r/cigars • • Apr 25 '22

Question Why is r/cigars marked nsfw? NSFW

1.4k Upvotes

r/cigars • • 9h ago

Question Question about the Don Carlos? NSFW

Post image
27 Upvotes

I just had my first Don Carlos last night (Amazing stick). But after switching from Meerapfel to their new supplier for the Cameroon wrapper, has anyone noticed a difference in taste/quality?


r/cigars • • 3h ago

Nutty Profiles NSFW

8 Upvotes

Lately I’ve been craving those medium bodied nutty profile sticks. I think at the top is probably something like a D4 (I’m in Europe) but with the price I can’t smoke 3-4 of those a week no matter how much I’d like too. Looking for some recommendations on cigars with those hazelnut, peanut, almond notes. Thanks.


r/cigars • • 42m ago

Review Atabey Black Ritos (2025) - Review NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I’ve been patiently waiting to try this particular blend for quite some time! A day such as my birthday seemed like a more than suitable occasion to awake this cigar from its slumber. The first thing that struck me was how oily the wrapper was. So much so that it stained my fingers after de-sleeving it from its cello. Certainly a good way to start 😎 Upon lighting, smooth oak and black pepper were immediately evident. After a few puffs, flavors of plum, lemon zest, and artisan coffee emerged. The first third of the Atabey Black was extremely approachable and characterized by smooth complexity and robust balance. Upon entry into the second third, flavors darkened slightly as rich dark chocolate and espresso became the most prevalent tasting notes. These particular flavors were here to stay as they remained for the duration of the cigar. Towards the end the final third, the last transition consisted of the development of cedar and nutmeg to provide additional depth. In totality, I greatly enjoyed the Atabey Black as a standalone blend. Although my preference will remain with the standard Atabey, as the cubaneqsue expression of the original perfectly embodies what my palate desires. Personal preference aside, I would highly suggest trying this cigar if seeking something with silky smooth balance that you can retrohale every puff with ease.

Chronological Flavor Profile: Smooth Oak, Black Pepper, Plum, Lemon Zest, Artisan Coffee, Rich Dark Chocolate, Espresso, Cedar, Slight Nutmeg

Rating: 91


r/cigars • • 13h ago

Review LADC Habano Reserve NSFW

Post image
32 Upvotes

Really liked this one. It was bold, smooth and flavorful with a distinctly savory side. I was getting spice, dried fruit, earthiness, cedar, and pepper. The aroma is fantastic and the construction is, of course, top notch. A bigger gauge than I usually prefer but that didn’t seem to matter. Highly recommended.


r/cigars • • 19h ago

Recent smokes & thoughts #83 NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Davidoff - Year of the Horse 2026 LE: my first Chinese zodiac from Davidoff; a very, very good cigar overall; smoked perfectly, amazing draw, burned perfectly; great blend, ECU wrapper and binder, DR fillers, straightforward, no fuss; medium overall, medium- strength, medium or so body, medium+ flavours, balanced; rich, depth, layered, dynamic, nuance, complex, very good profile to this one; flavours were on point (cayenne, cashews, caramel, raspberry, apple, oak, brown sugar, mustard, mild pepper, leather, orange zest, cedar); all thirds of the smoke had their own additions, which was very enjoyable; definitely top tier Davidoff in my opinion, had a bit more umph to it but maintained some serious complexity and nuance to it; I know this might sound odd, but it did represent a horse (I know, call me crazy if you want); definitely one worth trying, but it is a bit pricey; someone asked me a couple of weeks ago about USD$40-$60 smokes worth trying, I’d put this one up there

Concealed Carry - Detroit River LE: an ok cigar, nothing special about this one; smoked perfectly, zero concerns again (this has been a big plus for this line); undisclosed blend, but it is definitely an ECU wrapper, probably a SUM binder, NIC in the filler, very ECU forward, tasted like La Aurora; medium overall; rich, depth, layered, but that is about it; first third was pretty decent, but the rest of the cigar was very average, got muddled towards the last third; flavours were fine, pedestrian (red pepper, sweet tea, oak, caramel, dirt, woody, cinnamon, spices, lemon zest, tart); definitely could’ve used some more depth and nuance to the flavours, lacked a bit in that department; by far my least favourite from this line so far, very generic, basic ECU blend; not a lot to say about it because it was so basic

Casa 1910 - Calvary Edition Lucero: very good cigar from the boutique Casa 1910, a Mexican brand; smoked perfectly, loved the torpedo vitola with this one, zero issues; great blend, ECU wrapper, SA binder, NIC fillers, all of the tobacco flavours were there; medium overall, but the flavours were more medium+, great smoke output and draw; made in NIC but at an undisclosed factory, would love to know which factory; rich, depth, layered, balanced, nuanced at times; first and final thirds were solid, middle third was just ok; flavours were good, vibrant, transitions (oak, cayenne, SA smoky, walnuts, creamy, orange liqueur, dried leaves, cinnamon, soily, leather, fruity, tobacco, spices); very good cigar; 1910 typically uses more MEX tobacco in their blends, but it was good to see what they can do using SA only as the binder and using other tobaccos; if you’re a fan of MEX tobacco, I highly recommend trying them; they announced an overhual of their lines and discontinuing their Calvary and Soldadera lines for the time being and focusing more on their Mexican cigars; I suggest trying some of these while they’re still available

Montecristo - Maltés: no box date or factory code on this single; birthday smoke for me; my second one from the Línea 1935, I’ve smoked the Dumas years ago; this one was pure class; smoked very well but it did need. the tool to loosen it up, tight part about a third of the way down; basically a toro size, called the Sobresalientes in the Cuban naming system; started out on the mild/medium side but finished more medium+, which I love about Cubans; rich, depth, layered, good transitions, balanced, complex, very good; flavours were so damn good, so MC (red and white pepper, orange zest, oak, cinnamon, caramel, cake, creamy, coffee, terroir, cocoa), maintained that MC profile but more zest; this Línea 1935, in my opinion, is overpriced nowadays but by gollly they are so flipping delicious; I don’t remember the Dumas being this good, but I like their profile compared to other Montecristos; wish I’d bought a box when I had the chance (or at least a couple more); I really did not want this one to go out, but the ephemeral experience of cigars is also what makes them amazing

Concealed Carry - AA 1935 LE: last one from this line; another good cigar, but not great; smoked well but the wrapper split multiple times because it was packed so tight, luckily no serious problems; has to be La Aurora again, 100% sure SUM wrapper, some DR and NIC in there; all of these were the same robusto extra vitola; more on the medium+ side overall, had a nice nicotine punch to it; rich, depth, layered, some balance to it, not much transition or nuance; first third was just ok, but it got better as it went along; flavours were decent (red pepper, very soily/dirty, copper/metallic, dried leaves, spices, cocoa, DR terroir, cinnamon, root beer, nutmeg); not a bad cigar at all; not my favourite from this line, I still think the Speakeasy was the best; overall, this line was decent, it has some good smokes, some being better than others of course; definitely recommend for folks who enjoy trying a line that has an overall cohesiveness to it while having distinct cigars and those who like undisclosed blends; however, I still like Fratello’s regular production smokes better than these ones; the Concealed Carry II line will be released soon

Gurkha - Year of the Dragon 2024 LE: made at El Artista in the DR; last one of this release that I’ve tried; a very nice cigar, one of the better ones I’ve had from El Artista; smoked well, for some reason part of the wrapper wouldn’t stay lit in the last third, great draw, loved the vitola; an undisclosed blend, but it seemed like an ECU wrapper, some HON in there and some DR; medium, medium+ overall, fairly steady profile; rich, depth, layered, good transitions, cohesive flavours (pepper, soil, creamy vanilla, cocoa, nutmeg, cinnamon, leather, orange zest, woody, potato chip, BBQ sauce), an interesting flavour profile; not the most dynamic flavours, but I liked this profile a lot; fairly impressed; there were five different blends for this line (this one, one made by AJ, one by EP, one by Oliva, and one by Oscar), and this one was up with the EP and Oliva as my favourites (AJ was my least favourite); I still haven’t smoked anything from Gurkha’s core lines and I need to do it (I’ve only heard negative talk about their core line)

Jake Wyatt - Lucid Interval: very mediocre; smoked fine, wrapper split a couple of times, burn was wonky quite a bit but had an ok draw; nice torpedo vitola; a candela wrapper from an undisclosed country with DR binder and filler; made in the DR at a Tabacalera JVM, which I don’t think I’ve ever heard of; probably medium overall, maybe medium+; rich, some depth, layered, for sure nothing more than that but needed more; flavour felt monolithic, which can happen with a candela wrapper but this one even more so; the first third had some ok flavours but the rest was mostly boring (woody, pepper, grassy, green apple, green tea, very salty, BBQ meat, dry grass, creamy, cayenne); this cigar lacked any kind of developed profile for me; it had a few good puffs but the rest of it was bland and boring; I’ve now smoked three cigars from JW, and I don’t think I’ll be trying anymore from this brand, they’ve all been very average, if that

Eladio Díaz - 72 Anniversary North and South Edition LE: what a cigar, y’all, fantastic; made at Díaz’s factory in the DR; smoked mostly perfectly, needed one minor touch-up, great draw and burn; a DR puro with various DR varietals for the fillers, DR corojo wrapper, and a DR/SA binder, which I’ve never smoked before; around medium overall; rich, depth, layered, nuance, complex, balanced, great cigar; flavours were so damn good and cohesive (white pepper, Red Hot cinnamon, creamy oak, wheat roll, apple sauce, spiced cocoa, hay, nutty, DR terroir, zesty); my second one from this line that celebrates Díaz’s birthday and both have been awesome; his DR tobacco is second to none, I would put Díaz’s DR puros up against any others (looking at you OpusX); the North and South name comes from the fact that the cigar uses tobaccos grown in either the northern or southern regions of the DR; highly recommend this one

Fratello - DMV VA: a very nice cigar; made at La Aurora; smoked perfectly, no issues whatsoever, perfect draw and burn; an undisclosed blend but has to be a BRA wrapper, NIC in there for sure; medium overall; a standard robusto vitola, which I haven’t smoked in a while and still love; rich, depth, layered, nuance, balanced; had some very good flavours in this one (black pepper, swampy, blackberries, mahogany, dark cocoa, hazelnut, smoky, nutty, creamy earthiness, BRA terroir); the BRA wrapper from LA is really good, a bit different than others, very enjoyable; I ate a piece of the 62% chocolate at the beginning of every third of the cigar and that was actually a lot of fun; I’ve never done anything like that and it ended up being a very good pairing; I bought the Fratello Harmony sampler that has all four DMV blends along with chocolates that are paired with each blend; the DMV blends have been released multiple times with different tobaccos, and the ones in this sampler are all undisclosed


r/cigars • • 17h ago

The Queen is Dead 👑 NSFW

Post image
42 Upvotes

Another Caldwell banger. This one is in the “Blood Root” Vitola (Lancero). Beautiful Golden brown Leaf and construction. The band is amazing in typical Caldwell fashion. I got lots of dark fruit especially pineapple notes from the Indo-Sumatra binder.

Creamy white pepper from the Habano wrapper. Not too spicy and would probably have benefited from a little more spice tbh. I’m trying the requiem vitola next to see if I can pick up more of the corojo/crillo fillers. All in all, a medium light bodied banger 🔥


r/cigars • • 19h ago

Review Arturo Fuente Curly Head Deluxe Natural NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

Humidor: lit right after getting home from the B&M

Outside: 72F 48RH sunny and pleasant

This cigar looks just like a Fuente Curly head but with a band. Skinny and a little sloppy. Just like all the women I love. Fill is inconsistent with the mixed filler and I'm sure it's too humid, but that's normally not an issue for me on short filler. Clean cut on the sloppy cap. Good draw. Easy light on the partially closed foot.

1/3

Classic Fuente flavors to start. Creamy, buttery smooth with a touch of woodiness on top. Very little spice except on the tip of my tongue. Burn is even, ash is firm. I'm going to have to keep it short so it doesn't accidentally end up in the pool. A hint of nuts and earthiness. This thing is ridiculously smooth. There's cream with some oak and natural sweetness. It's not a particularly complex profile, but it's very agreeable.

2/3 and 3/3

This is not a cigar that needs to be reviewed in thirds. One of the limitations of mixed filler, in my experience, is the lack of structure to blend transitions into the profile. That being said, by the midpoint there's a dried fruit note that's lighter than the dried fruit notes I normally get from Honduran and some Nicaraguan tobacco. It's not as zesty or citrusy as some Nicaraguan tobacco, but it's a lot closer to that than say a fig or date note from Honduran tobacco. Nutty with more earthiness and just a hint of pepper in the second half. The grassiness that i find often in Dominican and Cuban cigars is present but was more prevalent in the first half. Slight touch of nicotine, but nothing to worry about. Draw tightened up and I got some sap so I re-cut the cap. Now it's pouring smoke and I'm getting a nice, soft pepper note on the nose. More wood, a little leather and just truckloads of creamy Dominican goodness. Burn and ash are consistent. Smooth and pleasant through the nub.

79/100

This is like the cigar equivalent of Coors Banquet beer to my tastes. It's approachable enough that the occasional cigar smoker will enjoy it, with just enough character to make it worth the time of the connoisseur. I needed a mango key lime pie at Publix and saw a sketchy smoke shop in the strip mall next door. $5 and 2 hours later and we have this review. I would get another for an occasion when I just wanted a smooth, easy cigar, but don't plan to pay too much attention to it. Also for what it's worth, for effectively 25% more in price than the normal curly head, I can't say it's 25% better. Try a single, you'll only be out the price of a coffee.


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Discussion Considering new outside cigar lounge for the backyard NSFW

Post image
79 Upvotes

Hey guys last year I had a Vevor pop-up gazebo but the Velcro detachable wind panels got real flimsy and came undone, preventing it from holding in heat whenever I had my heater on.

This year I’m going to try this kind of ice fishing tent also by Vevor. I’ll most likely install some type of duct ventilation where the chimney goes. It’s a $330 investment but beats spending $4000 on a more permanent solution as I rent. I have a very large backyard.

Take a look at the gazebo pop-up tent that I had in my previous post here it did really well, but I’ll probably use it more for the summertime so we don’t get eaten alive by mosquitoes since it has the mesh panels.

Other than going to your local brick and mortar how are you guys faring the winter?


r/cigars • • 17h ago

Shout out to glove guy - Drew Estate Kentucky Fire Cured Flying Pig while working on the car NSFW

Post image
25 Upvotes

Enjoying this KFC Flying Pig while replacing a thermostat assembly this afternoon. Very distinct scent of pipe tobacco after removing the cello, presumably from the Virginia and Kentucky tobaccos in this blend, the smoke has an excellent smokiness and a savory, salted nutty flavor along with some earth and oak. First KFC, though I've enjoyed fire-cured tobacco in other cigars. Construction was great, stayed lit through the whole process even with very occasional draws. Definitely will be trying this one in some different vitolas in the future!


r/cigars • • 22h ago

Question What is your Mt. Rushmore of Cigars? NSFW

42 Upvotes

Just curious on everyone’s “Mt. Rushmore” of cigars is. I assume this changes as we try new sticks. Mine are listed below and I consider myself still learning and honing in on my tastes.

My Father Le Bijou 1922
Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Mayflower Dream


r/cigars • • 16h ago

Sunday Morning Chill Time NSFW

Post image
12 Upvotes

This Fortaleza Y Libre Sun Country Connecticut is NOT for the faint of heart. VERY peppery, earthy, woody, leathery... not your typical Connecticut by any means. But WOW what a banger of a cigar!!!


r/cigars • • 21h ago

Whacha Smokin'? Today’s Sunday Morning Football Lineup NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Gearing up for this morning’s games, I selected a Liga Privada T52 and an EPC Allegiant from the humidor. The T52 is already tasting fantastic paired with my coffee, with earthy, woody and dark chocolatey notes coming through. What does everyone else have in their lineup for today?


r/cigars • • 23h ago

Champagne revisited NSFW

Post image
34 Upvotes

Had this as an early on recommendation and didn't taste much. That time I paired it with bourbon, and I think that's too bold for this stick.

After smoking a ton of different Connecticut shades, I got a feel for what I like. And I really like this stick. Citrus, vanilla, almond. Delicious flavor profile, just paired with water so as to not disturb the experience.

And I never have a bad experience with perdomo. Perfect burn, lots of smoke output, good flavor.

Overall a solid smoke. Would be happy with this cigar any day of the week.

Next Perdomo with be the 20th anniversary sun grown - I've heard good things


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Review Cigars Daily Cigartopia in review NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

Howdy folks, went to cigartopia earlier today and I had a BLAST. Went there as a group along with some people from the Brolo Cigars discord, more on that in a later post. It's always great to think of how a hobby can bring people together, especially something so dedicated to relaxation and craftsmenship in a work that seems to be more and more geared towards productivity and shortcuts. Let's talk about the booths

DAVIDOFF/CAMACHO

This booth was awesome I had no clue how many cigars fell under the davidoff umbrella. Ironically, because davidoffs aren't sold to cigars daily they didn't have a showing of the actual davidoff product but the rep came prepared with knowledge as well as a generous freebie I got to score in a Davidoff Dominican Puto very excited to review this stick. Upon mentioning I write reviews I also got to score a Camacho sampler which made me so happy as I love the branding on them and the barrel aged is tried prior was seriously amazing.

Funny enough as I was walking away the Camacho rep called my name and said he's seen my posts, that moment was pure magic I really love that the world and community can be so small and tight knit sometimes! I ended up getting the camachonecuador from a later conversation with him. If I remember right it seems that they have a solid filler base they use for their lines and per cigar they swap out the binder and wrapper so I'm really excited to give it a try. I'll be doing a week of Camacho here soon.

One question I set out to ask every table was "What cigar is the most baseline middle of the road cigar to get somebody started with a brand, not the cheap cuban sandwiches but also not the standouts, a good baseline to use to compare all the other blends from" I unfortunately neglected to ask the Camacho guy but the davidoff rep had an interesting answer in the Avo classic. She said the tobaccos used and the blending ideals are very similar to a ton of the davidoffs on the market so I'll definitely be picking up an avo here soon once my wallet recovers.

Aganorsa Leaf

I was very happy to hear that u/terenceaganorsa had seen my post involving the rare leaf reserve that I finally got to get an answer to the question of the best starting point. I'd had the JFR Habano earlier in the day (sorry for no review, the wrapper was CHEWED UP and it didn't feel right to post such a damaged cigar for people's potential introduction) and I got a really reasonable answer in the Agaganorsa Corojo/Aganorsa Habano. This makes sense as another requirement for me is that the cigar is widely available and I tend to see this one everywhere aganorsa is sold!

Scandanavian Tobacco

Got to meet Matt Booth himself but he was such a busy guy, slinging wieners at every bystander who consented I didn't get to ask about the baseline room101 which is such a shame because as far as all of the brands at the event go, this is the brand that I found it the hardest to answer for myself. Both the Johnny Tonacconaut maduro and the room101 17th anniversary had great showings at this event though.

Then we get to the most in depth conversation I had with a brand representative at this event. The scandanavian tobacco rep. The convo started a bit heated but I blame myself for that because I started by saying I like to write reviews and as a reviewer I bemoan the idea of so many brands and blends falling under such a large umbrella. Wondering where does the individuality and voice of each brand come in once owned by such a large umbrella. The rep then countered saying that this is a false narrative and it's reviewers that unfairly present a bias in their reviews against the products of scandanavian Tobacco because they don't like a certain factory or they don't like the idea of a large tobacco company as a whole so a cigar that may be rated above 90, may be knocked down just by association.

I explained that many of the cigars I view in a romantic light are their products. That I got my start in Macanudo and have been blown away by many other cigars that fall under their preview, many AJ blended. He let me know that every brand has their own brand manager and it's not just a blend milk but that each brand has their own respective voice. This was really refreshing to hear and I wanted to ask what the voices were but honestly there are so many different ones that we just didn't have time to get into that.

I got a more general answer to my question, any conneticut/ habano in a toro or robusto. I told him what I've been recommending to others is the Macanudo Inspirado white and he said I was on the money.

Oliva

Oliva is a brand I've come to look at a bit sideways. I love Oliva cigars, I tried the nubs very early on and I went on to use them as a baseline to test the humidors of new shops I'd go to for the first time because they're so damn consistently priced and experienced. As I've evolved I've drifted away from the nub and I've grown a deep appreciation of the serie O and the Serie V. My main concern with Oliva is that from the grapevine, and from what I've seen I've heard that they don't value the brick and mortar segment as much as the online world, which is such a shame. Cigars, in my opinion, are a very communal thing. It's that hour you take to yourself to relax and sit with others who are relaxing and connect over a shared interest. Yet online Olivas are priced so low that even I struggle to self-justify an in person purchase.

Now I didn't bring any of this up, their booth was busy and I'd learned not to poke the lion at the last booth. So I just hit them with my question and said I already had an answer in mind. My answer was Serie O, but the rep said they lean more towards the Serie G for beginners. They said they order tons of true African Cameroon and because of that they're able to price the G very entry level it's an approachable smoke.

And then something I really appreciate happened, I was handed a Serie G to try and review. This was just so funny to me because honestly outside looking in the vibe of the booth seemed a little stuffy, yet I was given an olive branch, a cigar that any attendee could reasonably buy for a bear nothing price yet just to spare me the trouble I was given one. Sometimes it's the small things.

My Father

Unfortunately Iissed out in the event exclusive they were gone vefore I even rolled around, still, I had a question and with My Father I had a hard time thinking of my own answer. According to the rep, the answer was something I hadn't tried yet, the flor de antillas in any shade. Priced right blended with very medium ideals rather than pure strength and available everywhere. I'll definitely be picking one up soon

DUNBARTON TOBACCO AND TRUST

Steve Saka himself was there which I do appreciate. I sugarcoat, he's a person that I've grown a bit of disdain for. I don't mind his hot takes I think he definitely is extremely knowledgeable in all things tobacco and cigars but man is his brand not about approachability at all.

He's gone on record saying his cigars are not for everybody and not everybody should be able to afford his cigars. The Cigars Daily DTT exclusive, the leche burra is pretty prohibitively priced at around 19 dollars. For me, anything over 15 gets into the territory of a bad time being unforgivable and it makes me nervous even thinking of picking up something new at that price point.

Still, DTT is popular for a reason, there's something there so I asked my question, how do you start. And of course I was not given one answer but recommended two different samplers, try em all essentially. I could've pressed but I figured it was a moot point, of course a sampler is to sample and I could see the father of tobacco children not being able to pick just one.

While I threw some shade saka was very pleasant to me and I wish him the best. Wish I had it in my budget for a Mi Querida but not today. Very excited to try an umbagog that was sent to me by a fellow redditor and the sobremesa that came in the event sample.

Casa Lovo

Now this was something really special. Among a bunch of tables decked out with swag there was an unassuming table with just two women behind it, one a torcedor who happened to own the brand and blend. Maybe it's the Californian in me speaking but I think there's something so pure and beautiful about a business owned by the worker, the roller herself. Not only that but she lives in my own home county of San Bernardino not far from where I went to school

But it's not just feel good stories here she came with something I've never seen. Cigars wrapped with a wine fermented leaf, a deep deep red with a winey aroma in both barbers and full on full red cigars. Someone from my group got me one of each as I unfortunately ran out of financial gas very early into the event. It's too bad that we didn't know until after the purchase that she was the private cigar roller for Arnold shwarzeneger himself and the non wined out cigars she was rolling at her table were his personal blend. Hopefully I can pick one up at her lounge in Rialto.

AMERICAN VIKING

I didn't think I'd get the chance but I caught Tim for a second and asked everything I'd been wondering about American Viking.

American Viking always stuck out to me because as a beginner cigars daily was a media superpower I gravitated towards. I would binge listen to their videos and podcasts a lot throughout my workday. Eventually I ran into the announcement video for the American Viking unlikable and MAN did I want to smoke one. It was banded and branded so I figured I could go anywhere and buy it but then came the conundrum. I couldn't find this thing in person ANYWHERE. On the website I eventually found a Californian lounge listed as having them, I drove out there and heard "American Viking? Never heard of it"

so I was wondering, "Damn what happened did this thing never get off the ground, did we put the cart before the horse?" And I got a perfectly reasonable answer.

Cigars Daily is a huge business not just as an online retailer but as a lounge and media producer as well. When American Viking launched with the vision of being a nationwide boutique brand, the pandemic hit in full swing, many places weren't accepting new stock and, many closed. It was a nightmare to launch just about anything that wasn't a fancy jpg or shitcoin. The stress from balancing that along with the business caused the brand to reduce down to something sold basically as a daily exclusive. I asked if there were plans in the works to give it another go and he said while there isn't anything concrete that is the goal and that is the dream.

He was interested to hear about my reviews and I was gonna chat more but I had to go soon after this soI didn't get to, unfortunately. I'll be reaching out via email and if I learn anything cool I'll include it in another post or in the reviews for the daily exclusives I picked up.

As far as a baseline goes, I figured I knew the answer as a fan but I neglected to buy it so I guess I needed to hear it from the horses mouth as the push to take a trip back into the humidor.

The Filthy Viking, Tim's desert Island cigar. One of the earlier blends, priced fairly, more medium than bold and the quality of the later blends has gone up since it's conception. I picked it up in Tim's preferred robusto and the lancero and I'm very excited to try it once my tongue recovers

Brolo Cigars

This is a brand that I have been so incredibly excited to try and the fact that I got some samples made it worth the trip, while this wasn't part of the event us fans went with the brand owner himself to the event. I asked the same question and as a burgeoning brand I got the expected answer that all 3 are different tones of the same voice. It's a harder question to answer when you aren't established.

I've had one so far, the porch light which will get a full review tomorrow

SPOILER, You need it in your life.

EDIT I FORGOT DREW ESTATE

This table was super cool and I wish I'd gotten pictures. The merch was very Liga focused including a huuuuuge Liga Privada knife with one of 3 designs on it. When I asked the question the rep had a tough time answering but his answer was Sweet Jane for non-traditional which surprised me because I thought acid was their bread and butter, but it makes sense it's not too far from traditional when compared to acid so it's a good starter. For traditional it was the white banded herrera esteli. I have one resting and will review it soon


r/cigars • • 1d ago

First Rocky Patel and probably last NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

Had yesterday with a friend a rocky patel grand reserve while he had a Montecristo white.

The rocky had burn issues from the 2nd third it kept tunnelling and I retouched it to fix it but nothing worked. I had to cut and relight in order to fix it, it got fixed for a few mins then started tunneling again, I threw away the last third. Had earthy dark notes to me, but I can say I ain't getting it again lol

I guess the hate regarding Rocky's quality control is valid 💀


r/cigars • • 19h ago

One of my favorites NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Joya de Nicaragua Black Swan.

A great cigar.

Starts with a burst of hot pepper and cream. After about an inch the pepper leaves and coffee with a little chocolate comes in. After a third the coffee and cream fades and some graham cracker joins in. Around the 2/3 mark another burst of hot pepper. The creaminess gets a bit stronger.

A smooth smoke. No harshness at all.

Very good construction. The burn was great, solid burn line with no issues. The smoke was good but not clouds.


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Whacha Smokin'? Rojas - Street Tacos - Cinco de Mayo 2026 NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Overall, very good cigar. Rustic vibes with great construction. Paired it up with a "Mexican" flavored, cold brew coffee. The sweetness and cinnamon were a nice compliment to the cigar itself.

Straight burn, near perfect draw. Very enjoyable cigar to a Saturday afternoon

Ecuadorian Habano over Mexican San Andres. Filled with Nicaraguan tobacco from the Jalapa region and some US Connecticut Broadleaf.

I got a nice balance of Cedar, some earthiness and light pepper notes. A savory, charred meaty and salty note came through in the middle of the cigar. Not strong, just kinda filled in the middle of the profile. All of this was well balanced and transitioned nicely. In the end, there was some cedar, leather and black pepper to send this cigar off in good style.

I look forward to next year, and the Street Tacos line is quickly finding itself in my humidor more often. The Barbacoa and Al Pastor are great smokes.


r/cigars • • 19h ago

Review Brotherly love in a very special Cigar. Brolo Porchlight Review NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Hi Folks, as I've mentioned recently I got to meet Josh the creator of Brolo cigars. I know there's been some complaints about posts about this brand here so I'm gonna keep it as genuine and non-spammy as possible.

If you were unaware, Brolo started from a literal dream. It's founder Josh, had enjoyed cigars for a while and had dabbled with the idea of opening a lounge. That hope was thrown out pretty soon after the pandemic struck. Soon after while asleep he dreamt he'd made a cigar and woke up with the idea for Brolo, meaning brotherly love.

When we look at new brands and unheard of offerings, it's natural to side eye them a bit. We've all heard the stories, enterprising would be business men heading down to Nicaragua, buying all sorts of seconds, unbanded test blends and other cigars the factories have rolled but have no reason to sell their name. These people come up with a cool label, slap a band on it and call it a day. A step above are the people who do actually go an ask for a blend to be made, and that's it. They get blended a cigar they get handed a cigar and they turn around and say "hey everyone check out MY cigar". Some people do have vision and they communicate that vision to the blenders who work with them in an iterative process, keeping the leaf selection to the blending expert but aiming to fit the brands goal. At this level it's something I can still respect, but when I asked Josh about what the process was like for him, I got the answer I was wanting to hear. When Josh was approved to work with the factory he flew down to Nicaragua and smoked a ton of one leaf type fumas specifically to get a taste and deal for each ingredient. Then selecting what he wanted in a blend and trying those in an iterative process with the blender. And while on one occasion the blender made a suggestion which improved the final product, in this blend the torchlight. The other two are completely Josh's design. When he says "My cigar" he really means it's HIS cigar. His voice, his palate in a stick.

As Tim from cigars daily often asks when looking at a prospective product to carry, "What makes you different" that Brand's character and mission is very community focused. The name literally means Brotherly Love. On top of that, you'll know Josh is a frequent poster here, looking to loop people in to his brand and his product, long before the cigars were available for purchase. On top of that, Josh has fostered a fantastic online community starting with a Google meets group chat that has since moved on to a popular discord. This place has all the hallmarks of a lounge, ribbing, cigar nerdert, and tons of talk on what deals to snipe among other hobbies and good stories. Being on the road all of the time, I appreciate having a lounge atmosphere when I'm not able to actually make it in to smoke.

Community, that's something I find disappointingly lacking in so many other places in the world of cigars. It's why I came to reddit with my hobby in the first place. Were a niche hobby, a fraction of tobacco users, a group which society has blamed and shamed for stinky air and detriment to public health. But unlike cigarette smokers a cigar is about class and a nice solid hour where you get to sit down and get away from it all. And because many people aren't in our world, and many people hate the idea of smoking tobacco. The lounge is our refuge, it's where we find like minded individuals to meet and share stories with. It's where I've gotten my greatest recommendations and tips! I love the lounge and I make it a point to mostly but from them even if cigars can be had much cheaper online.

And that's what brings me to the part of Brolo I appreciate the most, the dedication to upholding and honoring the brick and mortar seller. At launch brolo is being sold only by entities with lounges and stores. Specifically to honor these places that are our last bastion of solace in an increasingly regulatory world. So while you will be able to buy these cigars from an online partner, just know that this is possible because that partner is a lounge first and happens to also ship. And I think that's pretty cool.

This is the porchlight, the lightest of the bunch in a nice corojo

THE REVIEW

Full disclosure, this was my third cigar of the day.l so my words might not be the most accurate here, especially since the notes i experienced weren't mirrored by the others in my group.

I loved it full stop, the second I'm able to get another I will.

On light up what amazed me was how creamy it was in the first third. I got pretty light spice and a really nice richness. I wouldn't call it sweet but it was if you made plant-based milk out of tobacco. It's a flavor I love and one I had genuinely thought I had burnt out of my tongue. This was a flavor I got early on with my favorite lighter sticks like Serie O, Perdomo champagne and my beloved Macanudo Inspirado White.

Towards the end it went from cream to a nice woody note I hadn't tasted before. Much like cedar but a bit less sharp and piney. It tasted like how a nice camp fire smells. I don't know if that's poplar or what but it was certainly evergreen. This transitioned into a wee bit of baking spices layered on the wood, going into coffee towards the final third. I ended up having to leave before I could nub it and I mourn that lost opportunity.

Now, I'm not sure if it was by power of suggestion, as Josh mentioned this was his experience with it or if it was my slowly dying tongue, but this is where my opinion diverged with the others who tried. They didn't get too much spice and what spice they did get was on light-up. That's usually my experience too, spice at first which mellows out as the session proceeds. I however had a subtle spice that built and built. From white pepper to baking spices to a powerful black pepper piprin and all towards the end.

They also got a bready almost sourdough like note which I truthfully didn't detect in any way. In both our experiences this was a cigar that transitioned well what ch is something I really appreciate. It's so disappointing when a cigar remains the same the whole way through, when it happens many sticks in a row I almost get stuck in a rutt thinking "Was I fooling myself thinking there's depth here, do cigars low-key taste the same as each other and we're all lying to ourselves about magic flavor notes and transitions" and then something like this comes along a lnd reaffirms your love and analytical mind for the hobby. Total rutt-buster

This cigar will MSRP around 15 and I think that that's a perfect pricepoint. when I am able to I think I'll get a box (very attractive box)


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Question First cigars ever NSFW

Post image
18 Upvotes

I bought these on the 7th of September and as a complete novice, i haven’t stored them anywhere and have just left them in their plastic in a cool dark place since then. I know they are el-cheapos and wont be a fantastic experience as is, but have i ruined them entirely or could a buddy and I smoke them in the next couple weeks and be fine? They still feel stiff and dont crumble or break away when i pinch them so could be salvageable.

Any help here would be awesome!!


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Whacha Smokin'? Recent Cigars NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

Here are my most recent cigars over the last couple of months. I’d be lying if I said life hasn’t been kicking my ass lately… but things can always be worse. A good cigar every once in a while is a blessing, so I am here to share with you guys my recent smokes!

1) Opus XI - Didn’t smoke any of these, but I purchased it on my birthday as a present to myself. All I need to complete the collection is the Opus 5 and 8.
2) FFOX Rare Purple Diademas 56 - this cigar was good at best. I’m not a fan of bigger ring gauges. I think I’d enjoy the 54 more.
3) Davidoff Year of The Rabbit - One of my personal favorites, and I only have 1 left ;(
4) God of Fire Carlito’s Double Corona - A favorite of mine, one of the first cigars I fell in love with. Hard to find the DC at brick & mortars.
5) Arturo Fuente Don Carlos #2 - Another classic favorite of mine. Absolutely love the Cameroon wrapper.
6) Davidoff Year Of The Horse - Very good cigar, but after smoking a box, I think some age will serve it well.
7) Arturo Fuente Sangre De Toro - My least favorite Fuente release of 2025. Generally not a fan of San Andreas wrappers so not shocking.
8) Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Work of Art - Had to kick off October with a Rare Pink of course
9) FFOX Rare Black Double Corona - My favorite cigar I have smoked recently. The Rare Blacks are so good, and that vitola just wowwww.
10) FFOX El Trece Magistral - My favorite Fuente release of 2025. Chocolate bomb!
11) FFOX Temple De Oro #1 - Very similar to the classic Opus line, but more nuance to it. I’ll have to smoke it more to nail the flavor profile.


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Shitpost Spiral Ash?? NSFW

Post image
10 Upvotes

damn just look, never seen this before


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Review And what a golden hour it was, Review NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Hey folks, had lots of fun at the cigars daily event. I'll be reviewing both the cigar I smoked and the event itself.

GOLDEN HOUR WRITE-UP

Sorry for only two pics of this I forgot to take more.

San Cristobal to me seems like the awkward middle child among the la aroma de Cuba (artsy teen) , the Ashton (established oldest sibling), and my father (popular high schooler of the bunch)

If you're unaware, both San Cristobal and La Aroma De Cuba are made via a partnership between Ashton cigars and the Garcia family which makes My Father Cigars. Yet of the 4 it's the brand I see talked about the least. My only other experience with it thus far was the elegancia and it was a pleasant one, cedar forward conneticut but I wouldn't daily it.

When I saw on the Holt's YouTube channel that theyve worked with the garcias to come up with a brand new blend, the Golden Hour, I was really excited. At the time I was loving creamy Connecticuts and was hoping for something smooth and honey like. When the cigar did finally come out, reviews were a bit middling which disappointed me, though I still knew I had to have it once it dropped.

As some of you know, I live in California, because of our registration laws and red tape it takes blends a lot longer to become available here, many won't become available at all. So after weeks and weeks of asking about this one, when I stepped into my local lounge and found it there I knew I had to have it.

The wrapper was darker than I expected, not golden as the name would suggest, so I held onto it for a special day, and man was today special.

GOLDEN HOUR REVIEW

On light up I immediately widened my eyes and exclaimed "this is GOOD" Is had honey in my coffee earlier in the morning and this was reminding me of that. Lots of spice initially, hanging on the edge of baking spice and white pepper. Very wood forward at first though into the second third I found a very strong nuttiness like pecan or almonds. The retro was great full of oak and a bit of cedar. It was a long smoke, lasting me 2 hours while I walked and chatted at the event. Someone in my group smoked it as well and we both concur. This is a must try


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Haul Picked up some singles today. Excited to try some new blends. NSFW

Post image
76 Upvotes

Don Pepin, Plasencia, and Zino are familiar favorites, but the other four are all new to me. Has anyone here tried any of the four on the right? CH Thunderkiss, 2026 EPC TAA, Tatuaje Boris Karloff, and Eiroa 1916.


r/cigars • • 1d ago

Question Back in Florida, what should I get? NSFW

Post image
23 Upvotes

Howdy y'all! Taking a break from my usual mountain scenery for a re-stock and quick family trip down in South Florida.

What are the single sticks I should be seeking out at shops now that I don't have to worry about 56% excise tax? I already ordered some Davidoffs to the house, and will be sure to raid my dad's Opus X stash before going home.

This is a vacation for me, so I'm down for anything unique or perhaps higher-end since I'm saving so much per cigar.

Picture for attention. Old Aganorsa Leaf Signature Selection. So much age that the red pepper has almost entirely transitioned to baking spice. Smooth, nutty, leathery and a bit creamy. Phenomenal cigar if anyone has the patience to rest these or the good luck to find them with age. I think cigars taste better down here and I'm not freezing my butt off smoking it.