts like an immature asshole. His replies to the comedian who tried to get in the spotlight by attacking the favorite "morality scapegoat" of the moment are absolutely childish and stupid. The attack on his girlfriend was vicious and criminal. But Reddit should stop pretending they are hating on him for reasons other that enjoying being involved in lynchings, lynchings that are only targeted at people who don't appeal to its tastes.


r/circlebroke • • Mar 03 '20

BARNIE SANDLERS

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/circlebroke • • Dec 09 '15

AskReddit wants you to buy women and black people because of the your name or something?

0 Upvotes

Long time listener, first time caller.

I was perusing this thread in r/AskReddit and I was expecting a shitshow. I was not disappointed. I should remove that house of horrors from my defaults.

Top Post

Lol my name is Quin, so....a really nice quilt? Some.....quartz? Fuck, this would suck

Ten million dollars of quinoa. You now never have to go to whole foods again

Perfect. Good job, Reddit. All that was missing is a pithy, random tangentially related pop-culture reference. I'll give it a go...."I thought quinoa was a fish?"DidIdothatright?

A few post down was this gem...

Fucking J's. Joints, Jaguars, Jumbo Jet, Jesus. I could add some more. J-Crew, all Jennifers, Jackbox, Jewels, Jackets, Jerseys, Jeeps, Jammies?, Jugs, Jeans, Jerky, Jukebox, Junk, Jackhammer, etc.

Yeah. Everyone named Jennifer is a billable good. Women are a commodity. Yeah. Great. 'Murica.Freedom.FREESPEEEEEEECH!

A few more comments down...

What do you even buy that starts with 'N'? Whole buncha' nope? Maybe a lot of nicotine to overcome the depression that is being robbed of 10 mil. by only being able to buy things that start with 'N'.

I'll stop right here. This is obviously a bunch of bullshit. I don't know all of the different kinds of circlejerks that shuffle around Reddit's dusty hallways, but I know this one before we reach the turn. To put it more succinctly, "As a black man on Reddit, I know when someone is going crowbar the work nigger into a thread."

somewhere down in the thread....

Nickelback CDs

I lol'd. But the next one is the showstopper.

If you lived 150 years ago however...

QUAD GILDED, MOTHERFUCKER! Boom... 9086 points and 4X gold. This delicate dance of mocking slavery and the inference to the word nigger gets paid on Reddit. So sad.

Purify yourselves in the waters of Lake Minnetonka.


r/circlebroke • • Oct 07 '12

I hate to be mean to r/feminism, particularly because r/mensrights gives them such a hard time, but this moved me to write about it.

0 Upvotes

I have such a problem with this, particularly because it has been so heavily upvoted.

  1. It is a response to an open question that is clear-cut hypocrisy. If a woman ogles male swimmers and complains of men ogling female volleyball players, that is stark hypocrisy, as is a man damning female oglers while he himself ogles women.

  2. They're giving away the tickets that they can't sell, not the ones that involve women. Men are interested in men and men are interested in sport, so men watch men play sports. Women are interested in women but not as many women are interested in sport, so there are fewer fans for women's games. I don't wish more women found sports interesting.

  3. Muscley men are more attractive than muscley women, and feminine women are more attractive than feminine men. No?

  4. Female athletes struggling for sponsorship doesn't make it more okay for women to ogle men (personally I don't see anything wrong with anyone looking at athetes' bodies).

  5. You're cherrypicking Ye Shiwen. I could list hundreds upon hundreds of women who have broken records and not been accused of doping.

I like that she's looking deeper into something that seems simple on its surface. I wish I understood the 'male gaze' part - if you do please post it here. I wouldn't usually post something like this but it is r/feminism's #9 all-time top post. Tell me if you think I'm wrong, because I could be persuaded by a smart argument.