Davidoff - Year of the Horse 2026 LE: my first Chinese zodiac from Davidoff; a very, very good cigar overall; smoked perfectly, amazing draw, burned perfectly; great blend, ECU wrapper and binder, DR fillers, straightforward, no fuss; medium overall, medium- strength, medium or so body, medium+ flavours, balanced; rich, depth, layered, dynamic, nuance, complex, very good profile to this one; flavours were on point (cayenne, cashews, caramel, raspberry, apple, oak, brown sugar, mustard, mild pepper, leather, orange zest, cedar); all thirds of the smoke had their own additions, which was very enjoyable; definitely top tier Davidoff in my opinion, had a bit more umph to it but maintained some serious complexity and nuance to it; I know this might sound odd, but it did represent a horse (I know, call me crazy if you want); definitely one worth trying, but it is a bit pricey; someone asked me a couple of weeks ago about USD$40-$60 smokes worth trying, I’d put this one up there
Concealed Carry - Detroit River LE: an ok cigar, nothing special about this one; smoked perfectly, zero concerns again (this has been a big plus for this line); undisclosed blend, but it is definitely an ECU wrapper, probably a SUM binder, NIC in the filler, very ECU forward, tasted like La Aurora; medium overall; rich, depth, layered, but that is about it; first third was pretty decent, but the rest of the cigar was very average, got muddled towards the last third; flavours were fine, pedestrian (red pepper, sweet tea, oak, caramel, dirt, woody, cinnamon, spices, lemon zest, tart); definitely could’ve used some more depth and nuance to the flavours, lacked a bit in that department; by far my least favourite from this line so far, very generic, basic ECU blend; not a lot to say about it because it was so basic
Casa 1910 - Calvary Edition Lucero: very good cigar from the boutique Casa 1910, a Mexican brand; smoked perfectly, loved the torpedo vitola with this one, zero issues; great blend, ECU wrapper, SA binder, NIC fillers, all of the tobacco flavours were there; medium overall, but the flavours were more medium+, great smoke output and draw; made in NIC but at an undisclosed factory, would love to know which factory; rich, depth, layered, balanced, nuanced at times; first and final thirds were solid, middle third was just ok; flavours were good, vibrant, transitions (oak, cayenne, SA smoky, walnuts, creamy, orange liqueur, dried leaves, cinnamon, soily, leather, fruity, tobacco, spices); very good cigar; 1910 typically uses more MEX tobacco in their blends, but it was good to see what they can do using SA only as the binder and using other tobaccos; if you’re a fan of MEX tobacco, I highly recommend trying them; they announced an overhual of their lines and discontinuing their Calvary and Soldadera lines for the time being and focusing more on their Mexican cigars; I suggest trying some of these while they’re still available
Montecristo - Maltés: no box date or factory code on this single; birthday smoke for me; my second one from the Línea 1935, I’ve smoked the Dumas years ago; this one was pure class; smoked very well but it did need. the tool to loosen it up, tight part about a third of the way down; basically a toro size, called the Sobresalientes in the Cuban naming system; started out on the mild/medium side but finished more medium+, which I love about Cubans; rich, depth, layered, good transitions, balanced, complex, very good; flavours were so damn good, so MC (red and white pepper, orange zest, oak, cinnamon, caramel, cake, creamy, coffee, terroir, cocoa), maintained that MC profile but more zest; this Línea 1935, in my opinion, is overpriced nowadays but by gollly they are so flipping delicious; I don’t remember the Dumas being this good, but I like their profile compared to other Montecristos; wish I’d bought a box when I had the chance (or at least a couple more); I really did not want this one to go out, but the ephemeral experience of cigars is also what makes them amazing
Concealed Carry - AA 1935 LE: last one from this line; another good cigar, but not great; smoked well but the wrapper split multiple times because it was packed so tight, luckily no serious problems; has to be La Aurora again, 100% sure SUM wrapper, some DR and NIC in there; all of these were the same robusto extra vitola; more on the medium+ side overall, had a nice nicotine punch to it; rich, depth, layered, some balance to it, not much transition or nuance; first third was just ok, but it got better as it went along; flavours were decent (red pepper, very soily/dirty, copper/metallic, dried leaves, spices, cocoa, DR terroir, cinnamon, root beer, nutmeg); not a bad cigar at all; not my favourite from this line, I still think the Speakeasy was the best; overall, this line was decent, it has some good smokes, some being better than others of course; definitely recommend for folks who enjoy trying a line that has an overall cohesiveness to it while having distinct cigars and those who like undisclosed blends; however, I still like Fratello’s regular production smokes better than these ones; the Concealed Carry II line will be released soon
Gurkha - Year of the Dragon 2024 LE: made at El Artista in the DR; last one of this release that I’ve tried; a very nice cigar, one of the better ones I’ve had from El Artista; smoked well, for some reason part of the wrapper wouldn’t stay lit in the last third, great draw, loved the vitola; an undisclosed blend, but it seemed like an ECU wrapper, some HON in there and some DR; medium, medium+ overall, fairly steady profile; rich, depth, layered, good transitions, cohesive flavours (pepper, soil, creamy vanilla, cocoa, nutmeg, cinnamon, leather, orange zest, woody, potato chip, BBQ sauce), an interesting flavour profile; not the most dynamic flavours, but I liked this profile a lot; fairly impressed; there were five different blends for this line (this one, one made by AJ, one by EP, one by Oliva, and one by Oscar), and this one was up with the EP and Oliva as my favourites (AJ was my least favourite); I still haven’t smoked anything from Gurkha’s core lines and I need to do it (I’ve only heard negative talk about their core line)
Jake Wyatt - Lucid Interval: very mediocre; smoked fine, wrapper split a couple of times, burn was wonky quite a bit but had an ok draw; nice torpedo vitola; a candela wrapper from an undisclosed country with DR binder and filler; made in the DR at a Tabacalera JVM, which I don’t think I’ve ever heard of; probably medium overall, maybe medium+; rich, some depth, layered, for sure nothing more than that but needed more; flavour felt monolithic, which can happen with a candela wrapper but this one even more so; the first third had some ok flavours but the rest was mostly boring (woody, pepper, grassy, green apple, green tea, very salty, BBQ meat, dry grass, creamy, cayenne); this cigar lacked any kind of developed profile for me; it had a few good puffs but the rest of it was bland and boring; I’ve now smoked three cigars from JW, and I don’t think I’ll be trying anymore from this brand, they’ve all been very average, if that
Eladio Díaz - 72 Anniversary North and South Edition LE: what a cigar, y’all, fantastic; made at Díaz’s factory in the DR; smoked mostly perfectly, needed one minor touch-up, great draw and burn; a DR puro with various DR varietals for the fillers, DR corojo wrapper, and a DR/SA binder, which I’ve never smoked before; around medium overall; rich, depth, layered, nuance, complex, balanced, great cigar; flavours were so damn good and cohesive (white pepper, Red Hot cinnamon, creamy oak, wheat roll, apple sauce, spiced cocoa, hay, nutty, DR terroir, zesty); my second one from this line that celebrates Díaz’s birthday and both have been awesome; his DR tobacco is second to none, I would put Díaz’s DR puros up against any others (looking at you OpusX); the North and South name comes from the fact that the cigar uses tobaccos grown in either the northern or southern regions of the DR; highly recommend this one
Fratello - DMV VA: a very nice cigar; made at La Aurora; smoked perfectly, no issues whatsoever, perfect draw and burn; an undisclosed blend but has to be a BRA wrapper, NIC in there for sure; medium overall; a standard robusto vitola, which I haven’t smoked in a while and still love; rich, depth, layered, nuance, balanced; had some very good flavours in this one (black pepper, swampy, blackberries, mahogany, dark cocoa, hazelnut, smoky, nutty, creamy earthiness, BRA terroir); the BRA wrapper from LA is really good, a bit different than others, very enjoyable; I ate a piece of the 62% chocolate at the beginning of every third of the cigar and that was actually a lot of fun; I’ve never done anything like that and it ended up being a very good pairing; I bought the Fratello Harmony sampler that has all four DMV blends along with chocolates that are paired with each blend; the DMV blends have been released multiple times with different tobaccos, and the ones in this sampler are all undisclosed